In Iran, Trump is both escalating and deescalating

Summary

---

Episode Summary: "In Iran, Trump is both escalating and deescalating"

The NPR Politics Podcast | March 25, 2026
Hosts: Miles Parks, Frank Ordonez, Greg Myhre

---

Overview

This episode centers on the complicated, often contradictory state of U.S.-Iran relations nearly one month into the ongoing Iran war. The hosts examine President Trump's latest strategic pivots—including overtures toward negotiation while ramping up military deployments—and discuss how domestic and global pressures are shaping the administration's actions. They also analyze Trump’s attempts to declare victory, the reality of regime change talk, financial pressures, and regional concerns, particularly among Gulf states.

---

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. Trump Signals Negotiation Amid Escalation

• Contradictory Messaging: Trump began the week claiming “very good and productive conversations” with Iran, hinting at possible negotiations to end the conflict ([00:25]).
  • Frank Ordonez: Trump announced a 5-day postponement of attacks on Iranian power plants, attributing ongoing talks to his envoy Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner—though he kept the Iranian counterpart’s identity secret.
  • Trump claimed a deal “could have happened yesterday” and cryptically referred to a "big present" involving oil and gas, suggesting a possible breakthrough ([00:48]).
• Iran’s Denial: Iran officially dismissed the U.S. claims of direct negotiations, especially with Witkoff and Kushner, who they accused of deception before the war ([01:56]).

2. Are Both Sides Just Posturing?

• Greg Myhre: The conflicting public statements show just how far apart the two countries really are. Iran isn’t in a hurry to negotiate, especially with control of the Strait of Hormuz; it’s seeking guarantees against future U.S. military action ([02:22]).
  • Quote: "Trump has hit a point where he feels he's going to have to consider negotiations...but Iran may have time on its side." ([02:22])

3. Domestic & Global Pressures Mount

• Economic Fallout: High gas prices in the U.S., particularly over $5 in D.C., are adding political heat for Trump to find a resolution ([03:05]).
  • Frank Ordonez: Trump's public statements have sparked immediate reactions in global markets, with oil and the S&P 500 fluctuating quickly. "This is clearly something that is having an impact on markets. And Trump has always paid attention to markets, always." ([04:03])
• Tricky Alliances: Trump’s rhetoric has also pressured Western allies to join U.S. efforts to secure the Strait of Hormuz, warning them of consequences if they do not support this coalition ([03:34]).

4. Escalation and De-escalation—At the Same Time

• Troop Buildup: Despite talk of de-escalation, the U.S. continues sending additional troops—about 6,000 more from Marine and Airborne units ([04:44]).
  • Greg Myhre: "Trump always likes to keep his options open...he’s sort of chosen A and B, talking about a possible peace deal and a de-escalation. But also, we're hearing more troops are headed to the region." ([04:44])
  • U.S. total in the region: about 50,000 troops. Iran’s active duty army: over 600,000 ([05:40]).
• No "Boots on the Ground"? Though Trump repeatedly claims no intention for a ground invasion, he maintains plausible deniability by drawing lines that could be subject to interpretation ([06:15], [06:23]).

5. Who's Leading Negotiations?

• Diplomatic Uncertainty: U.S. negotiators Witkoff and Kushner, both controversial to the Iranians, have a history of negotiations that led to more conflict rather than peace ([07:29]).
  • Some speculation Iran might prefer to deal with someone else—potentially VP J.D. Vance or even through intermediaries like Pakistan.
  • As of now, talks remain indirect; no neutral venue has been secured ([07:29]).

6. The Elusive "Off Ramp" and What Victory Means

• Defining an Endgame:
  • Greg Myhre: The popular “off ramp” metaphor does not capture the scale—this is a major war likely to reshape the Middle East, not a simple sidestep ([10:25]).
  • Most wars end through negotiations, but the gulf between the two sides remains vast—especially regarding the now-central issue of the Strait of Hormuz, which wasn’t an active crisis before the war ([10:25]).
• Trump’s Narrative Control:
  • Frank Ordonez: For Trump, “declaring victory is as simple as declaring victory.” The president often crafts his narrative regardless of on-the-ground realities ([12:03]).
  • Trump’s likely claim of victory would be re-opening the Strait of Hormuz, even if regime change isn’t realized ([12:03]).
    • Quote: "For President Trump, declaring victory is pretty as simple as declaring victory." ([12:03])

7. Regime Change Now a "Twisted" Argument

• Earlier vs. Current Stance:
  • Trump once called for regime change and directly encouraged Iranian protestors. That rhetoric has faded post-appointment of a new Iranian supreme leader ([13:00], [14:21]).
  • Greg Myhre: Despite large losses among Iranian leaders and significant military blows, the regime persists and continues to function ([13:20]).
  • Frank Ordonez: Noted Trump’s rhetorical contortion: “How could it not be regime change?” after so many leaders were killed, even as the structure remains the same ([14:21]).

