The Spy Who Saved MI5 (Encore): How the Cambridge Five Changed MI5 | Episode 5 Summary

Released on July 15, 2025, by Wondery

Introduction

In the fifth episode of The Spy Who series titled "The Spy Who Saved MI5 (Encore) | How the Cambridge Five Changed MI5," host Tristan Donovan delves deep into one of the most infamous espionage cases in British history: the Cambridge Five. Joined by Andrew Lowney, author of Stalin's Englishman, they explore the intricate web of betrayal, the impact on British intelligence services, and the enduring legacy of these Soviet spies.

Understanding the Cambridge Five

Cambridge Five Overview

The Cambridge Five were a group of British spies who infiltrated key positions within the British intelligence apparatus during the Cold War. Andrew Lowney clarifies that while the popular narrative centers around Kim Philby, Donald Maclean, Guy Burgess, Anthony Blunt, and John Cairncross, the actual network was more extensive, involving around 20 recruits between 1934 and 1937.

Notable Quote:

Andrew Lowney (01:53): "I think it had a huge impact and we're still seeing the impact to this day."

Recruitment and Motivations

Recruitment Strategies

Recruited primarily from Trinity College, Cambridge, the spies were often former members of the Cambridge University Socialist Society, a communist front. Kim Philby, a central figure, played a significant role in recruiting his peers, leveraging personal connections and ideological sympathies.

Motivations Behind Espionage

The motivations for joining the Soviet intelligence were multifaceted:

• Ideological Alignment: Many sympathized with communism and saw the Soviet Union as a counterbalance to rising fascism.
• Personal Factors: Absent fathers and a sense of belonging provided by the Soviet network.
• Revenge and Disillusionment: A desire to undermine the British establishment, from which they felt excluded despite their elite education.

Notable Quotes:

Andrew Lowney (06:16): "A lot of them had absent fathers... the Russians Secret Service became their sort of their parents."
Andrew Lowney (06:03): "They basically just went to their friends who they knew would be sympathetic."

Roles and Impact

Operational Roles within MI5 and MI6

Each member of the Cambridge Five held significant positions within British intelligence services:

• Kim Philby: Gained access to MI6’s foreign intelligence, passing vital information to the Soviets.
• Donald Maclean: Accessed atomic secrets, significantly compromising British and Allied intelligence.
• Guy Burgess: Operated within MI5 and MI6, also influencing media through his role at the BBC.
• John Cairncross: Provided the Soviets with information about the Ultra project, which deciphered German codes during WWII.
• Anthony Blunt: Initially an art historian, later served as a recruiter within MI5.

Impact on British Intelligence

The betrayal by the Cambridge Five led to the largest expulsion of Soviet spies by a Western government during the Cold War. This infiltration severely compromised British intelligence operations and necessitated a complete overhaul of security protocols within MI5.

Notable Quotes:

Andrew Lowney (12:03): "Philby could pass information back and he would do that partly through dead drops, partly from meetings with his controllers."
Andrew Lowney (15:27): "Maclean had access to atomic secrets. Those were betrayed. Cairncross knew about Ultra, which was betrayed."

Unraveling the Spy Ring

Discovery and Exposure

The downfall of the Cambridge Five began towards the end of WWII when the Americans broke Russian codes, leading to the identification of a spy in the Washington embassy. This culminated in 1951 when Maclean and Burgess fled, revealing the extent of the espionage network.

MI5’s Initial Response

MI5 was initially reluctant to accept the severity of the breach, attributing the disappearance of Maclean and Burgess to minor misconduct. This negligence was rooted in the belief that elite Cambridge graduates could not be spies, a notion that proved disastrously incorrect.

Notable Quotes:

Andrew Lowney (16:16): "They were useful in all sorts of different ways and each of them had a slightly different role depending on where they were."
Andrew Lowney (17:33): "Security was very lax at this point... people had access to keys to safes. So it was very, very easy."

Fallout and Consequences

Impact on British Society and Intelligence

The exposure of the Cambridge Five led to widespread distrust in the British establishment. The term "the establishment" itself gained traction post-1951, reflecting the shaken confidence among the public and within government circles.

Rebuilding Trust

MI5 and MI6 implemented rigorous vetting processes and positive security measures to prevent future infiltrations. The incident also strained relationships with international intelligence partners, especially the CIA, leading to a period of reduced cooperation.

Notable Quotes:

Andrew Lowney (25:50): "Well, I think there was a sense that the establishment couldn't be trusted and that people who went to Eton could be spies."
Andrew Lowney (27:03): "The CIA and the State Department were not really cooperating with the British for some time afterwards."

Remaining Questions and Legacy

Unreleased Archives and Ongoing Research

Despite extensive investigations, much of the Cambridge Five’s activities remain obscured within MI5’s vaults. Andrew Lowney highlights that approximately 95% of related material has been destroyed or remains classified, suggesting that the full scope of the espionage network is yet to be uncovered.

Lessons for Today

In the context of modern-day tensions with Russia and ongoing espionage threats, the Cambridge Five serve as a cautionary tale. The necessity for vigilant security measures and the constant evolution of intelligence strategies remain paramount.

Notable Quotes:

Andrew Lowney (36:06): "We can never drop our guard against the Russians. We are in a new Cold War."
Andrew Lowney (34:45): "What can you say?"

Conclusion

"The Spy Who Saved MI5 (Encore)" offers a compelling exploration of the Cambridge Five, illuminating their profound impact on British intelligence and society. Through expert insights from Andrew Lowney, listeners gain a comprehensive understanding of how these spies infiltrated MI5, the subsequent fallout, and the enduring lessons applicable to contemporary intelligence challenges. This episode not only revisits a pivotal moment in Cold War history but also underscores the timeless nature of espionage and the ever-present need for robust security measures.

Notable Quotes with Timestamps:

• Andrew Lowney (01:53): "I think it had a huge impact and we're still seeing the impact to this day."
• Andrew Lowney (06:03): "They basically just went to their friends who they knew would be sympathetic."
• Andrew Lowney (12:03): "Philby could pass information back and he would do that partly through dead drops, partly from meetings with his controllers."
• Andrew Lowney (16:16): "They were useful in all sorts of different ways and each of them had a slightly different role depending on where they were."
• Andrew Lowney (25:50): "Well, I think there was a sense that the establishment couldn't be trusted and that people who went to Eton could be spies."
• Andrew Lowney (36:06): "We can never drop our guard against the Russians. We are in a new Cold War."

For more in-depth episodes and stories from the shadowy world of espionage, subscribe to The Spy Who on Wondery+ via the Wondery App, Apple Podcasts, or Spotify.