The Nikki & Brie Show

Host: Nikki & Brie Garcia
Guest: Nattie Neidhart
Episode: Nattie Neidhart: Live from the SiriusXM Fishbowl Part 2
Date: April 13, 2026

Episode Overview

In this dynamic continuation of their SiriusXM Fishbowl special, Nikki & Brie reunite with WWE legend Nattie Neidhart for a fun, honest, and inspiring conversation live from Las Vegas during the week leading up to WrestleMania. The trio dig deep into Natty’s evolution—both in and out of the ring—her decision to rebrand herself, all things Bloodsport, the power of grit, sisterhood, supportive husbands, and authenticity in wrestling and life. The episode is filled with laughter, real talk, personal stories, and tips on facing change with courage.

Key Discussion Points & Insights

Pre-WrestleMania Excitement (02:22–03:29)

• Nikki & Brie express excitement about WrestleMania week in Las Vegas, the WWE World festivities, and meeting their “Bella Army.”
• Promotion of their Bonita Bonita wine, now available in Vegas, Smith's, and Sam’s Club.
• Nikki teases her “Lambo dream” if Bonita keeps succeeding.

Welcoming Natty Neidhart & Nostalgia (04:31–05:14)

• Natty talks about how therapeutic it is hearing the twins' voices, reflecting on their shared early days at FCW.
• “Cody crashes the party”—the trio reminisce about Cody Rhodes’ fun, unpredictable energy at wrestling gatherings.
  • “Cody always has something like great to say. You know what I mean? It feels like he’s spitting knowledge. And it’s funny. It’s like knowledgeable but funny. And you’re like, ‘whoa, I just learned something. But I laughed.’” – Brie (04:51)

The Reinvention of Natty: From Natalia to Natty (05:14–07:23)

• Natty opens up about embracing a new, freer version of herself—using her real name after 18 years as “Natalia.”
• Credits Nick Khan for allowing the WWE name change.
• Writing her book was a turning point:
  • “If you don’t chase your dreams, somebody else with half of your ability is gonna do it, and it’s because they had the courage to.” – Natty (06:42)
• On breaking away from people-pleasing and seeking personal happiness:
  • “At the end of the day, you gotta look at yourself in the mirror and go, am I happy?” – Natty (06:58)

Natty’s Bold Step: Bloodsport & Stepping Outside WWE (07:23–09:36)

• Natty wasn’t booked for last year’s WrestleMania; instead of having a “pity party,” she took action, lobbying for a unique Bloodsport match outside WWE.
• “I walked right up to Triple H the following week at Monday Night Raw, and I said, I want to do Bloodsport...something outside of WWE.” – Natty (07:54)
• Natty’s pride in “blowing up” Bloodsport and proving herself in a new style of wrestling.
• The twins reflect how Natty always had this fierceness, tracing back to their FCW days and intense practice shoot fights.

On Grit, Reinvention, and Being a Woman in the Hart Family (13:30–20:00, 28:29–32:52)

• Natty sees her transformation as just getting started and is excited to keep pushing boundaries.
• Discusses debuting as Natty at various international events (Rumble, Saudi Arabia) and craving opponents who bring out her edge (like Shayna Baszler).
• Explains how wrestling with Shayna raises the bar due to her MMA pedigree:
  • “She’s tapped out men. She’s tapped out women...the toughest woman that’s ever been in a WWE locker room.” – Natty (15:00)
• Grit is built by overcoming hard times, not innate:
  • “Grit is built from going through hard things over and over and over again and coming out stronger.” – Natty (20:44)
• Natty reflects on being the "least likely" to make it in a legendary family:
  • “I am the first woman to do this, and I was the least likely to make it… But it’s proof...I want people to look at themselves in the mirror and go, why not me? Why not me?” – Natty (30:51)

Book Talk & Mentorship (19:02–22:59)

• Praise for Natty’s book and hints at a potential follow-up focused on her Bloodsport journey.
• The twins’ influence in teaching Natty “survival skills” beyond the ring (cutting promos, PR, costumes—even doing taxes).
• “My book was such a testament, I always say, to people that are just getting started in developmental—Read my book. It’s like a survival guide.” – Natty (20:44)
• Heartfelt stories of mutual support and friendship from their early career days.

