Transcript

Audible Narrator (0:00)

Audible's Romance collection has something to satisfy every side of you when it comes to what kind of romance you're into. You don't have to choose just one fancy a dalliance with a duke or maybe a steamy billionaire. You could find a book boyfriend in the city and another one tearing it up on the hockey field. And if nothing on this earth satisfies, you can always find love in another realm. Discover modern rom coms from authors like Lily Chu and Ali Hazelwood, the latest romantasy series from Sarah J. Maas and Rebecca Yarros, plus Regency favorites like Bridgerton and Outlander, and of course, all the really steamy stuff. Your first great love story is free when you sign up for a free 30 day trial at audible.com wondery that's audible.com wondery.

Jordan Harbinger (0:47)

Welcome to Skeptical Sunday. I'm your host, Jordan Harbinger. Today I'm here with Skeptical Sunday co host, writer and researcher Nick Pell on the Jordan Harbinger Show. We decode the stories, secrets and skills of the world's most fascinating people and turn their wisdom into practical advice that you can use to impact your own life and and those around you. Our mission is to help you become a better informed, more critical thinker. And during the week we have long form conversations with a variety of amazing folks from spies to CEOs, athletes, authors, thinkers and performers. On Sundays though, is Skeptical Sunday, where a rotating guest co host and I break down a topic you may have never thought about and debunk common misconceptions about that topic. Subjects like astrology, acupuncture, recycling, chemtrails, banned foods, diet supplements, the lottery, and more. And if you're new to the show or you want to tell your friends about the show, I suggest our episode starter packs. These are collections of our favorite episodes on persuasion, negotiation, psychology, disinformation, junk science, crime and cults, and more that'll help new listeners get a taste of everything we do here on the show. Just visit jordanharbinger.com start or search for us in your Spotify app to get started today. It's not the most pleasant topic on earth, but make no mistake about it, antisemitism is on the rise in America and in the West. Part of this is a problem of exposure. The Internet allows people to just post whatever crosses their mind at any given moment, but it isn't limited to the Internet either. The Anti Defamation league noted a 360% increase in anti Semitic incidents, including 56 physical assaults, 554 incidents of vandalism and over 1300 incidents of verbal or written harassment. There was also the May 2025 shooting outside of a Jewish museum in Washington, D.C. the firebombing of the protest for the release of Israeli hostages in Colorado. One quirk of modern antisemitism is that it's mostly not coming from the usual suspects of swastika wearing skinheads. Today's leading lights of antisemitism are soft spoken, well read, and armed with charts and citations. And perhaps most disturbingly, just ignoring them is perhaps the most dangerous thing that we can do. Today's antisemites are dressed, pressed, and probably more serious than ever. All of this raises the question, why do smart people fall for dumb ideas? And why is antisemitism rearing its ugly head yet again? Here today, to help me fact check the fine print on the world's oldest conspiracy theory is writer and researcher Nick Pell. So, Nick, before we get into it, explain why you were so insistent about covering this topic. And by the way, quick note. As many of you already know, I am Jewish, so keep that in mind during the episode for reasons that will probably become pretty obvious.

Summary

The Jordan Harbinger Show — Skeptical Sunday

Episode 1208: Antisemitism | Skeptical Sunday
Date: September 14, 2025
Host: Jordan Harbinger
Co-Host: Nick Pell

Overview

In this Skeptical Sunday episode, Jordan Harbinger and co-host Nick Pell tackle the topic of antisemitism: its ancient roots, modern manifestations, and the misconceptions fuelling its recent resurgence. The pair critically examine where classic antisemitic tropes originate, challenge popular myths with fact-based discussion, and address why today’s antisemitism is more embedded in intellectual discourse than in the caricatured extremism of the past. The episode combines personal perspective, historical exploration, debunking of conspiracy theories, and a case for engaging even offensive ideas with reasoned counter-argument.

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. Why Talk About Antisemitism Now?

Rising Incidents: Explains the surge in antisemitic incidents with chilling statistics from the ADL (360% increase, high-profile attacks in 2025) [01:10].
Why Nick Chose This Topic:

"I'm so tired of seeing people confront antisemitism in this lazy Kumbaya. All people are the same. Hate is bad, kids. ... It's ill prepared to confront modern antisemitism and it puts people I love in danger."
– Nick Pell [03:18]

2. What Does “Being Jewish” Mean?

Jews are an "ethno-religious community"—neither simply race nor just a religion [04:32].
Brief rundown of Ashkenazi, Sephardic, Mizrahi, Ethiopian, and Yemeni Jewish communities.

