Two Girls One Ghost — Episode 363: Reddit Scary Stories | The Creepiest EVPs & Paranormal Evidence

Date: March 8, 2026
Hosts: Corinne Vien & Sabrina Deana-Roga

Episode Overview

This episode dives into some of the creepiest and most convincing EVPs (Electronic Voice Phenomena) and paranormal evidence sourced from Reddit and listeners. Corinne and Sabrina explore chilling audio clips, debate possible meanings, share personal psychic moments, and include firsthand listener stories. The focus is on evaluating what makes paranormal evidence convincing—and unsettling.

Key Discussion Points & Insights

Catching Up: Personal Updates, Podcast Milestones, and Imposter YouTube Channels

Starts at 02:27

• Illness and Old School Vibes: The hosts return after being ill, reminiscing on how recording feels nostalgic.
• Imposter Alert: They recount a recent incident where someone recreated their YouTube channel, copying content and even engaging with fans through comments (04:08).
• "It was kind of a thrill… pretty stressful too." — Corinne (04:36)
• Listener Community Spotted the Fake: Several listeners helped uncover the imposter by commenting on their genuine videos.
• Social Media Safety: Quick reminder of the risks of having an online audience and the need for vigilance.

Sabrina’s Personal Psychic Experience with Gateway Tapes

Starts at 06:01

• Meditation & the Gateway Tapes: Sabrina shares a meditation experience after months away from the practice. She describes intense sensory and psychic phenomena.
• “Literally felt like my lower half of my body was, like, severed off of me. But not in a painful way, just like my body didn’t exist.” — Sabrina (08:31)
• Remote Viewing/Precognition: She repeatedly envisions their friend, Whitney, feeling stalked. Hours later, Whitney confirms a real-life incident matching these visions—a stranger placed an AirTag in her bag at a dog park.
• Syncing Psychic Hits: Corinne also felt a strong urge to reach out to Whitney around the same time. The hosts discuss shared psychic experiences and the nature of intuition.
• Paranormal & Empathic Connections: Both hosts reflect on their own and each other's psychic moments, sometimes doubting themselves but learning to trust these “hits.”
• Quote: "You time traveled. You literally saw into the past and witnessed… like, you time traveled." — Corinne (13:35)

Deep Dive: Reddit’s Creepiest EVPs and Paranormal Evidence

Main segment starts at 17:42

What is an EVP?

Brief explanation (21:36)

• Electronic Voice Phenomenon: Unexplained voices/sounds captured on recordings, sometimes not heard during the recording itself.

EVP #1: Ogden Exchange Building “Child in Water”

Timestamps: 26:14 – 36:44

• Source: Art Bell’s Coast to Coast (April 2, 2005) / Reddit user Oxum's Razor
• Location: Ogden Exchange Building, Utah. Recording by Ghost Investigator Society (GIS).
• Context: The building was abandoned; no water, no children present. Laptop left recording in an empty room.
• EVP Content: After silence, sounds of water splashing and a child’s voice saying "I can’t breathe," interrupted by a deep, possibly demonic voice.
• Quote: “My heart is racing… it feels wrong.” — Corinne (33:36)
• Possible Interpretation: Hosts and Redditors believe it may be audio of a child drowning—a chilling slice of residual haunting.
• Discussion: Both are deeply unsettled by how vivid and contextually off-the-charts this EVP is.

EVP #2: Martha Washington Inn Ballroom — "Jake's an Asshole"?

Timestamps: 37:25 – 41:22

• Source: Reddit user QuailMain9957
• Context: Audio captured in a ballroom; unclear statement.
• Hosts’ Interpretations Differ:
  • Corinne hears “Get down from there. Go the other way.”
  • Sabrina hears, “Jake’s an asshole. Go away.”
• Quote: “People trying to post what they heard kept getting deleted, so I do think people were hearing a curse word.” — Sabrina (38:58)
• Fun Segment: The ambiguity of EVPs and the “Yanny/Laurel effect.” Listeners encouraged to weigh in.

EVP #3: Haunted Dairy Ranch Affair — “Coming Back”

Timestamps: 42:14 – 45:49

• Source: Reddit user Jackshid
• Location: Former dairy ranch with tragic history (murder-suicide).
• EVP: Voice mutters “coming back” or “she’s coming back.” Some hear “fuck, he’s coming back.”
• Quote: “Like, it’s almost like a clearing of the throat… it could be the moment of like, oh shit, she’s coming back.” — Sabrina (45:18)
• Discussion: The ambiguity again—and a juicy backstory involving murder and betrayal.

