When a One-Star Review Means You’ve Officially Arrived | Unfiltered & Unhinged

Summary

---

Episode Overview

Episode Title: When a One-Star Review Means You’ve Officially Arrived | Unfiltered & Unhinged
Host: Nicole Kalil
Release Date: May 1, 2026
Podcast: This Is Woman’s Work with Nicole Kalil

This episode is a raw, humorous, and heartfelt reflection by Nicole Kalil on receiving her podcast’s very first one-star review. Instead of shrinking from criticism, Nicole embraces the moment, using it as a springboard to discuss authenticity, the value (and limits) of feedback, and the liberating realization that "woman's work" includes refusing to seek universal approval.

---

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. Confronting Criticism and Finding Joy

• Nicole reveals the arrival of a dramatic one-star review titled "Immoral" and details her honest (and surprisingly joyful) reaction.
• She explains why receiving public criticism—especially when impersonal—can signal that her work is reaching and impacting people.
• Nicole notes:

  “It made me feel like we have arrived. Like someone out there is emotionally invested enough in this podcast to be mad about it. And that feels like a really big deal.” (02:18)

2. The One-Star Review in the Spotlight

• Nicole reads the review word-for-word, highlighting its theatrical formatting:

  "Subject line is one word and it says immoral. And then it goes on to say, just a show glamorizing the breakdown of the family unit... The word unit has its very own line and it’s capitalized... breakdown was written as two separate words instead of one.” (01:14)

• She laughs off the review, pointing out it doesn’t resonate or poke at her insecurities.
• Nicole shares a moment of petty satisfaction at the reviewer’s questionable grammar:

  “I found myself thinking just a podcast review glamorizing the breakdown of education.” (05:00)

3. Feedback as a Mirror

• Nicole expands on lessons the review inspired:
  • Not all feedback is valuable or relevant.

    “Just because somebody says it doesn't make it true or worth your time.” (03:52)

  • Feedback often reveals more about the giver.

    “It means you're not watering yourself down to be palatable to everyone else. Which is exactly the point of this podcast.” (03:13)

  • You decide what significance to assign to someone else’s opinion.

    “It is your job. It’s within your power to decide what somebody else's opinion means to you, if anything.” (04:12)

4. Irony and The Algorithm

• Nicole revels in the irony that negative reviews still help her show’s visibility:

  “Algorithms do not care whether the review is glowing or scathing… So to the person who questioned my morality, thank you for helping boost our visibility. You may hate the show, but you accidentally supported it.” (05:33)

5. Embracing Authenticity and Rejecting Universal Approval

• Nicole affirms her commitment to the show’s spirit of authenticity and encourages listeners to do the same:

  “I no longer need to contort myself to be palatable to somebody else. And I certainly don’t need approval from somebody who thinks that a woman advocating for all of us to do what’s true and real and right for you is somehow destroying the family unit.” (06:11)

• She encourages fans to leave their own reviews (for algorithmic balance!) but reassures that those who disagree are free to “unsubscribe and move on.”

6. Encouragement for Listeners

• Nicole closes with a rallying cry for resilience:

  “Keep showing up, keep trusting yourself, and let the noise sort itself out. It turns out not everybody’s going to like you, and that might just be the clearest sign that you’re doing something right.” (06:46)

---

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• On Not Taking Feedback Personally:

  “If they'd said she rants too much, I probably would have to nod and say, yeah, that tracks... But this review, it didn’t touch a thing. It didn’t poke at any insecurities. It didn’t feel true, and it didn’t land.” (01:50)

• On the Joy of Haters:

  “I’ve had haters before, but this was the first public podcast hate... And weirdly, I loved it. It felt official.” (02:25)

• On the Core of "Woman’s Work":

  “I’m going to keep showing up. I’ll keep ranting... But I won’t ever shrink to keep the critics comfortable.” (06:24)

---

Timestamps for Key Segments

• 00:35 – Nicole introduces the one-star review
• 01:14 – Dramatic reading and playful critique of the review
• 02:18 – Discussing validation through criticism
• 03:13 – Core lessons about feedback and authenticity
• 05:33 – The irony of negative reviews boosting the show
• 06:11 – Reflections on self-approval and audience engagement
• 06:46 – Final message of support and empowerment to listeners

---

Episode Tone & Style

Nicole’s tone is warm, witty, candid, and encouraging—unfiltered and unhinged, as promised. She blends vulnerability with humor, using her personal experience to empower listeners to own their voices boldly, regardless of outside approval.

---

Takeaway Message

Keep showing up, unapologetically authentic, and let criticism roll off. The fact that someone dislikes your work may be the best signal that you’re on the right track—because “that is woman’s work.”

