Episode 207: That's Unfair?! Ft. Angela Giarratana

Host: Morgan Absher
Guest: Angela Giarratana
Release Date: March 13, 2025
Podcast: Two Hot Takes
Description: Morgan Absher and her co-hosts delve into the most compelling Reddit, listener write-ins, and online stories to offer their hot takes on dating, relationships, life, and AITA tales.

Introduction and Guest Welcome [00:21 - 01:03]

Morgan Absher opens the episode with her characteristic humor, engaging in playful banter with her co-host Angela Giarratana. Angela expresses her excitement about being on the show, highlighting Morgan's engaging setup.

Morgan [00:21]: "Don't tell me with a good time. The people are hearing that and they're like, oh, my God, is this going to be another three-hour-long episode?"

AITA Discussion: Hosting Friends' Wedding Without Plus One [04:35 - 22:58]

Story Overview: A Reddit user faces conflict over not allowing a plus one at friends Dave and Kim's wedding, which is hosted at the user’s grandmother's house. The complication arises from an ex-girlfriend, Leslie, who is not permitted to attend alone or with a guest due to past relationship issues.

Key Points:

• Morgan's Take: She remains split, acknowledging the potential chaos of having the new relationship and the ex at the same event.

  Morgan [06:18]: "I actually am a little split down the middle. Only because it would be chaotic to have the new relationship there with Leslie."

• Angela's Perspective: She emphasizes the importance of maintaining boundaries to prevent the wedding from becoming overshadowed by ex-related drama.

  Angela [08:15]: "It's okay. I get it. But at the same time, like, you might burn a friendship because this is also their wedding day."

• Insurance and Venue Logistics: The discussion touches on practical aspects like event insurance and venue logistics, showing the complexities of hosting a significant event amidst personal tensions.

  Angela [12:22]: "This is, it's got to be genius. Property damages. Red wine on a couch would totally be covered."

• Community Reactions: They explore Reddit comments suggesting strict boundaries, such as excluding Leslie entirely to maintain the event's integrity.

  Angela [14:03]: "Was wondering if you have any comments from OP... They kept the original decision even after the update."

Notable Quotes:

• Morgan [20:39]: "It's your house. You can do what you want."
• Angela [21:16]: "Why are you making Leslie's blow up? And immaturity and emotional irregulation. OP's problem."

Conclusion: Both hosts empathize with the original poster (OP), leaning towards siding with their decision to prioritize hosting responsibilities and personal boundaries over accommodating an unstable ex.

AITA Discussion: Life Insurance Payout Conflict [42:05 - 55:53]

Story Overview: A woman discovers she is the beneficiary of her ex-fiancé’s life insurance, originally intended for him and his pregnant girlfriend. The girlfriend now demands the payout to support her and the unborn child, leading to ethical and legal dilemmas.

Key Points:

• Morgan's Insight: She underscores the legal right of the beneficiary but empathizes with the emotional turmoil behind the demand.

  Morgan [43:30]: "This is pretty intense."

• Angela's Analysis: She grapples with the moral implications, questioning whether to honor legal entitlements versus addressing the girlfriend’s needs.

  Angela [47:59]: "Yeah, I get just in a way you could almost, even if you are wrong, convince yourself that it's right and justified because it is such a huge amount of money and life-changing."

• Reddit Community Reactions: The hosts discuss potential community perspectives, including suggestions to keep the money or allocate portions to the child, reflecting the gray areas involved.

  Morgan [54:21]: "What if the doctor was like, boy. No, it's a girl. No, it's a boy. No, it's a girl."

Notable Quotes:

• Angela [48:18]: "Eleanor. Chloe's the wife."
• Morgan [54:18]: "That's so sad."

Conclusion: The conversation highlights the tension between legal rights and moral responsibilities, emphasizing the complexity of navigating life insurance benefits in the context of fractured relationships and unexpected demands.

AITA Discussion: Husband's Obsessive Need for Physical Touch [56:27 - 73:43]

Story Overview: A woman contemplates divorce after her husband insists on touching her breasts to fall asleep, a behavior that has become suffocating and one-sided. Despite her attempts to set boundaries, his inability to adapt has strained their marriage.

Key Points:

• Morgan's Empathy: She considers the emotional and physical toll of pregnancy, condemning the husband's lack of sensitivity.

  Morgan [26:09]: "This isn't a trip to the grocery store or the arcade. My guy."

• Angela's Perspective: She identifies the behavior as a control issue, urging the woman to prioritize her well-being over the husband's demands.

  Angela [63:35]: "This is so bad... But, like, the first thing that came into my mind is, like, I kind of want to hit his hands with a baseball bat."

• Reddit Community Reactions: Comments generally support the woman’s decision, labeling the husband’s actions as manipulative and disrespectful.

  Morgan [60:26]: "Husband needs to go. This is so bad."

  Angela [66:57]: "He doesn't do housework. If he had done it, then I wouldn't be complaining like this."

