How to Be More Alive with Cole Arthur Riley (Best Of)

Summary

**Podcast Summary: "We Can Do Hard Things" – Episode: How to Be More Alive with Cole Arthur Riley (Best Of)
Release Date: January 12, 2025
Hosts: Glennon Doyle, Abby Wambach, Amanda Doyle
Guest: Cole Arthur Riley, Author of this Here Flesh: Spirituality, Liberation, and the Stories that Make Us

---

Introduction

In this poignant episode of We Can Do Hard Things, hosts Glennon Doyle, Abby Wambach, and Amanda Doyle engage in a deep and meaningful conversation with Cole Arthur Riley, the acclaimed author of this Here Flesh: Spirituality, Liberation, and the Stories that Make Us. The discussion navigates through themes of dignity, liberation, the intricacies of the human body, the significance of place, and the profound concept of wonder. Riley's work, which intertwines personal narratives with spiritual contemplation, serves as the foundation for exploring how to truly live a more alive and authentic life.

Announcing the Next Right Book: this Here Flesh

Amanda Doyle introduces Cole Arthur Riley’s book as the episode's focal point, declaring it the "Next Right Book" and emphasizing its importance as a sacred text rather than just a conventional book. This sets the stage for an in-depth exploration of Riley's insights on living authentically amidst life's inherent challenges.

Notable Quote:

Amanda Doyle [03:14]: "The Next Next Rite book. This might be the only damn Next Rite book you ever get."

Defining Contemplative Practice

The conversation delves into the meaning of being contemplative. Riley challenges the conventional notion of contemplation as mere intellectual or silent reflection, suggesting it encompasses a sacred attention to both the external world and one's internal state.

Notable Quote:

Abby Wambach [05:53]: "To me, I thought a contemplative was like the people who go off and sit in silence in an empty room and just think for hours on end."

The Intersection of Awe and Anxiety

Riley and the hosts explore the delicate balance between awe and anxiety. They discuss how deep attention and presence can simultaneously evoke feelings of fear and wonder, highlighting the complexity of human emotions.

Notable Quote:

Abby Wambach [14:42]: "I think there's something about awe and fear, that they're operating the same muscle almost."

The Role of Dignity in Liberation

A significant portion of the discussion centers on dignity as the foundational element for liberation. Riley shares personal anecdotes, including a transformative childhood experience where her father responded to her distress not with affirmations but with physical comfort, fostering a profound sense of unashamed self-acceptance.

Notable Quote:

Abby Wambach [33:11]: "If you don't understand that there is something inherent that can't be taken from you, it makes it very hard to even want liberation."

Intergenerational Trauma and Body Image

Riley poignantly addresses intergenerational trauma and its impact on body image and self-perception. She recounts her grandmother's struggle with body shame and her own battle with bulimia, illustrating how early experiences of shame can lead to long-term disconnection from one's body.

Notable Quote:

Abby Wambach [47:35]: "I think that distance can become disdain. That's it."

Connection to Place and Land Stewardship

The conversation shifts to the concept of place and our relationship with the land. Riley discusses her experiences with land ownership, highlighting a shift from seeing land as something to possess to viewing it as a space to nurture and protect. This perspective fosters a deeper connection to both the environment and one's sense of belonging.

Notable Quote:

Abby Wambach [59:37]: "Whenever I prune the path, whenever I bend down on the reeds and start picking the reeds to clear the path, I do that out of my own love. It's a very mysterious restoration."

Embracing Wonder as a Way of Being Alive

Riley emphasizes the importance of wonder in cultivating a richer, more alive existence. She contrasts the typical way people seek wonder in grand achievements or acquisitions with a more authentic appreciation for everyday beauty and human connection.

Notable Quote:

Abby Wambach [73:33]: "I think it's really difficult. I mean, if you're witnessing beauty, I think you're gonna be inclined to protect it."

Belonging Without Sacrifice

The discussion culminates with the theme of belonging, where Riley advocates for a form of love and community that doesn't demand sacrifices or strict adherence to beliefs. She stresses the importance of mutual witnessing and the authenticity of relationships as essential for genuine belonging.

Notable Quote:

Amanda Doyle [85:54]: "Belonging is a love that does not require a sacrifice at the altar of acceptance."

Conclusion

The episode beautifully weaves personal narratives with profound philosophical insights, offering listeners a roadmap to navigate the complexities of being truly alive. By embracing dignity, fostering authentic connections, honoring one's relationship with the land, and cultivating a sense of wonder, Riley and the hosts inspire a transformative approach to life's challenges.

Final Notable Quote:

Avery Doyle [89:09]: "The rest of you get the book and then we'll see you here next time. Bye."

---

Key Takeaways

1. Dignity as Foundation: Recognizing inherent self-worth is essential for any journey toward liberation and authentic living.
2. Contemplative Presence: True contemplation involves a sacred attention to both the inner self and the external world, fostering deeper self-awareness.
3. Awe and Anxiety: These emotions are intertwined, with deep attention capable of evoking both fear and profound wonder.
4. Intergenerational Trauma: Early experiences of shame and body image issues can have lasting impacts, necessitating healing through self-acceptance.
5. Connection to Place: Viewing land as a space to nurture rather than possess enhances our sense of belonging and responsibility towards the environment.
6. Authentic Wonder: Embracing everyday beauty and human connections can lead to a more fulfilled and alive existence.
7. Inclusive Belonging: Fostering communities based on mutual witnessing and authenticity without demanding sacrifices.

---

Recommended Listening:
For anyone seeking to navigate the complexities of life with authenticity and grace, this episode offers invaluable insights grounded in personal experience and profound reflection. Cole Arthur Riley's this Here Flesh is a must-read for those eager to embrace the hard yet rewarding journey of being truly alive.

Transcript

[Glennon Doyle]

When you hear a good idea, it's natural to do a double take. That's what you might do when you hear Discover will automatically double the cash back you've earned on your credit card at the end of your first year with cash back match. Wait, what?

[Abby Wambach]

Yep.

[Glennon Doyle]

Double the cash back is something so good you might do a triple take. It pays to Discover. See [e-mail] credit card.

[Cole Arthur Riley]

I don't know about y'all, but after the holiday rush, I can get a little glum. That's when I love treating myself to something special. But I do not break the bank. And that's where Quince comes in. May I please have the honor of introducing you to the comfort stretch trench coat at Quint? The average retail on this beauty is $228. But Quince's version, with 5 star average reviews is under 100 bucks. What I love about Quince is how they make everyday luxuries so affordable. All their pieces are priced 50 to 80% less than other high end brands because they partner directly with top factories, cutting out the middleman. Plus, Quince only works with factories that prioritize ethical, responsible manufacturing. Treat yourself this winter without the luxury price tag. Go to quint.com hard things for 365 day returns plus free shipping on your order. That's Q U I n c e.com hard things to get free shipping and 365 day returns. Quints.com hard things.

[Amanda Doyle]

Welcome back to We Can Do Hard Things. So here's the deal. I am a writer.

[Abby Wambach]

Yep.

[Amanda Doyle]

We know at this point on the planet, everyone who is a writer is expected to have a book club. It's just like, where's your book club? Why don't you have a book club? It's like, I'm not gonna have a book club.

[Abby Wambach]

Okay.

[Amanda Doyle]

I'm not gonna have a book club because Club. I feel like there's gonna be meetings. I feel like there's gonna be things expected of me. Plus, I treat books like I used to treat booze. Like, you know, I read like six books a week.

[Abby Wambach]

That's right.

[Amanda Doyle]

So by the time I'm in love with the book, like, I can't wait for everybody else.

[Glennon Doyle]

No, that's right.

[Amanda Doyle]

No, that's not gonna happen. So I am not gonna have a book club. What I am gonna have, I'm announcing right now.

[Abby Wambach]

Oh.

[Amanda Doyle]

And only because I read a book that is so effing beautiful.

[Glennon Doyle]

Yeah.

[Amanda Doyle]

That I have to demand that everyone reads it. We're starting something today called the Next right Book.

[Abby Wambach]

Oh.

[Amanda Doyle]

Because that's how I live my life is the next Right thing. I didn't make it up. It's a recovery thing. Today I announce the next Right book. Now, no one is allowed to expect anything of me. This might be the only next Right book I ever choose in my entire life. No one's allowed to ask when the next right book is.

[Cole Arthur Riley]

The next. Next Right book.

[Amanda Doyle]

The next Next Rite book. This might be the only damn Next Rite book you ever get.

[Glennon Doyle]

Yes.

[Amanda Doyle]

Okay, so pay attention. I'm looking at the person's face who we're interviewing right now, and I just realized I forgot to mention to her that I was announcing her book as the next Right book.

