
Loading summary
Sponsor
If you're like me, you have a lot of product on your bathroom counter. Well, I have found the secret serum and it's Vibriance Super C Serum. The ingredients in this one bottle can replace your day creams, eye creams, night creams, neck creams, wrinkle creams, and even dark spot reducers. Made in the usa with the highest quality ingredients including vitamin C, hyaluronic acid, vitamin B5 and vitamin E, Super C Serum delivers noticeable results. Simplify your skin care routine, get a healthier complexion and minimize wrinkles and age spots with Vibrance. I just began using Super C Serum last week and I love it. My skin feels so much better. Soft, moist and fresh. And by the way, it smells beautiful, like the orange blossoms outside my kitchen door. Give it a try and you'll love it too. And if you don't find it better than your current skincare routine, you'll get a full refund. Go to vibrance.com victor to save up to 37% off and free shipping. That's Vibrance. V I B R I A n c e vibrance.com Victor and we'd like to thank Vibrance for sponsoring the Victor Davis Hansen Show.
Jack Fowler
Hello, ladies and gentlemen. This is the Victor Davis Hansen Show. We are recording on Saturday, May 17th. I'm Jack Fowler, the host. I'm very, very privileged to be the host of this show and for five years been doing this with my great friends.
Victor Davis Hanson
Oh my gosh. Yeah, Victor, we were young ones.
Jack Fowler
Those were the days. Those are the days you would be pre, maybe even pre senior citizen status for we this this particular episode will be up on Thursday, May 22. Victor is the Martin and Ely Anderson Senior Fellow at the Hoover Institution and the Wayne and Marcia Buskey Distinguished Fellow in History at Hillsdale College. And he's got a website, the Blade of Perseus. Its address is victorhanson.com you should check it out. Subscribe. I'll tell you more later in this episode. Why you should. You were on the cusp of the Memorial Day weekend. Victor, I didn't tell you this ahead of time. We maybe at the end of the show maybe we could talk about a war movie or two. And but before that, boy, oh boy, we have the Supreme Court ruling on deporting illegal criminals as opposed to legal criminals, illegal alien criminals to Venezuela. There's a new issue of Strategica out. We have so many new viewers and listeners, I have a feeling a lot of folks don't even know what Strategica is. And we'll tell them about that. You have a piece you've written for your website on the failure of modernism. We can talk about reparations, the big beautiful bill in trouble, salt deductions, so much more. And we'll do all that when we come back from these important messages. Did you know you can get the photos on your phone, printed for free and delivered straight to your door? Do it with Freeprints, the world's favorite way to print photos. Just visit freeprints.com to get the Free Prints app and get your free photo prints. Now that's freeprints.com Freeprints has millions of five star reviews and has printed literally billions of photos.
Victor Davis Hanson
It's easy.
Jack Fowler
Just visit freeprints.com and get premium quality photo prints in your mailbox in just days. Go to freeprints.com or download the Freeprints app directly from Google Play or the App Store.
Sponsor
Hey everyone. This doesn't happen often, so you want to jump on this? Brick House Nutrition Memorial Day sale is on for a limited time. You can save 25% off everything with my code memorial25. That includes lean, the weight loss supplement that targets the goals of GLP1 injections, but without needles or prescriptions. People are seeing real results and they love that it curves the cravings. Check out the website reviews. Also on sale is Field of Greens, the super fruit and vegetable drink that literally promises your doctor will notice your improved health or your money back. I use Field of Greens multivitamin every day. Boy do I have more energy and feel healthier. I'm sold on Field of Greens and you should be too. Whether it's collagen, creatine or any other doctor formulated products, it's all on sale for 25% off. Kick off a healthy summer and save big while you're at it. It go to brickhousenutrition.com and use code memorial25 for 25 off. But don't wait. The sale's only on for a few days. That's brickhouse nutrition.com brickhousenutrition.com and we'd like to thank Brickhouse Nutrition for sponsoring the Victor Davis Hansen Show.
Victor Davis Hanson
Foreign.
Jack Fowler
We are back with the Victor Davis Hansen Show. So Victor, I guess we should start off today. Yeah. Getting some some take from you on the big beautiful bill it is when we're recording on Saturday to when the show's up. All kinds of things might have happened in the meanwhile to rectify political situations, but there are enough Republicans in the House who are just not in love with or the Senate not in love with this big beautiful bill. What are your thoughts on, on this and the politics of it?
Victor Davis Hanson
I have reservations about it because of the spending. You know, Moody's the bond adjudicator. I think that was patently political. It just lowered the bond rating of the United States government from Triple A to A1A the first time in history since 1917 a viewer wrote me that. And I think it was political. Just like the, the Fed. If you had these indicators under Biden of, you know, no inflation, job growth, corporate profits, energy, all these great news, they would have lowered the from 4.8 down to 4 or something that would save some of the $3 billion in interest were paying here. But all that said, you know, Doge has only found about $180 billion. That's a lot. But when you're talking about, when you're talking about giving tax breaks on tips on Social Security, on maybe military or first responders, that's going to take a while. I'm not sure if that's going to be the type of incentives that prime growth of the economy. So what I'm getting at is right now the biggest problem we have is debt, debt, debt, debt, $37 trillion in aggregate national debt, basically $2 trillion in annual deficits and 1.2 in trade deficits. And we're getting kind of mixed messages. I know that Trump want the deregulation and tax cuts, if they're continuing, will be great because that will grow the economy, the energy prices will grow the economy. 10, 8 to 10 trillion in foreign investment. We're not getting enough messages. It's only been three months and they say they have 160 to 170 billion. Does that mean that in the next quarter, next quarter, next quarter you're going to get 160, 160, 160, I'd like to know. And if they get 500 billion, that would make a big difference. You get close to maybe just $500 billion deficit, but we're not getting the information. So we're getting two signals that we're spending a lot of money, going to increase the defense budget, for example. We're not, we're having fights over cutting Medicaid. And then we were told we're going to get more revenue, but I don't think the tariffs are going to bring that much more revenue. We've discussed that. So what is going to be the bottom line? And is that why the Fed and Moody's are being pretty hard on this administration? They just See too much debt that they inherited and they haven't addressed it. I don't know the answers, but I would sure like to see a Simpson Bowles 2.0 commission to just go back and say, you've got to do this. This will get us a balanced budget in three years. In 10 years, this will cut the debt in half or something. And we're not, we need to have that. But he's the only president of 21st century that's talked about these things. The debt, the trade deficit, the budget deficit. But we got to get a clearer picture of what's going to happen is what I'm saying.
Jack Fowler
Victor, we all have our, our fingers. Finger or fingers in the pie to some degree on some proposals. You just, you mentioned, you know, no tax on tips, no tax on overtime. Then there's also salt, which is the state and local taxes, which were for me in Connecticut where we pay a.
Victor Davis Hanson
State income tax or New York, California.
Jack Fowler
Right. There were great boons.
Victor Davis Hanson
13.3%.
Jack Fowler
Yeah, I saw something.
Victor Davis Hanson
I don't think the government can afford it. It's already. Well, yeah, people are living in la la land. We saw that Cori Bush's successor, talk about reintroducing her bill for reparations and she wanted like a trillion dollars. It's not gonna all. It's just everybody talks as if we're not broke. Even Gavin Newsom finally admitted he can't demagogue the issue of giving free health care to illegal aliens to the same degree that he did before. There's no money. When the money runs out, there's no money. There is no money right now.
Jack Fowler
Well, you know what, I'm glad you raised the reparations. We'll get to that. But first I want to inform our listeners and viewers about our friends@besthotgrill.com There are a lot of special events coming up soon and besthotgrill.com recommends the gifts of food, good grilling and healthy eating. If you have a mom, a dad or grad you want to honor, do it with a gift that will be used, will be unforgettable, and will be truly hot. That would be a Solaire infrared grill from besthotgrill.com Solaire infrared grills heat up to 1000 degrees in just three minutes. It produces juicy, tasty food that is unmatched by any conventional grill. Maybe you're hitting the road or having a staycation. Solaire has hot and fast portable built in and cart models to help you step up your grilling. All Solaire Infrared Grills are made in the usa. They're built to last. Solaire Grills deliver the wow that everybody likes to get in a gift or a major purchase. Learn more about that amazing Solaire infrared grill@best hot grill.com that's best hot grill.com and we thank our friends at Solaire for sponsoring the Victor Davis Hansen Show. VICTOR Here's a headline, Democrats revive Reparations Demand in Congress. And this is from Newsmax. Congressional Democrats have once again introduced legislation to force the government to pay for damages suffered by enslaved black families. The latest attempt is sponsored by Representative Summer Lee, a Democrat from Pennsylvania who has who said in a release, quote, we are owed restitution and justice to repair the government sanctioned harm that has plagued our community for generations, end quote. The new congressional effort, the Reparations now resolution, was introduced initially by in 2023 by then Republic Cory Bush, Victor on its own and as a political politically, they wouldn't make a go with this. I mean, I think it's just nuts politically for the Democrats.
