The Rest Is History – Episode 508: America in '68: Nightmare in Vietnam (Part 1)
Host/Authors: Tom Holland and Dominic Sandbrook
Release Date: October 28, 2024

Introduction to 1968: A Pivotal Year in American History

In this episode of The Rest Is History, Tom Holland and Dominic Sandbrook delve into the tumultuous year of 1968 in the United States—a year marked by political upheaval, social unrest, and significant shifts in the American consciousness. Dominic Sandbrook, whose doctoral research extensively covers this period, provides expert insights into the cascade of events that defined the year, setting the stage for a series that draws parallels with the ongoing 2024 presidential election.

Dominic Sandbrook [00:45]: "It's not quite the effortless superiority that everybody imagines, but I have to say it does help to have a good team."

Lyndon B. Johnson: The Complex Presidency

Sandbrook paints a multifaceted portrait of President Lyndon B. Johnson (LBJ), highlighting both his extraordinary political acumen and his deeply flawed personal characteristics. Johnson's upbringing in the Texas Hill Country, marked by poverty and humiliation, fueled his relentless pursuit of power. His presidency is characterized by significant legislative achievements, including the Civil Rights Acts and the Great Society programs, juxtaposed with his domineering personality and controversial actions.

Dominic Sandbrook [09:44]: "No, he didn't just have a ruthless lust for power; he also had a side that is genuinely progressive and public-spirited."

Key moments discussed include Johnson's infamous "Johnson treatment," a combination of intimidation and charisma used to sway opinions and decisions, and his personal struggles with health issues and his relationship with his wife, Lady Bird Johnson.

Dominic Sandbrook [12:19]: "He is legitimately terrified he's going to have another heart attack or a stroke."

Civil Unrest and the Anti-War Movement

The year 1968 saw a surge in civil unrest across American cities, fueled by racial tensions, economic disparities, and widespread opposition to the Vietnam War. Riots erupted in places like Watts, Newark, and Detroit, vividly illustrating the nation's fracture. Concurrently, the anti-war movement gained momentum, particularly among college students who vehemently opposed the draft and the ongoing conflict in Vietnam.

Dominic Sandbrook [19:36]: "The riots are breaking out because there's growing tension over housing, over jobs, and over mistreatment, but over racism in the northern cities."

Sandbrook emphasizes the government's increasing frustration with the unrest, leading to a shift towards "law and order" rhetoric and the rise of political figures like Ronald Reagan, who capitalized on the public's desire for stability.

The Rise of Eugene McCarthy: A Political Underdog Emerges

Eugene McCarthy, a relatively obscure senator from Minnesota, emerges as a pivotal figure challenging LBJ's presidency. Initially reluctant to run, McCarthy is persuaded by progressive activists to mount a campaign against the Vietnam War, positioning himself as a candidate for peace and reform. Despite a well-funded campaign and significant support from young voters and students, McCarthy's efforts initially falter, reflecting the complexities of American political dynamics.

Dominic Sandbrook [35:05]: "He enters the race on the 30th of November, and it's a very, very sort of funereal scene almost."

McCarthy's unconventional approach, including his preference for discussing poetry and philosophy over traditional campaign strategies, sets him apart from typical political candidates. However, his lack of mainstream appeal and strategic missteps hinder his initial success.

Dominic Sandbrook [48:51]: "McCarthy's campaign is a disaster. It's so inept that it seems that only a paranoid view of his intentions can explain its failure."

The Tet Offensive: Shattering Illusions of Victory

A turning point in the Vietnam War, the Tet Offensive orchestrated by the Viet Cong and North Vietnamese forces, profoundly impacts American public perception and Johnson's administration. Despite being a military defeat for the Viet Cong, the offensive is perceived as a significant psychological victory for the North, revealing the government's misleading assurances about the war's progress.

Dominic Sandbrook [52:20]: "Middle America realizes for the first time the generals have been lying to us. There is no light at the end of the tunnel."

The offensive intensifies anti-war sentiments and undermines Johnson's credibility, leading to increased pressure for policy changes and fueling further political instability.

Dominic Sandbrook [54:08]: "At one of these meetings at the end of February, he literally breaks down in tears."

Johnson’s Exit: A Shocking Decision

Facing mounting pressure from both the anti-war movement and internal party dissent, Johnson makes a momentous decision to withdraw from the 1968 presidential race. This announcement is delivered in a grief-stricken speech where he cites personal and national exhaustion with the war, leaving the political landscape in disarray.

Tom Holland [69:54]: "They're all on it."

Johnson's exit opens the door for new contenders, drastically altering the trajectory of the Democratic Party and the upcoming election.

Dominic Sandbrook [71:15]: "Now, the narrative that had seemed predetermined has now been thrown into total flux."

Parallels to Contemporary Politics

Throughout the episode, Sandbrook draws compelling parallels between the political climate of 1968 and the contemporary dynamics of the 2024 election. Themes of political fragmentation, the struggle against entrenched power structures, and the role of media and public perception echo the historical narrative, offering listeners a nuanced understanding of both eras.

Dominic Sandbrook [71:35]: "So Johnson is very badly wounded... Nobody knows. Now, the narrative that had seemed predetermined has now been thrown into total flux."

Notable Quotes:

• Dominic Sandbrook [09:44]: "No, he didn't just have a ruthless lust for power; he also had a side that is genuinely progressive and public-spirited."

• Dominic Sandbrook [19:36]: "The riots are breaking out because there's growing tension over housing, over jobs, and over mistreatment, but over racism in the northern cities."

• Dominic Sandbrook [35:05]: "He enters the race on the 30th of November, and it's a very, very sort of funereal scene almost."

• Dominic Sandbrook [52:20]: "Middle America realizes for the first time the generals have been lying to us. There is no light at the end of the tunnel."

• Dominic Sandbrook [54:08]: "At one of these meetings at the end of February, he literally breaks down in tears."

• Dominic Sandbrook [71:15]: "Now, the narrative that had seemed predetermined has now been thrown into total flux."

Conclusion

Episode 508 of The Rest Is History offers a profound exploration of a defining moment in American history. Through expert analysis and engaging dialogue, Tom Holland and Dominic Sandbrook illuminate the intricate web of political, social, and personal factors that culminated in the crisis of 1968. This detailed narrative not only sheds light on past events but also invites listeners to reflect on their enduring relevance in today's political landscape.

For more in-depth discussions and access to exclusive content, join The Rest Is History Club.