[Glennon Doyle]

Yeah, you also forgot to mention who it is to me and Amanda.

[Amanda Doyle]

No, I told sister. I just didn't tell you. All right. Today we announce the next Right book of the world. Everyone must read this book. It's not even a book. It's a sacred text. It's a. It's a spirituality. It's a. It's a whole thing. The book is called this Here Flesh. It is by Cole Arthur Riley. Cole Arthur Riley is a writer and poet. She is the author of the New York Times bestseller this Here Flesh, Spirituality, Liberation, and the Stories that Make Us. Her contemplation, writing and spirituality embody her lived experience as a black queer woman who lives with autoimmune disease. Cole is also the creator and writer of black liturgies, which she describes as a space for black spiritual words of liberation, lament, rage, and rest. Welcome, Cole, to our first episode of the Next Right Book.

[Abby Wambach]

Hi. Thanks for having me and for calling my book the Next Rite book.

[Glennon Doyle]

Well, if you have been present in my home and on the zoom calls with Amanda, you would understand why this is the first.

[Amanda Doyle]

Yeah, it's.

[Glennon Doyle]

And maybe the only next Right book. The conversations that we've been having about this book and you are. They will continue beyond this conversation that we're having today. Thank you for being here and thank you for freaking you and putting your. Your spirit and your love and your mind into this book. It is un Freaking believable.

[Abby Wambach]

Thank you.

[Amanda Doyle]

Sometimes when I love something so much, my entire life is about telling women to trust themselves. So I constantly doubt myself all the time. So I was reading it and I was like, wait a minute. Is this as freaking beautiful as I think it is? So I call my sister and I say, I'm reading it. Are you reading it? And before I say anything, she says to me, I think this is the most beautiful book I've ever read.

[Glennon Doyle]

Glennon, we've been talking about the word contemplative. We've been calling you that. I don't really understand it because I am not one, and I need you to tell me, what is it? What is a contemplative?

[Abby Wambach]

I'll tell you what I thought a contemplative was because maybe some people have this in their minds. To me, I thought a contemplative was like the people who go off and sit in silence in a empty room and just think for hours on end. And I think I had that impression probably because I was operating in a lot of white intellectual spaces that kind of co opted true contemplative practice from Eastern spiritualities and made it this complete practice of the mind. So that's what I thought it was when I went to write this year, Flesh. I started to really have to put language to what does contemplation mean for me? And the best way I can describe it is a kind of sacred attention, you know, and maybe that happens in thought and in silence and solitude, but I think it doesn't necessarily need to. It can be attention to the body. It can be a presence. Incidentally, we had this mantra in my family growing up. My father would always say to us, pay attention. What were you paying attention to? Like, look up, he'd say. Like, he would quiz us, like, what was the waitress's name? Were you paying attention? You know, and. Or where is home from here? And I think that was so in me that by the time I started a contemplative practice, it really melded really naturally into just who I am because of that kind of family upbringing. I'll also say that there is some kind of connection to one's interior world and just kind of like a nearness to oneself. And it's not just attention to the exterior or the interior, but it's kind of like a bridge. Or at least that's how I think of it.

[Glennon Doyle]

Wow.

[Amanda Doyle]

It's funny because the thinking thing, most people think the contemplative is somebody who thinks all the time, but it's kind of like the opposite of that. Like the mind is the least contemplative place. It's like it's paying attention to. Is that true? Is it paying attention for you to your surroundings, to your body, to your spirit and getting out of your head?

[Abby Wambach]

Listen, I'm with you. I think other people might disagree with us, Glennon, but I'm with you. The mind is interesting to me as like a form of contemplation. But I think there are so many forms, and the one we tend to neglect is kind of a connection with one's physical self and one's body and a kind of presence. I'm an escapist. I've always been an escapist, from the time I was a child. And so I think I was drawn to kind of a false contemplation that was about kind of disconnecting. Let's live up here. This is safe. You know, I can't be hurt here. I can be analytical and not feeling, because feeling is such a risk. And I had to unwind a lot of that. And I really did this by thinking about the people who had come before me and the spiritual practices that they contained and had access to. And I talk about this a little bit in the book. Having this imagination for the spiritual lives that, say, my ancestors who were enslaved had to have. And this restraint of expression, this restraint in articulation. They couldn't say what they wanted to say. They didn't have control over everything. But what they did have control over is this connection to their interior life and this kind of hiddenness of self that I think is so special and sacred. And such a part of my contemplation is this, where are the secret places in me? And I go there not because I think everyone needs access to them, but because I deserve that union with myself. And so I'm trying to adopt some of that as well.

[Cole Arthur Riley]

Do you think that secret places in you and that need to protect yourself had anything to do with you were selectively mute until you're about seven and you have dealt with anxiety over your entire life. I'm wondering how that all fits together and whether it was kind of an innate protection of what you knew was the sacred in you not wanting to share it. Or was that about anxiety? Or is it all just a need to pay deep attention and shutting off your voice was a way to kind of keep paying closer attention?

[Abby Wambach]

Oh, that's interesting. I think the kind of shadow side I think of contemplation can be. Anxiety can be an overactive imagination of what could go wrong or what's at risk, what's at stake. When you're so close to your interior world and your physical body, you become so aware of everyone else's, and you know what's going on inside you. Because I know everything that is going on inside me that I'm not necessarily presenting. So, you know, imagination, it's such a beautiful thing. But there is this shadow side of what can this do when it's kind of put into hyperdrive and when it's the only way of existing. And as for kind of silence, I think maybe that's. It definitely has something to do with why I'm drawn to a more contemplative life is because I've had to honor that I'm distinct, that I have needs, and that I'm not always incredibly verbal. And I'm not someone who's going to process as I speak. There are these brilliant people who can just speak and say really profound things that they've never said before. I'm not one of them. You know, I need that pause. And I think I was resisting that for so long because I was ashamed of how I appeared in the world as this kind of shy and quiet girl. And I tried to force myself into this caricature of, like, the witty kind of charming. I did that for a few years in college. And it just. It required so much energy that I didn't have to give. And so contemplation was just this form of spirituality that I could just rest and say it's imperfect. Are there times when I'm silent not because of choice, but because of oppression, because of insecurity, because of anxiety? Absolutely. But are there times where my silence is actually a sacred path that, frankly, other people could learn from? I think so.

[Glennon Doyle]

For sure I could.

[Amanda Doyle]

We're going to talk about awe later because you have such a beautiful perspective on awe. But do you ever think that awe and anxiety are connected? Because it's like if you're paying deep attention, I get a little bit, just a smidge awkward in social situations. Okay, Abby. Just, like, often. Cole. My thing is when someone introduces themselves to me, I panic and introduce myself as them. So, like, if a person named Joel walks up to me and says, hi, I'm Joel, I panic every time and say, hi, I'm Joel. And then it's like this moment, it's just off, Just. Okay. So what I try to describe social anxiety sometimes is it's like being starstruck by everyone. Okay.

[Abby Wambach]

Yes.

[Amanda Doyle]

If you're really paying attention and you're like, wait, look at all these. We're bodies walking around with all of these worlds inside of us just, like, so exposed. We're just looking at each other. We're just, like, naked out here, just looking. It's just. Do you think being in awe of things, I guess you would say the shadow side of that.

[Abby Wambach]

I'm with you. I agree that there's something about awe and fear that I think are really intimately tied if you're a person. I mean, I say this, and I've said this in an interview a few weeks ago, and the person who was interviewing me was just like horrified, but I said, I'm a scared person. I don't say that to be self deprecating, but I think there are just those of us who live with a greater day to day fear. And I'm always assessing risk and I'm looking around and I. I was a very scared little child as well. Of course fear and anxiety are close, but also, you know, I do consider myself a person of awe. I'm so anxious to get on this podcast call. But beforehand I'm sitting here listening to the barn swallows outside, and I'm grounded in maybe both, for better or worse. But I think there's something about awe and fear, that they're operating the same muscle almost. That sacred attention can do really scary things as well.

[Amanda Doyle]

And isn't that fear and awe, even in the Bible, isn't aren't like fear? God, wasn't that original word awe? It's like those are always.

[Abby Wambach]

Wow.

[Amanda Doyle]

Those are always swimming together. Fear and awe.

[Abby Wambach]

Yes, yes.

[Amanda Doyle]

First, it should be said that your work, you have always said, and your work is clearly for black people and black liberation. I thought it would be okay to celebrate your book because you sent it to me. Yes, I felt like it would be okay. But what do you think of white people celebrating your book and celebrating your work? What is your reaction to that?

