The Rest Is History: Episode 556 - 1066: The Battle of Hastings (Part 3)
Release Date: April 13, 2025
Hosts: Tom Holland and Dominic Sandbrook

Introduction

In the third installment of their extensive series on the Battle of Hastings, Tom Holland and Dominic Sandbrook delve deeper into the complexities of one of England's most pivotal historical events. This episode meticulously examines the battle's key moments, scrutinizes historical sources, and debates longstanding narratives surrounding the Norman Conquest.

Recap of Previous Episodes

The hosts begin by revisiting the dramatic events leading up to Hastings. They remind listeners of:

• Stamford Bridge: A significant victory where King Harold Godwinson defeated Harald Hardrada, solidifying Harold's position.
• William of Normandy's Invasion: Despite adverse weather conditions delaying his crossing, William perseveres, culminating in the fateful clash at Hastings on October 14, 1066.

Historical Sources and Their Reliability

A substantial portion of the episode is dedicated to evaluating the primary sources that recount the Battle of Hastings:

1. The Carmen (Song of the Battle of Hastings):

   • Authors and Authenticity: Believed to be penned by a bishop allied with Matilda, William's wife, shortly after the battle (~Easter 1067).
   • Content Analysis: Provides vivid, albeit dramatized, accounts of the battle's commencement and key events.
   • Debate: Initially doubted as a medieval forgery, it's now largely accepted but remains contentious due to its graphic portrayal of the battle's brutality.

2. Bayeux Tapestry:

   • Nature of the Artifact: An embroidered cloth over 200 feet long, illustrating not just the Battle of Hastings but also preceding events.
   • Interpretation Challenges: While visually compelling, certain depictions (e.g., Harold being struck by an arrow in the eye) are debated among historians.

3. William of Poitiers:

   • Perspective: A soldier-turned-chaplain who served under William, offering a detailed and somewhat glorified account of the Norman tactics and leadership.

4. William of Malmesbury and Other Later Sources:

   • Credibility Issues: Written in the early 12th century, these accounts introduce elements like the infamous arrow in Harold's eye, which lack substantiation in earlier sources.

Notable Quote:

Dominic Sandbrook [08:25]: "Almost the only thing about the Norman Conquest that isn't controversial is the fact that the Normans won the Battle of Hastings. So there is lots to discuss."

Battle Tactics and Strategies

The discussion transitions to the tactical maneuvers employed by both the Normans and the English:

1. Norman Strategy:

   • Fortifications: Establishing castles in Pevensey and Hastings to secure strategic points.
   • Behavior: Unlike their usual hit-and-run tactics, William opts for a more direct confrontation to eliminate Harold as a rival.

2. English Defense:

   • Shield Wall: A formidable defensive line that proved difficult for the Norman cavalry to breach.
   • Terrain Advantage: The English positioned themselves on Senlac Hill, utilizing the natural landscape to their advantage.

3. Debated Elements:

   • Role of Cavalry: While traditionally depicted as a cavalry-dominated battle, Michael Lawson suggests that infantry clashes were more prevalent and that cavalry may not have been as decisive as once thought.
   • Duration of the Battle: The prolonged nature of the conflict challenges the conventional narrative of quick cavalry charges leading to victory.

Notable Quote:

Tom Holland [42:01]: "So, essentially, what he's saying is that cavalry may well not have played the key role in the battle that traditionally people have thought."

Death of King Harold

One of the episode's focal points is the controversial account of King Harold's demise:

1. Arrow in the Eye Narrative:

   • Bayeux Tapestry Depiction: Shows a figure with an arrow seemingly in his eye, accompanied by Latin text stating, "Hic Harold Rex interfectus est" (Here, King Harold is killed).
   • Historical Accounts: While Amatus of Monte Cassino (1080) and William of Malmesbury (12th century) mention the arrow, earlier sources like William of Poitiers do not corroborate this detail.

2. The Carmen's Graphic Description:

   • Alternative Account: Describes Harold being attacked and mutilated by Norman warriors, resulting in severe injuries.
   • Historical Plausibility: E.A. Freeman and Mark Morris argue against William Norman's participation in such brutality, suggesting it may have been embellished or fabricated for aggrandizement.

3. Skepticism and Debate:

   • Connorarity of Sources: The disparity between sources raises questions about the true nature of Harold's death.
   • Cultural Context: Comparisons are drawn to Viking sagas and Norse epics, indicating a possible narrative influence rather than factual recounting.

Notable Quote:

Dominic Sandbrook [48:34]: "We don't know how Harold died exactly, but one thing is certain. That Norman horseman trampling Harold down left him as just one among a heap of corpses piled around the toppled royal banner..."

Impact and Legacy of the Battle

The hosts reflect on the Battle of Hastings' enduring significance:

• Military Tactics: The clash exemplifies the transition from Anglo-Saxon infantry dominance to Norman cavalry tactics, influencing future European warfare.
• Political Ramifications: William's victory paved the way for the Norman Conquest, fundamentally altering England's cultural, political, and social landscape.
• Historical Interpretation: Ongoing debates highlight the complexities of medieval historiography and the challenges of interpreting contemporaneous accounts.

Notable Quote:

Dominic Sandbrook [43:07]: "This is a topic that's been kind of a live one for well over a century."

Conclusion and Cliffhanger

As the episode nears its end, Tom Holland and Dominic Sandbrook set the stage for the forthcoming conclusion of their Battle of Hastings series. They emphasize the battle's brutal realities and its critical role in shaping English history, leaving listeners eagerly anticipating the final episode's revelations.

Notable Quote:

Tom Holland [38:35]: "This is such a tragic story."

Final Thoughts

Episode 556 of The Rest Is History masterfully navigates the intricate details and enduring mysteries of the Battle of Hastings. Through insightful analysis and engaging dialogue, Tom Holland and Dominic Sandbrook offer listeners a nuanced understanding of this defining moment in English history, while also acknowledging the debates and uncertainties that continue to surround it.

For more episodes and in-depth historical explorations, join The Rest Is History Club.