Podcast Summary: "We're Here to Help" Episode 136 - Buttertoes with Catherine Reitman and Arden Myrin
Release Date: December 2, 2024
Hosts: Jake Johnson & Gareth Reynolds
Guest Helpers: Catherine Reitman & Arden Myrin
1. Show Update: Potential Hiatus Announcement
At the beginning of the episode (01:28), hosts Jake Johnson and Gareth Reynolds address the audience regarding the show's current status. They discuss a recent feud and the increasing demands on their schedules, particularly Gareth's involvement in a time-consuming movie project. This conversation leads to the revelation that they may be taking a temporary break from producing new episodes to prevent burnout and maintain the quality of their content.
Notable Quotes:
- Gareth Reynolds (02:19): "Who do the helpers call when they require help?"
- Kevin Bartelt (05:04): "I never wanted to repeat stuff over and over."
The hosts express gratitude towards their listeners and assure them that they will consider returning based on listener interest and their personal capacities.
2. Caller Sari: Navigating "Buttertoes" Insecurities
Caller Profile:
- Name: Sari
- Age: 27
- Location: Boise, Idaho
Sari reaches out with concerns about her toenails, describing them as "butter toes." She shares her history of having had toenail removal procedures due to severe nail issues, leading to unattractive and messy appearances. This has caused her significant insecurity, especially in her budding romantic relationship.
Transcript Excerpts:
- Sari (12:09): "I've got butter toes. My nails were really bad when I was younger..."
- Gareth Reynolds (14:01): "Sari from Boise."
3. Advice from Hosts and Guest Catherine Reitman
Jake, Gareth, and guest Catherine Reitman offer Sari practical and emotional support to overcome her insecurities. They emphasize self-acceptance and encourage her not to dwell on perceived flaws.
Key Advice Points:
- Normalize Insecurities: Acknowledging that everyone has physical insecurities.
- Avoid Overemphasis: Suggesting that not making a big deal out of her toes will prevent her boyfriend from fixating on them.
- Practical Solutions: Recommending pedicures or subtle enhancements like toe jewelry to boost confidence.
Notable Quotes:
- Gareth Reynolds (16:45): "If he has an issue with your toes, I promise you he's the wrong guy."
- Kevin Bartelt (20:00): "Don't let your anxiety get into his head and don't turn this into like this show the voice where you turn around and he has to form an opinion."
4. Second Caller Selena: Office Sponge Dilemma
Caller Profile:
- Name: Selena
- Age: 29
- Location: Tuileries County, California
Selena calls in with a different type of issue—dealing with a communal sponge in her office's break room. She describes the sponge as gross and is reluctant to use it, considering bringing her own but concerned about appearing weird.
Advice from Hosts and Guest Arden Myrin:
- Decoy Solutions: Suggesting the use of a personal scrubber hidden alongside a communal one to balance hygiene preferences without standing out.
- Practical Implementations: Recommending creative storage solutions like waterproof totes or designated personal containers to maintain cleanliness discreetly.
Notable Quotes:
- Arden Marine (35:37): "People will talk shit about you. But I think there will also be people that admire you."
- Gareth Reynolds (38:32): "I think you could stash the bag with the decoy scrubber in the kitchen somewhere where no one goes..."
5. Sari's Follow-Up: Success in Acceptance
In a heartfelt follow-up (50:01), Sari shares her positive experience after applying the hosts' advice. Having moved to Los Angeles to be closer to her boyfriend, she reveals that her relationship progressed without any issues related to her toes. Her boyfriend openly expressed that he isn't bothered by her 'butter toes,' validating the hosts' guidance on self-acceptance and confidence.
Key Takeaways:
- Self-Love Wins: Embracing one's insecurities can lead to healthier relationships.
- Confidence is Key: Believing in oneself diminishes the power of perceived flaws.
- Validation from Experience: Real-life application of advice leads to meaningful positive outcomes.
Notable Quotes:
- Sari (51:32): "I just had to take a leap of faith and trust you guys, because you were right."
- Gareth Reynolds (52:23): "It's a good lesson for really anybody who has a hang up about a physical thing for the most part, which is that nobody notices this thing more than you."
6. Conclusion: Empowerment and Encouragement
The episode wraps up with the hosts reiterating the importance of self-acceptance and not letting insecurities hinder personal relationships. They commend Sari for her courage and encourage listeners to share their own stories of overcoming similar challenges.
Final Thoughts:
- Self-Acceptance: Essential for personal growth and healthy relationships.
- Community Support: Listener interactions highlight the show's supportive community.
- Future of the Show: Despite potential hiatus, the hosts express optimism for future episodes based on audience engagement.
Notable Quotes:
- Gareth Reynolds (53:00): "Your toes are fine, you should accept them if your boyfriend doesn't accept your toes. What a weirdo."
- Kevin Bartelt (54:43): "What a blessing to hear that. Good for you."
Featured Guests:
- Catherine Reitman: Actress, writer, and director known for her work on "Schitt's Creek."
- Arden Myrin: Comedian and actress recognized for her comedic roles and performances.
Final Notes:
"We're Here to Help" continues its tradition of blending humor with heartfelt advice, addressing a wide range of listener concerns with authenticity and empathy. Episode 136 highlights the show's ability to empower individuals to embrace their imperfections and fosters a supportive environment for personal growth.
Timestamp Guide: