
After Midnight ////// 781 Part 1 of 1 www.TrueCrimeGarage.com Katara Johnson was a vibrant, young woman with a zest for life. On August 25, 2004 Katara worked the late shift, leaving work at midnight and heading home. By morning, her car was gone, and her family could not get in touch with the 21 year old. Less than 24 hours after leaving work, Katara was found dead. This homicide case remains open today, 20 years later. What happened to Katara in the middle of that night? Any one with information about the murder, Katara’s car, or a gathering that Katara attended days before the murder should call the Taylor Police Department at 512-352-5551, or to remain anonymous call Crime Stoppers at 1-800-253-7867. Beer of the Week - Lone Star Beer (the beer of Texas) Garage Grade - 3 and a quarter bottle caps out of 5 For all things True Crime go to our website www.TrueCrimeGarage.com and while you’re there check out the Garage Sale on the store page. More True Crime Garage c...
Loading summary
Commercial Narrator
All of us strands are in real danger. And whatever it is, it's closing in. It started with just a few lost hairs here and there. But now more and more of us are disappearing every day. But listen, we think we have a plan. A way to stop the shedding. Pantene Abundant and strong. Go now. It's not too late. Pantene Abundant and Strong. It's a three step system that reduces hair loss by 85%. Only the strongest will survive the shedding.
Nick
Hey, it's Ryan Reynolds here for Mint Mobile. Now I was looking for fun ways to tell you that Mint's offer of unlimited Premium Wireless for $15 a month is back. So I thought it would be fun if we made $15 bills. But it turns out that's very illegal. So there goes my big idea for the commercial. Give it a try@mintmobile.com Switch upfront payment
Commercial Voice
of $45 for three months, $90 for six months or $180 for a 12 month plan. Required $15 per month equivalent taxes and fees. Extra initial plan term only greater than 50gb.me slow when network is busy. See terms SA.
Nick
Welcome to True Crime Garage wherever you are, whatever you're doing. Thanks for listening. I'm your host, Nick and with me as always, is a man whose stolen bike is rumored to be in the basement of the Alamo. Here is the Captain.
Captain
Well, I guess I have to walk everywhere now. It's good to be seen and good to see you. Thanks for listening. Thanks for telling a friend.
Nick
This week we are very happy to be featuring Lone Star. Original Lone Star beer uses the finest hops with hearty grains from the central and northern plains added with malted barley and corn give this beer its full natural flavor. Choice hops lend complexity and aroma to the solid balance of alcohol, body and character. A this is the national beer of Texas. ABV 4.7% garage grade. Three and a quarter bottle caps out of five. And how about a cheers to our extended garage family. First up, a shout out to Shannon Hauser in Springfield, Ohio.
Captain
And a big we like your jib to Matthew in New Britain, Pennsylvania.
Nick
Next we got a shout out to Jen in Middleborough, Massachusetts.
Captain
And a big shout out to another gen in Blues Creek, North Carolina.
Nick
Here's a long distance cheers to Brian in Phoenix, Arizona. I love Arizona. I'll be in Phoenix in October. And last but certainly not least, we have a double fisted cheers to Eitan and carrie in Port St. Lucie, Florida. That's our good buddy and awesome wife from Crimecon. Cheers and thank you to everyone who contributed to the beer fund.
Captain
Yeah, BWWAN beer run. Go to true crime garage. Sign up on the mailing list, and we'll love you forever. And, Colonel, that's enough of the P.S.
Family Member
in the house.
Nick
All right, everybody gather round. Grab a chair, grab a beer. Let's talk some true cr.
Family Member
Right now, at this particular time, everybody's hurting. We all hurting, and, you know, we're all concerned.
Investigator/Reporter
Rodney Johnson says he's trying to stay strong.
Family Member
And I spent the day with her on Wednesday and I never thought that that would be my last day that I would see my niece.
Investigator/Reporter
On Thursday night, 21 year old Katara Johnson was found dead inside her home. She lived there alone, her body discovered lying in the hallway. Her family says they found no blood or obvious signs of a violent struggle.
Family Member
Why? You know, Katara was a very beautiful person. She loved everybody. Everybody loved her.
Nick
I mean, I tell Tara everything. That was my girl for real. I mean, that was my only friend that I had, really.
Investigator/Reporter
Tisha Brinson worked with Katara at this nearby Taco Bell. That's where Katara was last seen driving home from her job as a manager on Wednesday night. But neighbors say her car disappeared outside her house only hours after she got home. Presumed stolen by her killer, it was eventually found by detectives late Thursday. But investigators are not saying where.
Family Member
Taylor's been good to us. I mean, for this to happen here in Taylor, it's unbelievable. It seems like a nightmare, a bad dream.
Investigator/Reporter
Investigators must now piece together who is responsible. Family and friends say they have no idea who would want to do her harm.
Family Member
You know, my mother is on one side of her and I'm on the other side of it. She's right in the middle. I mean, if you, you know, if there had been some noise or something like, you know, we would have heard.
Nick
She was the type of person that kept us going and kept us happy.
Family Member
Like I said, she was special. And she's going to be missed. She's definitely going to be missed.
Nick
This week we bring to you a
Narrator/Host
true crime story that is what many would call a small town murder. Unfortunately, not many people outside of that town of about 15,000 have had much awareness of the murder of Katar Johnson. Katara was a hardworking young woman. Many would say that she had her whole life ahead of her. I say that she had her whole life right in front of her. She was a decisive individual. She knew what she wanted and she was willing to work hard for it. She set goals, made a plan, did her darndest to make it happen. So what happened to Katara? Who killed her? And just how many people in and around that town know the truth? Today, multiple agencies are working together to get those answers. The Taylor police, along with the Texas Rangers and the Department of Public Safety are investigating this homicide. And now many of you will be hearing it for the first time. This is True Crime Garage and this is the still unsolved homicide case of Katara Johnson.
