Summary of "Heather MacMahan is Our House Bunny" – Trash Tuesday Podcast

Episode Release Date: July 15, 2025

In this vibrant and candid episode of Trash Tuesday, hosts Khalyla Kuhn and Annie Lederman welcome the renowned comedian and podcaster Heather McMahon as their special guest. The conversation spans a wide array of topics, from personal adventures in Hawaii to deep dives into relationships, health, and the quirks of everyday life. Below is a detailed breakdown of the key discussions, insights, and memorable moments from the episode.

1. Hawaii Adventures and Surfing Experiences

The episode kicks off with the hosts sharing their recent trip to Hawaii, setting a relaxed and playful tone.

• Heather McMahon reminisces about her summers spent at Pasquet Surf Camp in San Diego during her junior high to high school years. She fondly recalls surfing alongside legends like Kelly Slater and developing a passion for the ocean despite being from landlocked Atlanta.

  [01:33] Heather McMahon: "I used to shred the gnar. I was landlocked in Atlanta, but Blue Crush came out, and my parents took me to Hawaii. I found my destiny there."

• The discussion highlights the liberating experience of surfing and how it shaped Heather's connection with the ocean.

2. The Concept of "Podcast Personality"

Annie Lederman introduces the idea of "podcast personality," describing it as a heightened state of reaction and engagement shaped by constant podcasting.

• Annie Lederman self-identifies with this persona, explaining how podcasting has trained her to react intensely to everyday topics to avoid "dead air."

  [07:18] Annie Lederman: "I've officially clinically diagnosed myself with podcast personality. It's like you can't just listen; you have to react and add information."

• Khalyla Kuhn adds her perspective, relating it to her own experiences of socializing and the fear of being perceived as annoying.

  [08:37] Khalyla Kuhn: "You're so right. I think this is why I've been a hermit. I don't like to socialize as much because I'm afraid of being that person."

3. Diet Coke and Health Anecdotes

A humorous yet insightful conversation unfolds around Diet Coke consumption, personal health habits, and the challenges of maintaining a balanced lifestyle.

• Heather McMahon shares her struggle with Diet Coke addiction, attributing it to her father's health issues linked to excessive consumption.

  [12:10] Heather McMahon: "My dad... I think he died of pancreatic cancer because he drank like 12 Diet Cokes a day. So I gave them up for 10 hard years."

• Annie Lederman discusses the complexities of reconciling past habits with current health consciousness.

  [13:14] Annie Lederman: "I'm longing for the days before I knew about cortisol spikes and ruining my guts. Five years ago, I would drink a giant black iced coffee and feel on fire all day."

4. Heather McMahon’s Plastic Surgery Journey

Heather opens up about her experiences with plastic surgery, detailing the challenges and humorous mishaps along the way.

• She recounts undergoing neck surgeries twice due to conservative medical approaches, using these experiences as material for her comedy.

  [16:15] Heather McMahon: "I had to get plastic surgery on the same spot twice. I never thought I'd be that person sharing stories about undergoing lipo on my neck."

• Heather emphasizes the importance of self-acceptance and dismissing negative comments.

  [17:14] Heather McMahon: "Nobody tells you that healing is linear. Don't change anything about yourself and don't listen to the negative comments. You're beautiful."

5. Long-Distance Relationships and Marriage

A heartfelt segment delves into Heather's long-distance relationship with her husband, Jeff, highlighting the dedication and mutual support that sustained their bond.

• Heather McMahon shares how they met in New York and navigated an eight-year long-distance relationship, ultimately leading to marriage.

  [73:28] Heather McMahon: "We were long distance for almost eight years, but we made it happen. I knew he was the right guy when he supported my dreams without holding me back."

• She offers advice to listeners about the viability of long-distance relationships when both partners are committed.

  [74:06] Heather McMahon: "When it's good, it's peak. If you're unsure in the early stages, it's not the relationship. It will only get harder as you move forward together."

6. Taste Test: Different Types of Cokes

In a playful and interactive segment, the hosts and Heather conduct a taste test of various Coca-Cola beverages to determine if listeners can distinguish between them.

• Jules and Heather engage in tasting different Cokes, leading to humorous reactions and debates about flavor differences.

  [47:14] Jules: "I think this is Diet Coke."

  [47:26] Khalyla Kuhn: "The second one was Diet Coke. You said it was spicy."

• They conclude that Mexican Coke stands out due to its use of real cane sugar, attributing a distinct and superior taste to it.

  [48:18] Heather McMahon: "Mexican Coke has real cane sugar. It's a cure-all for a hangover; it just hits different."

7. Personal Relationships and Family Dynamics

The conversation shifts to personal relationships, discussing the dynamics of living with family members and maintaining healthy boundaries.

• Khalyla Kuhn and Heather McMahon talk about living with parents and the challenges that come with it, especially when considering starting a family.

  [31:03] Heather McMahon: "I might need a crash pad or my own apartment where nobody can bother me. But I still want my mom close by for support."

• Heather shares anecdotes about her mother's active desire to date post-widowhood, adding a humorous twist to family interactions.

  [73:55] Heather McMahon: "My mom's been widowed for 10 years and is looking to date again. She's the hottest mom on the planet and deserves someone to travel the world with."

8. Final Thoughts and Closing Remarks

As the episode wraps up, the hosts and Heather reflect on the shared experiences and the importance of authenticity in relationships and personal growth.

• Heather McMahon encourages listeners to embrace their true selves and live life fully, emphasizing the support from her friends and family.

  [76:00] Heather McMahon: "Don't live it small, bitch. Do not."

• The hosts express their appreciation for Heather's participation, highlighting the enriching conversations and the bonds formed through shared stories.

  [76:07] Annie Lederman: "We're manifesting that for you and for Robin. Heather, thank you so much."

Notable Quotes with Timestamps:

• [01:33] Heather McMahon: "I used to shred the gnar. I was landlocked in Atlanta, but Blue Crush came out, and my parents took me to Hawaii. I found my destiny there."

• [07:18] Annie Lederman: "I've officially clinically diagnosed myself with podcast personality. It's like you can't just listen; you have to react and add information."

• [12:10] Heather McMahon: "My dad... I think he died of pancreatic cancer because he drank like 12 Diet Cokes a day. So I gave them up for 10 hard years."

• [16:15] Heather McMahon: "I had to get plastic surgery on the same spot twice. I never thought I'd be that person sharing stories about undergoing lipo on my neck."

• [73:28] Heather McMahon: "We were long distance for almost eight years, but we made it happen. I knew he was the right guy when he supported my dreams without holding me back."

• [48:18] Heather McMahon: "Mexican Coke has real cane sugar. It's a cure-all for a hangover; it just hits different."

• [76:00] Heather McMahon: "Don't live it small, bitch. Do not."

This episode of Trash Tuesday offers a blend of humor, vulnerability, and insightful discussions, providing listeners with relatable content and heartfelt advice. Heather McMahon's presence adds depth and relatability, making the conversation both entertaining and meaningful.