Loading summary
Annie Elise
Foreign you're listening to a Tenderfoot TV podcast.
Maggie Freeling
Hey y', all, Fall is here and with it the hunt for layers that actually last. That's why Quint has become my favorite place to shop. They have 50 Mongolian cashmere sweaters that feel like a splurge, premium denim that always fits just right and outerwear you'll wear for years. Their wool coats are my personal favorite. They have have that designer look but at a fraction of the cost. The secret is simple. Quince partners directly with top tier ethical factories and cuts out the middlemen. That's how they're able to bring luxury quality staples at half the price of similar brands. This fall my Quint's cashmere has been a daily go to and their denim is a constant in my closet. Find your fall staples at quint's. Go to quince.comvanishedweekly for free shipping on your order and 365 day returns. Now available in Canada too. That's Q-U-I-N-C-E.comvanishedweekly to get free shipping and 365 day returns. Quint.comvanished weekly.
Annie Elise
Some stories never make national headlines, but stories from small towns and coastal communities deserve recognition too. I'm Kylie Lowe, host of Dark Down East, a true crime podcast that gives voice to victims through investigative journalism and powerful storytelling. Set in my home state of Maine and the Greater New England area, it's my goal to dig through the archives to bring the stories of the people at the heart of these cases to Light.
Maggie Freeling
Listen to Dark down east wherever you get your podcasts.
John
Up and Vanish Weekly is released every Wednesday and brought to you absolutely free, but for one week early access and ad free listening. Subscribe to Tenderfoot plus at tenderfootplus.com or on Apple Podcasts if you're already a subscriber. Thank you for your support.
Maggie Freeling
This podcast discusses mature and sensitive content, including descriptions of violence that may be triggering for some audiences. Listener discretion is advised.
Payne Lindsay
Foreign.
Maggie Freeling
Hey y'. All, welcome to up and Vanish Weekly. I'm Maggie Freeling. Recently we shared with you our conversation with pathologist assistant Nicole Angemi. Nicole was just one of the many experts and influencers our team had the opportunity to speak with at CrimeCon 2025 in Denver, and today we wanted to share another one of those conversations. Annie Elise is creator of the YouTube series 10 to Life with over 1.5 million subscribers, and she hosts the podcast Serial Lessly. She's become a leading voice in the true crime genre and covers a variety of cases Both old and new. If you spent any time over the summer keeping up with the Karen Reed trial, odds are you saw some of Annie's coverage. Our producer John, sat down with Annie in Denver and discussed a variety of topics, including her entry into true crime and recent cases. She's covered on her platforms, and it sounds like she has a lot more to come. So here's a little bit of John and Annie's conversation.
John
Annie, thank you for sitting down with me.
Annie Elise
Yeah, my pleasure. Thanks for having me.
John
So, for anyone who may not know you, can you introduce yourself?
Annie Elise
Yeah. My name is Annie Elise. I am the host of the YouTube channel tend to Life and the True crime podcast serial with Annie Elise. And we cover all sorts of true crime. Old cases, new cases, breaking cases, kind of the whole gamut.
John
So we're sitting down Together live at CrimeCon. Any major takeaways from this year? This isn't your first crime con, correct?
Annie Elise
No, this is my second, and I feel like I have the same takeaway every year. I just feel it sounds so cheesy and cliche, but I feel like there's just such an incredible community that has been built here with victims, families, survivors, the media, everybody. And so I always come out of this just feeling very, like, positive and uplifted just because everybody finally gets to connect in person rather than digitally, and it's just incredible.
John
Have you had a favorite moment from the weekend?
Annie Elise
I did do a live episode, and I feel like just the response to that. And again, being able to connect with so many people in person, that was definitely a highlight for me.
John
That's awesome.
Annie Elise
Yeah.
John
So if anyone ends up listening to this that hasn't been to a crime con, like, how would you explain what the conference is?
Annie Elise
Usually I'll lead and be like, it's kind of like what you think when you hear Comic Con, but not that, obviously, but I think that there's kind of, like, a weird misunderstanding of what it's all about. I like to say, you know, it's not just people who enjoy the true crime or are interested in true crime. It's a lot of victims. It's a lot of families. It's a lot of education and awareness. And so it's like, there's so much education and value that comes out of a weekend like this. So it's not just about, you know, exploiting true crime or doing anything gross like that. It's actually very educational.
