Choice Classic Radio Detectives | Old Time Radio
Episode: Sherlock Holmes: The Dying Detective (Hobbs & Shelley)
Release Date: May 9, 2025
Overview
In this captivating episode of Choice Classic Radio Detectives, listeners are immersed in a tense and intricate tale featuring the legendary detective Sherlock Holmes and his steadfast companion, Dr. John Watson. Titled The Dying Detective, the story unfolds with Holmes appearing to be on his deathbed, setting the stage for a dramatic unraveling of deceit, vengeance, and the relentless pursuit of truth.
Characters Introduced
- Sherlock Holmes: The brilliant and enigmatic detective whose apparent illness masks a deeper strategy.
- Dr. John Watson: Holmes's loyal friend and confidant, determined to uncover the truth behind Holmes's condition.
- Mrs. Hudson: The caring landlady of 221 Baker Street, deeply concerned for Holmes's well-being.
- Culverton Smith: The antagonist, a planter with expertise in Eastern diseases, harboring a vendetta against Holmes.
- Inspector Morton: The astute police inspector who plays a pivotal role in the resolution of the mystery.
Plot Summary
1. The Illness of Sherlock Holmes
The episode commences with a distressing scene where Mrs. Hudson informs Dr. Watson about Holmes's declining health. "Sir, he's dying," she exclaims at [02:36]. Holmes adamantly refuses to see a doctor, stating, "No doctor," repeatedly, highlighting his unusual behavior ([01:09], [04:39]).
Dr. Watson arrives at Baker Street to find Holmes weak and unresponsive. The tension escalates as Holmes reveals to Watson that he has contracted a rare and deadly "coolie disease from Sumatra" ([05:31]). Despite Holmes's attempts to discourage Watson from intervening, Watson's medical instincts compel him to take action ([06:57]).
2. The Search for a Specialist
Realizing the gravity of Holmes's condition, Watson seeks the expertise of Culverton Smith, a specialist in Eastern diseases. Holmes, though dismissive of Watson's qualifications, urges him to secure Smith's assistance ([06:13]-[07:35]). Watson faces the challenge of persuading Smith, who harbors a grudge against Holmes, to help his friend.
At [13:11], Culverton Smith arrives at Baker Street, and Holmes engages him in a conversation that gradually reveals Smith's animosity. Through their dialogue, it becomes evident that Smith blames Holmes for the death of his nephew, Victor Savage ([16:04]).
3. The Confrontation and Revelation
As the interaction intensifies, Holmes cleverly maneuvers the conversation to implicate Smith in Victor's death. Smith, in a moment of rage, confesses to causing Victor's demise, revealing his motive rooted in revenge ([16:34]-[17:20]).
Holmes's apparent deterioration serves as a ruse to extract the truth from Smith. The climax unfolds with Inspector Morton's timely arrival, orchestrated as part of Holmes's elaborate plan to expose Smith's guilt ([20:07]-[22:07]).
4. The Resolution
Inspector Morton confronts Culverton Smith, arresting him for the murder of Victor Savage and the attempted murder of Sherlock Holmes ([21:27]-[21:32]). The meticulous execution of Holmes's plan showcases his unparalleled detective skills and strategic thinking.
Watson reflects on the ordeal, recognizing the depth of Holmes's deception and the lengths he went to ensure justice was served ([23:11]-[25:18]). The episode concludes with a reaffirmation of Holmes and Watson's enduring partnership, setting the stage for future adventures.
Key Moments and Notable Quotes
- Holmes's Deniability of Illness
- Sherlock Holmes: "No doctor." ([01:09], [04:39], [05:30])
- Watson's Determination
- Dr. John Watson: "Even if I weren't a doctor, do you think it would stop me doing my duty to an old friend?" ([05:46])
- Culverton Smith's Arrival
- Culverton Smith: "He's a very methodical man and I asked you not to go before six because I knew you wouldn't find him in his study." ([11:28])
- Holmes Confronts Smith
- Sherlock Holmes: "I knew you caused Victor Savage's death." ([17:17])
- Culverton Smith: "Do as you like. I don't see you in any witness box, Holmes." ([17:36])
- Inspector Morton's Intervention
- Inspector Morton: "Culver and Smith, I arrest you on the charge of the murder of one Victor Saddle." ([21:12])
- Holmes's Strategy Revealed
- Inspector Morton: "I owe you a thousand apologies. To think that I should have overlooked you." ([22:07])
Conclusion
Sherlock Holmes: The Dying Detective masterfully blends suspense, character development, and intricate plotting to deliver a memorable installment in the Sherlock Holmes saga. The episode not only showcases Holmes's genius but also delves into themes of loyalty, vengeance, and the pursuit of justice. Through compelling dialogue and strategic storytelling, listeners are treated to a narrative that honors the timeless appeal of the detective genre.
For fans of old-time radio and detective stories, this episode stands out as a testament to the enduring legacy of Sherlock Holmes and the ever-reliable companionship of Dr. John Watson.