Detailed Summary of “Going to Court - Talina Zar BONUS” from What Happened to Talina Zar

What Happened to Talina Zar is a gripping podcast series by iHeartPodcasts that delves into the mysterious disappearance of Talina Zar during the COVID-19 lockdown. This bonus episode, titled “Going to Court - Talina Zar BONUS,” released on July 24, 2025, provides an in-depth look into the first day of court for Corey Bommily Adams, the woman accused of attempting to murder Sherry and Mike Ziegler and later implicated in Talina Zar’s disappearance. Hosted by Melissa Jeltson and featuring investigative reporter Jess Trevino, the episode offers a comprehensive overview of the proceedings, the evidence presented, and the emotional toll on those involved.

1. Introduction to the Court Proceedings

The episode opens with Jess Trevino, the internet sleuth behind the podcast, attending Corey Bommily Adams' trial in Madison, Wisconsin. Jess recounts her anticipation and the significance of witnessing Corey's first day in court.

Jess Trevino [03:11]: "Jess Trevino, the Internet sleuth who spent the past five years investigating the disappearance of Talina Czar and digging into the background of Corey Bommily, the woman accused of killing her."

2. Entering the Courtroom

Jess describes her initial emotions upon entering the austere Dane County Courthouse, highlighting the tense atmosphere and her focus on Corey’s demeanor.

Melissa Jeltson [02:54]: "She seems smaller, older, but kind of smug still... I thought she was looking at me."

3. Courtroom Dynamics and Key Figures

The narrative introduces key individuals present in the courtroom, including Sherry and Mike Ziegler, the victims, and law enforcement officers from Wagner County, Oklahoma, who testify during the trial.

Court Clerk [04:29]: "The case before us today is entitled the State of Wisconsin versus Corey Bomily Adams."

4. Prosecution’s Case: Attempted Murder in 2014

The prosecution lays out their case, detailing the 2014 incident where the Zieglers returned from vacation to find signs of a break-in and discovery of ricin, a deadly toxin. Testimonies from Deputy Zach and Lieutenant Danny Elliott reveal Corey's criminal activities, including credit card fraud and attempts to poison her neighbors.

Sherry Ziegler [06:12]: "It's 10 years and it's taken the toll on us a little bit... I will be so happy and done with."

5. Evidence Presented

Key evidence includes ricin traces found in the Ziegler residence, recipes for ricin found on Corey's computer, and testimonies from Corey's ex-husband, Alexander Adams, who claims Corey confessed to poisoning intentions.

Danny Elliott [20:22]: "That is a small safe that was located in a bedroom closet."

6. Defense’s Arguments: Questioning the Prosecution’s Claims

Corey's defense team challenges the prosecution’s narrative by suggesting that Alexander Adams had the motive and opportunity to commit the crimes, casting doubt on Corey’s sole culpability. They argue the evidence is circumstantial and heavily reliant on Adams' credibility.

Defense Attorney [33:10]: "The state must prove that Ms. Corey's intent to murder the Zieglers exists, which there is no proof of."

7. Witness Testimonies and Credibility

Alexander Adams, Corey’s ex-husband, plays a pivotal role as a key witness for the prosecution. His testimony regarding Corey’s alleged confession is scrutinized, with the defense pointing out the lack of formal immunity agreements that might have influenced his statements.

Alexander Adams [22:33]: "When she told me she'd done this, I looked at her and I said, that's attempted murder..."

8. Corey’s Silence in Court

Despite the opportunity, Corey chooses not to testify, leaving the prosecution to rely solely on witness testimonies and physical evidence. This decision intensifies the courtroom drama as the jury deliberates on the presented facts without hearing Corey's side.

Court Clerk [32:34]: "I will not testify."

9. Verdict and Immediate Reactions

After four and a half days of testimony, the jury swiftly deliberates and finds Corey guilty of two counts of attempted first-degree intentional homicide. Jess Trevino recounts Melissa Jeltson’s exhilarated reaction to the verdict, despite not being present in the courtroom during the final moments.

Melissa Jeltson [40:11]: "I am so psyched... This really worked out. I feel like we got some... It’s like the first step in getting justice for Selena."

10. Impact on the Investigation into Talina Zar’s Disappearance

The conviction of Corey Bommily Adams marks a significant milestone but also serves as a precursor to Talina Zar’s impending trial. Jess Trevino expresses her intention to attend Talina's trial in Oklahoma, although she grapples with personal challenges due to negative online feedback.

Jess Trevino [42:39]: "I struggle with some of the Reddit stuff and some of the shitty comments... I don't want to stop talking about it, I’ll do it for them and for her."

11. Support from Zar’s Family

Despite online harassment, Jess receives encouragement from Talina Zar’s sister Cheryl and her mother, reinforcing her commitment to seeking justice.

Melissa Jeltson [43:12]: "Knowing that they think it's okay made this better for me... I am for them and for her."

12. Looking Ahead: Sentencing and Future Trials

Corey's sentencing hearing is scheduled for August, where she faces up to 60 years per charge. Additionally, Corey is expected to return to Oklahoma to stand trial for the murder of Talina Zar, setting the stage for the next chapter in this unfolding saga.

Jess Trevino [41:27]: "Corey will be sent back to Oklahoma to stand trial for the murder of Talina Zar."

Notable Quotes with Timestamps

• Jess Trevino [03:11]: "I'm here for a lot to report on the trial because it's connected to Talina's case."

• Sherry Ziegler [06:12]: "We've told the story many, many times... After a while, once the trial is over with, I will be so happy and done with."

• Melissa Jeltson [08:44]: "I'm not saying it's not... Yeah, the mullet, the jacket. I'm nitpicking her."

• Jess Trevino [27:06]: "The jury hears that the sample Sherry sent to Danny Elliott tests positive for ricin."

• Melissa Jeltson [40:11]: "This really worked out... I feel like this is the beginning steps of it."

Concluding Thoughts

“Going to Court - Talina Zar BONUS” provides a compelling snapshot of a pivotal moment in the quest for justice surrounding Talina Zar’s disappearance. Through detailed courtroom coverage, witness testimonies, and the emotional journeys of those involved, the episode deepens the mystery and highlights the intricate web of evidence and personal stakes. Jess Trevino’s dedication as an internet sleuth underscores the power of grassroots investigations in uncovering the truth, even as she faces her own challenges. As the podcast series progresses, listeners are left eagerly anticipating the next developments in Talina Zar’s case and the ultimate resolution of Corey Bommily Adams’ legal battles.