Podcast Summary: The Marketing Architects

Episode Title: Nerd Alert: Don't Age Out Your Audience
Release Date: July 24, 2025
Hosts: Lena Jasper & Rob Demars
Description: In this episode of "The Marketing Architects," hosts Lena Jasper and Rob Demars delve into the dynamics of brand loyalty among older consumers. Challenging the prevailing stereotypes, they explore whether older audiences are truly more loyal to longstanding brands or if their purchasing behaviors mirror those of younger demographics.

1. Introduction to the Episode

[00:00 - 00:39]

The episode kicks off with a light-hearted exchange between hosts Lena Jasper and Rob Demars, setting the tone for an engaging discussion centered around academic marketing research. Lena introduces the "Nerd Alert" segment, highlighting their commitment to translating complex research into actionable marketing insights.

2. Exploring Brand Loyalty Among Older Consumers

[00:39 - 04:27]

Lena presents a pivotal study titled "Examining Older Consumers' Loyalty towards Older Brands and Grocery Retailing" by Pei Lingpa, Rachel Kennedy, Zhang Trinh, Bill Page, and Byron Sharp from the University of South Australia (Journal of Retailing and Consumer Services, 2020).

Lena Jasper:
"This study digs into the belief that might feel intuitively true but might not hold up under scrutiny. Do older consumers mostly stick with the old brands they've always known?" [02:07]

Rob shares his personal perspective, questioning the definition of "older" and contemplating whether his own loyalty to brands might be more pronounced compared to younger consumers. Despite being 51, Lena clarifies that the study categorizes "older" as 55 and above.

3. Key Findings of the Study

[02:12 - 06:51]

Lena summarizes the study's methodology and surprising findings:

• Data Scope: Analyzed over 88,000 grocery trips across 60 brands in six diverse categories (e.g., deodorant, dog food, shampoo, sauces).
• Methodology: Utilized actual panel data from single-person households to accurately track purchase frequency and brand loyalty, avoiding the pitfalls of self-reported data.
• Findings:
  • Brand Loyalty: Older shoppers (55+) do not exhibit a stronger preference for older brands compared to younger consumers. Instead, loyalty correlates more with brand size.
  • Customer Profiles: There is no significant difference in the customer base profiles of older versus newer brands across age groups.
  • Brand Repertoire: All age groups tend to shop from a variety of brands, indicating that familiarity and longevity of a brand alone do not dictate consumer loyalty.

Lena Jasper:
"Despite common stereotypes, the data shows that older people try new brands. Older brands don't have a lock on older buyers." [05:15]

4. Broader Implications Across Product Categories

[06:51 - 08:49]

Rob questions whether these findings are exclusive to grocery shopping. Lena affirms that additional research across various categories supports the study's conclusions:

• Financial Services (2006, Uncles & Lee): Older consumers showed no significant preference for older financial brands, maintaining a mix of newer and established providers.
• Automobiles (2005 & 2010, Lambert et al., Anderson & Sharp): Initial studies suggested older adults preferred established car brands, but later research indicated that while they might favor these brands slightly, they still explore newer options.
• Diverse Product Categories (2012): A comprehensive study spanning 25 years across 50 product and service categories found minimal age-related differences in brand user profiles, reinforcing that older consumers are not confined to legacy brands.

Lena Jasper:
"Across all these different categories, the pattern mostly holds. Older consumers do not show a consistent preference for older brands." [07:48]

5. Addressing Potential Nuances and Questions

[07:19 - 08:49]

Rob introduces a nuanced question regarding brand loyalty when older consumers enter new product categories:

Rob Demars:
"If I'm an older consumer and I'm brand new to a category, am I more loyal to the brand that has been around longer?" [06:51]

Lena acknowledges the importance of mental availability and brand visibility, suggesting that while familiarity plays a role in initial adoption, the overall pattern indicates that older consumers remain open to exploring brands beyond their established favorites.

Lena Jasper:
"It's like your brand preferences are like your closet. Sure, there are a few classic pieces you've had for years. That doesn't mean you never add new stuff." [07:46]

6. Marketing Implications and Strategies

[08:06 - 08:49]

Lena draws actionable insights for marketers:

• Avoid Age-Based Stereotypes: Older consumers are not inherently set in their brand preferences and are open to trying new brands.
• Broaden Marketing Efforts: Brands should not exclude older demographics under the assumption they won't engage. Instead, ensure visibility and relevance to capture this audience.
• Stay Competitive: Legacy brands must continuously innovate and stay competitive to maintain their customer base, just as newer brands strive to gain traction.

Lena Jasper:
"Older brands can't rely on familiarity alone. They have to stay relevant, visible, and competitive, just like newer ones." [05:50]

Rob Demars:
"I am surprised. I would have thought that older folks have become pretty brand loyal by the time they get over the 50-year-old line." [04:55]

7. Conclusion and Final Thoughts

[08:49 - End]

The episode concludes with Lena emphasizing the importance of not overlooking older consumers in marketing strategies. By understanding that this demographic is as dynamic and brand-open as younger counterparts, marketers can effectively reach and engage a broader audience.

Lena Jasper:
"They're open to trying your brand. You just have to get in front of them." [08:48]

Rob echoes the sentiment, acknowledging the study's value in reshaping marketing approaches towards older demographics.

Notable Quotes

• Rob Demars:
  "I've graphed my nerd enthusiasm and the curve is exponential." [00:34]

• Lena Jasper:
  "Older brands can't rely on familiarity alone. They have to stay relevant, visible, and competitive, just like newer ones." [05:50]

• Rob Demars:
  "I would have thought that older folks have become pretty brand loyal by the time they get over the 50-year-old line." [04:55]

• Lena Jasper:
  "It's like your brand preferences are like your closet. Sure, there are a few classic pieces you've had for years. That doesn't mean you never add new stuff." [07:46]

Key Takeaways

1. Challenging Stereotypes: Older consumers (55+) are not inherently more loyal to older brands; their purchasing behaviors are similar to younger consumers.
2. Brand Repertoire: All age groups prefer a mix of brands, dispelling the notion that older consumers stick solely to legacy brands.
3. Marketing Strategies: Brands should focus on maintaining relevance and visibility across all age demographics, leveraging the openness of older consumers to new options.
4. Broader Applicability: The study's findings extend beyond grocery shopping, applying to various product and service categories, including financial services, automobiles, and personal care.

Connect with The Marketing Architects:
Stay updated with the latest in marketing trends and research by following The Marketing Architects on LinkedIn. If you enjoyed this episode, please leave us a review!