[Abby Wambach]

There's a tension in me. You know, I've lived with what Toni Morrison calls the white gaze. I've lived with that over my life, just looming for so many years. And certainly I've lived with that in my writing. And while I was writing this here flesh, I had to keep asking myself, who's in the room with you, Cole? And I'm almost embarrassed to say how many times the answer was some white intellectual man that didn't care about me, didn't care about my body or my words. Who invited you? I'm trying to write. I'm trying to write something for my family. I'm trying to write something that matters. And these different people, I would find they're not completely imagined, you know, they're real. But these kind of specters, these haunts, were just looming over my writing. And I had to kind of keep exercising the room and say, no, I know who I want in the room with me. I want my ancestors. I want my own voice, my own soul. So anyways, when white people approach black Liturgies or this here flesh. I'm always a bit cautious, I'm a bit wary. Cause I know there are times when the white gaze won. And I can be honest about that. And I think my journey will be, as I continue to write books, hopefully to continue to do better and better and be clearer and clearer about who I'm speaking to. And so I worry. But at the same time, you know, I don't really feel the need to gatekeep. You know, it would be kind of foolish of me to think that there's not something of my human experience that's worth experiencing by a white body like that. I'm not really interested in that. I don't really have the energy to gatekeep my work in that way. Some people do. I don't. And so I think if a white person can approach either black liturgies or the book and decenter themselves, like, I'm giving them a gift, you know, you're welcome. That's how I think about it, is this is. This is a gift. If a white person is capable of de centering themselves. But I've had this question so many times like, who do you want to write for? Who's your audience? And at first it was just black. This generalized black people, because that's what you're supposed to say, black people and whatever, that's fine. But when I'm most honest, I'm writing for my grandma. That's who I want my audience to be. My grandma, my father. Those are the people I'm thinking of. And when I think of particular people and not just this generalized notion of blackness and this, you know, allegiance, I think it helps. I think it helped my writing, if I'm honest, it helped my writing to seem compassionate. Because I'm not talking to you and I'm not talking to a stranger. I'm writing to honor the people that I love and who have held me.

[Glennon Doyle]

What does the future hold for business? Ask nine experts and you'll get 10 different answers. Bull market or bear market? Rising or falling rates? Inflation up or down? Can someone please invent a crystal ball? Until that happens, over 40,000 businesses have future proofed themselves with NetSuite, the number one cloud. Erp. With this unified business management suite, you gain a single source of truth that provides the visibility and control you need to make quick decisions. Imagine having real time insights and forecasting at your fingertips, allowing you to peer into the future with actionable data. When you're closing the books in days, not weeks, you can focus more on what's next instead of looking backward? Speaking of opportunity, download the CFO's guide to AI and machine learning at netsuite.com hardthings the guide is free to you at netsuite.com hardThings netsuite.com hardthings as parents.

[Cole Arthur Riley]

We all want to set our kids up for success, but it's not always easy. Maybe you've got a kid struggling with a particular subject, or they need help with homework, or it takes you 67 hours to find the online database where the assignments live. God help us. All of these situations are where IXL learning comes in. IXL is an online learning program designed to help kids understand fully subjects like math, language arts, science and social studies. They adapt to each child's needs with positive feedback to keep them engaged and motivated. One subscription covers pre K through 12th grade, making it easier to use for all kids, no matter age or level. Make an impact on your child's learning. Get IXL now and we can do hard things. Listeners get an exclusive 20% off IXL membership when they sign up today at ixcellearning.com we can visit ixllearning.com weken to get the most effective learning program out there at the best price.

[Amanda Doyle]

The Apple Watch Series 10 is here. It has the biggest display ever. It's also the thinnest Apple Watch ever.

[Abby Wambach]

Making it even more comfortable on your wrist whether you're running, swimming or sleeping.

[Amanda Doyle]

And it's the fastest charging Apple Watch, getting you 8 hours of charge in just 15 minutes.

[Abby Wambach]

The Apple Watch Series 10 available for the first time in glossy jet black aluminum compared to previous generations. IPhone XS are later required charge time and actual results will vary.

[Cole Arthur Riley]

You said you've always been an escapist, and I really loved your interrogation in the book about escapism, both internally but also in the Christian faith. So often it's set up as we don't have to worry about now. We don't have to worry about bodies right now. We we're worrying about later. And all our efforts are for later. You just mentioned your grandma. You say I don't know much about heaven, but I have no reason to believe it won't be made right here and everything will smell like my grandmother's perfume. Why do we do that? And what what is the power of reclaiming right now? The idea that heaven could happen right now?

[Abby Wambach]

Yeah, I think the kind of illusion of the someday heaven. I don't want to demean it because it's given so many people hope. It's how so many people have survived by thinking of the someday, but I think it's been manipulated by the powerful and by people who are insecure in the way they are in the world, the things that they do, the people that they're oppressing, the wealth that they have. And so it's kind of this cognitive escapism because you don't really want to pay attention to the very present material injustices that are happening to a person or the really present pain that exists in the world. Some people don't have the practice in attuning to that. And so the only kind of feasible answer I think is escape. Let's talk about someday it's all going to be okay and we'll be floating blissful spirits around. And you know, I have no idea if that's true or not. And so why expend so much energy, so much energy trying to force myself into this someday thing or live for this someday thing. And maybe that's because I'm just a past oriented person. I don't know, I'm a memory oriented person. But you know, I think what happens when we are able to, I don't know, interrogate that inclination to the someday heaven is we start to. Well, I think we get closer to ourselves. You know, we get closer to our sadness, I think we get closer to our anger. Really every felt emotion, I think is probably amplified when you bring yourself back in to what is happening now. And I wonder if it doesn't also make people more active. You know, there's a kind of urgency that changes. Oh, I don't love the word urgency, but there is some kind of, there's an emotional urgency whenever you're able to say, I want goodness for you now. I want peace, I want healing for you now. I want clean water for you now. You know, I want good relationships for you now. It creates this kind of urgency in our relationships and our emotions.

[Cole Arthur Riley]

I think, I think it's beautiful because of the change that we don't wait upon. Also, you said that that structure of escapism means that they've set up a system where the only holy things are invisible.

[Abby Wambach]

Yep.

[Cole Arthur Riley]

Because if only the holy things are, are those things we cannot see, that means that all the things we can see, our bodies, our love, our partners.

[Amanda Doyle]

Our planet, our planet, our planet our, are not holy.

[Cole Arthur Riley]

And so that reclaiming of no holy is now. And these things that I'm looking at and these people I'm looking at and myself are holy. That was really beautiful. So thank you for putting that in my Head.

[Abby Wambach]

Thank you.

[Amanda Doyle]

We are addicted to it, though. This whole, like, I'll be happy when, I'll be happy when I'm a grown up, I'll be happy. When I have a job, I'll be happy. So the escapism, religion is just like the ultimate arrival fallacy. It's like, yes, okay, how about we'll just. We'll start. You know what we'll do? We'll start living after we're dead. It's really a bit wild. That's what. That's what it is. Save yourself. Save yourself. Literally, save yourself till you. After you're dead. Right. And it also relieves us of doing anything hard, like a fighting for justice now it's okay. Everything will be fair later. A fighting for the planet now it's okay, there'll be some other planet later. It's fascinating. And so you. Your book, to me, I think that there's so many books that are about sacred texts or reflections. Your book feels to me like a new sacred text. And as such, people are going to, like, try to figure it out. So we've been thinking about, you know, reading a book is different than planning a podcast. So how do we talk about your book in a way, in a. In a language that all people of all faiths and no faith are understanding? We started Talking about your 15 categories in this book and then how they are ways of. Not of redemption, salvation now, not waiting for redemption, salvation later. Does it track for you to also call these, like, ways to be alive? Are these ways to be alive? Are these 15 things different ways to be alive? Or are we getting that wrong?

[Abby Wambach]

No, I. I see that. Ways to be alive. Yes. And maybe the. The beginning, we begin with dignity.

[Amanda Doyle]

Mm.

[Abby Wambach]

Maybe that's the one that's distinct. There's something inherent about it. It's not a way, it just is. And that can offer maybe some stability as you're approaching the other things. That's a constant, at least in my belief system. I don't think that your dignity is predicated on anyone else's belief, on your own belief. I don't think it requires that. It just is. And maybe liberation is just the. I don't want to call it the ending because it's not linear, but liberation maybe functions in the same way. That's the last chapter in the book of. It's this kind of form throughout the book. I think you're liberated into lament. I think you're liberated into rage, into belonging, and then everything in between. I like that language, ways, ways to be ways to live.

[Amanda Doyle]

And you said, dignity is the bedrock. Can you tell us the story about when your hair started turning gray when you were little?

