Can the GOP Unite Around Trump’s ‘Big, Beautiful Bill’?

Summary

Summary of "Can the GOP Unite Around Trump’s ‘Big, Beautiful Bill’?" – The Journal Podcast

Podcast Information:

• Title: The Journal
• Hosts: Ryan Knutson and Jessica Mendoza
• Produced by: The Wall Street Journal & Gimlet in partnership with Spotify
• Episode Title: Can the GOP Unite Around Trump’s ‘Big, Beautiful Bill’?
• Release Date: May 20, 2025

---

1. Introduction to Trump’s "Big, Beautiful Bill"

The episode delves into President Donald Trump’s ambitious legislative effort dubbed the "big, beautiful bill," which has been a focal point of GOP strategy as it seeks to advance its agenda through a comprehensive tax and policy package.

Jessica Mendoza [00:05]: "For months, President Donald Trump has been promoting what he calls his big, beautiful bill."

Trump himself emphasizes the significance and grandeur of the bill:

Donald Trump [00:12]: "The greatest tax cuts in history. One big, beautiful bill I think, is going to be."

---

2. Scope and Content of the Bill

Rich Rubin, a tax policy expert, provides insights into the bill's extensive nature and diverse coverage.

Rich Rubin [00:26]: "The version that the House Rules Committee has posted is just over 1,000 pages."

The bill is not limited to tax reforms; it encompasses various Republican priorities, including:

• Taxes: Extension and expansion of the 2017 tax cuts.
• Border Security and National Defense: Increased funding allocations.
• Electric Vehicles and Clean Energy: Rollbacks of Biden-era incentives.
• Education: Various reforms and funding adjustments.

Historical Context: The 2017 Tax Cuts

The discussion references the significant tax overhaul enacted in 2017, which marked the largest revision of the U.S. tax system in decades.

Paul Ryan [03:06]: "This is one of the most important pieces of legislation that Congress has passed in decades to help the American worker, to help grow the American economy."

Key features of the 2017 tax cuts included:

• Reduction of the corporate tax rate to its lowest point since 1939.
• Lowered individual taxes for most households.
• Temporary nature of several tax provisions, set to expire in 2025.

---

3. Expansion and Extension of Tax Cuts

The current bill aims to not only extend the 2017 tax cuts but also to amplify them, particularly benefiting middle-income households.

Rich Rubin [04:07]: "They see this as a moment to really go out and lock those in. That's the core of what this bill is."

Key Enhancements:

• Higher Standard Deduction: An additional standard deduction on top of existing amounts.
• Child Tax Credit: Increased to $2,500 per child.
• Senior Citizens’ Deduction: Significant increments for those aged 65 and over.

---

4. Balancing Spending and Tax Reforms

While the bill focuses on tax reductions, it also includes significant spending allocations and cuts.

Rich Rubin [05:19]: "Tax credits for wind, solar, battery, manufacturing. All those kinds of things, you know, finish sooner and phase out faster."

Spending Components:

• Increased Funding: Border security and national defense.
• Spending Cuts: Reduction of federal clean energy incentives introduced under President Biden in 2022.

Incorporation of Campaign Promises

The bill integrates specific campaign pledges from Trump, such as eliminating taxes on overtime pay and tips.

Donald Trump [05:37]: "No tax on tips."

---

5. Internal GOP Divisions and Challenges

Despite holding majorities in both the House and Senate, the GOP faces significant internal conflicts that threaten the bill’s passage.

Hardline Conservatives vs. Moderates

• Hardline Conservatives: Advocate for more aggressive spending cuts and stricter fiscal measures.

  Chip Roy [07:30]: "We are writing checks we cannot cash, and our children are going to pay the price."

• Moderate Republicans: Oppose certain elements like Medicaid cuts and the rollback of clean energy incentives, fearing backlash from constituents.

Key Points of Contention:

• Deficit Concerns: Analysts project a $2.75 trillion increase in the deficit over the next decade if the bill passes, leading some GOP members to seek deeper cuts.

  Rich Rubin [09:23]: "They want to see more aggressive spending cuts."

• Medicaid Reforms: Introduction of work requirements and limitations on nutrition assistance, which have sparked opposition within the party.

  Hakeem Jeffries [06:39]: "Hospitals are going to close, nursing homes are going to shut down."

• Clean Energy Tax Credits: Some Republicans worry that phasing out these incentives too quickly could harm rural economies that rely on wind, solar, and manufacturing jobs.

