The Tim & April Show - Episode 51 Summary

"Mass Shootings and Masculine Frailty: Christian Nationalism Loses Its Angle"

Date: October 3, 2025
Hosts: Tim Whitaker & April Ajoy
Network: The New Evangelicals

Overview

In this episode, Tim and April unravel recent events at the intersection of faith, politics, and American culture, with a particular focus on the alarming rise of mass shootings — including a recent attack at a Mormon (LDS) church in Michigan. They closely examine gun violence, the rhetoric and hypocrisy of Christian nationalism, and the troubling militarization and extremist language emanating from recent Trump and Pete Hegseth–led military events. The show draws from both personal experience and current data, inviting listeners to reject Christian nationalism and embrace a faith grounded in justice, love, and compassion.

Main Discussion Points

1. Michigan LDS Church Mass Shooting and America's Gun Problem

[06:24 – 26:30]

• Incident Overview:
  April recounts the mass shooting at a Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints (LDS/Mormon church) in Michigan, where the perpetrator (a white male veteran with mental health issues) attacked the congregation after an apparent personal grievance.

  • "There was another mass shooting this past Sunday at a Church of Latter Day Saints... And how many people. There were multiple mass shootings this past weekend, too." [06:27]

• Data on Mass Shootings:
  324 mass shootings so far this year (per Gun Violence Archive — defined as 4+ injured or killed, not including the shooter) – more than one per day on average.

• Root Causes and the Swiss Cheese Effect:
  Both hosts highlight that mass shootings stem from multiple intersecting factors: access to firearms (notably, assault-style weapons), insufficient federal gun law uniformity (state laws are easily subverted by out-of-state purchases), mental health access failings, and social instability.

  • "If you have 50 states with all different gun laws, it's a Swiss cheese approach... people will import guns more easily from a different state." [11:04 – Tim]
  • "The narrative from the right is always, like, 'they want to take away your guns.' ...That's not actually the position. It's about regulation." [11:56 – April]

• Comparing Guns to Cars:
  April and Tim use the car regulation analogy to drive home the sensible argument for gun safety: licenses, registration, and safety standards are commonplace for vehicles but fiercely resisted for firearms.

• International Perspective:
  The US leads the world in mass shootings by far, with 109 incidents between 2000 and 2022, compared to France’s 6.

  • “The United States leads the world... Next country below us is France with six. What do we think is going to happen?" [14:09 – Tim]

• Veteran and Healthcare Issues:
  The Michigan shooter was a veteran with inadequate VA support, substance abuse issues, and a son with a costly genetic condition.

  • "[He] was a veteran in Iraq, and his friends say that when he came back he was changed in a very different person. The VA is notorious for not giving our troops adequate healthcare access..." [16:06 – Tim]

• Frustration and Cynicism Toward Lawmakers:
  Hosts express frustration at government inaction, contrasting available data and international standards with entrenched inaction and NRA rhetoric.

  • “I'm just so over this rhetoric because it's killing people…” [16:05 – Tim]

2. Weaponizing Christian Identity After (and During) Tragedy

[18:40 – 24:22]

• Trump’s Baseless Statement:
  Donald Trump immediately claims on Truth Social that the Michigan shooting was a “targeted attack on Christians” without supporting evidence.

  • “This appears to be yet another targeted attack on Christians…” [19:10 – April, quoting Trump]

• Selective Solidarity with Mormons:
  Evangelicals suddenly rally to include Mormons/LDS as “Christians” for martyrdom narrative purposes, despite longstanding evangelical teachings that label Mormonism as heresy or a cult.

  • “They will consider the, the LDS community not part of their group until it’s convenient for them. Until it fits a narrative.” [22:13 – April]
  • “This is Mark Driscoll… They do not think that Mormons are real Christians.” [21:04 – Tim]

• Weaponized Narrative:
  The right uses tragedies to stoke Christian persecution narratives, but drops the story as soon as the shooter is identified as a white, right-aligned male or Christian.

