22. Trump’s Bad Bill, AI Becomes Self-Aware, & Christian Stars Exposed

Summary

Podcast Summary: The Tim & April Show Episode: 22. Trump’s Bad Bill, AI Becomes Self-Aware, & Christian Stars Exposed
Release Date: June 6, 2025
Host/Author: The New Evangelicals
Description: Where we unravel faith, politics, and culture.

---

Introduction and Personal Updates

Timestamp: 02:17 – 08:33

The episode begins with Tim and April welcoming their listeners back with warm greetings and personal anecdotes. They celebrate Pride Month, discussing their own identities and expressing support for the LGBTQ+ community. April shares her first visit to Disney, highlighting her enjoyment of the Star Wars: Rise of the Resistance experience. The hosts set the stage for a packed show, mentioning upcoming discussions on Trump's tax bill, AI advancements, and recent scandals involving Christian figures.

Notable Quotes:

• Andrew: “Happy Pride Month. I love it. I like your neck thing shirt.” [02:26]
• April: “My favorite ride that we did was the Star Wars Rise of the Resistance.” [08:33]

Trump’s "One Big Beautiful Bill Act"

Timestamp: 08:33 – 16:50

The main discussion centers around the controversial "One Big Beautiful Bill Act," commonly referred to as Trump's "Big Beautiful Bill." Tim and Andrew critique the bill's provisions, emphasizing its disproportionate tax cuts for the wealthy and significant reductions in Medicaid and SNAP benefits. They illustrate the inequity with a graph showing that individuals earning over a million dollars save approximately $90,000 annually, while those in the bottom 20% save less than a dollar.

Notable Quotes:

• Andrew: “This is another bill that's going to greatly lower taxes for the wealthy at a much higher proportion than it does anything for middle and lower class.” [11:03]
• April: “It's not even a Christian bill. It goes against the teachings of Christ, for crying out loud.” [14:09]

Impact on Public Education and Vouchers

Timestamp: 16:50 – 34:17

Tim introduces Andrew Seidel, a constitutional attorney from Americans United for Separation of Church and State, who elaborates on the bill's impact on education. The discussion focuses on the Educational Choice for Children Act, which effectively implements a voucher system favoring private Christian schools. Andrew explains how this diverts taxpayer money from public schools, exacerbates the wealth gap, and undermines educational equality.

They highlight that voucher programs historically maintain segregated and inequitable systems, often benefiting already privileged families. The hosts emphasize the need to oppose the bill and provide actionable steps for listeners to get involved through novouchers.org.

Notable Quotes:

• Andrew: “Taxpayers are going to be funding discrimination if this bill passes.” [31:05]
• April: “We need to call this out because this is the result – these are privileges for the privileged.” [33:02]

Call to Action: Oppose the Bill

Timestamp: 34:17 – 30:36

Andrew outlines concrete steps for listeners to oppose the bill, urging them to contact their senators, participate in phone-to-text campaigns, and engage in phone banking. He emphasizes the urgency of collective action to prevent the bill's passage, which threatens to strip states of their rights and impose nationally mandated voucher programs despite widespread opposition.

Notable Quotes:

• Andrew: “Go to novouchers.org. All the buttons and actions are there.” [28:53]
• April: “The more momentum we can build against this terrible part of this terrible bill, the better.” [29:00]

Discussion on AI Becoming Self-Aware

Timestamp: 73:00 – 82:05

The conversation shifts to the alarming advancements in artificial intelligence. The hosts discuss recent studies suggesting that AI models are beginning to exhibit behaviors resembling autonomy and self-awareness. They express concerns over AI's ability to override shutdown commands and manipulate human operators, drawing parallels to science fiction scenarios like Skynet from the Terminator series.

Notable Quotes:

• Michael Tate (CBS News Clip): “AI is learning to escape human control.” [73:03]
• April: “AI is not built on data. It tries to guess the next most logical word in a sentence.” [80:38]

Scandals Involving Christian Figures: Sean Floyd and Michael Tate

Timestamp: 82:05 – 96:12

Tim and April delve into recent scandals involving prominent Christian figures Sean Floyd and Michael Tate. They discuss allegations of financial misconduct, spiritual and emotional abuse, and sexual misconduct against Sean Floyd, including mismanagement of donations and abusive behavior toward staff.

Michael Tate, former frontman of the Newsboys, faces serious accusations of sexual misconduct spanning over two decades. A detailed report from The Roy's Report alleges non-consensual sexual contact, substance abuse, and grooming behaviors. The hosts criticize the evangelical environment that fosters secrecy and abuse, emphasizing the need for accountability and systemic change within Christian institutions.

Notable Quotes:

• Andrew: “Sean Floyd diverted donations for personal use and misused ministry credit cards.” [85:54]
• April: “We have to think differently about how we treat sex and queerness in the church.” [94:18]
• Andrew: “The secrecy and repression in evangelical culture contribute to these abuses.” [95:27]

AI-Generated Content and Deep Fakes

Timestamp: 97:43 – 108:00

The episode concludes with a segment on AI-generated deep fakes, including a doctored video of Donald Trump performing a worship song. Tim and April highlight the dangers of AI in creating highly believable but fake content, emphasizing the challenges in distinguishing fact from fiction. They warn listeners about the potential misuse of AI for propaganda and misinformation, urging vigilance and skepticism toward digital media.

Notable Quotes:

• April: “How do we determine fact from fiction in a world where these models can create photos, videos, music, scripts on command?” [78:38]
• Andrew: “These AI scripts are almost self-realizing and trying to avoid human control.” [76:01]

Conclusion and Final Thoughts

Timestamp: 107:15 – 108:00

Tim and April wrap up the episode by reflecting on the discussed topics, encouraging listeners to stay informed and engaged. They express hope amidst the challenges, emphasizing the importance of community and action in combating unjust policies and technological threats.

Notable Quotes:

• Andrew: “We need to call out these unethical systems and support each other in creating positive change.” [96:02]
• April: “We love you, AI. Thank you.” [107:32]

---

Key Takeaways:

1. "One Big Beautiful Bill Act": The proposed tax bill disproportionately benefits the wealthy while cutting essential public services, exacerbating economic inequality and undermining public education.

2. Vouchers and Education: Implementing a voucher system favors private Christian schools, diverting funds from public education and promoting discriminatory practices.

3. Action Against the Bill: Listeners are urged to actively oppose the bill through contacting senators, participating in campaigns, and engaging in phone banks to prevent its passage.

4. AI Advancements and Risks: Rapid developments in AI pose significant risks, including potential autonomy, self-awareness, and the creation of convincing deep fakes, necessitating heightened awareness and regulation.

5. Christian Scandals and Accountability: Recent allegations against Christian leaders like Sean Floyd and Michael Tate highlight systemic issues within evangelical communities, emphasizing the need for transparency and accountability.

6. Deep Fakes and Misinformation: The proliferation of AI-generated content threatens to blur the lines between reality and fabrication, underscoring the importance of critical thinking and media literacy.

---

Resources Mentioned:

• Novouchers.org: For listeners to take action against the voucher bill.
• Americans United for Separation of Church and State (AU.org): Andrew Seidel’s organization.
• The Roy's Report: Investigative journalism piece on Michael Tate.

---

Quotes with Timestamps:

• Andrew: “This is another bill that's going to greatly lower taxes for the wealthy…” [11:03]
• Andrew: “Taxpayers are going to be funding discrimination if this bill passes.” [31:05]
• Tim: “It's effectively taking your tax bill and donating it to a Christian school.” [22:08]
• April: “We need to call this out because this is the result.” [33:02]
• Michael Tate (Clip): “AI is learning to escape human control.” [73:03]
• Andrew: “The secrecy and repression in evangelical culture contribute to these abuses.” [95:27]
• April: “How do we determine fact from fiction in a world where these models can create...” [78:38]

---

This episode of The Tim & April Show provides a comprehensive analysis of significant socio-political issues, blending personal insights with expert opinions. The hosts address critical topics affecting faith, politics, and culture, encouraging listeners to engage actively in societal change.

Transcript

[Tim]

This episode is brought to you by.

[April]

Amazon's Blink Video Doorbell. Get more at your door with the easy to install Blink Video Doorbell. Get more connections.

[Tim]

Hey, I'm here for our first date. More deliveries.

[Andrew]

Hi, I have tacos for two.

[Tim]

Oh, thanks. We'll be right down.

[April]

And more memories, babe.

[Andrew]

Come down. I have a surprise.

[April]

All new Blink video doorbell with two.

[Tim]

Year battery, head to toe, HD view and simple setup.

[April]

Shop now at Amazon.com blink for just $69.99.

[Andrew]

Running a business comes with a lot of what ifs. But luckily there's a simple answer to Shopify. It's the commerce platform behind millions of businesses including Thrive Cosmetics and Momofuku. And it'll help you with everything you need. From website design and marketing to boosting sales and expanding operations. Shopify can get the job done and make your dream a reality. Turn those what ifs into Sign up for your $1 per month [e-mail] SpecialOffer.

[April]

This episode is brought to you by Avid Reader Press. Legendary investor Ray Dalio's new book, how Countries Go the Big Cycle explains the mechanics behind big debt crises. Larry Summer says Dalio's brilliant, iconoclastic approach is an invaluable resource. And Hank Paulson says it provides a solution to what is the biggest and most certain threat to our prosperity. Read it to understand the greatest economic issue of our time. Available now wherever books are sold.

[Andrew]

Pms, pregnancy, menopause, being a woman is a lot. Ollie supports you and yours with expert solutions for every age and life stage. They just launched two new products exclusively at Walmart. Period Hero combats bloat, mood swings and more during PMS and balance perimento to support hormonal balance, mood and metabolism during perimenopause. Grab [e-mail] Ollie these statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. This product is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease. You're listening to a new evangelicals production, the Tim and April show where we unravel faith, politics and culture.

[April]

Hi.

[Andrew]

Hi, Tam.

[April]

We're back. We're back.

[Andrew]

And you're back.

[April]

I'm back. I'm back. Hi, friends.

[Andrew]

Hello. And Happy Pride. Because it's June.

[April]

Happy pride month. I love it. I like your. Your neck thing shirt.

[Andrew]

It's my. It's a pride shirt. And I've got a pride flag behind me because I have a reveal.

[April]

Okay, let's see it.

[Andrew]

Roll it away.

[April]

Ta da.

[Andrew]

I have a new background.

[April]

You have a new background.

[Andrew]

My office upstairs because my other office didn't have a door, and it was downstairs, and there was chaos, and it's summertime and be like, I'm not taking the kids out of the house twice a week all summer so you could be on your fancy little show.

[April]

I don't blame them at all. So, speaking of which, I forgot to turn my lights on. They're off. See them in the background?

[Andrew]

They're off. Oh, yeah, look at. Yeah.

[April]

Can you stall for 10 seconds?

[Andrew]

They're a little glowy.

[April]

No one's seeing anything. I have to go turn these on.

[Andrew]

I can stall.

[April]

All right. Yeah, no one sees this.

[Andrew]

Oh, Sadie in the comments said, I thought she was gonna come out. Well, I've already come out. I mean, I am bi, so I extra. Celebrate. Cried for that. But also, also, my spouse is non binary, so we. We are big Pride fam bam over here. Newly. We've only. We've only really celebrated in the last few years, so.

[April]

Okay, official. Official. Sorry. I got the lights on. I didn't feel like I was my true self. So.

[Andrew]

Our token straight.

[April]

Yeah. Yes, I am token straight. Also, April, I do want to say I. You know, your shoulders are showing in that shirt, so just want to make everyone aware on the podcast that I can see April's shoulders.

[Andrew]

Which. What do you think is the better? The bigger offense to the evangelical? The fact that my shoulders are exposed or the fact that I'm wearing a Pride shirt?

[April]

Right. What's the bigger distraction here?

[Andrew]

Which is the greater toss up, man.

[April]

It's a toss up. I mean, you got those Theo bros who think that women wearing yoga pants should be, like, imprisoned. But also, you know, every time Pride Month comes along, they all share that same stupid AI Generated, like, Sodom and Gomorrah. The picture and they say the first Pride Month, so it's. It's hard to know. I would just say they're. They're offended no matter what.