• State and Local Tax (SALT) Deductions: Representatives from high-tax states like New York and California are pushing to raise the SALT deduction cap beyond the proposed $30,000.

  Rich Rubin [11:49]: "They are very concerned about that. And so you've got to push and pull, as you can see, with the hardliners."

---

6. Legislative Progress and Negotiations

The bill has encountered significant hurdles within the House, particularly within the Budget Committee.

Committee Votes and Party Dynamics

• Initial Blockade: Republican hardliners, alongside Democrats, voted against bringing the bill to the House floor, necessitating further negotiations.

• Pressure from Trump: The President has been actively urging unity within the party to ensure the bill's progression.

  Donald Trump [14:49]: "We have a tremendously unified party. I don't think we've ever had a party like this."

• Subsequent Vote: The four conservative holdouts shifted their stance from "no" to "present," allowing the bill to advance to the House floor.

  Rich Rubin [13:39]: "They've got to find a number that satisfies those SALT members... without losing votes on the moderate side."

Upcoming Steps:

• Full Floor Vote: Scheduled by the end of the week.

• Presidential Approval: Aiming to present the bill to Trump by July 4th.

  Speaker Mike Johnson [14:27]: "He expects the bill to pass in the House."

---

7. Reactions and Criticisms

Democratic Opposition

Democrats argue that the bill disproportionately benefits the wealthy and exacerbates economic inequalities.

Hakeem Jeffries [06:39]: "All because Republicans want to provide a massive tax break to their billionaire donors like Elon Musk."

GOP Defense

Republicans defend the bill as essential for economic growth and fiscal responsibility.

Rich Rubin [07:02]: "Republicans are talking about the tax cuts as essential... their argument is that Biden and Democrats overspent and they need to start reining that in."

Internal GOP Critiques

• Chip Roy [07:30]: Criticizes the bill for not addressing the deficit adequately.
• Senator Josh Hawley: Opposes Medicaid cuts despite being an ally of Trump, highlighting intra-party disagreements.

---

8. Implications of the Bill’s Passage or Failure

If Passed:

• Economic Impact: Continued tax cuts could stimulate economic growth but may also increase the national deficit.
• Social Programs: Scaling back Medicaid and SNAP could reduce support for low-income Americans, leading to potential public backlash.
• Energy Sector: Phasing out clean energy incentives may slow the transition to renewable energy sources, affecting jobs and environmental goals.

Rich Rubin [15:41]: "It's a signal of how far Republicans can be willing to go. It's a signal of what the Republican Party itself is capable of doing."

If Failed:

• Legislative Setback: The GOP may face challenges in demonstrating unity and effectiveness, potentially impacting future legislative efforts.
• Political Repercussions: Intra-party conflicts could weaken Trump's influence and the party’s overall cohesion.

Senate Prospects:

Even if the House passes the bill, the Senate poses its own set of challenges with different factions and priorities.

Rich Rubin [15:10]: "The Senate is not going to just take this and rubber stamp it... that's really the next phase of what happened."

---

9. Conclusion

The "big, beautiful bill" embodies the GOP's attempt to consolidate its diverse priorities under a singular legislative framework. However, internal divisions within the party present significant obstacles to its passage. As the bill moves to the House floor, the coming weeks will be critical in determining whether Republicans can overcome their differences to advance Trump’s comprehensive agenda.

Rich Rubin [17:01]: "This is the purest distillation of what this Republican Party at this moment, with these slim majorities, can produce."

---

Additional Reporting: Olivia Beavers and Siobhan Hughes

---

Transcript

[Jessica Mendoza]

For months, President Donald Trump has been promoting what he calls his big, beautiful bill.

[Donald Trump]

The great, big, beautiful bill. Great big, beautiful deal. The big, beautiful bill. Big, beautiful deal. The greatest tax cuts in history. One big, beautiful bill I think, is going to be.

[Jessica Mendoza]

How many pages is this bill?

[Rich Rubin]

The version that the House Rules Committee has posted is just over 1,000 pages.

[Jessica Mendoza]

That's our colleague Rich Rubin. He writes about tax policy, and he's been covering the bill as it moves through Congress. In a nutshell, what is this bill like? Why is it so big and so beautiful?

[Rich Rubin]

We're gonna need a very large nutshell for this. This is an attempt to roll a bunch of. Bunch of Republican priorities into one piece of legislation. Basically, they've got so many different factions of the party that everyone can get something, and even if there are parts of it that they don't like, that everyone will be on board for the one big, beautiful bill that represents the core of Trump's agenda.