8. The Broader Regional Picture

• Gulf States' Anxiety:
  • Gulf monarchies were against the war from the start and are now deeply concerned about an unstable outcome, continued Iranian attacks, and U.S. withdrawal.
  • Their fear: losing their "stable and predictable" brand if the conflict remains unresolved, which would threaten their security and economies ([15:33]).
    • Quote: "Their brand is stability...if they get dragged into this volatility, that throws their brand, their image completely up in the air." — Greg Myhre ([16:31])

---

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• “Trump has hit a point where he feels he's going to have to consider negotiations, that the current plan on the battlefield, another day or two or three of bombing is not going to make Iran capitulate.” — Greg Myhre ([02:22])
• “Trump always likes to keep his options open. And as I said, without any great movement on the battlefield under the current circumstances, he's basically got two options, escalate or de escalate. Well, he's sort of chosen A and B...” — Greg Myhre ([04:44])
• “For President Trump, declaring victory is pretty as simple as declaring victory.” — Frank Ordonez ([12:03])
• “Their brand is stability...if they get dragged into this volatility, that throws their brand, their image completely up in the air.” — Greg Myhre ([16:31])

---

Timestamps for Key Segments

• [00:25] – Episode opens: Overview of Trump’s negotiation claims
• [02:22] – Analysis: Contradictory U.S. and Iranian statements
• [03:05] – Domestic pressure: Gas prices and political implications
• [04:44] – Military posture: Troop buildup vs. de-escalation talk
• [07:29] – Who’s negotiating? Breakdown of diplomatic uncertainties
• [10:25] – "Off ramp" metaphor and the scale of the conflict
• [12:03] – Trump’s narrative on declaring victory
• [13:00] – Shift away from regime change language
• [15:33] – Regional dynamics: Gulf states’ perspective

---

Podcast Tone

• Language: Clear, direct, and explanatory, with occasional dry wit (e.g., the “off ramp” metaphor).
• Atmosphere: Analytical and measured, with a focus on clarifying the ongoing uncertainty surrounding U.S. choices in the Iran conflict.

---

For listeners seeking clarity on the quickly evolving situation in Iran, this episode of The NPR Politics Podcast offers a nuanced look at the tug-of-war between escalation and de-escalation, with sharp insight into Trump administration tactics, regional consequences, and the significance of the Strait of Hormuz in both foreign policy and the global economy.

Transcript

[Carvana/HomeServe/Odoo/Grainger Announcer]

This message comes from Carvana, who makes car selling easy. Enter your license plate or vin, get a real offer in minutes and have your car picked up from your door. Sell your car the easy way with Carvana. Pickup fee may apply.

[Miles Parks]

Hey there. It's the NPR Politics podcast. I'm Miles Parks. I cover voting.

[Frank Ordonez]

I'm Frank Ordonez. I cover the White House.

[Greg Myhre]

And I'm Greg Myhre. I cover national security.

[Miles Parks]

And we are recording this at 1:13pm Eastern Time on Wednesday, March 25th. And today on the show, we're nearing the one month mark of the war in Iran, Franco. President Trump started the week with a post on social media that said, quote, very good and productive conversations were going on with Iran, alluding to the fact that negotiations seem to be ongoing to move towards an end of the conflict. What more can you tell us about that?

[Frank Ordonez]

Yeah, it came as Trump announced that he was postponing attacks on Iran power plants for five days. And he said at the time that his team, you know, the envoy, Steve Witkoff, and son in law Jared Kushner were in touch with a, quote, top person in the regime, though he would not say who it was. And Mao really felt like kind of like a turning point in all this. You know, they were potentially moving into this new chapter of the war. That certainly seemed what Trump was signaling and moving toward this kind of negotiating ending. You know, Trump before said that he was not ready to agree to anything, but here he was saying that they were very willing to make a deal, that the US Was willing to make a deal, and that he said actually that if he was a betting man that he would bet on the deal happening yesterday. Of course, he spoke again about this top person actually delivering on a promise. He called it a big present. He didn't say exactly what that was, but he said it involved oil and gas. And he also said that was a sign at least that they were dealing with the right person. I do want to note one more thing, though, that Iran officially is dismissing the idea that they are negotiating anything directly with the US and actually would not negotiate with Witkoff and Kushner because they felt like those two misled them in the lead up to the war.