[Abby Wambach]

Yes. Yes. So I started getting gray hair when I was, like, I don't know, early six, seven. And it was getting worse and worse with each year. And I developed this. This ritual standing on my little stool in the bathroom. And I would part my hair, and I would try to find the perfect part where the least amount of gray was showing again. I'm a completely shy child. I'm just praying for my own invisibility. And I'm already distinct because of my blackness, distinct because of my silence. Here's this other thing that's making me distinct. And so, I mean, anytime a classmate would even look at me, I'm trying to, like, duck and dive. And this thing was just kind of screaming out, at least in my impression. So by the time I was maybe 11 or so, we were getting ready to go somewhere. My whole family and everyone was waiting downstairs for me. And I'm upstairs, you know, parting, parting, reparting, trying to pluck out hair. I was using my stepmom's mascara to try to cover up some of the grays.

[Amanda Doyle]

I do that now. I do that now.

[Abby Wambach]

And finally, my dad sends everyone to the car, and he comes to the bottom of the stairs, and very simply, he asks, how much longer is it gonna be, Nicole? And I don't know what happened to my little body, but I just lost it. I started yelling, I hate my hair. I don't even remember what I said. I threw the comb against my brother's door, and it was just not the kind of expression you would usually find out of me. I felt like spectacle. And finally, I look at my dad, who's just standing there calmly, face completely calm, and I say, I can't do this anymore. I have to dye my hair. And he told me to come down the stairs. And I came down, you know, afraid of what would be the consequence of my, like, outbursts. And he just takes my head and tucks it into his chest, and he says, okay, we can dye your hair. And I was so confused, so completely confused, and that I just stopped crying. And I'm looking at him like, that's not what you're supposed to say. You know, what's the script that we're told that we're supposed to say? We're supposed to try to rally someone's beliefs, you know, tell them you're beautiful. All of the language, all of the articulation. My dad Very wise. I don't think he even understood the moment, knew that that's not what I needed, that I needed. He would do whatever he needed so that I could stand unashamed in front of him and my family. That he had to do that. And it was a physical act, right? He tucks my head into his chest. He doesn't say, you're beautiful, but we draw near to beautiful things, you know? He kisses my head. He puts my hair into the bun himself. He takes on the labor. He puts my hair into a bun so I don't have to do it. We just walk to the car and get in. And we didn't talk about it again. We never went and bought hair dye. I never asked about it again, which is the strangest part of this story. Something mysterious happened on those stairs where the. You know, it changed me. And it's something that you don't know has changed you until after. It's like it comes to you in memory. You realize that was a real shift. Why? Why? Because I didn't need the lecture. I didn't need the three point reason as to why I'm beautiful. I needed someone's nearness. And I need someone to say, it's okay. What can we do, you know, what can we do to kind of stop the bleeding before I try to get you to march out and strut a Runway? What can I do?

[Amanda Doyle]

You said sometimes you can't talk someone into believing their dignity. You do what you can to make a person feel unashamed of themselves. And you hope in time they'll believe in their beauty all on their own.

[Abby Wambach]

Yes.

[Amanda Doyle]

Just this past weekend, Cole, I gave. A friend was staying with me. I gave her your book. She went downstairs, she came upstairs to the kitchen crying and saying over and over again, God made them close. They were ashamed. Adam and Eve, who throughout the book, you also switch to Eve and Adam every other time, appreciate you.

[Abby Wambach]

Good job.

[Amanda Doyle]

But they were ashamed of their naked selves. And God didn't give them the three point speech. God just made them close like your dad. Why do you think dignity is the bedrock of all of the forces of liberation or ways to be alive in your book? Why is dignity the bedrock?

[Abby Wambach]

If you don't understand that there is something inherent that can't be taken from you, it makes it very hard to even want liberation. I'm thinking of that Assata Shakur quote that she talks about. You can become so used to your chains, you know, that you don't have an appetite for liberation anymore because you start to think that's what you're meant for. And so how could I take someone on a journey of kind of liberating spirituality if they don't believe they're worthy of that? And that moment, that. That moment in Genesis with God and the clothes, there's something. It complicates the story in so many beautiful ways. I was taught when I went to college, this very un nuanced and frankly boring story about just this curse, this doom, you know, this doom and gloom and the dark clouds rolled in. And there's just this very simple, beautiful line that just complicates everything that's happening in the moment. Did God have to kneel? Did he kneel down in the dirt? Did he make the first kill? You know, he made the clothes out of skin. What did that cost him? And so it complicates the story, I think, of shame and attunement and care in a way that's really beautiful. It's tenderness. It's. It's. Yeah, it's tender, but it's painful as well. Yeah.

[Amanda Doyle]

Because your dad. Because it cost him something. Because he probably wanted to say, my darling, perfect daughter, you're perfect. Your body, yes, but he chose.

[Abby Wambach]

If you hate yourself, what does that mean about me? Imagine what my dad, he's a very young father. He was a teen dad. What does that mean about what I've done? I can only imagine the thoughts going on in his head. So there's two. I mean, my shame. I think this is how shame often works. Like it doesn't just. It doesn't just stay where it's meant to go. My shame activated something in him, I'm sure you know, of his own questions. What does that mean about my face? You bear my face as well. You hate your face. What does that mean about mine? What does that mean about the things I've told you? What does that mean about me greasing your scalp every morning? The shame, in a way, can be a kind of contagion. But I think there are people out there, wise people like my father, who are able to take that and decenter themselves in a way that allows them to care, even though it can be costly.

[Amanda Doyle]

We have a very exciting trip coming up.

[Glennon Doyle]

I can't wait.

[Amanda Doyle]

POD Squad. We are going to stay in Park City in a big house with all of the people who we worked with to produce Andrew Gibson's documentary, which is called Come See Me in the Good Light. Okay, so we've been working on this documentary all year, and it's going to Sundance. Yay. Yay. And we all wanted to stay together. And so Abby and I found this big, beautiful house that all the. I mean, I think it's pretty much all lesbians. Mostly all lesbians. It's gonna be a very gay, cozy house. We all want to have our own spaces, but we all wanna feel connected.

[Abby Wambach]

Yeah.

[Amanda Doyle]

So we went with Airbnb. If you're traveling with family or friends this winter like we are, consider an Airbnb. Those extra rooms and a full kitchen make all the difference. And if you're going solo, you can still find a place that feels like your own little sanctuary no matter where you are. So next time you're planning a winter getaway, give Airbnb a try. Trust me, it's an experience you won't regret. If you've ever thought you can't find a bra, it's functional and comfy, think again. I'm a big fan of thirdlove. I have some of their bras and they also have great athleisure. Heavy on the leisure. I know our producer Lauren has some leggings from there that she absolutely loves. They started this brand to make bra shopping way less frustrating. So they're trying to tackle all of the typical bra blms we all deal with, like having straps that actually freaking stay in place. Designed right in San Francisco. Their bras go through a ton of testing on real people before they hit the market. Plus, they offer a perfect fit promise and an easy 60 day return policy so you can shop with confidence. They even invented half cups. Amazing. So you don't have to choose between sizes that just don't work. Plus, you can visit their virtual fitting room to find your perfect fit fast. Time to get your problem solved. Use code PODCAST15 for $15 off your first order at ThirdLove. What do you say to someone who was not loved like your father loved you? Who. Who is needing to find dignity as a bedrock in order to begin living? There's so many times that you say dignity isn't something we offer to people. We just affirm it. How does someone find dignity when they haven't been loved? Well.

[Abby Wambach]

Right. I mean, I'm biased, but this is where I think that the spiritual should come into play. Whether or not that's a Christian spirituality, and I don't really care, but just an attentiveness to the mysteries of the world. How about we use that word? I'll speak from my own experience when I'm drawn into that. The mystery of being. I don't always need the Clarity of someone else's affirmation or my own affirmation. There's this really cruel rhetoric out there that I'm sure you've heard it, that says if you don't believe that you're beautiful, no one else will. How did we get. How cruel? What kind of strange. I mean, leave it to us to decide. We'll meet self hatred with self hatred. We'll meet self hatred with blame. If you don't believe that you're beautiful, no one else will. You just have to muster belief. I think it's so impractical. And right now we have a ton of people on social media pretending that. That. That self love is there. It's a. It's a theater because that's what you're supposed to say. That's what you're supposed to believe about yourself. I just feel so sad about that. I feel so sad about that kind of theater that we're all kind of forced into. Instead, I think we have a kind of. We can have a kind of mysterious framework for existence that says your beauty, it actually is not predicated on you. I don't have to believe it when I wake up in the morning. You just are. You can choose to breathe the air or not breathe the air, but the air is there. You know, it's there. And. And it's. It's more of an awareness than anything else, I think that's been so healing to me. Instead of trying to contrive this really triumphant, you know, this really triumphant form of dignity that says I deserve to be honored, I now say I possess honor. I possess that. I'm not waiting. I'm not waiting for anyone to give me the honor that I need. It's in me. And that changes. That changes how I'm able to. Yeah. How I'm able to survive, frankly, in a world that doesn't love my body, that doesn't love black women bodies. It changes things.

