A (0:03)

Why most 800 person churches die of niceness. Hey, it's Rich Burch here from the Unseminary podcast here with a solo episode for you today talking about mid tier, mid sized churches. There's an interesting sticking point between 500 and 1000 where a lot of churches get stuck. And I want to unpack that today and particularly help you. Whether you're a church approaching that or you're at that curtain sticking point, this podcast will help you unpack a few things that you should be doing to overcome that hurdle. Nice is not a growth strategy. When I was a young adult, I worked at a summer Christian camp called Camp Minioi. You know, you can picture this camp even though you've never been there. You know, it's canoeing on a lake, it's campfires around with s' mores at night, it's singing songs with kids. It's fantastic and great experience actually was the first place that really trusted me with leadership. I owe a lot of my leadership chops to working at Camp Mineowi. In fact, when I first was leading as a cabin leader, each of the cabins has six kids. And six is like a great number because you could sit six kids around the table that we would eat at and in the dining hall, I'd be at one end and the other people would be around the table. And, you know, you could reach out, everybody, help everybody, poke somebody, ask buddy somebody a question, that sort of thing. It was a perfect size. But then what happened is I graduated to an older group and the group size went from 6 to 10. And it was like I needed to learn a brand new leadership language. We used to go from sitting at one dinner table, there was enough kind of people in the cabin at night to have a good conversation. But then when you went to 10, all of a sudden we're now at not at one table, at mealtimes, we're at two tables. And now you've got just that much more kind of social interaction to try to get people to be friends and to connect. And it started to fall apart. What I was doing to lead a cabin of 6 did not work for leading a cabin of 10. Group size matters. Scale doesn't just add complexity, it alters the relational physics of a group. And I think the same dynamic is true for churches as they grow beyond 500 to 1000 and beyond. What got you to 500 will not get you to a thousand and beyond. And there's a number of key ways that we've got to think differently and ultimately act Differently the niceness trap, how healthy cultures turn hazardous at around 800. Let me be blunt. 800 frankly is a trap size. Only a sliver of North American churches get, you know, ever hit the 500 barrier and even fewer to get to a thousand and even fewer get to 2,000. It's like a consecutive pressure. As the church gets larger and larger, it becomes harder to do that. Only about 4% get to 500. About 2% break the thousand barrier. What does that mean? That half of the churches that break the 500 barrier will not break the 1000 barrier. And that's not random. It really is structural. At 800, what got you here? Tight relationships, consensus leadership and the beloved family feel. And a place that people frankly invited friends to come and be a part of quietly becomes the lid on what God wants to do next at your church. Tim Keller calls this the size culture. And in fact in our show notes today, you can click with this Great, it's almost 20 years old, this great PDF from 20 years ago where he talks through this. Every size behaves different. And if you impose small church expectations on a larger body, like expecting the senior pastor or to personally be available to everyone, that sort of thing, you ultimately wreak havoc. Decision making slows to a crawl. Six hour elder meetings become normal and leaders burn out doing the shepherding that should be owned frankly by teams and systems. You know, we've got a webinar coming up tomorrow. The day that this launches, it's literally the next day@churchgrowthlaunchpad.com and what we're looking at is really what churches do in this 500 to 1000 range that keep growing. One of the areas that we've got to focus on is invite culture. You see early on in a church's development, inviting just happened. But what we learn is the fastest growing churches that break the thousand, two thousand and more barriers, they don't leave invite up to chance. They train, equip and motivate their people to invite their friends. So at the church growth launchpad you can just learn more and register@churchgrowth launchpad.com we're going to be giving you a 90 day plan. So we'll actually talk you through. Here's what you should be doing in the next 90 days going into early 2026 to help you launch and grow or more than launch help you grow. And then we're also going to about five levers that fast growing churches pull to build their invite culture. I'd love to have you there. It's completely free one hour. It's at 12 noon Eastern or 9am for our friends on the Pacific coast. We'll also be doing Q and A and that sort of thing. So again, that's churchgrowthlaunchpad.com November 12, that's tomorrow, the day this releases. I want to have you there. If you're a church between 500 and 1000, you absolutely need to be at this webinar. But let's jump back in and talk through how the niceness trap shows up. Well, first of all, consensus as a creed, you know, there's this idea that like we all have to agree. And in a very small church maybe that was fine. And then in fact that kind of starts to ripple out. But consensus ultimately can slow down a church. We have to be led by people who I believe God has given a vision to. And a part of our job as a leader is to ask the Lord, what is it? What is the vision that you have for our church and how can I help lead us there. You know, the family can become a club insider. Language, cliques, a crowded calendar built around those who are already committed signal to newcomers. Man, this, this just isn't for you. The insideriness of a church of 800 is super insipid. You've got to work hard to make sure that you are both expecting and accepting new here guests. You've got to go out of your way to make sure that new here guests, people who are just arriving, feel welcome when they arrive. You know, this comfort thing can settle in in a church of this size. And what you really need to be have is have clarity around what it is that you believe God's called you to. What once felt like unity can become a veto power and actually slow the church down. It's not pastoral care, it's really organizational anemia. So friends, niceness, this idea of like we're all in here, it's us four and no more that erodes the is an undercurrent that erodes a church of 500 to 1,000 and you've got to work hard to push against that and really ultimately driving people to invite their friends to really make this about people who are not here yet. Niceness can feel like godliness, but it really isn't. Niceness can mimic fruit. It creates harmony. It's low comfort, positive vibes. But harmony without movement is a hospice. It's not health. Mid sized churches plateau and they show this uncomfortable pairing. Two things between an insider satisfaction is paired with low evangelistic engagement. So people are super happy with