  • “As soon as it came out that the man was a Trump supporter and a Christian himself, they're not talking about this shooting anymore.” [26:38 – April]

3. Data and Hypocrisy: Violence, Race, and Ideology

[26:57 – 42:39]

• Demographics of Mass Shooters:
  98% are white men; less than 1% trans; <2% women — yet conservative media focuses on marginalized groups when convenient.

  • “Where’s all the talk about the white violent epidemic?” [26:57 – Tim]

• Right-Wing Versus Left-Wing Violence?
  Analysis of recent Axios/CSIS data (see key quote and graph below):

  • Right-wing acts have historically been drastically more lethal and common, but in 2025, a (small) spike in left-wing attacks (mostly property/institutional, not people) sparks misleading conservative outcry.
  • “In the study, left wing attacks are less lethal...compared to right wing attacks that are usually targeting people or people groups.” [37:49 – Tim]

• Hostility to Accountability or Nuance:
  Many on the right refuse to address structural causes, pivoting to “it’s mental health” arguments while simultaneously voting against expanded mental health services.

  • “GOP, I think guns over people is what that should stand for.” [18:12 – April]

4. Christian Responses: Forgiveness, Compassion, and the LDS Example

[31:43 – 34:22]

• LDS Fundraising for Both Victims and Perpetrator's Family:
  Unlike performative expressions of forgiveness seen in other high-profile shootings, the LDS church extends tangible care to both the victims' families and the family of the shooter.

  • “The LDS Church is raising money not only for the victims... but also for the family of the shooter. I'm like, you know, I'm just saying as far as being Christlike goes...” [31:53 – Tim]

• Rejecting Exclusivity in Christian Identity
  April: “Now I’m at the point of like, if someone says that they’re a Christian and they follow Jesus, I’m going to consider them a Christian. Who am I to say, sorry, you can’t be in my club?” [22:23 – April]

5. Pete Hegseth, Militarization, and ‘Alpha Male’ Christian Nationalism

[45:33 – 61:00+]

• Trump and Fox News Host Pete Hegseth's Military Summit:
  Trump and Hegseth orchestrate a military “summit” — described as a “TED Talk for Generals” — complete with tough-guy posturing, calls for a “Department of War,” and attacks on “political correctness” in military practice.

  • “If I ever saw an alpha male, it’s Pete Hegseth…” [04:08 – Tim, joking]

• Hegseth’s Militarist Rhetoric:

  • “You kill people and break things for a living. You are not politically correct and don’t necessarily belong always in polite society.” [47:49 – Pete Hegseth]
  • Both hosts denounce the dehumanizing, hyper-masculine, and inflammatory language as dangerous, particularly against the backdrop of rising political violence.
    • “Not everyone in the military kills people or breaks things... it just feels so dehumanizing.” [49:19 – Tim]
    • “It’s building up more problems.” [48:19 – April]

• Rolling Back Sexual Assault Protections:
  Hegseth proposes rolling back Inspector General and Equal Opportunity complaint processes, deriding victims as “complainers, ideologues, and poor performers.”

  • "This is all code for, we're reducing protections for victims of sexual assault..." [51:30 – Tim]
  • "He just gave clear reign for predators in the military to assault people." [52:40 – April]

• No More ‘Politically Correct’ Rules of Engagement:
  Hegseth argues for “maximum lethality,” openly undermining established norms under the Geneva Convention.

  • “We unleash overwhelming and punishing violence on the enemy... No more politically correct and overbearing rules of engagement.” [53:54 – Pete Hegseth]

• Hyperfixation on ‘Fat Troops’:
  Hegseth fixates on fitness as the only qualification, proposing strict height/weight/PT standards for all military personnel.

  • "He’s honing in on the one thing that he's like, 'I could do fitness. Look at me do fitness. Me tough. Me have abs.'" [60:46 – April]

• Trump’s Performance for the Generals:
  Trump’s rambling speech is described as detached and concerning, with lines about “an invasion from within” and the military’s new role combating domestic enemies — blurring lines between defense and authoritarianism.