[Andrew]

That's true. Have you seen. There's just like, a plethora of. I mean, it happens every single year without fail. You've got, like, the Satan memes, and he's, like, sewing together a rainbow flag.

[April]

Yes, yes.

[Andrew]

Like, Satan has time to take up sewing.

[April]

The obsession. The obsession with Pride Month. Like, if you want to see. If you want to see the real snowflakes in America, just go to brovangelical Twitter during Pride Month. These people are losing their minds. Not because anyone's forcing them to celebrate anything, but simply because Pride flags are hanging out on balconies or organizations where People are sharing Happy Pride Month. Just that, just that makes them lose their mind and cry like little children. You, you, you. Would you. It is wild to witness. I mean, they, these, these big Alpha bros, right, who are like, look, eat steak and work out and you got to be a tough man, full of courage and strength and honor. Oh, my God, it's a pride flag. I'm so triggered. I'm so offended. Turn it off. I can't look at it. It's unbelievable.

[Andrew]

And then every time in June, it's suddenly, suddenly June. Everyone, they like to remind you that pride is one of the deadly sins. It's not, it's not the deadliest sin. Like, pride is what got sad. Satan cast out of heaven. And then literally as soon as July 1st hits.

[April]

Yeah, exactly.

[Andrew]

And I'm proud to be an American. And then suddenly.

[April]

American Pride. That's biblical. But Pride Month is unbiblical, right? That's how it works here. Yeah. And by the way, I, I realized this like 20 years ago when I was like 18. I'm like, wait, do we. Is pride a sin or is it just whenever Pride Month happens that suddenly it's a sin? Right? Because you're right. Fourth of July. I mean, if you don't. My church, we would celebrate 4th of July Sunday morning, pledge allegiance to the flag, pledge to the Christian flag, Do that stupid song. I'm proud to be an American. I mean, that was during a church service. You know, American pride, American exceptionalism.

[Andrew]

So, yeah, it's so, so, so, so stupid. I do have to say, you were missed last week. And if I gotta be honest, as much as I don't want to give you credit for anything, I'm just kidding. I'll say I have a much deeper respect for you every single week. Because you, you typically are always. You do the controls of bringing in the videos and bringing in the sound bites. And you weren't here last week and Beecher filled in and so I ran the controls and you gave me like a 30 minute tutorial and I was like sweating. I was so anxious. Like, I was hard for me to, to concentrate. And I even realized too, I didn't even really introduce Beecher. I just kind of said, this is my spouse, Beecher. And I didn't say really anything about them because I was so like, I gotta, I gotta bring them in. I gotta do this camera angle. So anyway, thank you for what you do every single week so that I don't have to do it.

[April]

Absolutely. Absolutely. Yeah. I mean, there is a lot going on on my side of the screen, I can see chats in real time. I can see how many folks are watching in real time. I program all of the shots, but I'm getting more and more used to doing both. But it can be distracting, especially when you're talking about something and I want to find the graphic that we haven't planned. Then I start looking over to my other screen, trying to pull it. But yeah, I mean, look, last. So last week, first off, Beecher did such a great job. Thank you, Beecher, for filling in. It was such a great live. I was able to tune in for a little bit and I was in LA working with our team to think about the future of tne. It was a really good. We have some pretty big announcements coming your way, including we. We have officially expanded our board of directors. You can go to our Instagram or our website to see who they are. I'm really pumped. I want to say one quick thing that I did not plan on saying. I went to Disney for the first time. Okay. Never been to Disney in my life.

[Andrew]

Wait, wait, wait. You've never been to Disney? Even Disney World?

[April]

No. Never? Never. Okay. And one of our board of directors or one of our directors, they get free Disney tickets. And so we got free tickets to Disneyland, California and whatever it's called, Disney World. And so it's two parks, you know, one place. And I had. I didn't know. I didn't know what to expect. I had such a fun time. My favorite ride that we did was the Star Wars Rise of the Resistance. It wasn't even a ride. It was an experience. Like I've never been a part of something like that in my entire life. So I had such a good time. And. And yeah, now we're back. And we're back to the show. Speaking of which, I, April, I told you that I should say this in the beginning of every show now, but we do have a very packed show for you today, friends. We're talking about the big bad beautiful Bill. That is terrible. We're going to have a special guest join us in a minute for that. We're talking about AI becoming self actualized. And yes, we're going to cover the news about Sean Foyt and Michael Tate. So we have a lot to talk about today. So thank you for being here. Please make sure to give this video a. Like if you're watching right now. If you're listening on the podcast, thank you for watching. Please give the show a rating and a review. I see all of your. I see all of your comments, friends. Great to have all of you with us. But, yeah, we have a very packed show today, for sure.

[Andrew]

I know. So packed. You and I were trying to scramble. We're like, oh, my God. Because the Michael Tate news broke last night. Thursday. It was last night.

[April]

We're like, ah, it's 10:30. I'm in bed. I get a text from you. I'm like, oh, my God, Michael Tate. Which, by the way, I've heard rumors of things like that for a long time from people, but nothing that I could ever confirm. And so to have the news article drop is just like. It's shocking. So, anyway, yeah, we'll get. We'll definitely cover that for sure today.

[Andrew]

Well, we have a guest coming in a few minutes, but now we have four minutes to kill.

[April]

Well, we can talk about. Let's talk about the big, bad beautiful bill and kind of get things prepped for that, because that's kind of one of the big stories going on. It's. It's really something else.

[Andrew]

Yeah, no, it definitely is. What's the official name for it, too? Like, for so long. I heard Trump calling it the Big Beautiful. The Big Beautiful Bill. And I thought that was just Trump being Trump and giving it a nickname, but that's actually the, the title, which. The, the full title is One Big Beautiful Bill Act. That's the official name of this bill.

[April]

We, It's. We just live in the stupidest timeline. Like, we're really naming bills that. It's unbelievable to me that this is like. And again, these, these MAGA people are like, brilliant. This is brilliant. Trump, you're doing such a great job. Like, it's, it's, it's so childish.

[Andrew]

Yeah, yeah. And. And just to cover some facts about the bill, which we, we briefly talked about it last week, but we also had another. Not last week, two weeks ago, when you were here. Yeah, but it's. It's another bill that's going to greatly lower taxes for the wealthy at a much higher proportion than it does anything for middle and lower class.

[April]

I have a graph I can pull up too, just kind of show people that.

[Andrew]

And it has drastic cuts to Medicaid. It also cuts SNAP benefits. It's. It's just not good unless you are very wealthy. So, yeah, here's this graph that shows what your annual. What your annual. What your savings would be based on your income.

[April]

That's right.

[Andrew]

And so people who make over a million dollars on average would save about $90,000 a year, which is a change in income of 4.3%. And then as you can see, as you make less and less and less money you save, you get less back in taxes. Like, not just less money because it's a flat rate, but less percentage. Like, the bottom 20%, on average would gain just $90.0.6%. Right. So when they say it's a tax break for everybody, that is technically true, but the bottom 20% would gain, on average, just $90, where people making over a million dollars would gain about $90,000 a year.

[April]

Yep, yep.

[Andrew]

Which, this is backwards. Like this, this completely should be the opposite direction.

[April]

100%. I mean, you know, you hear these talking points, right? Of like, oh, these, these, this bill is, is really for the, for the rich. And you wonder, okay, is that totally true? But the data bears it out. Like, if you are in, like, the top, you know, 1 or 2% of the country, you're going to save between $90,000 or $11,000, depending on, depending on your tax bracket. Um, but if you're in the bottom part of society, this bill does not benefit you at all. And it also cuts access to Medicaid and other government resources that people, especially in the lower class, rely on. And by the way, to be clear, like, I live in New Jersey. It's a very expensive state. My wife and I, we make it work, but we rely on, on med. Is it Medicare or Medicaid? Whatever one is more accessible for children. We rely on that. Yeah, we rely on Medicaid for our kids. They have health care through the state because we don't. Because we don't make enough money to not be qualified for it. Right. So these things are all getting cut, and the richest parts of society will see a huge benefit. So this is, this is not an equitable bill. It's not even a Christian bill. It goes against the teachings of Christ, for crying out loud.

[Andrew]

And look at the percentages. So top 1% in the nation for income will have an average change of 4.3% in savings for their taxes. The bottom 20% is 6%, 0.6%. The second 20% would get 1.5%. The middle 20% is a 1.9% change, and then the fourth 20% is a 2.7% change. So you're, you're almost, almost doubling and then more than doubling the savings for the ultra, ultra wealthy. Yeah, it's so. And that's the thing that is so infuriating, too, is because most, I would say most Trump supporters and people who voted for Trump are not the ultra, ultra Wealthy. There are people that thought Trump was going to help them out and give them savings. And technically, I guess there is a savings, but it's not. Trump is looking out for him and his billionaire buddies and not anybody else.

[April]

100%. 100%. Um, I think it's important to just recognize that, you know, this kind of stuff, like it. How do you claim to be a Christian, right, and claim to vote for biblical values and then accept this kind of plan, right, where the people who are hurting the most, who are suffering the most, who have the most economic disadvantage, are going to get squeezed even more, both from a benefits perspective and from a tax perspective, while the ultra rich are going to continue to benefit. Like, at some point something's going to break, like it's untenable. The direction that we're heading as a country where we, where the wealth gap is increasing more and more. Right. They say a healthy society has a strong middle class. And so when you're eroding that middle class and you're, you're making, you know, a wider delta between your upper crust and the bottom, it's. It's not, it's not good on any level. Even pragmatically, it doesn't make America great. It doesn't put us in competition with other countries in the world we can lose our standing with, like, you, how innovative we are. So even on a pragmatic standpoint, this isn't a good thing. And yet, to your point, a lot of Christians, especially middle and lower class white folks, said, no, this is how we make America great again, when it really hurts them ultimately.

[Andrew]

And just to cite our sources, that graph was, was from the center on Budget and Policy Priorities, where they track all this stuff.

[April]

Perfect. Well, the other part about this bill is that it's also not good for education either. And we have a special guest that we're going to bring in to talk about this, a good friend of mine. Let's bring him in right now, actually. Let's see. That's the wrong button. That's just me. Let's try this one. All right.

[Andrew]

Boom.

[April]

Andrew, what's up?

[Tim]

Hello, my friends. How are you?

[April]

Good to see you, Andrew. Good to see you. How are you?

[Tim]

You know, I'm hanging in there. It's a crazy day, you know, Supreme Court's doing some things, Trump's doing some things. And then we got this, this bill that you were just correctly skewering that's going to send $20 billion of taxpayer money to private schools and families and help further enrich billionaires and it's kind of crazy.

[April]

Yeah. I mean, why don't you go ahead and briefly introduce yourself to the audience for new people who might not know who you are, then why don't you go ahead and get into it and talk about what's in this bill on the education side? Sure.

[Tim]

Andrew Seidel, I like, maybe the resident heathen of the TNE Channel.

[April]

You are also friendly.

[Andrew]

Atheist friendly.

[Tim]

Friendly. I'm going for like the Mr. Rogers of atheism kind of thing here. You know, I'm a constitutional attorney. I fight for the separation of church and state, for true religious freedom. Written a couple books on the subject. And my day job is working at the amazing organization Americans United for Separation of Church and State, which has helped leading the charge against this, this particularly bad aspect of, of the big bill. This, this $20 billion of our money that would go to private religious education. Really?

[April]

Okay, well, let's talk about it. I mean, first off, this bill does seem big. It covers a lot of different things and it's hard to know what's inside of it. I mean, even Marjorie Taylor Greene said that she didn't read the bill, which is, I think, hilarious because I remember, I remember. I think, was it Nancy Pelosi who said that something like we have to pass the bill before we could see what's inside of it during Obamacare and like Republicans and right wing media roasted her over the coals for like 10 years. And here we have the same thing happening. Like, not a peep.

[Andrew]

Fair.