Notable Quotes:

• Morgan [57:36]: "He's literally like, come here. She can be like, get away."
• Angela [63:50]: "You can't have peace neither."

Conclusion: Both hosts firmly support the woman's stance, recognizing the husband's behavior as a form of emotional manipulation and control. They advocate for setting firm boundaries and considering divorce as a viable option for personal well-being.

AITA Discussion: Wife Throwing Away Late Wife's Videotapes [75:28 - 88:44]

Story Overview: A widower (Morgan) plans to gift his daughter Eleanor with videotapes documenting her late mother Chloe's pregnancy, intended for Eleanor’s 18th birthday. His new wife, Wendy, unexpectedly destroys the tapes, citing the need for Morgan to move on, leading to emotional and relational turmoil.

Key Points:

• Morgan's Perspective: She empathizes deeply with the widower, condemning Wendy's actions as destructive and unsupportive.

  Morgan [82:03]: "This is so devastating."

• Angela's Analysis: She highlights the gravity of destroying meaningful memories and the ensuing betrayal, urging the widower to reconsider his relationship with Wendy.

  Angela [87:34]: "This is so bad... Wendy needs to go."

• Reddit Community Reactions: The majority of comments side with Morgan, labeling Wendy's behavior as overstepping and emotionally manipulative.

  Morgan [95:06]: "So it's like a bad person in public."

  Angela [99:52]: "He needs to block them all and go, like, move."

Notable Quotes:

• Morgan [86:27]: "You don't tell anybody, please. No. You messed up."
• Angela [90:48]: "This is a line in the sand."

Conclusion: The episode underscores the emotional devastation caused by destroying cherished memories, especially those meant for a child. The hosts unanimously condemn Wendy’s actions, emphasizing the importance of supporting the widower in honoring his late wife's legacy for their daughter's sake.

AITA Discussion: Telling the Truth About Ending an Engagement [94:31 - 105:27]

Story Overview: A woman breaks off her engagement after discovering her ex-fiancé used his family's resources unethically to conceive a child with his brother’s wife through a controversial method. She confronts his family and ultimately decides to return his engagement ring, leading to further conflicts.

Key Points:

• Morgan's Insight: She condemns the unethical behavior involved, expressing disdain for the deceitful tactics used by the ex-fiancé and his family.

  Morgan [97:50]: "You're fucking around on you and lying about it."

• Angela's Perspective: She highlights the importance of honesty and the destructiveness of such deceitful practices, reinforcing the woman's decision to end the relationship.

  Angela [103:00]: "That's where it lies."

• Reddit Community Reactions: Comments largely support the woman's actions, criticizing the ex-fiancé and his family's manipulative behavior.

  Morgan [105:06]: "It's like you can't hide it."

  Angela [105:17]: "Don't be bad."

Notable Quotes:

• Morgan [100:03]: "It was nothing like that, it's just this and that."

• Angela [103:09]: "That's so weird, dude. Read the room."

Conclusion: The hosts strongly support the woman's decision to end her engagement, condemning the unethical and manipulative actions of the ex-fiancé and his family. They emphasize the importance of integrity and honesty in relationships, advocating for the woman’s right to end a harmful and deceitful partnership.

Final Thoughts and Wrap-Up [108:14 - End]

Morgan and Angela conclude the episode by reflecting on the intense discussions, expressing empathy for the individuals involved in each AITA story. They encourage listeners to engage with these complex scenarios thoughtfully and consider the broader emotional and ethical implications.

Morgan: "And that's, you know, it's about honoring who you lost a little bit. And this is the opposite of that."

Angela: "It's about the baby. It's about the baby."

The episode ends with a lighthearted exchange about their personal lives and upcoming projects, maintaining the engaging and supportive dynamic that listeners have come to love.

Notable Highlights:

• Emphasis on Empathy: Throughout the episode, both hosts consistently show deep empathy for the individuals in the AITA stories, recognizing the emotional complexities involved.
• Critical Analysis: They provide thoughtful critiques of the actions in each scenario, often siding with the party seeking fairness and respect.
• Community Engagement: By referencing and discussing Reddit comments, they offer a well-rounded view of the community’s perspectives, enriching the discussion.

Favorite Quotes:

• Morgan [73:37]: "It's not about the boob."
• Angela [63:35]: "This is so bad. But, like, the first thing that came into my mind is, like, I kind of want to hit his hands with a baseball bat."

Conclusion

Episode 207 of Two Hot Takes featuring Angela Giarratana delved into multiple intense AITA scenarios, providing listeners with in-depth analysis and compassionate perspectives. Morgan and Angela navigated each story with a balance of humor, empathy, and critical insight, making the episode a valuable resource for anyone grappling with questions of fairness and ethical dilemmas in relationships.

For more insights and full-length videos, follow Morgan on Instagram, visit the Two Hot Takes YouTube Channel, or support exclusive content on Patreon.