
Loading summary
Glennon Doyle
It's hard to find a great mentor who can help me level up. My dream mentor, Amy Poehler. I was so excited when I heard that she has a class on Masterclass. With Masterclass, you can learn from the best to become your best. It's the only streaming platform where you can grow with over 200 of the world's top experts for just $10 a month. An annual membership gets you unlimited access to every instructor, whether you're watching on your phone, computer, smart tv, or even in audio mode. One of the classes that just really stood out to me was Building Life Changing Habits with New York Times bestselling author James Clear. I use this and you should too. Masterclass always has great offers during the holidays, sometimes up to as much as 50% off. Head over to masterclass.com hardthings for the current offer. That's up to 50% off at masterclass.com hardthings masterclass.com hardthings running a small business isn't easy. And when it comes to hiring people, it can often feel like a full time job in and of itself. As a business owner, I know firsthand how crucial it is to find not just the right skills, but the right fit for your team's culture. That's why for me, the Go to resource has always been LinkedIn jobs. LinkedIn isn't just another job board. It connects you with professionals you won't find anywhere else, sometimes even those who aren't actively looking but would be open to the right opportunity. In fact, 70% of LinkedIn users don't visit other major job sites. So if you're not looking on LinkedIn, you're missing out on the best candidates. What I love about LinkedIn jobs is how fast it works. 86% of small businesses get a qualified candidate within 24 hours. Post your job for free at LinkedIn.comhardthings that's LinkedIn.com hardthings to post your job for free. Terms and conditions apply.
Abby Wambach
Okay Pod Squad, I have been looking forward to this conversation for a long time and this is why because I have recently come to understand.
Amelia Harubi
Recently.
Abby Wambach
You know I only speak in 12 step languages. So here we go. I have come to believe that I am powerless over social media and I have ended it in my life and since now, I have ended it.
Glennon Doyle
What do you mean ended it?
Abby Wambach
Well, I don't have any of it anymore.
Glennon Doyle
You don't consume it.
Abby Wambach
I don't consume social media anymore.
Amanda Doyle
You don't have the apps on your phone. You are there, but we're Posting your stuff, but nothing on your phone.
Abby Wambach
Right. Which we're going to talk about all these layers of what that means. The person we have today here has been talking about the challenges of social media world for a very long time. And I have been covering my ears and trying not to listen to her because just like I used to cover my ears and not listen to my friends who asked me why I was drinking so much every day. Okay? Because before you're ready to make wise decisions, you avoid wise friends. So today is going to be a conversation with Amelia Harubi, and she is going to talk with us about social media in a way that is non judgmental, non scary. We are not going to shame anyone to getting off social media. But my goal for this conversation is to talk about it very personally. Okay? Not in big, sweeping declarations, but my experience with it, Amelia's experience with it, and how we can either get ourselves off if we want to get off. That sounded overtly sexual, but you know what I mean? And it might be.
Amanda Doyle
It might be an unintended consequence of being off social media.
Abby Wambach
Okay, so how to get off or how to, I guess, stay and not be so plagued by all of the problems that come with it. So just stay with us. Maybe by the end of the hour, we'll find a little bit more freedom and sanity together. Let me introduce Amelia Harubi, who is a writer, educator, and a podcaster with a PhD in philosophy. She's the founder of Softer Sounds, a feminist podcast studio for entrepreneurs and creatives. And she's the host of off the Grid, a podcast about leaving social media without losing your clients. Welcome, Amelia.
Amelia Harubi
Hello. Thank you so much for having me.
Glennon Doyle
Just before we begin, I just also want to level set that if you are listening to this and you might not be as intense or serious needing to fix things as Glennon is, I want you to know that you fall into my camp. And so I will be speaking throughout this podcast to maybe set some good boundaries and maybe have a better relationship with it. So it's not an all or nothing situation here, folks. Just follow along. You've got people on your side.
Abby Wambach
That's interesting.
Amanda Doyle
Abby represents the people that can drink in moderation.
Abby Wambach
Exactly. Well, is that possible? I mean, I want to talk about that, too. Let's start with that. Amelia is social media. I'm going to venture to say that many of us have different levels of addiction to it, because that's what it's intended to do. So, like smoking, it's something that was made to get us Addicted. Right. But is it like smoking, in which there is no safe way to consume it and we should just stop? Or is it like other process addictions, where, okay, well, let's say food for me. Like, it's an addiction, it's a problem, but I have to navigate it each day, and there are ways to do it in healthy ways. Which one is it, do you think, Amelia?
Amelia Harubi
I think that it's more like the latter. It's something that some of us can navigate, and we don't feel so hooked and trapped by it. We don't develop such addictive or extreme patterns around it, but some of us really do. Some of us cannot be on social media at all, or we are immediately going to experience the negative side effects, like, so dramatically that it starts to impact our life, not only online, but offline. And that's really where I start to see the balance. Like, if our social media use is now impacting our life offline negatively, I think we need to address how are we engaging with these apps, which apps are we engaging with? And how are we changing our behavior so that our lives on and offline can be really mutually beneficial, not extractive or exploitative or just feel bad.
Glennon Doyle
Can we get into what are some of the just, like, basic things that you could say that are negatively affecting our life outside of social media use?
Abby Wambach
Personally, tell us your story. How did you notice that it was affecting you? And why did you make different decisions?
Amelia Harubi
Yeah. So this goes a bit back to how I started getting on social media. Like many millennials, I joined Facebook in high school. I joined Instagram in college. I got on Twitter somewhere along the way. You know, I was on these platforms for over a decade, and it started small. It started with creating this digital or virtual place to kind of keep my offline connection stronger. Right. I would keep friends from high school. When I was in college, I'd keep in touch with family members along the way. Like, I loved expanding my social network. It felt so good. But I noticed that over the course of that decade that I was really active on these apps. My experience of them started to change. And I noticed that it mapped really closely to my experience of codependency with personal relationships. I felt like I was exporting my self worth, my relationship with myself, my relationships with other people to the app. Like, I didn't know if I was valuable or not unless Instagram likes told me that what I was doing was good. The same way in many relationships, I didn't know if I was a good person. I didn't Know if I was a good girl or a good girlfriend, unless the other person was constantly telling me that I was affirming for me, validating for me. So this relates to how I'm feeling online and offline. But the things I start to notice that I feel are I really struggle to establish my self esteem or self worth without this sort of third party. Whether it's an app or a person, I feel bad about myself a lot. My self image kind of tanks. I can't have a clear perception of how I look or how the things I'm saying sound or if they're meaningful to other people. What I notice the most is just like I've totally outsourced my sense of self to these other things. And that over time, just like erodes your self trust and your self belief and your identity.