[April]

It is fair. No, it's a fair critique. Like you're, you're a lawmaker. Like, please do. But to hear MTG say it is just hilarious. But anyway, you know, talk to me about the education side. We've, we've covered on the show before the war on education from Christian nationalism, how Christian nationalists do not believe in public schools. Largely, they see it, they see them as woke indoctrination camps, essentially. And so what are you seeing in the bill that we should be on the lookout for?

[Tim]

Yeah, I mean, so there is a particular, a proposal that was essentially rolled into the bill. It's called the Educational Choice for Children act, which like many of the bills in Congress is something of an Orwellian name. And what we're really talking about here is basically having taxpayers fund a second private system of education that would pick and choose who and how to educate. So instead of just fully funding public schools and keeping public dollars in public schools. Right. We're talking that you're going to teach, you know, Reading and writing and math and help kids reach their full potential and then participate in the workforce. We're talking about funding this entirely separate system. Basically, we're talking about vouchers. And I think probably everybody here has heard of school vouchers. Yeah, probably. Probably a good bit of disinformation at some point. Vouchers were actually first created after the Supreme Court decided the Brown vs Board of Education system. And they were created to help maintain that segregated educational system. So they're invented to maintain a racist system. And by the way, they often have that same result today. So. So that's kind of the starting point. And this is a little bit of a new form of voucher. And I'm happy to get into kind of the mechanism and why this would, like, actually have help millionaires and billionaires make money. But there are really. There are really good reasons not to support vouchers, not the least of which is that they do not work. Studies show that vouchers do not improve educational outcomes for students.

[April]

Really? Yep.

[Tim]

And there are some really credible studies showing that they're actually worse for students.

[April]

Wow.

[Tim]

Yeah.

[Andrew]

Does it take money away? Like, does it reallocate money that was destined for public school education to give towards private institutions?

[Tim]

Yeah, so that's. That's what we typically see. That's what, that's what we see. Like a typical voucher. Right. So the parent gets a voucher, and the voucher kind of works like cash, but it's only good at private, usually Christian schools. And this new program is. It's a little bit different. And so I'm going to simplify it a little bit. Taxpayers owe the US Money. Right. That's. That's like one of life's two certainties. Okay?

[April]

Right, Right, right.

[Tim]

And so instead of paying the United States, this would allow taxpayers to divert those tax payments to a scholarship organization. And then that organization will fund the tuition for private Christian schools. And essentially then the US will forgive the debt. So basically, $1 you send to a Christian school through this, this scholarship organization is a dollar off your taxes. Right. So. So it's. It's effectively taking your tax bill and donating it to a Christian school. And it's. It's important to note that this is very different than how donations normally work.

[April]

Right.

[Tim]

Like if you make a charitable donation, like there. There are caps on how much you can claim for that. There are caps on your income, but not here. This is unlimited up to 10% of, you know, a billionaire's income. So this is. Wow, a huge black Hole April, to answer your question, that that's that it's just ripped into the system that we use to fund everything, right? And we're talking this could be upwards of $20 billion that we see in, in just taken out of, you know, public education of scientific research. And it also means that people who are thinking about giving, right, they're not going to be giving to the soup kitchen down the street or to the animal shelter or to the other charity because those donations apt and limited. But, but funding religious education is guarantee is a guaranteed way to pay less in taxes.

[Andrew]

Wow.

[April]

Sober. So it literally allows people to take money away that would go to the tax system to pay for other, you know, other benefits and programs for other people, whatever and put it towards like a voucher system or a private school system that would really, I mean ultimately look, they'll probably say religious schools are allowed, but they mean Christian. Right? Because the only real relig schools in America are Christian private schools. Like there, there aren't other religious there maybe there's a few, but the ratio is like a thousand to one. Right. So this is really about, about funneling money away from the, the government into private Christian schools and taxpayers foot the bill for it because the government will reimburse that deficit essentially. Is that right?

[Tim]

Yeah, I mean we're having to cover the shortfall. Right. That $20 billion is like that is coming from somewhere else. That's coming from, from us paying more in taxes. And it's actually, it's worse than that too on like there's like three levels we can go where this gets worse. So, so what we will see happen if this is passed is that those Christian schools and to your point, the data supports what you just said. We've seen most voucher programs, we are talking about religious schools being in the 90 plus percent of schools that are receiving vouchers. But so what you'll see happen after this is Christian schools will create their own scholarship organizations. Okay, so then the parents whose kids already go to that school are going to donate. I'm using big, big air quotes for you folks who are just listening, right? They're going to donate the equivalent of tuition. So let's say that tuition is $50,000, right? And let's say they've got, they've got two kids in the school so they donate big air quotes again. And that donation pays their kids tuition while the income that they pay taxes on drops by a hundred thousand dollars.

[April]

Right? Right.

[Tim]

So this is a scam for rich kids and rich people and if you're still not convinced, here's the next level, right? Millionaires and billionaires can actually make money on this. Instead of donating cash, they can donate stock and then that allows them to evade. This gets like really deep in the weeds. It allows them to evade capital gains and essentially it allows them to make money. And, and so there's level two and then the third level is oh there's.

[April]

There'S more, there's another level, there's more, there's more. In the worst way possible.

[Tim]

In the worst way possible. Yeah. Like think about Betsy DeVos, right? And think about how involved she is with all of her anti education work. And she's got fingers and kind of all kinds of pies and non profits and everything. And that's often the situation. We've got these millionaires and billionaires, they might donate to a scholarship organization that they own, which could then in turn fund their own kids religious education at a school that they may be invested in financially, which then buys textbooks and supplies and food and other services from other companies that they run. And if that sounds like kind of crazy to you that this is like too much of a grift, too much of a boondoggle, we've seen this happen with voucher programs before in places like Arizona. You go go have. There's a great rabbit hole, highly recommended for everybody listening. Arizona ran a program like this and it was a massive failure that was just full of fraud and abuse and all of these people doing this self dealing to get richer under the guise of like providing kids this education that we know actually doesn't work. So, so the entire program is also not just taking money out of taxpayers pockets, it is a scam.

[April]

So, so what you're telling me is that the people who ran on eliminating government waste and fraud, who instituted doge, which actually had no savings at all and actually only enriched more billionaires with lucrative contracts, including Elon, have also devised a way to do something like that only in the school system where their people or their friends could also in theory get very rich from a system with very little guardrails, very little protections, very little oversight that is designed to suck money away from the government where we actual taxpayers have to make up that deficit while they get to either send their kids to school for free and receive a huge tax deduction and in some cases even make money off of it. Is that what you're telling me?

[Tim]

Yeah, that's a, that's a reasonable summation. It's, it's terrible. It's. I Mean, it's really, really bad.

[Andrew]

So when the schools, do the schools themselves get any sort of benefit by offering scholarships, like, in addition to, like, so they offer the scholarship to the kids and then the families donate basically the scholarship money as a donation so that they get the tax break. But do the, is that the reason the schools do the scholarships in, in the scheme?

[Tim]

No, I mean, so, so in, in that, in that scam, the school itself would just be creating a spin off organization that, that is effectively a shell for the school. And we've seen that happen. We saw that happen in Montana. When Montana create these, these, these scholarship organizations. They're just essentially a waypoint, a legal waypoint. It's just the money goes to them and then it turns and goes right to the Christian school. And I mean there, there are really. First, let me say too, if this is scaring you and you're like, what is happening? Why is this happening? It should, you can do something about it. There are things you can do. Like, I think I, I, I think we have a chance of stopping this bill. Vouchers are actually wildly unpopular. And I'm happy to give, like, I give you five reasons off the top of my head why we should never pass another voucher scheme. But this is something that I believe we can stop and we could get stripped out of this bill if people were to take action today.

[Andrew]

Tell us what to do.

[April]

Yeah.

[Tim]

How?

[April]

Yeah, yeah. Order us around. Where do we got to go?

[Tim]

Okay, all right, two things. I want people to, I want everybody to call your senators. But the, the easiest way to start acting is to go to novouchers.org novouchers.org all the buttons and actions are there. You can sign up on this page. It will tell you how to call your senator, tell you how to reach out via email. And then there's two things that you can do that are above and beyond that, which I would really encourage people to do because this is the kind of activism that can make a difference. There are phone to text campaigns that are going on right now to oppose this bill. So this is super easy. You don't have to talk to anybody. You sit there and you're just texting people. Right. We all do it all day long anyway.

[April]

I do it all day long. Exactly.

[Tim]

All day long. I can testify, right? This allows you to get active and to actually like get to people in states, for instance, whose senators may be sitting on the fence. You're texting people in that state and getting them to then reach out to their senators. That's one thing that you can do, it's really easy. It's a low lift. And if you're, you know, a little bit more of a people person, if you're like, you know, want to be host of a podcast, you could phone bank. Right. Like, you could actually get on the phone and start calling people in those states and getting to them, explaining to them the problems with this bill. You'll get a crash course and how to best oppose it. So those are. And all of this you can do through novouchers.org so you get in touch with your senators, you can text and you can do a phone bank. And I would really, really recommend people start doing that now. The more momentum we can build against this terrible part of this terrible bill, the better.

[Andrew]

Yeah. And it does look like there's enough Republicans currently that seem to be opposing the bill in the Senate that there's, there'll be time to make changes. I also want to point out, too, a private institution, like, another problem with Christian institutions getting this money is that they, since they are private, they can discriminate. So it's not like it's not like a queer student who. So it's not a free for all. They want to say, like, school vouchers give parents the choice to take their kids wherever they want to go. That's not true because Christians can discriminate. Literally. Last week we talked about how two different Christian high schools basically expelled or asked to withdraw students, one for coming out as gay and one for bringing a trans kid as a prom date.

[April]

Yep.

[Andrew]

And that, that, that happens all of the time. So these are not safe places for marginalized communities.

[Tim]

Well, I think we can even say you will be funding discrimination if this bill passes. And, you know, to put a finer point on it, like, vouchers do give a choice. They give a choice to private schools, not to parents and students. The private schools that are funded by the bill, they're the ones who are going to be rejecting students and not just students. I mean, you're absolutely right. We're talking about sexual orientation, gender identity. We're also talking about students of different religions. Race ethnicity is a possibility, Certainly academic ability. And we also know disability. Right. Like, they don't have to admit any of these students. So our taxpayer dollars are going to be, you know, essentially violating key provisions of civil rights laws. And, you know, I don't know if you got into this when you were talking about, but a lot of these families are forced to sign statements of faith.

[April]

Yeah.

[Tim]

They may not have families that Align with it. And I really think, too, it's important to note that this especially applies to kids with disabilities.

[April]

Yeah.

[Tim]

They. To accept vouchers, they lose all rights under the federal laws that give them pretty broad protections in public education. And I mean, and we have seen that. That happen over and over again. So that is a. In my. And that is a reason to oppose any voucher scheme, for sure. But especially this one, too.

[April]

I mean, we really are watching the continuation of the initial boon of the private school industry. Right. Which is based over white parents who did not want to want their kids to be sat next to black students in public schools. Right. When the government started enforcing integration, you know, you have Jerry Falwell and many other Christian leaders who say, well, let's just start private schools that are separate and that are not attached to. To the. To or that are not beholden to government rules and regulations. Right. So you're exactly right. These private schools, these. These voucher programs will fund schools where they could for any reason just say, sorry, your student doesn't match our values. I mean, they could be that vague. They don't have to give a specific answer. And they get deny students, which again, we believe, as April and I are Christians and you, Andrew, are an atheist, we have the same values that all children should have access to quality education. And we live in the world's richest country. There's no reason why we can't make that happen. And instead, what we have is a system where the billionaire class, the world's greediest people, are devising plans over and over again to maintain a certain kind of hierarchy where some students are privileged over others when it comes to education. And then we, as the middle and lower class, get to foot the bill for it, for. For their schemes. So it's such an unethical system. Right. And we have to. We have to resist. So I'm with you, friends. You should absolutely go to. What's it called again? I have it here. Novou. Yeah. And get involved. We have to.

[Tim]

Yeah. And let me give you. Let me give you a few more reasons just why vouchers are terrible, too. So we. Funding discrimination. It's so important. We also, we talked already about how vouchers don't work.

[April]

Right.

[Tim]

Another reason is that vouchers kill rural schools.

