Climate Ricks Will Sink Home Values 3/5/25

Summary

---

Podcast Summary: Your Money Minute

Episode: "Climate Risks Will Sink Home Values"

Date: March 5, 2025
Host: Jessica Ettinger (CNBC)

---

Overview

This concise 60-second episode of Your Money Minute spotlights the growing impact of climate risk on U.S. home values. The episode draws a critical connection between increasingly unaffordable insurance and falling property values, referencing financial experts who see clear parallels between the climate crisis and the 2008 financial crash.

---

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. Real Estate Assumptions Challenged

• For years, real estate has been seen as a reliable way to build wealth—"Real estate is a good investment and almost always increases in value." (Jessica Ettinger, 00:02)
• This assumption is threatened as climate risks drive up the cost of home ownership, depressing property values.

2. Insurance Costs & Market Disruption

• Insurers have historically absorbed the cost of increasing weather events.
• That is "all falling apart now” (Unattributed, summarizing expert input, 00:16).
• As insurance companies raise premiums or withdraw from high-risk regions, owning and selling homes becomes more expensive and complicated.

3. Expert Parallels to the Subprime Crisis

• Dave Burt (Delta Terra Capital): A financial expert known for predicting the subprime mortgage crisis sees an echo of those problems today—"He sees a similar pattern emerging now with climate change. And he says at least 20% of American homes, one in every five, will be devalued." (Jessica Ettinger, 00:24)
• He warns of a substantial market correction spurred by climate-related risks.

4. Projected Market Fallout

• Dave Burt: "We think that those 20% of markets could be down 30% over the next five years in value, which is very similar to the 2007-2012 Great Recession experience." (Dave Burt, 00:47)
• This could mean a dramatic hit to the wealth of homeowners in high-risk areas.

5. The Divide: Wealthy vs. Mortgage-Dependent Buyers

• Wealthier homeowners can "self-insure" and absorb added costs.
• Buyers relying on mortgages are more vulnerable:
  • Lenders require insurance, so as premiums spike, many potential buyers may be locked out because they can't afford both the mortgage and mandatory coverage.
  • This diminished buyer pool can force sellers to drop prices further.
• "That leaves the seller less able to sell their home without lowering the price." (Jessica Ettinger, 01:15)

---

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• Jessica Ettinger (00:02):
  “You’ve heard for years that real estate is a good investment and almost always increases in value. But climate risk is front and center. And when the cost of owning a home rises, its value falls.”
• Dave Burt (00:47):
  “We think that those 20% of markets could be down 30% over the next five years in value, which is very similar to the 2007-2012 Great Recession experience.”
• Jessica Ettinger (01:09):
  “The wealthy will self-insure... buyers who need home loans may be priced out... and that leaves the seller less able to sell their home without lowering the price.”

---

Timestamps for Key Segments

• 00:00 – Introduction: Challenging long-held beliefs about real estate value.
• 00:16 – Insurance costs surge; the old pricing model collapses.
• 00:24 – Dave Burt’s warning: Climate crisis as the new subprime mortgage risk.
• 00:47 – Market correction forecast: Up to 30% drop in 20% of U.S. home markets within five years.
• 01:03 – How insurance and mortgage requirements accelerate the value decline.
• 01:15 – Sellers struggle to find buyers without dropping prices.

---

Summary

This episode distills a powerful warning: climate risks are no longer a theoretical threat, but an immediate force reshaping the American real estate market. As insurance costs climb and lending tightens, up to one in five homes could see values plummet by 30% over five years, echoing the devastation of the last housing crash. The episode urges listeners to recognize the financial realities of a warming world.

For more information and the full story, listeners are directed to CNBC.com.

Transcript

[A]

With a CNBC you Money minute. I'm Jessica Ettinger. You've heard for years that real estate is a good investment and almost always increases in value. But climate risk is front and center. And when the cost of owning a home rises, its value falls.

[B]

In the past, insurers have not increased prices because of these increasing weather events. That's all falling apart now.

[A]

Delta Terra's Dave Burt on cnbc. Burt made a lot of money predicting the risks in the subprime mortgage market more than 15 years ago. He sees a similar pattern emerging now with climate change. And he says at least 20% of American homes, one in every five, will be devalued. CNBC's Diana Olek spoke with him. The correction, he says, will be severe.

[B]

We think that those 20% of markets could be down 30% over the next five years in value, in value, which is very similar to the 2007-2012 Great Recession experience.

[A]

While the wealth wealthy will self insure because mortgage companies require insurance on the property, buyers who need home loans may be priced out of what they might have been able to afford. When you add on that climate risk insurance and that leaves the seller less able to sell their home without lowering the price. You can see the Full [e-mail] I'm Jessica Ettinger, CNBC.

[C]

Still jumping from tab to tab to create trades With Fidelity Trading Dashboard, you can easily access live data, advanced charting, portfolio insights and automated alerts all on one screen. Our streamlined view lets you quickly create and execute your trading strategies to help keep up with the markets. Because better trading starts with finding what you need fast. Your Fidelity Trading Dashboard is ready now. For free, visit fidelity.com tradingdashboard Investing involves risk, including risk of loss. Fidelity Brokerage Services, LLC Member nyse, SIPC.