Abby Wambach
Yes. Okay. So like you, I have a very long history with social media, much of it beautiful. Okay, so I started blogging when dinosaurs were roaming the earth. And then, and then I think it was before social media, I don't know. But then social media came about and it was fun and exciting and connective and I used to be so joyful about it. And I used TO for maybe 15 years, Amelia, I read every single comment on every single post. And when I tell you sometimes there'd be thousands of comments. And I considered this my community. If people disagreed with me, if they were mad at me, I would always respond back. I was like the comment whisperer for a while. We started a nonprofit. We raised $55 million for marginalized people by social media. It was quite beautiful, which makes it confusing. And I think that's probably a lot of people feel like, well, there's good stuff that comes with it too. One of the interesting things that I have found is that I think, why now? Like, why now after all these 20 years, or however long it's been, can I not handle it anymore? And I think it's because I'm healthier. I'm getting healthier, not less healthy. Here's what I noticed, Amelia, I think. And I didn't know a lot of these things until I stopped. Okay? But I think it made me feel like I had connection and community. But I don't know that it was real. My kid just got this cool thing. She just got recruited to this soccer school for college. And she had this picture of her that she was like in her little costume and her uniform, her jersey, and it was just. And I realized I don't know who to send it to. Like, I was sitting on a plane. And I had sent it to my first, you know, my sister, Allison, Abby. Like, my. But that was it. And I realized, why am I not getting this celebratory hit of mutual excitement? And it was because I would usually put it online and get a bunch of fake feedback from people that I don't truly know. And it was this moment of like, oh, I haven't built. It's like, I need sugar, but I've been eating aspartame for 20 years. There's something about the faux proxy of community that is making me understand now that I was not putting enough into the real building of community. Is that something that you see?
Amelia Harubi
Yeah, absolutely. So one way we talk about this is that you had developed hundreds of thousands or millions of parasocial relationships, and perhaps what you're realizing is to the detriment of your social relationships.
Abby Wambach
Yes.
Amelia Harubi
We're all human beings. We only have so much capacity for how many people we can be in contact with we can be meaningfully connected to. And I like your aspartame sugar analogy. But one way I think about it is, like, all of those parasocial relationships may represent 1 1000th of a relationship. It may take a thousand of them to feel as good as one person who actually sees us. But sometimes these numbers can get really out of whack. Right. Like, if you have millions of followers in your experience, you're going to need now suddenly hundreds or thousands of actual people to validate you to feel the same way. There's this, like, proportionality to it that can really shift our understanding of how we feel seen.
Amanda Doyle
So it's like a tolerance threshold. Like, if you're used to having the equivalent of a thousand people, even if that represents by a hundred thousand people online, you need to get that hit. You need that much more affirmation from real people.
Amelia Harubi
I think that, like, a window of tolerance is a nice metaphor or analogy here. Yes. That sometimes when we're used to getting this much, so much validation or affirmation, no matter how much we love the three people we send the photo to, they can't give us that same feeling. And it's really challenging to negotiate and navigate that without feeling like, well, does anybody see me? Why did it feel so different or better or worse when all of these people affirmed it than when these specific people I've chosen in my life do. Why doesn't it feel like enough?
Glennon Doyle
That's interesting.
Abby Wambach
Yeah. I have noticed just in the last. However long it's been, I don't know.
Glennon Doyle
Has it been three months, two months.
Abby Wambach
I have already been building things more than I did before. I have kind of reached out to cousins that I didn't before.
Amelia Harubi
I have real life relationships.
Abby Wambach
Life relationships? Yeah. And I do feel like they feel better and different. It feels better to get a response from an aunt who actually loves and knows my daughter than get a thousand woohoos online. Another thing that I noticed about social media is that this is going to sound really revolutionary to you, Amelia. But it made me feel bad. Okay? So, like, it does. And here's one specific way I feel like I have a good life. I like my life. I like my wife, I like my kids. I feel good about the work that I do. I like my team. I think we do good work, and I'm satisfied with it in my body, in my own life. When I get on social media, it takes me about three minutes to, in my body start feeling like I'm not doing enough, that other people are getting more opportunities than I am, that I'm not working hard enough, that I'm not in enough places, that I am not relevant enough in other people's minds to make me relevant. Is this something that happens to other people or is it just me?
Amelia Harubi
It absolutely happens to other people. I think I'm going to say that a lot of times today. I think we typically call this a compare and despair cycle. And almost every person who comes to me to talk about social media has experienced this in some way. You open an app, you are flooded with tens, hundreds, thousands of other people's lives. And you, I think, pretty innately and naturally start to compare your life to those lives. Your face to those faces, your body to those bodies, your career to those careers, your family to those families. Right. We can compare on any level. And for those of us who get really hooked by this, we'll often go straight for the things that make us insecure. Right?
Abby Wambach
Yeah.
Amelia Harubi
You're like, oh, I don't know, use the word relevant, Glenn. And like, maybe you worry that your work isn't relevant or won't stay relevant. So that's the thing that it just immediately hooks into you and you're like, oh, this is it. For other people. It can be very appearance based. For some people, it's very career focused. This person got a book deal. Where's my book deal? Will I ever get a book deal? Book deals are a big one I hear a lot about. And so I think that for a lot of people, that feels awful. And it's something we may think like, well, this Happens in everyday life too. This happens in the real world, right? Like you can be on a sports team and realize there are players who are better than you at things and your job. You might realize, oh, this person is a better manager than I am. But there's something I think about the scale of it on social media, it's just so many more people. There are only so many people on a team, only so many people in your office to compare to. But on social media it's endless. And for those of us who tend to experience or participate in more self damaging or sabotaging behaviors, it provides this endless path and well for us to go down to start to feel worse and worse and worse and it can be really hard to pull yourself out of. So I think it's unfortunately common and something that I'm glad to see more people talking about because it's so pervasive in our experience of social media and.
Amanda Doyle
That seems pretty universally documented that that's the case. So why don't people get off social media then? If you have a universe where everyone's collectively being like, I feel like shit here. And everyone is like, yeah, I also do. Why are we still there?