Transcript

[A]

I don't overthink and wait on things in my business the way that I used to. If something needs to get built, fixed, designed or analyzed, I'm not adding it to a someday list or dragging out some hiring process. Because the reality is, most of the time, I don't need a full time hire. I need the right expertise and I need it right now. And upwork makes it easy to hire specialized freelancers quickly so you can get the expertise you need to now without weeks of recruiting or training a full time hire. You can browse profiles and find specialized talent across over 125 categories. You can review past work and get help scoping the role so you can hire with confidence and get started quickly. It's free to sign up and posting a job is easy. Visit Upwork.com right now and post your job for free. That's Upwork.com to connect with top talent ready to help your business grow. That's Upwork.com Upwork.com. I am Nicole Khalil and you're listening to the this Is Woman's Work podcast. The Unfiltered and Unhinged Edition. Short episodes, Big truths. Absolutely zero. Perfection. Okay friend, it happened. We got our very first one star podcast review and I gotta be honest with you, I am irrationally happy about it. I wish I could show it to you, but since this is an audio recording, I'm gonna have to read it like I heard it in my own head. So here it is in all of its glory. The subject line is one word and it says immoral. And then it goes on to say, just to show glamorizing the breakdown of the family unit. Now you can't see this, so you're going to have to trust me. The word unit has its very own line and it's capitalized so it actually reads like this just to show glamorizing the breakdown of the family unit. And okay, this is even more petty of me, but breakdown was written as two separate words instead of one. I mean, what a moment. I read it kind of blinked a couple times and then immediately burst out laughing. Because here's the thing, none of that felt true to me. Now if they would have said she rants too much, I probably would have to nod and say, yeah, that tracks. If they'd said I wish she'd get her act together and launch an in person video podcast, I'd have to cringe a little. Because yeah, I do feel behind on that. But this review, it didn't touch a thing. It didn't poke at any insecurities. It didn't feel true, and it didn't land. It felt like it said everything about them and nothing about me. And if I had to guess, I'd bet they'd be horrified to know just how much joy their angry little review brought me. In a strange, probably, possibly twisted way, it made me feel like we have arrived. Like someone out there is emotionally invested enough in this podcast to be mad about it. And that feels like a really big deal. I've had haters before, but this was the first public podcast hate. The kind where somebody clicked one star, wrote a dramatic title, invested their time and energy, and hit submit. And weirdly, I loved it. It felt official because I have always believed that if you're doing something bold, meaningful, or really anything worth doing, there will be people who don't like it. Hell, there will be people who hate it. And that's part of the deal. It means you're not watering yourself down to be palatable to everyone else. Which is exactly the point of this podcast. So here are a few important things that this review helped me reconnect with that I kind of want to pass forward to you. The first thing is not all feedback is valuable or worth listening to. Just because somebody says it doesn't make it true or worth your time. The second, feedback often reveals more about the person giving it than the person receiving it. Third, it is your job. It's within your power to decide what somebody else's opinion means to you, if anything. And this isn't a takeaway, but I feel like it's worth pointing out I do have a petty streak and loved that the grammar in this review was, let's call it questionable at best. I found myself thinking just a podcast review glamorizing the breakdown of education. But again, that says more about me than the person who wrote the review. And listen, grammar aside, I almost want to frame the damn thing. And here's what I'm just going to call the delicious irony of it all. Even bad reviews help the show. Algorithms do not care whether the review is glowing or scathing. To the algorithm, engagement is engagement. So to the person who questioned my morality, thank you for helping boost our visibility. You may hate the show, but you accidentally supported it, which I find incredible. Look, we all have our stuff. I've got my insecurities, my blind spots, my places that I want and need to grow. But this wasn't that. This was a badge of honor. A very public, very dramatic, possibly questionable badge of honor. So yeah, I'm celebrating not the insult, but the reminder that I no longer need to be liked by everyone. I no longer need to contort myself to be palatable to somebody else. And I certainly don't need approval from somebody who thinks that a woman advocating for all of us to do what's true and real and right for you is somehow destroying the family unit. I'm going to keep showing up. I'll keep ranting. I'll eventually figure out video. Or maybe I won't. But I won't ever shrink to keep the critics comfortable. So thank you to you, my listener, for being here, for listening, for liking or even lovingly disagreeing with whatever it is that I have to say. And if at any point you don't like it, I trust that you'll do what mature, emotionally intelligent people do unsubscribe and move on with your life. But if you do love the show, feel free to balance out that one star review with a review of your own. The Algorithm loves the love, and I appreciate it so much too. So here's my message. I guess really what I'm trying to say here. Keep showing up, Keep trusting yourself, and let the noise sort itself out. It turns out not everybody's going to like you, and that might just be the clearest sign that you're doing something right. So keep showing up. Because that is woman's work.

[B]

Save on Family Essentials at Safeway and Albertsons this week at Safeway and Albertsons, fresh cut cantaloupe, watermelon, pineapple or Melon Medley Bowls 24 ounces are $5 each and Wild Caught Lobster Tails are $4.99 each. Limit eight member price plus selected sizes and varieties of Doritos, Lays, Cheetos, Sun Chips and Kettle cooked chips are $1.99 each limit for member price. Hurry in. These deals won't last. Visit safewayoralbertsons.com for more deals and ways to save.

[C]

What do you get when you take two childhood friends with a passion for unexplored history and a whole lotta booze?

[A]

You get us Queens Podcast and here

[C]

at Queens, we are spilling the tea on all kinds of women from history.

[A]

From New Orleans Voodoo Queen Marie Laveau to Marie Antoinette and everything in between.

[C]

Each queen is paired with a cocktail recipe that will totally get you in the mood to hear the fun, dramatic and juicy stories of fascinating women from history.

[A]

Listen wherever you get your podcasts.

[C]

Cheers.