PREVIEW: Jumping to Conclusions

Summary

Up and Vanished Weekly - Episode Preview: "Jumping to Conclusions"

Release Date: June 13, 2025
Host: Maggie Freleng
Producer: Tenderfoot TV

---

Introduction

In the preview episode titled "Jumping to Conclusions," hosts Payne Lindsey and Maggie Freleng delve into a perplexing case that has baffled the true crime community for over a decade. This episode sets the stage for an in-depth exploration of the mysterious death of Ellen Goldberg, raising questions about the initial conclusions drawn by authorities.

Case Overview

The Fateful Evening

On Wednesday, January 26, 2011, in Philadelphia—a city often referred to as the "City of Brotherly Love"—a significant snowstorm began to blanket the Northeast. Amid the chaos of the impending weather event, Sam Goldberg, 28, returned to his sixth-floor apartment at the Venice Lofts after a workout at the local gym.

At approximately 5:15 PM (00:20), Sam attempted to enter his apartment but discovered the door locked from the inside. With his fiancée, Ellen Goldberg, still inside, Sam's initial attempts to gain entry—knocking and pounding on the door—elicited no response (01:42).

Sam's Growing Concern

As minutes turned into hours, Sam's frustration escalated. By 1 hour and 42 minutes after leaving the gym, he resorted to using his phone to text Ellen, expressing his distress:

Sam Goldberg: "Hello? Open the door. What are you doing?" (01:42)

His attempts to communicate were met with silence, increasing his agitation:

Sam Goldberg: "I'm getting pissed. Hello? You better have an excuse. What the. Ah, you have no idea." (01:55)

Despite attracting the attention of neighbors due to his persistent pounding, Ellen remained unresponsive, and Sam's worry deepened.

The Horrific Discovery

After nearly two agonizing hours without any sign of Ellen, Sam finally forced open the apartment door. What he found was devastating:

Sam Goldberg: "I just walked in my apartment, fiancée's on the floor with blood everywhere. There's a knife taking out of her heart." (02:29)

The scene that awaited Sam inside his apartment became the focal point of much speculation and controversy over the ensuing years.

Controversy Surrounding Ellen's Death

Official Conclusion vs. Public Doubts

Authorities swiftly ruled Ellen's death as an obvious suicide. However, many in the community and true crime enthusiasts believe the evidence suggests a different reality. Questions have been raised about the nature of her injuries and the circumstances leading up to that tragic night.

"Jumping to Conclusions"

The episode's title, "Jumping to Conclusions," hints at the central theme: the potential misinterpretation of evidence by law enforcement. By examining the timeline, forensic reports, and Sam's account, the hosts aim to uncover whether Ellen's death was indeed a suicide or if foul play was involved.

Insights and Discussions

Analyzing the Evidence

Payne Lindsey and Maggie Freleng will scrutinize the available evidence, including:

• Forensic Pathology: Details about the knife wound and blood spatter patterns.
• Sam's Behavior: His actions and emotional state before and after discovering the body.
• Alibi and Motive: Exploring possible motives if considering foul play.

Community and Media Influence

The duo also plans to discuss how media portrayals and community perceptions can influence the investigation's direction. The widespread belief that cases are rarely straightforward underlines the importance of objective analysis in true crime investigations.

Conclusion

"Jumping to Conclusions" serves as a compelling introduction to what promises to be a thorough examination of Ellen Goldberg's untimely death. By challenging the official narrative, Up and Vanished Weekly invites listeners to engage critically with the case, encouraging a deeper look into the complexities that often surround tragic events.

---

Notable Quotes:

• Sam Goldberg on Attempting Entry:
  "Hello? Open the door. What are you doing?" (01:42)

• Sam Expressing Frustration:
  "I'm getting pissed. Hello? You better have an excuse. What the. Ah, you have no idea." (01:55)

• Sam's Discovery of Ellen:
  "I just walked in my apartment, fiancée's on the floor with blood everywhere. There's a knife taking out of her heart." (02:29)

---

This preview episode sets the tone for a meticulous investigation into a case where initial impressions may have led to premature conclusions. Listeners can anticipate a blend of investigative rigor and engaging storytelling as the hosts peel back the layers of this enduring mystery.

Transcript

[Tenderfoot TV]

You're listening to a Tenderfoot TV podcast.

[Maggie]

Hey y' all, it's Maggie. I hope you're enjoying up and Vanish weekly. Here's a sneak peek of next week's case.

[Narrator]

It's Wednesday, Jan. 26, 2011, in the city of Brotherly Love. As Philadelphia area residents start their morning routines, local news outlets blast airwaves with reports of a massive snowstorm slowly making its way across the Northeast. Inhabitants of New York, New Jersey and eastern Pennsylvania brace themselves and begin making preparations for what would become a historic snowfall for the region. The around 5:15pm that afternoon, 28 year old Sam Goldberg exits an elevator making his way towards his sixth floor residence. Sam had just finished a workout at the gym in his Venice Lofts apartment complex. As he approaches his doorway, he turns the handle and pushes, but his access is abruptly stopped. He realizes the door is locked from the inside. When he'd left the apartment an hour earlier, his fiance Ellen stayed behind. Sam knocks. There's no answer. He knocks again. Still no answer. Sam begins pounding as he takes out his phone and begins texting Ellen.

[Sam Goldberg]

Hello? Open the door. What are you doing?

[Narrator]

As minutes tick by with no response, Sam grows increasingly more frustrated.

[Sam Goldberg]

I'm getting pissed. Hello? You better have an excuse. What the. Ah, you have no idea.

[Narrator]

Sam's pounding begins to attract the attention of neighbors, but his concern is starting to mount. He continues to grow more agitated and after nearly two hours with no response from Ellen, Sam finally forces the door open, unprepared for what awaits him.

[Sam Goldberg]

I just walked in my apartment, fiance's on the floor with blood everywhere. There's a knife taking out of her heart.

[Narrator]

The scene that Sam stumbled upon inside his apartment has been the source of a lot of speculation over the past 15 years. While authorities quickly ruled Ellen's death as an obvious suicide, many believe the evidence tells a very different story.

[Tenderfoot TV]

If you hate waiting a week for new episodes, you can listen to the rest of this episode right now by subscribing to Tenderfoot Plus. Go to tenderfootplus.com to sign up and get early access, an ad, free listening experience, and other exclusive benefits on over 30 shows and 500 episodes. Again, that's tenderfootplus.com or click the link in our show notes.

[Groons]

Are you feeling overwhelmed with all the supplements out there? Totally get it. There's a lot of misinformation and fake claims. That's why Groons took the time to understand proper dosing. To ensure nutrition is optimized and safe, Gruns utilizes a convenient, comprehensive formula that is designed to replace the multiple supplements you take a day. This isn't a multivitamin, a Greens gummy or a prebiotic. Gruin's is all of those things and then some at a fraction of the price. And the taste is fabulous. Visit Groons co to get up to 52% off. That's groons copy.