Loading summary
Alastair Campbell
Thanks for listening to the Rest is Politics. Sign up to the Rest is Politics. Plus to enjoy ad free listening, receive a weekly newsletter, join our members chat room and gain early access to live show tickets. Just go to therestispolitics.com that's therestispolitics.com 4th.
Home Depot Advertiser
Of July Savings are here at the Home Depot, so it's time to get your grilling on. Pick up The Traeger Pro Series 22 pellet grill and smoker now on special buy for $389 was 549. Smoke a rack of ribs or bake an apple pie. This grill is versatile enough to do it all this summer. No matter how you like your steaks, your barbecues are guaranteed to be well done. Celebrate 4th of July with fast free delivery on select grills right now at the Home Depot. It's up to availability.
Alastair Campbell
The Rest is Politics is efficiently powered by Fuse Energy.
Rory Stewart
If you've got an electric vehicle a or if you're thinking about it, Fuse has a smart tariff with overnight charging for only 5 pence a kilowatt hour.
Alastair Campbell
And that's now available on both Apple and Android app stores and works with a wide range of chargers. No faff, no filibustering, no unexpected U.
Rory Stewart
Turns, so quite unlike Politics. And you don't even need a PhD in engineering. You just plug in your EV before bed and it'll be ready before the headlines hit your inbox.
Alastair Campbell
So if you need a charger installed, Fuse will sort the hardware, the fitting and the setup, often in under a week.
Rory Stewart
And when you sign up, you you'll get the trip members deal completely free ad free listening, early access to Question Time, bonus episodes, and pre sale tickets to our live shows.
Alastair Campbell
So while your car recharges, your podcast feed gets a power boost too.
Rory Stewart
Just head to getfuse.com politics Download the.
Alastair Campbell
App and use the code Politics Smart tariff, Swift installation. No white papers, green papers or red tape required. Welcome to the Rest of Politics Question Time with me, Alastair Campbell.
Rory Stewart
And with me Rory Stewart. Today, an incredible amount going on around the world. We'll of course touch on what's happening in the Middle East. We'll look at what's happening in the forthcoming NATO summit. You've been in France a lot, so we'll touch on what's happening in France and much more to touch on, including President Zelenskyy's visit to the United Kingdom. So over to you.
Alastair Campbell
Okay, well I think we should start with one of your explainers, Rory, given what's unfolding right now, in the Middle east, please could you do one of your explainers on the recent history of Iran, including its relations with Israel, the US and the UK and I think I'll give you 2 minutes, 20 seconds.
Rory Stewart
All right, here we go. So Iran, enormous country, sits right there between the Middle east and Asia. Ancient empire, one of the great civilizations of the world. So think about it almost as a civilization like China, Persian speaking, not Arabic speaking, and a originally Zoroastrian. And the reason many people will have heard of it is of course, the wars between Persia and Greece at a moment where Persia, and this is really important because Persians remember it today, had an empire that stretched from Egypt up into the Caucasus, the hod of the Middle east, right the way across to Afghanistan and Central Asia. And the edge of Pakistan went through many, many ups and downs. But there were many periods of incredible Iranian dominance. It became Muslim not long after the death of the Prophet Muhammad, predominantly Muslim. And then it became SH when a particular ruler took over in about 1500. Fast forward to the 20th century. Shah comes in, who is a modernizing autocratic military leader, makes the mistake of teaming up with Germany during the Second World War. By this stage, Persia has really got a lot of oil. And after a brief flirtation with a man called Musadegh, who leads them away from reliance on British oil in the us, the CIA puts a coup together where they support the Shah of Iran. And from then onwards, from the 1950s to 1979, the Shah of Iran is the key American ally in the Middle East. And Iran, Persian speaking, is known as sort of liberal, progressive country where people dress in liberal ways. But of course it's not the whole truth because in the background is a very conservative rural community. And this is exploited in 1979 when Khomeini comes in and Khomeini is a grand Ayatollah, an amazing religious figure, flies back from Paris, foments a revolution. The Shah of Iran flees and now we have the Iranian revolution. And from that point onwards, there are two major problems facing Iran. One of them is the attack on the United States. So they take Americans hostage, creating massive enmity with the US and then a war with Saddam Hussein in Iraq that consumes them for a decade as they out of the Iran Iraq War. There's a brief moment of flirtation with modernity and market liberalization figures like Rafsanjani. But from the early 2000s onwards, Iran becomes increasingly conservative. And under its new ruler, who replaces Khomeini, Khamenei, it finds itself increasingly seeing Israel as its major definitional enemy. That used to be normal. Many Arab states denied the existence of Israel. But as they gradually reconcile, Iran remains very focused on it and remains very focused on US and regime change. And a loss of the debate over the last 30 years has about whether or not it acquires a nuclear weapon and repression of people in Iran today. And I'm going to conclude on this final thought. I walked across Iran in 2000 and it was an amazing experience because what it revealed to me is a country completely split on the one hand between a very conservative rural areas where I slept every night in a different mosque, which was celebrating martyrs of the Iran Iraq War, deeply committed to the Revolutionary Guard and the revolution. And on the other hand, the cities which to this day remain dominated by a much more cosmopolitan, global, outward looking elite with scarcely disguised contempt for the regime. And where if you go to Tehran today, perhaps half the women are simply not wearing headscarves at all. They've just defied the regime and are not wearing them. So it's a very, very fascinating country and a country pushing in two different directions and has been for 40 years or more.
Alastair Campbell
Well, Lucy, thank you for your question. And that demand for a brief explainer, which was over twice as long as the limit that I gave Rory, he didn't even mention the UK we'll come back to that another day. Rory Russ, Ukraine now and I think this is what I really kind of worry about. Nan howit Trip plus member from Leeds. What does the Iran crisis, she calls it a distraction, mean for Russia and Ukraine and Gaza? And what do you think China will do? I do think this is partly because we now have, as the most prominent public figure in the world, this guy Trump, who is so obsessed by media, by what the story is, what the narrative is and so forth. And because we have a media in large parts of the world that it seems can only really focus with one big thing at a time. I think there is a real danger now that Putin is sitting there thinking, right, these guys are now so consumed about this, keep them over there and I'll just keep going with Ukraine. And Zelenskyy will feel more and more isolated. Zelenskyy will feel that the Americans and others are not going to be providing the arms that he needs. And then you're absolutely right as well about Gaza. There was yet another horrific, horrific killing of people who were trying to get food from this new humanitarian fund and it's not even on the news anymore. And so if you've got a combination of a media that sort of focuses on one thing at a time. A president who commands so much of the airspace around the world and who also focuses on one thing at a time, whichever, whatever happens to be the thing he wants to focus on at a time, and meanwhile these other things going on, then we shouldn't be surprised if the spotlight's not on them. That actually, given the history so far, the situation gets worse.