John
So, obviously, you've grown a tremendous following over the last number of years on, you know, across all of your platforms. And channels where you talk about true crime content. What's that journey been like from kind of start to where you are now? Reflecting back? What does that. What does that make you feel?
Annie Elise
It's definitely been a whirlwind. So it's something that I never even expected to happen. I was in the fashion industry for 15 years and never knew there was like, a creator world or anything like that. I had listened to maybe one podcast in my life, and then randomly, I just started talking about these cases that really bothered me or stuck with me for one reason or another. And it resonated with people who were hearing it and viewing it. And so that was all on social media, and then it just slowly took off from there.
John
So what got you into true crime to begin with?
Annie Elise
I was a consumer. Like so many people. I would watch every single Dateline. I would watch every single 2020. My sister and I, who's here with me today, we would have literally, like, Friday night froyo Dateline nights where we would just, like, eat food and, like, watch Dateline. And I just kind of always been fascinated with it.
John
So what. What kind of moved you from being interested in consuming and, like, keeping up with the latest things to actually becoming somebody who's actually covering and reporting on these cases?
Annie Elise
There were so many cases that I came across that I felt like there were so many unanswered questions or red flags or have a bigger light on them because they weren't getting enough attention. And so that's really where I started. I was like, I just want to highlight certain cases or, like, how this doesn't make sense or why is this happening? And it just snowballed from there. And that still is what I really hold true to this day with any type of content that I'm covering. I just want to make sure that there's some sort of value add.
John
When was the first time that you made a video or put some content out? Do you remember what year it was?
Annie Elise
2020.
John
Do you remember what it was about?
Annie Elise
My very first episode ever was about Lori Valo, and it was before she was ever even arrested. It was when she was still on the run and, like, when they were looking for the kids. And that was my introduction into the world of true crime on, like, creator side.
John
Have you ever gone back and watched, like, old videos that you've made?
Annie Elise
Oh, my God, I cringe all the time. It gives me the ick. 100%. And my. Just to give you some backstory, my YouTube channel is called Tend to Life, and it's because in the beginning I started doing just 10 minute case recaps. That was like the niche of it all. So I would talk like I was on three times speed. And so I watch it back and I'm like, okay, you sound like a lunatic.
John
Take a deep breath. Slow it down a little bit.
Maggie Freeling
Exactly.
John
So, so what was the goal initially? I mean, were you expecting to make, you know, this giant channel that a bunch of people would be following? Like, what was your vision for it?
Annie Elise
That was definitely not the goal. I didn't even know that that existed. Like, as I said, I started just by making little 60 second things on TikTok. And when TikTok first happened in 2020 and when it became big and then people wanted these longer deep dives. And so I was a YouTube person. I would go to YouTube to watch like Britney Spears music videos from the 90s that I didn't know there was like this, this whole world. And so I was like, okay, where am I going to upload this long video? I guess YouTube. And then I like realized what it was that then kind of took off and then I started the podcast. And so I. I've honestly just been learning as I go. It's all still very foreign to me. I'm not tech savvy. I am not like smooth with any of that. So it's a lot of trial and error.
John
So was there anybody, like, in the content creation space that you looked up to or that was kind of inspirational for you at that point?
Annie Elise
I think a little bit of everybody. Like, I mean, I have listened to up and Vanished for years. I watched Bailey Sarian here and there. I mean, there's. I feel like a few iconic people who are definitely in the space and so I still look to them for inspiration. And I feel like it's good to kind of just consume so much too, because it helps you get better and it helps challenge you in different ways as well.
John
How do you look to differentiate yourself? You know, especially in today's climate where there are so many people who are putting content out, like, is there something that you feel like makes you stand apart?
Annie Elise
I really just try to be true to myself. And so one of the things that I talk with everybody in my audience, in my community that I was like, I want to feel like your true crime best friend, where we're just talking and like, I want to break it down for you how I would talk with my sister about something or how I would want somebody to relay the information to me and just kind of keep it real. And authentic.
John
Have you seen how individual platforms have helped in a specific way? Like socials versus your YouTube versus a podcast?
Annie Elise
Yeah, I think for YouTube, it, it's like I've noticed a lot of people who watch YouTube on TV at home and they like enjoy it almost as like their show at night and they turn on YouTube, which is totally new to me. I've never heard of that and never done it personally. And so I feel like there's different ways of connecting. I think that like when you're in somebody's living room, it's very different than if they're hearing you on your commute to work. But it's still, you're at all of these touch points throughout somebody's day. And so I feel like all of the platforms are very unique.
