We Settled the Headphone Debate

Summary

Podcast Summary: "We Settled the Headphone Debate"

Podcast Information:

• Title: You Betcha Radio
• Host/Author: You Betcha
• Description: The most "Midwest" podcast on the planet. Myles the You Betcha Guy and the gang, Ryan, Tyler, and Jerrod, have been talking man culture, nostalgia, and being from the Midwest since 2019. Listen to each comedy-filled episode every Wednesday. Cheers!
• Episode: We Settled the Headphone Debate
• Release Date: August 4, 2025

---

Introduction to the Debate

The episode kicks off with the hosts delving into the perennial debate among audio enthusiasts: over-the-ear headphones versus earbuds. The conversation explores personal preferences, practicality, and the evolution of headphone technology.

Transition from Over-the-Ear Headphones to Earbuds

Jared initiates the discussion by sharing his shift in preference from over-the-ear headphones to earbuds.
“So for the longest time I was headphone over the year headphones guy. And then I just like reached the age of like 28 and I was like, I look ridiculous with over the ear headphones in public.” [00:07]

Mike adds his perspective on the social perception of over-the-ear headphones:
“If you have them around your neck, you're weird. If they're on, it's okay.” [00:31]

Tom counters by stating that certain over-the-ear headphones styles are still acceptable:
“I think like over the ear radio headphones are just fine.” [00:44]

The Rise of Earbuds and Technical Advancements

Jared elaborates on the advancements in earbud technology:
“Earbuds are more versatile. They're easy to carry around... over the ear headphones can be a lot and then they get sweaty and it's weird.” [02:52]

He further explains how noise-canceling earbuds have narrowed the experience gap between earbuds and over-the-ear headphones:
“Earbud technology with the noise canceling and how good they sound have gotten so good that I was like, well, why would I lug around this giant pair of headphones when I get the same experience or at least 90% of the way experience with just the earbuds?” [01:13]

Practical Considerations and Use Cases

Mike highlights the inconvenience of over-the-ear headphones:
“Over the ear headphones are so inconvenient to have on you.” [01:45]

The hosts discuss scenarios where different audio devices are appropriate. Jared proposes a "fuck, marry, kill" analogy to categorize their preferences:
“I think I'd kill over the ear headphones. I'd marry earbuds and I'll a Bluetooth speaker same.” [01:58]

Mary adds her own preference, balancing home use and public use:
“I'm over the ears guy. Like at home, but in public it's in ears.” [02:31]

Personal Anecdotes and Experiences

The conversation shifts to personal stories, such as Mike’s experience with custom over-the-ear headphones due to cauliflower ear:
“I had to wear over the ears because I got cauliflower ear in my left ear and not in my right ear.” [03:04]

Mary shares a humorous anecdote about a friend who overly relies on a Bluetooth speaker:
“I was at a bachelor party and my buddy, he had a Bluetooth speaker with him wherever he went. Really brought it everywhere.” [03:30]

Technology Preferences: AirPods vs. CarPlay

The discussion transitions to Apple’s AirPods and CarPlay. Jared praises AirPods for their convenience:
“They’re so nice to be able to just pop them up and put them in. That's connected. It'll just start playing automatically.” [04:54]

However, Mary introduces a comparison question:
“What do you like more? AirPods or Apple CarPlay.” [05:04]

Jared expresses a stronger preference for CarPlay:
“I use CarPlay more. So probably CarPlay.” [05:11]

Mike shares a transformative experience his father had with CarPlay in a rental car:
“I set up CarPlay, and it blew my dad's mind... CarPlay has completely changed his life.” [06:02]

Final Thoughts and Takeaways

The episode wraps up with the hosts reflecting on the practicality and technological benefits of their preferred audio devices. Jared emphasizes the convenience of CarPlay over traditional Bluetooth:
“Bluetooth still better than... Than no CarPlay.” [06:51]

---

Notable Quotes

• Jared [00:07]: “I look ridiculous with over the ear headphones in public.”
• Mike [00:31]: “If you have them around your neck, you're weird.”
• Jared [01:13]: “Why would I lug around this giant pair of headphones when I get the same experience... with just the earbuds?”
• Jared [01:58]: “I think I'd kill over the ear headphones. I'd marry earbuds and I'll a Bluetooth speaker same.”
• Jared [04:54]: “It’s just so nice to be able to just pop them up and put them in.”
• Jared [05:11]: “I use CarPlay more. So probably CarPlay.”
• Mike [06:02]: “CarPlay has completely changed his life.”

