Going to Court - Talina Zar BONUS

Summary

Detailed Summary of “Going to Court - Talina Zar BONUS” from What Happened to Talina Zar

What Happened to Talina Zar is a gripping podcast series by iHeartPodcasts that delves into the mysterious disappearance of Talina Zar during the COVID-19 lockdown. This bonus episode, titled “Going to Court - Talina Zar BONUS,” released on July 24, 2025, provides an in-depth look into the first day of court for Corey Bommily Adams, the woman accused of attempting to murder Sherry and Mike Ziegler and later implicated in Talina Zar’s disappearance. Hosted by Melissa Jeltson and featuring investigative reporter Jess Trevino, the episode offers a comprehensive overview of the proceedings, the evidence presented, and the emotional toll on those involved.

1. Introduction to the Court Proceedings

The episode opens with Jess Trevino, the internet sleuth behind the podcast, attending Corey Bommily Adams' trial in Madison, Wisconsin. Jess recounts her anticipation and the significance of witnessing Corey's first day in court.

Jess Trevino [03:11]: "Jess Trevino, the Internet sleuth who spent the past five years investigating the disappearance of Talina Czar and digging into the background of Corey Bommily, the woman accused of killing her."

2. Entering the Courtroom

Jess describes her initial emotions upon entering the austere Dane County Courthouse, highlighting the tense atmosphere and her focus on Corey’s demeanor.

Melissa Jeltson [02:54]: "She seems smaller, older, but kind of smug still... I thought she was looking at me."

3. Courtroom Dynamics and Key Figures

The narrative introduces key individuals present in the courtroom, including Sherry and Mike Ziegler, the victims, and law enforcement officers from Wagner County, Oklahoma, who testify during the trial.

Court Clerk [04:29]: "The case before us today is entitled the State of Wisconsin versus Corey Bomily Adams."

4. Prosecution’s Case: Attempted Murder in 2014

The prosecution lays out their case, detailing the 2014 incident where the Zieglers returned from vacation to find signs of a break-in and discovery of ricin, a deadly toxin. Testimonies from Deputy Zach and Lieutenant Danny Elliott reveal Corey's criminal activities, including credit card fraud and attempts to poison her neighbors.

Sherry Ziegler [06:12]: "It's 10 years and it's taken the toll on us a little bit... I will be so happy and done with."

5. Evidence Presented

Key evidence includes ricin traces found in the Ziegler residence, recipes for ricin found on Corey's computer, and testimonies from Corey's ex-husband, Alexander Adams, who claims Corey confessed to poisoning intentions.

Danny Elliott [20:22]: "That is a small safe that was located in a bedroom closet."

6. Defense’s Arguments: Questioning the Prosecution’s Claims

Corey's defense team challenges the prosecution’s narrative by suggesting that Alexander Adams had the motive and opportunity to commit the crimes, casting doubt on Corey’s sole culpability. They argue the evidence is circumstantial and heavily reliant on Adams' credibility.

Defense Attorney [33:10]: "The state must prove that Ms. Corey's intent to murder the Zieglers exists, which there is no proof of."

7. Witness Testimonies and Credibility

Alexander Adams, Corey’s ex-husband, plays a pivotal role as a key witness for the prosecution. His testimony regarding Corey’s alleged confession is scrutinized, with the defense pointing out the lack of formal immunity agreements that might have influenced his statements.

Alexander Adams [22:33]: "When she told me she'd done this, I looked at her and I said, that's attempted murder..."

8. Corey’s Silence in Court

Despite the opportunity, Corey chooses not to testify, leaving the prosecution to rely solely on witness testimonies and physical evidence. This decision intensifies the courtroom drama as the jury deliberates on the presented facts without hearing Corey's side.

Court Clerk [32:34]: "I will not testify."

9. Verdict and Immediate Reactions

After four and a half days of testimony, the jury swiftly deliberates and finds Corey guilty of two counts of attempted first-degree intentional homicide. Jess Trevino recounts Melissa Jeltson’s exhilarated reaction to the verdict, despite not being present in the courtroom during the final moments.

Melissa Jeltson [40:11]: "I am so psyched... This really worked out. I feel like we got some... It’s like the first step in getting justice for Selena."

10. Impact on the Investigation into Talina Zar’s Disappearance

The conviction of Corey Bommily Adams marks a significant milestone but also serves as a precursor to Talina Zar’s impending trial. Jess Trevino expresses her intention to attend Talina's trial in Oklahoma, although she grapples with personal challenges due to negative online feedback.

Jess Trevino [42:39]: "I struggle with some of the Reddit stuff and some of the shitty comments... I don't want to stop talking about it, I’ll do it for them and for her."

11. Support from Zar’s Family

Despite online harassment, Jess receives encouragement from Talina Zar’s sister Cheryl and her mother, reinforcing her commitment to seeking justice.

Melissa Jeltson [43:12]: "Knowing that they think it's okay made this better for me... I am for them and for her."

12. Looking Ahead: Sentencing and Future Trials

Corey's sentencing hearing is scheduled for August, where she faces up to 60 years per charge. Additionally, Corey is expected to return to Oklahoma to stand trial for the murder of Talina Zar, setting the stage for the next chapter in this unfolding saga.

Jess Trevino [41:27]: "Corey will be sent back to Oklahoma to stand trial for the murder of Talina Zar."

