Loading summary
Stephen Colbert
Let's check in on the Serta counting sheep.
Jim Gaffigan
Why aren't we counting anymore? Well, the all new Serta perfect sleeper has the Q4 support system that helps relieve aches and back pain. We'll never get counted again. Uh, nope.
Progressive Insurance Announcer
Certa. We make the world's best mattress.
DSW Announcer
At dsw, we ask the important questions, like what shoes are you going to wear? Whether you're prepping for wedding season, festival season, or just planning the ultimate vacay, the right shoes can make or break an rsvp. So own the mom. You've got big plans, and we've got just the shoes at the perfect price, of course. Get ready to get ready with designer Shoe warehouse. Head to your DSW store or dsw.com today and let us surprise you.
Jim Gaffigan
It's the Late Show Poncho with Stephen Colbert.
Stephen Colbert
Everybody is excited to see Tim Gaffing and as we always are here at the Late Show. And Jim, thank you so much for being here and bringing back more of your bourbon. By the way, the Father Time. Shall we? Test of the.
Jim Gaffigan
Oh, yeah.
Stephen Colbert
There you go. Let's sell some bottles. A little liquid courage. So, you know, I love having a little cocktail with you and talking to you when we're on the show, but the problem is, is that even though you and I have been able to spend some time not on show, like talking off camera, it's just never enough to learn about Jim Gaffigan.
Jim Gaffigan
Oh, thank you.
Stephen Colbert
There's always so many. There's so much more to plum about you. You're a bottomless pit of interest.
Jim Gaffigan
Oh, boy. And
Stephen Colbert
I think that's a compliment.
Jim Gaffigan
Don't oversell it.
Stephen Colbert
I think it's a compliment.
Jim Gaffigan
A bottomless head of entrance.
Stephen Colbert
Yes. Age cannot wither nor custom stale your infinite variety, Jim. And so what I like to do for special guests like you is that I like to ask them a series of questions we call the Colbert questionnaire. And the questionnaire. And you know how St. Paul says, then I shall know as surely as I am known. This, what it allows, allows the world to know you, Jim. And the question is, are you prepared to be known?
Jim Gaffigan
I am prepared.
Stephen Colbert
Question one.
Jim Gaffigan
Okay.
Stephen Colbert
As always.
Jim Gaffigan
Okay.
Stephen Colbert
Jim Gaffigan.
Jim Gaffigan
Yes.
Stephen Colbert
What is the best sandwich?
Jim Gaffigan
Ooh. Yeah. I didn't know it was gonna be hard questions.
Stephen Colbert
Yeah.
Jim Gaffigan
Some of this has to do with what you have to do after said sandwich. If you don't have anything to do, then it's a pastrami sandwich from Katz's Deli.
Stephen Colbert
Wow.
Jim Gaffigan
Definitely. If you don't have anything to do. And you're in Chicago. I'm going to go Italian beef from Mr. Beef. Mr. Beef or Lumon Lattice? You know, I love them all.
Stephen Colbert
I'm a Beef fan. Do you do your beef? Wet peppers, hot peppers, sweet peppers, hot peppers, hot peppers. Wet, huh? Hot and wet.
Jim Gaffigan
Hot and wet. Yeah, hot and wet. I mean, it's messy. Yeah.
Stephen Colbert
Yeah, sure.
Jim Gaffigan
Yeah.
Stephen Colbert
If you don't. If you do have something to do, what are these sandwiches gonna do to you?
Jim Gaffigan
Well, the thing is, is no one's ever, like, eaten a pastrami sandwich and done anything. You know what I mean? No one's been like, all right, I did that. Time to head back to be productive at work. You know, you have a pastrami sandwich and then you're like, goodbye. Right.
Stephen Colbert
What was your first concert you attended?
