The Nikki & Brie Show – "You Asked, We Answered! (Listener AMA)"

Date: September 8, 2025
Hosts: Nikki & Brie Garcia (aka Nicole & Bri)
Episode Theme:
This episode is a Listener AMA (Ask Me Anything), where Nikki and Brie respond to fan questions over voicemail, DM, and comments. The hour is full of candid, often hilarious, sometimes emotional insights about comebacks, regrets, vision boards, life as twins, being mothers, entrepreneurs, and public figures. Expect encouragement, advice, a dose of nostalgia, and the twin sisters’ classic unfiltered, sisterly banter.

Episode Overview

Nikki and Brie dedicate this special episode to their devoted "Bella Army" by tackling listener-submitted questions on career comebacks, life regrets, manifesting dreams, stepping outside comfort zones, and their signature takes on wrestling, fashion, food, and more. Throughout, the two share heartfelt reflections and actionable advice, while keeping the vibe fun, sisterly, and supportive.

Key Discussion Points & Timestamps

1. Opening & Community Shout-out

[01:17 – 03:20]

• Nikki and Brie introduce the AMA format, emphasizing love for their listeners and Bella Army.
• “We just want to celebrate our Bella army and highlight those voices that make this community so strong... Let’s go.” – Nikki [02:32]

2. Nikki’s Wrestling Comeback: Mindset & Goals

[03:20 – 08:31]

Voicemail from Naomi, Virginia: On Nikki’s goals for her WWE comeback and character evolution.

• Nikki shares that her initial focus was on regaining her physical and wrestling shape and fitting into WWE’s new era.
• "At first ... I wanted to keep Fearless Nikki as Fearless Nikki... But now ... I'm actually wanting to kind of change her a little bit. I think it'd be a lot of fun." – Nikki [05:40]
• She enjoys the current hands-on creative process and may push "Fearless Nikki" in new, less nostalgic directions.
• Brie adds thoughts on comebacks and reflecting as an athlete, especially post-motherhood.

Notable Quote:
“I’m going to be really proud in my next era of life looking back and going, whoa, you did that whole comeback, while keeping your son first and being this badass mom.” – Nikki [07:37]

3. Talking Regrets & People-Pleasing

[09:23 – 12:31]

DM from @Healing_Tribe_Vibes: What are your biggest regrets?

• Brie’s regret: Returning to wrestling postpartum because of others’ expectations, not her own readiness.
• Reference to Dwayne Johnson’s recent remarks about doing things for himself, not others.
• “I did so much for so many people ... I think I did a disservice to myself until I got into my 40s.” – Brie [10:58]
• Nikki reminds Brie of her impact as a trailblazer for mothers in wrestling.

4. Pasta Favorites & Local Food Picks

[15:32 – 17:45]

Comment from @Siana_is_a_Gemini: What's your favorite pasta dish and why?

• Nicole: "Sophia Loren" pasta at Bottega in Napa—simple, spicy marinara.
• Nikki: Classic Bolognese with a touch of chili oil.
• Local recommendations: Bottega, Don Giovanni, Scala in Napa.

Quote:
“All the right flavors you want in your mouth when you’re eating pasta.” – Nicole [16:47]

5. Vision Boards, Manifestation & Progress

[17:56 – 20:20]

Voicemail from Lindsay, Central PA: What's on your current vision board? Have any goals manifested?

• Nikki: Hosting ambitions (Emmy nomination, more TV shows), Bonita Bonita expansion, and Twin Love show pitch.
• “Definitely on there, that I hope that happens, is to get nominated for an Emmy as a host...” – Nikki [18:54]
• A bit of fun: Nikki says decisively there are no “hot men” on her vision board.
• Nicole: Mentions finally updating her vision board alongside post-reno closets.

6. Advice to Aspiring Wrestlers & Reality Show Hopes

[22:36 – 26:21]

DM from Michelle (14 years old): Advice for breaking into wrestling? Will there be another reality show with WWE women?

• Nikki: Stay active (collegiate wrestling, theater, public speaking, character work) and start “writing ideas of what you feel like your character would be.”
• “All of this starts to put you in an incredible place ... makes you a triple threat.” – Nikki [24:12]
• Nicole: Repetition and the "10,000 hours" rule; don’t expect expertise overnight.
• Both sisters would love to see a Total Divas/Bellas–style show return and want to produce more content.

7. Soft-Girl Era & Relationship Support

[28:23 – 32:05]

DM from Elizabeth: Brie’s “soft girl era”—was it self-driven or Brian-inspired?