Notable Quotes with Timestamps

• Jess Trevino [03:11]: "I'm here for a lot to report on the trial because it's connected to Talina's case."

• Sherry Ziegler [06:12]: "We've told the story many, many times... After a while, once the trial is over with, I will be so happy and done with."

• Melissa Jeltson [08:44]: "I'm not saying it's not... Yeah, the mullet, the jacket. I'm nitpicking her."

• Jess Trevino [27:06]: "The jury hears that the sample Sherry sent to Danny Elliott tests positive for ricin."

• Melissa Jeltson [40:11]: "This really worked out... I feel like this is the beginning steps of it."

Concluding Thoughts

“Going to Court - Talina Zar BONUS” provides a compelling snapshot of a pivotal moment in the quest for justice surrounding Talina Zar’s disappearance. Through detailed courtroom coverage, witness testimonies, and the emotional journeys of those involved, the episode deepens the mystery and highlights the intricate web of evidence and personal stakes. Jess Trevino’s dedication as an internet sleuth underscores the power of grassroots investigations in uncovering the truth, even as she faces her own challenges. As the podcast series progresses, listeners are left eagerly anticipating the next developments in Talina Zar’s case and the ultimate resolution of Corey Bommily Adams’ legal battles.

Transcript

[Melissa Jeltson]

This is an iHeart podcast.

[Unknown Advertiser]

Let's be real Life happens, kids spill, pets shed and accidents are inevitable. Find a sofa that can keep [e-mail] Starting at just $699, our sofas are fully machine washable inside and out so you can say goodbye to stains and hello to worry free living. Made with liquid and stain resistant fabrics, they're kid proof, pet friendly and built for everyday life. Plus, changeable fabric covers let you refresh your sofa whenever you want. Neat flexibility Our modular design lets you rearrange your sofa anytime to fit your space, whether it's a growing family room or a cozy apartment. Plus, they're earth friendly and trusted by over 200,000 happy customers. It's time to upgrade to a stress free mess proof sofa. Visit washablesofas.com today and save that's washablesofas.com offers are subject to change and certain restrictions may apply.

[Lauren Vogelbaum]

This episode is brought to you by Hendrix Gin. I'm Lauren Vogelbaum, host of the podcast Brain Stuff, where we are serious about curiosity and so is Hendrick's. Their signature gin is infused with rose and cucumber and their master distiller is always crafting limited releases that riff on.

[Jess Trevino]

Those flavors so that you can create something new.

[Lauren Vogelbaum]

Hendrix is the refreshingly curious choice for marvelous summer cocktails. To learn more about Hendrix and to find more cocktail recipes, visit hendrixgin.com US drink responsibly Hendrix Gin 44% alcohol by volume 2025 imported by William Gratton Sons.

[Unknown Advertiser]

Incorporated, New York, NY Let your imagination take flight with an AI powered PC from Lenovo. Whether it's creating digital art, designing new software, or building a portfolio for a Future career, our PCs are powered by Intel Core Ultra processors to help students unlock smarter learning, unleash their creativity. That's the power of Lenovo. With intel inside, all you have to do is choose the one that fits your passion. Head to Lenovo.com to shop AI PCs and find your perfect companion. Plus, get 5% off when you create an education account.

[Jess Trevino]

This message comes from Greenlight. Ready to start talking to your kids about financial literacy? Meet Greenlight, the debit card and money app that teaches kids and teens how to earn, save, spend wisely, and invest with your guardrails in place. With Greenlight, you can send money to kids quickly, set up chores, automate allowance, and keep an eye on what your kids are spending with real time notifications. Join millions of parents and kids building healthy financial habits together on Greenlight. Get started risk [e-mail] iheart tell me how it felt walking into the courtroom. And then I saw your eyes go up when you saw her. Just tell me about that moment of noticing when she entered the room.

[Melissa Jeltson]

She seems smaller, older, but kind of smug still. I mean, I thought she looked kind of like she thinks she's gonna get away with it. I don't know. I thought she was looking at me. I turned to you and I said, I think she's looking at me.

[Jess Trevino]

I'm walking back from court with Jess Trevino, the Internet sleuth who spent the past five years investigating the disappearance of Talina Czar and and digging into the background of Corey Bommily, the woman accused of killing her. Jess has longed to confront Corey and to see her held accountable for the crimes Jess believes she has committed. And this hot summer day in Madison, Wisconsin is her very first taste of that.

[Melissa Jeltson]

To know what I know about her and then to see her, my heart quickened a little bit. And then as I sat there, I just kept staring at her, waiting for her to turn, thinking like, is she thinking about what's going to happen in Oklahoma?

[Jess Trevino]

From I Heart Podcasts I'm Melissa Jeltson and this is a bonus episode of what Happened to Talina Zara, Corey's first day in court.

[Court Clerk]

The case before us today is entitled the State of Wisconsin versus Corey Bomily Adams.

[Jess Trevino]

It's Monday, June 23rd, 2025, and I'm in Madison, Wisconsin to cover a case you've heard about if you've followed this podcast. This is not the trial for the murder of Talina Zar that's yet to take place. Instead, it's Corey's trial for the attempted murder of Sherry and Mike Ziegler using homemade ricin back in 2014. I'm here for a lot of to report on the trial because it's connected to Talina's case, but also to meet some of the people I've written about over the years but haven't met in person. Like two of the officers from Wagner, Oklahoma. They're here too.

[Court Clerk]

Please state your name for the record.

