Loading summary
Commercial Announcer
Upgrade your laundry routine with a durable and reliable Maytag laundry pair at Lowes. Like the new Maytag washer and dryer with performance enhanced stain fighting power designed to cut through serious dirt and grime. And what's great is this laundry pair is in stock and ready for delivery when you need it the most. Don't miss out. Shop Maytag in store or online today at Lowe's.
Sarah Longwell
Hey, this is Sarah. Look, I'm standing out front of a.m. p.m. Right now and, well, you're sweet and all, but I found something more fulfilling, even kind of cheesy. But I like it. Sure, you met some of my dietary needs, but they've just got it all. So farewell.
JVL
Oatmeal.
Sarah Longwell
So long, you strange soggy.
Commercial Announcer
Break up with bland breakfast and taste AM PM's bacon, egg and cheese biscuit made with ktree eggs, smoked bacon and melty cheese on a buttery biscuit. AM PM Too much. Good stuff.
JVL
Hey, TNL buddies, it's JVL and Sarah.
Sarah Longwell
What's up, guys?
JVL
We. We have a secret show for you right here. It's a really good one. It's. It's all the dark stuff that I kept on the back burner for the last week, so. And I'm just going to ambush Sarah with it.
Sarah Longwell
Yeah, I don't know what the topics are. This is. We do this sometimes. JVL is just going to come at me and we're going to see where it goes.
JVL
It's like Candid Camera, but with the end of the world. Here's the show. Enjoy. Hello, everyone. This is JVL here with my best friend, Sarah Longwell, publisher of the Bulwark. Sarah, my guy John Bolton was indicted yesterday.
Sarah Longwell
Sure was.
JVL
That's pretty cool, I guess. We now have Jim Comey and John Bolton indicted on what seemed to be bullshit charges. An actual weaponization of the Justice Department. I mean, it's not great, Bob.
Sarah Longwell
It's real bad. Here's my question, and maybe you can help me out with it that I've been wondering and haven't had a full chance to run down. This is why this is a secret show and it is this. I've seen a lot of people arguing that the Bolton case is sort of substantively different than the Comey Tish James case. It appears that for Comey and Tish James, and by appears, I mean these ones I have looked at pretty closely and like, they are trumped up nothings. Those are 100% meant to just screw with these people, mess with their lives and the likelihood, like they barely got indictments and they are very unlikely to almost no chance of getting convictions. Anything can happen. But whatever. The Bolton one, where he has kept documents that he shouldn't have, which is an interesting one from a. Hey, there was a whole timeline in which Trump was keeping documents he shouldn't have in Mar? A Lago. Not only was he keeping them, he wouldn't give them back. And if that case had gone to actual trial, if we've been able to really move that one forward, everybody seemed to agree that was a pretty open and shut case. Whereas, and then you got Mike Pence, right, And, and, and Joe Biden, everybody was like, suddenly there was a documents bonanza. Nobody was doing the correct thing with their documents. Although when they were asked for their documents back, they of course just apologized, gave them back. They, you know, I, it was sort of unclear why they had them, other than their being president and Vice president allowed them much more latitude with these kinds of documents. And so unlike other people, where people get prosecuted for this stuff all the time, because you are definitely not allowed to have them. And so now we've got John Bolton doing it now. And this was also a case that started under the Biden administration about Bolton having these classified documents. So I can't there. I think both things can be true. I think this can both be vindictive prosecution, which it clearly, clearly is against Bolton. But what I don't know is just like with Trump where you could say, like, well, some of the cases brought against him, like the Stormy Daniels case or the one against, you know, Trump Inc. Trump, they weren't like, great cases to bring, but like, there was underlying criminal activity. Now it might not have been prosecuted in a different world. And I think that might be the case here, right, where it is both that maybe he did something wrong and it's vindictive prosecution, which is just different than Tish James and James Comey, which are just purely made up for the reasons of vindictive or like not made up. Like, they're like these tech. They're trying to get them on these like real technicalities of something that it's not even clear they did. So anyway, those are how I see them as being different. But what do you think?