Jim Gaffigan
My first concert was James Taylor. I was 16. I had gotten my license that day. And my brothers and sisters, I'm the youngest of six, they took me with them. They were all drinking, and I thought, hey, I'll drink, too. And so I went up to the bar. It was at Alpine Valley or whatever. And I said, doppler Creek. And I. They're like, do you have an ID? I'm 16 and one month, which had to be in Indiana. And I showed them my id, and the guy looked at my ID and he took it. And I said, can I have that back? He goes, no. And so then I got back from the concert the next day. My dad hadn't seen my license. He's like, I want to see your license. And I'm like, just one minute. I lost it. And so then we went and got another license. And eventually my license was mailed to me by the, you know, the organization that. It was Alpine Valley or whatever. And the head of the department that sent it, his name was also James Taylor. What? I never said it was interesting. I just thought that it was.
Stephen Colbert
I was about to say there was a fantastic buildup with a twist ending that in no way paid off.
Jim Gaffigan
There was no. There was.
Stephen Colbert
Wait a second. But I don't. I don't understand. Yeah, I don't understand. Was the license. Did you fake it? Did you, like, make it 18?
Jim Gaffigan
No, I was 16. I thought you just had to show an ID and they'd be like, all right, fine.
Stephen Colbert
And did the letter say your son tried to buy liquor?
Jim Gaffigan
Yes.
Stephen Colbert
Oh, shoot.
Jim Gaffigan
And my parents were, you know, they pretended to be, you know, disappointed. But at that time, you know, I think we were, you know, I was allowed to drink at home, you Know
Stephen Colbert
now it's all, what was the tour, by the way? What year are we talking?
Jim Gaffigan
Oh, Well, I was 16. I don't know. I don't know what the tour was, I think.
Stephen Colbert
You don't know what year it was when you were 16? No, I don't. What year were you 16? Jim Gaffigan. Can I see some ID?
Jim Gaffigan
Wait a minute, no one knows. What year were you when you were 16?
Stephen Colbert
16. 1980.
Jim Gaffigan
1980. Sorry. So I was probably before. After that, I was.
Stephen Colbert
I was.
Jim Gaffigan
How old are you now?
Blinds.com Announcer
How old are you now?
Jim Gaffigan
You know, you're weirdly smart. You know that, right? Like, you don't. Most humans don't have your knowledge. Like, the source of.
Stephen Colbert
What year I was 16. That's not exactly a trivia question.
Jim Gaffigan
People know the year they graduated high school, they don't know the year they're 16.
Stephen Colbert
Right. You know the year you graduated high school, then you take two years off. That's exactly how I did it. 82. 80, 16. That works out. I was born in 64.
Jim Gaffigan
All right, I'm dumb. Okay.
Stephen Colbert
What year were you 16?
Jim Gaffigan
We've got one question. No.
Stephen Colbert
2. Sandwich. Oh, yeah, yeah. Sandwich.
Jim Gaffigan
Okay.
Stephen Colbert
Because I went to the Just a terrestrial tour in 1982, so I was just wondering whether you went to that one.
Jim Gaffigan
I don't know.
Stephen Colbert
I mean, I'm gonna call James and say that you didn't care.
Jim Gaffigan
I did. I do care. Up on the roof.
Stephen Colbert
Have you met Mr. Taylor?
Jim Gaffigan
I don't think I have.
Stephen Colbert
Lovely fellow. Okay, what is the scariest animal?
Jim Gaffigan
Okay, I'm gonna say a drunk New York Rangers fan. Right.
Stephen Colbert
Have you run into one in the wild?
Jim Gaffigan
Oh, yeah. No. If you're walking around Penn Station and you, you know, like, they lost or won, neither one's that good.
Stephen Colbert
Okay.
Jim Gaffigan
Those people are having a good time.
Stephen Colbert
Jim Gaffigan, apples or oranges?
Jim Gaffigan
Obviously apples.
Stephen Colbert
Yes.
Jim Gaffigan
Right. Orange is way too much work and half the time, not worth it. Right? Yeah. Apples all the way.
Stephen Colbert
Peanut butter on apple. Peanut butter and orange.
Jim Gaffigan
No, no, no.