  • "We're under invasion from within. No different than a foreign enemy..." [66:19 – Trump]
  • "[The right has] plausible deniability. But obviously, given his rhetoric, he's talking about leftists." [66:57 – Tim]

• Audience Reaction:
  Notably, the generals appear unenthusiastic, and even embarrassed—a viral shot captures face-palming.

6. Christian Nationalism—The Big Picture

[82:04 – End]

• Eschatology and American Foreign Policy:
  April & Tim discuss recent rapture predictions, mocking the repeated recalculations by “prophets” and the harmful real-world consequences (e.g., people selling homes, not planning for the future).

  • “There are people who really get hurt by this stuff ... selling their houses ... or leaving their jobs.” [79:23 – Tim]

• Impact on Climate Policy and Foreign Affairs:
  They note how apocalyptic end-times beliefs (popularized in evangelical circles) drive resistance to environmental reform and unconditional US support for Israel.

• The Antithesis of Jesus:
  The show ends with an appeal to Jesus’ actual teachings—caring for the poor, welcoming the stranger, opposing oppression—which are directly contradicted by the current Christian nationalist movement.

  • “As Christians, we believe that this is an antichrist way of living. ... The expression that we see right now of a white American Christianity is doing the complete opposite.” [82:04 – Tim]

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• On American Gun Culture and Failure to Act:

  "The only thing that stops a bad guy with a gun is a good guy with a gun. Tell that to the parents of the Uvalde victims."
  — Tim Whitaker [16:05]

• On the Political Exploitation of Tragedy:

  "They will consider the LDS community not part of their group until it's convenient for them. Until it fits a narrative."
  — April Ajoy [22:13]

• On Right-Wing Media’s Hypocrisy:

  "Where's all the talk about the white violent epidemic? ... It's always about maintaining this white supremacist nationalist ideology."
  — Tim Whitaker [26:57]

• On Christian Ethics vs. Performance:

  “The LDS Church is raising money not only for the victims... but also for the family of the shooter. ... I can't think of a more Christlike thing to do.”
  — Tim Whitaker [31:53]

• On the Alpha-Male Military Rhetoric:

  “You kill people and break things for a living. You are not politically correct and don’t necessarily belong always in polite society.”
  — Pete Hegseth [47:49]

• On Christian Nationalism’s Endgame:

  "Christian nationalists are not here to participate in democracy. They are here to erode democratic norms...to rule over their neighbors."
  — Tim Whitaker [67:33]

• On Rapture Prophecies and Harm:

  "It's really sad though, because it. It not only does it harm people that literally think, okay, by this date this is going to happen and so I can sell all my possessions... But also it keeps so many Christians that keep thinking...there's no point in trying to stop climate change..."
  — April Ajoy [81:06]

Key Timestamps

• 06:24 – Mass shooting overview and data context.
• 10:27 – Explaining underlying causes and car-vs-gun analogy.
• 13:05 – Comparing auto safety standards to gun laws.
• 16:05 – Analysis of systemic policy failures.
• 18:40–20:08 – Trump’s “Christian attack” comments/evangelical hypocrisy.
• 26:38–29:34 – Conservative silence when the shooter’s identity doesn’t suit the narrative.
• 37:49–41:29 – Examining the Axios/CSIS left/right violence report.
• 45:33–61:00 – Trump & Hegseth’s military spectacle; hyper-masculinity and terrifying policy changes.
• 66:19–69:58 – Trump’s “invasion from within” rhetoric.
• 73:40–75:38 – Generals’ perceived embarrassment, audience shots.
• 77:52–83:48 – Rapture culture, eschatology, and real-world fallout.

Conclusion

This episode renders a powerful, fact-based critique of both the American gun violence epidemic and the ascent of Christian nationalism’s toxic rhetoric. Tim and April combine policy analysis, media critique, and personal reflection to highlight how faith-centered communities—and the nation at large—must reject performative religiosity, embrace nuance, and reclaim a just, compassionate Christianity.

Listen to full episodes and join the community at thenewevangelicals.com or on YouTube.