JVL
So we don't know. And you know, I, I don't want to prejudge it. We will find out. I mean, I, My general view of classified documents mishandling is that, I mean, a lot of it is really circumstantial and like, one of the reasons normies, right. If you are just a line agent in the FBI or the NSA or something and you, you don't have access to all that many classified documents, which is why it's a, a big deal if you mishandle them. Whereas at the upper echelons of government where you're like deeply involved in record keeping about what you do, there's, there's a, just a, a sea of documents. Documents do tend to be over classified. Like we do classify too much stuff and like innocent mistakes are the norm, not the, not the exception. And like the, the law of this as practice is typically like it's self policing or you know, in cases where you don't like you find yourself, you yourself find classified documents. You're like, oh crap, have your lawyer call the archives or the Justice Department to try to arrange a return of them. It just happens. And what made the Trump prosecution notable wasn't that he had classified documents. Like that is a totally, that's a non story. What made it notable was that he engaged in a prolonged period of lying to the Department of Justice about whether or not he had them and he refused to give them back and engaged in all sorts of criminal activity in order to avoid giving them back. Like that is, that is different. It's just a wholly different. Now maybe John Bolton, I was clear.
Sarah Longwell
That I also thought it was different. Right. I made that clear.
JVL
No, no, I.
Sarah Longwell
Completely different.
JVL
Maybe, maybe Bolton did the same thing and we'll find out. But I will say this is one of the. Because we're going to get real dark as we go. One of the few things that I feel relatively good about over the next three years is the criminal justice system. Because I think we have already seen that the Department of Justice is totally politicized and is going to prosecute people almost entirely based on politics, but they still have to convince juries. And that's one thing that MAGA can't fix. Right. Like they can't get into the jury room. And what we've seen with grand juries already has been very encouraging. And I, you know, I mean you could see where they will try to bring these cases in friendlier venues. Right. Like, you know, oh, we'll see if we can find a way to try them in Texas. Right. But yeah, in general I feel like a jury of 12 of your peers is like the closest to an uncorruptible place as there is. So I feel pretty good about that.
Sarah Longwell
Even with your low opinion of humans.
JVL
Yeah. Because one person in the jury room who is like not a mouth Breather can just say no, right? This is, this is why, you know, it only takes one of 12. You know, what are the chances if you put 12 people together that one of them will have an IQ over 80? I mean, it's not bad. That's pretty good odds. So that's bad. But I want to move us into item two here, because what I'm trying to do is layer. This feels like it was a slow newsweek, and yet I think there's so much that happened that just feels like authoritarianism run amok. Andrew Cuomo said this week that if Mamdani wins, quote, Trump will take over the city and it will be Mayor Trump who runs the city. This is probably not true, but on the other hand, like, it's not, it's not a ridiculous political attack, right? The idea that if, if Mamdani wins and Donald Trump has made it clear he does not like Mamdani, then Donald Trump will attempt to punish the city of New York for electing a politician he does not like, and that we're now at a place where that is just a totally acceptable of. Sure. Of course. Of course he would do that.
Sarah Longwell
Can I just quickly flag, though, how insane of an argument that is from Cuomo? Elect me because the authoritarian likes me better than the other guy.
JVL
I mean, it's, it's not insane.
Sarah Longwell
Shut up, Cuomo.
JVL
It may be the best argument he has.
Sarah Longwell
I don't know. I just, I think it, I think it demonstrates just how cynical and nihilistic Cuomo is sure to try to. He's basically like, threatening New Yorkers with Trump to get himself elected, even though he's Trump's preferred candidate. Gross, gross, gross. Okay. Like we've been saying, I'm anti anti Mamdani and I'm, I'm hard anti Cuomo. That said, I do. When we were in New York recently, I was talking to someone in New York and I was asking them, like, you know, I'm surprised you guys have avoided the National Guard so far. Like everywhere else, they've been going in to every major liberal city, or at least saber rattling about it. So why not New York? Why do you think? I, I, I suspect that would be in a way where you could sort of get away with Chicago because a. Whether it's true or not, the perception of Chicago as like, very, very like a place of deep crime, I think is enough of a national story that they can sort of use the pretext of that. It's also like the, and then D.C. i was going to say, like the Media is here, but we also have home rule complications that make D.C. a little bit different. You go to New York, you are full on in the national media. You are, you are in the place where the finance, finance and media live. And I wonder if there's something about New York that is causing him to not do that yet. But maybe it's true that as soon as Mamdani is in there, they will do the National Guard.
