The Redefector: Episode 2 - "Meet the Team"

Host: Julie Cohn
Release Date: March 19, 2025

Introduction: The Year of the Spy

In 1985, dubbed the "Year of the Spy," the CIA faced an unprecedented crisis as Soviet assets began to vanish mysteriously. Initially dismissed as bad luck, the disappearance of four agents in quick succession signaled a potential deadly leak within the agency. Amidst this turmoil, Colonel Vitaly Yurchenko, a high-ranking KGB officer overseeing espionage in North America, made a shocking move—he defected to the United States.

Vitaly Yurchenko’s Defection: A CIA Jackpot or a Clandestine Debacle?

Yurchenko's defection was initially celebrated as a monumental victory for the CIA. As Julie Cohn explains, "Vitaly Yurchenko seemed to have located the leak, or so they thought, and quickly proven his worth" (02:36). Escorted out of Rome in disguise within three hours of his arrival, his swift exfiltration was a testament to the high stakes involved.

However, doubts soon emerged. Was Yurchenko genuinely defecting, or was he a plant sent to deceive U.S. intelligence services? This uncertainty would lead to one of the most intricate espionage mysteries of the century.

Assembling the Task Force: CIA and FBI Collaboration

In Virginia, at CIA headquarters, an urgent task force was formed to handle Yurchenko’s debriefing. Julie Cohn introduces the key players who comprised this insular team:

1. Rick (Alias) - CIA Debriefer
   Selected by Burton Gerber, head of the SE Division, Rick was a seasoned counterintelligence officer fluent in Russian. As he mentions, Yurchenko’s volunteering was "the greatest thing that ever happened to us" (02:17).

2. Colin Thompson - Senior CIA Officer
   Colin’s extensive background includes covert operations during the Vietnam War. Reflecting on his experience, he describes Rick as "the best debriefer" and praises his blunt and acerbic style (07:14 – 07:27).

3. Dan Payne - CIA Bodyguard
   At 25, Dan was relatively new to the CIA but played a crucial role as Yurchenko's bodyguard. He recounts the swift mobilization to secure Yurchenko, emphasizing the lack of preparation time (08:42 – 10:14).

4. Reed Bros - FBI Agent
   Assigned by the FBI due to his prior knowledge of Yurchenko, Reed was initially reluctant to engage. His role was pivotal, given his connection to Yurchenko’s past, including an affair with a Soviet diplomat's wife (11:11 – 13:09).

5. Mike Rochford - FBI Special Agent
   Mike, with a 30-year career in the FBI, provided critical insights into foreign counterintelligence. His firsthand account details the urgency and chaos of the initial debriefing process (14:29 – 15:39).

First Impressions and Initial Challenges

The team arrived at Andrews Air Force Base under extreme time pressure. Mike Rochford vividly describes the abrupt wake-up call at 3:00 AM, highlighting the lack of preparation time: "Got to be at the airport by 5:00" (17:31). Yurchenko was swiftly transported from Rome to a safe house in Northern Virginia, a townhouse conspicuously marked by the presence of multiple suits and agents—a setup that immediately drew attention from the neighbors.

Tensions Between CIA and FBI

The collaboration between the CIA and FBI was fraught with tension. Phil (Rick's alias), representing the CIA, clashed with Mike Rochford, leading to heated exchanges. Mike recounts an intense moment where Phil attempted to assert CIA dominance: "You will never talk to him alone by yourself ever again" (28:33). This friction underscored the complexities of joint operations within the intelligence community.

Yurchenko’s Arrival: A Man of Contradictions

Vitaly Yurchenko, now known as Alexander within the safe house, presented a complex persona. Described as "tall," with a "warm smile" and "light blondish rust-colored hair" (27:55 – 32:23), Yurchenko defied the stereotypical image of a KGB officer. His demeanor was a blend of Soviet machismo and romanticism, making him both charismatic and inscrutable.

Julie Cohn delves into Yurchenko’s enigmatic character, noting his "deadpan sense of humor" and "intelligent and circumspect" nature. This duality fueled suspicions about his true intentions: was he a genuine defector or an intelligence asset designed to manipulate U.S. agencies?

Security Measures and Debriefing Protocols

The team implemented stringent security measures to prevent any further leaks. Yurchenko was urged to communicate only through secure channels, encapsulated in a card he received: "if you have anything extremely important to tell us, ... tell me now, and I will take you directly to him" (24:05). Despite these precautions, uncertainties lingered regarding the presence of other moles within the CIA or FBI.

Personal Reflections and Team Dynamics

Throughout the episode, personal anecdotes from team members provide deeper insights into the high-pressure environment they navigated. Colin Thompson reminisces about his first encounter with Yurchenko, noting the latter's "bursting with energy" and the gravity of the situation (20:12 – 20:42). Dan Payne reflects on the operational challenges and the immediate need for surveillance detection to safeguard against KGB countermeasures (22:51 – 24:05).

The Central Mystery: Plant or Patriot?

As the team delves into Yurchenko’s background and motivations, the central question remains: was he a genuine defector seeking refuge, or was he a KGB plant orchestrating a deeper intelligence operation? This ambiguity sets the stage for ongoing investigations and revelations, promising further exploration in subsequent episodes.

Conclusion: Unraveling Yurchenko’s Enigma

Episode 2 of "The Redefector," "Meet the Team," meticulously introduces the array of CIA and FBI personnel tasked with handling Vitaly Yurchenko’s defection. Through detailed interviews and firsthand accounts, Julie Cohn paints a vivid picture of the operational complexities and interpersonal dynamics that defined this critical juncture in Cold War espionage. As the mystery of Yurchenko’s true intentions deepens, listeners are left eager to uncover the layers of deception and truth in the episodes to come.

Stay tuned for the next chapter in this ten-part series as Julie Cohn continues to unravel the decades-long mystery surrounding Vitaly Yurchenko.

Notable Quotes:

• Colin Thompson ([02:17]): "It was the greatest thing that ever happened to us."
• Dan Payne ([08:42]): "We didn't have a whole lot of time to sit and plan. This was a look, here's what we got to do."
• Reed Bros ([11:11]): "He knew who had been recruited, who the KGB had been targeting, and so forth."
• Mike Rochford ([14:29]): "I spent 30 years in the FBI."
• Mike Rochford ([28:33]): "You will never talk to him alone by yourself ever again."
• Dan Payne ([22:51]): "Phil reported the answer in his debriefing notes."

Speaker Attribution with Timestamps:

• Julie Cohn: Main host providing narration and context throughout the episode.
• Colin Thompson: Former CIA officer sharing experiences and insights on debriefing Yurchenko.
• Dan Payne: Former CIA bodyguard recounting operational details and team dynamics.
• Reed Bros: Retired FBI agent discussing his assignment and background with Yurchenko.
• Mike Rochford: Retired FBI Special Agent detailing the urgent call and initial debriefing process.

Credits:
The Redefector is a production of Waveland. Written and created by Julie Cohn. Executive Producer Jason Hoke. Sound Engineer Shane Freeman. Additional Production Assistance by Leo Culp. Music by Robert Ellis.

Connect with Waveland:
Follow on Instagram @wavelandmedia for more information and updates on the series.

If you enjoyed this episode, please leave a review and share it with friends who appreciate gripping espionage narratives.