Victor Davis Hanson: The ‘Schumer Shutdown’ Gains Traction Each Passing Day

Fri Oct 31 2025

In today’s episode of “Victor Davis Hanson: In His Own Words,” Victor Davis Hanson and Sami Winc talk about former President Barack Obama, including his unlikability and growing irrelevance, how the “Schumer Shutdown” gains traction each passing day and more:

Transcript

Victor Davis Hanson (0:00)

The party that shuts down the government by basically filibustering and not voting in the minority to give a Senate 60 vote margin is basically telling the American people, we did not win your trust in the last election. If everything Trump says about foreign investment cut it in half and it's still a record 8 or 9 trillion dollars. So everything is going well. If you look at the culture.

Jack (0:24)

I don't know how he did it.

Victor Davis Hanson (0:26)

I mean that sincerely. I'm not being rhetorical, but he basically turned DEI into a pejor.

Jack (0:32)

Bolton was told by a federal judge.

Victor Davis Hanson (0:35)

Do not publish this.

Jack (0:37)

I can't stop it. It's already in circulation.

Victor Davis Hanson (0:39)

But you have harmed your country.

Jack (0:42)

I'm almost quoting verbatim. And you are going to be subject soon to civil and criminal exposure by using classified information. Foreign.

Sammy Wink (1:04)

Hello, and welcome to Victor Davis Hansen in his own words. This is our Friday news roundup. So we've got lots of news on the agenda. Russia, Mondami, Trump in Japan and South Korea and also just some reflections on the shutdown. So stay with us and we'll be right back with those stories.

Victor Davis Hanson (1:26)

Right is still right, even if you stand by yourself. Mr. Chief justice, may it please the court.

Hans von Spakowski (1:34)

This is Hans von Spakowski, host of the Case in Point podcast, which looks at the hottest cases affecting politics, culture and everyone's daily lives. But we talk about them without confusing legal jargon. And we have interesting guests like former House Speaker Newt Gingrich. And we end with reviews of classic Hollywood movies relevant to the topic. Case in Point, the podcast available everywhere you won't want to miss.

Sammy Wink (2:09)

Welcome back to the Victor Davis Hansen Show. Victor is the Martin and Nealy Anderson Senior Fellow in Military History and Classics at the Hoover Institution and the Wayne and Marcia Buskey Distinguished Fellow in History and at Hillsdale College. You can find him at his website, Victor Hansen.com and the name of the website is the Blade of Perseus. So, Victor, I thought we would start today with the shutdown since it's been so it's coming on a month now and Donald Trump and his crew are trying to find money for the soldiers and women with infant children to keep those programs funded. And while the soldiers paid and the programs f the WIC program funded. And I was wondering, oh, and last thing Politico has said they think some moderate Democrats might sign in. The thing that needs to be done, everybody, is to have the bill signed, voted in in the Senate. So what are your thoughts on the shutdown?

Summary

Podcast Summary: “Victor Davis Hanson: The ‘Schumer Shutdown’ Gains Traction Each Passing Day”

Victor Davis Hanson | The Daily Signal | October 31, 2025

Episode Overview

In this edition of “Victor Davis Hanson: In His Own Words,” Victor offers his distinctive analysis on political gridlock in Washington, the current state of the Trump administration, shifts in American culture, global affairs (with a spotlight on Russia and China), domestic lawfare, growing anti-Semitism, and the spectacle of contemporary American media and politics. With a blend of historical context, personal candor, and mordant wit, Victor addresses how the political, social, and international currents of the day fit into America’s longer trajectory.

Key Discussion Points and Segments

1. The “Schumer Shutdown” and Political Stalemate

[02:09–05:39]

Victor critiques Congressional minorities for shutting down the government via filibuster, saying it signals their lack of electoral mandate and an admission of defeat.
Shut-downs follow a distinct pattern: briefly, the party in power takes the blame, but as public assistance is delayed and frustration mounts, those blocking government reopening (in this case, Democrats) are increasingly seen as responsible by voters.
- Quote: “The party that shuts down the government by filibustering… is basically telling the American people, we did not win your trust in the last election.” — Victor [03:07]
He forecasts that public opinion is swinging against the shutdown architects, dubbing it the “Schumer shutdown.”
- Quote: “The Schumer shutdown is gaining currency. They're blowing up the process by not participating.” — Victor [04:24]

2. Trump’s Foreign Policy, Domestic Progress, and Political Image

[05:39–13:56]

Trump’s recent trip to Asia is described as a success, drawing attention to improving relations with Japan and South Korea and increased foreign investment in America.
- “He’s beloved [in Asia]… he should just focus on what’s working”—Victor [11:45]
Victor credits Trump for:
- A secure border
- Increased domestic energy output
- Lowered crime
- Record foreign investment, and the cultural shift turning “DEI” into a pejorative
He urges Trump to continue focusing on positive achievements and avoid reactive, bombastic online battles:
- Quote: “If Trump would just troll them in a different way — by talking about how great America is now… he would be [at] 55% approval.” — Victor [13:53]

3. The “Revenge Tour” and Lawfare Accusations

[13:56–26:29]

Responding to Gerald Baker’s Wall Street Journal editorial, Victor rejects the notion that Trump’s legal actions constitute “lawfare” for revenge.
He distinguishes between Trump's actions and the previous administration's conduct, insisting many Democrats benefited from legal “exemptions.”
- “We can’t say Trump is on a vengeful tour when these people have been beneficiaries of a weaponization of the government.” — Victor [18:17]
Examples include the lack of prosecution for John Bolton, Letitia James, Fani Willis, and others.
High-profile prosecutions (like Martha Stewart) are explained as deterrence, not revenge:
- “Sometimes you go after people to remind people… [to] have deterrence.” — Victor [25:05]