John
So you put out a ton of content every week. Like, how do you do that? That seems like so much work.
Annie Elise
I am in a constant state of like mania. If I'm being real. No, I film every single day. And when I left my job in fashion to do this full time, I kind of made a commitment to myself and I was like, if I'm gonna do this, I'm going to treat it like a full time job. I'm going to be in my studio and Office 8 to 5 every day. And that's what we do. And I have an incredible, incredible team that supports me.
John
How big is your team that you work with?
Annie Elise
We now probably between like video editors, researchers, operations, probably like around like 12.
John
Okay. That's a good size team.
Annie Elise
Yeah, yeah, they're great. And a lot of them, it's been great. I've been fortunate enough to source them from the community. So it's people who just have a passion for it, a love for it and like, and again, who I just feel like are trustworthy in that regard. And it's just, there's nothing like it.
John
So if you're running that hard every day, I mean, have you experienced burnout? Is that something that kind of a constant struggle?
Annie Elise
It is. I definitely, I get, it's weird, I get burnout. But I'm also someone who I constantly need to be busy. And my sister and I joked about it. We took a vacation over the summer where we were just gonna like unplug, decompress. And she's like, I know. I was like, I'm not bringing my recording equipment, which I did. And she's like, I know this isn't gonna be a vacation because even if you're not recording, your mind's gonna be spinning. Of all the different things you should be doing. And so it's like, I just don't know how to turn it off, which I think is very unhealthy. And the burnout and the crash I fear is coming.
John
Well, hopefully that doesn't happen. I know that your fans will be very disappointed if you have to take any kind of a break. Well, obviously you put so many episodes out and so much content about a lot of different types of cases. How do you even go about choosing the things that you decide to talk about and report on?
Annie Elise
That's a great question. So we do have a case submission tab on our website where people have the opportunity to either request a case or if they were a victim or a survivor of a case, they get to put a request in there too, if they want their story told. So we use that a lot. We also cover a lot of current events. So if there's something breaking in the news that we feel like needs awareness or needs eyes on it, we'll cover things like that that are breaking. We, of course, try to be very delicate in that coverage because it's still ongoing, it's not solved. So there's a variety of ways that we'll choose to greenlight a case, but at the end of the day, it kind of comes back down to, like, is there a value add here? Is there a reason that we should cover it? One of the most highly requested cases that I get all the time is JonBenet. I've never covered it and I don't think I ever will because, yeah, it's a different perspective, possibly, but it's also. There's no value add. It's been covered. Everybody knows it. You know.
John
Are there specific types of cases that you prefer to cover?
Annie Elise
I don't know that there's any. I would say that I prefer to cover. I stay away a little bit from any, like, from the horrible child cases. Unfortunately, in a lot of those cases, it's their parents who are the ones who did something. So I'm like, if we're not going to be the voice for them, their own family won't be. They're the ones who did this to them. But it's very difficult. I'm a mom myself, and so those have been tougher, for sure.
John
Have the types of cases that you've talked about, like, evolved over time?
Annie Elise
I think my coverage has for sure evolved. And I think sometimes now with the cases, I want to go into more of the complex ones and, like, kind of go down the rabbit hole and, like, challenge myself to look at things differently too, where it may feel so clear cut when you first hear about something, it's like I try to poke holes in it and see like how can we come into it from a different angle and like challenge ourselves with it really.
John
So I know that sometimes it's a little bit more of a surface type of a coverage versus a, you know, more in depth. Does one feel more natural to you?
Annie Elise
I feel like the in depth does just because I am inherently very nosy. Okay. Like I like to, to get in there. I like to go on the Reddit threads, I like to like get in the Facebook groups, contact it like so I would feel like deep dives are like my vibe because I just, I'm already like scouring things as it is.
Maggie Freeling
We'll be right back after a quick break. Just got a new puppy or kitten.
Annie Elise
Congrats. But also yikes.
Maggie Freeling
Between crates, beds, toys, treats and those.
Annie Elise
First few vet visits, you've probably already dropped a small fortune. Which is where Lemonade Pet Insurance comes in. It helps cover vet costs so you can focus focus on what's best for your new pet.
Maggie Freeling
The coverage is customizable, sign up is quick and easy, and your claims are.
