Nick Lachey Talks Life, Perfect Match, The Pods & More with AD on What’s The Reality

Summary

Podcast Summary: The Nikki & Brie Show

Episode: Nick Lachey Talks Life, Perfect Match, The Pods & More with AD on What’s The Reality

Date: September 15, 2025
Host: SiriusXM
Special Guest: Nick Lachey (host of Netflix's "Perfect Match")
Featuring: Amber Desiree ("AD" of Love Is Blind, Perfect Match)

---

Overview

This episode delivers crossover energy as the iconic Nikki & Brie share a vibrant, insightful conversation with Nick Lachey on a clip from the podcast "What’s The Reality?" Hosted by Amber Desiree (AD), the discussion offers a behind-the-scenes look at Netflix reality, specifically “Perfect Match.” They explore the format's evolution, challenges, dramatic twists, and the emotional aftermath—providing fans with an unfiltered backstage pass to reality TV’s highs, heartbreaks, and everything in between.

---

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. Expanding the Netflix Universe

Timestamp: 01:08 – 01:43

• AD asks Nick Lachey: How does he feel about casting stars outside the Netflix reality ecosystem?
• Nick Lachey: Praises the move, saying it brings a fresh dynamic and new "reality royalty" into the fold, making the competition even more interesting.
  • Quote:

    “As everything evolves and gets bigger...that was kind of a natural place for this show to go. I thought it added something, bringing our two Bachelor/Bachelorette stars into the mix. And I can see that being a format change that continues to work.” (C, 01:16)

2. Reality TV: Expect the Unexpected

Timestamp: 01:43 – 03:58

• AD and Nick reflect: On the surprise appearances, shocking twists (including Nick’s signature "monkey wrench" role), and the impact those moments have on contestants.
• AD’s personal recollection: Being unexpectedly voted off despite being seen as one of the strongest couples—a moment that ultimately strengthened her real-life relationship.
  • Memorable exchange:
    • AD:

      “There is a moment where Nick shows up with one of his lovely surprises...we were told we were voted by Daniel and Lucy as the strongest couple, and they ultimately had to decide which one of us left the house. And it was Freddie and me...But to your point, I wouldn’t be sitting here and being engaged and pregnant had that not happened.” (B, 02:59)

    • Nick:

      “Sometimes we don’t recognize why the challenge is being presented...but then in hindsight...that was a necessary step in the evolution of my life or my relationship.” (C, 03:58)

3. The Host's Dilemma: Messengers of Bad News

Timestamp: 03:58 – 05:40

• Nick Lachey: Opens up about the emotional weight of delivering hard news, admitting that seeing contestants’ disappointment affects him as well.
  • Quote:

    “You don’t think I’m standing there delivering that news and watching your face, and you don’t think that cuts into me? I hate being the guy that’s to deliver that news...but that’s part of the gig.” (C, 05:06)

4. The Power of Compatibility Challenges

Timestamp: 06:09 – 08:23

• Favorite Challenges: Nick admits the "kissing challenge" is most uncomfortable for him (but revealing for the contestants).
• Purpose of the Challenge: Tests physical as well as emotional chemistry—intended to jolt couples out of "autopilot."
  • Nick Lachey:

    “Your chemistry is tested in that moment...these things make you, force you to deal with things in a different way because it’s easy to get on autopilot. I think it’s the job of the format of the show to create those challenges.” (C, 07:07)

  • AD’s playful response:

    “Imagine doing that not blindfolded. There’d be cat fights, for sure.” (B, 07:42)

  • Nick (on improving the challenge):

    “At least we provided, I think, Listerine this time around...we’re learning every season.” (C, 08:14)

5. What Made This Season Special

Timestamp: 08:28 – 09:38

• Nick notes: Swift and authentic connections formed between contestants from the outset, resulting in fewer early shakeups and a distinctly positive group dynamic.
  • Quote:

