Podcast Summary: True Crime Obsessed - Episode 425: "Worst Ex Ever: Killing for Custody"

Introduction

In Episode 425 of True Crime Obsessed, titled "Worst Ex Ever: Killing for Custody," hosts Julia Betavale and Patrick Hines delve deep into a harrowing true crime case featured in the Netflix series Worst Ex Ever. This episode meticulously unpacks the tragic story of Eric and Rosa Hill, exploring the dark path from a seemingly idyllic marriage to a labyrinth of manipulation, violence, and ultimately, murder. Through their signature blend of humor, sass, and heartfelt commentary, Julia and Patrick provide listeners with a comprehensive understanding of the case, enriched with notable quotes and critical insights.

Case Overview

The episode centers on the tumultuous relationship between Eric Hill and Rosa Hill, whose marriage spiraled into a nightmare fueled by Rosa's obsessive desire for custody of their daughter. The narrative unfolds with Rosa's calculated maneuvers to isolate Eric from his family and friends, setting the stage for a series of devastating events.

Background: Eric and Rosa's Relationship

Eric Hill, portrayed as a dedicated and hardworking individual, found himself ensnared in a marriage with Rosa Hill, a woman with a domineering and manipulative personality.

• Eric's Perspective: “[02:35] I am very lucky to be alive today. If they had gotten away with it, you know, my daughter would never know who I was. But I did step up to this challenge, and I did persevere.”

Rosa's introduction into Eric's life brought initial hope, with both appearing deeply in love. However, beneath the surface, Rosa's controlling nature began to emerge.

• Patrick on Rosa's Control: “[10:27] And Rosa debers to May, so it's like being passed down in that family.”

Escalation: Isolation and Control

Rosa systematically isolated Eric from his support network, employing tactics such as whispering into his ear during conversations and controlling phone communications. This isolation exacerbated Eric's mental health, leading to severe depression.

• Julia on Manipulation: “[20:27] It's always the same thing. The isolation, the control.”

Despite Eric's relentless efforts to maintain a semblance of normalcy—juggling multiple jobs to support his family—Rosa's manipulation intensified, culminating in threats of divorce and increasing physical confrontations.

• Patrick on Eric's Struggles: “[26:18] So he'd get off work at 5p, sleep for a few hours, maybe sleep for a few hours, then go to work from 11:30pm through 5pm the next day.”

Violent Events: The Murder of Sally Hill

The situation reached a critical juncture when Rosa, accompanied by her mother May, violently confronted Eric, culminating in the brutal murder of Sally Hill, Eric's beloved grandmother. This heinous act was part of a premeditated plan to eliminate obstacles in Rosa's quest for full custody.

• Julia Describes the Attack: “[43:55] Etimum movement someone call that step on in the last years of the border fight Blaise and what happens include the thing in their house on the oh my God.”

The confrontation was chaotic, with Eric being assaulted and ultimately left fearing for his life as Rosa attempted to frame him for the murder.

• Eric's Desperation: “[45:04] I couldn't do anything for her. I just didn't want to die.”

Investigation and Unraveling the Crime

Law enforcement intervention was delayed until neighbors reported suspicious activity, preventing the complete execution of Rosa and May's plan. The discovery of Sally Hill's body in a locked shed unveiled the depth of their malevolence.

• Patrick on the Evidence: “[56:31] They also found a black backpack on the side of the house. It included braided rope, crossbows, a hunting knife, and other disturbing items.”

Forensic evidence, including DNA traces and meticulous planning documents labeled "Operation Custody," further implicated Rosa and May in the conspiracy to destroy Eric's life.

• Julia on the Forensic Findings: “[58:25] So they wrote, we're back again. It is never going to happen. You are not smarter than DNA.”

Conclusion: Justice and Aftermath

The trial concluded with Rosa Hill being convicted of the murder of Sally Hill and the attempted murder of Eric Hill, receiving a sentence of 25 years to life. May Hill was also convicted of premeditated attempted murder, serving a life sentence. Eric, despite enduring immense suffering, emerged as a survivor, dedicating himself to co-parenting his daughter and rebuilding his life.

• Eric's Resilience: “[62:36] I survived and I'm doing great. Rosa and me.”

The hosts close the discussion by highlighting the importance of recognizing and seeking help in abusive relationships, emphasizing the value of support systems in overcoming such traumatic experiences.

• Julia's Final Call to Action: “[29:37] If you have gotten yourself out of a situation, thank God. And you need to go to them. Go to them.”

Notable Quotes

1. Eric Hill on Survival:
   “[02:17] I am very lucky to be alive today. If they had gotten away with it, you know, my daughter would never know who I was. But I did step up to this challenge, and I did persevere.”

2. Patrick on Control Tactics:
   “[10:27] And Rosa defers to May, so it's like being passed down in that family.”

3. Julia on Manipulation:
   “[20:27] It's always the same thing. The isolation, the control.”

4. Eric's Desperation During Attack:
   “[45:08] Do you really think you're going to get away with this?”

5. Julia on Legal Implications:
   “[56:31] They also found a black backpack on the side of the house. It included braided rope, crossbows, a hunting knife, and other disturbing items.”

Closing Thoughts

Through their engaging narrative and incisive analysis, Julia and Patrick shed light on the complexities of abusive relationships and the devastating consequences that can ensue. This episode serves as a sobering reminder of the importance of vigilance, support, and the pursuit of justice in the face of overwhelming adversity.