Stephen Colbert
Have you ever asked someone for their autograph?
Jim Gaffigan
I stood in line to get J.J.
Stephen Colbert
walker's Jimmy JJ Dynamite Kid Walker, and
Jim Gaffigan
he signed my dynamite hat.
Stephen Colbert
Was this at the James Taylor concert?
Jim Gaffigan
No, that was. I was much younger. I don't know what year it was, but it was. I think I was, like, eight. But he came. I mean, we still lived in Illinois at the time. And I stood in line for a good hour, and he signed my cap.
Stephen Colbert
Oh, that's lovely.
Jim Gaffigan
And it was amazing.
Stephen Colbert
That's fantastic. What happens. What do you think happens when we die?
Jim Gaffigan
Well, thankfully, I'll never have to find out, you know, which is. I don't.
Stephen Colbert
Pearly Gates. I keep going for that. The whole nine yards.
Jim Gaffigan
Sure. I don't know. I mean, yes, I guess. Yeah. You want to believe that. I mean, I think the more I'm going to dodge the question, I think the more interesting question is why are we like human beings, and I witnessed this when my wife was very close to death, is that we exist generally in absolute denial about our demise. Right. So, like the fact that when we've all lost someone, we've all been in touch with that fear and that panic and that kind of concern, but generally we're like, I'm not gonna die. I'm not gonna die. So I guess. I don't know, but it's probably bad. I'm just too Catholic. I'm gonna get in trouble. What's really. I think. I mean, I mean, I don't know. I just. I just. I live with a lot of guilt. And I know that's not necessarily the intellectual Catholic approach, but that's where I am.
Stephen Colbert
Why do you say it with that tone?
Jim Gaffigan
Because you're the smartest person I know.
Stephen Colbert
But I'm not necessarily an intellectual Catholic. My dad was sort of an intellectual Catholic. He like reading. This isn't about me. Let's move on.
Jim Gaffigan
No, but I'm envious of it. I'm envious. I have all these books about saints that I want to read, but, you know, that involves paying attention.
Stephen Colbert
You know, I'll throw a free ball in here. You got a favorite saint?
Jim Gaffigan
I mean, I just love the fact that so many of them were just scumbags that ended up turning it around.
Stephen Colbert
Right.
Jim Gaffigan
Do you know what I mean? Like, that's what people don't realize. Like, we think of saint as these really holy people. But a lot of, you know, Paul was a dirtbag, you know, killing people left and right. Yeah. So, like, that's the whole. There's Particularly if you live in a pool of regret like I do. That's some hope there.
Stephen Colbert
That's the reason why I like St. Peter.
Jim Gaffigan
Yeah.
Stephen Colbert
And again, this isn't about me, but the reason I like St. Peter is that he was, you know, right hand man and then blows it.
Jim Gaffigan
Oh, yeah.
Stephen Colbert
He denies Christ three times before the cockroach and still gets the big job. And why so the rocks between the ears. Pete.
Jim Gaffigan
Yeah. You know, it seems almost intentional that he picked this guy. Right, Right.
Stephen Colbert
He picked someone who's fail at the job.
Jim Gaffigan
Infallibility. When Peter was obviously, you know, flawed. Right.
Stephen Colbert
Yeah.
Jim Gaffigan
We'll be right back.
Stephen Colbert
I think it's a misprint. I think it's inflatability.
Jim Gaffigan
Inflatability.
Stephen Colbert
Yeah. Favorite action movie.
Jim Gaffigan
Oh. Driving Miss Daisy.
Stephen Colbert
Probably quality kills when she takes a header. Yeah. Window or aisle?
Jim Gaffigan
Window. And I do not feel any guilt when I get up and make that person feel bad to go to the bathroom. Yeah.
Stephen Colbert
Yeah.
Jim Gaffigan
They should have gotten the window seat.
Stephen Colbert
Yep. Favorite smell?
Jim Gaffigan
Um, I would probably say bacon. Bacon, Right.
Stephen Colbert
Yeah. It's good.