    “You guys just formed connections so quickly out of the gate...I just didn’t see that coming...It was a great group, and everybody just seemingly got along really well.” (C, 08:34)

6. The Unpredictable Beauty of Reality TV

Timestamp: 09:38 – 10:11

• Nick reflects: On the unpredictability of outcomes, from unexpected breakups to lifelong relationships and even weddings.
  • Quote:

    “That’s the beauty of reality TV, right? You don’t know how it’s gonna play out...Look at you and Ollie as a result of this show and look at what has come from that. Nobody can possibly know this stuff’s gonna happen...that’s the fun of it. That’s the juice of it.” (C, 09:39)

---

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• On unexpected twists:

  “It was rarely good news when you showed up.” (B to Nick, 02:33)

• Reflecting on tough decisions:

  “Should we divulge what the moment is you’re talking about?” (C, 02:44)

• On contestant chemistry:

  “It was almost stupid how much you knew about each other or how in tune you were with each other. So it was like, wow. Yeah, we gotta mix this up a little bit.” (C, 05:53)

• On bringing in people outside Netflix:

  “Talk about reality royalty. She’s been doing that forever. And then Bachelor Nation is such a crazy combination, which I never saw coming.” (B, 01:41)

• Playful banter about contestant reactions:

  “No, not today...Back then, if they let me loose.” (B, 04:22)

---

Timestamps for Important Segments

• 1:08 – Expanding the cast beyond Netflix reality
• 2:11 – The surprise of veteran reality stars joining Perfect Match
• 2:44 – The “big moment” that changed everything for AD
• 3:58 – Nick talks about the emotional toll of hosting
• 6:09 – The infamous kissing challenge and its impact
• 8:28 – Why contestant connections were so strong this season
• 9:38 – The unpredictable outcomes of reality TV

---

Tone, Style & Takeaways

The conversation is casual, candid, and peppered with playful teasing and personal anecdotes. Nick balances warmth and gravitas as a host, while Nikki, Brie, and AD add humor and heart. The episode delves into both the reality and reality-TV aspects of contestants’ lives and relationships, ultimately highlighting that both growth and entertainment come from embracing the unexpected.

For listeners:
This episode is a must for fans of "Perfect Match," anyone curious about the emotional mechanics of reality TV, and those who want to hear what really happens behind the scenes—with laughs and honest moments you won’t see on screen.

Transcript

[A]

What up, everyone? It's Nicki and Bri. You may know us from the Nicki and Bri show, and we're so excited to share with you a clip from what's the Reality? Your all access backstage pass into the wild and unpredictable world of your favorite TV personalities and influencers. Hosted by Amber Desiree from Love Is Blind and Perfect Match. Every episode of what's the Reality dives deep into love, relationships, breakups, makeups, and all the drama you didn't see on screen. From unfiltered interviews with your favorite reality stars and celebrities to pop culture hot takes, AD and her guests, keep it real fun and unfiltered. Whether you're a die hard fan or just love a little tea, what's the Reality is where reality TV spills over into real life. New episodes drop Every Wednesday on YouTube or wherever you get your podcast.

[B]

I have some questions.

[C]

Yes, I bet you do. I have. So I may have some answers. Maybe not all. I need another drink of water for this. I'm in the hot seat now.

[B]

How do you feel about bringing outside stars that are outside of the Netflix universe in this season to kind of spice things up?

[C]

I like that twist. I mean, I think it started as a great celebration of Netflix reality and celebrating all the. All the stars of Netflix reality. But I think as everything evolves and gets bigger, hopefully and continues to grow, I think that was kind of a natural place for this show to go. So I thought it added, you know, I thought it added something, bringing our two Bachelor Bachelorette stars into the mix. And I can see that, you know, being a format change that continues to work, you know, perfect match going forward.

[B]

I thought that was so cool. Like, obviously none of us saw that coming. And then, like, people from, like, Love island and Juliet from Siesta Keys. What a show. Talk about reality royalty. She's been doing that forever. And then Bachelor Nation is just such a crazy combination, which I obviously never saw coming. And I never saw a lot of things coming the whole season, and you just had a pocket full of twists and turns.