[Jessica Mendoza]

The bill mainly has to do with taxes, but it touches all kinds of other stuff, from border funding to electric vehicles to education. But so far, the bill has faced some opposition, not just from Democrats, but from within the gop, putting the party's fault lines on full display.

[Rich Rubin]

It's a test for Trump. Can he get everybody together? But it's also a moment for those members to kind of decide how far they're willing to push up against where the rest of the party and the president are going.

[Jessica Mendoza]

Welcome to the Journal, our show about money, business, and power. I'm Jessica mendoza. It's Tuesday, May 20th. Coming up on the show, why Trump's big, beautiful bill has become a big pain for Republicans.

[Hakeem Jeffries]

This episode is brought to you by Uber. You know that feeling when someone shows up for you just when you need it most? That's what Uber is all about, not just a ride or dinner at your door. It's how Uber helps you show up for the moments that matter. Because showing up can turn a tough day around or make a good one even better. Whatever it is, big or small, Uber is on the way, so you can be on yours. Uber on our way.

[Jessica Mendoza]

This year's tax bill has a lot to do with another major tax bill, one that Republicans passed back in 2017 during Trump's first term. When that bill became law, it was a huge deal for the gop. Here's the House speaker at the time, Paul Ryan.

[Paul Ryan]

This is one of the most important pieces of legislation that Congress has passed in decades to help the American worker, to help grow the American economy. This is profound Change. And this is change that is going to put our country on the right path.

[Jessica Mendoza]

The bill represented the biggest overhaul of the US Tax system in decades. It cut the corporate tax rate to its lowest point since 1939, and it lowered individual taxes for most households. The tax law did face opposition. Democrats said the cuts favored the wealthy at the expense of poorer Americans. And the tax cuts added to the national deficit, according to official estimates, which angered fiscal conservatives. But some of the tax cuts in the 2017 bill were temporary.

[Rich Rubin]

I covered that bill in 2017, and when it passed, they set all these tax cuts, the rates, the standard reduction, the child credit to expire after 2025. And I was like, okay, well, I know what I'm doing in 2025. And here I am in 2025 covering the extension of those things.

[Jessica Mendoza]

And Republicans are actually in a good position to renew a lot of the policies they put in place about eight years ago. They have majorities in both the House and the Senate, and they have Trump in the White House.

[Rich Rubin]

They see this as a moment to really go out and lock those in. That's the core of what this bill is.

[Jessica Mendoza]

This bill is not just extending those 2017 tax cuts, but also expanding them.

[Rich Rubin]

The new stuff they really are focusing on, not people at the very bottom of the income scale who don't pay inc taxes now, but people in the middle. So there is a higher standard deduction on top of the additional standard deduction. There's a child tax credit, goes to 2,500 per child, maximum. The extra standard deduction for Senior citizens, people 65 and over, goes up by several thousand dollars if this passes.

[Jessica Mendoza]

Now, Trump in office for a second time, is more ambitious than he was in 2017. And this new bill shows that. For one, the bill increases spending on border security and national defense. But it also makes a lot of cuts. It rolls back federal clean energy incentives introduced under former President Biden in 2022.

[Rich Rubin]

Tax credits for wind, solar, battery, manufacturing. All those kinds of things, you know, finish sooner and phase out faster. And so that's also part of the way that they're paying for this.

[Jessica Mendoza]

And some of Trump's campaign promises are worked into the bill, like no taxes on overtime pay or on tips.

[Donald Trump]

No tax on tips.

[Jessica Mendoza]

But some of the most controversial aspects of the bill have to do with spending cuts. The bill suggests scaling back entitlement programs like Medicaid, which is government funded health insurance for low income Americans. Conservatives have long worried that these programs are too expensive and contribute to the national deficit. But Republicans have Previously been cautious about cuts to Medicaid because it's popular among constituents.

[Rich Rubin]

The Medicaid changes include work requirements for recipients.

[Jessica Mendoza]

Work requirements as in you have to have proof of work in order to be eligible for Medicaid.

[Rich Rubin]

Yeah. Or that you're seeking work or doing some sort of like work type activity if you're able bodied. Right. So that's part of it. There's some new limits on nutrition assistance. Right. What we call SNAP or food stamps. There's some limits on that. That's part of the bill.

[Jessica Mendoza]

Democrats have criticized the bill, saying it hurts poorer Americans.

