Episode Overview

Podcast: Voices of Search – A Search Engine Optimization (SEO) & Content Marketing Podcast
Host: Jordan Cooney
Guest: Jon Vantine (Director of SEO, GoodRx)
Episode Title: The most important signal to guide content updates
Date: January 31, 2026

This episode dives into practical strategies for updating website content in the dynamic landscape of SEO, particularly as generative AI transforms search. Jon Vantine, a seasoned SEO leader, shares his perspective on the single most important metric for content updates, explaining why fundamentals haven’t changed (despite evolving technology) and offering actionable advice for SEO practitioners.

Key Discussion Points & Insights

The Enduring Importance of Traffic Data

• [01:19] Main Signal for Content Updates
  • Jon Vantine stresses that, even with the rise of generative search and AI, traffic remains the top signal for determining when and how to update content.
  • The core truth: consistently check whether content is still attracting visitors—if not, it’s likely time for a refresh.
  • Quote:

    “I don't think this has really changed with Generative Search ... my take is that it's still just traffic, right?”
    – Jon Vantine, [01:19]

Analyzing Content Performance Over Time

• [02:57] How to Evaluate the Need for Updates
  • Jon advises SEO professionals to examine articles’ traffic trends across quarters.
  • If a significant drop-off is observed (“fell off a cliff”), this signals a strong need for an update.
  • Identify what content or competitor replaced your ranking, then iterate.
  • Quote:

    “Was the article getting traffic in Q1? What does it look like in Q2? Did it fall off a cliff? You probably need to change it. It probably fell off a cliff for a reason, right? Who took its place? Go back and update the content.”
    – Jon Vantine, [02:57]

The Power of Swift Content Refreshes

• [03:10] Small Edits, Big Returns
  • Minor updates—ensuring the latest information and relevance—can not only help regain lost traffic but sometimes even surpass previous best performance.
  • Timely refreshes significantly amplify organic visibility and user engagement.
  • Quote:

    “Content updates are so powerful. It is amazing consistently how just going in and changing a few things to make sure that the latest information is in there can cause not just a return to traffic, but also like even more traffic than the article ever saw before.”
    – Jon Vantine, [03:10]

The Importance of Monitoring Tools

• [03:20] Automation for Efficient SEO Monitoring
  • Vantine recommends having tools that alert you whenever traffic to a page significantly declines.
  • This enables rapid, data-driven interventions rather than reactive or periodic reviews.
  • Quote:

    “So just look at the content and have tools that will ping you when something falls off.”
    – Jon Vantine, [03:20]

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• “I don't think this has really changed with Generative Search ... my take is that it's still just traffic, right?”
  – Jon Vantine, [01:19]

• “Was the article getting traffic in Q1? What does it look like in Q2? Did it fall off a cliff? You probably need to change it. ... Go back and update the content.”
  – Jon Vantine, [02:57]

• “Content updates are so powerful. ... just going in and changing a few things to make sure that the latest information is in there can cause not just a return to traffic, but also like even more traffic than the article ever saw before.”
  – Jon Vantine, [03:10]

• “Have tools that will ping you when something falls off.”
  – Jon Vantine, [03:20]

Timestamps for Key Segments

• [01:19] – The most important signal to guide content updates (traffic)
• [02:57] – How to analyze traffic trends and interpret declines
• [03:10] – The impact of small, strategic content updates
• [03:20] – Using monitoring tools to automate content oversight

Tone & Takeaways

• The episode was concise, practical, and data-driven, with Jon’s advice centering on actionable, “back to basics” SEO fundamentals—even in an AI-driven search world.
• The big message: Don’t chase shiny new metrics—traffic tells the true story for when to update content and what to prioritize for SEO impact.

For SEO practitioners and content marketers, this episode is a clear reminder that, regardless of search technology’s evolution, the answers are still “in the data”—especially traffic performance data.