Jim Gaffigan
It's pretty perfect.
Stephen Colbert
Good.
Jim Gaffigan
Right?
Stephen Colbert
Do you know there's a difference between, like, bacon that says, like, you know, uncured or cured? Like, it all tastes the same? What's an uncured versus a cured bacon?
Jim Gaffigan
I think it's. I mean, I think we're now in this day and age where we're having an awakening to all the poisons in our food, thanks to RFK Jr. So, I think that. I mean, maybe I'm a little bit more open to it. About.
Stephen Colbert
To the poisons?
Jim Gaffigan
No, to, like, getting some of those uncured things out. I think it's better for you if it's uncured, right?
Stephen Colbert
If it's uncured. So it's uncured means, like, it's unvaccinated. Cause they didn't cure.
Jim Gaffigan
No, I think it's. No, I think that it's.
Stephen Colbert
This pig died of COVID Well, we
Jim Gaffigan
know that, like, what, Cured meat is really bad for you.
Stephen Colbert
Right? Just salt. Right. Isn't that just true?
Progressive Insurance Announcer
I don't know.
Jim Gaffigan
You know, I tell diarrhea jokes for a living. I mean. But no, there is something about. I just think the most interesting fact about bacon.
Stephen Colbert
What is the most. Hold on, ladies and gentlemen, hold. What is the most interesting fact about bacon?
Jim Gaffigan
Jim? Every union soldier was given a ration of bacon. I think. That's what happens when you don't read and you just get informed by Instagram reels, you know,
Stephen Colbert
Least favorite smell.
Jim Gaffigan
You know, I love my teenagers, but, like, some of the odors that come out of children, particularly teenage boys. Yeah. Is unbelievable.
Stephen Colbert
Yeah. Little gamey.
Jim Gaffigan
Unbelievable. And they just. Not only does it smell bad, they think it's funny. That's the problem.
Stephen Colbert
That's funny, though, is the problem. That is funny. Earliest memory.
Jim Gaffigan
Gosh. You know, I was one of these kids. There was. I was the youngest of six, and I remember there was a bunch of times where drinks were spilled on me when I was a little kid.
Stephen Colbert
Wait a second. I mean, like, milk. Unintentionally like a Harvey Wallbanger.
Jim Gaffigan
Tray of Cokes, a tray of milk. You know, it just happened three or four times, but I would be like four or five, and there'd be like this. You know, maybe one of my brothers had hit the waiter and these drinks would fall on me. So that's what I really remember. I remember drinks falling on me, which is really a metaphor for my life. Right.
Stephen Colbert
Cats or dogs?
Jim Gaffigan
I love both, but dogs. Oh, cats, dogs. Right.
Stephen Colbert
Yeah.
Jim Gaffigan
Yeah.
Stephen Colbert
You only get one song to listen to for the rest of your life. You don't have to listen to it constantly, but when you go to listen to music, this is the only song you get. What is it?
Jim Gaffigan
I am going to. My children hate that. I love sad songs. I love. And there's this song, this. It's based on an Irish poem called Raglan Road. It's essentially about unrequited love. And so. But I love it. I love sad songs. So. And I can listen to that. And when we drive back and forth from Westchester, I play it. And they really despise it. So that's.
Stephen Colbert
If you like really sad songs. Have you ever listened to any Mountain Goats?
Jim Gaffigan
No. Oh, oh.
Stephen Colbert
Sax Rohmer, Number one. There's a line that goes. And a rabbit gives up somewhere and a dozen hawks to send.
Jim Gaffigan
Oh, wow.
Stephen Colbert
Every moment leads toward its own sad end.
Jim Gaffigan
Well, you know about the Portuguese that. Like the Portuguese.
Stephen Colbert
I know very little about the Portuguese. Well, the Portuguese, other than all the octopuses.