[Miles Parks]

It does feel like it takes two to tango, Greg. And I don't know, doesn't that seem like if you have one side saying we're negotiating, things are going really well, but then Iran is denying that this is happening at all. What are we supposed to read from that?

[Greg Myhre]

Yeah, that they're far apart. And I think that's the only realistic thing you can say right now. I think Trump has hit a point where he feels he's going to have to consider negotiations, that the current plan on the battlefield, another day or two or three of bombing is not going to make Iran capitulate. So it is significant that Trump is talking about negotiations, but Iran may have time on its side. Now it sees the Strait of Hormuz closed, and it is in no hurry to bring an end to the war if it doesn't get some of the things that it wants. And one of those is a guarantee that the United States will not wage war again against it and try to topple the regime.

[Miles Parks]

So Franco political pressure is clearly building on President Trump and the kind of the all the different dominoes that are falling from this war going on weeks and weeks. I just drove past a gas station in D.C. this week where gas was priced over $5. It was the most expensive station I've driven by in D.C. it's consistently.

[Frank Ordonez]

I think I know which one you're talking about.

[Miles Parks]

Exactly. I'm not going to name names. But. But is it fair to say that there is starting to become, I guess, global financial pressure for President Trump to kind of change his tune on this?

[Frank Ordonez]

Yeah, and I think there's no doubt about that. And I think Trump clearly knows that as well. And I think you see that in the rhetoric from him over the past couple weeks, particularly when it has to deal with the Strait of Hormuz, whether it's threatening Iran to stop what it's doing, stop strikes on cargo ships, to threatening essentially allies and other Western nations to kind of join this coalition and saying if you don't join and help secure the strait, we will remember those things. But just back to that social post and kind of like this turning point, that social post actually came around 7 o' clock in the morning or just after. And that had such an impact on the markets. I mean, oil futures instantly rallied. The S&P 500 went soaring before the morning bell. So this is clearly something that is having an impact on markets. And Trump has always paid attention to markets, always.

[Miles Parks]

So you've got Trump talking about de escalation, Greg, but at the same time, isn't the US still building up its military presence in the region?

[Greg Myhre]

Yeah, Trump always likes to keep his options open. And as I said, without any great movement on the battlefield under the current circumstances, he's basically got two options, escalate or de escalate. Well, he's sort of chosen A and B, talking about a possible peace deal and a de escalation. But also there's, we're hearing more troops are headed to the region. Two Marine units, both have 2,000 troops or a little more, each one coming from Japan, the other from California. One should arrive any day now. The other is probably still a couple weeks away. And we've also heard that the 82nd Airborne is going to send about 2,000 troops to the region. So about another 6,000 troops. And these are highly trained troops that could certainly carry out a specific mission. But again, we're 6,7000 troops. That's not a huge number. There are about 50,000 U.S. troops in the region on ships, airmen, ground troops. So that adds to that total, which sounds pretty considerable until you think about the fact that Iran has more than 600,000 troops in its active duty army. So that US presence in the region, even with these additions, would still be less or maybe 10% of what Iran has. So it's not enough to carry out a major ground invasion. It's enough to carry out specific operations. Obviously, the speculation is on things like trying to open the Strait of Hormuz,

[Miles Parks]

but Trump has said no boots on the ground at different points related to the Iran conflict. Is that still the working assumption or.

[Greg Myhre]

Essentially, that's what he said. He's given himself some wiggle room saying, I haven't sent troops anywhere, but if I was, I wouldn't tell you. So he's left himself a little wiggle room. And one could certainly see him choosing that option if it's a specific operation. I mean, I think there's both. You know, if the US Troops were to seize an island to help clear the Strait of Hormuz, he might fudge that and say, well, that's not really troops on the ground. That's just part of an operation in the Gulf to take a small island. Again, I don't think there's just enough of a US Presence to do a major ground operation, what we've seen in Iraq and Afghanistan in the past. But there wouldn't be a if they were to carry out a small specific operation.

[Miles Parks]

So thinking about, I guess to your kind of the way you put it, Greg, which I thought was helpful in terms of there's a kind of a de escalation route and an escalation route. Think about the de escalation route. Who is leading negotiations at this point on the US Side or who's kind of leading the diplomatic effort to move this conflict toward a close?

