True Crime Garage – Episode: "Killing for Chaos /// Part 2 /// 840"
Release Date: May 7, 2025
Hosts: Nic and the Captain

Introduction

In this gripping episode of True Crime Garage, hosts Nic and the Captain delve deeper into the harrowing case of Nikita Cassap, a 17-year-old accused of the double homicide of his stepfather, Donald Mayer, and his mother, Tatiana Kassap. This installment, titled "Killing for Chaos /// Part 2," offers a comprehensive analysis of the investigation, evidence, and potential motives behind this tragic event.

Case Overview

On February 28, 2025, a routine welfare check in Waukesha, Wisconsin, unveiled a nightmarish scene: the bodies of Donald Mayer and Tatiana Kassap were discovered inside their home, while their son, Nikita Cassap, was found missing and later apprehended several hundred miles away.

Nic [02:07]: "Today we are still sipping on this great beer from Steel Tank Brewing. Aptly titled Wanna Go West..."

The Captain [02:44]: "And a big we like your jib goes out to Tanya from Cincinnati, Ohio."

Investigation Timeline

The investigation swiftly transitioned from a welfare check to a missing persons case, and eventually to a double homicide investigation. Nikita was arrested on March 3 for multiple minor charges, including theft of the family vehicle and a handgun, failing to stop at a stop sign, and driving without a license.

Nic [04:56]: "17 years old. High school student. And from everything we've seen, a very good high school student..."

Upon further investigation, authorities discovered alarming evidence on Nikita's cell phone and in the stolen vehicle, hinting at a more sinister motive behind the crimes.

Evidence and Manifesto

A pivotal moment in the investigation occurred on March 3, when the Waukesha County Sheriff's Office obtained a search warrant for Nikita's cell phone. This led to the discovery of communications related to the "Order of the Nine Angles," a reference that raised immediate red flags.

The Captain [09:12]: "Yeah, we have evidence they took their cell phones, that they took their IDs..."

Further searches on March 4 revealed a plethora of items in the vehicle, including electronics, a home security sensor, and valuable possessions, suggesting an attempt to conceal evidence and possibly fund more nefarious activities.

Nic [09:53]: "Taking the safe from the home, probably prying it open within the home..."

Nikita's communications pointed towards a manifesto titled "Accelerate the Collapse," advocating for the assassination of the President of the United States, bomb-making, and orchestrating terrorist attacks to destabilize the nation.

Nic [37:07]: "He, Nikita appears to be attempting to... He wants to overthrow the United States government..."

The manifesto explicitly referenced Adolf Hitler, indicating Nikita's extremist ideologies and intentions to incite chaos.

Family Dynamics

Contrary to what one might expect in such cases, reports from Donald Mayer’s mother, Judith Mayer, painted a picture of a harmonious family life. Nikita was described as a diligent student with impeccable attendance, sharing common interests with his stepfather, such as gardening.

Nic [20:20]: “She says, 'Donald didn’t have any other children...'”

However, the sudden disappearance of Nikita and the subsequent discovery of the homicides revealed a stark contrast to this facade, leaving many to ponder the underlying tensions or motives.

Motive and Analysis

The evidence strongly suggests that Nikita's primary motive was financial gain to fund his extremist plans. The theft of valuables and a substantial amount of money ($14,000) from the family home indicated a premeditated effort to gather resources necessary for his proposed attacks.

The Captain [09:26]: "The items that stand out to me here on this list... highly suggest that maybe the motive for the double homicide was... the theft of the money."

Additionally, Nikita's interactions with foreign contacts, particularly those communicating in Russian, hinted at potential external influences or support for his catastrophic ambitions.

Nic [35:01]: "He's communicating with some of these individuals that are overseas..."

The combined evidence of his manifesto, financial theft, and communication with extremist individuals abroad paints a chilling picture of a young individual driven by dangerous ideologies.

Future Proceedings

Nikita is scheduled to appear in court on May 7, shortly after the episode's release. Given the extensive evidence against him, including the manifesto and the nature of the crimes, the likelihood of a conviction on multiple charges is high.

Nic [51:36]: "He's very likely going to be convicted on all levels. At all levels, the state level and the federal..."

The investigation also opens avenues for uncovering other potential threats or conspiracies, especially if Nikita's interactions with foreign individuals are further explored.

Conclusion

The case of Nikita Cassap is a tragic reminder of how extremist ideologies can take root in unexpected places, leading to devastating consequences. As Nic and the Captain meticulously piece together the events leading up to the homicides, listeners are left to grapple with the complexities of motive, ideology, and the vulnerabilities of youth in today's interconnected world.

Nic [55:42]: "Recommended reading for this week Captain Is Koresh the True Story of David Koresh and the Tragedy at Waco by Stephen Talty..."

Notable Quotes

• Nic [37:07]: "He wants to overthrow the United States government... set into place a series of events. Chaotic and destructive events that will cause extreme chaos in the United States and then flee..."

• The Captain [44:00]: "Right."

• Nic [46:32]: "There's nothing in here to suggest that he is in the right frame of mind..."

Further Listening and Recommendations

Listeners are encouraged to explore related cases and recommended readings provided by the hosts to gain a deeper understanding of the intricate dynamics involved in such true crime stories.

Nick [55:42]: "Recommended reading for this week Captain Is Koresh the True Story of David Koresh and the Tragedy at Waco by Stephen Talty..."

For more in-depth analysis and updates on ongoing cases, visit truecrimegarage.com.

Stay tuned for more episodes as Nic and the Captain continue to unravel complex true crime cases, offering insightful discussions and thorough investigations for armchair detectives everywhere.