You Made It Weird with Pete Holmes
Episode: Nate Craig Returns
Date: August 23, 2023
Guests: Pete Holmes (Host), Nate Craig (Guest)
Main Theme & Overview
In this episode, Pete Holmes welcomes comedian Nate Craig back for a wide-ranging, hilarious, and introspective conversation. They dive deep into the craft of stand-up comedy, personal growth, relationships, mental health, and the idiosyncrasies of being a comedian — all in the show’s signature blend of warmth, vulnerability, and absurdity. Fans get a behind-the-scenes look at Nate’s new special Live at the Green Mill, candid talk about the weirdness of comedians, honest self-reflection, and plenty of digressive bits, classic "weird" humor, and memorable personal stories.
Key Discussion Points & Insights
1. Crafting Stand-Up Comedy & Nate’s New Special
- Pete praises Nate’s special for its fearlessness, craftsmanship, and musicality, emphasizing how rare it is for comedians to weave themes and callbacks so seamlessly (07:04).
- Quote: "You didn't bring up a premise without taking it somewhere worth bothering us with." (08:17, Pete)
- Timeliness and crowd work: Nate talks about building a special that truly reflects post-pandemic experiences, and keeping it fresh with crowd work elements.
- Insight: Both discuss how seasoned comedians (often in their 40s) tend to naturally start building to something more meaningful onstage, imbuing their comedy with urgency, vulnerability, and intent (12:19).
2. The Vulnerability and Sensitivity of Comics
- On listening and sensitivity: Pete and Nate agree that the best comics are those who really listen and tune into the energy and nuance of the room, with Rory Scoville and Marc Maron offered as prime, supersensitive examples (15:46).
- Quote: "There's a spectrum of how sensitive comedians are, and I tend to like the more sensitive ones." (15:46, Pete)
- Emotional drive: There's a running theme about anger being sadness in disguise, and how a lot of performance comes from a place of longing to be understood — often rooted in childhood or family dynamics (16:31).
- Quote: "Anger is sadness in disguise. … Weeping anger is the colorful candy shell on the M&M of sadness." (16:30, Pete)
3. Relationships & the Comic's Compulsion
- Nate reflects on his marriage: He shares the full story of meeting his wife at a yoga class, wooing her post-breakup, and how their partnership brings new stability and joy to his life (26:03–29:01).
- The complexity of being married to a comic: Both Nate and Pete admit that, in their marriages, they’re often "the ball and chain," the more complicated, shadowy counterpart to their generally sunnier spouses (35:48).
- Quote: "I'm the ball and chain. ... She's the sunlight, and I'm the shadow." (35:48, Pete)
- Acknowledgment of emotional compulsion: Both recognize the compulsive, even addictive, element in becoming a comedian, driven by a need to be noticed or validated in ways that weren’t always met in childhood (32:37).
4. The Self-Perception of Comics
- On feeling ‘dumb’ in traditional settings: Both discuss how traditional school or job settings made them feel dumb or mislabeled, but comedy became their domain to thrive and feel smart (39:44).
- Quote: "Sometimes you got to learn the hard way, which is working so hard towards something you want so badly and then realizing, like ... all the wrong places, dude." (40:59, Nate)
5. Road Rage, Apologies, and Societal Rules
- Humorous take on road rage: The pair breakdown the etiquette of road rage (63:03), the lack of a universal “I’m sorry” hand gesture, and riff about high-stakes apology scenarios.
6. Substance Use—Wine, Coffee, Nicotine, and Moderation
- The pleasures and rationalizations of wine: Nate explains how important wine is to his and his wife’s enjoyment of life and food, joking that he’d have to stop eating red meat if he couldn’t have wine with it (83:33).
- Quote: "If I ever stop drinking wine, I'm gonna stop eating red meat as well. … I think it's disrespectful to the animal." (83:33, Nate)
- Addiction vs. enjoyment: Pete gets candid about his own relationship with addictive substances like coffee and nicotine gum, and the fine line between appreciation and compulsion (88:12–91:52).
