Books With Your Besties

Episode: Unraveling the Delphi Murders Part II
Hosts: Emily and Ashley
Release Date: May 23, 2025

Introduction

In the riveting second installment of their deep dive into the tragic Delphi murders, hosts Emily and Ashley return to dissect the intricate details surrounding the disappearance and death of Abby Williams and Libby German. Building upon the foundation laid in Part I, this episode delves into the investigation's progression, focusing primarily on Ron Logan, a key figure whose actions and connections have kept investigators and the public intrigued.

Recap of the Case

The Delphi murders, which occurred on February 13, 2017, involved the abduction and subsequent murder of two 13-year-old girls, Abby Williams and Libby German, in Delphi, Indiana. Their bodies were discovered the following day on the property of Ron Logan, a local landowner.

Ron Logan: The Central Figure

Background: Ron Logan owned a sprawling 30-acre property near Deer Creek, adjacent to the Monon High Bridge Trail—the final known location of the girls before their disappearance. At the time of the murders, Logan was on probation for a DUI conviction, which explicitly prohibited him from driving.

Probation Violation: On the day of the murders, Logan drove to a nearby town, directly violating his probation terms. Upon confrontation by investigators, he not only admitted to this breach but also attempted to fabricate an alibi by requesting a family member to vouch for his whereabouts. This suspicious behavior raised significant red flags among law enforcement.

Hosts' Discussion: Ashley remarks, “It was unclear whether Logan's scramble to find an alibi was due to the murders or his impending return to jail for violating probation,” highlighting the murky motivations behind his actions.

Key Reasons Ron Logan Became a Suspect

1. Proximity to the Crime Scene:

   • Logan's property was located approximately 1,400 feet from where the girls' bodies were found, naturally placing him under scrutiny.
   • Quote: Emily states, “If bodies are found on your property, I'm pretty sure you're going to be a suspect.” [05:15]

2. Alibi Discrepancies:

   • Logan claimed he was at an aquarium store between 2-3 PM on February 13th, supported by a supposed receipt timestamped 5:21 PM, conflicting with his stated timeline.
   • Cell phone data revealed his phone was near the Monon High Bridge Trail during the critical time frame, contradicting his alibi.

3. Physical Similarities to the Suspect:

   • Witnesses noted that Logan’s physical build and voice bore resemblance to the man captured in a video recorded by Libby German.

4. Behavioral Concerns:

   • Logan had a history of violent behavior, including threats toward former partners and ownership of multiple weapons, further cementing his status as a person of interest.

Quote: Ashley adds, “Logan’s attempt to fabricate an alibi only deepened the mystery surrounding his involvement.” [12:40]

Investigation Developments

Despite the mounting evidence, including the proximity of Logan’s property and the inconsistencies in his alibi, he was never charged with the murders. Instead, investigations remained inconclusive, leaving Logan as an enigmatic figure in the case until his death in 2022 due to COVID-19 complications.

Quote: Emily reflects, “He has remained a murky potential suspect in the case,” underscoring the unresolved nature of his involvement. [20:05]

The Bombshell: Alleged Confession

A groundbreaking turn in the investigation emerged in February 2025 when attorneys for convicted murderer Richard Allen filed a motion requesting the release of evidence related to inmate Ricky Davis, who was incarcerated alongside Logan.

Key Details:

• Alleged Confession: Ricky Davis claimed that Logan confessed to him about killing the girls using a box cutter. Logan purportedly described how the situation escalated "out of hand" during a confrontation on his property.
• Additional Accusations: Logan allegedly mentioned two other individuals involved in the murders, although their identities remain undisclosed.

Quote: From Fox 59 News, Max Lewis states, “Logan has made reference to the killings in Delphi, Indiana. He told me he was the one who had killed those girls and that it got out of hand.” [35:50]

Supporting Evidence:

• Phone Data: Logan’s phone was detected near the crime scene at crucial times, including a text sent at 7:56 PM and another at 10:16 PM on the day of the murders, aligning with Davis’s account of Logan returning to the crime scene later that evening.
• Details in Confession: Logan’s confession included specific actions, such as attempting to move Libby's body and burning his clothes in a fire pit—details not previously public.

Quote: Ashley emphasizes, “The data completely lines up with this alleged confession and that he returned to the crime scene later.” [45:30]

Current Standings and Ongoing Questions

As of the episode's release, while significant information has surfaced regarding Ron Logan's potential involvement, the case remains officially unsolved. The revelation of Logan's alleged confession adds complexity, yet concrete charges have yet to materialize posthumously.

Hosts' Reflection: Emily and Ashley ponder the implications of Logan’s death on the case's resolution, questioning whether the truth will ever fully emerge.

Quote: Emily concludes, “With Logan gone, the door closes on many possibilities, but the search for answers continues.” [58:10]

Conclusion

In this compelling episode, Emily and Ashley navigate the labyrinthine investigation of the Delphi murders, shedding light on Ron Logan's contentious role and the emerging evidence that both implicates and complicates his legacy. The hosts leave listeners contemplating the elusive nature of truth in criminal investigations and the enduring quest for justice for Abby and Libby.

Notable Quotes:

• Emily: "If bodies are found on your property, I'm pretty sure you're going to be a suspect." [05:15]
• Ashley: "Logan’s attempt to fabricate an alibi only deepened the mystery surrounding his involvement." [12:40]
• Emily: "He has remained a murky potential suspect in the case." [20:05]
• Max Lewis (Fox 59): "Logan has made reference to the killings in Delphi, Indiana. He told me he was the one who had killed those girls and that it got out of hand." [35:50]
• Ashley: "The data completely lines up with this alleged confession and that he returned to the crime scene later." [45:30]
• Emily: "With Logan gone, the door closes on many possibilities, but the search for answers continues." [58:10]

Final Thoughts

"Unraveling the Delphi Murders Part II" serves as a critical examination of the case, blending thorough investigative discussion with the hosts' signature chemistry and insightful commentary. For enthusiasts of true crime and intricate storytelling, this episode offers a compelling exploration of one of Indiana's most haunting unsolved cases.

For more in-depth analysis and behind-the-scenes content, consider supporting Emily and Ashley on Patreon to access bonus episodes and exclusive materials.