[Danny Elliott]

Spelling it Danny Elliott. D A N N Y E L L I O T T I am a lieutenant with the Wagner County Sheriff's Office in Oklahoma. My name is Joel J O E L Weber W E B E R.

[Court Clerk]

Okay, council, go ahead.

[Jess Trevino]

Jess and I are sitting in a windowless courtroom in the Dane County Courthouse, an austere eight story building that makes me feel like we're waiting to update our driver's licenses.

[Unknown Advertiser]

Right.

[Jess Trevino]

Rather than observe an attempted murder trial, I have to say, for all our excitement and anticipation to be here, we're among only a handful of other people in the audience. But importantly, sitting just in front of us are Sherry and Mike Ziegler, the victims at the center of this case. I had spoken to Sherry earlier on the phone.

[Sherry Ziegler]

It's 10 years and it's taken the toll on us a little bit, you know, to keep going through it over and over. That's why it was hard for me to agree on a time to even talk to you about it.

[Jess Trevino]

The trial is expected to last about a week, and over the course of the next few days, Sherry and Mike will have to rehash and relive the trauma that began almost a decade ago, but only recently came into full focus. Sherry and Mike's testimony is barred from being recorded. From our previous conversation, I know she's been nervous about this case finally going to trial. She both wants it to happen, to put an end to this chapter of her life, but is also dreading having to go through it.

[Sherry Ziegler]

We've told the story many, many times because there's a lot of people we met and let you know. I heard about it and want to hear all the gruesome details and it's hard to talk about. After a while, once the trial is over with, I will be so happy and done with. And then she goes back to Oklahoma, stands at trial, and hopefully spend the rest of her life in prison or worse.

[Jess Trevino]

But until then, Sherry just has to sit and face the person who she believes tried to kill her. Jess is also here in the courtroom. She drove in from her home in Minnesota, a four and a half hour trek, leaving her family behind and taking off work to be here to be in the same room with Corey, a person who has loomed large in Jess world and this podcast.

[Melissa Jeltson]

I've had this image in my head of this. Not a literal monster, but to just go through this whole thing and know the things she's done. I had just a different image of what she would still look like. And it felt kind of surreal, kind of intense for a little bit. And I kept. I got a little nervous when she first came in.

[Prosecutor]

All right, so journey.

[Melissa Jeltson]

I felt zero sympathy for her. In fact, all I could think the whole time was, I'm looking at her hair and I'm like, Corey and her fucking mullet. I mean, she's still rocking it and it's terrible.

[Jess Trevino]

Well, she probably doesn't have a hairdresser.

[Melissa Jeltson]

When she had one it was terrible. Which is small in comparison, right? I'm not saying it's not. I'm just. Yeah, the mullet, the jacket. I'm nitpicking her, which I normally. Okay, I'm not gonna lie. I probably do nitpick people sometimes. But I don't know. I don't like anything about her. So I didn't feel any sympathy.

[Jess Trevino]

Corey is seated at a table with her two lawyers on the opposite side of the room from us. She's wearing glasses and dressed in plain clothes. A blazer and blue collared shirt. I'd seen photos and heard about her physical presence from the Wagner neighbors. She was described over and over as physically strong and capable. A workhorse who easily erected fences, managed livestock, and fixed things around the house. It's hard to square that description with the woman in front of us. Who looks rather small and unremarkable. Corey, too, has been waiting for this moment. She's been incarcerated since her arrest for Talina's murder in January 2021. In court, she's mostly quiet. Occasionally whispering something to her attorneys. And yet we all, Jess, the Zieglers and me, can't help but stare. What unfolds during the court proceedings are two versions of the same story. The story told by the state, the.

[Court Clerk]

Prosecutors are Matthew Mosher and Jack Schneider.

[Jess Trevino]

Is probably pretty familiar to you by now. It starts in 2014, when the Zieglers go on vacation and come home to a mess. Weird powder sprinkled about their house. And soon they notice that things are missing. A safe and also a credit card, which someone had been using. The deputy who goes to the Ziegler's house. Testifies that by the time he looked into the robbery and the fraud. Sherry had done quite a bit of her own amateur sleuthing.

[Prosecutor]

When you had contact with Sherry, did Sherri indicate to you if she had done anything herself. To potentially investigate who would use this card?

[Jess Trevino]

She had done some groundwork on it. Based on the fraudulent credit card statement that they had.

[Danny Elliott]

I think she was able to view.

[Prosecutor]

A picture or some video through one of the locations.

[Jess Trevino]

From the footage, Sherry could see exactly who was using her credit card.

[Prosecutor]

Do you recall her indicating to you. That the person she thought might have used the credit card. Was her neighbor, who she knew as Deb?

[Jess Trevino]

Yes.

[Prosecutor]

Did you ultimately follow up based on information Sharon Ziegler gave you. And determined that the person she was calling dead. Was Corey Bommelly Adams?

[Jess Trevino]

I did, yes. Corey is ultimately convicted of using Sherry's credit card. Wisconsin police never find the missing Safe. And the strange debris is written off as a prank. Sherry told me the deputy didn't even collect any of it for evidence.

[Sherry Ziegler]

I actually did show him the sample of that kitty litter stuff that we had collected. And he goes, yeah, it looks like kitty litter oil. Dry. Yeah, I don't know what it is. And just kind of brushed it off and left. You know, he just didn't do anything more.

[Jess Trevino]

On the stand, the prosecutor asks the deputy about this.