Rory Stewart
Yes. And look, there have been big strikes, very dramatic strikes by Putin on Kyiv, strikes in Odessa. He's made a speech on Friday, so we're recording here six days later, where he made it clear that he didn't rule out advancing on Sumy. And he keeps saying very openly that the Russian people and the Ukrainian people are one. And one of the reasons he hasn't been jumping to Iran's defence quite as much is that I think he'll be seeing this as an opportunity to push forward. One more thing that we should look at someday that we haven't looked at enough is the effect of drought. So I'm talking to you from London. You're in Cyprus. I don't know what it's like in Cyprus at the moment. They're really worried, but, boy, is everybody worried. I mean, Northern Europe has been hit by very little rain. My two famous Chinese pots that I discussed with the Chancellor are sitting outside without their tops on and they've been out there for three weeks and there's no water in them because no rainfall's fallen here in London on my pots. And the output in Europe is scheduled to be down by 15%. And we're seeing similar effects in the US. There is going to be a big climb in global prices on wheat. Beef, coffee, for example, is likely to go up. So climate change affecting food supply. Russia, Ukraine is having a real problem with drought and wheat production. So that's another thing to look at. We talk often about global conflict in terms of leaders, but we're not necessarily looking at the way that climate is beginning to drive things in very, very disturbing ways. Now, here's a question for you from Amber Trip member, London. With the NATO meeting coming up, I had a question about its future. The most recent conversation had been around whether or not Trump would pull out of NATO or honor Article 5. But given that the only time Article 5 has been used is to support the US and that Trump is an unreliable actor who is potentially getting involved in a new war in Iran that NATO members don't seem to support, is it in NATO's interest now to have America step away? Do they want to be dragged into a wider conflict in the Middle East?
Alastair Campbell
Well, let's mention again, as we did in the main podcast, the one we did live on Tuesday, the interview we've just done with the President of Cyprus, because he was essentially saying America can take the action that it's just taken and quotes, whether we like it or not, we are involved because in his case, we're just down the road from where the Americans have just launched this extraordinary bombing attack. And likewise for the European Union, it is. So the question suggests that would be an easy thing to do in NATO's interest now to have America step away. We're already seeing how difficult it is for NATO that America has pursued the policy that it's been pursuing since the reelection of Trump and J.D. vance. And you know, J.D. vance is who we've and people you know will be aware we've done this miniseries about J.D. vance. And one of the big things about Vance is this real disregard he has for Europe in part because of what he sees as our sort of cowardly approach to defense, defense spending, to looking after our own backyard. So I think we have to try to keep NATO going and we have to. And this point about Article 5 is important. So that's this basic thing that says an attack on one is an attack on all. Essentially, Trump sees NATO as a bit of an international nuisance because he doesn't like international gatherings and he doesn't like international institutions that might try to hold him to account. But I think it is absolutely in our interest to try to keep NATO as strong as it's been through most of our lifetime. It's going to be hard, though.
Rory Stewart
It's going to be hard. Something very interesting happening though now, which is the clarification that all NATO members are now committing to 5% GDP on defence. And this is incredible news. The small print is 3.5% of that is going to be classic defence spending. 1.5% is going to be things like national security, cyber protection. Another bit of small print, Britain saying it won't hit it till 2035, but it is still the most staggering amount of money. And it's extraordinary.
Alastair Campbell
Why is Spain being given a kind of opt out, do you think?
Rory Stewart
That's a really interesting question. I haven't got to the bottom of how Spain managed to get its opt out because everybody would want an opt out.
Alastair Campbell
And also I think I've told you before that here I am not far from Greece is I think that Greece has got pretty good numbers. But when you really dive into it an awful lot of their defense spending is pensions. So I think this is a very, very dramatic headline. But there'll be a lot of small printer, as you say, on the way.
Rory Stewart
The bottom line is that the numbers we're talking about are beyond imagining. So let's say that the GDP of Europe is about $20 trillion. This will be $1 trillion every year being spent on defence. And again, to return to this ridiculous calculation that Elon Musk keeps trying to encourage, so that we understand the numbers here, a million seconds ago is something like the 12th of June, right? We're recording on 24th of June. So about 12 days ago. A billion seconds ago is 1992. A trillion seconds ago is 30,000 BC.
Alastair Campbell
Wow.
Rory Stewart
So the difference between a billion and a trillion is like the difference between 1992 and 30,000 BC. And that's what Europe will have to spend on defense every year going forward.
Alastair Campbell
The other thing that you often say, which I did memorize, but you haven't said it recently, so I've now forgotten it, is your. Is your stat about Nigeria and the birth rate.
Rory Stewart
One in 10 children born in the world will be born in Nigeria by 2050.
Alastair Campbell
That's the one. That's the one. So I've now got two. That one I have to re. Remember. And then I've got the trillion one is just. Is just amazing. Now, Rory, here's one. I'm really looking forward to a discussion on this. You upset quite a lot of people on Monday. I don't know if you know about this.
Rory Stewart
Was this about talking about my mug?
Alastair Campbell
No, I'm talking about your. Our interview with Gabriel Atal. Sophie Pedder.
Rory Stewart
Yeah, Sophie Pedder. Sophie Pedder, the great supporter of Macron. The one who said he made the right decision to call the election. The one who never hears anything rude about Macron Italian. Is it the same?
Alastair Campbell
Sophie Pedder, our producer, has put the headline on this question hating the French question mark. Sophie questions as follows. I have a question for Rory Stewart and the fact she calls you Rory Stewart suggests a bit of a kind of edge already, rather than most of our listeners say for Rory, what is his problem with France and French politicians? Macron deserts deserves plenty of criticism, she says. I cannot recall Rory Stewart ever having a positive word to say about him. It's great to see you interview French politicians as you just did with Gabriel Atal. But again, Rory seemed lovely phrase coming disproportionately disappointed. It's time to hear, please, what really bugs Rory Stewart about the French. Listen, she wasn't the only one. Rory, we had quite. Including a friend of yours got in touch with me and said, what did you do to Rory today? He was so grouchy and grumpy and rude with that man.
Rory Stewart
Well, there we are. So I think the first thing is it's really not personal at all against the French. You have only to see my interview with Rachel Reeve to see that I'm absolutely.
Alastair Campbell
I know that's not an answer. That's. What about three? Tell me a French person that you've spoken about fondly.
Rory Stewart
General de Gaulle.
Alastair Campbell
When? When was that? I don't remember.