Nick
This week we are heading down to the great state of Texas. We wish we were here for happier reasons, but we promised to try to do some good while we're here if we can. This week we explore a still unsolved homicide case out of Taylor, Texas. Taylor is near Austin, about 45 minutes northeast of Austin. Taylor is in Williamson County. Today the population of Taylor is about 16,000. And at the time of our case, we are looking at close to 14,000 people. We are taking everyone back to August of 2004. I think we should start the timeline off for today's case on Saturday. This is Saturday, August 21st. We have 21 year old Katara Johnson. She is living out on her own. And on this Saturday, this is where we get the first part that's a little bit difficult to report in our coverage here on this unsolved case.
Captain
Well, that's because the details from everybody are a little wonky. Donkey.
Nick
On the Saturday, August 21, it's been reported a few different ways that there was either a party, an event, a gathering, and you can look and define those words any way that you please. But the general statement is that she was at an event or gathering that took place at a park down the street from her house. Some of the reports state that Qatar was the host of this get together. I am honing in on this part of our timeline because it seems to have some relevance or at least law enforcement believes that this could have some big time relevance to the case.
Captain
Well, it's strange because people don't know if she was the host or if she's just there. And some people at the party don't even know why the party was happening. Was it somebody's birthday? Was it an engagement party? Was it a baby shower? Nobody knows. So she attended. Or maybe she hosted this party on Saturday. But let's go to the following Wednesday, the day of the crime.
Nick
Yeah, we are going to go to Wednesday, August 25, 2004 at midnight that night. This is when the report is that she is last seen. She's alive, well and fine. At midnight on August 25, Qatar was working the late shift at the Taco Bell in Taylor, Texas. She was incredibly athletic at one time, was even offered a basketball scholarship, but the school was too far away for Qatar. She didn't want to be that far away from her parents, so she turned down the basketball scholarship. She goes on to have her own place. She's living in a trailer home, but it's not like last week's case where we're talking about a trailer park. This seems a lot more rural to me and we'll get into that here in a minute. But back to her working life. So she's doing her thing. She's a manager at this Taco Bell. She's closing down the shift for the evening. And she's last seen getting into her vehicle leaving the Taco Bell parking lot at approximately midnight that night. The following day on Thursday is when the alarm bell is rung multiple times. Family was having some issues because they say that they drove by her home and her vehicle wasn't outside. Now we want to point out here that her grandmother lives on one side of her and her uncle lives on the other side of her. But again, it's not, not a park like setting. These are more spaced out based off of what I've seen, the videos I have seen. Yeah.
Captain
So basically the family owned a plot of land and they had three different trailers on that plot of land.
Nick
She was living alone in the middle one. Her family becomes concerned because they are used to seeing her car parked out front. Her car is nowhere to be seen and people have tried calling her cell phone. She's not answering. It's around 7pm that night when they get increasingly concerned. This is because by this point she's not shown up for her shift at the Taco Bell. Again, she's a manager, she's quite responsible. It's unlike her to not show up for work at 8:40pm that night. Qatar's family is so concerned because that they have not heard from her. She's not answering her phone. She didn't show up for the evening shift at Taco Bell. Her 73 year old grandmother, this is Helen Rance, she lives next door. She and a six year old go over to Katara's home, knock on the door. The front door is locked, so the grandmother decides to open up a window and send the little one in to unlock the front door. And this is where things go from bad to worse. Grandmother Helen goes into the trailer home and finds Katara lying there lifeless and she calls the police. And now we have Taylor, Texas PD on the scene.
Captain
Well, not only do we have a murder victim, but we have her car missing.
Nick
This is where the evidence gets a little strange. Okay, so we have the car missing like the captain had said. And with that we got the car keys missing. And Katara's cell phone is missing as well. Now her family is on record later saying that other than that they didn't find anything else to be missing from the home. Again, reported a few different ways here. It's. It's stated in some reports that guitar was found in a hall way leading to the bedroom. Other reports, it seems like the most reliable reports here Captain are saying that she was found in the bedroom which would make sense based off of the description we get from grandmother with sending in the. The little kid. Thankfully he didn't see her if she was in the bedroom. Before unlocking the front door and allowing Helen to come in. The police immediately call in other agencies. They do their due diligence by calling in other agencies. Here this, keep in mind, we are at August, August 26th of 2004. This is their first reported homicide in Taylor of that year. The last time that they had had a homicide in Taylor, Texas was around Thanksgiving the year prior. So murder is not a commonality here in this city. They call in other agencies and one thing that they decide to do is we are going to keep the way that she was killed close to the vest. We're not going to give out those details until a later date eventually. What we learn is that she was shot and unfortunately was killed with a large caliber handgun. We don't have any better of a description than large caliber handgun and it's been reported that it may have been one shot there. There are some reports out there that say shot multiple times with a large caliber handgun. Again, with this being a detail that law enforcement doesn't want to go into great detail about, we do not know the exact specifics at this time in those reports. We also learn that when she was found that she was there was blood on her face, neck and hands and a blue and white nightgown laying across her body. So the speculation here by her family is that she would have been in the process of getting ready to go to bed, which makes sense. It's late at night, she's done working for the day, she's back at home. Her Mitsubishi Lancer is missing. This is a maroon vehicle at the home. Again, keys missing, cell phone missing, car missing. There's no weapon found. The murder weapon is not found inside the home.
Captain
Yeah, no gun Found at the scene of the crime. But I think a big thing for law enforcement is where did her car go? If we know that she worked that night? Well, let's just talk to people at her work. Did she drive home? And once they find out, oh, well, she left the shift and she was driving her car, then you go, well, now this car becomes our best lead. And what have we said a million times on this show, a lot easier to find a vehicle than it is a person.