Victor Davis Hanson
It's not going to work. It's 160 years since the end of slavery and it's probably 60 years, 70 years since the end of institutionalized Jim Crow in the south. Here in California. We were never a slave state and yet 3 or 4% of the population wants reparations. When she says the damage done, I wish when people make all these statements, they never calibrate it. They never say exactly what they mean. Does she mean that the African American community suffers higher rates of criminality, illegitimacy, interracial violence against other races? And if so, are those attributable to the legacy of slavery? And if so, how 160 years later and why, if that were to be true, and she thought it was attributable, why, when brilliant scholars like Shelby Steele or late Walter Williams or Tom Sowell suggested correctives such as restoration of the nuclear family or redefinition of the obligations of males in the African community to their families and fatherhood. Why are they pilloried or ostracized? And so when she, when people say reparations, then you say one particular group in the present owes you another. Other groups owe them something. And we're going to go down, and then we're going to go down a tribal list. So then you know what's going to happen? People are going to say, well, let's just then calibrate every particular group and we're going to measure what they gave and what they got, what they didn't get. And then we're going to have to even it out. Is that what we're going to do? So what is, what do we do with the people who just arrived here as immigrants and have no experience with the American system at all? Are they going to pay money to African Americans for slavery or are they going to pay money because they think they meet an African American who suffers from slavery and then that's part of the dues of entering the United States? Is there going to be some conservative white group who's going to say, well, let's just look at all the crime statistics and see which particular group has committed crimes in excess of their population or has taken welfare in excess of their demographic, and then we'll see how much money they owe the rest of the people for the damage they've inflicted. And you see, you get it. You're going to see people, they're going to say, well, why is the black murder rate six times higher in terms of interracial crimes toward whites than whites toward blacks? Or they're going to say, why are blacks overrepresented in interracial crimes and hate crimes and whites are underrepresented? Is there a kind of a compensation that's deserved there for victims? Why are Jews, almost half of the victims of hate crimes today? Do they? Are they owed special consideration? And if they are, from whom the people who perpetuate it? Minorities are more likely to commit hate crimes beyond their demographic percentages. Or we could go even further. If we want to play this dangerous and spiteful game, we can say, well, let's go through all the wars and see who was killed and what group deserves it. So let's look at Afghanistan and Iraq. They did white males, who cooked up that? Was it Mark Milley? Was it the chairman of the Joint Chiefs that decided that white, they keep track on everything. And when women are underrepresented on aircraft carrier pilots, or blacks are underrepresented in particular captaincies or pay grades, they address it. But they must have known, they must have known over 20 years of fighting that white males were dying roughly at double their numbers in the demographics. What insidious racism allowed that to continue? So you had 35% of the population dying at 72, 73% of all fatalities. Is that what we want to do? We want to do all that stuff? Because that's what. That's the ultimate logic of reparations. It's not going to be in isolation. It's going to say, each group then is going to try to see to what degree that they can game the system as a victimizer or on the receiving end of inordinate violence or insufficient funding or something. And it would be much better if the Black Caucus in Congress said, look, our future is on our hands. And we know the degrees to which half of the black, half of the black community is doing wonderfully. And black women, I think have a higher income level per capita than many other groups, maybe even white working women. So they're doing where but the half that's not doing well, why don't they just be introspective? Is it because of one parent? Families lack of fathers? Is it lack of policing in the inner city? Is it not dispersing and not enough integrate? What is it? Is it the school system unionized, a lack of school choice? Why don't they come up with an innovative solution? But they don't. It's all victimized and we want reparations and it's falling on deaf ears. And when you have the Hispanics, 62% are polling that they love the first 100 days of the Trump administration. There is no such thing as intersectionality anymore. It was all. It doesn't exist.
Jack Fowler
Yeah, we can call it.
Victor Davis Hanson
There's no rainbow coalition. They're just people, just individual reparations is.
Jack Fowler
Just another word for money. And the dishonesty is that there are many dishonesties, but the money has been central to the destruction of the black family and the black community. But federal trillions of dollars of federal money has subsidized the breakup of the black family. And the thought that reparations are going to do anything except am I going.
Victor Davis Hanson
To work very hard to pay taxes to give money to Ta Nahisi Coates, who just wrote one of the worst anti Semitic diatribes I've ever seen. And he was famous, remember for the talk, remember he said the talk that he has to all black fathers have to tell you that the police put them in danger. And then I think it was Roland fire at the height of the George Floyd aftermath pointed out that statistically given the number of encounters 11 million or so encounters with the police, that African American males who are unarmed and lethally shot was consistent with their demographics of encounters. 11 million. How many of the 11 million encounters they participated in. There was no systematic racism. That's one of the reason plotting gay went after to destroy his career for publishing that. I had and I wrote an article. I don't know if you remember it, Jack. It was a National Review maybe 20 years, 15 years. It was called the other talk. And I said. I had a talk, too, from my father, and he said, you're living in East Palo Alto, and it's got one of the highest murder rates in the United States, and you are white, and you're living in a predominantly black neighborhood, and I don't think that you're going to find it particularly safe. I was broken into, I think, twice. A guy. A guy put a hand through the door. My roommate and I had clubs, and we were trying to club this hand. You know, there's a chain on the door, and he was breaking it, and the hand came through. We hit it with a bat. And then I was walking once to down the drugstore, and somebody took a six pack of Coors bottles, you know, the bottles full of beer, and threw it right at my head. And so my point is, I got the talk, too. It said, be very careful of going into particular neighborhoods because crime is inordinately addressed at white people by black people. And you have to be very careful. When I wrote that, I got so many hate letters. How dare you do that? Given the history of racism, that's a small price to pay for what you people have done. Oh, this is crazy.
Jack Fowler
But I knew four guys in my neighborhood murdered because they were in the wrong. They went to the wrong neighborhood, and nobody had sympathy for them in the sense of, why did you go there? What are you stupid? You know.
Victor Davis Hanson
Well, I had three violent incidents. I just mentioned one as a graduate student. The other was, I was riding on University Avenue from East Palo Alto Inn on a bike, and a truck of four African Americans were driving around attacking bicyclists. And they saw me and they jumped out and tried to knock me over. And I clung like a jellyfish, an octopus, to my old bike, and they kept trying to pull it. And then everybody was honking their horn as they were all busy and they didn't quite get it. The other was. I was with my wife who was working at the Veterans Administration with disabled people. And she met one of her. We were walking and one of her patients was out, and he had traumatic brain injury, Vietnam. And he was on the street, and he was making sounds that were kind of loud. And she walked over to him and he recognized her, and she was assigned to her. To him. And even though she was more clerical, but she. She had worked with the patients when she could, and she was talking to them. And this two African American guys came up and pushed her and pushed me and started making fun of this guy. And there was a guy in Graduate school with me, who was a Vietnam veteran, Green Beret. And I don't need to go any further. And it didn't look, it didn't end well for those guys. I didn't really participate, but they were trying to rough up my wife, the person she was talking to. So my. Those three violent incidents were all on the part of African American teens that were unprovoked. Did I ever then make a statement or in my mind or no. About African Americans? Because no sooner did I see that than I saw another African American person that was perfectly the same as I was. But they were making the argument you have to give a talk because white people were systemically racist against black people. That might have been true in certain places at certain times. We know it was true. But to transfer that to all of America seemed pretty. And that's why I wrote this article, the talk.
Jack Fowler
I think I told you once before, maybe twice, Victor, that growing up in the Bronx in the 1970s and 80s, New York, 2000 plus murders a year, just brutal, brutal crime. But clearly a lot of it was race based. But then clearly things were getting so much better in America on their own. So I was, you know, I was the publisher of National Review and There were like 20 kids at my house and they were all gay, black, Hispanic, south, you know, Sri Lankan, whatever. And I just thought this is not something America would have seen at the house of the publisher of evil conservative right wing National Review 30 years ago. But this is what America was, had become. And then Obama came along and re. Energized the whole.
