What is The Coolest Instrument?

Summary

Podcast Summary: "What is The Coolest Instrument?"

You Betcha Radio
Date: June 1, 2026
Hosts: Myles (You Betcha Guy), Ryan, Tyler, Jerrod

Episode Overview

In this lively and comedic episode, the You Betcha crew dives into a spirited debate: What’s the coolest instrument to be really good at—harmonica, saxophone, or piano? True to their Midwest roots, the conversation mixes nostalgia, candid takes, and playful roasting as the guys weigh each instrument’s pros and cons from both a practical and a “cool factor” perspective.

---

Key Discussion Points & Insights

Opening Question: The Contenders

• Tyler kicks things off (00:00):
  “What instrument would be the coolest to be really good at? Harmonica, Saxophone or piano?”

Saxophone: Cool But Awkward

• Ryan’s Take (00:12):
  • Carrying a saxophone is a hassle; setting it up with the neck strap isn’t cool.
  • “Like harmonica and piano are definitely cooler, but there's less people who are really good at saxophone. You know what I mean?” (00:30)
  • Reminisces about a talented high school sax player, but says, “Just standing there with your saxophone, you look kind of like a dweeb.” (00:42)
• Punchline from Tyler (00:55):
  “He never got laid.”
• Ryan doubles down (00:57):
  "He looked dweeby standing there with the saxophone, but while you're playing it—it's sick."

Harmonica: Portable & “Cowboy Cool”

• Ryan (01:14):
  “There’s a low ceiling and a high floor with harmonica. If you got basic harmonica skills, it's going to be not that much different than someone who's an expert at harmonica.”
• Discussion:
  • You can always carry it in your pocket, cowboy vibes.
  • It's practical, but mastery doesn’t impress much more than the basics.

Piano: High Skill, Social Perception

• Ryan (01:31):
  Challenges around being a piano virtuoso:
  “The problem with piano though is if you're really good at piano, everyone just thinks you're autistic or deaf like Beethoven or whatever.”
  • The group riffs on this with references to Beethoven, Ray Charles (02:21), and perceptions around piano mastery.
• Pros:
  • Pianos are accessible in public places—just walk up and play (02:43).
  • Impresses people; considered attractive to women (03:22).

Deciding Factors: Social Utility & Attractiveness

• Ryan lays out the hierarchy (01:56):
  • Saxophone: “You can wow the crowd the most with it… crowd goes nuts.”
  • Piano: “Really cool. Lot of technical skills. You can… there's a high ceiling for it.”
• Tyler (01:55):
  Jokingly, "You can't have a piano in your pocket."
• On Attractiveness:
  • General consensus: piano skills are most impressive when trying to attract attention—“I don't know why I feel like chicks love when a guy can show them they can play the piano.” (03:22)
  • Harmonica, less so—“I don't think chicks are like, God, that dude can play the harmonica. I’m so wet right now.” (Ryan, 03:48)

Harmonica, Again: Underdog & Campfire King

• Tyler and Unknown Male Friend (03:05, 03:15):
  • Harmonica is a great “campfire” instrument.
  • Even a good player might not stand far apart from a great one, skill-wise.
  • Usually paired with another instrument; rarely a main act on its own (04:32–04:40).
  • Using the harmonica neck mount is “nerdy”—quipped: "I'll push you over into a snowbank." (04:45)

The Verdict:

• Ryan (02:23, 03:05):
  Torn but leans toward piano for its showmanship and “pick-up” potential.
• Unknown Male Friend (03:15, 05:23):
  Stands by harmonica for its portability and campfire value, but understands its limitations.
• Tyler:
  Enjoys harmonica, but acknowledges its limitations; jokes about his own skills.