Annie Elise
Handled in as little as three seconds. Lemonade offers a package specifically for puppies and kittens. Get a'llemonade.com pet your future self will thank you.
Maggie Freeling
Your pet won't.
Annie Elise
They don't know what insurance is.
Maggie Freeling
This episode is brought to you by Netflix. Everyone is telling her she dreamt it. But in the woman in cabin 10 Lo Blacklock is determined to uncover the truth in the gripping new thriller coming to Netflix October 10th. Keira Knightley plays a journalist aboard a luxury yacht who witnesses a crime she can't unsee. Adapted from Ruth Ware's best selling novel, directed by Simon Stone. Watch the woman in cabin 10 now only on Netflix.
Annie Elise
Think your lashes have hit their limit? Discover limitless length and full volume with Maybelline's Sky High Mascara. The Flextower brush bends to volumize and extend every single lash from root to tip. And the lightweight bamboo infused formula makes lashes feel weightless. Now in eight bold shades so you can take your lashes to new heights every day. Visit maybelline.com to shop Sky High Mascara now.
Maggie Freeling
And we're back.
John
One of the cases that we have been looking to cover is Robyn Gardner. What were your thoughts on that case as you looked into it?
Annie Elise
So when I had first heard about it, it was one where I again think it is very clear cut. What I believe happened, but it's one where I felt like there wasn't a lot of coverage out there at the time when I was looking into it.
John
So if someone's not familiar with the case, can you give just like a quick, like one minute summary of the details?
Annie Elise
So she was on vacation and she had been dating somebody, and there was just like a lot of toxicity in the relationship. And there was a lot of shadiness from this person's past, which I don't want to get too far in the weeds with it. And there was some involvement with life insurance and different sums of money. And it looked as though it was very intentional. What happened, especially when past relationships came forward, you know, with their stories and what happened to them and their experiences.
John
Was there, like one major red flag that as you started to kind of research and look more into it, that you're like, oh, this is. This definitely to me makes it seem like something that I need to be reporting on.
Annie Elise
I mean, just none of the story was adding up. I mean, there were so many things from the day that everything went down and the timeline of events and everything. It just. There were so many things that didn't add up. And then when you see and hear what the outcome is, it's like you kind of make the common deduction of what happened. Unfortunately, we see so many cases where there's, of course, violence against women. We see violence against everyone. And it's just one of those where it's like, it needs to be talked about more. Because I do think that the more awareness you bring to it hopefully educates people who are listening and they know what to look for and they know how to, you know, watch out for certain things or see certain red flags.
John
What do you think in a case like this is going to help actually bring clarity, bring justice? What's it going to take for there actually to be some sort of closure?
Annie Elise
So I'm somebody who firmly believes that the more people that talk about something or are aware about something, the more likely that a tip will be generated or a lead of some sort. Somebody maybe heard something or saw something, or after the fact, somebody's maybe gloating and they slip up and say something. So it's like. But people won't know what to look for or what kind of information should stand out unless they know about it. And so I believe the more awareness that's out there, the more likely you are to hear something.
John
So it used to be that, you know, reporting on these types of cases was primarily done by, like, legacy Media, obviously, in the last number of years, we've seen kind of the growth of like the quote unquote, like citizen sleuth movement, you know, in covering cases like, what do you make of that?
Annie Elise
It's really interesting, right, because I feel like sometimes the, you know, as you put it, the citizen sleuth, they can cause more damage than good. And I think that there is a very fine line of what. How involved you can get and what you should be getting involved in. But I also think that there's not a lot of trust out there with the mainstream media, unfortunately, these days, and people have an agenda for one reason or another. Not all the time, but sometimes. So I think that consumers like to hear from other people and like to trustworthy sources. And again, not in this very buttoned up news anchor voice that feels detached, but where they feel connected to you.
John
You've been a contributor on networks like Court TV and News Nation. What has that experience been like for you?
Annie Elise
Pretty surreal. I mean, I grew up watching Nancy Grace and let me just say I'm terrified of her. Okay? For sure. I feel like anybody in their right mind is, okay. She is like a bulldog in a great way. So being asked to be on these shows has definitely been surreal because I looked up to them in the space. I still look up to them in the space. And it's just. It's a really big privilege.
John
So you also recently did some coverage of the Karen Reed trial. What was that experience like for you?