[Greg Myhre]

Not entirely clear. We should certainly be looking towards the two people who've been involved in the past. Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner, however, both of those times last June when they were involved in negotiations, the US Joined Israel in bombing Iran. And in February they were involved in these efforts. And then the US Launched this war in Iran. So the Iranians are feeling maybe a little skittish about dealing with these two and that this doesn't necessarily mean there's going to be a peace deal coming out of that. So there is talk, and I would stress talk or speculation at this point that the Iranians may want to deal with somebody else. J.D. vance, the Vice president's name has been raised. We still don't have a venue fixed. Pakistan is a venue that's been raised. So a lot of uncertainty here. There does seem that these intermediaries, Pakistan, perhaps other countries in the region are trying to help set up some actual face to face talks. But it seems the discussions at this point have been indirect and we're trying to get to the point of some face to face are almost face to face meetings.

[Miles Parks]

All right. Let's take a quick break and more on the Iran conflict in just a moment.

[Carvana/HomeServe/Odoo/Grainger Announcer]

Support for NPR and the following message come from HomeServe. It never happens at a good time. The pipe bursts at midnight. The heater quits on the coldest night. Good thing. HomeServe's hotline is available 24 7. Call to schedule a repair and a local pro will be on their way. Homesen trusted by millions. For plans starting at $4.99 a month, go to homeserve.com not available everywhere. Most plans range between $4.99 to $11.99 a month. Your first year terms apply on covered repairs.

[NPR Sponsor Announcer]

This message comes from Grainger. Grainger knows that as an H Vac technician, you and your digital multimeter are in high demand. So when a noisy office H Vac turns out to be a failing blower motor, you don't break a sweat. With Grainger's easy to use website and product information, you can select the product you need to keep everything humming right along. Call 1-800-GRAINGER Click grainger.com or just stop by Grainger for the ones who get it done.

[Carvana/HomeServe/Odoo/Grainger Announcer]

This message comes from Carvana, who makes buying and financing your next car easy. Thousands of vehicles, terms upfront and 100% online. Even get it delivered to your door. Buy your car the easy way with Carvana. Delivery fee may apply.

[Miles Parks]

And we're back and we talk on the show a lot about President Trump looking for different ways to declare victory in Basically any situation. It's clear that he's looking for a way to do that, to kind of end this war. And off ramp is what some people have called it. What are his options at this point?

[Greg Myhre]

Yeah, Miles, before I get to the options, I want to sort of make a point about the phrase off ramp, which is what everybody is using, and I think we kind of understand what the meaning is. A way to end the war. But literally, when I think of an off ramp, I think I'm driving down the highway, I'm low on gas, I'm looking for an off ramp to fill up at the gas station. It's a minor inconvenience you need to deal with. We're talking about a war that really is going to reshape the region. We don't know how it's going to end, what the circumstances will be. So it's not just simply an off ramp in the sense that, yeah, hopefully this fighting can stop soon. We're talking about this reordering, reconfiguration in the Middle East. So we're talking about a solution to a major conflict, not just an off ramp. Now, in terms of options, most wars end with negotiations, and you don't see a clear battlefield solution right now, but you see two sides that are very, very far apart, not only in the goals that were stated initially, but now President Trump would really need to open the Strait of Hormuz, a problem that did not exist, in fact, for decades before this war. That had always been something looming out there that could gum up the oil markets and the global economy. Now the president has to make it a focus of his solution when he was talking about other things like regime change or getting rid of Iran's nuclear program. All of these may still be among the many things he wants to do, but he has to deal with some of the cards that Iran clearly has to play right now.

[Frank Ordonez]

I'll just add that, you know, I mean, we are talking about President Trump here. And for President Trump, declaring victory is pretty as simple as declaring victory. Everything Greg is saying is absolutely correct, and that's the reality on the ground. But oftentimes, as we've seen in the past, the reality on the ground is not necessarily what Trump is looking at. He just wants a reason to be able to call something a win, whether it's a peace deal around the country or in this scenario. And he's basically done that for the most part, including just yesterday, saying that they have basically won the war. Clearly, that's not the case. But for Trump, I think the victory that he's looking for is if he can basically get the Strait of Hormuz open, then he can at least say by his own definition that they have won the war, because, you know, while the regime may still be there, they're clearly degraded. And he's kind of backed off and on about whether he really wants regime change or whether at least that's necessary to end this.