---

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• On Saxophone’s Image:
  • “Just standing there with your saxophone, you look kind of like a dweeb.” — Ryan (00:42)
• Roasting Sax Players:
  • “He never got laid.” — Tyler (00:55)
• Harmonica’s Limits:
  • “If you got basic harmonica skills, it's going to be not that much different than someone who's an expert at harmonica.” — Ryan (01:16)
• On Piano Geniuses:
  • “If you're really good at piano, everyone just thinks you're autistic or deaf like Beethoven or whatever.” — Ryan (01:31)
• On Impressing Women:
  • “I don't think chicks are like, God, that dude can play the harmonica. I’m so wet right now.” — Ryan (03:48)
• Harmonica Neck Mount:
  • "A harmonica with a neck mount, that's like, I'm gonna...I'll push you over into a snowbank." — Unknown Male Friend (04:45)
• Motivation for Choosing:
  • "If I personally had to choose, I would choose a harmonica. But I understand why other people wouldn't." — Unknown Male Friend (05:23)

---

Timestamps for Key Segments

• 00:00: Episode opens with Tyler’s question on the coolest instrument.
• 00:30–01:16: Debating saxophone’s pros and cons.
• 01:14–01:56: Harmonica skill ceiling/floor, piano’s social perception.
• 02:43–03:05: Accessibility of piano, attractiveness to others.
• 04:32–04:54: Harmonica’s supporting role, neck mount discussion.
• 05:23: Final thoughts and summary of each host’s preference.

---

Episode Tone

The conversation is tongue-in-cheek, playful, and full of the banter that defines Midwest humor. The hosts combine genuine opinions with sarcastic asides and storytelling, making this both an insightful and entertaining listen on musical “coolness” and the social perceptions that go with it.

---

Bottom Line

Each instrument brings its own “cool” to the table:

• Saxophone: Epic while playing, dorky when holding.
• Harmonica: The ultimate campfire companion but unlikely to make you a star.
• Piano: High technical ceiling, easily impresses, especially in public, and gets bonus points for romance potential.

In true You Betcha fashion, the debate ends with no clear winner—just a lot of laughs and Midwest-style ribbing.

Transcript

[Tyler]

Tylenol. What instrument would be the coolest to be really good at? Harmonica, Saxophone or piano?

[Ryan]

I just. Saxophone is cool, but kind of everything around saxophoning is tough. Like. Like carrying a saxophone case around.

[Unknown Male Friend]

Yeah.

[Ryan]

Like taking it out and putting the thing around your neck. I don't know.

[Unknown Male Friend]

Yeah.

[Ryan]

Like harmonica and piano are definitely cooler, but there's less people who are really good at saxophone.

[Tyler]

Yeah.

[Ryan]

You know what I mean?

[Unknown Male Friend]

You can rip on a saxophone too, if you're good.

[Tyler]

Yeah.

[Ryan]

Look, I remember in high school there was a kid in the band who was playing saxophone and he was actually like really good. And it was cool when he was playing. But then after the fact, just standing there with your saxophone, you look kind of like a dweeb.

[Tyler]

He never got laid.

[Ryan]

No. Yeah, it was. You just. He's looked dweeby standing there with the saxophone, but while you're playing it. It's sick. Yeah. Harmonica is. I feel like there's a. There's a low ceiling and a high floor. With harmonica.

[Tyler]

I completely agree with that.

[Ryan]

If you got it, if you got basic harmonica skills, it's going to be not that much different than someone who's an expert at harmonica Feel like it's like there's not a lot of nuance. But piano, if you're really good at piano. The problem with piano though is if you're really good at piano, everyone just thinks you're autistic or deaf like Beethoven or whatever.

[Unknown Male Friend]

Yeah.

[Ryan]

So like harmonica is definitely like. I'm. I'm like the cool cowboy guy who can play harmonica really well and you can just always have it in your pocket.

[Tyler]

Can't have a piano in your pocket.

[Ryan]

Saxophone is definitely. You can wow the crowd the most with it. Cuz it. You get some big notes on that thing. Especially if you hold a Note for like 20 seconds, crowd goes nuts. Piano is really cool. Lot of technical skills. You can. There's a high ceiling for it. But then you just run the risk of people thinking that you're autistic.