Nick
And the thing here too, Captain, is this is going to be something that wipes away a big question mark for her family. Think about this in the moment on that Thursday, in the early goings of that Thursday when Katara is missing in action, vehicle can't be. It's not seen at her home as family would expect. She's not answering her cell phone. As a parent, as a grandparent, as her uncle, anybody involved in this situation, their worry is going to be that she's working late. She never made it home that night. Well, we unfortunately now know that she did in fact make it home that night. So it stands to reason that her car made it home that night as well. But now she is having been murdered in her own home and the vehicle is gone, keys gone, cell phone gone. So of course police are going to want to look for and find that vehicle and see what the missing vehicle has to do in relationship with our homicide victim here. They do locate. The vehicle is eventually found at a public pool. So this would be one of those community pools that you could pay to have a day pass, maybe you have a season pass to go into. Is found in the parking lot for this community pool in another town.
Captain
Yeah, it's about 12 miles away from her house.
Nick
And this town, I believe it was Thornville. I've been told that it's, it's located between Round Rock and, and Taylor, where she lived. And so Round Rock would be like the closest big city, right? About 100,000 people live there. This vehicle is found there. Now, here's the problem. Cell phone never located. I'm curious, what did they find in the car? What didn't they find in the car? And we know that they're going to keep a lot of that close to the vest. They're going to keep that under wraps because of what we saw with how she was killed. They kept that detail away from the public for a good period of time. They wanted to interview people, sit down and interview people and talk to people and figure out who knew what before they started releasing details.
Captain
Well, if you're law enforcement, you're going, how is this victim connected to this pool? If she is, or is there somebody in the victim's family or inner circle that's connected to this pool or connected to that town? I don't believe law enforcement found a connection to anybody that she knew to that town.
Nick
If they did, they're not saying so. And here's the thing, too, that you have to wonder with this type of setup and where the vehicle is found, could this just simply be a convenient spot to drop a car that you want to get rid of?
Captain
Well, here's what we don't know. Did she pick somebody up? The person commits a crime, then takes her vehicle to escape, or did somebody follow her back home? Did she meet somebody at home?
Nick
Was she expecting someone?
Captain
You have this car being placed 12 miles away. How did this person get home? Did they call somebody to get a ride? Was this close enough of a location that they could walk home?
Nick
Well, I love the tree that you're barking up here, Captain, because one of the statements here with this situation is that there was no signs of forced entry into her home. There are some reports that state that the back door to her home was found unlocked, which seems a little odd knowing that grandmother had to go to the lengths that she did to get in to get access to that home herself. But it may just be a situation where she didn't think to check the back door. However, what we do know from her sending the little boy in through the window, that window was unlocked as well.
Family Member
Yeah.
Nick
Now you have to question the crime scene, and you're looking at the crime scene and you're going, okay, did Katara let somebody into her home? Was she expecting someone? Did somebody just show up on a drop in and she chose to let them in? Or did somebody somehow gain access to her home and it was somebody that she wasn't expecting at all? That speculation has not been expanded upon by law enforcement. Now, another very strange detail. So that I find the vehicle to be a strange detail in this case.
Captain
Absolutely.
Nick
Parked at the community pool. But now, this is one of those details that you, you don't forget, Right? Unfortunately, there's. There's a thousand unsolved cases and we've covered as many of them as we can to date. But this is one of those details in a case that you just don't forget because it's a rarity. At some point, Katara's mother calls her cell phone and somebody answers the cell phone. And all we have to go on is A description provided to us by her mother, which says that when I called her phone, someone answered in an unfamiliar high pitched voice saying this is Katara. And obviously mom knows it's not her daughter.
Captain
Yeah. It makes me wonder, is this a female voice or is this somebody trying to disguise their voice to make it sound like a female voice?
Nick
And unfortunately, Katara's mother. This case is coming up on the 20th anniversary, okay? 20th anniversary of the sad day of when this young woman was killed. No one's been arrested and unfortunately her mother has passed away since. And what I would love to know is some more detailed information. We know the police have this, but exactly what the captain wants to know was this a male voice pretending to, you know, doing some absurd high pitched voice, weepy voice killer. We covered that case. Was it. Did the voice sound female and just putting on a. Put on voice for.
Narrator/Host
For.
Nick
To disguise their voice. Here's the thing though. Mom also says that she heard laughing in the background before. Before the phone hung up. Does that mean that this person answered the phone in the presence of others and these other people in their presence are laughing, giggling at the person answering the phone? Hello, Katara? The phone hangs up. Mom tries back. Now she's getting voicemail. Phone doesn't get answered again, going to voicemail. I do want to point out something here that is of interest to me and of the. The investigation at large. Police do say while we've never recovered that cell phone, we do have her cell phone records. We do have detailed information about that cell phone.
Captain
I'm assuming, since we have some information about that cell phone and we have records, do we also have voicemails or those lost with the phone?
Nick
The problem is we're going all the way back to 2004. Right. The phone information and what they could pull back then is certainly different than it is today. So I can't tell you how extensive the information is that they have, but they are on record saying that we do have that cell phone information. So think about this for a minute here we have a young woman who we're told doesn't have enemies. She didn't have beef with anybody that anybody knew of. She's murdered in her home, which is located between her uncle's place and her grandmother's place. In the middle of the night. We have to assume in the middle of the night. Right. Because the car's gone by Thursday and none of the families see it. So it would stand to reason that she's killed before the car disappears. Grandma and uncle both say we didn't hear anything. We didn't hear a scuffle, we didn't hear an argument, we didn't hear a scream. We didn't hear a gunshot. Which the uncle's on record saying that, you know, he thinks that if there was something crazy going on that they would have heard something. Again, looks to me the spacing of these trailers would have been great enough that potentially if whatever went down all occurred inside Qatar's home, that they may not have heard anything. Here's the other thing too. Unfortunately, while a gunshot might be loud, if it's just one or two, unfortunately, they're quick. Yeah, they're quick. And if they happen at an hour when everyone's sleeping, it might not even wake you up. If you're a neighbor, it might not. And if it were to wake you up, you may not know what woke you up. It's too fast, too quick. So we have Grandma and we have uncle on record saying they didn't hear anything that night. But what we learned months later is that she was in fact killed with a large caliber gun.