who's here and they're not reaching out to their friends around them. And we often, often might use theology to cover this up. You've heard leaders say this, oh, we're being faithful, we're not chasing the numbers. Faithfulness and fearlessness are not enemies. The church in ACTS was constantly adding people and was constantly in tension. They constantly had to reorganize and think about what are we doing to make space for people who aren't here yet. When peace becomes an excuse to protect our preferences, that's not gentleness, it's mission drift. Niceness never risks, never disappoints, and never decides. And you know what? That isn't love. It's abdication. So this the antidote for you, One of the antidotes, a significant antidote, the biggest antidote. The thing I want you to think about, dear Leader, is if you're in this church of 500 to 1000, you should be thinking about invite culture. The cure is clarity, courage and an invite culture. This isn't about being corporate, it's about becoming clear. It's the courage to choose mission over maintenance, which will feel less nice to insiders. That's just gonna happen because humans, we are focused on our own needs. It's not natural for us to worry about others. We are constantly self centered and a part of what we've got to do as an organization is we've got to reorient our organization to people who are not here yet. The data is super stubborn on this. Growing churches actively equip and encourage people to invite their friends. They train, mobilize and equip their people. 72% of growing churches emphasize invitation versus 43% of churches in decline. Think about that. Nearly double of fast growing churches, they are emphasizing invitation more than churches in decline. So what we've got to do is make invite culture your operating system. Preach the why relentlessly. Every number has a name. Every name has a story. Every story matters to God. Equip the how. Give scripts, give them things to to say. Give them social media assets, give them invite cards. Give them things to do. Fix the funnel. Invitation without assimilation is just churn. You've got to identify guests, you've got to follow up quickly. And you've got to have an over the top obvious next step for your first time guest design for scale. Think about kids, students, weekends, group. All of these engines must have capacity for you to pour invite gas. Listen, we've seen five strategic pivots to break 800 and to live to tell about it first of all is to go from the family feel to missional clarity. That's what we've been talking about here. Casting a crisp, repeatable vision for outsiders, not insiders. You've got to consistently say to your people, it's not about us, it's about the people that are not here. From consensus culture to accountable ownership, you've got to rewire your governance. Think about your board. They should be the one that are really guarding this mission, that are asking the question, where are we going from here? If the people on your board are not asking the question of who's not here yet, you might have the wrong people on your board. Your staff, they should be worrying about operations, they should be worrying about the day to day interactions of the church. Now what I like to do at this stage is to start challenging our board, that we should be thinking much more like a policy board than an operational board. And we should be asking the questions that are at least a year away. What is a year from now? How, how is the board leading us to where we're going? Rather than trying to fix the problems of today, Leave those up to staff. Another shift is from generalists to builders of builders. Your church stalls at the ceiling of your leaders, developing other leaders. If everything, if all of your volunteer teams report to staff, if all of your volunteers report to staff and they don't report to other volunteer leaders, you are going to cap your growth. Your staff, Ephesians 4, they need to be thinking about not being doers of the work, but by equipping others to do the number four from a program buffet to a simple, obvious pathway. You know, the foundational work of simple church still applies to so many churches out there. There was a time when I started in ministry that churches would brag, we have 112 ministries. And we thought that was a good thing. It wasn't because people can't deal with all that choice. We've got to provide a simple pathway from a new here guest to a person being fully connected. And it's got to be super clear, super obvious for people. And we've got to keep tweaking that during this time period. Oftentimes a church of 500 to 1000, they've got to retool their new here process to make it even more obvious. And then number five, from talking about invite to measuring it, what you celebrate gets replicated. There was a time where we were just surprised, oh, people showed up at our church. But now what we need to do is measure the new here funnel, measure the invite funnel. Understand, are your people actually inviting and are those friends actually showing up? We've got to get that in front of our leaders, get that in front of our people and keep them thinking about what can we do to increase the invite culture. Listen friends, when I was at that summer camp, you know, six kids at one table worked and I could pastor with just simply presence and charisma. But then when we went to 10, 10 kids in a cabin, man, I needed to build new systems. I had to come up with new ways to communicate. The same is true with your church. What you did at 400 will not work at 800 and 1,800 requires leadership. Not mean, not brusque, but clear. Leadership. Niceness keeps insiders comfortable. It keeps us focused on ourselves. What we need from church leaders like you is to focus us on inviting the people who are not here yet. You see a church of 200, a church of 100, a brand new church plant. They're good at inviting people, but that starts to drop off as your church grows. What you need to do is train, equip and mobilize your people to invite their friends. And actually tomorrow's online workshop@churchgrowthlaunchpad.com is at 12 noon for our friends on the East Coast, 9am for our friends on the west coast. We would love to have you there and we're going to go through really practically what can you do to increase the invite culture? Church plus, we're going to be opening up a brand new cohort for 2026 of church growth Incubator. This is a group coaching service where we take your senior leadership team for an entire year and we drive the lessons deep and increase the invite culture of your church. We've seen great results. In fact, there are churches that have been in this going on three, four years because of the results that they're seeing. Listen, nice doesn't change cities. You've got to get clear. You've got to have courage and animated by the spirit. Those are the things that will change your city that ultimately invite them to come and encounter Jesus. So thanks so much friends. Thanks for being a part of unseminary and tuning in. Let me know if there's anything, any way we can help you and make sure you drop by and join our online workshop tomorrow.