Call Her Daddy Podcast Summary

Episode: Amaya: Love Island Tell All
Release Date: July 16, 2025
Host: Alex Cooper
Guest: Amaya Papaya

Introduction

In this episode of Call Her Daddy, host Alex Cooper welcomes Amaya Papaya, the recent winner of Love Island. The conversation delves deep into Amaya's journey on the show, her personal experiences, relationships formed within the villa, and her future aspirations.

Amaya's Entry into Love Island

Amaya shares how she was discovered by Love Island without formally applying, emphasizing the spontaneous nature of her participation.

Amaya Papaya [12:42]: "They slid in your DMs and go down in the DM."

She recounts the surreal moment when she was invited to join the show while celebrating her mother's birthday in Fiji.

Amaya Papaya [12:42]: "It was just a very me mommy and daughter moment... I was just like, listen, there's some scenes that you might have to turn your head away for, but, girl, I'm excited to do the show."

Initial Experiences and Challenges in the Villa

Upon entering the villa as a "bombshell," Amaya discusses the initial challenges of fitting in and forming friendships amidst existing couples.

Amaya Papaya [23:30]: "The first couple of days were tough... I was spending the whole day, like, crying, and then somebody was like, 'Is someone crying?' And I'm like, 'No, it's just me. Allergies, bro.'"

Amaya highlights the emotional toll of the environment, where isolation can lead to self-doubt.

Amaya Papaya [03:17]: "I felt so misunderstood... Is there something wrong with me?"

Navigating Relationships and Connections

Amaya opens up about her attractions and connections within the villa, particularly her relationship with Brian, her eventual partner and Love Island co-winner.

• Attraction to Jeremiah:

  Amaya Papaya [17:05]: "I was attracted to Jeremiah because of his symmetrical face. He's handsome."

• Brief Connection with Ace:

  Amaya Papaya [18:27]: "And now burgers outside. No, baby, we were in and then out."

• Deepening Bond with Brian: Amaya details how Brian stood up for her during a contentious moment, solidifying their bond.

  Amaya Papaya [45:15]: "I felt like he was my knight in armor at that night, like, just saving me."

  Their relationship blossomed through intimate moments and mutual understanding.

  Amaya Papaya [46:42]: "It was steamy, all right... it was just us two."

Challenges Faced: The Heart Rate Challenge

A pivotal moment in the season was the Heart Rate Challenge, where Amaya faced verbal attacks from multiple male contestants.

Amaya Papaya [39:42]: "It was a really, really tough moment for me, to be honest with you."

Amaya expresses frustration over the lack of support from her fellow female contestants during this ordeal.

Amaya Papaya [43:10]: "I was just me, particularly especially like me... it was my voice against three guys."

Despite the overwhelming situation, Amaya remained steadfast and resilient.

Amaya Papaya [44:08]: "My skin is so thicker now. Thicker than raw beef."

Friendship Dynamics in the Villa

Amaya discusses the evolving friendships within the villa, highlighting her bond with Huda and Landry, who provided emotional support during challenging times.

Amaya Papaya [31:11]: "Me and Landry have a great, great friendship... she was really one of the main girls, just consoling me."

She also sheds light on Alondra's supportive nature, acting as a grounding force for others.

Amaya Papaya [31:52]: "She was ride or die for Shelly, and they were best friends... she would be there for someone who was down bad."

Unexpected Twists and Eliminations

The sudden departure of Sierra from the villa left Amaya and others in shock, reflecting the unpredictable nature of reality TV.

Amaya Papaya [53:28]: "One, like, literally we all started the morning together, and then out of nowhere, she did disappear."

Amaya speculates on the reasons behind Sierra's abrupt exit, emphasizing the importance of respect and personal responsibility.

Amaya Papaya [54:21]: "Everyone should be respected... She is a grown woman. So, like, hopefully moving on forward."

Life After Love Island

Post-show, Amaya plans to continue engaging with her supporters while pursuing her academic goals.

Amaya Papaya [65:25]: "A goal of mine... is definitely to get my PhD. So maybe next year, your girl will be returning back to school."

Her relationship with Brian is set to evolve beyond the confines of the villa, with plans to manage a long-distance relationship.

Amaya Papaya [66:42]: "We're definitely going to be taking turns seeing each other. And Boston is not far away from me."

Together, Amaya and Brian make history as the first Hispanic couple to win Love Island.

Amaya Papaya [66:59]: "It really is a huge moment... I feel blessed, and I feel so much gratitude."

Rapid-Fire Fun and Personal Insights

Towards the end of the episode, Amaya engages in a rapid-fire segment, sharing humorous and candid responses about her personal life, fears, and quirky habits.

• Weirdest Place to Have Sex:

  Amaya Papaya [56:29]: "CVS pharmacy. In the bathroom."

• Most Unhinged Post-Breakup Action:

  Amaya Papaya [57:20]: "I called my ex boyfriend's mom and I'm like, 'How dare you raise a son like this?'"

• Embarrassing Drinking Moment:

  Amaya Papaya [59:58]: "I started freestyling rap on a date on our way back home."

These light-hearted questions add a fun and relatable dimension to the episode, showcasing Amaya's vibrant personality.

Mental Health and Realities Behind the Scenes

Amaya emphasizes the importance of mental health support within the villa, acknowledging the intense pressures contestants face.

Amaya Papaya [68:49]: "We have doctors... whenever we are really having a bad moment... we're able to take a break and talk to doctors if needed."

She advocates for authenticity and emotional resilience, encouraging listeners to stay true to themselves.

Amaya Papaya [72:11]: "Never change for yourself. So as long as I keep on sending that message out, whether it's like my mini, like, get ready with me sort of vlogs, then for sure."

Closing Remarks

Amaya concludes the interview with heartfelt gratitude towards Alex Cooper and the Call Her Daddy community, reiterating her commitment to empowering women and fostering genuine connections.

Amaya Papaya [72:34]: "You just stay true to who you are... shine and illuminate you."

Both host and guest celebrate the successful collaboration, marking the end of a revealing and inspiring episode.

Amaya Papaya [73:39]: "I love you, Amaya. Call her Daddy. We did it."

Notable Quotes

• Amaya on Resilience:

  "It's my skin. My skin is so thicker now. Thicker than raw beef." [44:08]

• Amaya on Authenticity:

  "Never change for yourself... when people are making you feel like, okay, what's going on with me? What's wrong?" [72:11]

• Amaya on Love Island Impact:

  "I'm the first generation to be here in America, first generational nurse... Latino culture, to me, is very, very huge." [66:59]

Conclusion

This episode of Call Her Daddy offers an intimate glimpse into Amaya Papaya's transformative experience on Love Island. From emotional struggles and relationship dynamics to personal growth and future aspirations, Amaya's story is both inspiring and relatable. Her candid discussions about mental health and authenticity resonate deeply, providing valuable insights for listeners navigating their own personal journeys.