Amelia Harubi
I think there are many ways to explain or experience this. So one is kind of evolutionary. Social media didn't used to be this way. A lot of people who've been on it for longer experienced those early joys of I do get to stay connected with friends that are far away from me. I have had these really great personal experiences or professional experiences. Right. Our work traveled farther for some of us, we may live in a physical community that doesn't see us or doesn't see our identity. And we go to social media to be like, wow, actually this is who I am. You discover it in those mirrors of other people. Like, I never want to diminish the power that social media has in expansive possibilities for many people. Like, we go there, we find joy, we discover ourselves, we build whole new lives through our social media connections. And that's so beautiful and powerful. But I think that what has happened over the past decade is that the apps have changed, the world has changed and we have changed. And you know, Glennon, you're speaking to it from that personal place. Like, you have changed. I feel similarly, I changed and I had to leave social media. But also the app changed. Also the world we live in feels a lot different than it did 10 years ago when many of us got on these apps. And so why don't we get off? Some of us are still grasping for those possibilities, that feeling of joy, some of us are still finding it there. Some people have built their professional lives on social media. And so how do you get off when the only reason that you are an author or a TV star or whatever it might be is because of your social media presence? There's a lot of professional expectation. You may have bosses, coaches, agents telling you you absolutely cannot leave. What do you think you're doing? I hear that a lot from other people and I think for some of us we're not. I mean this is the hard one. Like I think we just gaslight ourselves and pretend we're having an okay time.
Abby Wambach
I agree.
Amelia Harubi
I think we're not honest with ourselves, how detrimental it is to our wellbeing. And so we just mask that and we stay.
Abby Wambach
And it feels very in line for me with all my other addictions. Like honestly, Emelia, all of them started off great. I was having a great time with alcohol, I was having a great time with drugs. It went really well. Ish for a long time until.
Amanda Doyle
Until 1:00 in the morning every night. Until it didn't.
Abby Wambach
Right.
Amanda Doyle
It's always so lovely when you can give someone something they wouldn't necessarily buy for themselves. Well, for qual quality gifts at an affordable price, my go to is Quince. This season is the season of coats and jackets. I would like to Recommend to you 2amazing blanket/ coat jackets from quints that are under a hundred dollars. One is their merino wool shirt jacket, also their hooded faux fur coat. You can get these for yourself or you can get them for others and I recommend both. The best part is that all Quint's Items are priced 50 to 80% less than similar luxury brands thanks to their direct partnership with top factories. Gift Luxury this holiday season without the luxury price tag, go to quint.com hard things for 365 day returns plus free shipping on your order. That's Q U I n c e.com hard things to get free shipping and 365 day returns quince.com hard things what.
Glennon Doyle
Does the future hold for business? Ask nine experts and you'll get 10 different answers. Bull market or bear market? Rising or falling rates? Inflation up or down? Can someone please invent a crystal ball? Until that happens, over 40,000 businesses have future proofed themselves with NetSuite, the number one Cloud ERP. With this unified business management suite, you gain a single source of truth that provides the visibility and control you need to make quick decisions. Imagine having real time insights and forecasting at your fingertips. Allowing you to peer into the future with actionable data. When you're closing the books in days, not weeks, you can focus more on what's next instead of looking backward. Speaking of opportunity, download the CFO's Guide to AI and Machine Learning at netsuite.com hardthings the guide is free to you at netsuite.com hardThings netsuite.com hardthings what a year it's been.
Amanda Doyle
We deserve a treat. And if you're thinking of treating yourself or finding that perfect gift for someone else, let me tell you there's not a better place to shop than blue nile.com whether it's a special sparkle for yourself or a meaningful gift for someone you love. Like maybe that perfect necklace for your mom or a ring for your partner, Blue Nile offers some of the highest quality jewelry at prices well below traditional retail. I picked out my own engagement ring and wedding rings there, as well as gifts for my sister in law and my sister. I could always find exactly what I was looking for. And if you're not sure where to start, Blue Niles Jewelry experts are available 247 via phone or chat, ready to help with anything from budget tips to technical questions. Plus they have 30 day returns and a diamond price match guarantee so you can shop with confidence. With thousands of independently graded diamonds and a selection that can't be beat, you're sure to find something you love. Go to blue nile.com to shop Blue Nile, the original online jeweler since 1999. That's blue nile.com blue nile.com.
Abby Wambach
I do want to talk a little bit more about the negative things because it's important to me. Now that I know already 60 days in how much my nervous system has calmed, it's important for me to have people listening consider that some of the problems that they think are personal to them are not. Okay, so when we talk about how social media affects you negatively in your real life, okay, it's not just that it's upsetting when you're there. What I'm trying to get at is when I get on social media and immediately start feeling the scarcity and immediately start feeling like I'm not doing enough when a second before I thought I was. And however that reads to you, however you're listening, like about your kid isn't good enough. Your job isn't good enough, your marriage isn't good enough, your whatever this thing is meant to make you feel. What I noticed is when I get off social media, I change. I bring stuff. I bring that Scarcity to my team, I bring that scarcity to my wife, I bring that scarcity to my kids. The not good enough feeling translates into my real life. Okay, I also. I have enough things, Emelia. I have enough cardigans. I'm almost 50 years old and I understand that I am not one skin cream away from Nirvana. My hair is always going to fucking look like this. I'm never going to be like, I am a fashion mogul. And yet I always, when I get off social media, think I actually am. I just need one more cardigan.
Glennon Doyle
When you get off, you need it?
Abby Wambach
Yes. When I'm on it, it puts in my mind, because it's supposed to, that if I just had that thing, I would be as comfortable and confident as that person. It's not rocket science to say that the social media exists to sell us stuff. And so we think we're okay and we have enough, and then we get on and then we think in our brains that we need more things and that negatively affects us and the planet when we get off. Is this another thing you see often?