Rory Stewart
I definitely done it in the podcast. I talked a lot about General de Gaulle. In fact, the fact that he made the right decision on NATO. Listen, there's a lot positive to say about Macron. I think it was extraordinary that he managed to create a movement from the centre ground. I think it was very, very exciting. It's risky because of what that's meant for the traditional centre right and the centre left in France. It creates the risk that you end up with a far right and a far left if the centre collapses. But I think what he did was very exciting. I think his vision of the world is often very exciting. But I think he has been a great disappointment. Sadly, as a European leader, I may be holding him to higher standards. That may be true even for my grouchy conversations with some of the new Labour leadership and even some of my grouchy interviews with my conservative colleagues. He has incredible intelligence, incredible fluency, and what he's decided to do, instead of crafting a detailed, coherent policy that brings Germany, France and Britain together, is, I'm afraid, to grandstand, is to give these huge speeches at the Sorbonne laying out grand visions of the future which largely alienate the Germans, most of whom are pretty skeptical about what he's talking about, allows himself to get caught up in small things like disputes about fishing quotas, and hasn't really ever stepped up. He's a great charmer. I mean, total credit to him for his lovely messages to Britain, his praise around D Day, his messages to the King and all this kind of stuff. But if you really judge him in the way that you want to judge people like Helmut Cole or Mitterrand, I don't think he's going to go down in history as having really done it. And his political judgment can be catastrophic, triggering an election which has effectively created a type of non existent French government that has almost never existed in French history. Sophie Pedder, I remember, disagreed with me when I criticized him for doing that, too. So I might also ask the Economist correspondent in Paris.
Alastair Campbell
Bureau chief.
Rory Stewart
Bureau chief.
Alastair Campbell
Subtle put down there.
Rory Stewart
Yeah. Does she ever question what actually he achieves, as opposed to the way in which he charms the world with his intelligence, his youth and his bravura?
Alastair Campbell
Oh, I think you're being very harsh on. I think because Sophie likes the French, you're displaying that she's not wrong, that you've got a thing about the French. Because Sophie, Feda has been critical.
Rory Stewart
I'm an equal opportunity abuser. You can see me being very rude about British politicians.
Alastair Campbell
Oh. In which case. Well, let's get down to that. You see, my theory. I'm going to repeat my theory that I said at the end of the interview.
Rory Stewart
No, no. Can I just point this out?
Alastair Campbell
You don't want these people who are young, who've achieved.
Rory Stewart
Is it possible that I'm actually trying to hold politicians to account who you're giving an easy ride to?
Alastair Campbell
I don't give anybody an easy ride. What I do, though, is I don't go into interviews thinking, right, this is what I want them to be and this is what I want them to say. The reason why he didn't like Atal, he didn't say what you wanted him to say about the current situation in Israel, Gaza, where he was frankly just parking the bus because he was thinking, I'm no longer in the government, I'm just going to park it. Which we both do from time to time. In interviews, you tried to sort of make out that France Al J Algeria was somehow the same as Stop the Boats. And he looked a bit confused. And I think, wait, do you mind.
Rory Stewart
Explaining why that's confusing? He's saying, if people come to us from Algeria, we should just push them back to Algeria. And when I suggest, if people come to us from France, we should push them back to France, he won't accept it.
Alastair Campbell
I think he was making the point about the French Algerian history being a bit different. My point about. The thing is, you shouldn't. The thing about interview Rory, listen to the answer and pick up on the answer. Don't go back to what you wanted them to answer.
Rory Stewart
Wait, Alastair, how about you listen again to the interview that you did with Speaker McCarthy where you literally can't let anything go. You ask him three, four questions to every one of mine because you're so excited about the fact that he's saying things about President Trump that outrage you. In the same way, I'm totally outraged by Attal's refusal to Stand up for international law. It's the biggest story in the world. European leaders failure to stand up for international law. So I'm allowed two or three questions on that, just as you're allowed 15 on McCarthy.
Alastair Campbell
Rory, Rory, I let you go. I just sat back.
Rory Stewart
And if somebody said, do you have a problem with McCarthy? The answer would be what?
Alastair Campbell
I don't like what he stands for, and I don't believe that he's saying what he does.
Rory Stewart
And I don't like what ATTAL stands for in international law, and I don't trust him on immigration. And I think he's much more right wing than people like Sophie Pedder want to credit.
Alastair Campbell
Okay. I think that in relation to McCarthy, I don't believe that when he was sort of putting the line for Trump, that's what he believes, and that's what I was trying to probe. I was doing it based upon what he was saying and then having an exchange. I do think sometimes, and I thought.
Rory Stewart
It was charming and lovely. Alastair, because you were passionate and you were engaged and I let you roll. The only thing that goes wrong is when I seem to be a little bit tough on somebody who's one of your friends. That's when the objection comes in.
Alastair Campbell
No, not at all. I'm talking about our reader's objections. Sophie Pedder is not the only. Only person who sent in this sort of question, Roy. And I think if you go back to the ones where you really lost it, not lost it, but, you know, be not your usual charming self. Let's just go through them. Jamie Rubin, Jonathan Powell, Sadiq Khan, your friends. No, no. Rachel Reeves.
Rory Stewart
Wait, wait. Jamie Rubin and Jonathan Powell?
Alastair Campbell
Yeah, yeah, yeah. They're close friends.
Rory Stewart
You don't. Don't like it when I have a go at your friends. So Jonathan Powell, just to remind people, was basically saying Iraq would have been fine if we'd just done it right and planned. Well, if you don't expect that to get someone wound up and challenged just in the way that you do when McCarthy's defending Trump. It's the same thing. Our worldviews are different. I thought the Iraq War was a catastrophe. And to hear Jonathan Powell calmly, when you and I were doing his job.
Alastair Campbell
About it, you were fine. I think sometimes you don't like these guys who are doing jobs that you love to do. You'd love to be National Security Advisor with Keir Star, but you'd love it.
Rory Stewart
There may be a bit of that. That the Maywell.
Alastair Campbell
So thank you for getting us to. Because people say that we agree too much these days. So, Sophie, thank you for getting us to agree. What were we doing there? Disagree agreeably.
Rory Stewart
Alistair, well done on disagreeing. So agreeably. Listen, that's a great reminder for people who are listening to this thing. What on earth are they talking about? Just a reminder. We have a separate feed called Leading where Alistair and I every week are interviewing some of the most interesting people in the world. So that was our interview. French Prime Minister that's just gone out. We've just done an interview with the President of Cyprus. And of course, we have interviewed Arnold Schwarzenegger, Bill Gates, Hillary Clinton and many, many more. You get to see and decide when I'm getting too wound up and when I'm being unfair and when Alice is being overly defensive of his good old mates by triggering to leading. So anyway, see you after the break. Thanks again.
Alastair Campbell
See you.
Rory Stewart
This is an advertisement from BetterHelp. In politics, we often talk about strength. Projecting strength, holding strength, you know, never showing cracks. And that idea seeps into everyday life, especially for men. Pressure to perform, keep things together, carry on. But bottling things up doesn't always make you strong. I think, as we all know, it can make you actually very bristle. Trying to be strong over time and that can lead to burnout or worse. Whereas being honest with yourself and others and doing something about it and talking can help lift some of these crazy weights, give some perspective, build resilience, help you to cope when life feels overwhelming, when you can't always be what you're trying to pretend to be. So BetterHelp has over 5,000 therapists in the UK. It's the world's largest online therapy platform, serving over 5 million people globally. And it works with a 4.9 rating in the App Store based on 1.7 million reviews. As the largest online therapy provider in the world, BetterHelp can provide access to mental health professionals with a diverse variety of expertise. Talk it out with BetterHelp. Our listeners get 10% off their first month at betterhelp.com restpolitics. That's betterhelp.com restpolitics.