Captain
This show is sponsored by Better Help. Have you ever avoided a difficult conversation? Or minimized how you felt? Or just waited too long to talk to somebody? When life gets heavy, the stigma is real. It's something I'm trying to change. It needs to be commonplace to talk about our mental health. Even in 2026, stigma can get in the way of a lot of things, like getting support for your mental health. Maybe you've encouraged friends to consider therapy while you're avoiding taking the first steps yourself because you're busy, worried about what other people will think, or telling yourself you should handle it alone. But therapy with Better Help, the world's largest online therapy platform, can be a space to slow down and talk through what's been building before it feels unmanageable. Just take a short questionnaire to identify your needs and Preferences and BetterHelp will handle the initial therapist matching work for you. Their industry leading match fulfillment rate means BetterHelp typically gets it right the first time. Feel confident knowing betterhelp therapists work according to strict code of conduct and are fully licensed in the US don't let stigma stand in the way of support. Start therapy with Better Help. Sign up and get 10 off@betterhelp.com garage. That's betterhelp.com garage this show is proudly sponsored by BetterHelp.
Nick
So many people are focused on where their money is. Today.
Narrator/Host
Acorns is the financial wellness app that
Nick
cares about where your money is going
Narrator/Host
tomorrow and with the Acorns potential screen,
Nick
you can find out what your money is capable of. Acorns is easy. You can sign up in minutes and
Narrator/Host
start automatically investing your spare money even
Nick
if all you've got is spare change.
Narrator/Host
Sign up now and Acorns will boost your new account with a $5 bonus. Investment join the over 14 million all time customers who have already saved and invested over $27 billion with Acorns. Head to acorns.com garage or download the Acorns app to get started.
Nick
Paid non client endorsement compensation provides incentive
Narrator/Host
to positively promote acorns.
Nick
Tier 2 compensation provided potential subject to various factors such as customers accounts age
Narrator/Host
and investment settings does not include Acorns fees.
Nick
Results do not predict or represent the
Narrator/Host
performance of any Acorns portfolio.
Nick
Investment results will vary. Investing involves risk.
Narrator/Host
Acorns Advisors LLC and SEC Registered Investment Advisor View important disclosures@acorns.com Garage Chime is banking built for you, not the 1%. They have thousands of fee free ATMs because why pay to get your own money? Plus with a Chime card, get travel perks like airport lounge access and 5% cash back on things like gas or groceries. Upgrade to America's number one choice for banking with a Chime checking account. Chime is not just smarter banking, it's the most rewarding way to bank. Join the millions who are already banking fee free today. Head to chime.comgarage that is chime.comgarage. it only takes a few minutes to sign up. Chime is a fintech, not a bank. Banking services for Chime card provided by Chime's bank partners. Optional products and services may have fees or charges. Stated cash back for Chime prime only. No minimum balance required. Checking account ranking based on a J.D. power survey published October 20, 2025. For more information on travel perks, go to Chime.com disclosures One thing about summer is that everything just feels easy. It's the season for comfortable go anywhere pieces that make getting dressed simple. That's what makes Quint such a great fit for the season. They focus on well made essentials that you'll actually live in all summer long. Quince's 100% European linen pants and shirts are breathable, easy to throw on and the summer upgrade your rotation needs and their tees are soft enough to live in all day and the lightweight cotton sweaters are exactly what you want when summer nights cool down. I love quints. I love shopping@quints.com for all of my clothing needs. It's How I fill my wardrobe and my closet. And I didn't make up the statement that their tees are soft enough to live in all day. They absolutely are. I love their tees. I love their socks. Especially for summertime. Tees from Quince can live in all day long. What does that mean? I wear them to the pool. I wear them when I go out to the restaurants and I have several that I've reserved as pajama tops because they are that comfortable, they are that breathable and they are super soft. They make you want to relax. The clothing on Quince.com is super high quality with great looks, great fashion and very affordable. Plus the checkout and shipping experience is always a good one. Make your summer wardrobe easier. Go to quince.comgarage for free shipping on your order and 365 day returns. Now available in Canada too. That's qui nce.comgarage for free shipping and 365 day returns. Quints.comgarage.
Captain
All right, we are back. Cheers, mates. Cheers to you, Colonel.
Nick
Cheers to you, Captain. Cheers to people on the other side of the pond. We will be hopefully seeing some of your beautiful faces soon. We'll be at Crimecon uk.
Captain
We're gonna drink as if we have no livers.
Nick
We're gonna drink like the United States lost the war, that we are still under the King's command and paying tax. Taxes without representation.
Captain
Yeah. So this case, man, a lot of questions. And I thought initially looking at this case, it's simple, right? We just figure out who picked up this individual at the pool and case solved.
Nick
Oh, yeah.
Captain
But then I was like, wait a second. Dumb, dumb head. It's possible that they just dropped the car off there. And it doesn't have to be two killers. The person could have again lived close enough or doesn't have to get picked up at that pool. Could have walked down to the nearest gas station, got a ride there. So it's not as simple. Now, I think it's probably likely that somebody did pick them up and whoever picked them up knows or has some suspicion that there was something weird that went down and probably just hasn't come forward to law enforcement. Maybe they're scared themselves. But there is a possibility that this, this killer just disposed of the car in this location without having anybody else know about it.
Nick
Well, these community pools, I'm glad you brought that up because these community pools, this complicates your investigation because I guarantee you law enforcement was looking at that same angle early on. So you can call yourself dumb, dumb if you want, but I think I was, and everybody else would have been looking at that same angle. It's still very much a possibility. And I think actually that's the right road to go down, but to explore. The other option here is these community pools. They're in a community. You could park in the parking lot and be in the community on foot rather quickly and in your own neighborhood fairly quickly as well. So it's not inconceivable that the killer didn't drop the vehicle and just simply walk away. My big question for detectives would be, did. Did you find the keys? What did the vehicle look like when you're. When you're there tearing that thing apart and you are processing the vehicle because, you know they're dusting it for prints. If they didn't dust it for prints, they didn't do their job. All right, so when you process this vehicle, what did it look like to you? Nobody knows what a boosted car, stolen car, looks like better than police. Was this thing all busted up and torn up?