Victor Davis Hanson
He did more damage than any president in recent memory. Whether it was Trevon was like the sun. I looked like the son I never had or the beer summit or downright mean country from Michelle or America's not an exceptional country any more than Greece or Great Britain. It's, it's, you know, I grew up with a lot of poor people and I was at Cal State and there was an African American couple, one of them was HIV positive and they were returning students and they were parents. They were in their 40s and they were history majors and they needed somebody to advise them on a senior history. I wasn't a member of the department, but I was there by association. I think at one point I had 11 master's students because I was at that time there wasn't a classical historian in the history department. I was a classical philologist in the foreign language. But anyway, the chairman said that we have these two people. They're kind of problematic. They're Older students, they're kind of angry. I didn't know what that meant. And we had. And that by that time we had a lot of Hispanic professors, a lot of women professors. I think we had one black professor, Asian professor. It was pretty integrated. And they asked me if I would be their advisors and meet with them every week. And I just, I didn't know who they were. And so I just said, well, I already have 11 students that I'm advising. And they said, no, nobody wants to advise them. I don't know why, but I did. And I met with them for 30 weeks, and it was during the O.J. trial. So we had lively conversations about the guilt or innocence of OJ But I got along with them wonderfully. I thought they were really admirable. And finally at the end, they were married. And he said to me, do you think a BA in history is really going to get me up into the middle class? I said, you're very well spoken, you're educated. What was your alternative? He goes, well, we would like to go to truck driving school and be a team. And I said, they make pretty good money. And so that's what they did. And I lost track of them. But they were very good friends. And my point is that I think most people don't really care what color of their skin or anything, if people will just get over it and treat people as people. But we can't seem to do that.
Jack Fowler
Yeah, well, we have to treat criminals as criminals. I'd like to think we do, and I'd like to think the Supreme Court would. And when we come back from these important messages, we're going to get Victor's take on the recent Supreme Court ruling on the Trump administration's use of the Alien Enemies Act. We'll do that when we come right back from this. In today's fast moving world, your team needs to stay connected to your customers without mixed messages, communication silos, or slow phone systems. A flexible and efficient business phone system isn't just nice to have, it's essential to succeed. Enter OpenPhone. OpenPhone is the number one business phone system that streamlines and scales your customer communications. It works through an app on your phone or computer, so no more carrying two phones or using a landline. With OpenPhone, your team can share one number and collaborate on customer calls and texts like a shared inbox. That way, any teammate can pick up right where the last person left off, keeping response times faster than ever. Plus, with AI powered call transcripts and summaries, you'll be able to automate follow ups, ensuring you'll never miss a customer interaction again. So whether you're a one person operation drowning in calls and texts, or have a large team that needs better collaboration tools, Openphone is a no brainer. See why over 50,000 businesses trust Openphone to manage their businesses calls and texts. Openphone is offering our listeners 20% off your first 6 months@openphone.com Victor that's O P E N P H O-N E open phone.com Victor and if you have existing numbers with another service Open Phone will pull port them over at no extra charge. Open Phone no missed calls, no missed.
Sponsor
Customers if you've been with us at all over the last six months or so, you are probably familiar with one of our favorite new brews, Wired to Fish Coffee. As you may know, their coffee is delicious and smooth, but more importantly, the company has amazing commitment to give back. Wired to Fish coffee gives back 25% of profits, 25% to conservation, clean water and things like missions and evangelical outreach. From river cleanups and initiatives for fish habitat to programs that give people in slums clean water and spread the word about Jesus. Wired to Fish Coffee is in it to make the world a better place. They also have just launched a medium roast decaf and for avid coffee lovers, their much loved brew is now available in 2 pound and 5 pound bags. Join us and enjoy your coffee while making a difference in the world and join a community of like minded coffee lovers. Subscribe and save today and enjoy discounted coffee and free freight or just give this great brand a try with discount code, Just news or justthenews for 10% off your first order. Head over to Wired Number 2 Fish Coffee today and make this year a year you align your coffee with your values.
Jack Fowler
We're back with the Victor Davis Hansen show recording on Saturday, May 17th. This episode is up on Thursday, May 22nd. Victor's got a website, the Blade of Perseus VictorHansen.com everything he does the weekly syndicated column, the weekly essay for American Greatness, other articles he writes, many appearances, archives of these podcasts that and more links to his books. I don't know how many 700 books Victor's written. I think well close to that. You and if you want to read the Ultra articles you'll see if you go there you'll see Ultra articles and a week weekly Ultra video. You need to subscribe in order to access those. 650amonth. $65 a year discounted. The Blade of Perseus if you're A fan of Victor. You're going to want to go there. And by the way, Father's Day is coming up. I think if your dad, you know, your dad loves Victor Davis Hansen, that would make a really wonderful Father's Day gift. Victor, before we get to the Supreme Court decision, you brought up General Milley again and you know, the, the he coats and all that. We have to look at these, I have to read these books and get educated. And I know in the last couple of years you've spoken so much about our, our generals and admirable admirals and some criticism of them, their violation of Section 88 and other things, but, and I know you've gotten guff from some military officials. Has anyone given you guff for that, for your criticism of Millie and for embracing this? We got to find the white supremacists. I, I, my, my gut tells me not really, but is, has that happened.
Victor Davis Hanson
In the sense that I was told by a colleague that a general said that I was exaggerating and that there was no such thing as di basically in the military, that it was just the same as all. And I had, when I, I had mentioned that there was a 45, 40 to 45,000 person shortfall and that person, officer said, high officer said that was due to gang activity, physical inability to meet basic standards, drugs. And I said those are constant throughout the last few days. What's new is DEI and especially the attitude of the Joint Chiefs and the public representations of the military that keep talking about white rage. And you couple that with the 8,500 that were drummed out for not getting the COVID experimental vaccine. Many of them are, from what I understand, the majority, vast majority white males. And there was a sense that white males didn't feel comfortable anymore in the military. And I had made the argument that, that whether you like that or not, there was a multi generational over representation, to use a, you know, a woke term, a disparate impact, a disproportionality that white males had inordinately joined combat units rather than instructive areas of the military to get skills and they had died at more than their demographics. And when you were going to have a shortfall of that particular group, you were going to be in trouble. Then I, I spent a great deal of time, I talked to a lot of statisticians, I looked at the deal, you can get the figures and it is true that when you looked at that 40 to 50,000 aggregate and all the branches of service shortfall, the one demographic that was Mostly, not entirely, but mostly responsible were white male. Now, in the first hundred days they have more or less met their recruitment goals. So if you want getting back to the Google question and their algorithms, if you Google recruitment restoration or recruitment rebounds, you know what you'll see. Trump unduly takes credit. This factor was already in the process when he was inaugurated. Trump should not take credit. And that gives the game away that he, you know, that that's what it was all about. So when Pete Hexseth repeatedly said, they're going to judge people on battlefield efficacy and the standards are going to apply to everybody regardless of race and gender and there was going to be no favoritism or bias and under promotion, retention, etc. Enlistment, then people felt that it was once again something that their family had always participated in. They were going to be the next generation to do so. But I had a lot of criticism about that. I had a lot of criticism about the revolving door that I said that I didn't think, I think there should be a waiting period before a four or three star admiral or general leaves the Pentagon before they go onto a defense contractor board. Because I don't think that our procurement necessarily is up to the latest developments on the battlefield. It seems to me that we're looking at drones, drones, drones, artificial intelligence, more rather than less more accessible, inexpensive platforms, you know, drones on the water, on land, in the air that can outperform human. And we're instead, we're just stuck on these very expensive, huge artillery platforms, huge carriers, $150 million jets, when we should be looking elsewhere from smaller, you know, companies. I got a lot of criticism for that. I wasn't directed at anybody, a colleague or anybody. But I got a lot of, there's something about if a civilian just looking at the military and worried about it, then you get, well, you never served or you, you know, you never did this and you don't know what you're talking about and how dare you. So I got, I've changed my attitude kind of radically about. I was also a professor at the U.S. naval Academy for a year. And I can tell you that I was the Nimitz guest professor for a while, for a week OR2 at UC Berkeley. I've taught at Pepperdine, Hillsdale, Stanford University for two years at visiting class at one year as a visiting class at center for Behavioral Studies. I can tell you at all these Cal State universities, I have never been in a more liberal place in my life than the U.S. naval Academy.