- Quote: "What's the difference between being addicted to something and something just being incredible?" (90:48, Pete)
7. Getting Older, Emotional Intelligence, and Letting Go
- Anger as an easy, 'empowering' emotion: Both talk about growing out of constantly indulging in anger, instead recognizing it as an unhealthy, reactive default and learning to let it pass (61:03).
- Developing loving-kindness: Nate shares his yoga mantra — "strength, symmetry, clarity, forgiveness" — and how he’s started including even people who annoy him in his loving intentions (77:48–79:11).
- Quote: “Treating them exactly like people that I love. … That’s pretty humbling.” (78:57, Nate)
8. Memorable Moments & Comic Anecdotes
- Nate shares a hilarious moment involving a friend sleepwalking, peeing into a succulent, and a neighbor playing trumpet at a party (102:00–106:45).
- Quote: "He pissed like nobody was watching. … We were all falling out of our chairs." (104:07, Nate)
Notable Quotes & Moments
-
On comedy craft:
- "You did this thing that's very topical, very fearless." (07:16, Pete)
- "Your set is listening to itself. … It comes back, it's on a tone." (10:17, Pete)
-
On the comedian's psyche:
- "There's an urgency to it, and I felt that here." (13:02, Pete)
- "It's a strange combination: intense insecurity and also a pretty clean confidence in yourself." (32:38, Nate)
-
On societal rules, the self, and relationships:
- "I probably complicate things a little bit more than she does." (36:21, Nate)
- "In other situations that I’m able to produce and construct for myself, I turn out to be very smart. … That’s the cure for dumb." (40:08, Nate & Pete)
-
On moderation and pleasure:
- "It's easier with coffee … My last thought of the day is, pretty excited for tomorrow's coffee." (91:42, Pete)
- "I feel like I know where the line is and that's healthy for you." (92:34, Nate)
-
On letting go of anger:
- "As I've gotten older, I get really good at stopping it … That’s your comfort zone, you know how to do that, it empowers you." (60:51–61:00, Nate)
Timestamps for Key Segments
- [07:04] – Pete analyzes Nate's special and the virtues of classic comedy structure
- [14:03] – The mental multitasking and challenges of performing stand-up
- [15:46] – Sensitivity and "listening" to a live audience
- [16:31] – Anger as disguised sadness, comedians as exposed nerves
- [26:03]–[29:01] – Nate tells story of meeting and courting his wife
- [32:37] – Both discuss compulsive need for validation and comedy as identity
- [35:48] – On being the “ball and chain” in a relationship
- [39:44] – Self-perception: feeling ‘dumb’ in the system, finding one’s strengths
- [61:03] – Anger as an easy emotion; learning to regulate it with age
- [77:48]–[79:11] – Nate’s yoga mantra and learning loving-kindness
- [83:33]–[84:55] – On wine, ritual, and making pleasure special
- [88:12]–[91:52] – Nicotine, coffee, moderation, and addictive pleasures
- [102:00]–[106:45] – Mushroom party, sleepwalking piss story, trumpet anecdote
Tone & Notable Banter
- Playful, digressive, and self-deprecating with a high level of mutual respect and warmth.
- Hilarious, extended riffs on old SNL sketches, Crystal Pepsi, aging, and road rage etiquette.
- Recurrent themes of vulnerability, earnestness, and willingness to dissect awkward or uncomfortable personal truths.
- “Keep it crispy” banter and repeated call-backs to the unique “weirdness” of comedians.
Closing Thoughts
This episode offers a classic You Made It Weird experience: a blend of serious introspection and comic absurdity. Pete and Nate are especially open about the inner wiring of the comedian’s mind, the difference between pursuing pleasure and feeding compulsion, and the bittersweet hilarity of failing, aging, loving, and striving for meaning as weirdos in a very weird world.