Trust Me: Cults, Extreme Belief, and Manipulation
Episode: Carol Merchasin - The Cult Assassin: Suing High-Control Groups
Release Date: August 13, 2025
Introduction
In this compelling episode of Trust Me, hosts Lola Blanc and Megan Elizabeth delve deep into the intricate world of high-control cults and the legal battles surrounding them. Their guest, Carol Murphy Murchison, a renowned lawyer affectionately dubbed the "Cult Assassin," shares her journey of combating abusive high-control groups through litigation. Carol's expertise offers listeners a rare glimpse into the legal strategies employed to hold these manipulative organizations accountable.
Carol's Journey to Becoming the "Cult Assassin"
Carol Murphy Murchison's transformative path began with her background in employment law, where she specialized in investigating sexual misconduct in the workplace. After retiring from her initial legal career, Carol was approached by a woman alleging widespread sexual assault within a Buddhist community in Canada. Skeptical at first, Carol was driven by a sense of justice to investigate these claims despite her reservations about a compassionate religion harboring such abuse.
Carol Murphy Murchison [03:30]: "She'll talk to us about why human trafficking is more subtle than we typically imagine. How the law in the US is behind on legally recognizing coercion that happens to an adult or doesn't involve immediate physical violence."
As Carol delved deeper, she uncovered numerous victims and sustained media coverage, leading her to realize that these organizations were systematically evading responsibility for their actions. This revelation ignited her dedication to using legal avenues to fight against such groups, ultimately earning her the moniker "Cult Assassin."
Legal Challenges in Suing High-Control Groups
Carol elucidates the complexities involved in bringing legal action against high-control groups. These organizations often feature charismatic leaders who wield significant power, making it difficult for victims to speak out. The legal system, which traditionally handles clear-cut cases of violence and exploitation, struggles with the nuanced forms of coercion prevalent in cults.
Carol Murphy Murchison [03:03]: "She'll talk to us about why human trafficking is more subtle than we typically imagine... how cults threaten to sue as a weapon to silence people who speak out about them."
One of the primary legal tools Carol utilizes is the Federal Human Trafficking Act, which addresses coercion and manipulation—common tactics used by cults to control their members. By framing their actions within this legal context, Carol aims to bypass traditional defenses that high-control groups might employ.
Understanding Coercion and Its Legal Implications
A significant focus of the discussion centers on the concept of coercion. Carol explains that coercion undermines genuine consent, making many actions within cults actionable under the law.
Carol Murphy Murchison [44:54]: "That's coercion...we have the Federal Trafficking Act, which does have an element that recognizes that coercion and fraud, I would say that they negate consent."
Using the BITE Model (Behavior control, Information control, Thought control, Emotional control) by Steve Hassan, Carol and her team assess and present evidence of coercive tactics to juries. This model helps illustrate the psychological manipulation that detracts from the victim's ability to freely consent.
Carol Murphy Murchison [46:36]: "We have to introduce evidence of all those elements of coercion so that a jury can understand exactly... they were being coerced."
Tactics of Cults to Suppress Dissent: Defamation Lawsuits
High-control groups often retaliate against critics by threatening defamation lawsuits, aiming to intimidate and silence those who speak out.
Carol Murphy Murchison [48:22]: "All the time...if you say anything about a cult leader, we're going to sue you for defamation."
Carol highlights the challenges victims face when threatened with lawsuits, including the financial and emotional burdens of legal defense. However, she points out the existence of anti-SLAPP (Strategic Lawsuit Against Public Participation) laws in states like California and New York, which protect individuals from frivolous lawsuits aimed at suppressing free speech.
Carol Murphy Murchison [50:43]: "You might be able to find a lawyer who will do it pro bono...they have to pay a lawyer and they have to put people under oath."
Support and Resources for Survivors
Recognizing the daunting nature of legal battles, Carol offers guidance and resources for survivors seeking assistance:
- BITE Model Framework: To identify and document coercive tactics.
- Therapeutic Support: Recommending therapists specialized in trauma and cult recovery, such as Dan Shaw and Rachel Bernstein.
- Legal Assistance: Encouraging survivors to seek out pro bono legal help through state bar associations and human rights organizations.
Carol Murphy Murchison [70:40]: "If you have a really strong case to defend against defamation, you would most likely qualify to have your legal fees paid, in which case you might be able to find a lawyer who will."
Dealing with Enablers Within Organizations
A significant hurdle in dismantling high-control groups is managing enablers—members who, often unconsciously, support the oppressive dynamics of the organization. Carol advises maintaining contact without engaging in arguments, emphasizing that enabling behavior stems from deeply ingrained beliefs rather than malicious intent.
Carol Murphy Murchison [64:29]: "Never ever...maintain contact because maybe someday something will change."
She underscores the importance of setting personal boundaries and recognizing that changing the minds of deeply indoctrinated individuals is often futile.
Recognizing Warning Signs of High-Control Groups
Carol outlines key red flags that indicate the presence of a high-control group:
- Exclusive Truth Claims: Groups that assert they possess the only valid truth.
- Suppression of Dissent: Disallowing or manipulating dissenting opinions.
- Authoritarian Leadership: Charismatic leaders who demand absolute loyalty and control.
- Manipulative Practices: Techniques like love bombing followed by withdrawal to destabilize members psychologically.
Ryan Reynolds [67:34]: "If you cannot have a dissenting opinion or it is set up and structured in such a way that you feel manipulated into hiding your dissenting opinion."
Recognizing these signs early can empower individuals to avoid falling prey to manipulative groups and seek help if they find themselves entangled.
Conclusion: Empowering Survivors and Enforcing Accountability
Throughout the episode, Carol Murphy Murchison emphasizes the necessity of legal accountability in combating high-control groups. By leveraging existing legal frameworks and continuously advocating for survivors, she aims to dismantle the structures that enable abuse and manipulation.
Carol Murphy Murchison [78:14]: "Thank you guys so much for listening to another episode...remember to follow your gut. Watch out for red flags and never, ever Trust Me."
The hosts, Lola Blanc and Megan Elizabeth, commend Carol for her invaluable work and encourage listeners to utilize the resources provided to protect themselves and support others.
Key Takeaways
- Legal Mechanisms: Utilizing the Federal Human Trafficking Act and anti-SLAPP laws to hold high-control groups accountable.
- Understanding Coercion: Recognizing psychological manipulation as a barrier to genuine consent.
- Support Systems: Accessing specialized legal and therapeutic resources for survivors.
- Warning Signs: Identifying red flags of high-control groups to prevent exploitation.
- Dealing with Enablers: Setting boundaries and maintaining contact without enabling abusive behavior.
Resources Mentioned
- BITE Model by Steve Hassan: [Link or reference if available]
- Therapists: Dan Shaw, Rachel Bernstein
- Legal Firms: McAllister Oliverious (Website)
- Support Organizations: Hartwood Heartwood (Website)
Note: All relevant links and contact information can be found in the show notes.
Follow Us:
Instagram: @TrustMePodcast
TikTok: @USMeCultPodcast
Email: trustmepodmail.com
Listen on: iHeartRadio, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
This summary encapsulates the core discussions and insights from the episode, providing a comprehensive overview for those who haven't listened while highlighting crucial quotes and timestamps for reference.