Marina Hyde
Hello to our lovely Restless Entertainment listeners.
Richard Osman
This is me, Marina Hyde, and me, Richard Osman. Hello, everybody.
Marina Hyde
Now our two part deep dive into the chaotic production of Jaws. The first blockbuster has been a smash hit, bit like the film itself. And that has been a huge hit with our club members.
Richard Osman
Yeah, the response has been incredible. Thank you all so much. Deep Dive is an unfortunate thing to say in relation to Jaws, but I know what you mean. It's great to be able to do these deep dives into entertainment stories that are off the beaten track. We'd have to do topical stuff. We can tell, like amazing stories about amazing movies, amazing albums, amazing characters, amazing stories from the past of showbiz and famous.
Marina Hyde
So much history, really.
Richard Osman
Yeah, it's like the rest of history, but, you know, you get to talk about Noel Edmonds.
Marina Hyde
Okay, so here is the thing. Just like Universal, who are desperate to get their money back with a nationwide release of Jaws, we want all our listeners to experience what our club members have been raving about.
Richard Osman
Hold on a second. Are you saying what I think you're saying? Which is for a limited time, you can access our Jaws series absolutely free just by visiting thereses entertainment.com that is.
Marina Hyde
Exactly what I'm saying.
Richard Osman
You have got to be kidding me.
Marina Hyde
It is the perfect way to discover why our bonus content is so special and why club membership is absolutely worth it.
Richard Osman
We're going to need a bigger podcast. Join the rest of the entertainment club today by visiting thereses entertainment.com we'll see you there.
Rory Stewart
So welcome back to the Restless Politics Question Time with me, Rory Stewart and.
Alastair Campbell
With me Alistair Campbell.
Rory Stewart
The Restless Politics is, as ever, efficiently powered by our friends Fuse Energy Energy prices Back in the headline, here's a question from Emmett what's going to happen to global oil prices if things escalate in the Middle East? Isn't this yet another argument for the UK Government to invest in renewable energy very quickly for me, then, before I throw it back to you, the oil price is jumping around like you cannot believe. I mean, it was at a very low historical level. Then there were Talk when the US strikes happened that jumping up to 100, $120. Then as soon as Trump put out his true social thing, saying there was peace, the global oil price has collapsed again. But it really matters for Britain because basically, as we've found in a lot of our leading interviews, the energy prices in Britain track these global prices more closely, in fact, than they do in Europe and the United States. So when oil prices go up, it really hits cost of living in Britain. And of course, renewables is part of the answer to that. That but renewables can't do it all because there's still the problem on how you store the renewable energy and what happens when the wind isn't blowing and the sun isn't shining, which is why obviously things like nuclear become relevant. Anyway, over to you.
Alastair Campbell
No, look, you and I are both big supporters of sort of getting to net zero and renewable Energy is absolutely the heart of that. And it was interesting right at the height of the current Iran Israel crisis, Donald Trump, another sort of post that he did was he did a big drill baby drill. Oil price volatility, we've got to get more of our own and blah, blah, blah, blah, drill baby drill. So a very, very different perspective on it. But just go back to what happened in Ukraine that had a direct impact upon energy prices for British and other consumers around the world. We were talking when the Israelis started the recent attacks on Iran, about one of the possible options for Iran in terms of retaliation was mining or closing the Straits of Hormuz. There are something like 20 billion barrels of oil a day are going through there. If that suddenly becomes difficult, then it has an immediate impact upon prices. This is a very, very, very volatile market. And that's why when we talk about the need for stability in the world, it's not least because you have these spikes and some people make lots of money out about that. But ultimately consumers, once it goes up, tend to have to pay a high price on their bills. And energy debt in Britain is already nearly 4 billion. So you get bills rising. It makes it that even worse.
Rory Stewart
This is, I guess, where these energy companies come in. I mean, our sponsor, Fuse, for example, is locking in fixed tariffs for 18 months, keeping it on average below the cap. But these caps, the price cap limits unit rates and standing charges. It doesn't limit your total bills. So there's a lot of issues around cost of living. And the other thing I guess fusion would say is they would say in the end you've got to double down on solar, that nuclear and carbon capture is absorbing a lot of money, but the real potential is solar, which is, they argue, cheaper, faster, more stable. I mean, everybody listening will know the incredible story of the drop in the price of solar energy, that it's like one twentieth of what it was a few years ago, partly because it's incredible. Chinese transformation.
Alastair Campbell
Well, Fuse are giving you customers a free trip membership for the whole of 2025. That means you get ad free listening, early access to episodes, discounts on live shows and things like the miniseries that we've just done on JD Vance. Just download the Fuse app, sign up with the code Politics for all the details and full terms. Head to getfuse.com politics Anyway, Rich C.
Rory Stewart
Trip+member leads many conflicts, both historically and current, seem to be attributed to one person, usually a country's leader, as Putin is in Ukraine. In reality, how important is the influence of one person? Aren't they actually just the face the regime in charge, surely wider factors are at play. Well, this is a really interesting thing, isn't it? Because generally when you go back in time and a historian is writing, they will tend to diminish the importance of the kind of Great man theory of history, and they will tend to explain how decisions emerge from a deeper economic crisis, social background, cultural moment. But when we look at things today, we have a real tendency not to say, you know, Keir Starmer is the sort of passive victim of a slowing British economy, poor demographics, a declining power in the world, and there's not much he can do. We tend to put the responsibility right on him as leader. And of course, they encourage that themselves, don't they, because they want to present themselves as being in charge. Anyway. What do you think about Great Men theory of history?
Alastair Campbell
Well, I think just to pick up on what you just said there. So what they then do is this is what you'll hear people say, critics of Gearstein will say, oh, well, he's no Thatcher, he's no Blair. In other words, they say, this is about him. It's only about the leader. Let's just take Rich's question, which talks about Putin. It is about him. However, it's about him at the end of a very long period of time where he has aligned with the forces around him, forces that he can control and forces that he can't, to get himself into this position of extraordinary power within his own country and therefore within the world. We talked on the main podcast about Ali Khamenei, very similar, you know, we said, I said, reminded people that at the start he was in there as a sort of stopgap because he wasn't even remotely qualified by their own constitution. But over time, he cements that power. Donald Trump at the moment is immensely powerful within his own country and in its politics, and therefore powerful within the world. There was an interesting related question from Margaret William, another TRIP member said, I've not yet listened to your miniseries, the Real JD Vance. However, does this new venture indicate that you and I are leaning towards the Great man theory of history? And it doesn't. But what it does is that that often, I think part of what we see our role as is trying to explain politics and political trends to people who at the moment are finding politics and political trends unbelievably confusing. And often that is done through the personalities that people connect with. J.D. vance, in a very short period of time, has become one of the best known vice presidents of our lifetime. He is A household name around the world. That is very, very rare for an American vice president. So he's become a significant figure already. He might be the next president. So therefore he probably merits, I think, more analysis than most vice presidents we get. I don't think he's a great man, by the way. I think he's a pretty bad man. It's funny, isn't it? It's great man. Very rare that we talk about great woman theory, and I think that's because women tend not to start wars in the same way.
