The Lord of Spirits Podcast | Ancient Faith Ministries

Episode: "Taught by a Star to Worship the Sun of Righteousness"
Hosts: Fr. Andrew Stephen Damick & Fr. Stephen De Young
Date: December 25, 2020
Theme: The Seen and Unseen World in Orthodox Christian Tradition (Christmas Special)

Overview

This special Christmas episode explores the intersections of astrology, scripture, the unseen world, and the Nativity of Christ. The hosts discuss ancient Jewish and Christian understandings of the heavens, the biblical and patristic roots of associating stars with angelic beings, how astrology relates to the gospel, the true nature of the Magi’s star, and the theological meaning behind Christ’s birth as cosmic good news. The show seeks to recapture the depth and wonder of the enchanted worldview pervasive in the Orthodox tradition, especially as it relates to the union of the seen and unseen in the Christmas story.

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. Ancient Synagogues, Zodiac Imagery, and First-Century Judaism

[03:47–06:43]

• Galilean synagogues from the time of Christ contained zodiac mosaics.
• Fr. Andrew: “When Christ entered to pray and even to preach in nearly any Galilean synagogue in the first century, quite prominently displayed in mosaic would have been an image of the 12 signs of the zodiac. What can this possibly mean? Were ancient Judeans syncretistically incorporating pagan astrology into their synagogues? And if so, why didn't Jesus protest this?” (03:47)
• The zodiac presence isn’t syncretism; it’s tied to the ancient Jewish understanding of the stars and their relationships to spiritual beings.

2. Jewish and Pagan Astrology

[04:10–08:44]

• Fr. Stephen: “Jewish astrology is a thing ... it goes all the way back to ancient Israel.”
• Jews (and pagans) saw the sun, moon, and stars as linked to divine beings. The difference: Pagans considered them gods to be worshipped; Jews saw them as subordinate “officials” under God’s governance.
• Ancient astrology wasn’t simplistic fortune-telling—it was layered and intertwined with religion, politics, and mythology.
• The “flat” modern, materialist view dismisses this as superstition, but the ancient view saw political, mythic, and astrological realities as interdependent.

Notable Quote

“For ancient people, all three [political, mythological, astrological] are real, and you have to have all three transparencies layered over each other to look at it and see the whole event.” — Fr. Stephen (12:26)

3. Fate, Determinism, and Angelic Powers

[13:49–17:09]

• Ancient mythologies saw not just mortals but also gods subject to fate; even the gods couldn’t escape destiny.
• In contrast, in Israelite (and Orthodox Christian) thought, even the angelic beings are not independent, but work as God’s emissaries.
• Christian cosmology opposes fatalism and astrological determinism, affirming divine governance and human free will.

4. The Layered Meaning of Stars in Scripture

[17:13–24:25]

• The heavens/angelic hosts function as communicators of God’s will. Biblical references to sun, moon, stars are more than poetic; they encode layers of meaning including “astrological” ones.
• Fr. Andrew: “We’re not engaging in syncretism ... We’re going to be looking closely at the scriptures and seeing what’s actually going on there.”

5. Listener Questions: Influence of Stars, Angels, and Free Will

[18:38–24:25]

• Ancient and medieval Christian thinkers recognized that heavenly bodies (as angels) had influence, but not to the point of overriding human freedom.
• Angelic beings are channels—messengers or agents—but not rulers who control destiny. God acts through them, but is not the Fates.

6. Psalm 19 and the Ecliptic (“Their Line Goes Out ...”)

[24:48–34:08]

• Psalm 19: The “line” (often translated as “voice”) refers to the ecliptic—the path of the sun through the heavens, along which the constellations (zodiac signs) appear.
• Even the biblical text embeds astronomical and astrological references, such as “the heavens declare the glory of God … day to day pours out speech.”
• This communication of knowledge through the heavens is seen as both literal and theologically significant in Scripture.

Notable Quote

“The language of the sun to rule the day and the moon and stars to rule the night is all over the place in the Old Testament. And we gloss over that rule verb very quickly, but it actually is there.” — Fr. Stephen (06:26)

7. The Sun of Righteousness and Liturgical Hymnography

[34:14–39:39]

• Nativity hymnography (“Son of Righteousness”, “from the East of the Highest”) references not just Christ as the Sun, but also his cosmic role as fulfillment of the ecliptic imagery—tied to biblical astronomy.
• Christ’s coming is heralded by cosmic signs with deep scriptural and liturgical resonance.

Notable Quote

“So we have this element of the Son of righteousness ... refers to the point of origin of Christ ... that point of origin of the sun and this bridegroom language related to the sun ... that triparian, which of course comes later than the Scriptures, also has this astrological layer of meaning in it.” — Fr. Stephen (37:46)

8. Pauline Astrology: The Heavens Declare the Gospel

[39:39–54:01]

• St. Paul uses Psalm 19 in Romans 10: “Their voice has gone out into all the earth ...”
• Not merely the apostles physically traveling everywhere, but a reference to the apostolic ministry as a fulfillment/embodiment of the astrological and theological significance of the twelve tribes/zodiac (constellations), now centered on Christ.
• The twelve apostles, sitting on twelve thrones, judging the twelve tribes, correspond to the 12 tribes/constellations—cosmic governance.
• The Gospel is “written in the stars,” not as fortune-telling, but as a deep, prefigurative layer of revelation that was accessible even to pagans, making them “without excuse.”