“When someone talks about how the Jews control the world, it’s like... which ones?”
– Nick Pell [06:32]

3. A Brief History: The Evolution of Antisemitism

Three Phases:

a. Religious Antisemitism (Middle Ages, Inquisition, blood libels)
b. Racial Antisemitism (Enlightenment & Modern Era, Dreyfus Affair, Nazis)
c. Intellectual/Contemporary Antisemitism (today’s ‘sophisticated’ iteration)
[07:21–07:46, 36:32]

Myths about "Jews being expelled from 109 countries" debunked — real number closer to 12 [08:26].
Medieval expulsions often for financial reasons: rulers would expel Jews to avoid repaying debts, justifying it with slander [18:12].

“They’d get in over their heads and decide it was just easier to expel all the Jews than pay back their loan.”
– Nick Pell [18:12]
Consequences of Expulsion:
- Local economies suffer; Spain expelled Jews in 1492, economies tanked, Portugal (which accepted Spanish Jews) soon outstripped Spain.
- Nazi Germany: huge brain drain (Einstein, etc.). Same for Arab states post-1948 [19:54–20:59].

4. Iconic Antisemitic Tropes: Explanation & Debunking

Trope: Jews Control the Banks

Medieval roots: Christians forbidden to lend at interest; Jews fill the gap [15:39].
Today: demonstrably false. Only a tiny number of leading bankers worldwide are Jewish.

Trope: Jews Are Communists

Kernel: a handful of prominent Jews in early socialist/communist circles—explained by right-wing repression of Jews in Europe [22:13].
Reality: Soviet leaders were not Jewish; Marx was ethnically Jewish but anti-religious [23:15].
Contradiction in anti-Jewish rhetoric: “Are we money grubbers dominating the West, or evil Communists?” [25:50]

Trope: Protocols of the Elders of Zion and "The International Jew"

Both are historically important, but proven forgeries and full of borrowed plagiarism [36:10–36:25].

"It's kind of like a conspiracy website citing another conspiracy website as its source."
– Nick Pell [36:25]

Trope: Jews Run Hollywood & Porn

Hollywood: Due to historical barriers elsewhere, Jews found success in entertainment early on (e.g., Irish cops, not a ‘plot’) [42:51].
Porn: No, a rabbi doesn’t “own Pornhub.” Occasional Jewish involvement vastly exaggerated [61:09].

"Big news. Lots of people are assholes and say mean things about other groups of people."
– Nick Pell [60:33]

5. Modern/Intellectual Antisemitism: The New Challenge

Today’s antisemites are more often “soft spoken, well read, and armed with charts and citations” [01:40].
Kevin MacDonald (“the Marx of the anti-Semites”):
- Former evolutionary psych professor, his influential trilogy ("Culture of Critique") claims Judaism is an evolutionary group strategy aimed at outcompeting others.
- Nick recounts meeting MacDonald—he’s charming, intelligent, not a clichéd “villain,” and that's worrying [38:37–38:47].
- MacDonald's theories as "compliments" mis-framed as conspiracies (“high-investment parenting,” “verbal intelligence,” “cultural solidarity”).
Intellectual Antisemitism’s Danger:
- Harder to spot, more persuasive, influential in “polite middle class circles,” less socially radioactive [15:17].
“People have to put aside this, like, Star Wars villain of what an anti-Semite is if they’re going to get anything from this episode.”
– Nick Pell [38:47]
Why Ignoring Is a Mistake:
- Failure to seriously engage bad arguments allows them to “metastasize” [50:24–50:44].
- Notable: It took decades for any serious academic takedown of MacDonald’s work (see Nathan Kaufness's 2018 review) [51:13].

6. Weaponizing Jewish Heterogeneity

Anti-Jewish narratives often require mutually contradictory claims [26:06]:
- "Jews are leftist revolutionaries" and "dominating right-wing capitalists."
- Turns ordinary group variation into sinister intent—e.g., voting patterns, Jewish subgroups, etc. [64:41]
“The problem is when you associate those broad patterns with the entire group at an individual level.”
– Nick Pell [64:41]

7. Misuse of Jewish Texts: The Talmud

Talmud is a dense, contradictory compendium of rabbinic debate—not Jewish “bible” or accepted doctrine [66:29–67:19].
Antisemitic sites take passages out of context, willfully misleading or even fabricating quotes [68:53].