Annie Elise
It was interesting because obviously there was a lot of division out there, right. And I had covered it years ago when everything first took place. And then it had this whole new, like, renewed interest when Body in the Snow came out, when everybody started watching the did second trial. And I ended up getting in touch with her family and I went out there and I attended court with her parents. And I was very much of the mentality of. And still to this day, which I have no. You know, I have never held back. I don't know what truly happened that night, but I do know that there was way too much reasonable doubt to convict her. I think that there was so much shadiness and evidence that didn't match and mishandling of things along the way to where I felt like there was no justice in them trying to get that murder conviction against her. And so I'm happy with the outcome. But it definitely was a whirlwind because that was one that, like, we saw just pop culture, even, like kind of just take it and just go wild. They still are going wild with it. And I think it's kind of changing the landscape a little bit with true crime too.
John
Why do you think a case like that just, you know, hits headlines and people just, you know, they're on the edge of their seats. What makes that case fall into that category versus maybe some others?
Annie Elise
I think people like conspiracy. I personally don't. I try not to be a conspiracy theorist. Sometimes I get swept up in it, but I'll be honest. But I think people, they're more open minded to the possibility of corruption, conspiracy, and things like that. So this case had all of that and it had all of these unknowns. And I think for me, at least, to a big fascination with true crime. I think, I don't know, maybe from everybody or just myself, but it's almost like the puzzle piece of it all. Trying to problem solve, strategize, figure it out. And so with that case, I think a lot of it was people trying to figure out what really happened. And there's that challenge and problem solving element to it. And so I think everybody just was very interested because of that.
John
Is that something you want to do more of moving forward?
Annie Elise
I would love to, yeah, definitely.
John
Any that you have your eyes on that you'd potentially like to start doing?
Annie Elise
Well, I definitely plan on being at the Barry Morphew trial for sure. And there's a lot that I've been following. It's tough because, again, I have two small kids, so I can't always get there. And that's why I'm so fortunate with my team too, because I can have them go cover some certain trials. But Barry Morphew is next on my list for sure.
John
There's a lot of discussion, and we talked about this a little bit earlier, just about the idea of like ethics in true crime. Not making everything salacious, making sure that we're, you know, talking about the victim and the impact on the victim's family. What does like, ethical true crime look like to you?
Annie Elise
I think ethical true crime is if you're not exploiting in like to your point, a salacious story. It's somebody's worst day of their life. They either lose their loved ones, their family members, or they survive something horrible. But the, the root of it is it's the worst day of their life. So somebody that. Taking that and spinning it and just churning content over and over, coming at it with like the salacious details, overly dramatic things, things that aren't true. It's like, I think people can lose their way a little bit with that. And I've seen creators unfortunately do that, as I'm sure you have, where they just are in it for the clicks or the money. And they don't. I don't even think they believe what they're saying half of the time. And it's almost as though they've become so detached that this is a real person's life and story. So I think it can be a fine line and everybody has mixed opinions, but if you go into it knowing what your goal is and that you're going to stay true and remember that these are real people that this happened to, then hopefully you know you're doing more good than harm.
Maggie Freeling
Back after a short break.
Annie Elise
Imagine fast hydration combined with balanced energy. Perfectly flavored with zero artificial sweet sweeteners. Introducing Liquid Ivy's new energy multiplier, Sugar free. Unlike other energy drinks, you know, the ones that make you feel like you're glitching, it's made with natural caffeine and electrolytes so you get the boost without the burnout. Liquid IV's new energy multiplier, Sugar free hydrating energy.
Maggie Freeling
Tap the banner to learn more. Join Vanguard for a moment of meditation. Take a deep breath. Picture yourself reaching your financial goals. Feel that freedom. Visit vanguard.com investinginyou to learn more. All investing is subject to risk. The holidays have arrived at the Home.
Annie Elise
Depot and we're here to help bring.
Maggie Freeling
The excitement with decor for every part of your home. Check out our wide assortment of easy to assemble pre lit trees so you can spend less time setting up and more time celebrating. And bring your holiday spirit outdoors with unique decor like one of our Santa inflatables.
Annie Elise
Whatever your style, find the right pieces at the right prices this holiday season at the Home Depot.
John
Hey listeners, if you have a tip or theories about a case you want to share or a case of interest you'd like to recommend to us, then we want to hear from you. Email us casesnderfoot TV DM us on Instagram avweekly or give us a call at 770-545-6411. You can also join the conversation on our Discord at Discord GG upandvanished. Now back to the show. How have you found the balance between covering, you know, all aspects of the case, you know, researching, putting all the pertinent information out there, even if it may be difficult, but it's, you know, part of what needs to be shared with also balancing, you know, respect and care for the family and of the victim.