Rory Stewart
So very quickly, before we get on to the great man theory, just wanted to say the second episode of our Members Only JD Void series, which we've both recorded, is out tomorrow, Friday 27th June, and we talk about the emergence of the new right, the influence of figures like the tech bro Peter Thiel, and how a shady network of billionaires want J.D. vance to become an American monarch. If you want to hear this series, which we've really enjoyed recording, sign up to hear the first two episodes@thereals politics.com to get a seven day free trial. So the Great man theory of history is a quote from Thomas Carlyle's book Hero and Heroism. And this is an early 19th century account. And it's a real reminder of the kind of gap between the way in which we tend to think in normal culture, which has gone a long way away from heroes, and then this weird phenomenon of Trump and populism, which has brought sort of pseudo fake heroes back into power. So the basic story would be that for nearly, I guess, 2000, two and a half thousand years, we had this idea of kind of great men, great heroes, kind of warriors, Alexander the Great, Napoleon, even Victorian heroes. And that collapsed, as you've pointed out, collapsed because feminism said, oi, what about the other half of the population? Pacifism said, enough of the war. Psychoanalysis said these people are a bunch of egotistical narcissists. Class analysis said they tend to be elite, anti colonialism said they tend to be imperial, et cetera. So we get to the stage by the end of the Second World War where we're going for ordinary heroes clapping NHS workers, you know, the unknown firemen, trying to get away from the idea of these superheroes. But there's a totally different trend. Almost as though, and maybe this is your, the work that you're doing on men and young men, where there's resistance against getting rid of heroes. And that deploys with superheroes in movies, celebrities, sports stars and eventually Musk and Trump. Where. Where all that repressed desire that we're going to have, these great men, comes back in a much more sinister, contorted, immoral form, leaving us, really, I think, only with Zelenskyy as the only person I can think of today who I'm still prepared to really say, this guy does kind of match up as a hero.
Alastair Campbell
Interesting. I think you should take those sort of points you just made, and I think this is sort of, maybe not a book, but there's a very interesting long article in that all those you're going through, all those threads of why the Great man theory is rejected alongside why it appears to be coming back in fashion. Trump, as you say, do you think Farage, who. Here we are. This week was the ninth anniversary of the referendum. He was a big factor of that. Most people in Britain now accept that it was probably a really silly thing to do. And yet Johnson, it's sort of ultimately, as he's been seen off, Farage is back as a force. And a lot of his support is coming from certainly men more than women, and disproportionately young men as well. Do you think that's related to the things that you've just been saying?
Rory Stewart
Yes. And I think one of the reasons why you and I tend to, I'm afraid, probably underestimate figures like Farage over time is it's difficult to square the fact that. That on the one hand, he's clearly a pretty absurd figure who gets an incredible amount wrong, contradicts himself all the time, lost many, many elections, and yet is really making the weather. I mean, it's a very odd gap. I mean, we had a glimpse of it with Boris Johnson. There's a huger image of it with Trump. Farage is part of this phenomenon, which is not, to return to Sophie Pedder's thing, we'd want to believe that the people who are making an impact are these sor. Earnest, very clever intellectuals like Macron, making highly intelligent speeches. But actually, we're in a world in which the people who really seem to be making the weather are people who on the surface seem quite kind of buffoonish and unserious, seem to be having more influence than the people doing the strategic analysis.
Alastair Campbell
I was in France the other day and I did an interview for. There's a Channel 4 documentary which I think is going out today, I think Thursday, if you're listening, on Thursday, I think it's today. And it's Fraser Nelson, X of the Spectator, and the Premier Mrs. Will Nigel Farage be the next Prime Minister now, a few years ago, in fact, even a couple years ago, that would have been a complete joke. I still think it's highly unlikely, but it's not impossible because we're in such volatile times as you know, Roy, I tend to prepare if I'm doing interviews or at least think it a bit. And I jotted down a few notes, but I think my best line came just spontaneously. Tell me what you think of this. I said economically, Farage is Trust Mark 2. Politically and presentationally, he's Johnson Mark 2. Are we really going to put a combination of the worst two Prime Ministers in our history into Downing Street? Are we really going to do that? I thought it was quite good.
Rory Stewart
Very good. With a little sprinkling of Trump on top.
Alastair Campbell
Okay, yeah. Oh, it's interesting. He's distancing himself from Trump. He's not really getting engaged in Trump.
Rory Stewart
At the moment and amazing that he's managed to do that, isn't it? Given that there are all those photographs, them grinning together and so many record statements of him praising him. It's extraordinary. Okay. George Lambrood, TRIP member. I'm a new father, five month old little boy. Congratulations, George. Fantastic. And I'm growing incredibly concerned about his future. Knowing what we know about politics around the world and the likelihood of conflict involving Britain, would you recommend having children? My answer is absolutely yes. That's the thing I've done. And we're not really here to drive you into such gloom that you don't have children.
Alastair Campbell
But listen, Rory, a lot of young people are thinking in these terms because they're basically saying, can't afford a house. Climate change. Social media seems to be sort of destroying our brains. Britain is not as powerful as it was. The world is now led by complete sort of, you know, monsters.
Rory Stewart
And Gabriel Atal's not going to save us. So.
Alastair Campbell
Oh, you can't leave it alone, can you? You cannot leave it alone.
Rory Stewart
I love the French.
Alastair Campbell
Food, you love wider food.
Rory Stewart
I really like the British. I just was massively disappointed by this great messiah.
Alastair Campbell
But George. The other thing to say to George Lambreu is that, you know, if we think about the sort of. I think there is also a patriotic case for, for getting the birth rate back up. We are demographically in a mess.
Rory Stewart
Are you gonna patriotic case for getting the birthright? You're gonna have Keir Starmer making a little speech encouraging everyone to. That's quite old fashioned. That's quite. That's type of political communication we haven't seen for a long time.
Alastair Campbell
Just look at the birthright.
Rory Stewart
Well, do you know what Orban did, which was very interesting. I don't know whether it's fully been realized, but he announced that if you had, I think it's more than four children, you would be exempt from income tax from your entire life in an attempt to get a Hungarian birth rate up. And that's a pretty amazing policy.
Alastair Campbell
The one French person that you like, De Gaulle, he was always trying to get people having babies. And Nicola Sturgeon, didn't she have. She had a big push on. On, you know, supporting.