“If you ever encounter somebody who, like, isn’t a rabbi that told you that they read the Talmud? They were lying to you.”
– Nick Pell [68:46]

8. Antisemitism on the Political Right and Left

Right-wing antisemitism: Now stigmatized, largely confined to fringe, but responsible for rare but horrific violence (e.g., Pittsburgh synagogue shooting) [77:38].
Left-wing antisemitism: More socially accepted in some activist and academic circles, often coded as anti-Zionism.
- Example: Al Sharpton’s Crown Heights incitement and enduring respect in politics [78:18–79:10].
- Recent political candidates defend “globalize the intifada” rhetoric [79:32].
Obsessive focus on Israel, Israel lobbying “controlling” US foreign policy: debunked as overblown, Israel is not the puppet master of America [80:53].

“A country with a GDP of Maryland and population of Michigan is not running the country with the world’s largest military and nuclear arsenal.”
– Nick Pell [80:53]

9. Why You Must Engage, Not Censor

Censorship feeds the “keepers of dangerous secrets” narrative and drives interested people into the arms of bad ideas [50:24, 86:18].
The answer to bad ideas isn’t to ignore or crush them, but to present better arguments and truthfully debunk them [86:53].

“Don’t lie to protect the truth. Learn how to tell the truth better.”
– Nick Pell [86:18]

10. Antisemitism as Resentment

Drawing on Nietzsche, Nick describes antisemitism as the “resentment of your betters,” reframing failure as moral virtue and others’ success as evidence of evil [73:12–73:39]:

“You reframe your failures as some kind of moral virtue and say that actually excellence is bad and victimhood is good.”
– Nick Pell [73:39]

Notable Quotes & Moments

On intellectual antisemitism’s danger:

"He’s not a frothing at the mouth weirdo on the Donahue Show. He could be your neighbor."
– Nick Pell [39:24]
On historical expulsion:

“The biggest borrower in any country in Europe, especially during the Middle Ages, is going to be the king or the local lord. ... Easier to expel the Jews than pay back the loan.”
– Nick Pell [18:12]
On overrepresentation:

“Are black people overrepresented on the Supreme Court? Because it’s two out of nine? Like, I don’t think so.”
– Nick Pell [44:16]
On the value of disagreement:

"Bad ideas need better responses than silence."
– Nick Pell [53:35]
On the futility of Talmud-based attacks:

“You can’t really understand Talmud without studying all of it. And it’s insanely long and incredibly dense. ... Most Jews, even observant ones, they have no idea what’s in the Talmud.”
– Nick Pell [68:46]
On left vs. right-wing antisemitism:

“Right-wing antisemites are generally considered weirdos and people want nothing to do with them. Left-wing antisemites have representation in Congress.”
– Nick Pell [78:18]
On conspiracy thinking:

“Once you decide that antisemitism is true, you just start seeing the rationale for it absolutely everywhere.”
– Jordan Harbinger [74:34]

Timestamps for Major Segments

Introduction/Context: 00:47–03:18
What is Jewish Identity: 04:29–06:37
History of Antisemitism: 06:37–12:37
"Jews & Banks": 15:39–20:31
Jewish Communism: 22:13–25:06
Protocols/Foundational Texts: 31:28–36:25
Modern Intellectual Antisemitism & Kevin MacDonald: 36:32–51:13
Jews in Hollywood, Academia, and Porn: 42:51–62:01
Talmud Myths: 66:29–70:08
Nietzsche on Antisemitism as Resentment: 73:12–74:34
Right vs Left Antisemitism, and Israel: 77:38–83:57
Debating, Not Censoring: 84:14–86:53
Closing Thoughts: 86:53–end

Conclusion

Jordan and Nick provide a comprehensive, fact-based examination of antisemitism, past and present. They expose the “kernels of truth” behind persistent myths, detail the dangers of ignoring intellectual antisemitism, and urge good-faith engagement over censorship or platitudes.

Key takeaway: The antidote to antisemitism—like all bad ideas—is open inquiry, factual engagement, and the courage to drag persistent old lies into the daylight and show them for what they really are: expressions of resentment, not hidden truths.

Full episode and resources available at:
Jordan Harbinger Show — Skeptical Sunday

1208: Antisemitism | Skeptical Sunday