Annie Elise
I think it's just doing your Due diligence, of course, getting as much information as you can and fact checking all of that. But also, I've talked with so many victims families where they want the legal terms used or the sensitive terms, because that is what their loved one went through. That is what this monster did to them. And so I personally get frustrated if it's a YouTube or somebody like that where they make you censor all these things, because you're then diminishing what their experience was and you're watering down what that monster did to those people. You know, I think it's a fine.
John
Line, obviously, with the amount of cases that you look into. It's very heavy content. It's very difficult, but it's necessary work. But how do you protect yourself, your mental health, you know, how do you kind of find that balance between doing what you believe in, you know, deep within your gut, but also knowing that, you know, it can take a toll on you?
Annie Elise
Absolutely. I feel like I don't know if this is healthy or not, but I have found a way to compartmentalize so that when I go home, I truly try to turn it off and be present with my family and just, like, enjoy and be thankful and grateful and be in the moment. I also have found myself not consuming true crime as much as I used to, just because I'm doing it so much every single day that the last thing I want to do is, like, at home, watch another horrible, you know, situation. So I try to just, like, protect my mind when I'm outside of it, to just, you know, be in the moment and be positive and happy.
John
Has there been, like, a high mark from the work that you've done, something that you reflect on and just very, you know, special to you or something you're particularly proud of?
Annie Elise
I think anytime a victim's family reaches out and. Or comes out, even here at Crimecon, coming up to the booth and just being thankful of the coverage that we've done or how we told their loved one's story, that every single time will be the high mark. Just because it makes me remember and, you know, just. It reinforces what we're doing, and it just makes me feel like, okay, we're on the right track here.
John
So if somebody, you know, follows you, you know, is inspired by the work that you're doing, and they say, you know, I feel like that's something I could do myself. What kind of advice, what kind of guidance would you give them as they're starting out?
Annie Elise
So I get that question all the time, and I tell Everyone just start. Just. You don't need any fancy equipment, you don't need any sort of plan in place. If there's something you're passionate about and there's a story you want to tell and there's something that you feel like needs to be out there, just start talking and the rest will come.
John
Well, Andy, this has been amazing. We really appreciate you and your time, all the work that you, that you're doing. What's next for you? Anything in particular you want to shout out?
Annie Elise
So I'm on tour right now, so I'm about to go back out in a few days and then we'll be done at the end of October. And yeah, just continuing to chug away on the podcast and YouTube. Just lots of content going out and.
John
If people don't already follow you, where can they follow you and all of.
Annie Elise
Your channels so they can follow either on social media, which is at underscore Annie Elise YouTube tend to life podcast serial lessly and yeah, that's it. Yeah.
John
Thanks Annie.
Annie Elise
Thanks so much.
John
I appreciate it.
Maggie Freeling
Breaking into this industry is hard without kids, so listening to Annie Elise tell her story is really inspiring. What started as a social media hobby has turned into a career, and it sounds like she has a lot more she wants to accomplish, and I personally really appreciate her making an effort to cover cases where there is value to add and not just regurgitating the same information. We're super grateful Annie spent a few minutes with our team during her busy CrimeCon schedule. CrimeCon offers such a unique blend of experts, influencers, survivors, victims, all in one setting, and we hope you enjoy listening to some of the conversations we were able to have there. Y', all, thank you so much for listening to this week's episode of up and Vanish Weekly. Be sure to tune in next week as we dig into another new case. Until next time.
Payne Lindsay
Up and Vanish Weekly is a production of Tenderfoot TV in association with Odyssey. Your hosts are Maggie Freeling and myself, Payne Lindsay. The show is written by Maggie Freeling, myself and John Street. Executive producers are Donald Albright and myself. Lead producer is John Street. Additional production by Meredith Steadman and Mike Rooney. Research for the series by Jamie Albright, Celicia Stanton and Carolyn Tallmadge. Edit and mix by Dylan Harrington and Sean Nurney. Supervising producer is Tracy Kaplan. Artwork by Byron McCoy. Original music by Makeup and vanity set. Special thanks to Oren Rosenbaum and the team at uta, Beck Media and Marketing and the Nord Group. For more podcasts like up and Vanish Weekly, search Tenderfoot TV on your favorite podcast app or visit us@Tenderfoot TV. Thanks for listening.
