418: Worst Roommate Ever: Housemate from Hell

Summary

Podcast Summary: True Crime Obsessed - Episode 418: "Worst Roommate Ever: Housemate from Hell"

I. Introduction

In Episode 418 of True Crime Obsessed, hosts Jillian Betavali and Patrick Hines delve into the harrowing case titled "Housemate from Hell." This episode explores the extreme circumstances that transform a seemingly ordinary roommate situation into a true crime nightmare.

II. Setting the Scene: Cathedral City, California

The episode opens in Cathedral City, California—a tranquil locale adjacent to Palm Springs known for its low crime rates, averaging one to five homicides annually. The central figure is Anita Cohen, an elderly woman who meticulously crafted her ideal living environment.

III. The Initial Incident: Anita's Death

On June 14, 2016, police responded to a welfare check requested by Anita's daughter-in-law, Cindy, after failing to reach Anita. Officers arrived around 11 PM, only to discover Anita Cohen brutally beaten in her backyard pool. The scene was chaotic, with broken glass and blood marks indicating a violent struggle (03:47).

IV. Introducing Daryl: The Model Roommate

Daryl emerges as Anita's longest-running roommate, described as respectful and responsible. Despite his personal struggles, including a recent divorce and financial hardships, Daryl maintained a cordial relationship with Anita. He expressed admiration for her hard-earned independence and the dream she fulfilled by owning her home (05:08).

V. The Arrival of Scott: A Red Flag

Scott Pettigrew enters the narrative as Anita's new roommate introduced in early 2016. Initially perceived as a clean-cut, friendly individual with two small dogs, Scott seemed like an ideal addition. However, red flags soon surfaced, including Scott's odd behavior and manipulative tendencies (13:12).

VI. Escalation of Hostility: Scott Targets Daryl

Scott's demeanor shifted dramatically, becoming increasingly hostile towards Daryl. He made unfounded accusations, such as claiming Daryl was secretly filming him in the bathroom, creating tension within the household. These allegations strained Anita's perception of Daryl, leading her to mistrust her longtime roommate (14:08).

VII. Daryl's Wrongful Arrest: A Tragic Miscarriage of Justice

As tensions peaked, Scott orchestrated a situation that led to Daryl's wrongful arrest. On March 7, 2016, after a series of manipulative actions, Scott falsely accused Daryl of senior abuse and property damage. Despite Daryl's innocence, he was arrested without substantial evidence, facing severe felony charges and potential prison time (28:19).

VIII. Unraveling Scott's Troubled Past

The hosts investigate Scott's background, revealing a history marked by substance abuse and violent outbursts. Through testimonies from Scott's former partner, Rob Salcedo, it becomes evident that Scott's destructive behavior was deeply rooted in his traumatic childhood and deteriorating mental health (44:26).

IX. The Murder: Anita's Final Moments

On August 29, 2019, years after the initial events, Anita Cohen was found dead in her pool. Bodycam footage from the responding officer, Sergeant Heather Olson, captured the chilling aftermath. Anita had inadvertently recorded her own murder on a digital recorder, providing crucial evidence that ultimately led to Scott's conviction (62:11). In a final confrontation, Scott confessed to his crimes, further cementing his role as the perpetrator.

X. Conclusion: Justice for Anita and Exoneration for Daryl

Scott Pettigrew was convicted of first-degree murder, elder abuse, and violating a protective order, receiving a sentence of 25 years to life in prison. Daryl was exonerated, although the emotional and professional fallout from his wrongful arrest left lasting scars (64:06).

XI. Insights and Lessons Learned

The episode underscores the critical importance of thorough background checks when sharing living spaces. It also highlights systemic failures, such as inadequate police response to domestic disputes and the challenges victims face in proving their innocence. Hosts Jillian and Patrick emphasize the need for vigilance and empathy to prevent such tragedies.

XII. Final Thoughts: Be Kind and Conduct Due Diligence

In their closing remarks, Jillian and Patrick urge listeners to "just be nice" and conduct essential background checks when selecting roommates or shared living arrangements. They advocate for stronger support systems and legal reforms to protect vulnerable individuals from manipulative and abusive behaviors.

Notable Quotes:

Jillian Betavali on the ease of being a bad roommate: “It's really. It's actually incredibly easy.” (00:06)
Patrick Hines on Anita's dedication to her home: “She worked really, really, really hard for this house. This was her dream.” (05:08)
Jillian Betavali reflecting on Daryl’s wrongful arrest: “I was going through a divorce and I was living in a shack out in the middle of nowhere...” (12:18)
Patrick Hines summarizing Scott's manipulation: “He’s a manipulator for sure. She was a victim of this.” (24:05)
On the final police response: “I've never heard of something so ridiculous in all of my career.” – Sergeant Heather Olson (53:27)

Conclusion

Episode 418 of True Crime Obsessed masterfully narrates a complex tale of trust, betrayal, and justice. Through engaging storytelling and insightful analysis, Jillian Betavali and Patrick Hines shed light on the profound impacts of abusive relationships and the critical need for systemic support to protect victims.