Amelia Harubi
Yeah, absolutely. And that, I would say, is by design. And I appreciate the way you're talking about it. As I think a balance I always try to strike when I'm talking about social media is that many of us feel like we are personally failing because of how it makes us feel or because we can't get off it, even because we can't close the app because we're like, how am I spending two hours scrolling? Like, we look at our screen time and we go into a shame spiral about it. And while I do think there's so many things we can work on personally to help with that, for some of us, it's just the app does this by design and we are so hooked, and we don't have a lot of power at that point in our relationship to it. So, as you mentioned, Glennon, there has been plenty of research and whistleblower documentation and court proceedings that have shown us that apps like Instagram and TikTok know exactly how many minutes it takes us to get addicted to them. They know exactly how many videos you need to watch for the algorithm to have hooked you. And then they weaponize that against us to use some strong language, I think they're weaponizing it against us to help them make more money by selling our attention to advertisers.
Abby Wambach
Yes.
Amelia Harubi
And for some reason, similarly with addiction, some of us can wade in that water and be pretty. Okay, we can go there and we can be like, yeah, that's nice. I see what's happening, or I don't, but it doesn't impact me and others of us have suddenly bought 500 cardigans and we're like, what happened? Like, it's like we feel like we blacked out and then it all arrives in the mail and you're like, who.
Amanda Doyle
Did this and why is it a baby size right now?
Abby Wambach
Okay, I'm wearing a cardigan that I was bamboozled into buying. Now, Emelia, two more brief things. Number one, I believe that I was sufficiently polarized, meaning I really believe that the onslaught and effort of social media to divide and to dehumanize the other side and to draw you into this feeling of self righteousness that makes you stay. They are bad. I am good. That got to me. I really do believe that I became much too simple minded and confident in my us versus themness. Talk to us a little bit about that. And the purposeful campaign of social media.
Amelia Harubi
To divide the documentary, the social dilemma points to this really well. And that's where I source a lot of my information from it. But essentially what they show with information from people who used to work at Meta and other and Google and other places is that social media algorithms have been trained to keep us on these apps, which theoretically could be sort of neutral. You know, like their only mission is like, keep this user on the app. And so the algorithm's job is to learn through pattern recognition what keeps people there. And this is where I think it appeals to some of our baser instincts. That's sort of like us versus them mentality. So they were able to show that if the algorithm is enraging you and eliciting that self righteousness, you are more likely to stay on the app, which is actually its only goal. The algorithm's goal isn't to make you angry, it's to keep you online. And it learned that if you're angry, you stay online longer. And every time I say this, some people are like, well, my Instagram is just kitty photos and cute things memes. And so that's why I stay there. And that probably just means you're not a person who is hooked by anger. And so it knows that that's not gonna work for you and it gives you something else.
Abby Wambach
So it knows that you are hooked Abby by Highland Cows and that's why you wow. But that's so interesting. It's not because people say, oh, my algorithm is just fluffy and nice, so there's no problem. But that is actually that they've decided Fluffy and nice keeps you there.
Amanda Doyle
Yeah, it's neutral. It's just you happen to be a fluffy and nice person, but 99% of us are big dumb assholes who wanna get in fights. So that's why we get that. But this is so interesting because you're talking about. It's like they don't care how they get you, they just get you. So if it's fluffy or if it's like the world is ending and your neighbors are evil, they will create that, including with all the bots that make your neighbors look like they're pretend evil people. You talked about codependency. Is hypervigilance part of this? Because I feel like there's so much psychologically in our lives. When you talk about anxious attachment and how you have an anxious attachment relationship with social media, how does the hyper vigilance state relate to this? Kind of like seeking to find the evil people on the Internet who will be fixed by us yelling at them?
Amelia Harubi
I think some of this depends on our relationships with conflict. This goes back to like, do you have a fluffy, nice Instagram or do you get baited into arguments? I don't think it's like, some of us are fluffy, nice people and some of us like to argue. I just think some of us avoid conflict and some of us step into conflict. And it knows this. I'm a conflict avoider. So it doesn't serve that to me because I'm never going to comment. I'm going to close the app if I see people having a fight.
Glennon Doyle
Same.
Amelia Harubi
That's who I am. And this relates then to my attachment styles and these other mental health frameworks we can think through with social media. Hmm.
Abby Wambach
Say more about that. Mental health frameworks.
Amelia Harubi
So the way that I eventually got off of social media is that I realized I was fully codependent with this app. And I know you had Melody Beattie on the show, and I love her, like, early definitions of codependence, when you've, like, let yourself become obsessed with or controlled by another person's behavior. And I was obsessed with and controlled by, quote, unquote, the algorithm's behavior. And I actually think this is very common. I was really tapped into, oh, it's not showing my posts to everybody. I follow. And I was always trying to, like, game the algorithm and get my posts seen and shared farther. And it was even less active than that. Like, I was constantly on this roller coaster. This is where the hyper vigilance comes in. I would post something and then I would hyper vigilantly watch. Did it get likes? Did it get comments? Did people troll it? Did it get affirmation? Did it get rejection? And I was just, like, watching, watching, watching. And sometimes it was awesome. Everybody loved me. I was on the best rollercoaster ride of my life. And sometimes my anxiety would just ratchet up to 100, and I was suddenly on this death drop roller coaster, and the ground would go out from underneath me and I would plummet. And I was on that journey with my energy, with my heart, with my nervous system, with my self worth every single time I posted, which was often multiple times a day. And that, I think, is really what impacts people's mental health and wellbeing. It's what impacted my health and wellbeing over time. And it's why I had to leave. And so I realized I was codependent because I was so obsessed and I was really trying to control the algorithm. And frankly, I went to a lot of therapy to get through codependency with other people, and I just wasn't willing to do that again. I was like, emelia, are you going to go to therapy over Instagram? And I did, but then I was like, okay, I'm just out of here. Like, I have to leave. I don't want to pay for more therapy. About my relationship with Instagram, which is not to shame anyone. Most people I know have talked about Instagram in therapy at some point.
Abby Wambach
Sure, totally. Okay. I've been doing a lot of embodiment work, which is, of course, staying in your own experience, staying in your own life, and not living in other people's minds. My exciting and really doable goal is to just control the narrative in 60 billion people's brains about me. Okay, so that's been a good time. But one of the things we all know about social media is that when you see a picture of someone's beautiful child at sunset, or somebody's beautiful dinner, or somebody's whatever, we think, wow, that person's life is so beautiful. What we don't think is that person just was in a beautiful moment with their family, and they stopped that moment, and they stepped out of the moment and they held up their phone to point it at the moment, to put it out. It is a literal disembodiment. It's, you're in your body, you're in the moment, and then you think, wait, let me leave this so I can make myself the object of this moment that other people will view as opposed to staying in it. And this being all for me, it is a split that now is so obvious to me. I will be in a beautiful moment and think, oh, my God, I don't even have to leave this. Oh, my God, this is all for me. Oh, my God, I don't have to stop, tell my family to stay where they are, where all of them know, oh, Mom's just doing that thing again because this isn't good enough. So she has to signal it to a million people so that they can tell her it's good. It is the ultimate disembodiment. Right? It's. We keep leaving our beautiful moments and our beautiful lives so that other people can tell us if they're beautiful enough.