Rory Stewart
Do you think, Alison, I mean, if someone had said to you if you had four children, you'd be exempt from income tax for life, you might be quite tempted. I'd be quite tempted, yeah.
Alastair Campbell
I think having had three, you just thought, yeah, let's go again. Go again. Now, at the other end of things from Poppy McGee, how would you both have voted in the debate on the assisted dying Bill if you'd been in the Commons? I would have voted very much in favor.
Rory Stewart
I probably would have voted against, reluctantly. And we got into that, actually. We had quite a good series of agreeable disagreements, if people are interested. We did actually quite a good leading interview, didn't we, with the author of Kim Ledbetter? With Kim Ledbetter.
Alastair Campbell
What's your main. If you had to say in sort of, you know, one sentence what your main objection is?
Rory Stewart
My main objection is a fear that an old, frail person is going to feel, not that they're bullied, but just sort of of subconsciously pick up. They're becoming a bit of a burden and they're costing their family money. And maybe it'd be kinder and better if they just took themselves out of the way. And I wouldn't want to feel that anybody felt that. I also have been a bit troubled by some of the data coming out of the Netherlands. I mean, it's an extraordinary number of applications now for assisted dying in the Netherlands. I'd be a bit troubled if we were moving towards a situation where it was becoming very, very common for lives to end in that way. But anyway, this is a much, much bigger conversation. But you were more, I think, concerned by the constitutional role of the House of Lords on this, because this is something that got through the House of Commons, remind people, got through on a private member's bill, which is a very interesting thing where just occasionally, members of Parliament get to bring stuff forward. I remember Rebecca Harrison, in my intake in Parliament, tried to take one through to change British Summertime. She wanted to change our clocks and make sure the clocks weren't changing in a way that over benefited Scottish farmers. So we're going to. Actually, I think we were going to leave Greenwich Meantime entirely. If that bill of got through, that.
Alastair Campbell
Would be very bad for soft power.
Rory Stewart
Well, I mean, obviously massive conservatives like me were just so attached to the symbolic value of Greenwich Meantime that I failed to support my friend Rebecca when I should have done.
Alastair Campbell
I agree with you. I'd worry if the laws mess around with this. I've already heard some of the members of the House laws saying that, you know, well, it's not a government bill and it wasn't promised in the manifesto and therefore, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. I think this is a case where the House of Commons should show premise. The House of Lords is absolutely welcome to put forward proposals to, to improve it, but I worry that those who have failed to defeat the arguments in the Commons will now try to use the House laws to stop this and listen. And I also wasn't that happy with Wes Streeting, who, okay, he's entitled to come out and vote against it, but then I think to come out afterwards and basically say the health service can't afford this bill. I wasn't sure about that either.
Rory Stewart
Interesting, isn't it? Because he, as, I guess his objection is partly as a Christian to the bill, but it's interesting to then, as you say, use his position as Health Secretary to undermine it on a cost basis.
Alastair Campbell
Yeah, because the Prime Minister voted for it. He could easily, he come out and say, well, you know, okay, we have to make this work. Rory, I'm going to put forward a very controversial idea here. Oh, yes, go and tell me whether your Christian view thinks this is bad. I would like to be able to say in age now 68, compos mentis, that if I get to a place where I don't have control of my own physicality, my own mental faculties, that I would like to be able to say that these are the circumstances in which I would no longer like to continue living. What do you think of that?
Rory Stewart
Look, I mean, I think you're expressing something that's really powerful in humans. I don't think we like feelings that we're not who we were and that things are falling away. And that's, I think, I guess, one of the reasons why we used to love the idea of sort of people to come back to heroes dying young, because they die at a moment where they're at their absolute peak. The only thing I'd say gently against it is maybe we also need to be kind to ourselves and we need to embrace aging and not I was a bit, you know, I sort of slightly had a conversation when we were doing the leading interview with Kim about this, when she talked about somebody saying she didn't like seeing her mother looking undignified in hospital. I sort of think that we should be more comfortable with being undignified, that aging isn't awfully dignified and we should embrace that as part of our mortality. But who knows? Listen, I'm not going to push that on you. You've lived a tough life, you've done a lot of things and you've got a particular way of viewing yourself. But I wouldn't want everybody to feel that just because they're getting older and frightened that, that they're somehow demeaning themselves and becoming a nuisance and they might as well pop on.
Alastair Campbell
Final question Landy Roberts, this is about Zelenskyy talking to the king and of course, the queen. If you put together the number of world leaders that the queen met and had private conversations with, the question from Landy is what do politicians talk about when they meet the king? How interested do you think the king is in geopolitics? Well, I think he's very interested in geopolitics. How interested he is in what a lot of the political leaders say is probably another question. But.
Rory Stewart
Well, I think he's doing an amazing job. I mean, I obviously keep praising him because I'm a huge fan. But Zelenskyy was over again just two days ago in Britain, did a visit on Monday. And it's really interesting the way that the king has made a real effort to host world leaders. He's hosting many, many more of them than people realize because these aren't just state visits. He's often, you know, he'll bring the king of Bahrain over to a meeting at Windsor. He, he'll and he's really, I think, being creative in the way in which he hosts people. He often thinks hard about what they might be interested in seeing, takes them to different places, but really makes the effort to sit with them, spend time with them. And as you say, he's got very, very clear views about the world, is fascinated by the world and is really feels that he's got a role. I mean, I think he has got a role. The one we talked about, I suppose, two weeks ago is that he's obviously, obviously the head of state of Canada at a time when Trump is talking about making Canada the 51st state. And Trump likes the British Monarchy. So he's got to signal. Oy, hold on a second. Canada is something associated with the Royal Family, so please back off. But he's also, I think, able to, in the Gulf, he's got these relationships which nobody else has got, because he's known all these people since they were children, since he was a young person. So he will have met them over 50 years. Nobody else can quite do that. And that means that he can pick up the phone, he can steer things. Presumably, the challenge is he's also got to balance the fact that he's a constitutional monarch, the Prime Minister is the elected head of government, and he's therefore got to balance all the time his strong personal views about what's going wrong in the world and who he thinks is. Is causing trouble with his responsibility to represent the state.
Alastair Campbell
And the thing, though, about what they talk about, because, I mean, they have this sort of inbuilt advantage because of sort of, kind of general deference that is shown towards them, including by foreigners. I mean, it's really quite extraordinary, the sort of power they have. You'll meet an absolute arch French Republican. I don't mean Republican Party, I mean somebody who just absolutely doesn't understand or like the concept of monarchy. But you see them with, when they meet the Queen, when she was alive, or King Charles now, and they will just sort of bow down. It's like it's this really kind of weird phenomenon. And they do have. So much of their time is with these endless small talk when they're doing garden parties and visits to villages and hospitals and the rest of it where, you know, the Queen always used to say, you know, how far have you come? And I don't know what Charles has as a tick to sort of get people going.