[Cole Arthur Riley]

Cole, you originally thought you were going to write a book of spiritual contemplation, but you grew up in a family that you call not overtly spiritual, but had a very strong commitment to storytelling. So you had these stories of your family that you were compelled to write. You wrote those, and now you have this gorgeous book of stories that isn't exactly the spiritual contemplation book that you originally planned. Yet it seems to me that in writing your intergenerational stories of lament and joy and struggle and wonder that you compelled into spiritual contemplation the missing piece. Right. The dignity and wisdom of you and your people. It makes me think of Jesus was called the word made flesh, how it was imperative that the message became the body, and it's likewise imperative that the body become the message. So faith can't be embodied without the story of our bodies. Like it must take on account of our stories and our bodies. What does it mean to you to have your faith integrate and take account of your story and your body and your father's story and your father's body and your grandmother's story and your grandmother's body?

[Abby Wambach]

Mm. I mean, it's terrifying. It's. It's. It's terrifying. I could have written a book that's just purely contemplation and philosophizing, but this book, there was something about connecting it to the stories that made me. That forced me to tell the truth about things that I think I could have really gotten away with lying about. You know, people say they believe all kinds of things. We can say we believe all kinds of things. I don't. I think the percentage that we really believe those things is probably really slim for most people when you take account of their lived experiences and their stories. I can go on social media and say, love your body, listen to your body. But the more honest thing would be to say I've been outside of my body for over a decade. You know, I'm telling you to listen to yours because here's the story of. I don't share this in the book. Here's the story of me having bulimia for 10 years, me living with bulimia for 10 years, that has the message. There's something behind it that's storied. And I agree with people who say we carry our stories in our body. So I couldn't tell the stories without talking about the body. I couldn't talk about contemplation without talking about its effect on the physical, material world, including me. And so, yeah, it was. It was always going to be connected, but it was hard.

[Amanda Doyle]

And the body, living in a body, or body, I should say, is another way that you tell. That you write about a way of being alive. So, like dignity, body is another way of being alive. And as you write about and as we all have experienced in different ways, we are often cut off from that way of being alive through shame. So can you tell us the story about your grandmother as a child? And this note? She got home from school from her teacher.

[Abby Wambach]

Yes. So my grandma, I can't remember her age, but she was young, young. Like, this was elementary school. And she Just had a chest. She's always had a big chest. And she was starting to mature. She's a teacher. Wrote a little note and tucked it in her. In between her sweater and her backpack strap that said, phyllis can't run in the playground. You know, needs bra or something like that. Now, my grandma, she was living in a extreme. I mean, all kinds of abuse were taking place in the house that she was being raised in. But, yeah, verbal abuse being no small part of that. She then had to look at her, the woman who was not her mother. She had to look at her face and watch them, watch that person hate her even more because of her body. So she was also enduring sexual abuse, surviving sexual abuse as a child. And she talks about being so, you know, disconnected from her body. She did stop running on the playground, and even though they. They bought her a bra, but she said she would sometimes look down and think, is that my hand? Is that hand mine? Because she was so disconnected. Or she would pass herself in a window and do a double take because she was so disconnected from her physical appearance, from the sight of her own face and the sight of her own flesh. For a number of reasons. Yeah. And her journey was kind of, I want to say, to overcome, but I think it's probably more complicated than that. I think her journey is maybe partially overcoming, but partially learning to exist with what everything that happened to her in childhood did to her relationship with her body. And I think many of us have had similar experiences of the shame that begins at childhood. And it finds a place to rest in your body, and it just grows and grows and grows. And there are seasons where you're maybe able to kind of cut out the cancer a little bit, and then maybe it grows again. But I think it's just a journey. And it was hers, and it's mine for sure.

[Amanda Doyle]

It is an expulsion. It feels like an expulsion. It's like if being in our body is a way. A force of liberation, is a way of being alive, then the shaming of our bodies that happens so early, it's just ejects us. It's like an Eden ejection. An Eden ejection. It's a. And then we don't get it. Exile. Thank you. It's an exile.

[Abby Wambach]

Yes.

[Amanda Doyle]

And then we don't get it anymore. The line where you said that your grandmother was the. The lone body that required bondage when they said she has to have a bra, that then your grandmother in that class became the lone body that required bondage. And it changed the way she Moved forever. Do youth have any clue what the hell? Bulimia. How do you understand bulimia with your contemplative self?

[Abby Wambach]

Yes. Yeah. Yes. Well, here's the thing. It begins with the body, but it's. It's not solely embodied, of course it has to do with shame. We know this. But I. I've been pretty. I have. I had a pretty distorted relationship with my body from the time I was a child. Even before I had developed bulimia as a way to kind of cope with the world. I already was kind of living in my head and leaving my blackness behind in certain spaces or feeling kind of alienated because of my bigness. I was a chubby child, so there were all these. And I mentioned this very briefly in the book, but I also survived ongoing sexual abuse as a child. So I'm. I learned at a time when kids are learning how to move in their bodies, how to. Their agility. This the age that they're learning how to be free and that they can jump from here to there. I was learning how to leave my body to survive. You know, that was my strength. You need to leave. And I am. You know, I'm certainly no expert, but we know that that's a very common and necessary trauma response. Dissociation gets a bad name, but in the moment, it's a mercy, you know, in the presence of trauma, it's a mercy. Sadly for me and for many other people, it just happens to be that we take that mercy and we extend it, even though the threat is no longer there anymore. You know, we extend it. And I think that happened for both my grandma and I. And we learn to dissociate even when we don't want to and we don't need to necessarily for survival. So I was already at a distance, you know, at a distance from my body. And that was my gift. That was my strength to leave, to escape, if you want to connect it there. Then as I go into adolescence and I'm dancing, I'm in front of a mirror, however many hours a day, pretty much every day of the week, I'm in front of a mirror. I can't escape the sight of my own face. I can't escape the relationship with my body. So what do I do? I turn against it. That distance becomes then, you know, really disdain, self hatred. I mean, maybe it begins with neglect, but it ends with self hatred. For me, at least, that's what my. I think that was the story of my bulimia, a hatred of my body. But more than that, A hatred of me, a hatred of myself, which I think is so sinister and it's so imprecise that I think it's really difficult because it felt so necessary to my survival. In the same way that leaving felt necessary to my survival, this new ritual of purging felt necessary for my survival. I mean, and so I wonder if you resonate with that kind of desire to leave becoming a desire to annihilate, you know?

[Amanda Doyle]

Yeah. I mean, you just said distance can become disdain. That's it. I feel like I've figured it out now, so. And I'm gonna have it figured out until at least you get off this podcast, and then I'm gonna forget again. But, yes. And I'm wondering if that's why the only things that really, truly helped me, besides my medication, are practices where I'm in your body. In my body, presence becomes love for me when I'm forced to be present in my own body. And that makes sense, right? Because the truth is love, it's there. Like you said, we don't have to earn it. We don't have to have self love. We don't have to feel self love. It just is. So when you're forced to be present, it is. But when you stay distant, hate grows. Which, yes, is true for everybody and everything in every place. Being divorced from which gets us to place. So place you talk about, as you write about, as another way for us to be alive that we have been separated from in a million different ways. And one of the lines you introduce, the idea of place being something we need to reconnect with in order to be alive, is you say, did you know that birds do not land because they are tired? They know and they have always known that their liberation depends on their ability to recall the ground. I still. I've read it 60 times. I still get. Because it reminded me of immediately, which then you wrote about my. All of my strategies with my therapist and all the people like about when I'm freaking out or any sort of panic or big anxiety, immediately go to. Okay, what's one thing you smell? Tell me what you can hear. Fear. That kind of anxiety or fear is a way of not being alive and a way of returning to life is to be re. Is to remember the place I am in where things are usually okay. Right? And so you say there is a mysterious entanglement between our welfare and our capacity to ground ourselves in a certain place. So can you talk to us? Because we often don't think about where we are at all. So what does place to you have to do with being alone, alive, like being liberated?