Jack Fowler
And that was 20 plus years ago, yes.
Victor Davis Hanson
2002 to three. I've never been in a place where it was so polarized. In the lounge of the history department, on one end there was CNN and the other end there was Fox. 70% of the professors were watching CNN. And I never had so much hostility there. It was very uncomfortable year. I did meet some great people, but four or five, but it was pretty nasty. And I never want to go back there again. I met great students. I had some of the best students I ever had. And I still communicate with a lot of them. They were really good students. And I met two or three of the best people I've ever met. Miles Yu was one of them. But I don't have a happy memory of the institution the way that I just didn't. There were some really nasty people I met there.
Jack Fowler
Well, Victor, there are nasty people who have been arrested by ice, sent back to Venezuela. And what happens the Supreme Court on Friday, and this would be on the 16th of May, decided in favor of an appeal by a group of Venezuelan migrants, they call them migrants in this story, who asked high court to halt their deportation under the Alien Enemies Act. This, I don't think, Victor, this overturned the use of this. I think it sent it back to a lower court to some degree, but not, not a win for the Trump administration. Justices Thomas and Alito dissented from the opinion. So there's a couple of things here, Victor. The actual decision and then this kind of animus, no conservatives, like, why did we get these? This is our Supreme Court, you know, with friends like these.
Victor Davis Hanson
Anyway, I just, I just don't understand that. You let in 10 to 12 million people. You don't audit them. You're kicking out people in the military that are not vaccinated. You have no idea whether they're vaccinated. You have no idea whether they have tuberculosis. They have no idea whether 500,000, as it turns out, were criminal. And you bring them all in and 75% that are given detained and given a car that they have to a hearing don't show up. And they're all here illegally. They all broke the law when they came, they broke the law when they reside. I don't understand why a law enforcement officer just can't politely go and get one person and say, you're here illegally and you have to go back to your home. I'm going to escort you back home and don't do this again. I don't know why there was no hearing required for them to come. Why didn't we just Say we have a wall or we have. And if you want to come to the United States, you have to apply as a legal immigrant. Why don't we put the onus on them? They didn't do what they were supposed to. We make people jump through all sorts of hurdles that come legally. They didn't. They came on the, the idea that they could break the law with impunity and if they stayed here long enough, their advocates would give them some type of rolling or blanket amnesty. So what I'm getting at is the court doesn't. I can understand what they're talking about, the niceties of the law, but would they just give us an option or would they give us a direction? How you deal with 10 million people in the last four years on top of 20 million other people who all are here illegally and broke the law? Do they all. Do the court really believe that we're going to have to have a 4 or 5 million dollar hearing for each of the 10 million people? Is that what it is? A suicide pact? And do they, do they know, do they care when they make these rulings? I mean they. Do they, do they understand the pragmatic. I was walking today at 6:30 in the morning around my perimeter. It's partly the 40 acres I own and partly the 120 acres we used to own, but the neighbor owns. And I can walk there. I walk and try to look for things, you know, if I see a broken emitter or somebody turned on a valve, I always turn them off or I notify the owner. So I try to. But I was walking today and I turned the corner and here was a car with a door open and here were two guys didn't speak English and they were. The door was open and they were snorting or using some kind of drug. And I walked. As I turned around, I had to walk within a foot of them. I had no idea who they were. I asked them something, they spoke Spanish. I don't know why they were trespassing. I don't know what kind of drug they were using. But why do. Is that what I'm getting at? They probably came here illegally and why do they understand what's happened when you put 10 to 12 million people in the United States? In other words, if you create 10 instant San Franciscos, what happens to those people the day after, the month, after the six months? Is it people in the inner city of Chicago that have to deal with them and not the people at Martha's Vineyard or Nantucket? Is it the people in Southwestern Fresno county that deal with them when they're bused here and not the people in Piedmont or Presidio Heights in San Francisco or Malibu or Brentwood. That's what the court doesn't seem to be aware of. That this was a catuscle plasmic event. It really did affect millions of people and it will affect millions of people for now on. And no one who broke the law and knowingly facilitate has ever paid a price. Why doesn't why Joe Biden and Mayorkas Majorca should have been convicted, didn't have the votes. But Joe Biden should have been impeached for this. He really should have. And there should have been some accountability. They deliberately destroyed the border for political purposes and no one cared. And the court didn't get involved at all. Never. And the court has no clue right now what to do. If you're a member of the Department of Interior or you're the member of the Homeland Security or you're a member of the DOJ and you go to the court and you say okay, we can't use the Enemy and Aliens act or we need to give a hearing before we deport this person who is admittedly here illegally and knew he was here illegally and came illegally. What do you how much do you want us to spend of 10 million people? Just tell us, just give us a figure. How much a million dollars is it? Do you want to spend 12, 15 billion dollars? Just tell us and just tell us what to do and we'll do it. And how many employees should we hire? Should hire another 200,000 to facilitate this. And should we give them much more deference than they gave us? They gave us zero deference. When they came in, they just took their middle finger out of us and said, you know what? This is what I think of your country because I'm just going to walk right through it. I'm going to live here and I don't care about your laws. And now we are going to consider them as the same as a citizen apparently. But they don't have any practical solutions. None. And that's the problem with the judiciary today. They operate in a vacuum and they don't offer unless you're on the left. And you know when they find they'll tell a school, you have to do this and you have to do this and they'll order people, but not when they're culpable. So.
Jack Fowler
Well, Victor, I want to take a moment for our one of our sponsors, longtime sponsor and great sponsor Hillsdale College. Did you know that Hillsdale offers more than 40 free online courses. That's right, more than 40 free online courses. Learn about the works of C.S. lewis, the stories in the book of Genesis, the meaning of the US Constitution, the rise and fall of the Roman Republic, or the history of the ancient Christian Church with Hillsdale College's free online courses. You can even take Victor Davis Hansen's class, the Second World Wars. This free seven lecture course will help you to understand this massive and complex conflict in a new way. Go right now to Hillsdale. Edu VDH to enroll. There's no cost and it's easy to get started. Started. That's Hillsdale. Edu VDH to enroll for free Hillsdale. Edu VDH and we thank the good people from Hillsdale for sponsoring the Victor Davis Hansen Show. Victor, before we head to break, I want to ask you to reflect on a piece you've written, mentioned earlier that you write these ultra articles for your website twice a week over the course of a year. It's the equivalent of, I believe, of two books of wisdom. And you have a series right now, I think you may have concluded it the Failure of Modernism. And I just want to read a little from part four of this particular series you wrote. Was the US a more stable and confident society with two parent, three children homes, or now with media, single parents or no children, couples? Did Winnie the Pooh, Alice in Wonderland, the Hobbit, the Jungle Book or the wizard of Oz offer young readers a better model of plot, character, language, grammar as well as ethics, morality and character than the teen books on the shelf in most public schools today? The Harry Potter books accepted. Would the workmen with those workmen, architects and city regulators of 1940, 50 with unsophisticated tools and technology have rebuilt the burned out neighborhoods of Los Angeles more quickly than our crews of today? Victor, what is the failure of modernism?