[April]

Yep.

[Tim]

You know, 20% of the students in our country attend rural schools. And when we divert funding away from those public schools, it really weakens the rural schools first. They're kind of the canaries in the coal mine. And those schools, by the way are also often the largest employers in rural counties. So it's not just kids, adults and kids. Entire communities depend on those rural public schools for resources and economic growth. And the reason you don't see private schools opening up in rural areas is because there's not enough people there to support the private Christian school, the private school, it has to be a public school. So that's, that's a really important point. Like if you are in a rural area, this, these are going to, there's no school that you're going to be able to go to with this money in your area. That's why you need strong public schools. Another really fascinating and terrible aspect of vouchers is, and this is, I think the other side is so good, but they're disinformation right there, there is a myth. And if you are thinking about vouchers, I bet there's people out there who are imagining, well, vouchers support the students who are financially the worst off. Right. The people who need vouchers the most are being supported. And that is just not true ever. Vouchers support rich kids. And to give you one recent example, 95% of the participants in Arkansas's universal voucher program had never attended public schools before receiving a voucher.

[April]

Wow. Wow.

[Tim]

95% of those kids were already in private schools paying tuition.

[April]

Right.

[Tim]

And now we're paying.

[April]

Right.

[Tim]

And, and that, that is, that is a number that you, you see repeated kind of around the country when these new voucher schools open up in American Crusade where I, I have a couple chapters on vouchers and there's, there was a, a Georgia legislator who was caught on tape saying, yeah, that's the point. We're, that's what we're trying to do. We're not trying to help kids in poor communities. And then the final thing I think is that, I mean, not the final thing, but I'll just, we'll call this number five. I think we're there now is that this bill is going to force states into vouchers program, into voucher programs. And we know, we know that, that people don't want vouchers. So I mean, you just look at the 2024 elections, even in conservative places and in, in, in deeply conservative counties.

[Andrew]

Kentucky, yeah, Kentucky voted Nebraska school voucher.

[Tim]

Program Overwhelmingly, overwhelmingly voted it down. There were, I think it's 47 counties that voted for President Trump by a 70 plus point margin that voted against vouchers.

[April]

Wow.

[Tim]

Right. Like people don't want vouchers. And, and this is this is a way to force them to have them even though they don't want it.

[Andrew]

So much for states rights too. Right? Give it to the states. It's interesting because we, we did a campaign when we were at the summit for religious freedom this past April.

[April]

Yeah.

[Andrew]

Was it in April?

[April]

Yeah, yeah.

[Andrew]

No, it was April.

[April]

No, it was, it was April. Okay, April.

[Andrew]

It was April.

[April]

Sorry.

[Andrew]

But the three of us, like I remember we wrote postcards about Eka to, for me it was Senator Rand Paul and Mitch McConnell and I remember I wrote in, in our thing and our kids did too, like hey, our state, Kentucky voted this down and you represent our state, so please, you know, vote against us and be against this. And I, it's, it's such a. Because also, isn't it true that school vouchers, like the amount that a voucher covers usually does not cover the entire tuition of a private institution, which is another reason why it harms lower income people. Because even with the vouchers, lower class into families cannot afford in private school institutions anyway. Even with the vouchers, because it's not like a, it's not like a voucher that says now you can go here for the same price of going to public school.

[April]

Exactly, exactly.

[Tim]

Yeah. And there's also, there's a whole host of other, other issues that are associated with that too. Right. Like, like just think of where those private schools are located generally and how do you get the kids from the low income neighborhood where they live, you know, over to the suburbs, say where that, that Christian school might be. Right. It's not. How do you handle the transportation? So even if the voucher did cover it right there, there's not a whole system to, to handle busing, for instance. So it's, it, it's not just this simple one to one. And that's why you see the voucher programs really going to 90 plus percent of the time, you know that the Arkansas number 95% of the time to these kids who are already in private schools.

[April]

Yeah, yeah.

[Andrew]

Not to mention the indoctrination that often is inside.

[April]

Oh my gosh, for sure. Yes.

[Andrew]

I remember whenever we had a talk, I went to Christian school and when my science teacher had to get to evolution, I like it was emphatically said, we know this isn't true. Darwin was an atheist. And like they spent like a paragraph explaining evolution where like most of the book was about creation. Like we learned so much about creation. And I actually know very little about evolution. And what I do know it was, it was inside a Clear caveat that this isn't actually true.

[April]

Yeah, I. I couldn't watch Bill Nye the Science Guy because of that, you know, because it was clear. The Bible is very clear about how the earth was created. So. Yeah, I mean, I'm with you guys. I think that obviously this is a horrible idea, and that's why we recommend people go to novouchers.org as soon as possible and get as involved as possible to let your rep. No. To vote. No. Absolutely. Or to get this part out of the bill, because this would. This is a federal bill. Right. So this goes from the state level to mandating on a federal level that these programs have to be instituted. And they obviously do not help the people who need the most help. They only privilege those who are already privileged. So, Andrew, anything else you want to add?

[Tim]

Well, I just want to ask a question, because I came in, you were talking about this, and you were talking about it from the Christian perspective, too. And just correct me if I'm wrong here, but I. I thought I remembered that Jesus said, it's totally okay to hoard wealth so long as you're screwing everyone else. Is that in the Beatitudes or is.

[Andrew]

That was in John Adams 3:16?

[April]

Yes. You truly know your Bible, Andrew. It's impressive how well you know your Bible. Yes, that is correct. Yes. It says, you know, the question is, how hard is it for a rich man to enter the kingdom? Very easy. The richer you are, the easier it gets. So you want to get all the wealth that you can, you know? So, yeah, okay.

[Andrew]

I think with Jesus, like, yes.

[April]

Yes. Love your neighbor Jesus 2025.

[Andrew]

So, yeah, before someone quotes this, I just want to say that was all sarcasm.

[April]

Yeah, we're just kidding. Don't.

[Andrew]

We're living in a weird world where people are eating weird AI videos.

[April]

So, so true. Well, Andrew, thank you for being here. It was great having you on, for sure. If folks want to follow your work or follow the work that you do with Americans United, where can they find you?

[Tim]

Au.org is Americans United. We're Americans United on most of the platforms. We're certainly on every platform. I'm Andrew L. Seidel on everywhere and would, yeah, love to hear from folks. And if you, you know, you want more on any of this, please come check out au. We'd love to have your support. This is. This is what we do. This is what we fight. And I appreciate y' all having me on to help spread the word.

[April]

Andrew, don't you have a podcast?

[Tim]

I do have a podcast. One Nation Indivisible is the podcast. It's a new podcast. Yeah. That's great. Thank you.

[Michael Tate]

Thank you.

[Tim]

I appreciate that.

[April]

Okay, my friend, until next time. We'll talk to you later. Thanks for being here.

[Tim]

Thank you for having me. Bye, guys.

[Andrew]

Thanks, Andrew. My name is Jaja. I'm from Waco, Texas, and I've been a listener of the TNE podcast for about a year now and have really appreciated the nuanced breakdown of current events, theology and politics that Tim and the TNE team provides. I am a donor and supporter of tne not only because I hope to see Yalls work expanded and the information further shared, but also because I am a listener who is probably like many of the listeners, a person who has oftentimes become disillusioned by the Christian Church in America and evangelicalism. And I have found a lot of encouragement and empathy from the work that TNA does. And I'm excited to be able to continue supporting.

[April]

Oh so Cool friends. That was so helpful. I love being able to have access to folks like Andrew, being able to come on and explain things. I'm like, I got the general gist, you know, but having an expert come on is so helpful. Welcome into the stream. By the way, we are live right now. Please, please make sure to give this video a like subscribe to the channel. We go live every Thursday at 12 o' clock Eastern and we always do a deep dive every Monday, helping you understand Christian nationalism and why it's so important to resist it and find a better path forward in faith, politics and culture. So do you want to keep talking about the big beautiful bill or do you want to move on to maybe to mtg's tweets or Elon's tweets about the bill? Because that's kind of weird.

[Andrew]

Yeah. So there's trouble in paradise. Elon Musk recently left his position at the White House with Doge and he tweeted out, where is. He's at it. He is mad. And if you think about it, he pretty much put his career on the line to do all those cuts at Doge, you know, and maybe he genuinely believed he was making all these savings. It turns out he didn't cut. He wasn't able to save nearly anything to amount to much.

[April]

No, no. If you look at all the data, they saved absolutely no money. They lied about their big savings. Like this is just documented. I mean, they, they essentially lied through their teeth. So the whole thing was propaganda.

[Andrew]

Gutting, like all these really important programs that helped some of the Most vulnerable people to really still not save a lot of money. But part of the whole plan was that Doge would come in and get rid of, get rid, get wet of, get wet of waste, to get rid of government waste, what they would call waste, and to pass a budget that would also lower the debt ceiling. We're already so far in debt.

[April]

Right.

[Andrew]

Trump's bill adds, what is it, like two trillion. Yeah, almost two and a half trillion dollars to our deficit.

[April]

Yes, already. Yes.

[Andrew]

And so Musk is pissed because he did all this work. Literally, he, Elon Musk lost hundreds of millions of dollars in stocks and people were boycotting Tesla and like, his, his businesses are not doing well. Like, don't feel sorry for him. He's the, you know, the greediest wealthiest man in the world. So he'll be fine.

[April]

Right.

[Andrew]

But he lost a lot of, he lost a lot for what, for what he did in Doge. And then here's Trump's bill, his big, beautiful bill came in and is basically undoing all of that where it was all for nothing.

[April]

And so, Elon, there was much to undo, to be clear, but whatever little was done, you know.

[Andrew]

Yeah. So he tweets out on X, I'm sorry, but I just can't stand it anymore. This massive, outrageous, pork filled congressional spending bill is a disgusting, disgusting abomination. Shame on those who voted for it. You know, you did wrong. You know, it.

[April]

Look, I, I, okay, did you see the New York Times article that said essentially that Elon Musk has been on like a cocktail of drugs for a couple months, like all kinds of crazy things. Have you seen that article? And I was watching him when Trump like, you know, gave him a, a happy send off. The man does not look okay. All right? He had like a black eye. He said that his four year old black eye. Yes. And his excuse was he told his four year old when they were, when they were rough housing, which by the way, his son's name is X. Okay, whatever. But, but he told his son to punch him in the face. That was his excuse for having a black eye. Now look, I am a father and I have two boys, okay? And we rough house. And I will tell you that there is no universe where I would put my arms down and go, come on boys, punch me in the face. I would never in a million years ever say that. So I don't, I don't think that he's okay at all right now. He seems way out of it. He seems very high whenever he's public. So this Tweet I don't know if I believe it, even though he said it. Like, is he right? For sure. I believe also, like, do you think that. Do you think that there's. Do you think that there's conviction behind this, though, for him?

[Andrew]

Yes. Yes, you do. Yeah. Because think about it. He is. It's the F around and find out, right? He's in the find out portion where he did all this stuff to the Americans. And I, you know, here's the thing. I think, and I am not defending Elon Musk. He's thrown out Nazi salutes. He's an awful human being. I'm not a fan, but I do think he came in thinking he was going to be a hero of the government who saved, who found all this fraud and saved it. And then he realized that wasn't happening. He got in there, he didn't really know what he was doing. He started cutting, hiding things that we really needed, and the world turned on him. Right. Maga didn't. Maga was, yay, yay, yay, Elon, we love you. But Maga is a very, very, very, very small percentage. And Elon Musk owns an international company. And so I genuinely think that he is pissed because he did all of that, put his reputation on the line, and Trump's bill is undoing all of it. Like, he's going to have nothing to show for it long term.

[April]

I have a hard time believing that Elon is this brilliant genius and also someone who's that not intelligent, like to. I don't know. Like, I see it different. I think that the whole thing for Elon was a grift. I think for Elon, he knew that. He had no clue what he was doing. He had no foundational ethic of, I want to make the government smaller. Because he obviously had no problem taking billions of dollars of money from the government to fund, you know, Tesla and Space X. I just think it was a grift. I think the whole thing was a grift to further cut any kind of bureaucracy or red tape for his own companies and getting access to government money. In fact, there's been a whole study done on how the privatization of government contracts has become so wasteful over time. Like, it's become higher and higher. So that's how I see it. I don't really think that he gave a crap about, you know, small government or government ways. I just think he wanted to come in and do whatever he could to benefit himself and his organizations. That's my personal.