Rory Stewart
He's very good at it. I mean, you may have seen Chelsea Garden show all the way, Windsor Garden Flower Show. I mean, you can see one of the things that he's always doing is he often looks back over his shoulder and points at someone with a smile, a sort of cheeky smile to say, ah, yeah, I just remember that. He's got a great way of. I mean, actually more than his mother. I think he actually really enjoys it. He's more like your friend Bill Clinton. He seems to get genuine energy from. Not be drained. I mean, he's actually in that sense, a bit of an extrovert. He really seems to be.
Alastair Campbell
I can't remember somebody recently told me that when Trump was with the Queen that she told somebody afterwards all he wanted to talk about was my sister. He was obsessed with my sister. Why is he so interested in my sister, his Princess Margaret? But because the other thing they've got, let's say Prince Charles is meeting Zelensky, okay? Now it's obvious that because of the government position on Ukraine, Russia, he's perfectly able to sort of of be very, very, very, very supportive. But of course, you know, there was a time when Putin was not Persona non grata and when he will have had meetings, observations and what have you. I guess the question then is how frank can he be in a situation like that? Or is there always a part of him that's thinking I have to slightly hold back?
Rory Stewart
Yeah. And of course he'll get. I mean, I think the other thing that you'll know and I know, but readers don't know is that of course he gets like the Prime Minister, he gets a red box with all the briefing. He gets very detailed speaking notes. There will be points to make. I mean, Alison, maybe you could sort of explain to listeners this sort of weird thing that Prime Ministers and ministers get these sort of sheets of paper that sit in front of them when they meet someone else, where the civil servants have said, these are the points you must make, these are points it would be nice to make and these.
Alastair Campbell
Are the points to avoid.
Rory Stewart
Well, one of the lovely examples of this is John Le Carre, who, you know, the famous spy writer, but who was initially a British intelligence officer, goes off to see Harold Macmillan when he's prime minister in the 60s with a guy called Fritz Ehrler, who's a German politician who the British think is going to be potential future Chancellor. It's quite interesting actually. I don't know whether it would happen today. Would the Prime Minister spare time for a kind of upper middle ranking German politician who they think might become the Chancellor in the future Anyway, in those days they did. He takes Fritz Ehrle in to see Macmillan and Macmillan has these speaking points in front of him and Macmillan is clearly a bit tired, bit out of it, sort of stumbles through the speaking points that Fritz, Ella and Le Carre can all see sitting on the table. And Ehler leaves with absolute sort of amazing Olympian disdain for Macmillan and just how pathetic it is to see him sort of struggle through these speaking points. We're meeting him instead of feeling grateful for the chance to meet the British Prime Minister now. I just want a little glimpse from you, though. Go on, give us a story, if you can, about what it's like dealing with these kinds of things, because I think You've got one up your sleeve.
Alastair Campbell
Tony Blair, with whom I've discussed most things, he was incredibly discreet about his meetings with the Queen. You know, he'd go off to see the Queen and he'd come back and he'd say, what are you talking about? Oh, you know, this and that. Can't retire. He wouldn't sort of say, oh, I'm the Prime Minister, I can't talk about it. Constitutional propriety, etc. Although, remember when we talked to Jacinda Ardern, she did something which Tony was told not to do in his memoirs, which is. Quoted her directly. And one night he came back from a meeting at Buckingham palace and said, oh, God, I think I really put my foot in it with. With her Maj. And what he said, well, oh, God, he said she was wearing this green dress, a green suit, and. And she said that she was going to Scotland at the weekend to present the Scottish cup football, Celtic Rangers. And he said, I hope you're not wearing that dress, Green being Celtic and the Queen having to stay neutral in all things. And he didn't. He couldn't quite work. Work out whether she understood that that might be a problem. So he. He was really worried that actually she just went away thinking, why is it. Why is my new Prime Minister insulting what I wear?
Rory Stewart
Yeah, yeah, I could. I can see. I can see that. That's. It's a bit. It's difficult getting. Getting a tone right that you don't. You. It's probably not great telling any woman, you know that you don't like her dress and telling the Queen, maybe.
Alastair Campbell
So whatever the. Whatever the search. Anyway, he got very good at saying mom. The. Right. It's mam, isn't it? Ma' am. I always used to say mam, but it probably is mam. You don't have a very long A.
Rory Stewart
At school. We said ma' am in relation to the. To our Matrons.
Alastair Campbell
Right, yeah. So Sir's just so much easier, isn't it, Rory?
Rory Stewart
Sir is much easier. That's what I tend to call you, Alistair, when we're not on screen. Have a lovely day. Have a safe flight from Cyprus.
Alastair Campbell
Thank you. And just remind listeners and viewers, tomorrow, rest is politics. Plus episode two of who Is the. Of the Rest. Real JD Vance.
Rory Stewart
Very good. Looking forward to it. Bye bye.
Alastair Campbell
See you soon. Bye.
Richard Osman
Hey, everyone, here's that Jaws clip that we mentioned during the break. You can listen to the whole episode for free on thereses entertainment.com. there's no cast at this point as well.
Marina Hyde
The cast is so last minute for this.
Richard Osman
It was nine days before principal photography was due to start. Two of the three main parts, Quinton Hooper still hadn't been cast nine days before. So everyone's ready. Everyone's ready to go, you know, the.
Marina Hyde
Whole unit, who are eventually played by Robert Shaw and Richard Dreyfus in the movie. And those two have a massive feud. There were so many other different people that they considered. Now, Brody, who was actually played by Roy Scheider, and it's a brilliant performance. He's so sort of. It's an amazing performance.
Richard Osman
He's so put upon and like every man.
Marina Hyde
But, yeah, I mean, the other people considered were Paul Newman, Charlton Heston, Robert Duvall, Gene Hackman. Like, definitely the last two of those could have done it.
Richard Osman
Yeah. So I think Charlton Heston was desperate to be in it. And Spielberg, again, you know what? He was smart right from the beginning. Spielberg, he said, think about Charlton Heston, he's too big a star.
Marina Hyde
Why is he too big? Because, you know, Charlton Heston always wins. That's the problem. You know, Charlton Heston is going to defeat the shark. You don't know what Reichrider is going to do. You just don't know. So it's really important.
Richard Osman
Roy Scheider has the look of a man who could be eaten, who could definitely be eaten. You'd be like, yeah, I can see it. I don't know if his agent is, you know, gonna be saying he's gonna be in it, but he can't be eaten. It could definitely be eaten.
Marina Hyde
Charlton Heston eats sharks. The end.
Richard Osman
Charlton Heston Eat Sharks. Another. Again, another great title for the book.
Marina Hyde
Roy Scheider actually heard Steven Spielberg talking about it at a party. And Steven Spielberg was saying he'd had this idea for how he could get the shark to jump onto a boat. Roy Scheider thought, I'd like to be in that movie.