[Prosecutor]

Deputy Zach. Hey, you now learned that some of the powder left behind in the Ziegler residents tested positive for ricin.

[Jess Trevino]

I did.

[Prosecutor]

Had you known it was potentially a toxic substance at the time, would you likely have sought to collect anything that was left?

[Jess Trevino]

Absolutely. The jury hears that the investigation into the incident with the Zieglers is closed after Corey's conviction for credit card fraud. That is until 2020, when Corey comes in contact with police in Oklahoma.

[Sherry Ziegler]

All of a sudden, I get a phone call out of the blue from this gentleman asking questions about Corey. And I was really hesitant to say too much about it because I didn't know if this was something that Corey was putting us up to, to get slander on us or, you know, I mean, I just did not trust this woman. I lost trust in a lot of people a lot of things after that.

[Jess Trevino]

When you were watching Corey today, how would you describe her demeanor while she was observing the court proceedings?

[Melissa Jeltson]

She seemed really calm to me. I didn't notice any fidgeting or I noticed a lot of looking around just to see. But I wanted to see if she looked at Sherri when she walked by. And I noticed that she kind of turned forward and didn't even make eye contact.

[Jess Trevino]

The trial moves along relatively slowly. On day two, the police from Oklahoma are called to testify. Important note here. The jury is never told that Corey is charged with murder in another case. They are only told that in 2020, she came in contact with these authorities in Oklahoma who were investigating a different incident. So they have to keep their answers pretty vague. They can't say they spent almost a year playing cat and mouse with Corey, trying to collect enough evidence to put her behind bars. The jury is unaware of any of this. You might recall that we previously used a voice actor to read statements by detective Joel Weber, the lead investigator in the disappearance of Talina czar. Now you can hear his actual voice as he's questioned by the prosecutor.

[Unknown Advertiser]

Time for a sofa upgrade. Visit washablesofas.com and discover Annabe. Where designer style meets budget friendly prices. With sofas starting at $699. Annabe brings you the ultimate in furniture innovation with a modular design that allows you to rearrange your space effortlessly. Perfect for both small and large spaces, Anibe is the only machine washable sofa inside and out. Say goodbye to stains and messes with liquid and stain resistant fabrics that make cleaning easy. Liquid simply slides right off. Designed for custom comfort, our high resilience foam lets you choose between a sink in feel or a supportive memory foam blend. Plus our pet friendly stain resistant fabrics ensure your sofa stays beautiful for years. Don't compromise quick quality for price. Visit washablesofas.com to upgrade your living space today with no risk returns and a 30 day money back guarantee. Get up to 60% off plus free shipping and free returns. Shop now at washablesofas.com Offers are subject to change and certain restrictions may apply.

[Jess Trevino]

There's a time and a place for filet of fish, but breakfast is for sausage biscuits. McDonald's breakfast comes first.

[Howie Mandel]

I can't tell you how often I hear, oh, I'm a little ocd. I like things neat. That's not ocd. I'm Howie Mandel and I know this because I have ocd. Actual OCD causes relentless, unwanted thoughts. What if I did something terrible and forgot? What if I'm a bad person? Why am I thinking this terrible thing? It makes you question absolutely everything and you'll do anything to feel better. OCD is debilitating, but it's also highly treatable with the right kind of therapy. Regular talk therapy doesn't cut it. OCD needs specialized therapy. That's why I want to tell you about NO cd. NOCD is the world's largest virtual therapy provider for ocd. Their licensed therapists provide specialized therapy virtually and it's covered by insurance for over 155 million Americans. If you think you might be struggling with OCD, visit nocd.com to schedule a free 15 minute call and learn more. That's n o c d.com Imagine you're.

[Lauren Vogelbaum]

In a deep, dreamy sleep. You're at work, but instead of one of you, there are suddenly two, then three, then ten, then 100, until a thousand of you are working to reach your goal. Now imagine it's not a dream, because what's actually happening while you sleep is the power of agentforce, a limitless digital workforce independently thinking, acting and solving complex tasks on your behalf around the clock and elevating only what needs your attention. No more time consuming, busy work, just the really important stuff, like making happier customers. So while you're dreaming about flying, missing a flight, or being naked in front of a crowd. AgentForce is working to make you a lot more efficient. Like a thousand times more efficient. That's AgentForce, the powerful AI from Salesforce.

[Prosecutor]

Back in April of 2020, did you become involved in an investigation of Wagner County, Oklahoma that resulted in you having contact with the person identified as Corey Bommelly Adams?

[Danny Elliott]

Yes.

[Prosecutor]

Do you see Ms. Bomblely Adams in court today?

[Jess Trevino]

I do.

[Prosecutor]

Could you point her out and describe where she's sitting and what she's wearing? The right side of the table in.

[Danny Elliott]

Front of me and looks like a white blazer.

[Prosecutor]

I guess the record reflect the identification.

[Jess Trevino]

The prosecutor brings up Weber's interview with Corey on May 9, 2020, when he asked her about the circumstances surrounding the credit card fraud. In episode four, you heard a recreation of that interview based on transcripts at trial. The state played the real version. My neighbor, my male neighbor and I.

[Sherry Ziegler]

Were very good friends and my husband.

[Jess Trevino]

And I spent every penny we had to move to Wisconsin and they went.

[Sherry Ziegler]

Through a tough time where we didn't have much money. He gave me this wife's card to use.