Victor Davis Hanson
Well, it's relativism that there is no standard of judgment or justice, that everybody can have situational ethics or personal environment. They can claim that they're exempt or they're deserving of some kind of special, special exemption because of something, some particular trade or experience or trauma. So it's relativism. There's no accountability in a democracy. You, you know, Tocqueville said that the problem with the democracy, and he was a big admirer of democracy, is that most people would rather be equal and poor than all better off, but some much better off. And that is what democracies from Athens on deal with is this institutional envy. And you can see it today with oligarchs. Oligarchs. Oligarchs. Oligarchs. Aristocrats. So you have somebody like AOC barnstorming in a private jet railing against oligarchs. Why? Her district that she's supposed to protect and represent is overrun with criminality, homelessness. It's a mess. But it's this constant demagoguery in the modern age. And then there's a lack of standards because of equity. We are so afraid of offending people. It's partly the therapeutic, you know, everybody is special. T ball. It's a T ball idea. And there's no winners, there's no losers. You don't keep score. There's always second, third, fourth, fifth chances. Used to be American second chances. That was it. But when you look at the decline, I mean they built the, basically the California Water project, the California Aqueduct. They built it in about five to six years. They couldn't do that. Today. They have no ability to do that. It's very funny because this is the most hubristic and arrogant generation that I can think of. They really believe that they are special and that they've done so much. But when you look at high speed rail or their freeway system, I don't. The United States is in decline. You mentioned Minneapolis. Does anybody believe that The Minneapolis of 1955 was a dirtier place than today? I think it was much cleaner. I think it was much more functional. So this happens in history. You know, one of the ways we created Greek mythology, it's believed there was this sophisticated Mycenaean kind of palace culture at Mycenae, at Tiryns. It's monumental architecture. They have a system of writing, linear B. And then we don't know why it collapsed. And then there was a dark age. And in this Dark age period, population declined by 90% probably. But people bumped into the stuff. They thought, wow, look at that arch, look at that 40 ton arch. We couldn't do that. We don't know how to read or write. What are all these little symbols on clay? And they started creating this myth of a once glorious time right about. But they were really talking about the Mycenaean period. But they made them into heroes like Achilles and Ajax and the gods, Zeus and everybody. In fact, some of the heroes that are in the Homeric epics, the names appear on linear B tablets as if they were just pedestrian Mycenaean lords or something that were exaggerated through periods of five centuries. And then when, you know, writing re emerge and you had the Greek city state but My point is that we're kind of like that today. I'm always like that when I go around California and I look at certain things that were created by others, like the aqueduct. Who built that? Who built all these reservoirs? My gosh, who built those penstocks over the grapevine? Tallest penstocks in the world. They pump all that water into Pyramid Lake. It's amazing. We're just custodians. We don't, we don't try any of these projects. And then we always are so judgmental about prior. These people were racist, they were homophobic, they were transphobic, they were horrible people. 16, 19, I think. What are they going to say about you? That you, you had a million abortions, 10,000 late term fetus killings in the birth canal? Are they going to say you had a million homeless people that were injecting, fornicating, urinating right in front of you every day on the sidewalks of your major cities? Are they going to say that you took a subway system that was very dysfunctional 30 years ago and made it almost impossible to ride at night? Is that what they're going to say of your generation? I think they will, but they're so self righteous and, and you know, a lot of it comes from the university. These, the university. Another thing, they do not want scrutiny. They're giving about 70 to 80% A's because these faculty members are terrified. Once they destroy the standards the last four or five years, they're terrified to know how to, they don't know how to grade because if they were to grade according to the actual performance, they would be giving 70% Fs and these and they would be, that would be the end of them. So we're in a period of decline. And when Donald Trump keeps talking about we're going to make America great again, everybody gets angry. But he's trying to do a counter revolution on every single level. Architecture, art, we talked about sculpture. But he's trying to restore some past standards. And maybe you think he's an imperfect vessel to be the catalyst for all that, but nevertheless, it's an effort to arrest what is going on now, to arrest biological men spiking a ball down the throat of a girl and claiming that that's fair. And the other thing is that people don't have any answers when confronted. I had a, a person talking to me about transgenderism. I just asked a simple question. If transgenderism is a separate category and men have no advantages over women, why do females that transgender to males, they're males, right? He said, yes, they're males. I said, why have they not won one major sports contest? Not one. And why do women. Women who transition don't win, and males who do transition to women win a lot. Can you explain why? Silence. And so anyway, this. Never have I seen a generation so full of themselves and for so little cause as this, my generation, and the next two below it. And we always make fun of, gosh, the idea that you could be attacked on December 4, and by September 2, four years later, you would have all of your enemies prostrate and destroyed. And then you turn around and rebuild them all. And then you turn around and fight a cold war against a nuclear powered monstrosity like the Soviet Union. And you'd win.
Jack Fowler
With half the people we have now.
Victor Davis Hanson
Yeah, with half. We couldn't do that today. We can't even deal with the Middle East. We can't deal with Iran.
Jack Fowler
Couldn't get the work permits.
Victor Davis Hanson
No, we can't. And so it's nothing to be proud of for this generation. If you look at a standard historical. And you know, we're. I've been shocked. I'm not going to mention the students in the situations where I met them, but I always thought the hope of your iPhone was you would have the world's cumulative knowledge over 2,500 years at your fingertips, and all these young people would be saying, I'm walking along and I see a Supreme Court column. Is it Doric? Make it on my phone and I'll find out whether it's Ionic, Columbian or Doric. That's not what it's useful. It's to take a selfie and say, this is what I'm doing today. Looking at a stoplight and then send it to somebody. Or worse. So all of the ancient arts and knowledge are being slowly lost. The ability to write cursive, the ability to speak well, grammar, syntax, the old pedestrian ideas of manners. That's why when I gave my Hillsdale graduation speech, I was really shocked, Jack, because it's the only place in the world, I think, on a campus. When I first got there, I mentioned in the speech that I left my bike there and it wasn't stolen the next day. I thought, man, that would have been gone in two seconds in Fresno State. And then the second thing, everybody was nice. Hi. Hello. Can I help you? I don't recognize you. Do you need any help looking at the library? No, I'm fine, thank you. Thank you. Are you Dr. Henson? No, I'm not a doctor. You know, it was just. Hey, you when you were teaching at Cal State or when I was at Santa Cruz as a student. And I mentioned that in these essays. So it's kind of. There's a word for guys like me. It's. It's a laudator temporis acti. Horace makes fun of him on one of his. What is it means an appraiser of the time that's gone by. An old funny duddy. And yet Horace has all sorts of things. He has another one. We are a gener. We are a bankrupt generation about to produce a generation worse than us that will produce a generation worse than themselves.
Jack Fowler
Well, we're conservatives. We're supposed to be conserving something, right?
Victor Davis Hanson
I hope so.
Jack Fowler
Yeah.
Victor Davis Hanson
I hope that the. I get so many nice. You know what keeps me going is the rare times I travel and I'm traveling a lot, but I hope it's rare. People come up to me and it's just amazing the stories they tell about themselves and they believe in the country and they work hard, they follow the rules. They're self educated or they're formally educated. It's about half the country really keeps it going. They're very capable people. And you know, there's 340 million people and you get up to 160, 170 really sharp people of all different races and classes. That's bigger than any European country, you know what I mean? That's what keeps the United States going. But it's not the people I read of every day in the Fresno B that have killed somebody in a drunk driving accident or stabbed somebody or shot somebody or stole something.
Jack Fowler
Yeah, the people you meet on your. In the. In the alleyways and amongst the vines.
Victor Davis Hanson
Almost every nine of us. My son, he stayed here one day and when I went. When I was in bed in Iraq, somebody gave me a bulletproof vest. I didn't need it because when I got over there the two times they made us wear the better ones with plates, but I still have it. So when he stays here, when he walks the dogs or not, he puts it on. He says, yeah, he says, I'm not stupid like you, dad. I'm gonna put on that vest.
Jack Fowler
Well, you know, I've been there. There's a Mad Max essence to your town, but there's also beauty, a great beauty to where you are.
Victor Davis Hanson
Also very beautiful area. It used to be one of the. One of the last things my grandfather told me was sitting out under this tree that's still here up a country. It was about June of 1976 and he said, this is the nicest place in the world. It was in early May. He said, this is the nicest place in the world. He explained why the sunset and the wind coming in Farm. All the different farmers who were so helpful, nobody had any key. You know, I don't think anybody has a lock on their door within us. It was a wonderful place and it's completely gone. I hope it's not a microcosm. I hope there's little renaissances everywhere. Maybe there'll be one here, something. I got a call yesterday from a painter. I'll call. I'll just give him a name. Jose. He's one of my favorite people. He paints everything I have. And if I don't have anything to paint and he shows up, I have him paint over something that's already painted. But he called up and said, I'd like to do a job painting. I'm really. I need to. I need to keep busy if I'm not busy. And, you know, it's kind of a lull. So we were talking about. This is. A guy had a kidney infection and he smelled all of these strong resins and turpentine, all these toxic chemicals. And he had to go up to Stanford for injections. And he never complained one second. He was one of my favorite people. And it wasn't because every five minutes he turned to me. Why was he painting? Tell me. Victor Trump is winning, right? He's going to win, right? I said, yes, he is.
Jack Fowler
You. You are the. The weather vane, my friend. Hey, Victor, when we come back, we have a little time. You know what? I think I will ask you about a movie or two and we'll do that.