[Abby Wambach]

Yeah. I mean, I think it has to do exactly what you were saying with the sensory, the very real sensory. What's one thing you hear? Tell me three things. You see, but for a long time, I kind of was reflecting as if it was only people who were forming me. More than that, I would say circumstances. And when I left home, and, I mean, I didn't go far. I went to school in Pittsburgh. I was born and raised in Pittsburgh, but in very different parts of Pittsburgh. So when I. When I left home for college and I was in this new place, I think I knew that something in me had shifted. But it really wasn't until I started to return home and I, for the first time in my life, had experienced this homecoming that many of us experienced, that I realized just how much of me comes awake depending on the place that I'm in. And I don't think it means I'm faking it at college. It just means I can access. There's an entrance into parts of me that I don't have. I don't have easy access to when I'm in a room full of, you know, academics. But what. But when I would walk the streets of Brookline, when I'm walking down the boulevard, there's some kind of nearness that I'm able to, I don't know, kind of move toward. But I think it's easier not to pay attention. I'm kind of. The jury's out, really, on why this is. I'm sure it has to do with dissociation. And so many people living in their minds are living to kind of play out whatever conversation they thought they were supposed to have, or kind of consumed with each other, consumed with their own thoughts and lack a kind of awareness of, okay, where are the lights in my room? You know, what are the shadows doing to that wall? And it's a very kind of privileged thing to be able to pay attention to. To be able to take a minute and really ground yourself and see where you are and for different people. I think. I'm sure that grounding and that attunement is costly in a different way. And I can say this for myself, not all the. The homecoming. It wasn't all warm, fuzzy feelings. You know, those entrances. It wasn't going to necessarily beautiful places in myself. I was going into hard places and realizing, oh, that's the reason. Maybe that's the reason why you flinch. You know, what happened to that door? You remember someone Pounding on that door. That's why you don't like loud knocks. I'm passing the door. And now I have a little bit more of an awareness for. About who I am in the world.

[Glennon Doyle]

Wow.

[Amanda Doyle]

You're saying you're. It's a way of being alive. Nobody's promising that. Being alive is all touchy feely, good stuff. I mean, I have had moments where I walk back into my childhood home and I find myself in the pantry shoving food in my mouth in the first 20 minutes, and I'm like, how did I like binging like that? And. And I'm 45. Like, I've. It's just wakens. It awakens for. For better or worse, you can be alive. Alive in different places.

[Abby Wambach]

Yes. And it absolutely has to do with your body that I. I've completely resonate with you saying where I just end up a place, and I'm like, how did I get here? I've started to tell myself, cole, if you're not in your body, someone else is. And so who is it? Who is it? You know, how did you get. How did you get here? You know, it's not that you're not just walking around empty. Something is who's at the helm. You know, it's not you. You're not leaving behind an empty vessel. And something about that, I think, has really changed me to think, hello, you know, this is. It's risky. Are you sure? Are you sure you don't want to eat until 6pm Are you sure you want to? You know, because someone else, you know, something else. And I think that that something is probably different for different people, Whether it's capitalism or the patriarchy or. Or whatever, you know, a white supremacy. If we leave our place, if we leave our bodies, if we lose our connection to the sensory, you know, it might seem like survival is what I'm learning. It might seem like survival, but really it's a death, and it's very dangerous. Changes. Changes how. How I relate to it. Now I feel this kind of fierce protection over my body in a way that maybe I didn't before.

[Amanda Doyle]

Mm. One of the many gorgeous things is that it feels like every chapter that you have or every way of being alive is. Seems to be discussed as a way of being personally more alive and then also a way of responsibly living among other people or the planet. That is a shift in our understanding of that thing. So, for example, you talk about place as a way for us to be personally more alive. And we've just discussed that. But you also talk about respecting place in a way that shifts our understanding about our relationship to place. For example, when you fell in love with Wisewood, your home, and you buy this place, you have land ownership, whatever that means. You said of Wisewood, it never felt as if it belonged to us. But my own sense of belonging became magnified. Something was restored in me. I am reconciled to the land by this place and I have known no greater reconciliation to date. And then you go on to describe your ownership of that land being your responsibility to nurture it. Not that this land is mine, but this land is my responsibility to nurture.

[Glennon Doyle]

I love this so much.

[Amanda Doyle]

Can you talk to us about that and that shift and how all of us in this western world, because this is part of the reason why our planet's on fire and everyone's moved off their land, right? So talk to us about that shift in thinking about land and place.

[Abby Wambach]

I was raised in the city, you know, I never, I know people say this. I truly never had an imagination for land ownership. It was the furthest thing from my mind. The reason why we were drawn to the house actually wasn't the land, it was the beautiful brick of the house. And it just happened to come with, you know, eight or so acres. And we were like, what are we gonna do with this? It used to be orchards. It's so interesting the shift that's occurred and really, yeah, the whole household's heart is really toward the land. I started to walk around in the kind of reeds that lead to. We found a pond during the pandemic. We have a pond found on this land, a full on pond. It's not a small thing. I'll walk through the reeds and I'll discover something new or I'll stop at a tree and I'll think, man, you are allowed to be here. And I, and I thought, how interesting that my first thought isn't, I own this, this is yours. I didn't, I mean, I'm, I'm. I really didn't have that thought in my mind. Other people would say that to me, can you believe you own a pond? I thought, that's interesting. That's not really what, that's not really the first thing that came to my mind. I thought, you can be here, you're safe, no one's going to kick you off of this land. Which I think is really, I mean that in me is maybe some of my own formation. But that desire to kind of get away from the idea of owning and possession, I think is far more Rooted in kind of indigenous wisdom than my own. And knowing that this house exists because this land was stolen, that's complicated when you're walking down these halls. And because the house is so old, it was built in 1840, we have some historical documents so we're a little bit closer to the story because we have it in writing. You know, this land was granted to, you know, he who shall not be named for serving in this war. They just gave away land as if it was something to be owned. So here I am kind of walking through this tragedy. I have to find a way to contend with my own like shame, guilt, whatever you want to call it. But I also have to find a way to engage the beauty and the way that the land demands and to kind of take, not completely take the human experience away, but like, are we able to de center humans for just a moment? You know, like we, we truly are small and not in a self deprecating way, not. And not in a degrading way. But there's a smallness to us and there's a youth to us in the grand scheme of history and the cosmos. There's a youth to humanity that I think we're not really aware of because we're kind of just a little bit, I'll say human centered. Whenever I go outside and I'm walking around, walking the perimeter of my house or walking to the land, I need to find a different word besides smallness. But that kind of it's perspective may be a better word. It allows me to connect in a way that I never, I mean, never thought I would. And it doesn't just extend to these like really beautiful landscapes in the pond. Now when I go to the city, I was able to go back to Pittsburgh for a while. I'll look at the buildings and I'll think, what a miracle. How did we, how did we do this? How did we, how are we able to construct these things? There's beauty here, you know, the sidewalk. Not a huge fan of sidewalks. But is there beauty there? Is there history? Are there little marks? So there are people's names written in it. But going back to Wisewood, it's hard to put language to it, but. So this house was. The land was given in 1820, the house was built in 1840. We all know what was happening to my ancestors in 1840 and 1820, right? What? Like when I think about a kind of intergenerational self, not just me, what a beautiful kind of mysterious thing. And I'm not trying to romanticize it, but to think that I now am able to land. Belong to the land that I live on, not out of bondage, that I get to choose that I'm safe, that I'm free to be here. I'm free to leave. But whenever I prune the path, whenever I bend down on the reeds and start picking the reeds to clear the path, I do that out of my own love. It's a very mysterious restoration. I think that happens. I'm all for black land ownership because I've seen it in my own life. I never thought it'd be someone who just, like, sits outside and listens to birds. Like, what. What is that? Who? Why? You know, but there's this connection and there's this responsibility that I feel that I've never. I've never felt before.

[Glennon Doyle]

I was so taken by this part in your book, in that what really jumped out at me was the impermanence of it all. And how. Because as me in my white body, it has been my goal in life to be an owner of things. And this completely shifted my mindset around that. That, oh, no, I don't. And I can't own anything. It is all impermanent, and I will have to let this go. And so the idea of nurturing this thing for whenever I'm here, however long I get to be lucky enough to be on this land, or in your case, at Wisewood, that is my joy, that is my responsibility.

[Amanda Doyle]

And you only take as much also as you can nurture. And you can be in wonder about a huge responsibility which takes us to wonder. Oh, wonder. Cole, your discussion of being alive.

[Cole Arthur Riley]

Through wonder, you talk about how wonder includes the capacity to be in awe of humanity, even your own. Can you talk about that? The way that we have set up our worlds to kind of like an amusement park, where this is stuff that is worthy of wonder. This is just normal stuff that is.

[Amanda Doyle]

And.

[Cole Arthur Riley]

And how you so beautifully integrate that.

[Abby Wambach]

Yes. So when I. I have done some traveling and, you know, I hiked in the Himalayas, I. I try not to brag about it, but, yeah, I hiked. I'm, like, trying to find a different way to say it. I'm like, just say it.

[Amanda Doyle]

Cool. You did that.