LifeLock Advertiser
October is cybersecurity awareness month. A reminder that your digital life is always a risk. Every day hackers steal identities, drain bank accounts and open fraudulent accounts. Lifelock is here with tips to help prevent you from becoming a victim. Use strong passwords, set up multi factor authentication on your accounts, report scams and update the software on your devices. And for peace of mind, get LifeLock. LifeLock monitors millions of data points a second for threats to your identity. If your identity is stolen, a LifeLock US based restoration specialist will fix it, guaranteed or your money back. Plus, LifeLock plans include the million dollar protection package, meaning LifeLock will reimburse you to your plan's limits if you lose your money due to identity theft. Stay smart, stay safe and stay protected. Get comprehensive identity protection with a 30 day free trial@lifelock.com use promo code NEWS. That's lifelock.com promo code NEWS for 30 days. Free terms apply.
Commercial Announcer
Time is precious and so are our pets. So time with our pets is extra precious. That's why we started Dutch. Dutch provides 24,7 access to licensed vets with unlimited virtual visits and follow ups for up to five pets. You can mess message a vet at any time and schedule a video visit the same day. Our vets can even prescribe medication for many ailments and shipping is always free. With Dutch, you'll get more time with your pets and year round peace of mind when it comes to their vet care.
JVL
I mean, I think it's as simple as Eric Adams is mayor and Eric Adams is a Trump ally.
Sarah Longwell
Yeah, right.
JVL
And so that's right, yeah, you're the pretext. Trump wants pretexts. And so the pretext to move on New York would be, well, they elected a socialist and we got to stop socialism. Look at what this horrible socialist has done, right? And then it'll be, look, everything was fine in New York when Eric Adams was Eric Adams, who I've just pardoned or whatever. When he was in office, everything was fine, but it's all gone to hell since you elected this socialist. And, and then they'll go, I mean that's just what I assume also it could be they can't eat two major cities at the same time. I mean, Chicago is sucking up all of federal resources. I don't think they can do Chicago and New York simultaneously. I think they have to do these things in serial.
Sarah Longwell
What happens when there's, like, a real emergency? Like the kind of thing the National Guard would do before it was planting trees in major cities.
JVL
You mean like a. No, kings protest that they have to go break up, or do you mean something different? Different kind of emergency. What kind of emergency? Are you talking about a political emergency or, like, an actual natural disaster?
Sarah Longwell
I meant like a natural disaster.
JVL
I can tell you exactly what'll happen. If the natural disaster is in a blue area, they won't show up. And if it is in a red area, they will show up belatedly. And none of the voters there will blame them. They will blame the Democrats. Somehow it'll be, Somehow it was AOC's fault that the National Guard didn't get to Asheville North Carol or something, because that's how those people are.
Sarah Longwell
All right, keep going. What are we getting? We're getting progressively darker. You say?
JVL
Yeah, we're gonna get progressively darker. Pentagon has purged the press corps. There are only three American news outlets which are now credentialed at the Pentagon.
Sarah Longwell
One of them's Oan, One of which.
JVL
I have written for.
Sarah Longwell
Oh, the Federalist. Did you write for the Federalist?
JVL
I did.
Sarah Longwell
What'd you write?
JVL
I wrote a piece, a long piece, about how Prince Hans was not actually the bad guy in Frozen.
Sarah Longwell
Are you serious? Are you telling me the truth right now?
JVL
Yeah.
Sarah Longwell
Okay.
JVL
This is the piece I wrote for the Federalist.