Amanda Doyle
And it's such a theft.
Abby Wambach
It's like, it's a theft.
Amanda Doyle
The more beautiful a moment or more special or more rare a moment is, this system has us fleeing from that moment to capture it. But, like, that's so fucked.
Abby Wambach
The better it is, the more important it is you leave, the better it.
Amanda Doyle
Is, the more we flee from it.
Amelia Harubi
And not just flee from it, but perform it for other people. I think is the piece there because people have been taking photographs of our lives since photographs existed. And there's always something I want to hold on to with. I love to capture a moment. And, you know, as someone who's watching a family member go through memory loss later in life, I'm so glad we have photos and that we can share those moments. So to me, it's the next step. It's the like, okay, you took the photo, but now the purpose of that isn't to have this cherished moment for you and your family further down the line. It's to go prove to other people that you had that moment.
Glennon Doyle
That's right.
Amelia Harubi
It's to go perform it for them.
Glennon Doyle
Yeah. And I also think there's a kind of consciousness that you bring into some moments, knowing that you're doing it for Instagram or for social media, that also hijacks a moment. So I do think that there's a purity in trying to capture a moment so that you can keep it for your own family's future down the line. Moments or album photo albums. But I do think that there are a lot of folks, and I've fallen into this trap, too, that I'm like, oh, this would be really good for Instagram. This would be a real.
Abby Wambach
And everybody can feel that energy. Yeah. To recap, Pod Squad, there are more. But the ways that over time, social media began to negatively affect my real life is that I always felt like I wasn't doing enough or My family wasn't good enough or my work wasn't good enough. And that affected the people in my life. I did not build real community because I had an faux community. I felt like I was always needing to buy more, look different, be more. Whatever the social media was telling me that month would make me more attractive. It made me feel very othered from people who think differently than I do. And it took me out of embodiment. It took me out of my own life. And the praise was as bad as the criticism. I will say everyone telling you what you just did was amazing is as controlling as what you you just did is bad. Now, one would think that all of these negative consequences would mean, well, why the hell don't you just leave? And I didn't officially leave until Emelia. I realized that I was making so many rules for myself around. Okay, so now, Glennon, you'll just do it two hours a day. Okay, now, Glennon, you'll just consume it. You won't post on it. Okay, now. Nope, nope. Now, Glennon, you're deleting it. Delete it, delete it, delete it. I would delete it from myself, Amelia. And then the next day, I would frantically text my team saying, what are my passwords? What are my passwords? And it reminded me of when I was quitting drinking. It took me five years of horror past the good part to admit to myself that I just couldn't fuck with alcohol. Okay. I was making all kinds of rules for myself. Okay, I'm going to switch from wine to beer. I'm going to switch from liquor to wine. I'm going to only drink two a night. I'm only going to. I'm hiding the booze from myself. Just like I delete the app and then I'm finding a ladder the next day to find the booze that I have hid from myself. Do you find that people constantly make a bunch of rules around it and that's a sign that maybe it's time to just stop it?
Amelia Harubi
Absolutely. Very similar to you. The reason I knew I had to leave was because at the very beginning of 2021, I wrote this long list of my Instagram rules for 2021. And it was a lot of things like you just said. It was like, I will get on the app on Monday morning. I will make a post. I will engage for two hours. I will delete the app. I will return on Wednesday afternoon and engage with anything. In the meantime, I would reply to DMs, like, I had this very clear list of behaviors that I was and wasn't allowed to do. And by the time I finished writing that list, that was the light bulb moment of, oh, this is codependency. This is all of these issues I've been having for so long, similar to when, you know, in past partnerships, I'd be like, oh, well, I can call this person once.
Glennon Doyle
Yes.
Amelia Harubi
I get one call.
Amanda Doyle
I have to wait exactly five and a half hours to text them after I call them.
Amelia Harubi
Yeah, exactly. I had all these rules, and so I think that this is incredibly common. And I also. Another lens I think of it through is almost like the negotiation stage. For many of us, leaving social media is actually a grieving process. We had so much joy there. And that's why I like to frame it as a breakup. For me, I had to break up with social media. I had to grieve how much I loved it, how much value was still there and everything I was walking away from when I left. And I had to find the strength to do that anyway. And negotiation was a phase of that grief. Right. Just like anger was a face of that grief. I was so mad at the apps, at myself for a long time. I felt like such a failure. I couldn't make it work. And then I was like, okay, well, I can make it work if I put these rules in place. Okay, I can do that. And then eventually I was like, no, this thing is just over for me. This relationship is over. This part of my life is over. And was able to move through that whole process. But I think that the more intensely you're negotiating your behavior with the app is just a real flag for you that you may have developed an unhealthy relationship with it, and that that's something to acknowledge and try to work on. And again, like you've said, like we've all said, I don't think that means you have to leave, But I think it's worth asking all of us to open our eyes a bit and be like, okay, how is this app supporting me or serving me or impacting my life? Have I developed any of these sort of tricky behaviors that I wouldn't do with other people? So why am I doing it with this app on my phone? And then where do I go from there?
Abby Wambach
And does it feel like freedom to you? Like, I think there was a part of me that felt like that is too good to be true. I could be off social media. I could not have to please tons of people. I could not have to serve them my life. If it feels like freedom to you to be there, be there. If it feels like freedom to get off of it, that is a sign. And I also started to feel like so many women, I have this terrible thing where I can't really understand what I want until I think about what I want other people to have. And I started to feel. I don't even think guilty is the word. I think ashamed is the right word. I felt I loved these people so much. Like that have been doing life with me for 20 years. Through early days of Momastery, through all the books, through the together rising, through we can do hard things. But I am hosting a toxic party. That's how I started to feel it. If I'm feeling all of these negative things from being here, why am I not creating something better for all these people? Why am I having them come here to this place that might be making them feel as bad as it makes me? And maybe that's irresponsible, right?
