The Late Show Pod Show with Stephen Colbert – Episode Summary: “Stephen Presents: Cole Escola (Extended)”

Release Date: May 29, 2025
Host: CBS
Guest: Cole Escola, Broadway Star and Tony Award Nominee

Introduction and Setting the Scene

The episode opens with casual banter between Stephen Colbert and Jon Meacham, setting a relaxed and personable tone for the discussion. The hosts engage in light-hearted conversation about their shared experiences with constant construction noise near their studio on Broadway. This segment not only humanizes the hosts but also establishes a relatable atmosphere for listeners familiar with New York City's ever-changing landscape.

Notable Quote:

• Jon Meacham [01:00]: "It's hump day."

Navigating the Construction Chaos

Colbert and Meacham delve into the intricacies of ongoing construction projects near their location, sharing anecdotes about past and present building endeavors. They discuss the challenges of working amidst heavy machinery and the unique geological aspects of Broadway, such as the proximity to bedrock. This discussion provides listeners with an insider's glimpse into the urban development that shapes their work environment.

Notable Quotes:

• Jon Meacham [01:33]: "They're drilling into the bedrock."
• Stephen Colbert [02:29]: "And that's where we are."

The Mystery of the Daily Bang

A humorous yet intriguing segment unfolds as the hosts recount the enigmatic "Daily Bang" noise that resonates from their studio each afternoon. Colbert affectionately attributes the sound to their stagehand, Nikki, creating a light-hearted mystery that adds a whimsical element to the episode.

Notable Quotes:

• Stephen Colbert [05:35]: "Our joke is that Nikki is body slamming someone up there."
• Jon Meacham [05:55]: "The mystery of the Daily Bang continues."

Introducing the Guest: Cole Escola

Transitioning from their local anecdotes, Colbert introduces Cole Escola, a celebrated Broadway star known for his role in "Strangers with Candy" and his Tony-nominated performance in "O Mary." The introduction sets the stage for an in-depth conversation about Escola’s latest theatrical achievement.

Notable Quote:

• Stephen Colbert [12:25]: "Please welcome to the Late Show, Cole Escola."

In-Depth Conversation with Cole Escola

Background and Inspiration for "O Mary"

Cole Escola opens up about his Broadway play "O Mary," portraying Mary Todd Lincoln as an alcoholic aspirant cabaret star. He delves into the genesis of the play, inspired by contemplating the impact of Abraham Lincoln's assassination on his wife. This introspective exploration highlights Escola's creative process and his ability to blend historical context with contemporary storytelling.

Notable Quotes:

• Cole Escola [14:21]: "It's about Mary Todd Lincoln's hopes and dreams."
• Cole Escola [15:09]: "What if Abraham Lincoln's assassination wasn't such a bad thing for Mary Todd?"

Journey of "O Mary" to Broadway Success

Escola recounts the journey of "O Mary" from its initial off-Broadway run at the Lucille Lortel Theater to its extended performances and eventual move to the prestigious Lyceum Theater on Broadway. He expresses astonishment at the play's reception and the enthusiastic embrace by the audience, underscoring the unpredictable nature of theatrical success.

Notable Quotes:

• Cole Escola [16:24]: "It's still surprising to me."
• Jon Meacham [16:50]: "What was it like to see somebody else doing the part that you created?"

Collaboration and Support Within the Theater Community

Cole expresses gratitude towards fellow actors Betty Gilpin and Titus Burgess, who took over his role in "O Mary." He emphasizes the supportive and collaborative nature of the theater community, highlighting how such relationships can elevate a production and foster mutual growth among artists.

Notable Quotes:

• Cole Escola [16:51]: "They enthusiastically took over this role and loved it like it was their own."
• Jon Meacham [17:15]: "People hate you."

Future Aspirations and Creative Directions

Looking ahead, Escola shares his desire to diversify his roles by portraying a straight character, moving away from the flamboyant persona he is known for. This ambition reflects his commitment to challenging himself and expanding his versatility as an actor.

Notable Quotes:

• Cole Escola [17:32]: "I'm dying to play a straight guy."
• Jon Meacham [19:04]: "Being known."

Interactive and Humorous Segments

The episode features playful interactions where Escola demonstrates his acting skills by attempting to portray a straight character, leading to humorous exchanges with the hosts. These segments showcase Escola's comedic talent and his ability to engage the audience through improvisation and character work.

Notable Quotes:

• Cole Escola [20:05]: "Do you know that eggs are actually bad for you?"
• Jon Meacham [20:19]: "Ow. I felt like I just lost an argument I wasn't having."

Conclusion and Final Remarks

As the episode draws to a close, Colbert and Meacham express their appreciation for Educa's presence and contributions. They promote "O Mary," encouraging listeners to experience the play at the Lyceum Theater, thereby supporting the arts and highlighting the show's success.

Notable Quotes:

• Jon Meacham [20:45]: "O Mary is on Broadway at the Lyceum Theater."
• Stephen Colbert [20:49]: "Thank you for being here. Thank you for the frippery."

Key Takeaways:

• Cole Escola's Versatility: Escola's ability to transition between his iconic comedic roles and his dramatic portrayal of Mary Todd Lincoln underscores his range as an actor.

• Theatrical Success Through Collaboration: The supportive relationships within the Broadway community are pivotal in bringing performances like "O Mary" to fruition and achieving extended runs.

• Humor and Human Connection: The interaction between the hosts and the guest fosters a genuine and entertaining dialogue, making complex topics like theater production accessible and engaging to listeners.

Final Note:

For those interested in experiencing Cole Escola's acclaimed performance, "O Mary" is currently running at the Lyceum Theater on Broadway. The episode not only highlights the intricacies of bringing a play to life but also celebrates the collaborative spirit that defines the New York theater scene.