Conclusion

In "We Settled the Headphone Debate," the You Betcha Radio team thoroughly explores the evolving landscape of personal audio devices. From the practicality and social perceptions of over-the-ear headphones to the sleek convenience of earbuds and the integrated functionalities of CarPlay, each host provides their unique perspectives and experiences. This engaging discussion not only highlights the technological advancements but also underscores the importance of choosing audio solutions that align with one's lifestyle and preferences.

For more insights and detailed discussions, visit patreon.com/youbetradio or search for You Betcha Radio on your preferred podcast app to access hundreds of additional episodes.

Transcript

[Mary]

Mary kill earbuds, headphones, Bluetooth speaker.

[Jared]

So for the longest time I was headphone over the year headphones guy. And then I just like reached the age of like 28 and I was like, I look ridiculous with over the ear headphones in public. I don't know if you guys feel that way or not, but I just feel like, like I just got. I outgrew the over the ear headphones.

[Mike]

So my, my theory, my take on over the your headphones, if you have them around your neck, you're weird. If they're on, it's okay. I think it's so weird that just people walk around with them around their necks.

[Jared]

See?

[Tom]

But I think like over the ear radio headphones are just fine.

[Jared]

Those are cool. I would wear that.

[Tom]

Yeah. But there's something about like not having the little antenna coming up from, you know, say a pair of bows or skull candies make it look weird. You know, it's like, I don't need to be wearing skull candies to noon ball.

[Mike]

Yeah.

[Tom]

I think I'm more of an airpod guy. But like.

[Jared]

Well, it's also like over the ear headphones were more advanced than earbud technology for a while there.

[Mike]

Long time.

[Jared]

So if you wanted a good listening experience, you had to go over the ear to. To get good one. And then the earbud technology with the noise canceling and how good they sound have gotten so good that I was like, well, why would I lug around this giant pair of headphones when I get the same experience or at least 90% of the way experience with just the earbuds?

[Mike]

Yeah, that is a good the. You kind of glazed over it. But a really good point is the over the head, over the ears are so inconvenient to have on you.

[Jared]

Yeah.

[Mike]

Unless you're putting them around the neck and looking like a weirdo.

[Jared]

Yeah. So that's my thought. That's why I go earbuds, mini earbuds guy.

[Mike]

I would marry those.

[Jared]

Is this a fuck marry kill.

[Mary]

What is it Bluetooth? Yeah. With speaker? Yeah.

[Jared]

I think I'd kill over the ear headphones. I'd marry earbuds and I'll a Bluetooth speaker same. Not every scenario is a Bluetooth speaker is good, but most of the time a Bluetooth speaker can enhance whatever you're in. Like right now would be. Would not be good because it's a podcast. So I can't say every scenario is improved by a Bluetooth speaker, but most social situations can be.

[Tom]

Well, that's why you're married to the earbuds too. You're just looking for. If you're just looking for a buddy every once in a while. Bluetooth speakers.

[Jared]

Great, great example. Is anyone Jared? Are you over the years guy?

[Mary]

I'm over the ears guy. Like at home, but in public it's in ears.

[Jared]

Yeah, yeah.

[Mary]

Because I like listening to music. Like with over ears. It's just a little better quality.

[Jared]

Also like I feel like earbuds are more versatile. Right. They're easy to carry around if you're gonna work out over the ear. Headphones can be a lot and then they get sweaty and it's weird.

[Mike]

So I caught before they made the earbuds better fits and like you could change the sizes of the thing. I had to wear over the ears because I got cauliflower ear in my left ear and not in my right ear. So I was always over the year. And working out in those things is just the worst. You like, if you work out hard, you'll literally get a pool of sweat in those things.

[Tom]

Yeah. Oh yeah.

[Mike]

Disgusting. Yeah, yeah.

[Jared]

Greed.