[Abby Wambach]

Good job. And a beautiful. One of the most beautiful experiences that I've had. Seeing the snow on the mountains and watching the transition from, like, warmth to cold. So beautiful. I started to review my journal from that trek. It was about three weeks. I was just talking about people. I was. I was writing poetry. And the images were so often about the people that were with me, you know, the image of this young girl picking these purple flowers that would kind of burst through the earth. It's a zoom in moment. I wasn't. I wasn't writing the image of the majesty, the mountaintops. I wrote very little about on the days that we were at a peak and we were camping at a peak. Very little written. So much attention and so much interest in the people that were around me. The people we would bow and say namaste to as we passed. And the tops of their heads, their images that were just as much grounded in, you know, the earth as they were humanity. It makes you wonder, what is it that we see in, like, a landscape that we're so unwilling to see in each other? I had this friend tell me one time. It was he. He was joking, but he said, let's look at each other like we're art. For 30 seconds, everyone look at your neighbor. Like, I'm like, oh, my goodness.

[Amanda Doyle]

It's one of those weird intimacy exercises.

[Abby Wambach]

Yes. Like, no, thank you. I didn't do it, of course, But I started to do it on my own. In practice, I'll find myself just drifting off, staring at someone and thinking, wow, look at the way their hair grows. Or look at those spots. It's very. I mean, if I'm honest, it's difficult to do with myself. But what a practice to believe that whatever is in the mountaintop is also in the face of your neighbor and the face of your child. In the face of the person you love or the person you hate. That there's something beautiful in that.

[Cole Arthur Riley]

Do you think, Cole, that has something to do with the same discussion we were just having about ownership? Because I feel like people and their bucket lists and their acquisitions of places and Majesties, and it's as if collecting done, Hawaii.

[Amanda Doyle]

I've done. Yeah, yeah, yeah.

[Cole Arthur Riley]

We're collecting them for our ownership, for our own portfolios. And so therefore, it has to be things that are on that list and not things that can be found in the everyday. Because that isn't something worthy of ownership and acquisition.

[Abby Wambach]

Yes, I think it's absolutely. I think it's absolutely tied. We're just we, man. Not everyone. I think this of whiteness. I think whiteness loves the conquering of beauty, loves the collecting. I've seen that. I've seen that in white supremacy. I mean, it wants to be supreme. It wants to have the supreme. And. But you see this in whiteness in general, Just like this desire to reach the mountaintop, you know, that's the goal. Here I am. You can reach the mountaintop, and that can be a beautiful thing. Nothing against hikers or people who trek in that way, but what do you feel when you're at the top of. I want to ask people, what do you. You feel when you're at the top of that? Does it feel like a conquering. And why, why. Why do you need to feel like you've conquered something? Or the people who kind of. They. They. They're able to practice wonder, but only so that they can, like you said, acquire it. They want the beauty. They want the beauty for themselves as opposed to, you know, wit. Bearing witness. It's not enough to bear witness. How can I have this? How can I. How can I take. Mm.

[Amanda Doyle]

So the. The discussion of wonder is life changing. And. And there's a. A few different levels of what wonder can do for us and for the world in your discussion of it. And one seems to be a personal liberation, right? A personal way of being alive. And you use the description of. I think you used the Color Purple, right? Talk to us about that iconic moment in the Color Purple and what she was doing, what she was reclaiming in that moment.

[Abby Wambach]

Yeah, that iconic line. I think it pisses God off anytime you walk past the Color Purple and don't appreciate it. I mean, talk about a complicated character. You know, talk about writing a very human character. There's something in. I mean, the story, the Color Purple, if you've read it or if you've watched the film adaptation, so much tragedy, right. It would be very, very easy to reduce that story to mere tragedy. And I think we were inclined to that. Sometimes, especially in relationship to black stories, we're inclined toward the traumatic. I think there's a really sinister curiosity around black death, around black pain. Everyone. I mean, even if you don't necessarily crave it, there's this interest, right? What does it mean to have a spiritual practice that's grounded, that doesn't begin at the site of trauma, but begins at the site of beauty and attentiveness? I mean, how liberating to be able, like I said, to listen to the barn swallows outside of my room instead of getting wrapped up and what you really smart people will think of me, that's a liberating act. That's liberating access that I have to the beauty of the world. That it's not escapism in the way that I think you can use it as. It's not escapism. It's actually really unapologetic presence to the nuance of the world, that there are terrors, you know, but there is also beauty. And to be unapologetic in witnessing that and communicating that, you know, I think is what Alice Walker was doing.

[Amanda Doyle]

Yeah. It's like wonder. Every time we behold. You say, is we behold something, we look at it as a piece of art, or we just feel the aliveness in us that comes when we have wonderful. We are asserting what you say, that we are more than a grotesque collection of traumas. Right. It's like suddenly you are something else. And then you talk about wonder as not only a personal way of being alive, a personal liberation, but a way to save the world, really? Because you talk about. I think you said we can't destroy things, that we're beholding something like that.

[Abby Wambach]

Yeah. I think it's really difficult. I mean, if you're witnessing beauty, I think you're gonna be inclined to protect it. You know, you could be inclined to take ownership over it, claim it, acquire it. But there's this other very true, I think women, us. That wants to protect beautiful things. If you're witnessing beauty in the world, that's what's gonna kind of cultivate a love in you and cultivate this sense of, how can I keep this safe? You know? How do I protect the flame?

[Amanda Doyle]

Yeah. Yeah. I don't know. We went back and forth about the most beautiful lines in this book, and we have 40 million. But one of them has to be the Northern lights are one thing, but when I die, tell them I went to Nome, Alaska, only to find God in a Minecraft parody. And you'll just have to read to understand that. But.

[Cole Arthur Riley]

Oh, burst out crying. Burst out crying when I read that.

[Amanda Doyle]

Yes, she did. Okay. I want to. By the way, Cole, if you ever need a full reading guide of your book, please just email me, because I have all 15. But what we will do is end with calling, because that's the next one. Oh, God. It was just as a complete control freak who was always talking about God and. And not even ever sure she believes in God. Like, I'm just like, am I. What am I talking about? Am I. Am I making all this? Like, I don't know. Okay, so you're talking to your brother about your lucid dreams, okay? And these are dreams in which you are making. You know, you're dreaming. So you're calling the shots in your own dream.

[Abby Wambach]

Yes.

[Amanda Doyle]

Okay. You're changing your dream. You're deciding what's next. You're controlling your dream, and your brother says you live and sleep in control. I want to know how to know. And you say to him, I wanted to know how not to know how to feel like there is a calling from outside of you driving you to that door until you walk through it, like there is no other way. Sometimes you want to believe the dream. I'm not one given to belief. I don't know if I'll ever love anyone as much as I loved you after those lines. Because to me, I just felt like, okay, sure, things are beautiful and magical because I make them that way. Like, I want God this, God that I'm a great PR agent for, to show up and do something so that I will feel called to that and know that I'm not controlling all of this. That magic is real.

[Abby Wambach]

Yes.

[Amanda Doyle]

And that was the first. The first one I ever got like, that was. This one was Abby. When Abby walked into a room and I suddenly, God was like, here she is. And also, you're queer, honey.

[Abby Wambach]

Surprise.

[Amanda Doyle]

Like, I was like, this is a plot twist that I can say for sure I didn't control.

[Cole Arthur Riley]

That was a calling from outside.

[Amanda Doyle]

That was a calling from. But was it. Because then I'm still reading from Cole, right? Then I'm like, you know what? What if it wasn't even. I mean, because one of the things that's so important to me about your work is your refusal to decide whether God is just outside or inside or. Because in the Christian, people get so freaked out. If you ever even begin to consider that the deepest self is God. Do we even have to decide whether it's coming from outside or inside? Or whether it's God on some phone, outside call in the sky, or whether God is the self calling to itself.

[Abby Wambach]

Yeah. Whether going into yourself isn't going toward God, going toward the divine. Howard Thurman talks about that beautifully. I don't know if I quote him in the book, but he talks about that beautifully. The sound of the genuine in you. He says, who are you? You have to find out who your name is. And he connects that to. If you're not, you're just going to end up like some marionette on. You know, on the strings that someone else is. Is pulling. Ultimately, who are you? And. And that call to self being a call toward the divine. I think it's one of those mysterious things that I don't feel pressured to distinguish. You know, if it's true, it's. If it's true, it's true. You know, my dad says this. The truth is the truth, whether or not you're prepared to tell it, or you just tell it. If it's true, it's true. Any kind of fidelity to something that's true in me, I think is a fidelity into. To a truth in the divine and to a truth in who God is. So, yeah, maybe the call. Maybe the call was both coming from inside the house and outside. And there's beauty in both, and you don't need it to come from outside in order for that to be valid. You don't have to wait for that to seem like it's. Although I want that. Yeah, I want the magic. People say they hear God. I'm like, I'm waiting, you know, hasn't. Hasn't yet happened to me, but have I. Have I. Have I met the face of God? You know, have I met the face of God and the person I love? Yeah.