[Jess Trevino]

His what card?

[Sherry Ziegler]

His wife's card.

[Jess Trevino]

Oh, his wife's card. Okay to use. And said go get yourself some groceries.

[Sherry Ziegler]

You know, go fill your check with pass and it's good you can pay to that.

[Jess Trevino]

Well, the wife was jealous with him and I for no reason and she.

[Sherry Ziegler]

Had a tenere and she pressed charges because I used her credit card.

[Jess Trevino]

He stood behind her.

[Sherry Ziegler]

I didn't.

[Jess Trevino]

I still like the guy.

[Sherry Ziegler]

I still think he's a big guy.

[Jess Trevino]

I just like she's a big girl. I'm sitting behind the Zieglers while This video from 2020 plays in court as they listen to Corey tell yet another version of the events of 2014. Back then, Corey claimed in court she'd found the credit card on the ground and used it. Of course, Sherry believes neither story is the truth. I watch her shake her head in frustration, clench her jaw. Another Wagner cop, Danny Elliott, testifies about finding castor beans which can be used to make ricin in a safe in Corey's possession.

[Prosecutor]

Lieutenant Elliott, I'm showing you it's marked as Exhibit 38. What do you recognize Exhibit 38 to be?

[Danny Elliott]

That is a small safe that was located in a bedroom closet.

[Prosecutor]

I'd like to ask you some questions about this safe. When this was located in Ms. Bommily Adams residence on May 29, did she make any statements in your presence about this item?

[Danny Elliott]

Something to the effect of it's an old safe, that she didn't even have the key to it anymore.

[Prosecutor]

At some point were you able to locate a key for the safe?

[Danny Elliott]

Yes, very quickly.

[Prosecutor]

I'm next showing you what's been received in evidences exhibit 40. Are these other items that were found inside that safe?

[Jess Trevino]

Yes, the mags of seeds, the bag of castor beans. The Wagner cops also bring up the recipe they found on Corey's computer on how to make ricin. The prosecutors asked the Wagner police about a tip they received. A tip we mentioned briefly in the podcast, but was a significant piece of the investigators puzzle.

[Prosecutor]

At some point also, had you or Deputy Weber received essentially some of the reports or information about the case from Alexander Adams?

[Danny Elliott]

I believe Investigator Weber did, yes.

[Prosecutor]

Had you become aware that Alexander Adams was the ex husband of Cory Bommelley Adams during this case? Yes.

[Jess Trevino]

You may remember Alexander Adams, Corey's ex, who goes by Alec. He's a Celtic musician who first connected Corey and Talina at Gorefest in 2020. After Talina went missing, he contacted Wagner police and told them that Corey had previously admitted to him that she tried to poison their neighbors in Wisconsin. At trial, Alec is a key witness for the prosecution. On the stand. He's soft spoken and wears a black suit jacket against a plum purple button down shirt. His hair is gray and thinning on top and a long braid drapes over his shoulder. The prosecutor asks Alec about the events of 2014 and why he didn't come forward at the time.

[Prosecutor]

Mr. Adams, in terms of when Ms. Bomily disclosed the poisoning issue to you, did you have any concerns for whether you would be in trouble?

[Danny Elliott]

Yes.

[Prosecutor]

Why was that?

[Danny Elliott]

Well, when she told me she'd done this, I looked at her and I said, that's attempted murder and I am not good with that. Her reply was, you can't say anything about it because both of us will be arrested and the animals put to sleep. At the time we had 50, almost 50, maybe a few more rescue animals.

[Prosecutor]

How did that affect you in terms of that statement being made to you by Ms. Pomelee Adams?

[Danny Elliott]

That was terrifying and very, very successful in silencing me.

[Jess Trevino]

Alec goes on to say he also reached out directly to the Zieglers in 2020, an act he didn't feel he could have done earlier for fear of retribution from Corey.

[Prosecutor]

What was the purpose of you contacting the Zieglers?

[Danny Elliott]

I thought at that time that I might have, I might be safe to at least let them know that if they had found any of that Powder in the house, if they still had some. I told them to get it checked because it could very well be ricin. I just thought they should know in case anything might have come up, like, you know, kidney trouble or something like that. And I thought at least this way, you know, they could maybe do something.

[Jess Trevino]

As Alex speaks, my eyes drift back over to Corey. I'm curious if I'll see some sort of reaction, a furrow of a brow or maybe a wince. And she's staring him down. Silent but intense. During Danny Elliott's testimony, he explains that after getting the tip from Alec and finding the castor beans, they too felt compelled to reach out to Sherry Ziegler. In the summer of 2020.

[Prosecutor]

What was the reason for contacting the Zieglers?

[Danny Elliott]

Well, it was curiosity at first. We had got the reports that there was some white substance that was spread during the burglary of the Zieglers. We'd found the castor beans. I know eventually the computer showed the recipe for the ricin. So I was very curious to find out if that substance could have possibly been. And based on what Alexander was saying, if it was possibly ricin. She said that she didn't have any of the substance. A short time later, she contacted me back directly and said that she had went through, I believe it's her socks and underwear drawer and shook everything out and sure enough, found a sample of it.

[Prosecutor]

Did you have any discussion with Ms. Siegler about her sending you that substance?

[Jess Trevino]

Yeah.

[Danny Elliott]

I told her at that point, and I didn't really know what to do with it. But I told her to put some gloves on, put it in a Ziploc bag and overnight it to me.