Narrator/Host
Was there.
Nick
Was there an abundance of evidence inside? Were there items inside of that vehicle that you could show to her family and say, does this belong to Katara? Obviously, it complicates saying that she doesn't live under lock and key of mom and dad's house. She's an independent woman. So they may not be able to give great answers. Maybe, yes, no and a maybe are all involved in. And did this hoodie, did this shirt, did this bracelet, flip flops? Whatever you find in this vehicle, did they belong to her? We know the cell phone was never found. So if killer is completely operating alone, they dropped the car and took the cell phone with them. How long it remained in their possession, that's anybody's. That's anybody's guess. But the car should provide you some evidence here. I'm curious to find out what was in that vehicle and if the keys were ever found.
Captain
Absolutely.
Nick
The other thing, too, let's go back to that phone call we talked about. Was the voice male? Was it female? What was mom's speculation about that phone call? Because here's one thing we know for sure. Whoever answered that call, whether they're the killer or not, they were in possession of one of the very few things that was taken from her home, from the murder victim's home, in short time, short proximity, from when our victim was killed.
Family Member
Well.
Captain
And if you're going to pretend to be the victim, then guess what? Use a piece of shit.
Nick
The other thing here, where I go to the idea that there are probably a few different people that may know or have insider information about either what happened to Katara or who was involved. Is that giggling in the background that mom heard when she called the cell phone? That almost seems to me like this crime feels very juvenile. Very juvenile. That somebody. You said dum dum earlier. I think we. I think we called whoever answered that cell phone, let's call them dum dum.
Captain
Because dum dum, scum, bum.
Nick
They clearly didn't understand that that puts them on the radar whether they're the killer or an accessory to murder. And then you have the people in the background giggling and laughing.
Captain
Yeah, that's another one. Is it simply that we have somebody at a party? Does the other people around this person that answered the call, do they even know what is being said on that call? Or is this a TV in the background or a radio in the background? I mean, that's. Some of this stuff seems so simple in this case. And you go, so this should be solved by now. But I think there's twists and turns to every piece of evidence. Again, did somebody pick up the killer at the pool? Somebody should know. Contact law enforcement. Somebody else could go, well, I was actually with this guy that answered the phone and said the victim's name, pretended to be the victim.
Family Member
Right.
Captain
That's strange. Let me call law enforcement. And this, like you said, this is not, you know, this is a. If anybody's ever seen Friday Night Lights, the movie or the TV show, this reminds me of. Of East Dillon and. But probably a little bit more of a rural area.
Nick
Well, that's very strange and ironic that you say that. If you look up Taylor, Texas.
Captain
Yeah.
Nick
One thing that they will tell us is as small as this town is, right? Currently 16,000 people. One thing. And I. And I think if you live far from this place at all, like us Ohio boys here, we would have no way of knowing this. But notable movies filmed in and around Taylor, Texas. There's some big ones here. The movie, Michael, Suburbia, Varsity Blues, I
Captain
don't want your Life, the life of
Nick
David Gale, the Texas Chainsaw Massacre, Friday night lights.
Captain
Here's Gad here's. And football. And in 10 years from now, Street. Good friends living large in Texas. Texas forever. Street. Yo, everybody, listen up. Let's do it. Let's touch God this time. Texas forever. Street.
Nick
So I had forgotten all about that until you had. Had dropped that title there.
Captain
But yeah, when you see photos of this town, because they talk about this party and so let's go back to this party. A little bit strange. It seems like so simple. Okay, so she's having a party, she's a host. Well, what was this party for? Nobody knows. The sister was there. Her sister goes to the party, doesn't even. The sister remembers talking to her sister, but doesn't remember why they had the party. That seems strange to me.
Nick
Is this the same sister that said that she thought police thought of her as a suspect?
Captain
Could be. Could be.
Nick
So one of her sisters, Kenyatta, is on record telling the newspapers and media that she thought that police thought that she should be a suspect. And look, she's very upfront. She says, look, I have a police record. I was arrested one time for assault.
Captain
Right?
Nick
And she says, none of us are perfect. This was a mistake. I would never ever harm my sister at all. And she says, I really, I would never kill anybody.
Captain
Right?
Nick
But I'm not, I wouldn't hurt my sister. The assault wasn't on my sister. And in the defense of law enforcement, they, everyone's a suspect until you're not. No shit. So I don't know that I didn't get the vibe from the sister that they were, you know, up in her face, grilling her and threatening her with spending the rest of her life in prison. I didn't get that vibe. I think because what she says to the media is that based off of the line of questioning, it would seem like they thought I was a suspect. Police did give a direct response to that statement saying, we've not named a suspect at this time.
Captain
Right.
Nick
We have interviewed over 50 people. We have administered several polygraphs. We have also sent physical evidence off to be tested.
Captain
Yeah, but think about this. If you're law enforcement, you, you go, so Katara has a party and then you start asking people about the party and you're getting these wishy washy answers. It makes it feel like people are covering up something. How can you not know who the host of the party is? How can people not know why there was a party? Because you can have a party just to have a party. But people at the party would know. Oh, well, what's the occasion? Nothing. Just to have a get together.
Nick
Right, but they've been investigating this for 20 years. That's where another speed bump comes up for me in this investigation.
Family Member
Yeah.
Nick
Where I have to wonder, when did police, when did law enforcement think that this gathering.
Captain
Right.
Nick
Should could, I should say could rather than should, hold some significance to the murder?
Captain
Yeah.