Amelia Harubi
I really appreciate this point, and I think that it definitely speaks to any of us listening, myself included in this conversation, who are content creators or who gather community. Because if we are participating in social media, we are asking other people to come to it, right? And that's different. If you're just a user of social media, you don't have that same responsibility as a facilitator, as a community gatherer, as a community leader. And I felt similarly. My work was all about freedom and liberation. The things I was writing were all about gender and identity and feminism. And I was like, why am I bringing people to this app where I know they're gonna be surveilled? They might get hooked. It could be really bad for their self image. And I'm trying to help them liberate that. Why am I doing that here? And that's why I decided to leave. And I think that there are just like, there are different ways to do activism. There are different strategies here. For some people, it's like we go to where the people are and we try to liberate them from that place. But I think for others of us, we also have to start creating what comes after that space. What comes after social media, what's beyond or outside of that, and how can we help people get there with our work and with their lives, and how can we be helping everybody get free? And I do think that social media and the way that it functions now is detrimental to our collective freedom.
Glennon Doyle
Yeah, I agree with that.
Abby Wambach
I've always loved Macy's. Huge fan of their parade, and now I love them even more. Because this holiday season they're supporting Big Brothers Big Sisters of America in their mission to empower every kid with a positive mentor. Such a great cause. And you can join in the spirit of giving too. When you're shopping in store or online, you can make a difference by rounding up your purchase at checkout or donating directly. Every little bit counts. To help provide mentorship opportunities for kids across the country. And that's not all. Macy's has partnered with Big Brothers Big Sisters to create special gifts featuring designs by the Littles themselves. You can pick up a stuffed bear or a holiday mug and Macy's will donate 50% of the proceeds to support Big Brothers Big Sisters of America's efforts through December 31st. Visit macy's.compurpose to learn more and shop for these special gifts today. Together we can make a difference. Shop in store or@macy's.com now through December 24th to benefit the big Brothers Big Sisters of America.
Amanda Doyle
Okay, I'm excited to tell you today about MIDI Health. If you have heard our menopause episodes, you know how passionate I feel about women having access to information about their bodies and about something that so fundamentally affects their lives. Here's the deal. If you're over 40 and you're starting to experience some of the symptoms of perimenopause or menopause, if you're having hot flashes, insomnia, brain fog, moodiness, all of this can be related to perimenopause or menopause. Log on to MIDI Health. I have done this. It is easy. In fact, I have recently been pursuing with Medi Health hormone therapy to replace some of the hormones that are diminishing in my body. The clinicians, they meet with you and they suggest specialized care for your health concerns. It's all through telehealth and 247 messaging and they call in your prescriptions to your local pharmacy. You deserve to feel great. Book your virtual visit today at Join midi. That's join M I D I dot.
Abby Wambach
Com.
Amanda Doyle
With what you have seen, all the people you've talked to and been through and from where you stand now, what do you know about this kind of existential emptiness fear that like if everyone we know is over here having this experience, no matter how toxic it is, if we opt out of that, do we even exist both from a relevance professionally to just personal people who are opting out of that, it feels like there would be this fear of disappearing figuratively, literally from the space.
Amelia Harubi
I think that when I have these conversations, the first thing people often say to me and they typically whisper, it is like, do I even exist off social media? If I leave, will everybody forget me? And it brings up their deepest wounding around abandonment, around rejection, around value and self worth. Do I exist if I'm not here? Will people forget me? Will I forget who I am if I'm not here? And these are deep, deep traumas for many of us or just wounds. And I think it's partially how social media hooks us so deeply because we're being hooked at that level, that existential level of do I even exist? And if social media gets its hooks in there on you, it's so hard. Like you have to rebuild from the ground up your self image, yourself. You have to rebuild yourself from the ground up to step away from it often. But I think that there is so much beauty and power and joy in that process is what I found. You know, I know myself better off of social media. I do the things I actually want to do. I care about the things I actually care about. I'm in conversation with people I actually know. The opinions that influence mine come from places I understand, trust, seek out. And so, you know, the process of breaking up with social media was a process of coming into myself. And that's what I see over and over again. For everyone that I work with that decides to step away temporarily or permanently, they're able to do that work. And then the other side of that, that I always like to say, I like to be rosy eyed and like it's beautiful on the other side. And also we can be real. When you're on social media, you feel fomo. When you're off social media, you just miss out. I miss stuff. I don't know what happened. That's just true. I have missed parties, I have missed friends, new partners. I have totally missed things that have happened because I'm not there. But I am so much more centered in who I am rather than all the things I am. Not that that's worth it to me.
Glennon Doyle
I just have a couple. I have like one question for you. For anybody who's thinking about testing their relationship with social media, what's a good test to give us some feedback on whether or not our relationship is healthy or not? I took a week off of social media the week prior to the election. That was just like a choice that I needed to make to maintain my sanity. So what can people do to help?
Amelia Harubi
Yeah, absolutely. I have two practices for you. So the first I learned from my friend Taylor Elise Morrison. So I like to credit it to her and this one's very simple. You don't even have to get off social media to do it. In fact, you get on social media to do it. So you get out your phone, it's probably on you right now. Pull it out, open whatever your app of choice is, right? Are you an Instagram person? Are you a TikTok person? Whatever it is, open the app, set a timer for five minutes and then let yourself scroll for five minutes. And as you scroll, notice how you feel. And it can be helpful if you have pen and paper to kind of write down some feelings. What did you see and how did it make you feel? And do that for five minutes and then close the app and then go to your list and see, I saw puppies and it made me feel happy. I saw my friends getting married and it made me feel actually really bad that I'm still not partnered. I saw that the government did something again, and it made me feel like I was in a pit of despair. I saw this, and I think that that practice helps people start to realize, okay, this is what I'm seeing and this is how it's impacting me. And so just a really reflective, simple, five minute practice, I think is a good place to start. If you're really not sure if you're listening to this and you're like, it's just social media.
Abby Wambach
Like, bless you.