Annie Elise
Limu Emu and Doug.
John
Here we have the Limu Emu in its natural habitat, helping people customize their car insurance and save hundreds with Liberty Mutual.
Annie Elise
Fascinating.
John
It's accompanied by his natural ally, Doug. Limu is that guy with the binoculars watching us. Cut the camera. They see us.
Payne Lindsay
Only pay for what you need@libertymutual.com Liberty.
John
Liberty Liberty Liberty Savings Fairy Unwritten by Liberty Mutual Insurance Company affiliates excludes Massachusetts.
Annie Elise
In 2007, a man was murdered in a quiet Memphis suburb. The case was closed fast. Maybe too fast. I've spent the past year retracing the investigation, following the evidence and the lives that were forever changed. What I found wasn't just a case. It was a story too important to stay buried. I'm Stephanie Tinsley, and this is everything they missed. A new true crime investigation. Episodes drop weekly. Listen wherever you get your podcasts.
Podcast: Up and Vanished Weekly
Host: Tenderfoot TV (Maggie Freleng, Payne Lindsey)
Guest: Annie Elise (10 to Life, Serial-lessly)
Release Date: October 17, 2025
Location: Live from CrimeCon 2025, Denver
Key Segment: Interview conducted by John (Tenderfoot TV)
This episode features a live conversation with Annie Elise, renowned true crime creator and host of "10 to Life" and "Serial-lessly." Recorded at CrimeCon 2025, the discussion dives into Annie's path from fashion industry professional to true crime influencer, her approach to covering sensitive cases, insights into the true crime community, and the ethics of reporting on real-life tragedies. The episode aims to shed light on Annie’s impact and process, while exploring broader themes of responsibility, community, and the evolving landscape of true crime.
On community at CrimeCon:
"I always come out of this just feeling very, like, positive and uplifted." – Annie Elise (04:10)
On authentic content creation style:
"I want to feel like your true crime best friend, where we're just talking... I want to break it down for you how I would talk with my sister." – Annie Elise (09:02)
On citizen sleuths:
"Sometimes the, you know, as you put it, the citizen sleuth, they can cause more damage than good... But I also think that there's not a lot of trust out there with the mainstream media." – Annie Elise (17:43)
On the challenge of covering true crime:
"It's somebody's worst day of their life... The root of it is it's the worst day of their life." – Annie Elise (21:21)
On mental health and boundaries:
"I have found a way to compartmentalize so that when I go home, I truly try to turn it off and be present with my family..." – Annie Elise (25:26)
Advice to newcomers:
"Just start. You don't need any fancy equipment, you don't need any sort of plan in place. If there's something you're passionate about... just start talking and the rest will come." – Annie Elise (26:40)
| Timestamp | Segment/Topic | |------------|------------------------------------------------------------------| | 03:40 | Annie introduces herself and "10 to Life" | | 04:10 | Takeaways from CrimeCon & community | | 05:34 | Transition from fashion to true crime | | 06:58 | First video (Lori Vallow case, 2020) | | 09:02 | Discussing her style: authentic, “best friend” approach | | 10:00 | Creating daily content; treating as full-time job | | 10:48 | On burnout and mental load | | 11:40 | How Annie selects cases and value add | | 15:23 | Examining the Robyn Gardner case | | 17:43 | Citizen sleuth movement & media distrust | | 18:24 | Experience as a network TV contributor (Court TV, News Nation) | | 18:50 | Reflections on the Karen Reed trial | | 20:49 | Interest in future trials, specifically Barry Morphew | | 21:21 | Defining ethical true crime | | 25:26 | Managing mental health amidst difficult material | | 26:08 | High points: positive feedback from victims’ families | | 26:40 | Advice for aspiring creators | | 27:03 | What's next for Annie (tour, future content) |
The conversation remains candid and warm, with Annie Elise’s humor and self-awareness shining through. Her reflections, practical advice, and ethical stance highlight both the promise and complexity of true crime content creation. As Maggie Freleng concludes, Annie stands out for prioritizing meaningful, value-added coverage and for her empathetic commitment to victims and their families.
(Summary skips all advertisements and non-content sections per instructions. For more, visit Tenderfoot TV or find "Up and Vanished Weekly" on your podcast app.)