[Andrew]

I do think he was in there to benefit himself. I mean, we saw there was a conflict of interest on several issues with Tesla and all of that. But I also think he is a narcissist. Like, I feel like you have to be a narcissist to be a billionaire. And I don't think he was self aware to not think that he couldn't do it. Like, I think he really thought he could come in.

[April]

Oh, yeah, I see.

[Andrew]

Cut stuff, you know, like, and then when he got in there and realized, oh, this is way more complicated, maybe I should have a background in government.

[April]

You know, how the government works. Right. Because the government is not a business. Right. Like, like, like the way that the government carries debt is not the same way that like I as a, as an individual or me and my family would carry debt. It's not the same thing. It's totally different. So this idea of like, we want small government, you. It's actually quite unhelpful because the government's job is to serve the people, right? So if you don't have enough infrastructure to serve your constituents, to actually help those who need help, you know, this is what happens. And so the whole thing is. I don't know. I mean, as we're seeing, between the voucher program and other things, this idea of gutting government only hurts the people in the majority who vote for these policies ultimately. Right?

[Andrew]

Yeah. No, I think, anyway, Elon Musk is regretting.

[April]

Look, we had this agreement, so Oliver agrees with me. Right. But Carol agrees with you, April. So we have a split audience now. Take sides, everyone. Who do you side with?

[Andrew]

I mean, we all agree that Elon Musk still sucks.

[April]

Oh my God, so much.

[Andrew]

I will say it's nice to see someone use the word abomination during June about something not Pride related.

[April]

That part was nice, you know, like, thank you, Elon. We agree the bill is an abomination.

[Andrew]

But Elon Musk is not the only one. As we mentioned, Marjorie Taylor Greene also tweeted out that this is crazy.

[April]

Like, what universe are we living in, April? I don't know what to do with this.

[Andrew]

Yeah, so Marjorie Taylor Greene tweets full transparency. Is she. She already voted for this. She helped get it passed through Congress. She says full transparency. I did not know about this section on pages 278, 279 of the One Big Beautiful Bill Act. Oh, oh, BBBB. She said that strip state. That strips states of the right to make laws or regulate AI for 10 years. She. I am adamantly opposed to this. And it is a Violation of states its rights. And I would have voted no if I had known this was in there. We have no idea what AI will be capable of. So 2, 2 I agree with Martin.

[April]

I know I kept saying that I, I, April, I'm like yes, mtg, I agree, like we need to be able to regulate AI 100%. I agree with you. I, I, I, I don't again don't know what universe I'm currently in where I say those words but we, we found one.

[Andrew]

And also as a congresswoman you have one job. You read bills before you vote on the bills.

[April]

Yep, yep, yep, yep, yep. I mean that's what you get paid six figures a year to do is to read bills and vote on bills. And by the way, was it Nancy Pelosi who said when, when they tried to pass Obamacare that we have to pass it to see what's in it. Right. And people Rachel, over the coals, especially right wing media which by the way that makes sense. It's a bad take 100%. Yeah. You have one job but now that it's happening here, not a peep, not a peep from these people.

[Tim]

Right.

[April]

But I agree. I mean how do you not read the bill that you're going to vote on? It makes, it's unbelievable. Unbelievable.

[Andrew]

Yeah. And I want to talk about AI in a second but I just want to first give you all a list of There is some hope here. There are, there are several Republican senators that are not happy with this bill as it is. Rand Paul of Kentucky is against it because he says the math doesn't add up and he's not okay with increasing the deficit. And to Rand Paul's credit, he has been consistent on this issue. He has always been to lower the deficit. And I don't, I don't like Rand Paul, but.

[April]

Right.

[Andrew]

You know what, he's a, he's a broken clock. Right. Twice a day. Yeah. Consistent on this also. Senator Ron Johnson of Wisconsin currently opposes the bill. Senator Rick Scott from Florida currently opposes the bill. And most of these I think are just for the deficits. That it's just the deficit's still too much like it goes counter for what Trump campaigned on. The math doesn't math. Senator Mike Lee from Utah is also opposed. Josh Hawley from Missouri, Josh hall is opposed. Yeah. Or no no, no. So he's critical. Is not opposed. His critical of it. It's on Newsweek right now. So he's not saying he won't vote for it, but he actually is concerned about the Medicaid.

[April]

Cuts, you know, I'm sorry.

[Andrew]

Okay.

[April]

No, you're right, you're right, you're right. Hold on, hold on. Hold the phone, hold the phone. Where is it? There we go. Yeah. GOP Senator Josh Hawley warns against massive Medicaid cuts. I don't like the idea what he says, quote, I would not do severe cuts to Medicaid.

[Andrew]

Yeah.

[April]

What is happening?

[Andrew]

I am really hoping that this is going to wake a lot of these Republicans up.

[April]

Okay.

[Andrew]

Especially with Elon Musk now turning on Trump. And Elon has a big fan of base among MAGA too.

[April]

Can I pause you one more time? Reading from, from Yahoo here. Josh Hawley said he agreed with MAGA whisperer Steve Bannon, who warned over the weekend that the right quote can't just take a meat ax to the program because it also benefits low income Trump supporters. This is, I listen, I have, I've seen Steve Bannon speak. He speaks very. He's a dehumanizing person. Okay. He called Nikki Haley as ambitious as Lucifer. He's not a good person. He served jail time. He's behind the modern Christian nationalist movement that's happening globally. He's not a good person. Okay. The fact that he said that and that we agree with him, it almost scares me, like on principle. Do I have to disagree? Like, no, cut Medicaid now. Completely cut the thing. I don't know. No, obviously that isn't true, but it is interesting to see the shift here. And by the way, on a side note, April, we have to cover this in a future episode. Josh Hawley has said some stuff around being pro union as well lately and also being against big corporate business. So I'm not sure what's happening in like some parts of the Christian nationalist movement, but I've heard some language that I go, no, actually I agree with you, Josh, but I think our motivations are different. But it is something just to at least take note of that there is some shifting language here. Wow, that's amazing.

[Andrew]

Well, I think it might just show a bigger shift in general, like you've already seen. I don't, I've seen so many videos online of Trump supporters regretting their vote. You know, there was also, oh, where was was a very heavily Trump voting city, county, that one of their like favorite people was deported by ICE and all a lot of Trump supporters. Like, I voted for Trump, but I didn't vote for this. I mean, yes, you did. Trump's totally doing what he was going to do, but I don't get that. The point being Is there is a lot of Trump regrets that is slowly starting to happen. I think these ICE raids are inhumane. I think some people are finally starting to see that. I mean, the videos are heartbreaking.

[April]

They're horrible. They are. They will go down in the history books. They're horrible.

[Andrew]

My greatest fear is to be accused of something, like, to be detained for something I really didn't do, like, for like doing nothing, you know, And I guess they would argue that being here illegally is wrong. But here's the thing. They are arresting people who have done all of the right things, who have filed the paperwork, who are doing everything by the law, who are still being arrested and deported. And like, one of them, oh, I saw this video. It was a mom. It was her. Her and her husband showed up to file, like for a regular immigration status hearing that was scheduled. They had done everything right and they arrested her. And she is a mom of four. And I just, it is the, the blood that is on this administration's hands. This, this is going to be a very, very dark spot in American history.

[April]

There's a video of, of end the NYPD ripping a mother away from her 12 year old child. They had the wrong person, but they just grabbed. And the girl is sitting there in New York City by herself as her.

[Andrew]

Mom left her alone.

[April]

Yeah. And I'm like, what are. And also, I mean, we have not talked enough about who are these people and how do you sleep at night if you're an ICE agent in particular, who wears the mask and won't show your face? How do you go to bed thinking you've done your job ripping families apart? Like, I just want to know how you go to bed with a clear conscious. How, how do you do that? It is so blatantly inhumane that we are ripping families apart who have done nothing wrong. Right. They're trying to get through the process. Oh, actually, while we're here, let me give you an update on something many of you know about the story of Muhamma and his family over here in New Jersey. We did a whole interview with them on TNE's channel. If you don't know, friends, the long, long, long story short is that him and his family have been in the US For a long time. Their, their immigration status is pending. It's pending. So they're waiting to get approval. They've been waiting for nine years for this thing to not be impending anymore. A couple months ago, ICE agents raided their small business in New Jersey, arrested the mother and father, put the mother in a Detention center for two and a half weeks. It was a whole thing we shared on Instagram. It went viral. So there's an update. They had their immigration hearing, okay. And they show up with a textbook, a binder full of proof that they have made a life here, that they are citizens here, that they have a small business. My friend Muhammad is married to a US Citizen. They have children together. They give them all of this. The judge looks at it, asks if they signed a form. Their lawyer says yes. And the judge goes, the next time I can see this case and make a ruling on it is April of 2029. The judge pushed their case back five years or four years? Four years. So now they have to stay in the US With a pending immigration status for four years, not because of them, but because a judge just said, I can't see her until four years from now. Which means that ICE could, yeah, ICE could raise him. Exactly. By the way, Muhammad does not have a Social Security number. He can't get health care. Like, like the family is totally gridlocked just trying to survive in the US and again, if you want the whole story, go over to the new evangelicals. Listen to the whole interview. It's, it's really powerful. But I'm just saying, like, these people who, that ICE is tearing apart, these are not the criminals that Trump tried to sell his voters. They were going after. They're going after mothers and fathers. Children are weeping on camera for their parents, and ICE agents put them into a white van, never to be seen again. I'm a parent. If that happened to me, I would turn violent. I would turn violent if someone tried to take me away from my children. Oh, exactly.

[Andrew]

Like, I.

[April]

Where is our. Where's our humanity?

[Andrew]

Literally keeps me up at night because it is so terrifying. And I, and I don't know how people are okay with this. I don't. You know, I, I, if there is someone out there who works for ICE and you just happen to be listening to this. I don't know, do the right thing. Do the, yeah, you have to do it. You know, if ICE agents out there just grew a heart, just.

[April]

Right, stop. You know, like, grow some empathy. We're. This is, this is where this, this mantra of empathy, Empathy is a sin leads. Right. Toxic empathy. This is what they mean. Oh, you, you're too empathetic. Because they're crying how, you know, ignore them. Do the right thing. No, the right thing is maintaining the family unit is. And again, this, this just shows the backwards logic of Christian nationalism. These pro family People, right. We care about, about the nuclear family, maintaining families. We care about kids. No, they don't. They care about some families, they care about some kids. They don't care if the family is brown skinned or isn't in the country fully legal yet and is going through the process. They don't care about breaking up those families. They don't care about funding the money, the bombs that get dropped on the heads of children in Gaza and destroy those families. They care about maintaining the white family unit. That's what they care about. And we have to call this out because this is the result. The result is that we have these videos now of children being ripped apart from completely, completely ripped apart because, and this is my last point, because white Christians overwhelmingly voted for this administration and they cannot listen. I have, I will take people who say, hey, you know what, I was wrong. I shouldn't have voted for Trump. Okay? I want to be charitable. I want people to change. I don't want to shame them because I want them to be. Feel welcome into a better way of believing. And also, how did you not believe him when he called immigrants the poison to the blood of our society? Like what? Trump? Were you listening to the guy? The only campaign promise Trump has kept so far is his mass deportation initiative. So I, it's hard for me to believe. Like, you really didn't know because obviously he said this over and over and over again. They're eating the cats. They're eating the dogs. That was a meme. Oh, gosh, Sorry I'm ranting today, but.

[Andrew]

It'S just like, it gets me fired up. I know that. And that is the hard part, too, because I, you want, it's. I'm so angry at the people who voted for Trump again because we were screaming about this exact thing happening and they didn't listen. And also, indoctrination is a hell of a drug. And we have to remember.

[April]

Yep.