[Hakeem Jeffries]

Hospitals are going to close, nursing homes.

[Rich Rubin]

Are going to shut down.

[Jessica Mendoza]

That's House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries.

[Hakeem Jeffries]

All because Republicans want to provide a massive tax break to their billionaire donors like Elon Musk.

[Jessica Mendoza]

What is the goal for Republicans here? Like, what is the argument behind these proposals? How are they, like, talking about it?

[Rich Rubin]

Republicans are talking about the tax cuts as essential. The idea of extending the tax cuts is basically non negotiable. It's something that they really feel is imperative economically, something they need to do. The spending changes, the spending cuts are something they also feel is an imperative to turn the tide on budget deficits, to try and rein in spending. Their argument is that Biden and Democrats overspent and they need to start reining that in.

[Jessica Mendoza]

But the bill has gotten off to a rocky start, partly because it doesn't reduce the deficit. In fact, it increases the deficit. And that's annoyed some Republican hardliners like Texas Congressman Chip Roy.

[Chip Roy]

This bill falls profoundly short. It does not do what we say it does with respect to deficits.

[Jessica Mendoza]

Before even heading to the House floor, Republicans in committee meetings have gone as far as temporarily blocking the bill. And while the party does have a majority in Congress, that majority is super slim. They can only afford to lose three Republican votes. And keeping the coalition together isn't easy. That's next.

[Shopify Ad]

Starting a business can seem like a daunting task unless you have a partner like Shopify. They have the tools you need to start and grow your business. From designing a website to marketing to selling and beyond, Shopify can help with everything you need. There's a reason millions of companies like Mattel Heinz and Allbirds continue to trust and use them. With Shopify on your side, turn your big business idea into sign up for your $1 per month [e-mail] specialoffer.

[Jessica Mendoza]

Let'S talk about the challenges that the bill has faced up to this point. What have the key holdouts been arguing?

[Rich Rubin]

So there are, I think, a few different groups of holdouts, and we'll take them in turn. One is the conservative hardline holdouts, people like Chippewa of Texas, Andrew Clyde of Georgia, Josh Burkin of Oklahoma, and Ralph Norman of South Carolina. They're concerned about spending, largely right. They think that the bill doesn't do enough to rein in spending.

[Jessica Mendoza]

Budget analysts have crunched the numbers and they've found that if the bill were to be passed into law, the country's deficit would grow by about $2.75 trillion over the next decade. The four conservative holdouts say they want to see more aggressive spending cuts.

[Chip Roy]

We are writing checks we cannot cash, and our children are going to pay the price.

[Rich Rubin]

They're concerned that the work requirements for Medicaid start too late. Right. It's backloaded, and that a future Congress might just come in and change that. And so they want to accelerate that probably to 2027. They're concerned that the clean energy tax breaks don't go away fast enough.

[Unnamed Speaker]

Right.

[Rich Rubin]

There's sort of a ramp down and, you know, if you set a 2031 date for when, you know, the final phase out of certain energy tax credits, that lobbyists will come and the next Congress will come and Trump will be out of office and there will be opportunities to extend those days further out.

[Jessica Mendoza]

While hardline conservatives feel that the spending cuts don't go far enough, there are Republicans in Congress tugging in the other direction. Some have come out against the Medicaid cuts, saying it would take health care away from their poorest constituents. Missouri Senator Josh Hawley, usually an ally of the president, was one of those critics.

[Chip Roy]

These are working people and their children who need health care, and it's just wrong to go and cut their health.

[Hakeem Jeffries]

Care when they're trying to make ends.

[Chip Roy]

Meet, trying to help their kids.

[Jessica Mendoza]

Other Republican members don't want the bill to cut the Biden clean energy credits.

[Rich Rubin]

Clean energy projects, though it was passed by Democrats, have largely happened in Republican districts because that's where there's open land tends to be more rural. So wind, solar, factories tend to be rural, more tenable and more feasible in those places, as opposed to in Manhattan. And so vast phase out would hurt those projects that are happening and jobs and investment that are happening in those districts. So you've got those sort of moderate, more moderate members of the Republican conference who are very concerned about that. And so you've got to push and pull, as you can see, with the hardliners.

[Jessica Mendoza]

And then there are Republicans from blue states like New York and California, they're focusing on the state and local tax deduction, also known as salt. It works like this. If you pay a lot of state and local taxes, you can deduct some of those from your federal taxes, but there's a cap on how much you can deduct. And these Republicans who represent wealthier, higher tax areas want that cap raised.