Sarah Longwell
Man, I got to tell you, we were living in a different world when you just had the time to sit there and opine on the frozen characters.
JVL
My case for people listening is not that, of course, Prince Hans is the villain in the movie as we saw it, but if you go deep in the early versions of the frozen script, the reason Elsa has these powers is because she is cursed. Like, there's a prophecy, and they did away with the idea of a prophecy. And once there's no prophecy, which is powering her arc and all of the tragedy they have to create. They had to create a villain, right? Because the prophecy was the villain. And so that's why they took. So Prince Hans, his character, he takes a turn that is basically totally unearned. Like, he is a genuinely. Like, hey, Prince Hans is great. And when he turns and goes bad, you're like, wait, A minute. That feels out of left field. The answer is it was out of left field. It's because, as he was originally written, he wasn't the villain.
Sarah Longwell
Anyway, it does feel out of left field, now that you mention it.
JVL
It's the only thing wrong with that movie. It's a great movie.
Sarah Longwell
Great. Great music.
JVL
Yeah, fantastic. Anyway, that was the piece I wrote for the Federalist. Again, it was a different time. So our American Pentagon press corps is the Federalist, the Epoch Times and oan and six Turkish outlets which are of various connections to Erdogan.
Sarah Longwell
Well, like a surprising number of Turkish outlets.
JVL
Is there twice as many Turkish members of the Pentagon press corps as American?
Sarah Longwell
Well, we're all gonna have to start reading the Turkish papers to find out what's going on at our Pentagon.
JVL
So I don't know if you listened to Tim's Ann Applebaum show yesterday. I assume you did. She. Don't answer that. Don't answer that. She made a point which I had not considered, which is that the Pentagon and the Trump administration knew full well that no American news outlets would agree to this. And the whole point of it was to get them out of the building so that we now have official state sanctioned media outlets. Because that's what the Federalists and the Epoch Times and OAN are now. They are people who. They will report only the administration approved news. No different than, you know, Xing Zhao or Pravda or anything. So they've gone from being like, you know, obviously, totally, and maybe there's. This is a distinction without a difference, but from like, just ideological allies and political allies to wholly owned subsidiaries in terms of what they are allowed to report because they've signed a pledge. I thought that was pretty sinister.
Sarah Longwell
That is. Well, it is sinister. It's interesting, this idea that they wanted them out of the building on purpose because I will tell you, I am surprised at how many people didn't sign it, including people like the Washington examiner. And because we've had a real problem. I mean, Trump has been doing the thing where they kick out reporters who have been reporting stuff. Right. They're going after the Wall Street Journal. And the media has been. Has done nothing to defend themselves, their professional allies. Right. Their colleagues. And I was actually was genuinely viewed it as a positive, like a net positive.
JVL
Oh, don't. Don't do that.
Sarah Longwell
This is unwilling to sign it.
JVL
Now this, this wasn't principled. This is. I mean, what, what distinguishes Newsmax from OAN or the Federalist or the Epoch Times is that those three outlets which are on site are judgment proof because they have no assets like those. Those are fly by night operations with nothing for anybody to ever come after. Whereas if you are Fox or the Wall Street Journal or even Newsmax. Newsmax is a publicly traded company. You can get yourself into legal trouble. Right. You sign on that pledge and you wind up breaking it somehow accidentally. And now you are opening yourself up to legal action and you have assets. That's what this is about for them. They're like, no, no, we can't do that. We'll still be friendly to the administration. This is about principle. But like, we do have to protect our assets. And so they're, they're, they are not judgment proof. And you know, Oan and the Epoch Times and the Federalist are.