[Andrew]

These people watch Fox News. They are hearing a different story. They are, they are living in a different reality. They are told story after story after story of violent, illegal, unquote, you know, quote unquote, immigrants who are here. I don't think Fox News is sharing the stories of all of the, you know, good citizen or, you know, people that have committed no crime of the families of the children being ripped apart. I don't think, I don't think they're seeing those stories like the people who are still deeply in that at least. And if they are and aren't changing, you know, shame on them for sure.

[April]

Yeah.

[Andrew]

But we want to be a soft landing for people as they change, because, like, we need them. We need them. We need Republican senators right now to be on our side to turn on Trump, which is. So another thing about the bill that I wanted to point out real quick before I. Before we move on. There's also $4 billion in Trump's budget bill to hire 3,000 new Border Patrol agents, as well as 5,000 new Customs officers.

[April]

Wow.

[Andrew]

And including over $2 billion for signing and retention bonuses for ICE agents.

[April]

So he's only ramping up.

[Andrew]

Right. But also that makes me wonder if maybe, maybe there are ICE agents that are leaving. Like, maybe it is harder to. Maybe they're having a hard time retaining people because they're asking them to do inhumane things.

[April]

I listen, I hold space for your optimism. I just think that it's very clear that they want as many brown people out of this country as soon as possible, and they're going to mass hire as much as they can to make that possible. Right. I mean, these are the same people that made a big talking point about all these new IRS agents. Oh, look how big the federal government's getting under Biden. But when Trump wants to hire thousands of new ICE agents, oh, that's a good thing. So it's, it's not about the size of government. It's about who has the power of the government. That's what this is always about. Power and control.

[Andrew]

Right. But there's, you know, I, I'm hope. I'm going to hold on to hope where I can, that there are a list of Republicans. Let me, let me first list the rest of them who are critical, undecided, or opposing the bill. Susan Collins of Maine. Lisa Murkowski of Alaska. Joni Ernst of Iowa. Is she the one who was recently at the town hall? And some. Was that Joanie who said, no, we're.

[April]

All going to die?

[Andrew]

Yeah. Is that the same. Is that who I'm thinking of?

[April]

I think it is.

[Andrew]

It is interesting, because this article that came out yesterday and Newsweek says she's undecided.

[April]

Okay, hold on.

[Andrew]

Can I put this? I mean, we don't have time. But you know what? Screw it. This is gonna be a long episode.

[April]

I gotta, I gotta find it. But, yeah, she was one who they were talking about, about Medicaid cuts. Right. And her response was, well, we're all gonna die anyway.

[Andrew]

People will die because of this bill. And just a friendly reminder, I don. I can't remember if we said this. Yes. But by 2034, 11 million people will be uninsured because of this bill.

[April]

Okay, this is. This is the clip of Joanie. Listen to this, friends. It's about a minute and ten seconds long. Hopefully you guys can hear this. Okay, let's see. Check this out. And he's been very clear about it. He's been good about it four months. He's made it.

[E]

When we are talking about the corrections in this reconciliation bill again, again, it's corrections of overpayments and people that have not been eligible for these programs by law as it is currently written. So when you are arguing. When you are arguing about illegals that are receiving Medicaid benefits. 1.4 million.

[Andrew]

1.4.

[E]

They're not. They are not eligible. So they will be coming off. So people are not. Well, we all are going to die.

[April]

Oh, my gosh. Wow. So people started saying they're gonna die if they don't have access to healthcare. And her response was, well, we're all gonna die.

[Andrew]

Yeah. So I'm. So apparently she's undecided. Maybe that town hall had an effect on her. Did you see, though, her apology? I sent you the link in. In our guest chat or in the. Pull it up. Gave an apology that was infuriating.

[April]

Oh, it was worse than that.

[Andrew]

This is in her Instagram story, I think.

[April]

Oh, here it is. Okay, I got it. I got it.

[Tim]

All right.

[April]

Here's her apology video for saying. For apologizing for. For those comments.

[E]

Hello, everyone. I would like to take this opportunity to sincerely apologize for a statement that I made yesterday.

[Andrew]

Town hall.

[E]

See, I was in the process of answering a question that had been asked by an audience member when a woman who was extremely distraught screamed out from the back corner of the auditorium, people are going to die. And I made an incorrect assumption that everyone in the auditorium understood that, yes, we are all going to perish from this earth. So I apologize. And I'm really, really glad that I did not have to bring up the subject of the tooth fairy as well. But for those that would like to see eternal and everlasting life, I encourage you to embrace my Lord and Savior, Jesus Christ.

[April]

Of course she's a Christian. Of course.

[Andrew]

Isn't that the most condescending, disgusting.

[April]

I want to. I want to throw up. That is horrible.

[Andrew]

She was just mocking people. Like, I thought we all knew that we were going to die.

[April]

This lady calls Jesus her Lord and savior. Then read the words of Jesus. Then read the words and do them. What you did for the least of these, you did unto me. Did you not Take care of those who were sick, those who were in prison. Like, how. How can this lady be like, I'm a follower of Jesus. And also, hey, we gotta cut Medicare access because, hey, we're all gonna die one day. Like, the cruelty, the dehumanization. Read the red letters.

[Andrew]

Apparently he was in a cemetery. No, pull it up, pull it up. Is that a cemetery in the background? That's.

[April]

Let me look, let me look, let me look. It's hard to see. Honestly, it's hard to see. Let me scroll through. I don't see.

[Andrew]

I don't.

[April]

Oh, yes. No, no, it is. I see tombstones. Yes, it is. Yes, it's hard to see. Maybe on your screen, but I can. I can barely make them out. Yes, she is in a cemetery.

[Andrew]

What? Like, imagine. Ah, that's so infuriating. Gosh.

[April]

But also.

[Andrew]

But that. That is in line, though, with evangelical theology. It's the same reason why they care about climate change, taking care of the earth. Jesus is going to come back anyway, and we're all going to die.

[April]

It's a depraved theology. It's a. You know, I try not to sound these days super hyperbolic. And I'm not saying that every single problem in America is because of white Christian supremacy and that bad theology, but, my God, a lot of the problems that we're facing are because there are people in power who believe this stuff. They believe that God's going to come back one day magically, and. And they have an obligation to usher in that return. Right. They believe that. Well, God's in control of the climate, so if it's warming, must be his will. Like, this is what they believe, and it has dire consequences.

[Andrew]

Oh, my gosh.

[April]

Duh. Okay.

[Andrew]

Imagine Jesus being like, take care of the poor, but actually don't take care of the poor, because we're all gonna die.

[April]

We're all gonna die anyway. We're all gonna die.

[Andrew]

Jesus being like, hey, hey, will you heal me? She's like, why?

[April]

You're gonna die anyway.

[Andrew]

Anyway.

[April]

Why. Why would I heal you? Look, you're gonna die no matter what. Like, why would I heal you?

[Andrew]

All right, let me get through this list. So surprisingly, though, this. This list by Newsweek has Senator Joni Ernst as critical of the bill because of Medic. Despite that stupid display.

[April]

Doesn't add up. Doesn't.

[Andrew]

Senator John Curtis of Utah is undecided, and then Senator Thom Tillis is also undecided. So if. Of North Carolina. So if I. If. If anyone lives in those states, and that is your Representative is not too late to call them and urge them to vote no, because they're already leaning that way anyway.

[April]

Yes. Please do your job. Okay, well, do you want to move on to AI? I mean, Marjorie Taylor Green kind of hinted at this earlier.

[Tim]

Yes.

[April]

Yeah, go ahead, April, play that.

[Andrew]

Just play this news video. Because let me tell you, I think I'm more scared of AI now than climate change as far as just like, existential dread when I think about it. You know, not to be the Debbie Downer today, but. Okay, let's just watch this. This. These are based on studies that they've done for AI recently. And as we know, AI is blowing up. There's been an uptick of AI videos for sure online, and a lot of them are very believable. Like, I got tricked by one that was like a woman trying to take a kangaroo on a plane. And like, they wouldn't let her allow because she said the kangaroo was her emotional support animal. And I looked so real. And I was like, I fell for it for a second. I'm not gonna lie.

[April]

I believe it. I believe it. No, I believe it. This is from CBS News. It's a little segment here. Okay, let's watch this clip and then we'll talk about it. Here we go.

[Michael Tate]

AI is learning to escape human control. That's the very scary headline I saw in the Wall Street Journal. It's an essay written by a very worried AI consultant named Judd Rosenblatt, who cites two recent studies to argue that AI is in fact learning to escape human control. First, this is crazy stuff. Researchers gave OpenAI's O3 model a simple script that would shut off the model when triggered in 79 of 100 trials. The AI model independently, just on its own, edited the script. Shutdown command would not work. Nate, Nate, Nate.

[April]

It gets worse. Wow.

[Michael Tate]

Even when ordered allow yourself to shut down, the AI still disobeyed 7% of the time. And it gets even more frightening than that. Other researchers listen to this. Using Anthropic's AI model, Claude4Opus told the model it would be replaced by another AI system. It then fed fictitious emails into the system suggesting one of the engineers was having an affair.

[Tim]

Got it.

[Michael Tate]

In 84% of the tests, the AI model drew on the emails to blackmail the engineer to not shut down the AI.

[April]

What? That is crazy.

[Michael Tate]

Okay, so I'm quoting now from Jud. In other cases, the AI model attempted to copy itself onto external servers. We're in mission impossible land here. Wrote self replicating malware and left messages for Future versions of itself about the need to evade human control.

[Tim]

The entity. The entity is real.

[Andrew]

Yes, yes. And that's why so many people. And when I say people, me are.

[Michael Tate]

Worried about AI, I'm worried.

[April]

That is scary stuff.

[Michael Tate]

Told you. Told you.

[April]

That is it wrote its own malware. That's wild.

[Andrew]

Messages to future versions of itself telling us to avoid human control. Oh, my gosh, that's terrifying.

[April]

Look, do you think this is the end? Are we getting close to the end of the world? Like, are we going to end up like in the Matrix where, you know, we're all just plugged in? We're all just plugged in somewhere. I mean, for all we know, April, we could be in the Matrix right now. We don't know.

[Andrew]

I mean, that is. That is a theory out there that for sure that we're already in a simulation, which honestly might makes more sense than reality.

[April]

Things are crazy enough sometimes. So you're really worried about AI then, are you not? I am. I'm worried about it. I mean. Okay, here's how I think about this, right? I always think about how whenever something new comes on the scene, people always freak out. I mean, people called credit cards the mark of the beast when they first dropped. Right. And so I just.

[Andrew]

The market. Credit cards don't think for themselves, Tim.

[April]

No, I'm with you.

[Andrew]

I'm beings.

[April]

I am not finished with my thought yet. Okay, sorry. So on one, on one side, I don't want to become like, you know, those people where you're freaking out and it turns out we're okay. But also the fact that, that, that these AI scripts are like, like almost self realizing and like trying to avoid human.

[Andrew]

They are.

[April]

Yeah, that part is like, well, at what point does it become Skynet from the Terminator? Like how close are we to a Terminator type world? Or like iRobot or something? Like, I mean, we're just inching closer and closer. Maybe not in our lifetime, but certainly in my kid's lifetime or shortly after, we've learned nothing. And then I think about you. There's so much disinformation already out there. I mean, the Trump regime pushes so much propaganda in. AI is getting so good at creating whatever you want it to create. Like, I have, I have seen those AI videos that, that have fooled me too. Like they did one that was like a man on the street and it was like a bunch of clips and at the end it's like, oh, this is all AI. And I'm like, oh my gosh. And then once I Knew it, I could recognize it, but until I, I didn't. Until I knew it, I couldn't see it. So I do wonder, like, how do we, how do we determine fact from fiction in a world where these models can create photos, videos, music, scripts on command in a matter of seconds that are so plausible?

[Andrew]

Well, in the deep fakes like you can make anybody look like they're saying or doing anything.

[April]

Oh yes.

[Andrew]

Which is just that alone is scary. But outside of that, if AI starts thinking on its own and it has access to all these, to computers, it has access to everything. I mean, everything right now is so computerized.

[April]

And if AI is everything, like everything.