[Tyler]

Yeah.

[Ryan]

Or blind.

[Tyler]

Yeah. Ray Charles.

[Unknown Male Friend]

Yeah. Yeah.

[Ryan]

So I think at the end of the day though, I think I will choose saxophone. Just nerdy and like, I think, I think I'd choose piano. Yeah.

[Unknown Male Friend]

I think I would choose harmonica because

[Ryan]

it would be sick to just like go to when an airport's got a piano. Just like walk up to it and just be able to play a diddy.

[Tyler]

Yeah. Because like with harmonica and saxophone you need your own harmonico and. Or saxophone.

[Ryan]

Piano are just laying around.

[Tyler]

Exactly.

[Unknown Male Friend]

Low barrier to Entry, though, with harmonica. But I.

[Ryan]

That's why there's a low ceiling, though.

[Unknown Male Friend]

Yeah. Yeah. It doesn't. It doesn't make it as like.

[Ryan]

I mean, Tyler can play the harmonica. It's just. I can't choose that. But I. I'll go piano. It would be sick.

[Unknown Male Friend]

I think. I think I gotta go harmonica. I think piano is sweet. It. Let's like, if you're a single guy.

[Ryan]

Mm.

[Unknown Male Friend]

I don't know why I feel like chicks love when a guy can show them they can play the piano.

[Ryan]

Wait, what?

[Unknown Male Friend]

Chicks love when a guy can. Will show them that they can play the piano.

[Ryan]

I thought you said harmonica.

[Unknown Male Friend]

Nope, I said. I'm pretty sure I said I. I think piano is. Would be great for a single guy.

[Ryan]

I thought you said harmonica.

[Unknown Male Friend]

I would take the harmonica.

[Tyler]

I. You might have said harmonica, but you might be.

[Ryan]

Yeah, that's why I was laughing, cuz I was like, I don't think chicks are like, God, that dude can play the harmonica. I'm so wet right now.

[Unknown Male Friend]

If I did say that, I meant. I meant p.m. okay.

[Ryan]

Yeah. I think P was definitely the most attractive to women out of those two.

[Unknown Male Friend]

Agreed. Yeah. In terms of vibe wise, though, like around. Being around a campfire with a harmonica and if you're good, I. I also feel like you can rip notes on a harmonica.

[Tyler]

You can.

[Unknown Male Friend]

I don't think you can take what Tyler did. I don't. I don't think we can take that too seriously because it wasn't that good.

[Ryan]

I know, I know. But an expert isn't that much better than Tyler is. What I'm trying to say

[Tyler]

between, like. Yeah. And if you compare that to like an average piano player and an expert, it's much different.

[Unknown Male Friend]

Yeah, yeah, yeah.

[Ryan]

Like, okay, here's a great example. There's no talent shows where guys are getting up there and playing the harmonica.

[Tyler]

But. And if they are, they're playing another

[Ryan]

instrument with the harmonica while they're playing the harmonica. It's always a supplemental device. See?

[Unknown Male Friend]

But a harmonica with a neck mount, that's like, I'm gonna. I'll push you over into a snowbank.

[Ryan]

Oh, you're saying that's nerdy. Yeah. What if you're playing the guitar and

[Tyler]

the drum with your foot?

[Ryan]

Yeah, I.

[Unknown Male Friend]

That's fine. That's fine.

[Tyler]

That's where the neck thing comes in.

[Ryan]

But the neck thing is only because you're doing something else. No one's just playing the harmonic go with only a neck.

[Unknown Male Friend]

They're not. What if you're trying to stoke the fire up or something. Or pour another drink.

[Ryan]

You might have the neck mount on Crazy Ryan. That's crazy.

[Unknown Male Friend]

What if you need your hands like beatboxers need their hands in order to hit certain notes? Could be the same for Harmony, anyway. If I personally had to choose, I would choose a harmonica. But I understand why other people wouldn't.