Nick
Was it months afterwards? Was it, was it a week afterward? Or was it years because if it were years or even months, it. It's not out of the realm of reason that people that attended didn't fully know what it was for, especially if it was for no reason at all other than just to get together. But the sister not knowing does complicate things as well. Here's the thing, though, Captain. So this is one thing that I want to point out, the reason why, and this is a call to action to all the listeners out there. Because what I'm hoping is that with the unfortunate 20th anniversary coming up with this unsolved homicide, that we can get some renewed interest in this case. One, with the anniversary, two with our coverage, too. Law enforcement have said that they want to know more about this gathering. In fact, one thing that law enforcement did very well in this case, circling back to something we said at the beginning, they brought in other agencies, bigger agencies with more resources. And one of those agencies was the Texas Rangers. And it's a Texas Ranger that is on record saying that we want to know more about this gathering that took place the Saturday before she was killed because we have concerns that there could be. There could be information, details about that gathering that could give us or provide a lead here in this case. According to Detective Hunter, that event may be crucial in finding out what happened to Katara. And investigators are urging anyone who may have seen or heard anything during that party to call police. Now, that statement. That's why a question. When were they asking individuals about that gathering? Because that statement to the media, that with their calling and asking for the public's help, that was 15 years after she was killed. Maybe they stumbled onto something that made them think, wait a second. We got to go back and examine. Not just the. The day leading up to the night that she's murdered, or the movement of the vehicle or the movement of the cell phone and who may have had been in possession of the phone or the car. Both. Maybe we need to go back early in our timeline to that Saturday, to that gathering. Maybe they stumbled onto something and to expand on the car, too. So that car. It's reported that the car was found on Friday morning. It's found. Here we go. August 27, 2004. Friday a.m. qatar's Mitsubishi Lancer is found at the Thorndale Community swimming pool. This swimming pool is approximately 12 miles from Qatar's home. She's alive and well. Wednesday at midnight, after her shift at the Taco Bell, seen getting into her car. We know she makes it home safe. She's killed. After that, her car disappears. Why? Why does that car disappear? Was she murdered for the car? Unfortunately, it wouldn't be the first time Michael Jordan's father was killed by two teenage asshole boys that just wanted to steal his vehicle and go joyriding. Did somebody just go out and joyride in this thing for a day? And when was it dumped at the pool? Just because it was found Friday morning doesn't mean it was gone the entire time. It's not terribly far from her home. It's found relatively quickly. That makes me wonder that the car is not. Not the answer. It might be the answer to finding out who's involved, who's responsible. But I don't. I don't feel like that she was killed for the car.
Captain
No. But the other tough thing is, like we said, she lives on this property owned by the family. Two family members live on each side of her. But we have no family member coming forward and saying that they even saw the car at her trailer that night.
Nick
Right.
Captain
Again, they might not have been looking or might not even have the viewpoint or the vantage point to be able to see that unless they get in their car and drive aways.
Nick
And I'll make a couple of assumptions here, and I'm underlining that their assumptions, so don't, don't take this as fact, but I'm going to make the assumption that Grandma is not hanging out at 1am on a Thursday.
Captain
And Grandma likes to party.
Nick
Grandma likes to get down, especially on a Wednesday night. Then we have the uncle living on the other side. It's the middle of the week.
Commercial Narrator
Right.
Nick
Very likely he's got work in the morning. So I'm picking up what you're putting down. We don't have anybody saying that they saw the vehicle there that night. But I also don't think that. I don't think I would expect them to have seen it.
Captain
I'm going to assume that that car made it back to her trailer at some point.
Nick
Oh, yeah.
Captain
After work.
Nick
Absolutely. So.
Captain
But we. But our timeline becomes shorter and I'd like to talk. I wish they had more information that they're releasing about the shift that she worked beforehand. What were her responsibilities?
Nick
Was she closing the store that night?
Captain
Yes. And who was she closing it with and what were her responsibilities? Because was she supposed to take a deposit and does she take a deposit home with her or is that something that she did that she shouldn't have done?
Nick
Are you the leader of the Bloodhound Gang? Because I feel like you are. You're taking us down the perfect path here.
Captain
Well, I do sit down to be.
Nick
I was talking about the ones that solve mysteries, not. Not the musicians. That's where I'm at. If this were. If this were the case that you and I caught, and we are driving around in the old. The old patrol car talking about where. What. What lead do we want to look at first? After we interview everybody, her immediate family and friends and everyone. I'm looking at this thing going. And I'm. Of course, I'm trying to relate it to my own life experiences, but sometimes that there is value in that, right? I look back at the old colonels. Being 21 years old, living out on my own, and my life looks very similar to what her life looked like to me. I was 21, living in a tiny little apartment with an okay car, and I had a decent job, right? Katara living on her own in a small place doing, you know, doing her thing. She's building her life. She's really starting out and building her life here. She's got. She's got a car and she's got a job and she's got her place. And you know, what if her life was like mine after those three things? I didn't have any. Anything. I was broke. You. You come into my place. Remember, Captain, you come to my place, you open up the fridge. What was in there? Some beer and some condiments. That's about. That's maybe some. I kept slices at that young age. I kept red wine in the fridge, too. But the thing here is where. Where I'm going is where you're going. The three things missing from this young woman's home. Her cell phone, her car, which implies her keys were missing. And guess what could be on that key ring along with the key to her car. Did she have the key to that Taco Bell, or did somebody think she didn't have to have the key? Somebody could have just thought that she had it.
Captain
But if I don't think this seems like a sexually motivated crime, doesn't seem like any type of revenge.
Nick
Well, we're basing that off of the description that we're getting of the murder scene, right? There doesn't seem to be a huge scuffle. Now, the. No forced entry might imply that it was somebody that she could have been, you know, could have been somebody of the opposite sex showing up that she either wanted to or didn't want to show up.
Captain
Or a friend or family member. But that's why I don't think it's out of. Look, law enforcement has to question the inner circle.
Nick
It's somebody that knows her 100%.
Captain
Yeah.
Nick
I'm thinking here, Captain.
Family Member
Mm.