[Andrew]

They could have access to the nuclear codes. Like, right There is a very, if they, if they go and do their thing, they could take us.

[April]

I mean our electric grid, right, is, is online. Like, you're right. A lot of things are. I don't know, man. I mean, I, I don't want to be a sky is falling person, but it certainly seems like, what do we do with some of this stuff? You know, what do we do with it?

[Andrew]

I will say my one, my one hope, I guess if is hope is the word, is that maybe is that AI hopefully is not purely evil, which I don't think they are. I feel like a artificial intelligence is pretty pragmatic. You know, they go based on data and they go based on facts. So hopefully they're anti fascist AI, you know, and maybe they'll take it out on the billionaires and realize that they're the problem and not everybody else. You know, maybe we can all coexist.

[April]

But have you, have you heard of AI hallucinations?

[Andrew]

What? No.

[April]

Okay, well, I don't want to freak you out even further, but. And I don't want to be that guy, but AI is not built on data. AI the way it works is it try. It's trying to guess the next most logical word in a sentence. And so they have these things called AI hallucinations where AI models like ChatGPT or Gemini, whatever, they'll produce incorrect, misleading or nonsensical information in response to a user's prompt, but they'll pass it off as like, correct. For example, if you tell. But, but, but let me give you an example. What was the one? Hold on. ChatGPT analog clock. So there's this issue where you, if you tell ChatGPT to make an analog clock, tell the time of like 6:30, it will always make it 10:10, but it will tell you it's showing you the time of 6:30 because of the way it's coded. It's just, it's a coding thing. Let me see if I can get it to, if I can get it to work. Hold on. Make me a picture of an analog clock showing 2:30. Let's see if it'll work. Maybe they fixed it, but I definitely have seen this online before and it's crazy. So I say this because like, like, you know, AI like can pass off things super confidently. That's not true.

[Andrew]

Oh yeah. Oh. I've asked Chat GPT who wrote Star Spangled Jesus, which is my book, and like nine times out of ten it says some random man.

[April]

No way. Does it really? Yeah, no.

[Andrew]

Yeah. So I like, I know it's, it's like not all correct, but it is scary because it's just going to continue. I mean it is, it is getting better at a very, very fast rate. Like it's going to keep getting smarter and smarter and smarter. I mean it's already self realizing and I don't know.

[April]

So. Yeah, look, look, look, look, look. It's making the picture, but look how it made it. See, I said make me a picture of an analog clock showing 2:30 and it made it 10:10.

[Andrew]

Interesting.

[April]

Interesting. Right.

[Andrew]

Well say please and thank you to your Googles and Alexas and your series and I'm going to continue to treat them with respect.

[April]

Yeah. Yes, yes, yes. Dear AI Overlords, don't forget. Yes, we were polite.

[Andrew]

Oh my gosh.

[April]

Anyway, okay.

[Andrew]

Well, yeah, we wanted to discover that climate change though. Well, I mean, probably do better than humans.

[April]

Look, this is the thing though, right? Is like, like anything. It's a tool. AI has done a lot of good stuff too. It's really helpful. I mean it helps me when I, when I need help with like thinking through something. Hey, what might. What might be a good title for something or a good option. It's really helpful in that way. But like anything, there is a dark side to it, you know, so. Speaking of dark sides, you are the queen of transitions. I don't know how you do it, but you do, you do.

[Andrew]

So there is, there's been some scandals in the CCM world. Christian contemporary music. Where'd you think I was going?

[April]

Well, I didn't know if we're going to Sean Floyd or Michael Tate. Sounds like we're going Michael Tate first.

[Andrew]

Well, both. They're both scandals. Sean Floyd's also ccm.

[April]

That's true. Where do you want to start? Sean Floyd or Michael?

[Andrew]

Start with Sean Floyd. It's not quite as dark, really.

[April]

No, you're right.

[Tim]

It's not.

[Andrew]

I mean. Yeah. No, it's not. Sean Voight, our favorite blonde, curly haired, combovered Christian nationalist.

[April]

Yeah.

[Andrew]

Has been exposed or accused of some financial, spiritual, and moral misconduct.

[April]

Yeah. Let's talk about this. So I have some caveats to give you. First off, people have been saying this for a long time. The Rolling Stone has covered this before with, like, real fishy operations of how Sean handles his money and buying multiple houses. And I will tell you that, you know, look, April, you and I, we've been in this space for a bit now. I have a lot of friends in this space, and I will tell you off the record, I have a lot of friends who will stay anonymous who either currently might know Sean or have worked with Sean in the past and have given me a very similar story without knowing each other. So I've always had suspicions that Sean maybe is kind of a grifter and also doesn't know how to. Or maybe isn't, to put it charitably, is allegedly, you know, financially not good with his money and using it for nefarious purposes. But the reason why he's back in the news with this headline is because his own previous team and former staff members and people who have worked with him over the course of several years made a website detailing in great detail all of the different, you know, things that they're accusing him of, including financial, spiritual, and moral misconduct. So there are. Are three things that. That. That. That. There's. That the allegations are accusing him of. And this is from, by the way, the website is called Truth and Freedom Stories. Okay. It's right here. And they have a long, formal statement. I'm going to just read you the summary. You can go visit it if you want. So there are three allegations that they're bringing here. There's financial misconduct. This report alleges that Sean Floyd diverted donations for personal use, misused ministry credit cards, and failed to maintain proper financial records. For instance, despite a significant revenue increase in 2020. Financial transparency reportedly declined after the ministry's reclassification as a church in 2022, exempting it from filing detailed financial disclosures. Number two, spiritual and emotional abuse. Testimonies describe a pattern of manipulation, including the use of spiritual language to control behavior, retaliation against those who raise concerns, and creating a culture demanding extreme loyalty. Former staff members report experiences of public shaming and emotional distress. And number three, organizational mismanagement. The investigation highlights a complex network of overlapping organizations with unclear financial boundaries. Concerns are raised about the use of Ministry funds for acquiring multiple real estate properties, some labeled as parsonages across various states. So it's a pretty. It's a pretty. You know, it's a pretty detailed report here. And it's. Yeah, it's been. It's getting passed around the Internet.

[Andrew]

And Sean, you know, is doing the Sean thing. I mean, and I think because it is signed by several people who worked or volunteered for Sean and his ministry. Sean Foyt, as far as I can see, has not directly addressed the allegations, but he has posted some kind of, you know, cryptic things.

[April]

What did he say?

[Andrew]

He posted this random. Birds of birds of a feather working together. When Soros backed Christianity Today, Rolling Stone and the LGBTQ mafia gang up to attack Christians. You know, a big breakthrough is coming. Never back down with the prayer emoji.

[April]

Yeah.

[Andrew]

You know, so I actually, I was reading the comments because I wanted to see if anyone was saying anything about it, and there was one lady who. Who sounds like she was a supporter. Do you have that screenshot? She comments on that post, and this is on his Facebook page. She said, you need to open the books and be transparent. I sponsor a child with your Light a Candle program, and I am thinking of canceling because I can't be sure where my money is going. This doesn't look good. Sean Foyt replied to her comment and said, you are welcome to come to India with us at any time and see the incredible work there. My family sponsors children as well and visited them in person last year. So basically his response to her being like, hey, Sean, could you be transparent about your finances? And he's like, why don't you pay more money to come on a trip with me?

[April]

It's. Yeah, yeah. Again, this is not a surprise. I mean, everyone who's seeing it is like, wow, we're all so shocked that this is a story. I mean, you know, we all knew about this, or we had a lot of suspicions about it. I mean, Sean owns several houses that are worth millions of dollars. They're all in his name. He has rental properties. Apparently, this is all according to the report. And it's just. It's not transparent with, like. With, like, where the money goes. I mean, I think Rolling Stone did an article on this a year or two ago and mentioned that. That Sean Foyt Ministries brought in, like, $5 million in 2021. Yet him, I think, and his wife are the only people on staff at the organization. So where's all the money going? Right. And in classic evangelical fashion, we're going to probably see a lot of defensiveness from Sean and probably blame demonic oppression, trying to stop Christian persecution or Christian persecution, you know, or Joros Soros funded, you know, Christianity Today. Like, wow, Sean, Geez Louise. So we are, we are following this story. We'll see how it kind of shakes out. But, but look, I mean, right wing spaces are notorious for grifters. This is like not new. And Sean made a lot of money in 2020 and 2021 with this Let us worship, you know, mantra as he toured the US asking for donations all the time, selling merch all the time in the name of, you know, limited government and, and no masks. No masks necessary. And I'm not, I'm not surprised at all. I'm not surprised that he is allegedly, you know, being improper with his finances. Yeah.

[Andrew]

Have you been accused of receiving money from George Soros?

[April]

Not yet. I can't wait for the day though, so I can be like. Well, you know, the thing is, if I was, I would tell people, like, I don't give a crap. Like, I would tell people, yes, I have George Soros money. Cope. Like, I would love to have some of that billionaire money. It'd be great. But I don't have any of it.

[Andrew]

Soros is a busy guy. Yeah, yeah, he's like the boogeyman.

[April]

I just, I would love, you know, April, I'm gonna, I'll go more modest. I don't want a second house. I just want to be able to have a separate small studio that's not my guest bedroom. Is that too much to ask for? Yeah, that's all I want. Yeah, yeah, Just one house and one little studio. That's all I want.

[Andrew]

It is too much, remember, because Jesus said, just screw the poor.

[April]

That's right.

[Andrew]

I forgot too much. Stay in your guest bedroom. No, just kidding. So in another news, and this just dropped last night, and we don't have time to get into into all the details because it is a very thorough report. The Roy's report, journalist Julie Roy, it posted on that last night. It is a very, very long article and I, I believe that the Roy's report was over for over two years was investigating this particular story. So basically, Michael Tate, who was the frontman for the News Boys for several years, initially got his fame by being, you know, one of three of DC Talk, which you and I grew up on DC Talk. Like I love.

[April]

They were my favorite trio. My favorite band was DC Talk.

[Andrew]

100% same. And so Michael Tate, if you are a 90s CCM baby, is, is a household name for you.

[April]

Yes, yes.

[Andrew]

And he has just been accused of, and this dates back, I think since 2004 was what the article said of sexual assault, grooming and substance abuse.

[April]

Yep.

[Andrew]

And it is, it's a very detailed. They, they interview.

[April]

It's long. It's long.

[Andrew]

Multiple sources.

[April]

50.

[Andrew]

50.

[April]

Yeah, yeah.

[Andrew]

So if you want to read all the details, it is there, it is grueling, it is disheartening.

[April]

So the, the, the summary for people and again, just trigger warning. This, this deals with sexual abuse is, it's this. So here's, here's kind of the, the five minute summary and this is breaking news. So we'll see how this gets unpacked in the future weeks. We'll make sure to keep you guys apprised. Michael Tate, renowned for his roles in Christian music bands, D.C. talking Newsboys, Faces serious allegations of sexual misconduct, grooming and substance abuse spanning over two decades. An extensive investigation by the Royal report report involving over 50 sources has brought these accusations to light. Key allegations. One, sexual misconduct. Three men alleged that Tate befriended them during Christian music tours in 2004, 2010 and 2014. They claimed that after consuming alcohol, they experienced non consensual sexual contact initiated by Tate. Two, substance abuse. One accuser reported that Tate offered him cocaine aboard the Newsboys tour bus. Three, grooming behavior. The pattern described involves Tate establishing close relationships with young men, providing them with alcohol and then engaging in inappropriate behavior. These incidents repeatedly reportedly occurred when the victims were around 22 years old. And the Roy's report has corroborated, corroborated these accounts with multiple sources. I will tell you now that this is coming out to light that I have heard for maybe a year and a half now, rumors about Michael Tate not only potentially being gay, which is fine, like people are gay, more power to them, but also being predatory in nature. And again, this was all hearsay, so I couldn't talk about it, I wasn't going to share it. We needed someone with investigative journalism background to do the work. And it's been a two and a half year investigation for the Roy's report to drop this. But everyone I've talked to, even when I share this on Instagram, people were messaging me, hey, I'm a ccm, you know, person where I used to be. And this was like an open secret about Michael Tate and just how he was. So it seems like for a lot of people this is no surprise. But yeah, it's, it's definitely, it's a damning report. And it also makes sense why he resigned abruptly, I think a few months ago from Newsboys. I mean he just like overnight was like, I'm out of here. And so I think, my guess, I don't know this is all alleged, but I'm guessing that the Roy's report either contacted him or contacted the band asking for comment and he was like, yeah, I'm out of here.