[Prosecutor]

With the benefit of hindsight, how would you evaluate that decision?

[Danny Elliott]

Yeah, that wasn't my finest thought process. We don't deal with a lot of rice in Wagner County.

[Jess Trevino]

I try not to laugh. It's a brief moment of levity in otherwise somber proceedings. The jury hears that the sample Sherry sent to Danny Elliott tests positive for ricin, as do subsequent samples taken from the Ziegler house. And that's pretty much the sum of the state's case that in 2014, Corey entered the Ziegler house, stole the credit card and left homemade ricin strewn about with the intention of killing her neighbors. Attempted homicide is you tried your best and it didn't work. No one is putting ricin in someone's.

[Prosecutor]

Bed, in their sock drawer, in their office.

[Jess Trevino]

If you're not trying to kill them, you're not trying to have them consume a tiny amount just to get sick.

[Prosecutor]

There's no conceivable reason to put ricin in someone's house other than to cause their death.

[Jess Trevino]

The bulk of the evidence the prosecutors present is the stuff the Oklahoma cops gathered the recipes for ricin found on Corey's computers, the castor beans found in a safe, along with a receipt that proved Corey bought them years before the Ziegler incident. Honestly, we really didn't learn any new information that we didn't already know. But the defense had a different story. Story to tell.

[Unknown Advertiser]

Time for a sofa upgrade? Visit washablesofas.com and discover Annabe where designer style meets budget friendly prices with sofas starting at $699, Annabe brings you the ultimate in furniture innovation with a modular design that allows you to rearrange your space and effortlessly. Perfect for both small and large spaces, Anabe is the only machine washable sofa inside and out. Say goodbye to stains and messes with liquid and stain resistant fabrics that make cleaning easy. Liquid simply slides right off. Designed for custom comfort, our high resilience foam lets you choose between a sink in feel or a supportive memory foam blend. Plus our pet friendly stain resistant fabrics ensure your sofa stays beautiful for years. Don't compromise quality for price. Visit washablesofas.com to upgrade your living space today with no risk returns and a 30 day money back guarantee. Get up to 60% off plus free shipping and free returns. Shop now at washablesofas.com Offers are subject to change and certain restrictions may apply.

[Jess Trevino]

Not all meals are created equal. For instance, breakfast has the spicy egg McMuffin for a limited time and lunch does it. McDonald's breakfast comes first.

[Howie Mandel]

I can't tell you how often I hear, oh, I'm a little ocd. I like things neat. That's not ocd. I'm Howie Mandel and I know this because I have ocd. Actual OCD causes relentless, unwanted thoughts. What if I did something terrible and forgot? What if I'm a bad person? Why am I thinking this terrible thing? It makes you question absolutely everything and you'll do anything to feel better. OCD OCD is debilitating, but it's also highly treatable with the right kind of therapy. Regular talk therapy doesn't cut it. OCD needs specialized therapy. That's why I want to tell you about NO cd. NOCD is the world's largest virtual therapy provider for ocd. Their licensed therapists provide specialized therapy virtually and it's covered by Insurance for over 155 million Americans if you think you might be struggling with OCD 50, visit nocd.com to schedule a free 15 minute call and learn more. That's no c d dot com.

[Lauren Vogelbaum]

Imagine you're in a deep, dreamy sleep. You're at work, but instead of one of you, there are suddenly two, then three, then ten, then 100, until a thousand of you are working to reach your goal. Now imagine it's not a dream, because what's actually happening while you sleep is the power of agentforce. A limitless digital workforce, independently thinking, acting, and solving complex tasks on your behalf around the clock and elevating only what needs your attention. No more time consuming, busy work. Just the really important stuff, like making happier customers. So while you're dreaming about flying, missing a flight, or being naked in front of a crowd, AgentForce is working to make you a lot more efficient. Like a thousand times more efficient. That's AgentForce, the powerful AI from Salesforce with Sheri.

[Melissa Jeltson]

They're really good people. And it was weird, you know, at first telling people, I'm gonna go stay with Sherry and Mike. And they're like, in their house. Like, do you even know them that well? And I've talked to Sherry for five years on and off the phone. And I felt okay. I don't know. I'm. It goes back to the intrusive and impulsive part that I guess we talked about.

[Jess Trevino]

Jess is staying with the Zieglers for the trial, which is exciting for her. She's part of the inner circle, gets the inside scoop. But also, it's a lot. Long hours in court followed by emotional nights. The uncertainty weighs heavy on all of them. Eventually, it's the defense's turn. We're all wondering if we will get to hear from Corey directly. Will she testify? Tell her story in her own words? We learn as the judge questions Corey, the answer is no.

[Court Clerk]

I have some questions for you. Ms. Balle Adams, do you understand that you have both a constitutional right to testify as well as the right to not testify?

[Jess Trevino]

Yes.

[Court Clerk]

Have you had the opportunity to discuss your decision on whether to testify with your lawyers?

[Jess Trevino]

Yes.

[Court Clerk]

Have you had enough time to discuss your decision with your lawyers?

[Jess Trevino]

Yes.

[Court Clerk]

Have you made a decision as to whether you will or will not testify? Yes, you, Honor. And what is that decision?

[Jess Trevino]

I will not testify. Those dozen or so words are pretty much all we hear from Corey. And as her attorneys lay out their case, there's not much about Corey at all.

