Podcast
We Should Know Better (fka Bros, Bibles & Beer)
Hosted by Andy McCraw, Zack Krater · EN
Welcome to the We Should Know Better Podcast (fka Bros, Bibles & Beer)!
We believe that exploring the depths of faith, theology, and culture shouldn't feel like sitting through a dry lecture. Whether we're dissecting complex scripture or discussing how faith intersects with modern life, we do it with honesty, humor, and the realization that—honestly—we should probably know better by now.
Join us for unfiltered conversations that challenge the mind without losing the heart (or the sense of humor).
15episodes
Episodes
Newest firstAll episodes
277. When Love Becomes Your Worst Enemy w/ Matthew J Distefano
3w ago01:21:06Tap to summarizeIn this engaging conversation, Matthew Distefano explores the profound themes of love, morality, and storytelling through the lens of video games like The Last of Us and Red Dead Redemption 2. He wrote a killer book on it called "Saints, Sinners, and Clickers: Love and Loss in The Last of Us". The discussion centers on how these narratives challenge our perceptions of morality, the power of storytelling, and the intersection of faith and culture. Connect with Matthew on Instagram, check out Quoir Publishing on Instagram & YouTube, and The Heretic Happy Hour Podcast SUBSCRIBE & SHARE us this week!Contact Us: brosbiblesbeer@gmail.com Leave Us A VoicemailYouTubeSimpleCastSpotifyApple PodcastsFacebook XInstaBros Bibles & Beer is: Jeff, Zack & Andy Find us wherever fine podcasts are distributed. Oh, and share us with a friend this week! Grace. Peace. Cheers! Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.
Transcribe →
277. The Holy Trinity of Christian Outrage
Apr 2302:10:19Tap to summarizeWhat happens when a simple video of leading worship sparks a viral "kerfuffle" north of a million views? This week, the guys sit down with Courtney Lancaster from the "Heal/Create" podcast to unpack the "Holy Trinity of Christian Outrage": religion, gender roles, and the deconstruction movement. Courtney shares the story behind her unexpected Instagram traction after posting a video of herself leading worship and opening up about her "faith reorganization." The conversation explores the tension of staying within a faith tradition while holding views that differ from conservative evangelical norms. Key Discussion Points: The "Mean Christian Comments" Game: Courtney and the hosts react to actual comments from her viral post, ranging from questions about women in ministry to accusations of "New Age psycho-babble." Theology of Shame vs. Trauma Recovery: A deep dive into why many were raised with the identity of "shame and depravity" (the idea that God is only good because we are bad) and how trauma-informed therapy offers a different lens on our value as "well-loved children of God." Worship Lyrics and Integrity: Courtney explains why she refuses to sing songs that rehearse a shame narrative, such as certain lyrics in "Reckless Love," arguing that a child shouldn't have to "earn" or "deserve" a parent's love. Post-Christianity and Individualism: The crew debates the concept of "post-Christianity"—stripping out parts of the faith one likes while discarding the rest—and whether this leads to a "narcissistic" echo chamber or a healthy "faith reorganization." The Future of the Church: Reflections on the closing of Mountain View Church and the hope that more "centered-set" spaces will emerge where people can wrestle with divergent ideas without being "kicked out." Information Overload: Andy and Courtney discuss how our brains aren't designed to handle the "woes of the world" delivered via 24/7 digital feeds, and the importance of "touching grass" to maintain mental health. SUBSCRIBE & SHARE us this week!Contact Us: brosbiblesbeer@gmail.com Leave Us A VoicemailYouTubeSimpleCastSpotifyApple PodcastsFacebook XInstaBros Bibles & Beer is: Jeff, Zack & Andy Find us wherever fine podcasts are distributed. Oh, and share us with a friend this week! Grace. Peace. Cheers! Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.
Transcribe →
276. The Biblical Zombie Apocalypse
Apr 1401:35:29Tap to summarizeWe dive into one of the strangest and most cinematic passages in the entire New Testament: the "resurrection of the saints" in Jerusalem following Jesus crucifixion. Was it a literal historical event, a metaphorical callback to Ezekiel, or something else entirely? The boys play a high-stakes round of "Zombie or Zom-bae," testing their Bible trivia on everything from Lazarus’s "smell factor" to Elisha’s miracle bones. Bros, Bibles and Beer is officially rebranding soon. We discuss the heart behind our new name—We Should Know Better—and share some heavy news regarding the closure of our church home. 00:00 - Intro: Trump Bobbleheads & Hop Secret Beer 02:34 - New Game: Zombie or Zombie! 04:00 - The 48-Hour Resurrection Delay (Matthew 27) 06:10 - Lazarus & the 4-Day Cultural Proof 07:55 - Elisha’s Miracle Bones vs. Gary 10:00 - Tabitha’s Portfolio & Brisket Recipes 11:55 - Andy’s Carpool Lane Confession 15:00 - The Theology of "Celestial Zombies" 21:20 - Midrash: Was it a Literal Zombie Army? 27:00 - The "Revealed" Veil: A New Perspective on Access 31:00 - Oral Tradition: 9/11 and the Megaphone Theory 43:00 - Is the Bible "Perfect"? Exploring Literary Genres 50:30 - Major Announcement: Rebranding to "We Should Know Better" 01:00:58 - Hard News: The Closing of Mountain View Church 01:18:20 - Why the Community Was Worth Fighting For 01:28:30 - Muscle Mommies & Kerry Underwood’s Legs 01:33:30 - Future Plans & Final Cheers SUBSCRIBE & SHARE us this week!Contact Us: brosbiblesbeer@gmail.com Leave Us A VoicemailYouTubeSimpleCastSpotifyApple PodcastsFacebook XInstaBros Bibles & Beer is: Jeff, Zack & Andy Find us wherever fine podcasts are distributed. Oh, and share us with a friend this week! Grace. Peace. Cheers! Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.