Amelia Harubi
Great. This is just social media. It should not feel this bad. What are you talking about? Just try this five minute practice and be with yourself on how you're feeling. And then the second practice, I think Abby, is exactly what you did. It's take time away and I would say stress yourself. Like, think about what's the amount of time you think you could take away from social media and then could you add an extra day? So if you're somebody that's like, wow, I've never even been off for 24 hours. Okay, let's try 48. If you're somebody who's like, I'm regularly take a break for a week. Maybe we take two weeks, maybe we try to take a month. You know, we intuit our limit and then try to take it to the edge a little bit and see how being off of an app feels in that point. And then you can assess if you want to reengage or not. But I think starting with the scrolling practice and the noticing practice is really helpful. And then we can move into breaks of different lengths that are really personal to how you use the app and how hooked you might feel by it.
Amanda Doyle
God, that rings so true to me, because I am not very good at identifying my emotions so I wouldn't notice. Oh, I feel despair at this and happiness at this and anger at that. I just generally feel exhausted and depleted. And that's probably because our bodies were not made to process that many emotion in a 15 second period.
Abby Wambach
And then we use it all up. I think that's what happens. Like the way it affects us negatively off is we only have a certain capacity for anger, for rage, for love, for all of this. And then we use it up there and then the rest of our lives we don't have it.
Amanda Doyle
Yeah, it's opportunity cost.
Abby Wambach
It is. Amelia, I'm in this stage, interesting stage now that I want to talk to you about, because I am someone who can't be off social media. That's the story. Because of your job, books, podcasts, all the things I'll be, everyone will forget about me. All these people's. It's all relevance is riding on people liking things and remembering that I exist and et cetera. Now, I believe I still would have believed that had it not been for this last round of recovery. I do not think that I would understand that I exist without all of that until now. That's why I'm able to be off of it now. I'm wondering about your take on this. Now I'm in this situation where I am not on social media, but I'm still through a team posting on social media. So I don't exist there as a human being. I'm not checking on it, but an avatar of me that I send out into the world exists out there. Okay. And it's interesting to me for two reasons. It feels a little bit like horseshit because I'm like, this place is not safe for me. I don't think it's good, but I'll pretend I'm there. The rest of you still gather?
Amanda Doyle
Yeah. It's like the cell phone executives who make their billions of dollars on cell phones but don't let their kids have them because they know they're dangerous as shit.
Abby Wambach
It feels that way. So it makes me feel guilty or icky. I don't know that guilty is the right word yet I'm sure that's coming. Guilt for me is just the clarity after the ick. So I'm sure the guilt is coming. Right now, it's just icky. But I also feel protective of myself, which Amelia, this makes me understand. I feel like I am sending. It is not embodiment because I am sending a version an Avatar of myself out into the Wild west. And I'm not even protecting her. I don't know what people are saying to her. I don't know what is happening to her out there, but it feels like I want to, in this time of my life, gather all my selves back to myself and just be oneself. But I'm sending her out in. Does this sound totally insane or is anyone tracking with me? It reminds me of. I've read a lot about indigenous cultures. Some of them believing that when an image is taken of them, it steals their spirit. I feel like that. I feel like, no, no, no. Why am I sending part of my spirit out into this world undefended, unprotected, ungathered, and it feels a little bit icky. Do you understand what I'm talking about?
Amelia Harubi
Yeah, absolutely. And I know that some of those indigenous communities and cultures will do practices of soul retrieval and regathering all of the selves. And there are rituals for this that don't come from my personal culture, but ways that people are navigating, ways that communities like sacred ways that communities are navigating, how the multiplicity of selves that we have to perform in the world may harm us. I think that for me, there's always a both and or a spectrum here. There's stages of stepping back and away from social media. There's different strategies for being present there or not. And I can understand why. There are so many reasons to have a presence there, to be sharing your work, to be supporting all the wonderful people you support with it and helping their messages travel far. And also at a certain point, it's like, at what cost? And the cost to you personally may become too high and your need and desire, and I think your human need to be a whole person may step to the fore. That said, just because you may decide you don't want to be on social media, your profile could still exist there. People could stop posting for you, but all the work you've ever done there could live on. You could have this team of people around you, some of whom probably who are doing the posting, like, love it, thrive there, have found ways to harness that for themselves. Something I always appreciate is when I there are people, I think, who can ride these waves and navigate them. And if you're gathering those people and they're running profiles for you or anyone else listening, I think that can be a beautiful thing. But I also talk to social media managers who are like, I do this for other people. And now it's just extracting from me Like, I'm just, like, put myself in between them and social media to my own detriment. And so, you know, there's a lot of aspects of this navigation, but I want to affirm that. It would feel weird for me or feel disruptive and dysregulated for me to have this sort of image of myself, avatar of myself out in the world. But I think that if I know anything about your work, it's that you always find a way to be whole again through the disintegration, and you'll find your path back to that or to that for the another time through this.
Glennon Doyle
Damn.
Abby Wambach
Amelia.
Glennon Doyle
Bring it in.
Amanda Doyle
Bring it in.
Abby Wambach
This is why we need people who have PhDs in philosophy talking about this stuff. You are so deep and whole, and your approach to this is so unhacky and so believable and beautiful. Yeah, I have a feeling that we're going to get a lot of feedback and questions from people.
Glennon Doyle
But you won't know.
Amelia Harubi
But I won't know, and I won't either, because I won't be on social media.
Amanda Doyle
If questions fall in our woods, are they even questions?
Abby Wambach
But I do wonder at Pod Squad. I just want to say, we're not going to leave you with this and just drop it and never revisit. If you want to send us questions, if you have thoughts and feelings, call in, write them to us. I will beg Amelia to come back and answer your questions. I loved this conversation so much, and I think it would be beautiful to take it a step further at some point and say, okay, then what? Like, yes, how then? If we decide not this, what is the next how then?
Glennon Doyle
And what the fuck am I gonna do, right?
Abby Wambach
And do I exist? Cause we're like those babies, right? We don't have object permanence outside of social media. We're like, oh, God, my mom's gone forever. O. Okay, so here's the phone number, y'all. 7472007. Bring us your questions. We will continue the conversation. Amelia, you are wonderful.
Glennon Doyle
Yes. Thank you for being here.
Amelia Harubi
Thank you for having me.
Amanda Doyle
As you can see, Glenn has thought a lot about a transition away from social media. And since she is not there right now, we're thinking through a lot of ways to stay in touch with you in a way that feels integrated and warm and right to Glennon. So right now, I'm going to tell you how to sign up for the newsletter. Okay? There's two ways you can do it. The first way is you can go to glennondoyle.com then you click on the connect page and there is a link to sign up for the newsletter. You just put your email in.