Victor Davis Hanson
You haven't told me which one, so I might.
Jack Fowler
Well, not yet. Not yet. Yeah. No, it might be a free throw. Free throw. We'll do that when we come back from these floors. Final important messages.
Sponsor
You know when a new shirt or sweater just becomes your go to? That's what happened when I picked up a few pieces from Quince. They're the first things I reach for in my closet. Lightweight, comfortable, and always on point, Quince has all the things you actually want to wear, like organic cotton silk polos, European linen beach shorts, and comfortable pants that work for everything from backyard barbecues to elegant dinner parties. The best part, everything with quince is priced 50 to 80% less than what you'd find with similar brands. By working directly with top artisans and cutting out the middleman, Quince gives you luxury pieces without the crazy markups. And Quince only works with factories that use safe, ethical, responsible manufacturing practices and premium fabrics and finishes. My purchases from Quince Sweaters, shirts and vests are at the front of my closet and more often in my hamper. I like that they are comfortable and stylish, easy to clean, just like my other online store purchases, only much less expensive. Elevate your closet with quints go to quince.com Victor for free shipping on your order and 365 day returns. That's Q U I-n c e.com Victor to get free shipping and 365 day returns. Quince.com Victor and thank you Quince for sponsoring the Victor Davis Hansen Show.
D
I rarely trust the media anymore. It's so appealing, opinionated, fragmented and polarizing. Thankfully, I found Ground News to help me see through the misleading media narratives. Ground News is a platform that makes it easy to compare news sources, read between the lines of media bias, and break free from algorithms. Recently, I was using Ground News to dig into the economic impact of Trump's proposed tariffs. On the left, MSNBC ran with Trump aid says tariffs will raise $6 trillion, which would be the largest tax hike in U.S. history. Meanwhile, over at Fox News, the headline read, Trump's $6 trillion tariff plan aims to bring Jobs Back and reduce Reliance. So is this a devastating tax on American families or a bold move to protect US Industry and jobs? Whether you're worried about your grocery bill or your job going overseas, or you're somewhere in between, what we can all agree upon is that the media landscape makes it hard to know what's really going on. Ground News is what I use to step outside the echo chamber and see how every story is being told across the political spectrum. Go to groundnews.com start now to get 40% off the ground News Vantage plan and get access to all the of of their news analysis features. That's ground news.com start now for 40% off the ground News Vantage Plan for a limited time only.
Jack Fowler
We're back with the Victor Davis Hansen Show. You know what, Victor? I said we'll talk about movies. Would you first, though briefly, talk about since we have so many new viewers listeners, the strategica, the online journal you oversee for Hoover, which has a new issue on our Total little wars Obsolete. So maybe you want to give us a little take on what the new issue is and maybe also again for our new listeners viewers, just what Strategic is.
Victor Davis Hanson
It's a magazine of the Military History Working Group, which I founded 12 years ago under the auspices of our wonderful late Director John Racian and we bring anywhere from 30 now we're up to 50 scholars and maybe 50 attendants every year we fly them out and we, we discuss contemporary war in a closed session. We have a lot of four star generals, diplomats, politicians, military analysts. We try to get. I tried to select them on the basis of both their ability and expertise and record, but also that they don't agree with each other. So sometimes there's. It can be quite incisive and decisive and the disagreements. And then we publish every three to four weeks something called strategica. That's the Greek word for actually generalship in the plural, but it has come to mean strategy. And we have a background history. So if I pick the topic and do a poll and then the managing ever, David Berkey along with Bruce Thornton, he contacts the, he picks the contributors and then he shepherds the essays with Bruce who edits them as well. And then we, we compile this online magazine and there's a backgrounder that puts the question in a historical context. And we have kind of a pro or con. Sometimes they're both pros, both con. This time is, is, you know, as war absolute war, obsolete. Can you come to a strategic conclusion in the age of nuclear weapons? And we, I think, and I'm doing this by memory, Jakob Grego, who wrote the main essay and gives examples of wars that really cannot be decisively ended because they're proxy wars for nuclear powers or their existential crises, border wars. We just saw one with Pakistan and India. Those weren't absolute, but they can be retarded or bordered before they do become something that threatens the nuclear world. And then we had one by Chris Gibson. I think maybe he wrote about Clausewitz still matters as I remember that the people change, weapons change, modernity comes and goes, but human nature is constant. So the rules that Clausewitz saw in the Napoleonic war about what causes wars, who wins, who loses, why, how do wars end, pretty much are. Stay constant even in the age of bioweapons, AI and nuclear weapons. You know, everybody said the war is all over because of nuclear weapons. Well, who's to say? I mean there might be sophisticated lasers that can shoot the missile down in the first seconds. So defense offense, defense offense, counter response, response counter, counter. That always goes on. And then we had Gordon Chang also about whether you really know you're in a war yet. And I think he's been arguing for years that we've been in an existential war. We've China. He's been very critical, by the way of The Chinese Trump deal.
Jack Fowler
Oh, he has, yeah.
Victor Davis Hanson
He thinks that we didn't get enough out of China that the tariff wasn't the percentage of tariffs wasn't the key point. It was to enforce the fact that they cheat, they dump money, they manipulate currency, they steal patents and ignore copyright, et cetera. He's right about that.
Jack Fowler
For decades, listeners should know strategica is free. If you go on the Hoover website and. Or Google it or search for it, strategica, you will come to it. And I think this was issue 97, thereabouts. And many, most of the previous issues, I think, are quite evergreen.
Victor Davis Hanson
So. And I'm getting a lot of calls from people say, you, you wrote four books this year, Victor. I said, no, no, no, I did not write four books. But what the Hoover Institution has done, essays I wrote long time ago. They've been repackaged as email books, and I don't know anything about it. I lost. I mean, when you write for Hoover, they own it, but they're being recast as ebooks. So you press a button and then you go and say, if you want to read Victor's new ebook, then you can learn about Hoover or give. But I've had all these people ask me, did you write about populism? Did you? No, I didn't. I didn't.
Jack Fowler
Those are, you know, you can't. You can't go to a new website and not get a Hoover ad with big. Victor Davis Hansen.
Victor Davis Hanson
I know, and I didn't do it. I. I'm not criticizing Hoover. I'm just saying that they have taken essays in the past, that I wrote single essays and they relabeled them.
Jack Fowler
Books packaged. Yeah.
Victor Davis Hanson
And I don't. And they're used for promotional purposes, which, which helped me as a member of the Hoover Institution. So I have no complaint. I don't want to misrepresent myself that I'm. Well, if writing ebooks out there, you.
Jack Fowler
Are a machine of writing. Anyway. Hey again, Victor, this coming weekend, where we are, this episode is up on the 20. Did I say the 22nd? And coming up is Memorial Day weekend. I take this a little more seriously than I do any other federal holiday, and I think it deserves to be taken the most seriously. After all, Victor, remembering those who gave their lives for us, for our country, for our freedoms, and Turner Classic Movies, which I'm a junkie of, they drive me nuts a lot because they cannot help. But anytime someone wrote a movie who was one of the Hollywood blacklisted, they talk about Dalton Trumbull, like Joe Just shut up. These guys were communists. Yeah. Oh my God. You know, High Noon and all that. But they do run a marathon of 30 plus movies starting. We'll start tomorrow, Friday and it'll go through Monday. And terrific war movies. One or two is comedy like Kelly's Heroes, that kind of thing. But they have a couple. Few good movies. Have a lot of good movies. I just want to recommend a few myself. And Victor, if you have any thoughts on these or if there's any you want to tell us. I know about Dos Boot. You one of your favorite movies. But here are some of the movies that a Turner is showing. A Walk in the sun with Dana Andrews, which is I. It is a just a sensational movie, I think. Bridge on the River Kwai Battle.
Victor Davis Hanson
David Lean movie. That was great.
Jack Fowler
Oh yeah.
Victor Davis Hanson
Bill Holden, one of my favorite actors. I don't. Jack, he was in it too.
Jack Fowler
John Ford said he was his. He was the best actor ever. Jack Hawkins was.
Victor Davis Hanson
He's a good actor.
Jack Fowler
Oh yeah, terrific.
Victor Davis Hanson
He died early I think from lung cancer. He did, yeah.
Jack Fowler
He was in a great military war movie. Well, he was in bed. Yeah. But he was in the Cruel Sea.