4. Russia, Ukraine, and Geopolitical Calculus

[30:42–36:31]

Analysis of Vladimir Putin’s “colossal blunder” in Ukraine, mounting Russian casualties, economic woes, and the impact of Trump administration sanctions.
He outlines Putin’s three choices: negotiate and cut losses, escalate in desperation, or halt unilaterally (deemed unlikely).
- Quote: “If [Putin] was smart… expand Russian territory a bit, declare victory, and pivot to triangulate against China.” — Victor [32:07]
He assesses that Russia’s threats of nuclear force stem from growing weakness, increasing NATO unity, and the latest long-range missile tests as bluster.

5. China, “Sex Warfare,” and Tech Espionage

[38:08–44:36]

Discussion on Chinese and Russian espionage via “sexpionage”—with salacious accounts of spies luring U.S. tech professionals.
- Victor singles out public cases (Eric Swalwell and Dianne Feinstein’s staff) as failures of judgment:
- “Eric Swalwell… has to be the most arrogant, stupid person in Congress to fall for that.” — Victor [40:14]
Victor sees the U.S. as strong compared to China in long-term innovation, provided it doesn’t sell out its tech secrets.

6. Domestic Culture Wars and Political Characters

[45:36–58:08]

Reviews the New York mayoral campaign, calling Mandami a “pathological liar” and lamenting the electorate’s attraction to increasingly radical figures.
Discusses AOC, Bernie Sanders, and the phenomenon of political branding, skepticism of authenticity, and leftist virtue-signaling.
- “When somebody tells you they’re not crazy or sane, the more people listen…” — Victor [52:26]
Observes diversity and assimilation through the lens of the World Series, celebrating baseball’s Japanese-American ties.

7. Obama’s Media Campaign and Political Legacy

[60:24–70:18]

Victor analyzes Obama’s strategy of making late-stage endorsements only for presumed winners and assesses his waning influence.
Critiques Obama’s shifting stances and role in redistricting battles, highlighting the left’s inconsistencies.
- “They said democracy dies in darkness… Now they gerrymander to get rid of opposition and call it democracy.” — Victor [70:00]

8. California Politics and Political Storytelling

[71:51–74:41]

Discusses Gavin Newsom’s attempt to recast himself as a self-made, underprivileged candidate despite his privileged background, linking it to broader trends of “log cabin” campaign stories.
- “Everybody appreciates authenticity more than even ideology.” — Victor [74:41]

9. Viewer Mail: Anti-Semitism and Generational Trends

[75:16–83:54]

Responding to a millennial commenter, Victor and the panel express concern over rising anti-Semitism across generations and its presence both on the left and now increasingly, troublingly, on the right.
- Outlines the roles of cultural, political, and media influences, including rap and right-wing podcasts.
- “It’s a no-brainer… Israel is a democratic constitutional system… It’s a natural empathy, especially when it’s beleaguered.” — Victor [79:11]
He laments once-libertarian figures drifting into anti-Semitic rhetoric and the harm of ideological tribalism.

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

On Political Shutdowns:
“The party that shuts down the government by basically filibustering… is basically telling the American people, we did not win your trust in the last election.”
— Victor Davis Hanson [03:07]
On Trump’s Communication Strategy:
“If Trump would just troll them in a different way—by talking about how great America is now… he would be [at] 55% approval.”
— Victor [13:53]
On Lawfare Accusations:
“We can’t say Trump is on a vengeful tour when these people have been beneficiaries of a weaponization of the government.”
— Victor [18:17]
On U.S.-China Tech Espionage:
“All we have to do is not hand over all our technology to these Chinese operators and… get tough on them.”
— Victor [42:53]
On the “Pathological Liar” Mandami:
“He is many things, but among them is a pathological liar.”
— Victor [45:21]
On Anti-Semitism:
“It’s a no-brainer… Israel is a democratic constitutional system… It’s a natural empathy, especially when it’s beleaguered.”
— Victor [79:11]

Timestamps for Key Segments

| Segment | Timestamp | |:------------------------------------------ |:---------------:| | Schumer Shutdown Discussion | 02:09–05:39 | | Trump: Asia and Domestic Achievements | 05:39–13:56 | | “Revenge Tour”/Lawfare & Legal Inequality | 13:56–26:29 | | Russia and Ukraine Analysis | 30:42–36:31 | | China’s Tech Espionage/Sexpionage | 38:08–44:36 | | NY Mayoral Race & Left/Right Virtue | 45:36–58:08 | | Obama’s Political Legacy & Media | 60:24–70:18 | | California Politics & Political Storytelling| 71:51–74:41 | | Viewer Mail: Anti-Semitism Discussion | 75:16–83:54 | | Episode Close & Personal Notes | 86:46–87:36 |

Tone & Style Observations

The episode is explanatory, historical, and occasionally acerbic; Victor’s tone is dry, critical, even sardonic at times, especially about establishment politics, media hypocrisy, and virtue-signaling.
The dialogue includes panel interludes, jokes, and off-hand asides that bring warmth and humor despite the serious subject matter.

For New Listeners

This summary distills a wide-ranging intellectual review of today's most salient American political and cultural debates. Victor Davis Hanson's analysis is deeply rooted in both contemporary observation and historical perspective, making it worthwhile for anyone seeking intelligent, candid, and occasionally trenchant commentary on the direction of the nation.