Richard Osman
That sounds good. I like this kid.
Marina Hyde
And he said, I would like to be in this movie.
Richard Osman
Anyway. Charlton Heston, by the way, vowed never to work with Spielberg after that.
Alastair Campbell
Right. Well done, everybody. Who's still listening, because that means you've listened right to the end of the episode. Thank you. Very impressive. But can I ask you something? Did you hear an advert on today's episode, and did you think, you know what? I'm sure the listeners would rather hear about my brand rather than all these other things they're promoting. Well, you could be right, but there's only one way to find out.
Rory Stewart
That's right. You could be the next NORDVPN or betterhelp put your brand in front of millions of like minded listeners by advertising on the Restless Politics and other shows across the Goal Hanger network. So who a Goal Hanger? Well, they're the company behind this very show and if you're in the market to increase the value of your brand, they want to hear from you. You can register your or your company's interests by going to goal hanger.com right now. That's go H-A-N-G-E-R.com see you there.
The Rest Is Politics: Episode 420 - Question Time: The History of Iran vs. the West Release Date: June 25, 2025
Hosts: Alastair Campbell & Rory Stewart
Podcast Description: Alastair Campbell and Rory Stewart dissect current affairs in the UK and globally, offering expert analysis and insider perspectives on British and international politics.
The episode begins with promotional segments for The Rest Is Politics Plus membership and sponsors like Home Depot and Fuse Energy. These segments provide information on exclusive content, ad-free listening, and special offers for members.
Timestamp: [02:16] - [06:15]
Rory Stewart provides an in-depth explainer on Iran's historical and contemporary relations with the West, particularly focusing on its interactions with the US, UK, and Israel.
Key Points:
Notable Quote:
"It's a very, very fascinating country and a country pushing in two different directions and has been for 40 years or more."
— Rory Stewart [05:58]
Timestamp: [06:15] - [07:57]
Alastair Campbell introduces a Trip member question from Leeds regarding how the Iran crisis serves as a distraction for Russia's actions in Ukraine and Gaza, and the potential implications for China.
Rory Stewart expresses concern that intense focus on Iran might embolden Vladimir Putin to continue aggression in Ukraine, as global attention is diverted. He also touches upon humanitarian issues in Gaza and the media's role in spotlighting conflicts selectively.
Notable Quote:
"There is a real danger now that Putin is sitting there thinking, right, these guys are now so consumed about this, keep them over there and I'll just keep going with Ukraine."
— Rory Stewart [07:03]
Timestamp: [07:57] - [12:13]
A Trip member from London inquires about NATO's future, especially in light of President Trump's unpredictable stance on the alliance and Article 5.
Alastair Campbell argues against the US stepping away from NATO, emphasizing the importance of maintaining a strong alliance despite challenges posed by leaders like Trump who view NATO as an "international nuisance."
Rory Stewart highlights NATO members' commitment to increasing defense spending to 5% of GDP, underscoring a collective effort to bolster the alliance's strength despite logistical challenges and opt-outs like Spain's.
Notable Quote:
"It's absolutely in our interest to try to keep NATO as strong as it's been through most of our lifetime. It's going to be hard, though."
— Alastair Campbell [10:34]
Timestamp: [12:40] - [21:39]
Sophie Pedder, a producer, questions Rory Stewart's apparent disdain for French politicians, particularly President Emmanuel Macron.
Rory Stewart clarifies that his critiques are directed towards political actions rather than personal sentiments. He praises Macron's initial steps in creating a centrist movement but expresses disappointment over Macron's failure to deliver coherent policies, his tendency to grandstand, and perceived political misjudgments.
Notable Interaction:
Timestamp: [25:07] - [28:57]
A Trip member, Emmett, asks about the impact of escalating tensions in the Middle East on global oil prices and the UK government's renewable energy investments.
Rory Stewart discusses the volatility of oil prices due to geopolitical events, emphasizing how Britain's energy prices are closely tied to global markets. He advocates for renewable energy as part of the solution but acknowledges challenges in storage and reliability.
Alastair Campbell reinforces the importance of renewable energy in achieving net-zero goals, highlighting the potential consequences of disrupted oil supplies, such as increased consumer bills and economic instability.
Notable Quote:
"When oil prices go up, it really hits cost of living in Britain."
— Rory Stewart [26:19]
Timestamp: [28:57] - [35:14]
A Trip member, Rich, questions the influence of individual leaders in historical and current conflicts, challenging the "Great Man" theory.
Alastair Campbell and Rory Stewart debate the extent to which individual leaders like Vladimir Putin, Ali Khamenei, and Donald Trump shape global events versus broader socio-economic factors. They acknowledge that while systemic issues play a significant role, charismatic and influential leaders can steer agendas and impact international relations substantially.
Notable Quote:
"It's a world in which the people who really seem to be making the weather are people who on the surface seem quite kind of buffoonish and unserious."
— Rory Stewart [35:14]
Timestamp: [38:18] - [44:25]
A Trip member, Landy Roberts, poses a moral and constitutional question regarding assisted dying and the role of the House of Lords.
Alastair Campbell and Rory Stewart share their perspectives:
They discuss the constitutional implications, particularly the House of Lords' involvement in legislating such sensitive issues.
Notable Quote:
"I wouldn't want everybody to feel that just because they're getting older and frightened that, that they're somehow demeaning themselves and becoming a nuisance and they might as well pop on."
— Rory Stewart [43:59]
Timestamp: [44:25] - [51:40]
Discussion centers around the British monarchy's role in international relations, particularly King Charles III's interactions with global leaders like President Zelenskyy of Ukraine.
Rory Stewart praises the King's adeptness at hosting and strengthening diplomatic relationships, noting his unique ability to connect with leaders and influence soft power dynamics.
Alastair Campbell contemplates the inherent power dynamics and ceremonial responsibilities of the monarchy, questioning how candid the King can be given his constitutional role.
Notable Quote:
"He's getting into the kind of awkward parts of his role, where he has strong personal views about what's going wrong in the world and who he thinks is causing trouble with his responsibility to represent the state."
— Alastair Campbell [46:17]
Timestamp: [51:40] - [52:00]
The hosts wrap up the episode by teasing upcoming content, including Episode Two of the "Who Is the Real JD Vance" series, and remind listeners about The Rest Is Politics Plus membership benefits.
Episode 420 of The Rest Is Politics offers a comprehensive exploration of Iran's historical and current geopolitical stance, the complexities of NATO alliances amidst shifting US policies, critiques of French political leadership, the intricate dynamics of energy prices and renewable investments, and nuanced debates on constitutional matters like the Assisted Dying Bill. The hosts also delve into the enduring relevance of individual leaders in shaping global events and examine the British monarchy's subtle yet impactful role in international diplomacy. Throughout the episode, Alastair Campbell and Rory Stewart engage in thoughtful discussions, providing listeners with valuable insights into pressing political issues.