Gettysburg Battlefield Video — Marching Ghosts

Timestamps: 46:03 – 49:40

• Source Video: Family records multiple apparitions at different heights seemingly “marching” behind a rock on the battlefield.
• Hosts’ Analysis:
  • The apparitions appear to duck behind a rock, then stand tall—possibly a residual haunting reenacting a Civil War march.
  • The evidence’s renown in the ghost hunting community is discussed.
• Quote: "You could do 400 episodes on Gettysburg..." — Sabrina (49:13)

The Sally House Demonic Basement EVP

Timestamps: 52:53 – 61:52

• Background: Famously haunted Kansas house. The spirit “Sally” is possibly not a little girl, but a dark entity. The house has a long history of physical attacks, especially on men.
• Live Sci Fi Investigation: Two striking EVPs from the basement:
  • EVP 1 (58:42): In response to “Do you believe in God?” a deep voice retorts “No help there” or “He’s not up there.”
  • EVP 2: In response to “Is this how you show love, by inflicting pain?” hosts hear “you think,” “sick,” or “Nick”—followed by real-life evidence of scratch marks on an investigator’s neck.
• Quote: “Either way, it feels like it’s mocking.” — Sabrina (59:16)
• Reflection: The “Carl” phenomenon at Lizzie Borden House — negative entities may arise from intense emotional energy.

Listener Evidence: Vanderbilt Mansion & Poolside Apparition

Timestamps: 69:58 – 77:55

• Sarah (Vanderbilt Mansion): Captures a whisper on Snapchat; several interpretations (“I died in this house” / “I die for this” etc.), demonstrating the elusive nature of EVPs.
• Annette (Apparition Photo): Photo at a pool post-family member’s passing appears to show her ghost swimming with the family. Hosts note how the ghostly face appears unusually white, likely due to exposure but nonetheless haunting.

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• “You time traveled. You literally saw into the past and witnessed… like, you time traveled.” — Corinne (13:35)
• “My heart is racing… it feels wrong.” — Corinne (33:36) [After the child-drowning EVP]
• “People trying to post what they heard kept getting deleted, so I do think people were hearing a curse word.” — Sabrina (38:58) [On the Martha Washington Inn EVP]
• “You could do 400 episodes on Gettysburg...” — Sabrina (49:13)
• “Either way, it feels like it’s mocking.” — Sabrina (59:16) [On the Sally House EVP]
• "If you have your own paranormal evidence, please share it with us. The universe is calling you!" — Hosts (77:59)

Episode Structure & Timestamps (MM:SS)

• 02:27 — Personal catch-up & imposter YouTube channel drama
• 06:01 — Sabrina’s psychic/meditation story (“Gateway Tapes” and sensing a stalking incident)
• 17:42 — Introduction to main topic: Reddit’s best paranormal evidence
• 26:14 — Ogden Exchange Building EVP: child, water, and demonic voice
• 37:25 — Martha Washington Inn EVP: "Jake’s an asshole"? (auditory illusions)
• 42:14 — Dairy Ranch EVP: "Coming back" / historic murder context
• 46:03 — Gettysburg Battlefield marching ghost video
• 52:53 — The Sally House: history and chilling basement EVPs
• 69:58 — Listener submissions: Vanderbilt Mansion EVP & pool apparition photo

Tone, Language, and Style

• Conversational, friendly, humorous, and affectionate (“two ghostesses,” “clutch your clavicle!”)
• Respectful of listener sensitivities (trigger warnings when needed)
• Genuinely spooked by evidence, often echoing the audience’s chills and skepticism
• Encourages listener participation and feedback (“let us know what you hear”)

Listener Participation & Community

• EVP Interpretation: Hosts repeatedly urge listeners to share their own interpretations of the EVPs played ("Let us know what you hear!").
• Call for Submissions: Listeners invited to email or submit their own paranormal evidence and stories.
• Special Episodes: Promise of a future “Encounters” episode featuring listener EVPs and evidence.

In Summary

This episode is a spooky thrill ride of real-life psychic moments, bone-chilling Reddit EVPs, legendary haunted places, and firsthand listener accounts. The hosts guide listeners through interpreting eerie audio evidence and reflecting on what makes the paranormal convincing or debatable. Sharing, speculation, debate, and a genuine love of all things creepy tie it all together.

For more spine-tingling evidence, subscribe, submit your own stories, or join the Discord and Patreon communities. And remember:
"We’ll see you on the other side."