Transcribe →
Biblical Israel Is Not Today's Israel
Mar 3102:15:48Tap to summarizeIn this heated and deeply personal episode of Bros Bibles & Beer, Andy McCraw, Zack Krater, and "professional Christian" guest Carey Robinson deconstruct the modern evangelical obsession with defending the modern State of Israel at all costs. The crew kicks things off with a high-stakes game of "Rapture, Barely Even Know Her" forcing the hosts to choose between being a "Beamer" (pre-tribulation escapee) or "Last Man Standing" (tribulation survivor). The conversation turns provocative as they challenge the "ironclad truth" of Dispensationalism—a 19th-century theological framework they argue has been used to manipulate the American church into blind support for the modern State of Israel. From Netanyahu and Epstein files to the "uniparty" and toxic empathy, no cultural third rail is left untouched. Are we following the Prince of Peace or just political operatives in pulpits? Grab a beverage of choice and join us for a dive into biblical prophecy, Christian Zionism, and why spiritual maturity often looks a lot like deconstruction. SUBSCRIBE & SHARE us this week!Contact Us: brosbiblesbeer@gmail.com Leave Us A VoicemailYouTubeSimpleCastSpotifyApple PodcastsFacebook XInstaBros Bibles & Beer is: Jeff, Zack & Andy Find us wherever fine podcasts are distributed. Oh, and share us with a friend this week! Grace. Peace. Cheers! Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.
Transcribe →
273. Is James Talerico's Theology Actually Dangerous?
Mar 1401:51:33Tap to summarizeThis week on Bros, Bibles & Beer, Andy McCraw, Zack Krater, and producer Colin dive into the theological firestorm surrounding Texas State Representative James Talerico. Prompted by Allie Beth Stuckey’s recent "demonic" label of Talerico, the guys put their own beliefs to the test with a provocative new segment: "Are You a Heretic?" Using a quiz powered by Gemini AI, the team explores the divide between traditional orthodoxy and Talerico’s progressive "liberation theology." From debating whether Jesus was a political revolutionary to deconstructing the "theology of consent" regarding reproductive rights, the conversation gets personal, heated, and deeply honest. Also in this episode: -The Allie Beth Stuckey Critique: Does labeling progressive Christians "demonic" go too far, or is she right to sound the alarm on "twisting" scripture? -The Sovereignty of God: A breakdown of Stuckey’s view on God’s control vs. the guys' own experiences with deconstruction. -Ozzy Osbourne & the Prince of Darkness: Why you can't always trust the media's portrayal of a person's faith. -Vegas Trip & Satanic Spheres: Andy shares his "uncomfortable" experience with the dark visuals at a recent concert in the Las Vegas Sphere. -The "Joy and Matt" Mystery: A strange, dark-web voicemail involves missing nail polish and a guy named Matt. SUBSCRIBE & SHARE us this week!Contact Us: brosbiblesbeer@gmail.com Leave Us A VoicemailYouTubeSimpleCastSpotifyApple PodcastsFacebook XInstaBros Bibles & Beer is: Jeff, Zack & Andy Find us wherever fine podcasts are distributed. Oh, and share us with a friend this week! Grace. Peace. Cheers! Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.
Transcribe →
272. Truth Over Tribe & God's Forgiveness vs Ours
Mar 601:12:25Tap to summarizeThis episode explores faith, culture, forgiveness, and the influence of social contagion, blending humor with deep philosophical and theological insights. Join us for a candid conversation on how beliefs shape our understanding of God, morality, and society. SUBSCRIBE & SHARE us this week!Contact Us: brosbiblesbeer@gmail.com Leave Us A VoicemailYouTubeSimpleCastSpotifyApple PodcastsFacebook XInstaBros Bibles & Beer is: Jeff, Zack & Andy Find us wherever fine podcasts are distributed. Oh, and share us with a friend this week! Grace. Peace. Cheers! Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.
