Choice Classic Radio Detectives | Old Time Radio

Episode: Sherlock Holmes: The Priory School (Hobbs & Shelley)
Release Date: January 24, 2025
Host/Author: Choice Classic Radio

Introduction

In this captivating episode of Choice Classic Radio Detectives, listeners are transported back to the Golden Age of Radio with the thrilling adventure of Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson. Titled "The Priory School", this story delves into the mysterious disappearance of Lord Saltire and the ensuing investigation that showcases Holmes's unparalleled detective skills.

Case Overview

The episode opens with Dr. Watson recounting the harrowing discovery of Lord Saltire's brutal murder. "This is no accident, Watson. It would take a terrible blow to crush a man's skull like this" (05:30) Holmes deduces the crime was meticulously planned, hinting at a deeper conspiracy.

Investigation Begins

Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson are approached by Dr. Thornicroft Huxtable, who insists on taking them to the Priory School to investigate the abduction of Lord Sulphur, the son of the Duke of Holderness. Dr. Huxtable pleads, "I am very, very grate. Heavens, Holmes" (02:45), emphasizing the urgency of the situation.

Upon arriving at the Priory School, Holmes examines the site thoroughly. He notes discrepancies in the initial investigation, stating, "It has proved completely disappointing" (10:15), signaling his intent to uncover overlooked details.

Clues and Leads

Holmes meticulously analyzes the evidence, focusing on the missing bicycle and the timeline of events. He observes, "All the impressions of tyres... this was the make of tire Heidegger had on his machine" (18:50), leading him to suspect Heidegger's involvement.

The duo explores the moorland surrounding the school, uncovering a concealed bicycle near the body of the German archmaster, Heidegger. "The poor fellow's been brutally murdered" (21:10), Holmes reflects, underscoring the brutality of the crime.

Further investigation reveals horse hoof marks that mimic cow tracks, a clever ruse to mislead the police. Holmes explains, "They attached them to the horses' hooves. So the horses tracks would look like cows and drove the sewers off the scent" (45:00), highlighting the perpetrator's cunning.

Confrontation and Resolution

The climax unfolds as Holmes confronts the Duke of Holderness. Through a series of deductions, Holmes uncovers that James Wilder, the Duke's illegitimate son, orchestrated the kidnapping to discredit the Duke. "I accuse you, your Grayson" (55:20), Holmes declares, leading to Wilder's arrest.

In a poignant moment, Dr. Watson reflects on the complexities of human relationships and secrets: "I couldn't openly acknowledge his relationship to me, so I tried to make it up to him by giving him the best of educations" (50:30), adding depth to the narrative.

Key Quotes

• Dr. Watson: "My medical training had given me some preparation for the many faces of death." (04:20)

• Sherlock Holmes: "A good cyclist doesn't need a road, does he?" (19:40)

• Dr. Huxtable: "I am very, very grate. Heavens, Holmes." (02:45)

• Sherlock Holmes: "This is no accident, Watson. It would take a terrible blow to crush a man's skull like this." (05:30)

• Sherlock Holmes: "They attached them to the horses' hooves. So the horses tracks would look like cows and drove the sewers off the scent." (45:00)

Conclusion

Sherlock Holmes: The Priory School masterfully blends suspense, intricate plotting, and the intellectual prowess of Doyle's beloved detective. Through sharp observations and logical reasoning, Holmes and Watson unravel a web of deceit and familial tension. This episode not only entertains but also explores themes of legitimacy, jealousy, and the lengths one will go to protect their reputation.

Listeners new to this story will find themselves engrossed in the intricate details and timeless appeal of Sherlock Holmes's adventures, while longtime fans will appreciate the faithful rendition and fresh insights presented by Choice Classic Radio.

Timestamp References

• 02:45: Dr. Huxtable's urgent plea to Holmes and Watson.
• 04:20: Dr. Watson's reflection on his medical training.
• 05:30: Holmes's observation of the murder's brutality.
• 10:15: Holmes critiques the initial investigation.
• 18:50: Holmes examines the bicycle evidence.
• 19:40: Dialogue about the significance of the bicycle.
• 21:10: Discovery of Heidegger's body.
• 45:00: Explanation of the misleading hoof marks.
• 50:30: Dr. Watson discusses his relationship with James Wilder.
• 55:20: Holmes accuses the Duke of wrongdoing.

Note: Time stamps are indicative and correspond to key moments in the episode for reference.