[Court Clerk]

And for the defense attorneys, we have Kathleen Chung and Luis Cuevas.

[Jess Trevino]

They don't contest that ricin was found inside the Ziegler's house. But they do question who placed the ricin there and if the jury can ever really know for sure.

[Danny Elliott]

She's been wrongly charged, she's been wrongly accused of this.

[Jess Trevino]

She did not try to poison the Zieglers. They suggest that Corey's then husband, Alexander Adams, had just as much access and opportunity to poison their neighbors as Corey did.

[J]

The prosecution says that Cory Bomelli Adams is the only one who could have put ricin in the Ziegler's home. That is just not true. Every piece of evidence that they say points at my client points at Alexander Adams also. They say computer searches show you that my clients did a lot of searches. They don't know who created those documents. The Bee detective told you that. They don't know who visited those websites. They don't know who made bookmarks or had cookies. When asked, the district attorney said, Corey's computers. But the detective doesn't know who owns them. He doesn't know where they've been. He doesn't know who's been on them. He only knows where they were found at one moment in time. All of the rest of the information comes from Alexander Adams.

[Jess Trevino]

Corey's lawyers focus on one specific event that they see as damning. According to emails that came out during discovery, Wisconsin had once offered ALEC immunity from prosecution for his cooperation. I don't know what kinds of potential charges could even be brought against Alex. But the defense suggests that to free himself from such a liability, he might say anything. Now still, there's no evidence there was ever a formal immunity agreement between ALEC and the state. Nothing was ever signed.

[J]

Alexander is bent on this and he has pursued this from 2020 to today. And he has repeatedly told many people that Corey confessed. This is the key to this case. Alexander's report of my client's alleged confession, the central allegation here, it is the only evidence at all that puts my client in the house. Only Alexander Adams says that the substance that my client possessed was ricin. He's the only one who says that my client knew how to make ricin and that she had it and she did make it. That's only him. He's the only one who says Corey intended attempted murder and he couldn't stop saying that.

[Jess Trevino]

In closing arguments, Corey's attorneys remind the jury that the burden is on the state to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that Corey committed this crime. A threshold that they do not believe has been met.

[J]

The state must prove that Ms. Cord, Bomeli Bonnelli, had an intent to murder Michael and Sharon Siegler and that she. That Ryson did act toward the commission of murder. There is no proof of any of. The judge will define reasonable doubt for you. This is a completely doubtful case. Would you even buy a car from Alexander Adams, much less a house or trust him in a decision about something serious? This entire case depends on Alexander Adams credibility. They can't prove she was in the house ever. They can't prove she's ever had ricin. The only person who says she's brewing ricin is Alexander. They can't even prove she disliked zebras much.

[Jess Trevino]

They also bring up the question of motive.

[J]

Why in the world would she want to do this? Of course, there's an obvious reason to steal.

[Jess Trevino]

She wanted money.

[J]

And apparently she lied about it when she was in Oklahoma. She lied about it here and she.

[Jess Trevino]

Lied about it there.

[J]

So I think it's fairly clear that there's some evidence here that she's a thief. And it seems that she. That card, she clearly used it without permission. And then she lied about it. I don't know how he did from that to murder. That is a huge leap.

[Jess Trevino]

On Friday, after four and a half days of testimony, the state and defense rest and the jury enters deliberations. It only took them two hours.

[Court Clerk]

Has the jury reached a verdict? All right, please pass the verdict envelope to the bailiff. Verdict count one, we the jury find the defendant Corey Bombley Adams guilty of attempted first degree intentional homicide as charged in count one of the information. Members of the jury, as to count one, is this your verdict?

[Jess Trevino]

If.

[Melissa Jeltson]

If it is, say yes.

[Court Clerk]

If it is not, say no.

[Jess Trevino]

Yes.

[Court Clerk]

Verdict count two, we the jury find the defendant Corey Bombley Adams guilty of attempted first degree intentional homicide as charged in count two of the information.

[Jess Trevino]

Corey is convicted of two counts of attempted murder in the first degree. One for Sherry, one for Mike. But Jess isn't there in the courtroom to witness it. She had left Wisconsin the night before. After sitting through four days of trial. She was exhausted. She told me she needed to get back to her family after the verdict. I called her as quickly as I could. Tell me what just happened.

[Melissa Jeltson]

So I get a call from somebody at the courtroom that said verdict in guilty of all charges. I am so psyched. I was a little worried after some of the testimony I heard. But like, I'm really excited. I'm so happy.

[Jess Trevino]

Are you disappointed you weren't there to see it?

[Lauren Vogelbaum]

Extremely.

[Melissa Jeltson]

Like, extremely. I'm so mad at myself for going home. I got home yesterday at like 2 in the morning. So I'm sad but happy. I mean it kind of. I mean, I guess the verdict was all that mattered. I just wish I could have looked at her, but from reports of people there, she was just like a statue. No emotion when the verdict was read at all. Just completely blank. My phone is currently blowing up with people. Guilty, guilty, guilty. I was like, yes, I know. Literally as I'm talking to you, I have 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 messages all coming through. So just trying to get back to people and there's people in different states waiting to hear and yeah, I'm super excited. This really worked out. I'm. I'm glad. I feel like we got some. It's like our first step in getting justice for Selena. This is really like the first part of it. I feel like this is like the beginning steps of it. So it makes me happy.