Victor Davis Hanson
Yes.
Jack Fowler
Based on the book My Montserrat which is. Oh since. But it's not part of what Hoover show. Not who. What TCM showing. Last thing I'll mention is. Is very short movie. Black and White. The Red Badge of Courage.
Victor Davis Hanson
Audie Murphy, Stephen Crane. Yeah, that was good.
Jack Fowler
That's a beautiful movie.
Victor Davis Hanson
That was kind of like Mind Me of Incident at Owl Creek Bridge. Remember that movie? That was a. I've never even heard of that.
Jack Fowler
Really?
Victor Davis Hanson
That was a surreal movie it was based on. Was it Emerald Pierce, A short story. It's kind of crazy.
Jack Fowler
I could write that down.
Victor Davis Hanson
There's not a lot of great. I mean there was Gettysburg, that great mov four hour production.
Jack Fowler
Yeah. Well, it had its moments. A little round top. You can't help but think the portrayal there was phenomenal. It was just terrific.
Victor Davis Hanson
But it was. And. But there hasn't been a lot of great Glory was a good movie, but there hasn't been a lot of really good action. You know, like a Battle of Shiloh or something. That was right. A great movie. World War II is. I don't know. There's. As far as the production, the craftsmanship. I really like Saving Private Ryan, but there's something about it, the message I didn't quite connect with.
Jack Fowler
Yeah.
Victor Davis Hanson
That. That although there was a lot of irony in it and Das Boot was a great movie though. And so Was Downfall Hitler's Last Days.
Jack Fowler
Oh yeah. Much parodied or used for parodies?
Victor Davis Hanson
Yeah, yeah, yeah, that was, that was something else.
Jack Fowler
Yeah. One of my colleagues said he saw it in the movie theater. I said, then it was out on video. I said should I see it? He said you got to see it. You got to see it, boss. And I said, well, can I see it with my kids? Absolutely. Like there's no problem. Absolutely no problem at all. Well, the movie has this scene in it, Victor, if you don't remember where they're having chick, they're all drunk in the, in the furacella and they're having chicken fights with naked secretaries on the shoulders. Like thanks my, to my colleague. Thanks for. Well, my 10 year old son is watching that life experience. Anyway, I, I want to recommend folks check out Turner that not an advertiser here any. And and I do recommend honoring Memorial Day. It certainly deserves to be honored. Hundreds of thousands of people who find them in our cemeteries and they gave their lives for us. So Victor, you've been terrific today the show but I just want to read one or two comments from folks. Much of this is from YouTube. Here's one from Patty Chapman. 7296. Thank you so much Victor and Jack, I was a history major in college but went to computer science because of job prospects. I love watching your podcasts on YouTube. It doesn't matter if you're with Sammy or Jack. I get an update I know I can trust. It serves up a few served up with a few laughs. A great way to start my day. Thanks again. And then one last one. This will be from BECKT48. This is off of Rumble. And you, you often are wearing a hat.
Victor Davis Hanson
Victor, you're not today but writes I love baseball cap.
Jack Fowler
Yeah, that's okay. I love the hat. I appreciate your common sense approach to answers for today's problems. You give me hope for my great grandchildren's future. That's really lovely. Yeah. Thank you Beck T48 for your dear thoughts on Victor. Victor, we're gonna. Oh, I'm gonna tell people. Go to Civil Thoughts. I am going to tell people civilthoughts.com why are you going to go there? You're going to sign up for Civil Thoughts, the free weekly email newsletter I write for the center for Civil Society. Comes out every Friday, has 14 recommended readings. Great articles I've come across the previous week and I know you'll like it. Yes, my friend.
Victor Davis Hanson
I want to thank everybody who's sent me suggestions how to get Over a three month chronic sinus infection. I can tell you that I have not done the carnivore Carnivore diet. I'm considering maybe I haven't done intravenous cabovillin, but I have done. I got a navage. I do the Neti pot. I do steam. I've done Manuka honey sprays. I've done iodine sprays.
Jack Fowler
Wait, wait, wait, wait. What's a Manuka honey spray?
Victor Davis Hanson
What is that natural antimicrobial spray sprayed up your nose? Yes. And then I've done grape seed extract. I've done a German pill called Sinopret. I have done. Just a minute. There's another one. Anyway, I'm now on A doctor wrote me, I'm on a probiotic L. Lactobacillus case and I'm trying to spray that up to create a new culture. I've done doxacillin, I have done Z pack. So I did the antibiotic route. It just made me. Made it worse. It's a. It's a plumbing problem, you know, way up. I had my CAT scan as somebody suggested, and I have two blocked maxillary sinuses. It looks like cottage cheese on the. Stuck in there. So I'm scheduled for a surgery, but I'm trying every last thing to avoid it. But I really appreciate this is all. I appreciate what the people have sent me. It's amazing.
Jack Fowler
Would it be over 100? What have you gotten over a hundred recommendations?
Victor Davis Hanson
No, I've got about 15 to 20, but they're, you know, there are vitamins and, and X clear and put baby shampoo in your salt rinses. They all have scientific basis. Yeah, every one of them is not crazy, believe me. They're all. When I look at, you know, NIH studies, they all have some efficacy. The problem is that the more you read about. I've had this my entire life. Chronic sinitis for three or four months. And I used to get bombarded with steroids and. And then I had this massive operation five years ago where they cut my turbinates, they took out polyps, they straightened my septum, they drilled out my maxillary passages. I was wonderful. And then I got long Covid twice. And the ENT said when I went in there, he said, you're all stepped up again, meaning that the sinuses have collapsed. And I said, yeah. And he said, did you have a problem with COVID I said, yes, I have long Covid for nine months. I got it again for three months. Said most of his patients that had very Good success with surgery. Correctives for chronic sinitis had. Had Covid. And it created a. For some reason, in those types of patients like myself, it created kind of a chronic inflammatory condition that closed. Once the passage is closed and the sinus builds up, you can't sleep. It just. You know. So I'm hoping that I can open these up before surgery. So my strategy now, on recommendation of one of our most loyal readers, is to implant positive bacterial flora to kill. Strangle. Can I say the word? 86. The bad bacteria that have thrived with their help of the atomic bomb doxacillin. And maybe when I talk to you next time I'll be in Washington, D.C. i have one last trip and I will be breathing again without.
Jack Fowler
Well, just in case, I'm going to bring some baby shampoo to give to you.
Victor Davis Hanson
That stings. That. Tell you the truth.
Jack Fowler
Okay. Well, Victor, you in whatever state, you're.
Victor Davis Hanson
Trying to keep a good attitude about it because so many people have it. You wouldn't believe that. People say I had it for one year. I could hardly walk. I was fighting it off. I was cranky. I was obsessed. I was going crazy. And then I took horseradish or, you know, something that was a magic cure. And I'm trying all of them just because I have no limitations.
Jack Fowler
Well, horseradish will clear out your.
Victor Davis Hanson
I can't take steroids. That's the one thing. Because I used to take them. And I have glaucoma. And that's a. No, no. If you have glaucoma, you are one.
Jack Fowler
Of the most complex medical people I know. But you're one of the greatest people I know.
Victor Davis Hanson
I got bad genes. Well, or maybe I was too wrecked. I don't know. But my two siblings. I don't remember a day they've ever been sick. So. But I. You know, my parent. My mother died very young and my daughter. So I don't have great longevity in my. In my immediate family. If I stayed here, did what my grandparents did and just stayed on the farm and never left. My grandfather died in his sleep at almost 87, and he was 86 and a half. And my grandmother.
Jack Fowler
That's the plan to stay.
Victor Davis Hanson
None of their daughters lived over 66. Three of them. Anyway. I have your note. We're gonna see you soon.
Jack Fowler
See you in Washington. You'll see me and actually. And we'll eat over pancakes, maybe. Folks, you've been terrific for checking us out and stick with us. Thanks, Victor. You've been wonderful with all the wisdom you shared. We'll be back soon with another episode of the Victor Davis Hansen Show. Bye Bye.
Victor Davis Hanson
Thank you everybody.