Sarah Longwell
Okay, well that. All right, you've convinced me that that is deeply sinister. And actually the only thing I'm going to. Yes. And on this is it does layer into what is. To me. Sometimes people ask the question, you know, what keeps you up at night? What are you most worried about? And for me, it is. And it's happening slowly, but it's happening really, really clearly. The media legacy and independent and new is increasingly owned by Trump. Sympathetic allies, people who are trying to curry favor with Trump. And that goes for Paramount and the Ellisons who have purchased Paramount, which owns cbs, they are trying to buy Warner Brothers. Goes for Elon Musk who owns X and Mark Zuckerberg who own, owns Instagram and Threads and, and Facebook. It goes for many of the people who are working on the AI slop that is coming our way. It Tick Tock was just sold to Trump's allies. Like, the. The extent to which the media ecosystem is becoming a wholly owned subsidiary of Trump and his allies cannot be overstated. And that has the very long term ramifications. And so this is another way in which the more they own the media or it is seeking Trump's approval, the more they feel emboldened to do things like this.
JVL
Yeah. All right. I want to take you further down the hole, but we should do that behind the paywall. So, I mean, what, what a, what a great sell that is to people listening to the show. If you would like to be even more depressed and hear even darker stuff, you should become a member of Bulwark Plus.
Sarah Longwell
I will say, depending on what he's about to say, I may have an optimistic take, but I may not.
JVL
Spoiler. She's not going to be able to.
LifeLock Advertiser
It's cybersecurity awareness month. Lifelock is here with tips to help protect your identity, use strong passwords, set up multi factor authentication, report scam and update your software. And for comprehensive identity protection, Lifelock is your best choice. Lifelock alerts you to suspicious uses of your personal information and fixes identity theft guaranteed or your money back. Start your protection today with a 30 day free trial at LifeLock.com use promo code NEWS terms apply.
Commercial Announcer
Time is precious and so are our pets. So time with our pets is extra precious. That's why we started Dutch. Dutch provides 24? 7 access to licensed vets with unlimited virtual visits and follow ups for up to five pets. You can message a vet at any time and schedule a video visit the same day. Our vets can even prescribe medication for many ailments and shipping is always free. With Dutch, you'll get more time with your pets and year round peace of mind when it comes to their vet care.
Date: October 18, 2025
Hosts: Sarah Longwell, JVL (Jonathan V. Last)
Producer: The Bulwark
This “secret show”—originally released behind The Bulwark’s paywall—delves into a bleak, dark mood as Sarah Longwell and JVL unpack the week's news, exploring themes of democratic backsliding, authoritarian creep, and the growing stranglehold of Trump-aligned actors across politics and media. Through candid banter, the hosts tackle the politicization of the justice system, disturbing trends in law enforcement, threats to independent media, and more. The tone is frank, frustrated, and occasionally laced with black humor—true to TNL’s signature style.
[01:21]–[08:41]
JVL launches into the episode’s “dark stuff,” mentioning the recent indictment of John Bolton as a symbol of DOJ weaponization.
Sarah Longwell draws distinctions between the different cases:
JVL expresses one sliver of optimism:
Sarah teases him for cynicism about people: “Even with your low opinion of humans.” [08:41]
[08:41]–[14:58]
Discussion shifts to Andrew Cuomo’s warning that if Mamdani wins, “Trump will take over the city… it will be Mayor Trump.”
The National Guard as political weapon
[15:40]–[22:54]
JVL breaks the news:
Brief comic detour:
Back to the key point:
Broader worry—Trump’s growing control of media
[22:54]–[23:52]
| Timestamp | Segment | |-----------|----------------------------------------------| | 01:21 | Opening “secret show” and Bolton indictment | | 03:49 | Sarah’s argument: Bolton v. Trump v. Comey | | 05:15 | JVL: Why Trump’s case is different | | 08:41 | Optimism about juries | | 09:37 | Cuomo’s Trump ‘threat’ warning | | 10:11 | Sarah: “Insane argument from Cuomo” | | 13:59 | National Guard as political weapon | | 15:40 | Pentagon press corps purge | | 16:23 | Comic aside: Frozen villain discourse | | 18:11 | State-sanctioned media explained | | 19:22 | Resistance from legacy/right media | | 21:17 | “Media is increasingly owned by Trump” | | 23:13 | Tease for subscriber section |
This summary presents the entire substance of the public portion of this “secret show,” letting newcomers grasp both the factual details and the anxious, acerbic spirit that defines The Next Level.