[Rich Rubin]

The more they raise that cap, the more that people who pay lots of state and local taxes can deduct those taxes from their federal income and pay less to the federal government. Republican plan, as it currently stands, raises that tax deduction limit of $10,000 to $30,000. And they said, no, $30,000 is not enough. That can be. You know, property taxes are really high. This is a very sort of symbolic issue now for in those areas. And they're saying they will kill the bill if they don't get more.

[Jessica Mendoza]

So it does seem to really. This whole discussion over this tax bill kind of seems to show the conflicting priorities within the GOP under Trump.

[Rich Rubin]

Yes. Oh, no. You're absolutely seeing the divides in the party. Overspending over taxes, over energy, over Medicaid, over health care. Broadly, yes. It's all on display here in the House of Representatives.

[Jessica Mendoza]

The intraparty conflict came to a head during a Budget Committee hearing on Friday. The Republican hardliners joined Democrats to vote no on bringing the tax bill to the House floor, which forced the committee to continue negotiations through the weekend. As the different sides of the party try to find common ground, pressure continues to mount from the president on social media, Trump has called on Republicans to unite, stop talking and get it done. Late on Sunday night, the Budget Committee had another vote. This time, the four conservative holdouts changed their votes from no to present. That switch lets the bill move to the full floor of the House, where Republicans will have to continue sorting out their differences.

[Rich Rubin]

They've got to find a number that satisfies those SALT members, like the New York, New Jersey members. They've got to somehow get them on board, or at least enough of them. They've got to figure out how to get the hardliners satisfied without losing votes on the moderate side. So on Medicaid and the clean energy.

[Jessica Mendoza]

Stuff, it seems like, yeah, the margins are super thin and there's like a very narrow space where everybody might be able to agree.

[Rich Rubin]

That's the hope that they have. I mean, one alternate theory is there is no space. Right. That's the fear, I think, is that. And Johnson is eternally optimistic and confident that he can make magic happen here.

[Jessica Mendoza]

The Plan is to have a full floor vote by the end of the week and to get the bill to Trump's desk by July 4th. Speaker Mike Johnson has said he expects the bill to pass in the House.

[Chip Roy]

President Trump's one big, beautiful bill will be passed, and that will be the key to turning this thing around. We have to get this done, and it just shows more of the urgency of why we're doing exactly what we're doing with the legislation.

[Jessica Mendoza]

Today the President was on Capitol Hill to turn the screws on the more reluctant members and convince them to unite around the bill. One reporter asked Trump what his message was to the holdouts.

[Donald Trump]

Well, it's not a question of holdouts. We have a tremendously unified party. I don't think we've ever had a party like this. There are some people that want a couple of things that maybe I don't like or that they're not going to get.

[Jessica Mendoza]

But some Republicans said they weren't sold. If the bill does pass the House, the next step will be the Senate, where it's bound to face challenges as well.

[Rich Rubin]

The Senate is not going to just take this and rubber stamp it. The Senate's got its own ideas, its own personalities, its own factions, its own divides, its own priorities. And that's really the next phase of what happened. And so as important as this week is, it is just that step. And then the Senate will have its say.

[Jessica Mendoza]

Rich, why does this bill matter in the end? Like, what difference could it make?

[Rich Rubin]

It matters because it.

[Unnamed Speaker]

It's the government pulling back a little bit on the protections it provides for low income people and the government pulling back on taxes across the board, both from middle income households like we've talked about, and people at the top who get to continue having the tax cuts they've been having. The last time that Republicans really made a dent in these sort of entitlement mandatory programs was nearly 30 years ago. And so a lot has happened since then. And that, I think, is a real signal that there's a willingness and an interest to do those kinds of changes. It's a signal of how far Republicans can be willing to go. On the spending side, the changes in Medicaid, in nutrition assistance, in agriculture, whatever those end up being, whatever those spending changes end up being, they're a sign of what the Republican Party itself is capable of doing. This is not Republicans pressuring a Democratic president into accepting things. This is the purest distillation of what this Republican Party at this moment, with these slim majorities, can produce.

[Jessica Mendoza]

That's all for today. Tuesday, May 20th. The Journal is a co production of Spotify and the Wall Street Journal. Additional reporting in this episode by Olivia Beavers and Siobhan Hughes. Thanks for listening. See you tomorrow.