Jim Gaffigan
The Portuguese have their. I wish a sonata, or I can't remember the term, but, like, the sad song is such a cultural important event in Portuguese culture that there will be. There are restaurants you will go to, and people will come in and sing these sad songs. Because the Portuguese were such explorers. So, like, everyone would lose their wife or their husband. They'd go on a boat trip and they'd disappear. So it was. But it's a big tradition of sad songs. And I wish I knew the name. The name of the thing. Do you know what I'm talking about? Fado, fado, fado. Amazing stuff.
Stephen Colbert
What is the song?
Jim Gaffigan
Oh, my song. Raglan Road.
Stephen Colbert
Raglan Road. Okay.
Jim Gaffigan
Yes. And it's a poem by Patrick Kavanaugh.
Stephen Colbert
Do you know it?
Jim Gaffigan
Well? Yeah, but would you mind giving this a taste? You know, I mean, on rag. No, I can't do that. I'm not. I appreciate it, you know, See, let me explain something. There are some comedians that want to be musicians. I'm not one of them.
Stephen Colbert
Yeah, but can you.
Jim Gaffigan
On Raglan Road I saw her standing there and now I'm too nervous to even think of the words. But it is. It is. I mean, go to your Spotify and check it out, and if you spend time in Ireland, they might play it in a pub. It's a pretty popular place.
Stephen Colbert
I love how sad the Irish get. It's wonderful.
Jim Gaffigan
Yeah.
Stephen Colbert
How much they enjoy the sadness.
Jim Gaffigan
They do.
Stephen Colbert
Yeah. Yeah. What number am I thinking of?
Jim Gaffigan
5. No. You always say no.
Stephen Colbert
Well, it's no, you're wrong. You're wrong. Okay.
Jim Gaffigan
Oh. Cause you're not. It's usually people think it's 1 to 10, but it's no.
Stephen Colbert
No. I am thinking of a number. Describe the rest of your life in five words.
Jim Gaffigan
Nobody works harder than Gaffigan.
Stephen Colbert
Congratulations, Jim.
Jim Gaffigan
Thank you.
Stephen Colbert
You're known. I'm known. Thank you for listening to the Late Show POD show with Stephen Colbert. Just one more thing. If you want to see more of me, come to The Late Show YouTube channel for more clips and exclusives.
Progressive Insurance Announcer
You're listening to this podcast, so I know you've got a curious mind. Here's a helpful fact you might not know yet. Drivers who switch and save with Progressive save over $900 on average. Pop over to progressive.com, answer some questions, and you'll get a quick quote with discounts that are easy to come by. In fact, 99% of their auto customers earn at least one discount. Visit progressive.com and see if you can enjoy a little cash back. Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and affiliates. National average 12 month savings of $946 by new customers surveyed who saved with Progressive between June 2024 and May 2025. Potential savings will vary.
Blinds.com Announcer
The right window treatments change everything. Your sleep, your privacy, the way every room looks and feels. @blinds.com, we've spent 30 years making it surprisingly simple to get exactly what your home needs. We've covered over 25 million windows and have 50,000 five star reviews to prove we deliver. Whether you DIY it or want a pro to handle everything from measure to install, we have you covered. Real design professionals, free samples, zero pressure. Right now. Get up to 40% off site wide. Plus get a free professional measure@blinds.com rules and restrictions apply.
Episode: Jim Gaffigan's Colbert Questionert
Date: April 13, 2026
In this lively and humorous episode, Stephen Colbert puts comedian Jim Gaffigan in the hot seat with his signature "Colbert Questionnaire," a rapid-fire series of quirky and probing questions designed to reveal surprising truths and character quirks of his guests. The conversation maintains a playful tone, with Colbert’s wit matched by Gaffigan’s dry and self-deprecating humor. Beyond laughs, the duo touches on nostalgia, mortality, faith, family, and even deep-cut music recommendations—all filtered through Jim Gaffigan’s unique comedic perspective.
This episode of the Colbert Questionert showcases Jim Gaffigan’s quick wit and reflective side. Through seemingly simple questions, both hosts reveal layers of personality, thoughtful introspection, and plenty of laughs—serving up a well-balanced mix of humor and humanity.