Nick
The cars taken out of happenstance. If you're. If you go there looking for the key to that store and you take the keys again, I go back to the impulsivity of the juvenile nature that I feel like we have here. In this case, the juvenile tendencies in nature was to answer that cell phone when it rang the first time. Too dumb, too impulsive to know better. Answer the phone, make a joke. This is guitar, whatever voice, male voice, female voice, we don't know. Giggling in the background. This feels very juvenile to me. Did she close the store that night? And did somebody have a window of opportunity to attempt to return to the store to open it up? Or as you said, was she in charge of a deposit? Did she take the deposit home for some reason and that is actually missing? And it's been proven in law enforcement are aware of it, but they don't want to release that detail. Her killer knew her. I feel like many people, when I say many, it could just be two or three other individuals I think know what happened here. I'm hoping with the. How young the killer could be and it could be as simple as somebody that knew her brought a bad element along with them. We're just going to. We're just going to go get the money from the restaurant. That's all we're going to do.
Captain
Yeah, again. But it still bothers me that we don't have much information, even from people that went to this party or this gathering. Seems like. I don't know. I think if I'm the lead detective and I start asking people about this event and I'm getting these dumb answers, I'm going to go. It should be pretty fucking simple.
Nick
Well, and you're right. And that's what they did. Right. Because they're asking the public for help on that front, saying, hey, we, we want to know more about this gathering because we think that there could be some. Some clues or it could hold significant information as to the murder of this young woman. Yeah, I, I'm. I'm a little clueless on the vehicle. The cell phone. I get it. You know, it's 2004. A much, a much higher percentage of the population didn't have cell phones then that do today. I don't think she was killed for the phone. I think it was taken as maybe an afterthought. I just really wonder if unfortunately, with her responsibilities and her duties as a manager of that restaurant was it just. Did somebody see what they thought was an opportunity to collect thousands of dollars from the place. And she was, forgive me for saying, collateral damage. Just. Just. They killed her to try to gain access to either the deposit for that day or access to that restaurant. And 2004, the thing that you would be hopeful of is. Well, can I. I think rather than her friends and family, I would be looking at people that worked under her.
Captain
Absolutely.
Nick
More so, I feel like there's a lot of ties to this restaurant here. That's the last thing that we are aware that she did in her Life. And in 2004, you're probably hoping, surveillance, maybe we. If the Taco Bell didn't have it, could we pick up surveillance from neighboring businesses or on the route from her place to the restaurant to see if we can see her vehicle heading in that direction?
Captain
Yeah. Or what happens when you're younger at work? That doesn't really happen so much when you're older at work. Your friends stop by. Is there somebody that stopped by during
Nick
her shift riding shotgun and saw something?
Captain
Yeah. Or just. Or is there somebody that went through the drive through just to say hello?
Nick
Where's the bad element? On the fringe of her acquaintances or friends or associates? Where's that bad element? Because that might be your person responsible or the center of this investigation. Now, one thing we should point out here to Captain, is that the family has voiced some concerns over the years that they didn't think that law enforcement was so forthcoming to them, keeping them up to speed and up to date on the investigation itself. I wish that they didn't feel that way. I wish that they had a different feeling and that their experience was different. I will say this, though. What we can say is based off of the limited information that they've released to the public, it makes sense that they've not released a lot of that information to the family as well. And I. And I. I want to be able to share in your. Your hurt and your anger in that regard. I will say this, though. We know the NAACP was brought in for. For a brief period of time here to take a look at the case, and I'm glad that they were. But I will say this. Multiple agencies were brought in. Texas Rangers were brought in. Taylor. Texas PD is still involved in this case. And this is one that. This is one that pisses them off. This is a case that when it first happens, you think, all right, we're going to be able to get some justice for this young woman because we have some leads with the vehicle with the cell phone and when it starts to fizzle out and you start to not get answers or you start getting pushback from, from persons and I, I, what I'm trying to say I think here, Captain, and not so eloquently, is that I understand the frustrations of the family and I'm glad that the NAACP was brought in. I applaud you for that. I would do the same thing. But the flip side of that coin, from what I've observed, it looks like they were, they were working this one real good and continue to work it over the years. You know, periodically we've had statements from police and the Texas Rangers and other agencies at the one year mark, at the, at the two year mark, at the five year 10 year 15, and I'm sure we're going to see it again at the 20 year mark. I spoke with two individuals at the Taylor Police Department and they agree. I said, here's my guess, this one pissed you guys off. They said, yes, this one pisses us off. We want help with this one. We want help with this one. They still think that they can get it done and I think the other agencies think that they can get it done too. The other thing too is when you're not getting answers or you don't feel like you're being brought up to speed, you keep in mind there's multiple agencies working the case. Agency one might not have all the information that Agency two has and so on and so forth in a manner that they can deliver them to you. I'm hopeful about this case. As sad as it is that we're reaching the 20th anniversary, as sad as it is that Qatar is no longer with us. She seemed like a bright, hardworking young woman who cared about her family. She loved her family so much she turns down a basketball scholarship. She don't want to be away from, from her family. She in distance. She, she was working hard, she was building her life and someone came and snuffed it out for reasons undetermined by us here in the garage today. But I tell you, I can't get over the simple fact. Garage task force gut check here tells me that this has to do with, with that restaurant. I just feel I can't get over that. Like I can't move past that.
Captain
Small town, not a dangerous town, pretty safe. And I think that's one of the problems when this is not a crime that you investigate often. But I do think they are steadfast and I do believe that they want this crime solved and they want justice to be served.