[Amanda Doyle]

You said, I've accepted that the whole of my life will be a pilgrimage toward the sound of the genuine in me. But also, if practiced right, your calling into selfhood may enhance the sound of selfhood in someone else. Meaning, like, this is the kind of God pyramid scheme I can get into, right? Because usually it's like, oh, I'm collecting people for God. And it's just like. Kind of like Mary Kay. It's like a pyramid. You know, I brought him and I brought her, and we're all getting points. But maybe this is a sort of evangelism I can believe in, which is like the closer we get to God, which is the closer we get to our deepest self, frees somebody else to get the closest that they can get to God and to their deepest self. And this is a sort of real ripple liberation.

[Abby Wambach]

Yes. In that speech that Thurman gives the. The sound of the genuine, he gave it to Spelman College. There's this line where he says, it's possible if I go down in me, go toward my true self, if I can go down in me and come up in you, and having made that pilgrimage, I can see myself through your eyes and you can see yourself. And there's this intimacy with the self. There's this intimacy with another person. Like, is that not what love is? You know, I can go down in my true self, come up in you, and make that pilgrimage of mutuality, of mutual love and mutual beholding.

[Amanda Doyle]

You know, mutual beholding.

[Cole Arthur Riley]

And in fact, maybe. Maybe that's the only way, because, as you say. Can you describe your father looking in the mirror and your revelation about what he saw versus what you were able to see?

[Abby Wambach]

Yes. I don't know, maybe someone listening has had. Like, if you. You've seen someone else's face, the mirror, and you just know it's not lining up quite right. And I. I don't remember how old I was, but I had this experience with my dad. He's doing his hair, getting his curls with this vita point. I'm looking at him and I'm. I'm like, do you think that's what you look like? And he's looking at me like, what are you talking about? I'm like, that's not your face. That's not what you. I'm sitting there just. I want to shake him and say, that's not. That's not your face. And what I wanted to say is your. Your face is way better than what that mirror is translating what that mirror is communicating. But instead I just kind of grabbed his face and stared at him in the way that like a very queer little child would do. I just kind of grabbed him and stared and was like, that's not your face. Because, I mean, even with mirrors, you know, you're seeing this projection. You're seeing everything kind of new and out of alignment. It's not actually showing what you truly look like. It's showing an iteration of it maybe, but. But not your true face. And I think, I mean, how mysterious that we were made that we cannot see our own faces. I will never. I will never see my own face the way that you're seeing it.

[Glennon Doyle]

Really.

[Amanda Doyle]

I will never get over it. I will never get over you telling us that we will never see our own faces.

[Glennon Doyle]

It's scary.

[Amanda Doyle]

If you could see me, Cole, like literally crossing my eyes, trying to find some way. How beautiful is that?

[Cole Arthur Riley]

It's the most beautiful thing. We will never see our own faces, which is why we need to see other people's faces for them and why other people need to see our faces for us. And why we need other people to see the face of God. Because God is made in our image, which we are not able to see.

[Abby Wambach]

Yes. I need you, you know, I need you to look at me. You know, for all the people who want to, you know, live in invisibility. All the little children. I needed other people to behold my own face. My dad needs that. You need that. I think that. I mean, that's the best case for belonging. That we have these pseudo wise people who think they can live a solitary life. It's just not true. There's something missing. There's some, you know, people always say you have to know yourself. They Say these things. It's the same with the beauty. They say you have to know yourself. You have to really know yourself before you can be with someone. I'm like, okay, yes. And you have to really know how to be with someone in order to really know yourself. You know, it's not either or. I have to really be able to stand and not cover my face while I'm talking to my spouse. You know, I need to be able to stand before them and have that very, you know, strange and, you know, scary experience of being seen in order for me to go into, you know, our nice little meditation space and then try to encounter myself. It's not how it works. I reject that. I'm a big evangelist for belonging in the sense that I think we were made for that kind of mutual witness.

[Amanda Doyle]

And it's not right that it can't be that we know ourselves before we go knowing anyone else. It's like place. People are like place. They will bring stuff up in us that we don't even have never seen of ourselves before. They will show us part of our face that we have never seen before. Every new person, you cannot know yourself. Just like every place brings us, brings a new part of ourselves out. Every person does. That's why it requires presence and aliveness.

[Glennon Doyle]

It's like the first time I've struggled with faith, religion, Christianity, being brought up in the Catholic Church, being a little queer kid, didn't have the language for it until I was in my teenage years. And Glennon has allowed me, and I'm now kind of putting these pieces together throughout this conversation. You've allowed me to see God because I see it in your face. And it has allowed me to feel God inside of me. And I don't know, I just think that this is one of the most beautiful things that a person can experience. Especially when you feel like you've have. You have to reject God because they rejected you first. I'm like, no, I reject you first. And so to be able to come back into it in a witnessing way, when I look at my spouse and I can see God, I can see the divine in her. And it's my job to kind of mirror that, for lack of a better term right now. Back to you.

[Amanda Doyle]

You just mentioned belonging, which is a whole nother unbelievable way of being alive that you discuss in the book. Okay? And you said, each year, I know love and belonging. A love that does not require a sacrifice at the alt of acceptance. Pod Squad. Did you hear that? Belonging is a love that does not require A sacrifice at the altar of acceptance. What parts of yourself, Cole, do you continue to feel that the world wants you to sacrifice at the altar of acceptance?

[Abby Wambach]

I mean, my blackness, my queerness. But I mean in a different way. I think my silence, my nature, my person, my disposition. You know, I'm a writer. I'm doing podcasts. How can you be interesting? You know, my intellect. But there are so many. Not all belonging is good. Belonging. And I have belonged to spiritual spaces that were so concerned with what I thought about God, with any given belief or any given doctrine or creed that if you. If you fall out of line, then you're bad. You're the bad one, and your belonging is at stake. How terrifying for young people trying to grapple and make sense of who they are in the world and who their people are in the world to demand a kind of belief that means you belong. So, anyways, I've decided that if it's a kind of belonging that demands I believe any given thing, I don't want it, because I know what that does to us. I know we'll say that we believe all kinds of things if it means that we can have a place at the table, a place, you know, a warmth. If it means we can have company, you know, everyone's looking for that. So I'm very skeptical of spiritual spaces in particular that are like that. And I think that's why many Christian spaces probably wouldn't claim me even, because I don't have an allegiance. I don't have an allegiance to Christianity that terrifies people.

[Amanda Doyle]

Prophet has nowhere to lay her head. Cole. The prophet has nowhere to lay her head.

[Abby Wambach]

I have an allegiance to the questions of what it means to be human and what it means to be a spiritual human in the world. And Christianity is one way I make sense of that. And I might wake up some days and think, yeah, God exists. Maybe it has something. And I might wake up many other days and think, no way. But my fidelity is to the questions. To the questions. It's finding the people who are okay with that. Not just okay with that, but welcome that and know that they actually need that in order to be whole and not whole, be full themselves.

[Amanda Doyle]

Ooh, be full. I love that. Cole. Arthur Riley, thank you. Just. Thank you.

[Abby Wambach]

Thank you.

[Amanda Doyle]

The rest of you, your next right thing is to get the next right book. And you might want to do this, because I don't know that there'll be another one for the next decade. The next right book, which must belong in any. Any human being who. Who loves life, who loves other people, who loves spirituality, who has a fidelity to the questions. Just gonna say that must have this one, this here flesh Cole Arthur Riley thank you Cole. Thanks for helping us do the hard things, the hardest thing, which is fully being alive.

[Abby Wambach]

Thanks for inviting me into your space and trusting me with your people.

[Amanda Doyle]

The rest of you get the book and then we'll see you here next time. Bye. If this podcast means something to you, it would mean so much to us if you'd be willing to take 30 seconds to do these three things. First, can you please follow or subscribe to We Can Do Hard Things? Following the POD helps you because you'll never miss an episode, and it helps us because you'll never miss an episode. To do this, just go to the We Can Do Hard Things show page on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Odyssey, or wherever you listen to podcast podcasts and then just tap the plus sign in the upper right hand corner or click on Follow. This is the most important thing for the pod. While you're there, if you'd be willing to give us a five star rating and review and share an episode you loved with a friend, we would be so grateful. We appreciate you very much. We Can Do Hard Things is created and hosted by Glennon Doyle, Abby Wambach, and Amanda Doyle in partnership with Odyssey. Our Executive Executive Producer is Jenna Wise Berman and the show is produced by Lauren Legrasso, Allison Schott, Dina Kleiner, and Bill Schultz.