[Mary]

I was at a bachelor party and my buddy, he had a Bluetooth speaker with him wherever he went. Really brought it everywhere. Like and it was always like blaring Morgan wall into like a conversation.

[Tom]

See when you.

[Jared]

Yeah, see, Overdoing it. Not good, not good. Now over the ear headphones. You're at a silent disco. That's the time. Yeah, yeah.

[Tom]

Has anyone ever been to a silent disco?

[Mike]

No.

[Jared]

No. I don't think people actually go that. I think it's just like a myth made up on the Internet.

[Mike]

That'd be a awesome prank in like 10 years. Like remember silent discos? None of them ever actually happened. We made it up.

[Tom]

Yeah, yeah.

[Mary]

We were silent about.

[Tom]

I thought it was like popular on cruise ships.

[Jared]

And now one thing. I have the AirPods as my in ear headphones. The one thing I don't like is if I wear them for, you know, like after about like 20, 25 minutes, it will get less noise canceled. And then I have to like readjust them or take it out and put it back in and then it re. Noise cancels. I don't know if that happens to you guys. Maybe I have ill fitting.

[Mike]

I was just gonna say it's just getting loose or.

[Jared]

Yeah. I don't know if like just by moving around they start to like kind of come out a little bit.

[Mike]

But I've never had AirPods. I have little Bose tiny buds.

[Jared]

I think that AirPods are like one of the sneaky best products Apple ever.

[Tom]

Made, I would agree.

[Mary]

Looks like their most profitable one.

[Tom]

I would agree.

[Jared]

Yeah, they're. They're. It's just so nice to be able to just pop them up and put them in. That's connected. It'll just start playing automatically. It's great.

[Mary]

Oh, here we go. What do you like more? AirPods or Apple CarPlay.

[Jared]

I use CarPlay more.

[Mary]

Yeah.

[Jared]

So probably CarPlay. Yeah, yeah, yeah.

[Tom]

CarPlay is great.

[Jared]

CarPlay is.

[Tom]

Yeah.

[Jared]

Did I talk about that? I like. I'll. I'll delay a road trip if my car play is not.

[Mike]

Yeah, I've seen it happen.

[Jared]

I. I need CarPlay on rental car.

[Mike]

On the way to the Ozarks. We sat in the parking lot for 25 minutes.

[Tom]

Well, going off two years ago, it's.

[Jared]

I don't know if it's a comfort thing for me or a peace of mind, but just having everything on the screen. You need to pull up gps. It's right there. Nothing's worse than, like, having to do one of these.

[Mary]

Dangerous, dangerous.

[Jared]

You know, if you get a phone call, you just. You don't even have to look at your phone. You just. All right there. It's the best, I think is the best.

[Mike]

I don't know if I brought it up on the pod, but I definitely brought it up to you guys in person. On the way from Saskatoon to our bear hunting camp in our rental car, I set up CarPlay, and it blew my dad's mind. I'm like, dad, you have a 2025 Ford. You have CarPlay. He's like, shut up. I can do this in my truck. So he just, like, when he first turned it on, just hit no on everything like an old guy does. And now CarPlay has completely changed his life.

[Jared]

Also a huge flex that your Dad's got a 2025 Ford. Yeah.

[Tom]

Not to brag.

[Mike]

It's fucking sick.

[Jared]

It's a. That drone. Money must be good.

[Mike]

Yeah, if it makes it better. It's a lease, so.

[Jared]

Oh, he does company lease.

[Mike]

He's borrowing one.

[Jared]

Yeah, company. Yeah, I see how it goes.

[Tom]

My CarPlay, my. I have a 2020, so I have to plug in to get CarPlay. It just doesn't. It doesn't.

[Jared]

Bluetooth still better than.

[Tom]

Yeah, no.

[Jared]

Than no car play.

[Mary]

Does your car also run on kerosene, too?

[Jared]

You got to crank it to start. Guys, if you want more, you bet your radio. You got to check out our Patreon. You got to go to patreon.com, you bet radio. Or look us up on the app, and we have hundreds of hours of other episodes on there that you can't get unless you're signed up. So you got to check us out on Patreon. You bet your radio, baby.