Transcribe →
271. Bethel Church and Shawn Bolz Exposed?
Feb 2501:46:33Tap to summarizeIn this episode of Bros Bibles & Beer, the hosts engage in a candid discussion about leadership, accountability, and the recent scandal involving Bethel Church and Sean Bolz. They explore the complexities of truth in social media, the burden of leadership decisions, and the importance of transparency in faith communities. The conversation delves into the cultural dynamics of church leadership and the impact of prophetic deception, ultimately reflecting on the need for responsible leadership in the face of crisis. SUBSCRIBE & SHARE us this week!Contact Us: brosbiblesbeer@gmail.com Leave Us A VoicemailYouTubeSimpleCastSpotifyApple PodcastsFacebook XInstaBros Bibles & Beer is: Jeff, Zack & Andy Find us wherever fine podcasts are distributed. Oh, and share us with a friend this week! Grace. Peace. Cheers! Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.
Transcribe →
270. Kirk Cameron's Brave New Hell & Is This Christmas Prophecy False?
Dec 1501:23:44Tap to summarizeShould Christians ditch Santa? Is the "Christmas" prophecy in the book of Isaiah really about Jesus? And Kirk Cameron recently confessed (bravely, dare we say) to his changing view on hell.In episode 270 of Bros Bibles & Beer, Andy, Zack, & producer Colin explore the cultural implications of Santa Claus as a replacement for Christ, the alleged deceitfulness of teaching children about Santa, and their personal experiences with the myth. They talk about Christmas bible prophecy interpretations, particularly Isaiah's prophecy, and discuss evolving beliefs about hell, including Kirk Cameron's controversial new views. The conversation emphasizes the urgency of faith, the complexity of biblical interpretation, and the potential future of Christians leaning towards annihilationism and universal reconciliation versus people going to hell forever."Your actions betray your stated beliefs." Takeaways: -Has Santa become a cultural replacement for Christ? -Will teaching children about Santa undermine their trust in parents? -Have you had a traumatic Santa experience? -Isaiah's prophecy may raise questions about its interpretation regarding Jesus. -The concept of hell is evolving, with many questioning traditional views. -Kirk Cameron's shift in belief about hell is significant and brave. -Urgency, or lack thereof, in sharing faith reflects deeper beliefs about salvation. -Biblical interpretation can be complex and context-dependent. -Annihilationism presents a compelling alternative to eternal torment. -The future of faith may lean towards universal reconciliation. SUBSCRIBE & SHARE us this week!Contact Us: brosbiblesbeer@gmail.com Leave Us A VoicemailYouTubeSimpleCastSpotifyApple PodcastsFacebook XInstaBros Bibles & Beer is: Jeff, Zack & Andy Find us wherever fine podcasts are distributed. Oh, and share us with a friend this week! Grace. Peace. Cheers! Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.
Transcribe →
269. Confessions of an Ex-Pastor w/ Todd Rodarmel
Nov 1801:55:03Tap to summarizeThe great and powerful Todd Rodarmel returns! A former pastor, Todd reflects on what he does and doesn't miss about full-time ministry, learning about the nature of God via parenting, and the one thing the Bible does really well. Also, we react to a viral clip of Christian nationalist pastor Dale Partridge calling for the repeal of women's voting rights, and many much more things that have interest for you. NOTE: Apologies for the audio quality. The original audio was corrupted. We were able to salvage it to a degree, but you will notice it's not quite to our standards. But don't let that stop you from finding the gold conversational nuggets that lie within. SUBSCRIBE & SHARE us this week!Contact Us: brosbiblesbeer@gmail.com Leave Us A VoicemailYouTubeSimpleCastSpotifyApple PodcastsFacebook XInstaBros Bibles & Beer is: Jeff, Zack & Andy Find us wherever fine podcasts are distributed. Oh, and share us with a friend this week! Grace. Peace. Cheers! Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.
Transcribe →
268. Will Trump Go To Heaven? Is Peace In The Middle East Possible?
Oct 2301:19:46Tap to summarizePeace in the Middle East? Donald Trump will get into heaven, but will he like what he sees? And the average Christian doesn't know how grace works. In this episode of Bros Bibles & Beer, the hosts delve into complex themes surrounding faith, love, forgiveness, and the nature of justice. They explore the cognitive dissonance experienced by individuals grappling with their beliefs, the pursuit of enemies in love, and the vagueness of love itself. The conversation also touches on cultural perspectives, the role of comments from listeners, and reflections on political issues and peace in the Middle East. Throughout, the hosts emphasize the importance of connection, grace, and understanding in navigating these challenging topics. SUBSCRIBE & SHARE us this week!Contact Us: brosbiblesbeer@gmail.com Leave Us A VoicemailYouTubeSimpleCastSpotifyApple PodcastsFacebook XInstaBros Bibles & Beer is: Jeff, Zack & Andy Find us wherever fine podcasts are distributed. Oh, and share us with a friend this week! Grace. Peace. Cheers! Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.
Transcribe →