• Brie: Always shared values with Brian (gardening, sustainability, “hippie talk”) but the new, aligned life phase is fully her own.
• “The one thing I love where I’m at right now—everything just feels aligned ... I feel, like, really great. I wake up every morning ... you get to have fun today.” – Brie [31:33]

8. Bonita Bonita Event Updates

[32:09 – 33:05]

• Next Bonita Bonita event is in Las Vegas (September), with potential for NY as early as Spring 2026.

9. Talk Show Ambitions

[33:10 – 34:49]

Voicemail from Kyle, Jersey: Would you host a twin talk show if offered?

• Nikki & Brie: “That is on the vision board!” – Nikki [33:39]
• Would love to break new ground as the first famous twin talk show hosts but want to wait until their kids are older (unless streaming shortens production).
• “We’re gonna be the first twins to have a talk show.” – Nicole [34:29]

10. Stepping Outside the Comfort Zone

[34:48 – 38:49]

Comment from @Demetra_21: Moments when you pushed yourself out of your comfort zone.

• Nikki: Competing at regionals in track as a kid, joining WWE, and motherhood.
• Nicole: Public speaking in college, motivational speaking events, joining the X Games.
• Both discuss the thrill and nerves of trying new things:
  “There’s nothing like when you push yourself outside your comfort zone ... that feeling of achievement.” – Nikki [37:33]

11. Wrestling Mount Rushmore of Fashion

[42:54 – 45:08]

Voicemail from Ella, Buffalo: Who’s on your "Mount Rushmore" of wrestling fashion (in and out of the ring)?

• Immediate choices: Charlotte Flair, Bianca Belair, Jade Cargill, and Natalya (“Natty”).
• “She [Charlotte] is just crushing it in and out of the ring.” – Nikki [43:24]
• “Jade does a lot of high fashion ... icons, right, for wrestling.” – Nicole [44:10]

12. Brie’s Argument Skills & Twin Dynamics

[45:25 – 47:43]

Comment from @BlackWidows: Does Brie know how good she is in arguments?

• Brie: Has had a lifetime of practice thanks to having a twin, claims she simply “spits the facts.”
• Nikki: “You are like a chihuahua ... you can be brutal because you spit the facts.” [46:25]
• Nicole: Brie’s quick to stand up for herself and calls out any shade, but is also kind and only holds grudges when necessary.

13. Inspiration/Affirmation of the Week

[47:43 – 48:42]

• From Proverbs 12:14:
  “If you could eat your own words, would your soul be nourished or poisoned?”
• Reflection on the importance of kindness and self-awareness, especially in today’s social media age.

Notable Quotes & Moments

• “My comeback was about nostalgia ... but now I want to change her [Fearless Nikki] a little bit.” – Nikki [05:40]
• “I did so much for so many people ... people pleaser mentality ... did a disservice to myself until my 40s.” – Brie [10:51]
• “I want to have men to flirt with and like, yeah, maybe a casual hookup, but I don’t want a man.” – Nikki [20:41]
• “All of this... makes you a triple threat. Makes you so prepared and will for sure conquer.” – Nikki, on preparing for wrestling dreams [24:17]
• “Everything just feels aligned ... you get to have fun today.” – Brie [31:33]
• “We’re gonna be the first twins to have a talk show.” – Nicole [34:29]
• “There’s nothing like when you push yourself outside your comfort zone ... that feeling of achievement.” – Nikki [37:33]
• “If you could eat your own words, would your soul be nourished or poisoned?” – Nikki [48:21]

Episode Vibe & Takeaways

• Warm, honest, and supportive; listeners feel like part of the inner circle.
• Unapologetic about growth, self-reflection, and living authentically.
• Genuinely invested in fan questions and fostering a positive, motivated community.
• Offers practical tips for pursuing dreams, handling setbacks, and embracing change.

Useful Timestamps

• Nikki’s comeback & goals: [03:20 – 08:31]
• Regrets and people-pleasing: [09:23 – 12:31]
• Vision board updates: [17:56 – 20:20]
• Advice for young wrestlers: [22:36 – 26:21]
• Soft-girl era reflections: [28:23 – 32:05]
• Talk show ambitions: [33:10 – 34:49]
• Stepping outside comfort zones: [34:48 – 38:49]
• Wrestling fashion icons Mount Rushmore: [42:54 – 45:08]
• Brie on argument skills: [45:25 – 47:43]
• Episode affirmation: [47:43 – 48:42]

For Fans & New Listeners

This episode distills the heart of Nikki & Brie’s appeal: down-to-earth wisdom, relatable stories, and lots of laughter. Even if you’ve never watched a wrestling match or don’t follow their businesses, you’ll find encouragement, sharp wit, and genuine connection in this answers-packed hour.