Sisterhood, Family, and Husbands in the Wrestling World (16:24–18:20)

• The challenges of training with spouses: Natty with TJ; Brie with Bryan.
• Banter over wanting tough feedback vs. support and affirmation.
• TJ’s pride in women wrestlers and his role as producer.
• Sisters borrowing (and sometimes not returning!) clothes—Natty’s infamous Gucci sweater story.

Inspiration & Taking Charge of Your Story (32:52–34:25, 44:15–45:36)

• Natty encourages listeners to own their journey, face adversity, and never wait for success to be handed to them.
• “Don’t leave your life in anybody else’s hands. Take control of your shit. Take control your world. Take control of what you want to chase.” – Natty (31:20)
• “True success is getting to the place you want to be and staying yourself and being happy.” – Brie (32:52)
• Final advice:
  • “Remember where you came from, acknowledge those hard things, but don’t live there. You can grow from it, and you can become stronger because of it.” – Natty (44:28)

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• “If you don’t chase your dreams, somebody else with half of your ability is gonna do it, and it’s because they had the courage to.” – Natty (06:42)
• “I could have had a pity party about not being a part of WrestleMania, but I got to work. I used my name. I thought about, how am I gonna make my hair different? How am I gonna make my gear different? How am I gonna make my work different?” – Natty (08:36)
• “Grit is built from going through hard things over and over and over again and coming out stronger.” – Natty (20:44)
• “You guys taught me to survive. And that was the stuff that was going to take me to where I'm at right now in WWE. I wouldn't have survived where I'm at today if I didn’t know how to cut a promo, or...talk to press, or...do my taxes.” – Natty (21:46)
• “I was planning on being buried in that [Gucci] sweater, for God’s sake.” – Natty (42:02)

Fun & Games: "Heart or Heel" (35:13–43:25)

The trio play a light-hearted game where Natty has to choose between being her classic sweetheart “heart” self or her bold “heel” persona in everyday scenarios:

• Getting cut off in traffic? “I will be a heart. Because I’m probably one of the worst drivers…” (35:16)
• Wrong coffee order? “Heel.” (35:35)
• Unanswered important text? “Heel…I’ll be internalizing that for weeks.” (35:42)
• Someone posting an unflattering photo? “Oh, heel. Yeah, that’s like…” (39:14)
• A borrowed outfit not returned? "If it’s something I’m not in love with, I’m fine. But if it’s expensive, now we have to have an awkward conversation." (41:35)

Entertaining stories about the Great Khali’s legendary selfies and their Total Divas days round out this segment.

Wrestling, Women, & Empowerment (various)

• The power of owning your narrative, not letting anyone else define your career.
• Mutual admiration for each other’s honesty, resilience, and ability to trend regardless of WWE status.
• Emphasis on staying relatable, facing adversity, and helping each other succeed.

Closing Thoughts & Affirmation (44:15–46:36)

• Natty’s affirmation:
  • “Remember where you came from...but don’t live there. You can grow from it and become stronger because of it...You can have a pity party, but then you gotta kick out and get strong.” (44:28–45:29)
• The twins echo the importance of honoring your past, staying present, and not letting hardship define you.

Final Event Plugs & Sendoff (46:06–47:40)

• Natty’s Bloodsport match info — Friday, 3–5:30 PM, Las Vegas.
• WrestleMania week reminders: WWE World, Bonita Bonita wine at the airport, Nikki & Brie’s appearances, and their SiriusXM and social channels.

Timestamps for Major Segments

• WrestleMania & Bonita intro: 02:22–03:29
• Natty on reinvention & identity: 05:14–07:23
• Bloodsport journey: 07:23–09:36
• Sisterhood & mentors: 19:02–22:59
• Grit & Hart family: 28:29–32:52
• Games & stories: 35:13–43:25
• Natty’s affirmation/closing: 44:15–46:36
• Bloodsport/WrestleMania plugs: 46:06–47:40

Tone & Style

True to the original, the episode is a mix of playful banter, unscripted honesty, and deep mutual respect. Nikki & Brie’s warmth and Natty’s candid storytelling make this a feel-good, motivating episode—especially for women (and anyone) striving to own their power, write their own story, and support their tribe.