Memorable Moment

“So this is now the apostles taking over that function. And so this is a fulfillment of the kind of move that Deborah was talking about in her song [Judges 5].” — Fr. Stephen (65:14)

9. Zodiac and the Tribes of Israel

[51:38–59:19]

• The twelve tribes corresponded (in Second Temple and rabbinic Judaism) to the twelve constellations—entrenched in temple ritual, priestly dress, and the general Jewish worldview.
• This is evidenced in literature (e.g. Jubilees, Genesis 49, Psalm 19) and even in synagogue art, rooted in a vision of Israel’s destiny that’s “written in the stars.”

10. The Christmas Star, Magi, and the Gospel in the Stars

[66:19–98:19]

• The magi were Mesopotamian/Persian astrologers/priests capable of interpreting rare celestial events.
• The “star in the east” is not a comet or ordinary “constellation”—but a confluence of astronomical signs (conjunctions) pointing to something earth-shaking (see section on dating below).
• Early Christians, especially St. Ignatius of Antioch, saw the star as a cosmic sign, hidden from the “rulers of this age” (i.e., angelic/demonic powers).

Notable Quote

“God appeared humanized in order to bring about the great newness of unending life ... the destruction of death was being prepared.” — St. Ignatius of Antioch, quoted by Fr. Andrew (74:48)

11. Hidden Mysteries: The Rulers of This Age, Angels, and the Nativity

[75:08–92:22]

• St. Ignatius and St. Paul both teach that the Incarnation and death of Christ were “hidden” from the “rulers of this age” (demons), and only revealed to them by the “star” and subsequent events.
• The visible sign in the heavens isn’t just for the Magi, but a cosmic signal to spiritual beings—a “D-Day” for the demonic powers, as expressed in the apocalyptic reaction of Herod (the “counterattack”, like that of Pharaoh in Exodus).
• This ties directly to recurring liturgical texts referencing the “mystery hidden from ages, unknown to the angels, revealed to those who dwell on earth.”

12. Dating the Star of Bethlehem

[103:42–149:37]

• Analysis of Herod’s death (likely 1 BC, not 4 BC), the Gospel timeline, and the Passover calendar points to 3 BC as the year of Jesus’s birth.
• The feast of Christmas (December 25) is determined by early liturgical tradition relating conception (Annunciation, March 25) and birth, not by Roman pagan feasts.
• A rare astronomical conjunction in 3 BC, on Tishri 1 (Jewish New Year, Rosh Hashanah—coinciding with Noah’s birthday and coronation of David), is a compelling candidate for the Magi’s star. This day, on the Gregorian calendar, is September 11th, 3 BC.
• The Magi’s journey and the “star” are thus a confluence of theology, astronomy, and liturgy.

Notable Quote

“So all of this comes together for a pretty strong argument ... and that day on our modern calendar was September 11th...” — Fr. Stephen (148:47)

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• On the Psalms regarding the heavens:
  “The word ‘line’ there is referring to what’s called the ecliptic ... the path that the sun follows over the course of the year.” (29:23)

• On Pauline Cosmology:
  “The heavens declare the glory of God—St. Paul is saying, the Gospel is the content that’s being communicated, the word of Christ.” (48:48)

• On the Magi and the star:
  “This is what the Magi see. This is what St. Ignatius is talking about. This is what St. Paul is talking about.” (149:19)

• Patristic reflection:
  “God appeared humanized in order to bring about the great newness of unending life. And that which had been planned by God was given a beginning.” — St. Ignatius, quoted (74:48)

Important Timestamps

• 03:47 — Zodiac mosaics in first-century synagogues and their significance
• 12:26 — Layered realities: politics, myth, and astrology in ancient worldview
• 24:48, 29:23 — Psalm 19 and the ecliptic; differences in biblical translations
• 34:14 — “Sun of Righteousness” in Orthodox Nativity hymnography explained
• 39:39 — St. Paul’s use of Psalm 19: “Their sound has gone forth…” as applied to the apostolic mission
• 51:38 — The tribes of Israel as constellations (Matzarot)
• 65:14 — The apostles as the new “stars”/constellations
• 74:48 — St. Ignatius on the cosmic significance of the Nativity
• 90:03 — Herod’s massacre as demonic counterattack, typology with Pharaoh
• 119:51–125:00 — Dating the birth of Christ, why the traditional Christmas date is chosen
• 148:47 — September 11, 3 BC: the probable date of the Nativity based on astronomical and scriptural evidence

Takeaways & Final Reflections

• The episode challenges modern “flat” readings, demonstrating how biblical cosmology, astrology, and theology are complexly interwoven.
• The “star of Bethlehem” becomes not merely a historical curiosity, but a cosmic signification of Christ’s victory over demonic powers, the reuniting of heaven and earth, and the restoration of creation’s purpose.
• The reclaiming of time (liturgical calendar), space (sanctified places), and cosmic imagery (stars and tribes) is an ongoing act of Christian worship and worldview transformation.
• Modern materialism/alientation undermines our connection to creation—Orthodox tradition invites us to re-enchant the world, participate in cosmic liturgy, and know ourselves as creatures in God’s sacred cosmos.

Suggestions for Further Listening/Reading

• On the ancient worldview and biblical cosmology, see Michael Heiser’s work on the Divine Council.
• For more on the patristic understanding of the Nativity, explore the hymns of the Orthodox Church and writings of St. Ignatius of Antioch.
• For a critique of “pagan Christmas” myths, see William Tighe’s article “Calculating Christmas.”

“Glory to God in the highest, and on earth, peace, goodwill toward men.”
(Luke 2:14; sung by the “stars” at Christ’s birth)

For episode questions, email lordofspirits@ancientfaith.com or join the Lord of Spirits Facebook group. The podcasts air live on the 2nd and 4th Thursdays of the month, 7pm Eastern.