[Miles Parks]

So is regime change just completely off the table at this point in terms of. That was something that was mentioned a lot earlier this year in terms of President Trump talking about the protesters in Iran and how they were treated by the regime. And then early in this conflict, President Trump begging the people of Iran to basically stand up for themselves. Are we hearing any of that sort of language now?

[Greg Myhre]

We're really not. He stopped talking about the protesters are rising up. And certainly the analysis from analysts is that's just not likely. It's just not realistic to be talking about it at this point. The Iranian government and military have shown that they can absorb these heavy blows. The US And Israeli bombing campaign, huge damage has been done, to be sure, to their military capabilities. They had a weak navy and air force to begin with. That's really been decimated. Its missile program, its drone program have all been set back very substantially. But at some level, the government is still functioning, and so is the military. It's still carrying out attacks. And we heard Tulsi Gabbard, the director of National Intelligence, testify last week saying Iran's government is weakened, but it's still intact. Dozens of top leaders have been killed, including the previous supreme leader, been replaced by a new supreme leader. It's just there's not a clear path to regime change at this point.

[Frank Ordonez]

Yeah, I think when the new supreme leader was announced, I think that really kind of changed the narrative for the Trump administration, because he was really talking a lot about regime change and all the steps towards regime change before then. But then when Iran dug in their heels and said they were going to continue to fight, the administration quickly kind of backed off that kind of language and focused more on the military goals. I did find it interesting, though, yesterday. Trump kind of twisted himself, or at least twisted the language into a little pretzel in order to say that this was still regime change, saying that they have killed so many leaders, how could it not be regime change? And then floated again the idea that this new person that they're supposedly talking with could eventually be the person who kind of serves as, you know, in what we've talked about before. This Venezuela type model where it is actually the same regime, but it's a new person involved.

[Miles Parks]

Greg, I want to ask before we close, just about how the region moves forward from this, no matter how it ends. Can you talk a little bit about the US Relationship with other countries in the region and how the other countries are kind of viewing this conflict and thinking about it?

[Greg Myhre]

Yeah. One thing I think that has gotten some attention, but not enough are the Gulf states, and we're talking about six Muslim Arab countries, all with hereditary monarchies, all which are very conservative, very averse to change, and they all oppose the war. They were against this war beginning. And now that it's begun, their big concern is that Trump may just call it off and pull out and sort of leave them with a mess behind, that the Strait of Hormuz issue may not be resolved, that they are clearly within striking distance from Iran. They're getting hit every day with Iranian missiles and drones. And now that Iran has crossed that threshold, that would be an ongoing threat they would have to face. And so they're very worried in terms of their security, in terms of their economy. They're going to be left in a much weaker and more vulnerable position if this war just ends abruptly without a clear, decisive measure. And their brand is stability. They've prospered by being this coastline of stability in the volatile Middle East. And if they get dragged into this volatility, that throws their brand, their image completely up in the air. And so that's a huge concern for them.

[Miles Parks]

All right. Well, let's leave it there for today. The political news does seem like it's changing at an especially rapid pace right now. This podcast is here to help you make sense of it. Please do not miss an episode. Hit that follow button wherever you listen to your podcasts and we'll be right back. Back on your feet tomorrow. I'm Miles Parks. I cover voting.

[Frank Ordonez]

I'm Frank Ordonez. I cover the White House.

[Greg Myhre]

And I'm Greg Myrey. I cover national security.

[Miles Parks]

And thank you for listening to the NPR Politics podcast.

[NPR Sponsor Announcer]

Support for NPR and the following message come from Washington Wise Decisions made in Washington can affect your portfolio every day. Washington Wise from Charles Schwab, is an original podcast that unpacks the stories making news in Washington. [e-mail] Washingtonwise this message comes from Rosetta Stone. Spring Travel coming up. Rosetta Stone has been the trusted leader in language Learning for over 30 years, ready to start learning a new language this spring. Visit rosettastone.com NPR today.

[Carvana/HomeServe/Odoo/Grainger Announcer]

This message comes from Odoo. Running a business is hard enough, so why make it harder with a dozen different apps that don't talk to each other? Introducing Odoo, the all in one fully integrated platform that makes your work easier from CRM, accounting, inventory, e commerce, and more. And the best part, Odoo replaces multiple expensive platforms for a fraction of the cost. This is why over thousands of businesses have made the switch. Try Odoo for [e-mail] that's o-o o dot com.