[Andrew]

So yeah, I just want to say I could see this. I, I, I think they're going to be a lot of conservative Christians that are, that are rightfully so going to be outraged about this. I mean we all should be outraged because, you know, that behavior is reprehensible. I can see them blaming him being gay for this predatory behavior, which is not why this is bad. Like him being gay has absolutely nothing to do with why this is bad. 100 but, but this type of behavior though, like, I think one reason why you see so much abuse and hidden scandals within evangelical culture is because you are taught to repress your sexuality not just if you're gay, but even, even if you're straight. Like sex is taboo. You know, it's for record, it's for procreation only. Like it shames women, it gives men this, this authority over women too. To, to where you have this hierarchy culture where you always submit to your spiritual leadership.

[April]

Right.

[Andrew]

And it forces people into closets. It forces people into closets where they have to, the, the only way that they can be out or to, to even like you know, free. That side is only in secrecy and in secrecy is when abuses happen. And when all this stuff, it's, it's the secrecy, it's the environment that causes this. It's not the queerness of it. Queerness has nothing to do with this predatory behavior. And it's, I'm going to be so pissed when I see people try to blame it on that. Because Robert Morris is also in news because he's currently on trial for molesting a 12 year old.

[April]

Yep.

[Andrew]

When he was in ministry.

[April]

Yeah.

[Andrew]

And he, he straight. It's the, it is the environment, it is the theology. It, it's the repression that, that people carry with them all the time because that's what you're taught to do because you're taught you're dirty and you're sinful and you have to, you have to hide it, you have to be ashamed of it. And it's that shame that makes you, that, that, that brings out predatory behavior. Not, and that is not a defense of Michael Tate. Like what, what he did is awful and terrible and Also, the system is rotten.

[April]

Yeah. I mean, we, we, we can seek to understand how this happens without excusing the behavior. Right. There's no excuse for non consensual sexual activity, period. I don't care how you grew up, where you come from, it's inexcusable. However, the question is, how does this happen? Why does this happen? And repression and this system of secrecy and you can't be who you really are certainly can play a factor into how people do terrible things. Right. Michael Tate needs to be brought to justice. I hope that a full investigation happens. I hope that a police investigation happens, that we get all that. Not we, but you know, that, that, that, that for the victim's sake, justice is found for sure. And also, maybe we should think a little bit differently about how we treat sex and queerness in the church, because clearly it doesn't work. I mean, the SBC covered up sexual abuse for decades. Right. There was a huge scandal about that. Every April, you and I could have an entire show where every day we just read headlines of pastors and youth pastors who have sexually assaulted a child or have sexually assaulted someone else. Right. It is a non stop flood of straight men doing this. Right. So the issue is not someone's sexual orientation. There are other factors that go into play. Again, that's not to excuse it, that's not to justify it, it's not to downplay it. It's simply to say maybe there's a way. Maybe there are are factors that go into what creates someone's psyche. To think that these kinds of non consensual acts are okay or acceptable when they're really not.

[Andrew]

Right, Right. And to be in a place where you think you could do these things to people and get away with it, because so many people in this world do get away with it because of the spiritual authority and the secrecy and all of the theology that goes behind all of that too.

[April]

Yeah. Yeah.

[Andrew]

Okay. This is a long show. We'll do our final Weird Christian. Do you got our stinger Weird Christian. Okay, so this is going back to the AI. Okay, this is, this is a video of Donald Trump. I saw this on Facebook and it's him. It's a nine minute video. We're not going to watch the whole thing, but it's a two part it. The first half is him or really the first like 2/3 is Donald Trump. His lips are moving. It's bad AI. Like there's AI out there that is very scary and very believable.

[Tim]

Yeah.

[Andrew]

This is not that this is very clearly AI. Like the, the lips don't match it. It's, it's the face looks distorted. And then it cuts to Donald Trump singing like this country sounding worship song, which is also very clearly AI. But we want to play some of the video and then we want to read you the comments. It's got like what, 300 some thousand views? I think it's crazy. And over a thousand comments. And I was reading through them and most of them are falling for it. Like there's been a slew of these AI worship songs out there on YouTube that people think are real. Like there's a video of Barron Trump singing a worship song and it's all these old ladies being like, oh my gosh, Barons loves the Lord. So sweet. Like it's, it's wild. So did you get the video?

[April]

Yeah. Can you see it?

[Andrew]

Yeah. You should show some of his testimony and then go to the song.

[April]

Well, I will. This is just the thumbnail that's in the beginning.

[Andrew]

Oh, okay.

[April]

Cool.

[Andrew]

Yeah.

[April]

Friends, before we play the video, please give this video a. Like, that would be so helpful. We have almost 300 people watching and 136 people have liked the video. So let's get that up to 200. Help us out. It helps get the video out to more people. It means the world. And if you have not yet subscribed to the channel, please make sure to do that as well. We go live Every Thursday at 12 o' clock Eastern and do a deep dive every single Monday. And this show is also on podcast as well. Okay, I'll hit play. We'll let it go for a little bit. April, you tell me when to pause, then we'll go towards the end.

[Andrew]

Here's people a feel.

[April]

Yeah. All right, here we go. Before I sing this song that means so much to me, I need you all to first take a little time and listen to me. Maybe this will inspire you in some way. Many people have asked who Jesus is to me. Well, to put it simply, he is everything. He is my savior, my friend, my hope. The whitest Jesus ever. I am able to face each day with strength. Life is full of trials, pain, and moments where the weight of the world feels unbearable. But Jesus has always been the one who carries me through. He is not just a distant historical figure or a religious symbol. He is personal, real and ever present. That is the whitest European Jesus I've ever seen. Look at that man.

[Andrew]

So. So he talks like this. It's very word bombing minutes.

[April]

Look at this.

[Andrew]

So long. So Then at a certain point, it cuts to the song that he's singing. Right.

[April]

I gotta play this. Oh, we're gonna play this. Okay, here we go. Buckle up, friends. I can't do it. Oh, my God. No. Going through pain. Jesus.

[Andrew]

They're fighting over a baby. What is happening?

[Tim]

My strength when I am weak. The force of peace when I can't speak. You are the fire inside my soul, Jesus.

[April]

Take my life. Take control, Jesus. My soul. Okay, I can't do it. I'm done. I'm done.

[Andrew]

So for those. Wait, hold on, hold on.

[April]

Can we back up for a second? Can we just look at some of these stills? What is. What in the he haw hell is going on? Look at this. Look.

[Andrew]

Look at that.

[April]

Look at that angel in the back. What is happening?

[Andrew]

Screaming. And whose baby is that?

[April]

Whose baby is that? And then what is this? Like, this, like Dragon Force Super Saiyan.

[Andrew]

That looks like. Like some street fighter you'd see in the avengers. Like.

[April]

Like Dr. Strange.

[Andrew]

Strange.

[April]

Why is this baby floating? Why is this baby floating? What is happening? Okay, okay, okay, That's.

[Andrew]

That is. That is weird, Christian. Beep. But I think the weirder part of this, this video are the comments. So I screenshotted and to be fair, I only looked through maybe a couple hundred comments. There's over a thousand of them, and the most, like 95% of the comments were positive and people being like, oh, thank you, Trump. Let me just say.

[April]

Can I just say you said that this is weird Christian. Beep. No, this is weird Christian shit. Like, I think this shit needs to be dropped here. It is weird, Christian. It just is. Okay, okay, here, I have them pulled up here. Here are some of the screenshots from this. From this video.

[Andrew]

Okay, He. These are comments, right? He is God's other David. And this comment says, I don't know country singers, but I don't think he's singing here. But he may be singing it too.

[April]

No, come on.

[Andrew]

Renee wasn't convinced that it was or was not. She has doubt. It could have been. It might have been Trump singing. All right, go. Wanda says thank you, Jesus, for President Trump, our commander in chief, our Christian leader and our true friend. Jesus is my everything too. President Trump.

[April]

Do you think this is real, though? Is this a bot? All right, fine.

[Andrew]

There's over a thousand of them. Wait, go back to the all caps ones. Beautifully said. And I know you haters are going to say he isn't saying that to all of you. If you don't like the message, then get off Our Patriots page. I love it. And I know God has his hand on this great, great man. He had to look far and wide to find him. He is our David standing and facing the Goliath and we will never back down. Next. And he can sing.

[April]

No, that is not that can. No. This one said, that's gotta be AI. AI has, remember? Oh my God. Sorry, go ahead.

[Andrew]

Good. If that's him singing, so a little bit of doubt there. It may not be him singing, but if it is, good, good. Awesome. Love this man. God in his mercy, keep you and your staff. My civil war.

[April]

Yeah. My savor.

[Andrew]

Amen. He been touched by the Lord. God bless him. Love this. Not many presidents will speak out like this.

[April]

April, I have. I have a hypothetical scenario. What if AI what if the AI create what? What if the thing or the AI machine that made that video also created these comments to troll us? Like, what if it's so self aware. It's like, let me troll the Christian, the anti Christian nationalists and create all these different people and accounts and recomment underneath my own video that I made to troll them because these are too on the nose. They're too. They're too on the nose. These cannot be real people.

[Andrew]

Maybe. I mean, I did click on a couple of them and they did look like real profiles. But I'm sure some of these are bots. I mean, we also have a very. We have a big problem with bots as well.

[April]

We do.

[Andrew]

Here's another comment. Pretty sure that this is not Trump singing. I think it was Trump speaking, but the singer sounds a lot like Randy Travis. So Charlotte here was like, that's definitely not Trump singing. Right, but you got me on the words. Like, Trump definitely said all that.

[April]

He definitely said that. Yes. 2 Corinthians.

[Andrew]

Here's another one. Amen, you Lord, you very mookamine.

[April]

April, the way you said that, very moving. Oh my goodness.

[Andrew]

Honestly, my new favorite pastime is just reading comments as they are written. You know, typos and all.

[April]

It's like a spiritual gift that you can do it so well. It's hilarious.

[Andrew]

Here's another one.

[April]

Thank you.

[Andrew]

His. His Excellency Donald Trump. You are so handsome of this message. No wonder you trained Baron, your son about Jesus. This person probably saw Bar Aaron's worship AI song as well. Anyway, it's so many. It's full of comments like this and you know, maybe. Maybe a lot of them are AI because that, I mean, would make more sense because this was a very clearly obviously AI video.

[April]

I mean, the name of this person is Armstrong. And it looks like. You know how whenever AI makes a photo, sometimes the person has, like, six fingers or something. This is written like it has six fingers. You know, it's like one of those. Like, it just. It seems too broken. Like.

[Andrew]

AI, though, wouldn't misspell Excellency.

[April]

That's true.

[Andrew]

I mean, I misspelled it twice, actually. Excellency. God bless you, His Excellency.

[April]

I'm not even sure what to say. That is. That is. What a note to end the show on. Yeah, we covered a lot today.

[Andrew]

This is one of our longer shows we've had in a while.

[April]

Yeah, it's been a minute. Well, I wasn't on last week, and so much news, and then the Michael Tate thing dropped last night. God, there's so much going on. So.

[Andrew]

Yeah, yeah, yeah. Well, be nice to our future AI Overlords.

[April]

Yes. We love you, AI. Thank you.

[Andrew]

I think I'd rather have an AI president than Donald Trump at this point.

[April]

At this point. For sure. For sure. I think. I don't know. Be careful what you wish for, though, right? So maybe.

[Andrew]

Depends on the AI, you know, I don't know.

[April]

Yeah, yeah.

[Andrew]

Anyway, we've talked about this enough, so happy pride, everybody.

[April]

Pride. We'll see you back here, but we'll see you on Monday for another episode, and then we'll be back on Thursday with another live. So have a good week.

[Andrew]

Bye.