True Crime Garage - Episode: "Killing was Purposeful Interviews /// Off The Record"

Release Date: May 21, 2025

In this compelling episode of True Crime Garage, hosts Nic and the Captain delve deep into two significant cases from Northwest Ohio: the unsolved homicide of Lori Ann Hill and the tragic, yet resolved, abduction and murder of Sierra Joggin by James Worley. Titled "Killing was Purposeful Interviews /// Off The Record," the episode offers a thorough exploration of these cases through detailed interviews, community impact discussions, and the formation of a dedicated nonprofit organization aimed at enhancing women's safety.

Introduction and Case Overview

The episode opens with Host Josh Kolasinski providing an overview of the content covered in recent weeks, highlighting the transition from previous episodes (841 to 844) titled "Killing Was Purposeful" to this special edition, "Off The Record." Josh emphasizes the importance of understanding both unresolved and solved cases to grasp the full spectrum of true crime in their community.

Notable Quote:

Josh Kolasinski (03:39): "We ran a four-part series titled Killing Was Purposeful episodes 841 to 844. If you haven't listened to those yet, please go back before listening to this free edition of off the Record."

In-Depth Interviews with Law Enforcement

A significant portion of the episode features interviews with Jeremy Simon, a retired officer from the Fulton County Sheriff's Office with over 25 years of experience. Jeremy provides an insider's perspective on the investigation into James Worley, detailing his early interactions with Worley, prior awareness of Worley's behavior, and the meticulous process that led to Worley's conviction for Sierra Joggin's murder.

Case of Sierra Joggin: Sierra Joggin, a 20-year-old, was found dead, and substantial evidence led to James Worley's conviction. The investigation revealed that Worley had been monitoring Sierra, ultimately abducting and murdering her. Jeremy recounts the discovery of crucial evidence, including Sierra's bicycle near a cornfield and suspicious activity around Worley's property.

Notable Quotes:

Jeremy Simon (06:28): "I was on my second canine with the sheriff's office when I got the call about Sierra. Her mom was frantic, and knowing Sheila Vaculik from high school added a personal layer to the investigation."

Jeremy Simon (12:46): "We believe Worley laid the bike down after a scuffle, possibly intending to ambush Sierra as she continued along the county road."

Unsolved Case of Lori Ann Hill: The episode also touches upon the unsolved case of Lori Ann Hill from the late 1980s, drawing parallels between her disappearance and Worley's known criminal activities. Jeremy suggests that Worley might be connected to multiple unsolved cases, indicating a possible pattern of predatory behavior over decades.

Notable Quote:

Jeremy Simon (23:02): "We have unsolved female homicides in the area dating back to the 1980s, and every law enforcement officer I've spoken to is convinced Worley is guilty of more than just the cases we have evidence for."

Community Impact and the Birth of a Nonprofit

Following the detailed examination of the cases, the episode transitions to an emotional discussion with Bob and Nikki Kolasinski—Sierra Joggin's parents. They share their personal journey through grief, the challenges of having their son questioned during the investigation, and the profound impact Sierra's loss has had on their lives.

Formation of "Keeping Our Girls Safe": Motivated by Sierra's tragic fate, Bob and Nikki co-founded Keeping Our Girls Safe, a nonprofit organization dedicated to empowering women through self-defense training and personal safety education. The organization provides free self-defense classes, resources on recognizing and avoiding potential threats, and supports mental health initiatives for first responders and jurors involved in traumatic cases.

Notable Quotes:

Nikki Kolasinski (28:20): "We created this organization to offer free self-defense and personal safety classes for women, ensuring that knowledge is power and that women feel empowered to protect themselves."

Bob Kolasinski (29:06): "Turning our son over to the FBI was one of the most difficult moments, but we knew it had to be done to find the perpetrator."

Programs and Initiatives:

• Self-Defense Classes: Over 3,500 women have attended, learning practical skills and receiving safety tools like the "Angel in Disguise" keychain.
• Honoring Good Deeds: A program supporting first responders and jurors with mental health resources and stress management.
• Community Engagement: Events like purse bingos and motorcycle rides to fundraise and raise awareness.

Notable Quote:

Nikki Kolasinski (45:42): "Our instructors are all law enforcement officers to foster a sense of community and trust, ensuring that women feel comfortable and supported."

Discussion on the Death Penalty and Justice System

The Kolasinskis express their views on the justice system, particularly focusing on James Worley's death penalty sentence. They discuss the moratorium in Ohio, pending petitions, and their hope for the execution date to be carried out, emphasizing the severity of Worley's crimes and his impact on the community.

Notable Quote:

Host Nick (37:12): "Everybody has a different opinion about the death penalty, but in cases like this, it's about justice for the victims and safety for the community."

Closing Remarks and Call to Action

The episode concludes with a heartfelt appeal from the Kolasinskis to support their nonprofit's upcoming events and initiatives. They highlight the importance of community involvement in enhancing personal safety and supporting those affected by violent crimes.

Notable Quote:

Nikki Kolasinski (53:06): "Every single dime goes back into helping the community in one way, shape, or form. Whether it's self-defense classes or supporting our first responders, we're committed to making our community safer."

Call to Action: Listeners are encouraged to visit www.kogsafe.com to learn more about Keeping Our Girls Safe, donate, or participate in upcoming events like their annual purse bingo fundraiser.

Conclusion

"Killing was Purposeful Interviews /// Off The Record" serves as a poignant reminder of the lasting impact of violent crimes on victims' families and communities. Through detailed investigations and heartfelt personal stories, True Crime Garage not only sheds light on unresolved and solved cases but also showcases the resilience and proactive efforts of those determined to prevent future tragedies. This episode underscores the importance of community support, awareness, and education in the ongoing fight against crime.

Stay Connected: For more stories, follow True Crime Garage on your preferred podcast platform and join the community of armchair detectives eager to uncover the truth behind true crime stories.