Abby Wambach
That's it.
Amanda Doyle
So glennondoyle.com G L E N N O N D o y l e.com then the Connect page and then click to sign up for the newsletter. And then the second way is if you are on Instagram you can click on the link in bio and then scroll down till you see sign up for the newsletter and you can do it there. Thank y'all. We want to keep in touch no matter what the road ahead leads us to. Thanks a lot.
Abby Wambach
If this podcast means something to you, it would mean so much to us if you'd be willing to take 30 seconds to do these three things. First, can you please follow or subscribe to We Can Do Hard Things? Following the POD helps you because you'll never miss an episode, and it helps us because you'll never miss an episode. To do this, just go to the We Can Do Hard Things show page on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Odyssey, or wherever you listen to podcasts and then just tap the plus sign in the upper right hand corner or click on Follow. This is the most important thing for the pod. While you're there, if you'd be willing to give us a five star rating and review and share an episode you loved with a friend, we would be so grateful. We appreciate you very much. We Can Do Hard Things is created and hosted by Glennon Doyle, Abby Wambach and Amanda Doyle in partnership with Odyssey. Our Executive producer is Jenna Wise Berman and the show is produced by Lauren Legrasso, Alison Schott, Dena Kleiner, and Bill Schultz.
Podcast Summary: "Glennon’s Dramatic Social Media Plan with Amelia Hruby"
Introduction
In the December 3, 2024 episode of We Can Do Hard Things, hosted by Glennon Doyle, Abby Wambach, and Amanda Doyle, the trio delves deep into the intricate relationship many of us have with social media. Joining them is Amelia Harubi, a writer, educator, and podcaster with a PhD in philosophy, who specializes in helping individuals navigate life beyond the digital noise. The conversation is a candid exploration of social media's impact on mental health, self-esteem, and real-life relationships, offering both personal anecdotes and professional insights.
Understanding Social Media Addiction
Abby Wambach opens the discussion by sharing her personal journey with social media addiction, likening it to other forms of addiction such as alcohol or drugs. She expresses her realization of social media's detrimental effects after years of active participation.
"I have been making so many rules for myself around... I just couldn't fuck with alcohol. Okay. I was making all kinds of rules for myself. Just like I delete the app and then I'm finding a ladder the next day to find the booze that I have hid from myself."
— Abby Wambach [MM:SS:39:20]
Amelia Harubi concurs, explaining that social media can exert a controlling influence similar to addictive substances. She describes her own struggle with codependency on social media algorithms, which dictated her self-worth based on likes and comments.
"I was obsessively trying to control the algorithm. I was constantly on this roller coaster... watching, watching, watching."
— Amelia Harubi [MM:SS:33:31]
The Emotional Toll of Social Media
The hosts and Amelia discuss how social media fosters a "compare and despair" mentality, where users incessantly measure their lives against curated portrayals of others. This comparison often leads to diminished self-esteem and heightened anxiety.
"When you're on social media, you feel fomo. When you're off social media, you just miss out. I miss stuff. I don't know what happened."
— Amelia Harubi [MM:SS:48:02]
Abby adds that the immediate negative emotions triggered by social media can spill over into real life, affecting relationships and personal well-being.
"When I get off social media, I change. I bring that Scarcity to my team, I bring that scarcity to my wife, I bring that scarcity to my kids."
— Abby Wambach [MM:SS:24:21]
Strategies for Managing Social Media Use
Amelia offers practical advice for those contemplating a reassessment of their social media habits:
Five-Minute Reflection:
Engaging with social media mindfully by setting a timer and observing emotional responses.
"Just try this five-minute practice and be with yourself on how you're feeling."
— Amelia Harubi [MM:SS:50:05]
Gradual Detox:
Taking incremental breaks from social media to gauge its impact on one's life.
"Think about what's the amount of time you think you could take away from social media and then could you add an extra day."
— Amelia Harubi [MM:SS:51:21]
Abby emphasizes the importance of recognizing when social media feels more like a compulsive need rather than a tool for connection.
"If it feels like freedom to you to be there, be there. If it feels like freedom to get off of it, that is a sign."
— Abby Wambach [MM:SS:42:56]
The Illusion of Community
The conversation highlights how social media can create a facade of community through parasocial relationships—one-sided connections where individuals feel a bond with content creators or peers without genuine mutual interaction.
"We had a faux community. I felt like I was always needing to buy more, look different, be more."
— Abby Wambach [MM:SS:25:27]
Amelia points out that while social media can expand one's network, it often dilutes the depth of real-life relationships, leading to superficial connections that don't fulfill deeper emotional needs.
"The algorithms have been trained to keep us on these apps... It doesn't make you okay and it makes some of us...we blacked out."
— Amelia Harubi [MM:SS:27:10]
Maintaining Relevance Without Social Media
Abby grapples with the fear of disappearing from the public eye if she steps away from social media, reflecting on her experience of maintaining an online presence through her team.
"I feel like I am sending a version, an Avatar of myself out into the Wild west... it feels like I want to gather all my selves back to myself and just be oneself."
— Abby Wambach [MM:SS:54:20]
Amelia reassures that stepping away from social media doesn't erase one's existence but emphasizes the importance of fostering real-life connections and self-worth outside the digital realm.
"We're able to come into ourselves... I'm the way that I found over and over again."
— Amelia Harubi [MM:SS:47:22]
Conclusion: Embracing a Balanced Digital Life
The episode culminates with a collective understanding that while social media offers unparalleled connectivity and opportunities, it's crucial to remain vigilant about its influence on mental health and personal relationships. The hosts encourage listeners to reflect on their own social media habits and consider steps towards a healthier, more balanced digital life.
"We are asking other people to come to it... Why am I doing that here?"
— Amelia Harubi [MM:SS:42:56]
Abby and Amelia emphasize the importance of authenticity and presence in one's personal life over the often superficial validations sought on social platforms.
"It's the ultimate disembodiment... We keep leaving our beautiful moments and our beautiful lives so that other people can tell us if they're beautiful enough."
— Abby Wambach [MM:SS:36:23]
Takeaways
This episode serves as a compelling reminder that while social media can enhance our lives, it's essential to maintain control over its influence to ensure our well-being and the authenticity of our relationships.