[C]

It tends to be that. Yeah, it tends to be that. And I love how you guys, your reaction to me even being. Even being around is like, oh, here we go. Here we go. What bomb is Nick about this?

[B]

He was just like, the biggest smile. Come sit down.

[C]

We're sitting here by the pool and our bikinis having a shot of tequila, and here he comes, Nick coming in to throw a monkey wrench in the whole thing. Literally.

[B]

It really. It was rarely good news when you Showed up.

[C]

I hate being that guy.

[B]

I know.

[C]

Don't look at it as bad news. It's just interesting news.

[B]

Just interesting news.

[C]

Different news.

[B]

Devastating news for some.

[C]

You know what, though? Those moments, it's interesting. When you look back, though, do you think that things would have turned out for you maybe the way they did if that moment hadn't happened? And should we divulge what the moment is you're talking about?

[B]

Yes, of course. We can. We can bring that up. There is a moment where Nick shows up with one of his lovely surprises that is not so lovely for me and Freddie, where we're told that we were kind of voted by Daniel and Lucy as the. The strongest couples, and they ultimately had to decide which one of us left the house. And it was Freddie and me, which came as a shocker. Very devastating shocker. But to your point, I don't think my life. I would be sitting here and doing the things and feeling the way and being engaged and pregnant had that not happened. Because one, it tested our relationship for sure. Like, and that's what the show is about, testing the relationship. And two, you know, I know and the producers know I was never gonna leave that man, and he was never gonna leave me. And there was. There would be no way to test if we were really, truly a perfect match. So although it was, like, devastating and it's hard to watch, but it just. It made sense for why it needed to happen.

[C]

Yeah. I think sometimes we don't. We don't recognize why the challenge is being presented to us. But then in. In hindsight, having the benefit of that 2020 hindsight vision, you can say, okay, you know what? I can actually see that. That. That was a necessary step in the evolution of. Of my life or my relationship or whatever the case may be. So I'm glad you feel that way. Now. You're not going to jump across the room and stab me to death?

[B]

No, not today.

[C]

Rage.

[B]

No. Back then if they let me loose.

[C]

But no, it was. I mean, look, the show is. The format is based on if you. If you're lucky enough to win the challenge and go into the boardroom with me, then you have an opportunity to upset the apple cart and try and, you know, and try and take out your strongest competition. Because at the end of the day, you know, it. It is all about trying to. To win that title of being the perfect match. Right. So that was a format twist, obviously, but it was a necessary one to kind of do what. What it did, which is upset the apple card a little Bit and. And create a little, Create a little perspective.

[B]

Yeah, yeah, it was, it was helpful and hurtful in the moment. You don't understand it.

[C]

And by the way.

[B]

Yeah.

[C]

You don't think I'm standing there delivering that news and watching your face and seeing how devastated you are and you don't think that cuts into me? I hate, I hate being the guy that's. To, you know, deliver that news.

[B]

No, I know.

[C]

Oh, and Madison and Freddy, where was. She was devastated. So I, you know, in no way, shape or form do I get off on being that guy to come in and.

[B]

Yeah.

[C]

And. And give that speech. But that's. That's part of the. That's part of the gig.

[B]

Yeah.

[C]

Part of what I sign up for. And that's why at least now I too can look at you and see your happiness and be, you know, feel at least a little better about it.

[B]

Yeah. We made it through.

[C]

Yeah, you did. But you guys, what. What people don't. And they'll see when they see the entire season, but even through the first however many episodes we're in, I mean, your guys connection was so palpable.

[B]

Yeah.

[C]

And in terms of like, knowledge of each other. And we would do a challenge and it's like, guys just. I mean, it was like almost stupid how much you knew about each other or how in tune you were with each other. So it was like, wow. Yeah, we gotta mix this up a little bit.