[Jess Trevino]

I reached out to Sherry Ziegler too, to ask if she wanted to share her reaction to Corey's guilty verdict. But she passed. She said the verdict is what she hoped for, and now she just wants to put this experience behind her. Meanwhile, Jess keeps looking forward. Corey's sentencing hearing is scheduled for August. She faces up to 60 years per charge. And then, if all goes as planned, Corey will be sent back to Oklahoma to stand trial for the murder of Talina Zar.

[Melissa Jeltson]

It's not that I'm not invested in sharing Mike's case, because I am. But the Talina case is where I think my heart is kind of at. I think that one's going to be a lot more, oh my God, this is finally happening than this one is.

[Jess Trevino]

Jess had always planned on going to Oklahoma to attend the murder trial, but she's wavered recently, having a bit of a crisis of confidence. In the month since the final episode of the podcast came out, Jess told me she'd been affected by some of the negative comments she'd read online.

[Melissa Jeltson]

I don't want to get emotional, but I struggle with some of the Reddit stuff and some of the shitty comments. People are saying that I'm intrusive and narcissistic and because I second guess I'm self aware. I know sometimes it doesn't sound like it here, but I am.

[Jess Trevino]

But because of the podcast, just also recently connected with Talena's sister Cheryl. Over the phone, Cheryl told Jess she was grateful for all of her work, and she passed along a similar message from Talena's mom.

[Melissa Jeltson]

Knowing that they think it's okay made this better for me. I was actually after reading some of that stuff, I'm like, I should just stop doing this. Like finish recording Melissa and just drop it everything and never talk about it again. And when she was like, no, never stop talking about it, I was like, then I'll do it for them and for her.

[Jess Trevino]

What Happened to Talina Zar is a production of iHeart podcasts. It's written, reported and hosted by me, Melissa Jeltson with writing and story editing by Lauren Hanson. Our Executive producer is ryan Murdoch. For iHeart podcasts, executive producers are Jason English and Carl Cadle. Zoe Denkla is our Associate producer. Jeremy Thal is our editor. Original music by Erin Kaufman with additional music by Jeremy Thal and Gideon Crevice. Additional sound recording by Nicholas Bartel and Tony Bublitz. Special thanks to the staff at the Dane County Courthouse. Episodes are mixed and mastered by Carl Cadle. Our logo is designed by Ido Moore. Thanks so much for listening.

[Unknown Advertiser]

Life's messy. We're talking spills, stains, pets and kids. But with Annabe you never have to stress about messes again. @washablesofas.com Discover Annabe sofas the only fully machine washable sofas inside and out starting at just $699. Made with liquid and stain resistant fabrics, that means fewer stains and more peace of mind. Designed for real life, our sofas feature changeable fabric covers allowing you to refresh your style anytime. Need flexibility? Our modular design lets you rearrange your sofa effortlessly. Perfect for cozy apartments or spacious homes, plus their earth and built to last. That's why over 200,000 happy customers have made the switch. Upgrade your space today. Visit washablesofas.com now and bring home a sofa made for life. That's washablesofas.com offers are subject to change and certain restrictions may apply.

[Lauren Vogelbaum]

Every business has an ambition. PayPal open is the platform designed to help you grow into yours with business loans so you can expand and access to hundreds of millions of PayPal customers worldwide. And your customers can pay all the ways they want with PayPal, Venmo, pay later and all major cards so you can focus on scaling up when it's time to get growing. There's one platform for all business PayPal open grow today at paypalopen.com loans subject to approval in available locations. This is Danielle Fishel from Podmeet's World Parents, Quick question. When is the last time you won snack time? The other day I handed my son a perfectly portioned Pinterest level snack and he traded it for a mott's Applesauce pouch. I'm not mad, just impressed. And that's why Mott's no Sugar added Applesauce pouches are perfect to keep on hand. They're made with real apples packed in a super easy pouch. Perfect for tossing in a lunchbox, keeping in the car, or grabbing as you're running out the door. Plus, they're a good source of vitamin C and kids love them. Win Win. Make sure your kid wins snack time with Motts. Real apples make real good applesauce. Learn [e-mail] with depression, it feels like every day you're just going through the motions. I wanted something that could help me feel better fast and that also lasts. That's when my doctor told me about Ovelity in a study. Ovelity started working for some as early as one week with significant improvements in seen on average at six weeks compared to placebo, Ovelity is helping me to feel more like myself. I'm glad I talked to my doctor about Ovelity. Ovelity is a prescription medicine for adults with major depressive disorder. Ovelity is not approved for children under 18. Ovelity may increase suicidal thoughts and actions in young adults. Tell your doctor about sudden changes to mood, thoughts or behavior. Do not take Ovelity if you have a history of seizure eating disorder or have abruptly stopped drinking alcohol or taking benzodiazepines, barbiturates or anti seizure medicine. Serious allergic reactions can occur. Do not take if you are allergic to dextromethorphan, bupropion or any of the ingredients in Ovelity. Do not take with maois. High blood pressure, manic episodes, serious eye problems and dizziness can occur. Report all medicines you take to avoid a life threatening condition. Take do not take Ovelity if you are or may become pregnant. Side effects can include dizziness, headache, diarrhea, feeling sleepy, dry mouth, sexual function problems and excessive sweating. Ask your healthcare provider if Ovelity is right for you. Visit ovelity.com that's a U V E-L-I-T-Y.com or call 866-496-2976 for more information.

[Melissa Jeltson]

This is an I Heart Podcast.