Detailed Summary of "Dragnet: The Big Heel" Episode

Podcast Information:

• Title: Choice Classic Radio Detectives | Old Time Radio
• Episode: Dragnet: The Big Heel (July 20, 1954)
• Release Date: July 29, 2025
• Host: Choice Classic Radio
• Description: Showcasing the greatest detectives from old-time radio, featuring popular programs from the Golden Age of Radio.

Introduction

"Dragnet: The Big Heel" is a classic episode that delves into a compelling police investigation led by Detective Sergeant Joe Friday and his partner, Frank Smith. Set in the sweltering heat of Los Angeles on July 6th, the episode captures the meticulous process of solving a series of juvenile burglaries through keen observation and persistent detective work.

Case Introduction

The episode opens with Friday and Frank reviewing the details of a series of housebreakings believed to be perpetrated by a juvenile thief. The primary clue linking the crimes is a unique heel mark found at each burglary site.

Friday: "The heel mark, same as in the other. You get a cast of it?" (05:20)

They discuss the lack of significant physical evidence, noting that the burglar seems to favor stealing inexpensive costume jewelry, which suggests a lack of profit motive.

Investigation and Clues

Friday and Frank examine the crime scenes, identifying consistent entry methods and negligible stolen items. The detectives focus on the distinctive heel prints, determined to trace their origin.

Frank: "None of them can tell us where it was made." (12:45)

Their investigation leads them to a custom shoe manufacturer, but initial inquiries yield no substantial leads. As the heat persists, the detectives canvass playgrounds, shops, and public areas, attempting to locate potential suspects wearing the unique shoes.

Suspect Identification

Their efforts culminate in a traffic stop involving Alec McCarron, a 16-year-old high school senior. McCarron's shoes match the unique heel marks, and his lack of a prior criminal record raises suspicions.

Friday: "Do you think I'm the one. Well, it looks like it, doesn't it?" (22:30)

McCarron denies involvement, but circumstantial evidence mounts against him as costume jewelry is found in his possession and positively identified by victims.

Family Confrontation

Friday and Frank confront McCarron’s father, Henry McCarron, who vehemently defends his son's innocence, highlighting Alec's well-maintained lifestyle and lack of motive for theft.

Henry McCarron: "I've got faith in my son. He's had all the things a boy could want." (40:15)

Despite Henry's assertions, the evidence seems compelling enough to proceed with juvenile court proceedings against Alec.

Unraveling the Truth

As the case against Alec solidifies, new evidence emerges. The detectives discover that the unique heels were sent out for resoling and had been missing from the returned shoes.

Frank: "Looks like we might be wrong about that McCarran boy." (58:50)

This revelation prompts further investigation, leading them to a shipment from the shoe manufacturer addressed to a suspicious individual named Homer Ellsworth in Ventura, California.

Climactic Resolution

Tracking down Homer Ellsworth reveals inconsistencies, including a missing finger, which tarnishes the credibility of the suspect. The detectives then shift their focus to Fallon, Ellsworth's real name, a former handyman who recently quit his job.

Friday: "You come back with a warrant. If that'd be easier for you." (1:15:30)

Confronting Fallon at his residence, they uncover the truth: Fallon orchestrated the burglaries to frame Alec, fueled by resentment towards Alec’s privileged life.

Fallon: "I put him there. Wanted to sew it up, make it look good." (1:25:10)

Fallon is subsequently tried and convicted of multiple counts of first-degree burglary, vindicating Alec McCarron and restoring justice.

Conclusion

"Dragnet: The Big Heel" effectively illustrates the diligence and ethical considerations inherent in police work. Detective Friday and Frank Smith's unwavering commitment to uncovering the truth not only exonerates an innocent youth but also brings a seasoned criminal to justice. The episode underscores themes of integrity, the pitfalls of circumstantial evidence, and the importance of thorough investigation.

Notable Quotes:

• Frank Smith (05:20): "None of them can tell us where it was made."

• Friday (22:30): "Do you think I'm the one. Well, it looks like it, doesn't it?"

• Henry McCarron (40:15): "I've got faith in my son. He's had all the things a boy could want."

• Frank Smith (58:50): "Looks like we might be wrong about that McCarran boy."

• Friday (1:15:30): "You come back with a warrant. If that'd be easier for you."

This episode not only entertains but also provides valuable insights into investigative procedures and the pursuit of justice, making it a timeless piece for old-time radio enthusiasts and new listeners alike.