[B]

Yeah.

[C]

And Lucy and Daniel took, you know, took the opportunity to. To do that now.

[B]

Right. Do you have a favorite compatibility challenge as a host?

[C]

Oh, man. I mean, I could say the one that's the most uncomfortable for me is the kissing challenge. Because. Because it is probably the most comfortable for you. Well, it's uncomfortable for me to have to be the one to present it because I can see on your face like, ah, here we. And you know, it's coming.

[B]

Yeah.

[C]

I mean, it's. It's been a staple of. Of every season of the show. And I think it is telling. I think there's physical chemistry, especially on this show, is a big part of the equation. It's obviously a very different show than like a Love is Blind where physical chemistry comes later. But your chemistry is tested in that moment. And we saw some drama with that challenge this season. So it does kind of put things out there on the table and you gotta, you know, you gotta confront. Cause it's really what it's about.

[B]

Right.

[C]

It's about trying to create why they're called challenges. Challenges. Not only in the moment. But challenges for each of these connections you guys have formed. All right, can you. Can you make it through this moment? Can you make it through the fact that barely, your partner may have thought someone else was a better kisser? Oh, hold on now. You know, I mean, like, those things, it makes you. Forces you to deal with things in a different way because it's easy to get on, like, autopilot. Hey, we're hanging out in the house. We're having a good time. We're all partying. We're, you know, we're doing what we're doing. And I think it's the job of the format of the show to create those challenges and create those opportunities to really look at your connection in a different way.

[B]

Imagine doing that not blindfolded. I wouldn't. There'd be cat fights, for sure.

[C]

Well, the most awkward part to me is leading the men out in this elephant line of. Here we go. Everybody hold on to my waist. I'm gonna lead you out. And they're all like, we can't see. Where are we going? It's such a weird, awkward challenge, but I do think it has a lot of. I do think has a lot of meaning in terms of the. The arc of the show and what it. What it presents you guys with and the challenges again that it presents everybody with.

[B]

No one went home happy after that. Oh, that was a mess.

[C]

No, I mean, it's. At least we provided, I think, Listerine this time around. You know what I mean? We're learning every season, they make it a little bit more. A little bit more tolerable.

[B]

Yeah. A little easier. We made it through.

[C]

Yeah, barely. You did. You made it through.

[B]

So was there anything about this season that stood out to you compared to other seasons?

[C]

You guys just formed. You just formed connections so quickly out of the gate. Like, I mean, there was very little turnover at all from, like, the second mixer. It was like you guys were just locked in.

[B]

It was the boys.

[C]

I mean, just locked in. I just didn't see that coming.

[B]

You know, they literally, like, stuck their teeth in us, and they were like, you guys are not allowed to do anything, but we're gonna act a fool.

[C]

And we were like, okay, well, but you guys. I mean, it seemed like everyone was just, like, really, really comfortable and really locked in. And I don't think that's necessarily happened on. On other, you know, other seasons, but. But no, it was. I. I had a blast this season. You guys were awesome to work with. It was a great group, and everybody just seemingly got along really well. Yeah, it was definitely more drama, I think, maybe kind of weird, jealous drama on other seasons, but this season, I think was really, really special in a different way. And that's the beauty of reality tv, right, Is you don't know how it's gonna play out.

[B]

You can't predict.

[C]

You could have five weddings, five I do's on Love is Blind, or you could have one. You could have. I mean, look at you and Ollie as a result of this show and look at what has come from that. Nobody can predict that stuff. Nobody can possibly know that this stuff's gonna happen. So that's the beauty of. To me, it's like, that's the beauty of being a part of reality TV is that it can go any which way and you got to be ready to roll with it.

[B]

Yep.

[C]

If it goes this way, hey, we're going right. Goes this way, we're going left. Yeah, that's just the. That's the fun of it. It's the. That's the juice of it.

[A]

What's the reality? New episodes drop Every Wednesday on YouTube or wherever you get your podcast.