Voices of Search Podcast Episode Summary

Episode Title: Will AI Systems Be Able To Fully Diagnose Traffic Drops And Identify Fundamental Issues?
Host: Tyson Stockton
Guest: Sam Torres, Gray Co
Release Date: May 10, 2025

Introduction

In this insightful episode of the Voices of Search podcast, host Tyson Stockton delves into the capabilities of artificial intelligence (AI) in diagnosing traffic drops and identifying the underlying issues affecting website performance. Joined by Sam Torres from Gray Co, the discussion navigates the current landscape of SEO tools and the potential future role of AI in search engine optimization.

Main Discussion: AI's Role in Diagnosing Traffic Drops

Assessing AI's Diagnostic Capabilities

Tyson Stockton initiates the conversation by posing a critical question: "Will AI systems be able to fully diagnose traffic drops and identify the fundamental issues within the next 12 months?" (00:43). This sets the stage for a deep dive into the effectiveness and limitations of AI in SEO.

Sam Torres' Insights on AI Limitations

Sam Torres provides a grounded perspective, expressing skepticism about AI's ability to pinpoint fundamental SEO issues comprehensively. She states:

"I do not think they'll be able to identify the fundamental issues in an effective way. ... It's very rarely one thing unless you like. ... It's always going to be a myriad of factors." (02:23)

Torres emphasizes that modern SEO challenges are multifaceted, often resulting from a combination of factors rather than a single, identifiable issue. She argues that AI systems, as they stand, may struggle to account for this complexity.

The Human Element in SEO Diagnosis

Further elaborating, Torres shares her observations on AI's diagnostic approach:

"Once it finds one thing, it's like, oh, I'm done. They're like, no you're not. You keep looking. ... We need to keep digging. We need to go through the list because yeah, that looks like it might be it, but it might not be the only thing." (02:23)

This highlights a critical limitation of AI: the tendency to halt analysis after identifying an initial issue, potentially overlooking subsequent problems that contribute to traffic fluctuations.

Key Insights and Conclusions

Complexity of SEO Issues

The conversation underscores the inherent complexity in diagnosing SEO problems. Unlike simpler scenarios where a single issue can cause a traffic drop (e.g., setting a "no index" tag inadvertently), most real-world situations involve multiple interrelated factors. This complexity poses a significant challenge for AI systems aiming to provide comprehensive diagnostics.

AI as a Supplementary Tool

While recognizing the current limitations, the discussion implicitly acknowledges that AI can still play a valuable role in SEO by identifying obvious issues quickly. However, the nuanced analysis and continuous investigative process required to uncover all underlying problems remain areas where human expertise is indispensable.

Future Prospects

Looking forward, the episode suggests that while AI will continue to advance and potentially improve its diagnostic capabilities, achieving the level of sophistication needed to fully diagnose and resolve SEO traffic drops within the next year remains uncertain. The blend of AI efficiency and human analytical skills appears to be the optimal approach for effective SEO management.

Notable Quotes

• Tyson Stockton (00:43):
  "Will AI systems be able to fully diagnose traffic drops and identify the fundamental issues within the next 12 months?"

• Sam Torres (02:23):
  "I do not think they'll be able to identify the fundamental issues in an effective way. ... It's very rarely one thing unless you like. ... It's always going to be a myriad of factors."

• Sam Torres (02:23):
  "Once it finds one thing, it's like, oh, I'm done. They're like, no you're not. You keep looking. ... We need to keep digging. We need to go through the list because yeah, that looks like it might be it, but it might not be the only thing."

Conclusion

The episode wraps up with Tyson Stockton thanking Sam Torres for her valuable insights and encouraging listeners to connect with her through LinkedIn and the Gray Company website. The discussion leaves listeners with a balanced view of AI's current capabilities in SEO diagnostics and the indispensable role of human expertise in navigating complex search engine challenges.

For more episodes and expert insights on SEO and content marketing, subscribe to the Voices of Search podcast on your preferred podcast platform.