Sponsor
If you've been with us at all over the last six months or so, you are probably familiar with one of our favorite new brews, Wired to Fish Coffee. As you may know, their coffee is delicious and smooth, but more importantly, the company has amazing coffee commitment to give back. Wired to Fish coffee gives back 25% of profits, 25% to conservation, clean water and things like missions and evangelical outreach. From river cleanups and initiatives for fish habitat to programs that give people in slums clean water and spread the word about Jesus. Wire to Fish Coffee is in it to make the world a better place. They also have just launched a medium roast decaf and for avid coffee lovers their much loved brew is now available in 2 pound and 5 pound bags. Join us and enjoy your coffee while making a difference in the world and join a community of like minded coffee lovers. Subscribe and save today and enjoy discounted coffee and free freight or just give this great brand a try with discount code. Just News or justthenews for 10% off your first order. Head over to Wired2Fish Coffee today and make this year a year you align your coffee with your values.
Podcast Summary: The Victor Davis Hanson Show - "From the Big Beautiful Bill to the Failure of Modernism"
Release Date: May 22, 2025
Hosts: Victor Davis Hanson and Jack Fowler
Co-Hosts: Occasionally joined by Sami Winc
In this episode, Victor Davis Hanson and Jack Fowler delve into a range of pressing political and social issues, including the ongoing debates surrounding the "Big Beautiful Bill," the contentious topic of reparations, recent Supreme Court rulings on deportations, and a broader critique of modern societal trends. The discussion is enriched with personal anecdotes, historical context, and sharp analysis of current events.
Date Recorded: Saturday, May 17
Release Date: Thursday, May 22
Discussion Highlights:
Spending and Debt: Victor expresses reservations about the Big Beautiful Bill (likely referring to significant infrastructure or economic legislation), citing concerns over increased spending and the national debt.
"Right now the biggest problem we have is debt, debt, debt, debt, $37 trillion in aggregate national debt, basically $2 trillion in annual deficits and 1.2 in trade deficits." ([05:59])
Bond Ratings: He criticizes Moody's downgrade of the U.S. bond rating as a politically motivated move, questioning the administration's fiscal policies despite positive economic indicators.
"Moody's... just lowered the bond rating of the United States government from Triple A to Aaa—for the first time in history since 1917." ([05:59])
Economic Growth vs. Incentives: Victor debates whether current tax breaks and incentives will effectively stimulate economic growth or merely exacerbate the deficit.
"When you're talking about giving tax breaks on tips on Social Security, on maybe military or first responders, that's going to take a while." ([05:59])
Discussion Highlights:
Legislative Attempts: The hosts discuss the resurgence of reparations proposals in Congress, spearheaded by Democratic Representative Summer Lee from Pennsylvania.
"Congressional Democrats have once again introduced legislation to force the government to pay for damages suffered by enslaved black families." ([09:53])
Victor’s Critique: Victor argues against the feasibility and fairness of reparations, pointing out the complexities of attributing historical injustices to present-day policies and the potential for an unmanageable system of payments.
"It's not going to work. It's 160 years since the end of slavery... What is, what do we do with the people who just arrived here as immigrants and have no experience with the American system at all?" ([11:58])
Broader Implications: He raises concerns about setting precedents that could lead to widespread demands for reparations from various groups, thereby complicating societal harmony and fiscal responsibility.
"Then you know what's going to happen? People are going to say, well, let's just then calibrate every particular group and we're going to measure what they gave and what they got." ([11:58])
Discussion Highlights:
Case Overview: The Supreme Court ruled against the Trump administration's use of the Alien Enemies Act to deport Venezuelan migrants, leading to significant political debate.
Victor’s Perspective: He criticizes the administration's immigration policies, highlighting the logistical and financial challenges of deporting millions of undocumented immigrants without adequate legal and infrastructural support.
"You bring them all in and 75% that are given detained and given a care..." ([37:18])
Judicial Inaction: Victor expresses frustration with the judiciary's inability to provide practical solutions, suggesting that courts often operate in isolation without considering real-world implications.
"But the court doesn't seem to be aware of that this was a catuscle plasmic event." ([37:18])
Discussion Highlights:
Impact of DEI Policies: Victor discusses the influence of Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) initiatives on military recruitment, particularly how they have affected white male participation and overall military efficacy.
"There's a sense that white males didn't feel comfortable anymore in the military." ([30:39])
Recruitment Challenges: He highlights a significant shortfall in military enrollment, attributing it to DEI policies and the subsequent demographic shifts within the armed forces.
"There was a multi-generational overrepresentation... white males had inordinately joined combat units rather than instructive areas of the military." ([30:39])
Structural Issues: Victor advocates for systemic changes, including stricter recruitment standards and reducing the revolving door between military leadership and defense contractors.
"I think there should be a waiting period before a four or three-star admiral or general leaves the Pentagon before they go onto a defense contractor board." ([30:39])
Discussion Highlights:
Relativism and Accountability: Victor criticizes modern societal trends, particularly the rise of relativism, lack of accountability, and the erosion of traditional moral and ethical standards.
"It's relativism that there is no standard of judgment or justice, that everybody can have situational ethics or personal environment." ([45:05])
Cultural and Infrastructure Decline: He laments the decline in infrastructural projects and cultural achievements, contrasting past feats like the California Aqueduct with current inefficacies in projects like high-speed rail.
"When you look at high-speed rail or their freeway system, I don't. The United States is in decline." ([45:05])
Generational Critique: Victor expresses disappointment in the younger generations, believing they lack the discipline and collaborative spirit necessary to tackle large-scale challenges effectively.
"I've never seen a generation so full of themselves and for so little cause as this." ([45:05])
Discussion Highlights:
In anticipation of Memorial Day, Victor and Jack share their favorite war movie recommendations, highlighting classics and discussing their impact:
"Das Boot": Praised for its intense portrayal of submarine warfare.
"The Bridge on the River Kwai": Commended as a masterpiece by director David Lean.
"The Red Badge of Courage": Recognized for its faithful adaptation of Stephen Crane's work.
"Saving Private Ryan": Appreciated for its craftsmanship, though Victor felt conflicted about its message.
"Downfall": Mentioned for its detailed depiction of Hitler's final days.
"Saving Private Ryan... there's something about it, the message I didn't quite connect with." ([67:35])
"But it was, you know, I grew up with a lot of poor people..." ([68:56])
Discussion Highlights:
Listener Appreciation: The hosts read and respond to positive feedback from listeners, acknowledging the support and sharing personal experiences.
"Thanks again. And then one last one. This will be from BECKT48... 'I appreciate your common sense approach to answers for today's problems.'” ([69:03])
Victor’s Health Struggles: Victor shares a personal update about his ongoing battle with a chronic sinus infection, detailing the various treatments he's tried and his scheduled surgery.
"I got two blocked maxillary sinuses... scheduled for surgery, but I'm trying every last thing to avoid it." ([71:30])
"I've had this my entire life. Chronic sinusitis for three or four months. And I used to get bombarded with steroids..." ([72:01])
Hope and Resilience: Despite his health challenges, Victor remains optimistic, expressing gratitude for the supportive community and sharing his strategies to overcome his condition.
"Trying to keep a good attitude about it because so many people have it. You wouldn't believe that." ([75:24])
In concluding the episode, Victor and Jack reiterate the importance of honoring Memorial Day, appreciate the listeners' support, and encourage continued engagement through their respective platforms—Victor's website, The Blade of Perseus, and Jack's Civil Thoughts newsletter.
On National Debt:
"Right now the biggest problem we have is debt, debt, debt, debt, $37 trillion in aggregate national debt, basically $2 trillion in annual deficits and 1.2 in trade deficits." ([05:59])
On Reparations:
"It's not going to work. It's 160 years since the end of slavery... What is, what do we do with the people who just arrived here as immigrants and have no experience with the American system at all?" ([11:58])
On DEI and the Military:
"There's a sense that white males didn't feel comfortable anymore in the military." ([30:39])
On Modern Societal Trends:
"It's relativism that there is no standard of judgment or justice, that everybody can have situational ethics or personal environment." ([45:05])
On Personal Health:
"I have two blocked maxillary sinuses... scheduled for surgery, but I'm trying every last thing to avoid it." ([72:01])
This episode of The Victor Davis Hanson Show offers a comprehensive discussion on significant political and social issues, blending rigorous analysis with personal insights. Victor Davis Hanson's perspectives on economic policies, reparations, military dynamics, and societal changes provide listeners with a thought-provoking examination of contemporary America. Coupled with recommendations for meaningful Memorial Day observances, the episode serves as both an informative and reflective piece for its audience.