Nick
Absolutely. 100%. They've worked it, I believe, the best that they can. Right. Because they're up against a brick wall with some of this. If you, if you're reaching out to people and you can't get information or they're dodging your questions. And we probably have a situation too, where a few of the people that they would like to talk to, they may not have awareness of hiding behind a veil of a friendship or allegiance with, with other persons here. So we have a case where we know that they've interviewed over 50 people and that's, that is within the first few years of the case, polygraph test administered, evidence sent off to crime labs. I'm curious what new evidence could be collected off of those same items today or that we could yield different information today than it did 20 years ago. We may have technology on our side here, but we do need police, need your help with this. And this is a situation where it doesn't have to mean that you know who did this or why or other players involved or that you know why the car was moved or the details of that or information about the cell phone, maybe you know about the cell phone call police. But here's an opportunity. If you were at that gathering, that event, that party, whatever you want to call it, or if you heard people talk about it, investigators want information about that event, about that gathering that took place on Saturday, August 21st. They want information about that as well that could give them the lead or the breadcrumb trail that they've so needed for 20 years now. Qatar Johnson was taken away far too early. She was only 21 years old. Building her life. She loved her family deeply. Her sister said to the perpetrator or perpetrators she didn't deserve what happened to her. If you don't turn yourself in, God is going to deal with you. Anyone with any information at all regarding this case and the gathering that took place days before her murder is encouraged to contact the Taylor Police Department at 512-352-5551. Or if you want to remain anonymous, you can call Crime Stoppers at 1-800-253-7867. Or for some reason you are uncomfortable speaking with law enforcement at all, you can contact one of us here at the garage.
Commercial Narrator
Foreign.
Captain
Thank everybody for joining us here in the garage each and every week. Colonel, do you have any recommended reading
Nick
for the beautiful listeners this week? Captain? It's a little self serving. I'm doing it again, but it's because of the garage sale going on. Gonna recommend my book. The Delphi Murders the Quest to Find the Man on the Bridge. We have autographed copies for a limited time available back on our Website, true crime garage.com youm can tell from this episode we're doing everything we can just to get you to go to our website. But no, we have limited copies. Autograph copies of the Delphi Murders. The case is heating up again. Should be going to trial here soon. So if you need to get up to speed, if you want to get all the information, as I saw and as I explained it as one man's obsession with an American murder investigation, check out the Delphi Murders book the Quest to Find the man on the Bridge by yours truly. Of course, you can get that on Amazon. You can get it on Audible or Kindle. But if you want an autograph signed copy, go to our website, truecrimegarage.com and
Captain
not only is it signed by the Colonel, but it's also signed by Bo Jackson. And until next week, be good, be kind, and don't litter.
Commercial Narrator
Sam,
Commercial Voice
You're more than just one thing. You're the boss. Hey, Google, what time is my meeting with Tim today? The athlete that class wrecks me. The ringleader. And we're good and always their mom. Everyone in the all new Mazda CX5 more to move every side of you. Learn more@mazdausa.com Google is a trademark of Google LLC. Sequences shortened and simulated. Ondeck is built to back small businesses like yours. Whether you're buying equipment, expanding your team, or bridging cash flow gaps, Ondeck's loans up to $400,000 help make it happen fast. Rated A by the Better Business Bureau and earning thousands of five star Trustpilot reviews, OnDeck delivers funding you can count on. Apply in minutes@ondeck.com depending on certain loan attributes, your business loan may be issued by Ondeck or Celtic Bank. Ondeck does not lend in North Dakota. All loans, an amount subject to lender approval.
Episode 781: After Midnight
Release Date: August 20, 2024
Case Covered: The unsolved 2004 homicide of Katara Johnson, Taylor, Texas
Hosts: Nic & the Captain
This week, Nic and the Captain tackle a deeply troubling, still-unsolved murder from small-town Texas. 21-year-old Katara Johnson was found dead in her home outside Taylor, Texas, in August 2004. With very little national coverage, little evidence, and enduring pain for her family, the hosts re-examine the case, searching for new angles and appealing for public help as the 20th anniversary approaches. This episode combines somber storytelling, smart detective work, and their characteristic blend of banter and empathy.
"This week we bring to you a true crime story that is what many would call a small town murder. Unfortunately, not many people outside of that town of about 15,000 have had much awareness of the murder of Katara Johnson."
“…People don’t know if she was the host, or if she's just there. And some people at the party don't even know why the party was happening. Was it somebody's birthday? Was it an engagement party? Was it a baby shower? Nobody knows.”
“No gun found at the scene of the crime. But I think a big thing for law enforcement is where did her car go?”
“Mom also says that she heard laughing in the background before the phone hung up. Does that mean that this person answered the phone in the presence of others and these other people in their presence are laughing, giggling at the person answering the phone?"
"If you’re law enforcement, you…go, so Katara has a party and then you start asking people about the party and you're getting these wishy washy answers. Makes it feel like people are covering up something."
"…Originally I thought, hey, just find out who picked them up and case solved. But it doesn't have to be two killers…could just walk away from there."
"That almost seems to me like this crime feels very juvenile. Very juvenile…just too dumb, too impulsive to know better."
"…Did she have the key to that Taco Bell, or did somebody think she did?"
On small-town closeness and investigative complications:
"Law enforcement have to question the inner circle. It's somebody that knows her, 100%." (Captain, [49:18])
On the significance of the party:
"If you were at that gathering, that event, that party…investigators want information…that could give them the lead or the breadcrumb trail that they've so needed for 20 years now." (Nick, [57:21])
On why the case remains unsolved:
"They've worked it…I believe, the best that they can. They're up against a brick wall with some of this. If you're reaching out to people and you can't get information or they're dodging your questions…" (Nick, [57:21])
On the sense of injustice:
“Qatar Johnson was taken away far too early. She was only 21 years old, building her life… She didn’t deserve what happened to her.” (Nick, [57:21])
The hosts urge anyone with knowledge about the party/gathering on August 21, 2004, or the days leading up to Katara’s murder, to come forward.
Nic ends with:
“If you were at that gathering…or if you heard people talk about it, investigators want information… that could give them the breadcrumb trail they’ve so needed for 20 years.”
Contact info for tips:
With their thorough review and heartfelt analysis, Nic and the Captain spotlight the unsolved killing of Katara Johnson, highlighting the importance of even small clues from listeners. They emphasize her character, the persistent work of detectives, and the devastating impact on her family, while inviting renewed public participation in hopes that the 20th anniversary finally brings answers and justice.