
Loading summary
Advertiser
Hey, guys, don't take my word that bluechew can get things going in the bedroom. Take hers and hers and hers.
Host
Oh, yeah.
Advertiser
Go to bluechew.com right now and meet online with a licensed medical provider. If you qualify, bluechew will give you a free month's supply of chewables with the same active ingredients as Viagra or cialis for just $5 shipping. Visit bluechew.com and use the promo code yes. For this amazing deal. Got it. Get it bluechew.com promo code yes.
Host
Welcome to Choice Classic Radio where we bring to you the greatest old time radio shows like us on Facebook, subscribe to us on YouTube and thank you for donating@ChoiceClassicRadio.com Johnny Dolan.
Jerry Holland
Jerry Holland. Johnny. TRI Mutual Insurance Limited.
Johnny Dollar
Oh, sure, Jerry. How are you?
Jerry Holland
The name Curtis Randall mean anything to you?
Johnny Dollar
The banker here in Hartford?
Jerry Holland
That's the one. He's also one of our big policyholders. At least he was.
Johnny Dollar
Oh, what's happened to him?
Jerry Holland
Day before yesterday, he and a friend of his fellow named Byron Peters, they went deer hunting over near Kingman, New York. And they hired some old character in the neighborhood to act as guides. Randall and Peters didn't know it, but the old goat was an alcoholic.
Johnny Dollar
So what happened?
Jerry Holland
At the end of the day's hunt, they raised Cain with Curly because he hadn't found him a deer.
Johnny Dollar
Curly? The name of the guide, huh?
Jerry Holland
Yeah, they had a big argument over 500,000.
Johnny Dollar
Wow. Who's Randall's beneficiary?
Jerry Holland
His hunting companion. Peters.
Johnny Dollar
Peters. No wonder you want me to investigate Johnny. Only this one looks too easy. Right, Johnny? I'll be right over.
Narrator
Bob Bailey in the exciting adventures of the man with the action packed expense account, America's fabulous freelance insurance investigator, yours truly, Johnny Dollar. And now, act one of yours truly, Johnny Dollar.
Johnny Dollar
Expense accounts submitted by special investigator Johnny Dollar to the TRI Mutual Insurance Co. Ltd. Hartford, CT. Following is an account of expense during my investigation of the hapless hunter Matter expense account item 195 cents for a taxi across town to Tri Mutual in the office of Jerry Holland. As they opened the door, he met me halfway.
Terry
Hey, what was the idea of hanging up on me, Johnny? Then when I tried to call you back, you'd left.
Captain McManus
Well, sure.
Johnny Dollar
I figured if this thing only happened a day or so ago, the faster I could get working on it, the better.
Captain McManus
Well, I'll go along with you on that.
Johnny Dollar
But where is this man Peters?
Terry
In the hospital.
Johnny Dollar
Because if anybody should be suspect, he's short. After all, As a benefit. What did you say?
Terry
I tried to tell you on the phone, only you hung up. Byron Peters is in the hospital.
Johnny Dollar
Where?
Terry
Over in Kingman, New York.
Johnny Dollar
Why?
Terry
Because he was shot up too, by that drunken guide when he tried to prevent him from killing Randall.
Johnny Dollar
Oh, then Curly killed himself.
Captain McManus
Yeah.
Terry
You know, if you'd stop going off half cocked, you might get somewhere on this case. If it really is a case.
Johnny Dollar
Sorry. I guess I jumped to a conclusion because half a million is still a lot of money.
Terry
Sure it is. If you need it.
Johnny Dollar
And Byron Peters doesn't.
Terry
Well, according to the local police chief who called me, it was in Byron Peters brand new Eldorado that they drove over to Kingman. It was Peters who arranged for the guide service. It was he who supplied the guns and equipment.
Johnny Dollar
Yeah. Okay. Okay, Terry. I'll take your word for it. What hospital is he in? Over there.
Terry
Angel of Mercy. It's the only one.
Johnny Dollar
Any other information I ought to have?
Terry
None that I can give you. As I told you, this is just routine. Because of the money involved? Company policy.
Johnny Dollar
Of course.
Terry
For your report, you might try to find out if this old Curly Summers, the guide, had any reason to have it in for Randall.
Johnny Dollar
Randall knew him before, huh? I thought you said Peters arranged for the guy.
Terry
I guess I did, but.
Johnny Dollar
Now, John, let me have Peter's home address, would you? And Randall's?
Terry
Sure, why not? And I hope you don't think.
Johnny Dollar
Did you know Randall well?
Terry
Yes.
Johnny Dollar
Was he a drinking man?
Terry
One martini before Denny, that's all. Why?
Johnny Dollar
How about Peters?
Captain McManus
I don't know.
Terry
What difference would it make?
Johnny Dollar
Oh, just wonder.
Terry
Don't kid me, Johnny. You've got something up your sleeve. Now what is it? You know something about these people that I don't?
Johnny Dollar
Not a thing, so help me. But 500,000 is a lot of money.
Terry
And I tell you that if you suspect Byron Peters, you're crazy.
Johnny Dollar
Did I say I still suspect?
Terry
But the way you've been talking, did I?
Johnny Dollar
Well, no. Well, I do. Sure. With so little to go on, I had no reason at all to suspect Peters except for a hunch. But hunches have paid off for me more than once. Expense account item 2380. A tank full of gas for the drive across Route 6 to the new York state line. There I picked up 9W, then 212to Kingman. I found the angel of Mercy Hospital on the way into town. The chief resident physician of Dr. Matthews was completely cooperative and of no help whatsoever.
Dr. Matthews
Quite pointless to see him at the moment. Mr. Dollop.
Johnny Dollar
Ah, what do you mean, doctor?
Dr. Matthews
Mr. Peters is sleeping under sedation. Oh, I'm afraid the ordeal with the police left him quite exhausted.
Johnny Dollar
The police have already seen and questioned him.
Dr. Matthews
Yes, and they had no business questioning him so long in view of his condition. Shock, you know.
Johnny Dollar
Tell me something. Do they suspect that he killed Mr. Randall too, then wounded himself for an alibi?
Terry
You mean that you do?
Byron Peters
Yeah.
Johnny Dollar
Do they?
Dr. Matthews
Oh, my boy, you must be joking.
Terry
Of course not.
Johnny Dollar
Ah, why not?
Dr. Matthews
Whether you realize it or not, and you will, if I permit you to see Mr. Peters, see the manner in which he was wounded, see the extent of his wound.
Johnny Dollar
I'll realize what? Oh, my boy, I asked you a question, Doctor.
Dr. Matthews
You will realize how impossible it would have been for him to shoot himself in that fashion. How narrowly he himself escaped death at the hands of that rum crazed guide.
Johnny Dollar
You're sure, Doctor?
Dr. Matthews
Of course I'm sure. And so are the police.
Johnny Dollar
Well, where does that leave me, if.
Dr. Matthews
I may say so, with egg on your face.
Narrator
Act two of yours truly, Johnny Dollar in a moment. And now, act two of yours truly, Johnny Dollar and the hapless hunter matter.
Johnny Dollar
A hunting guide had run amok near the little town of Kingman, New York, and according to a report, was responsible for the death by shooting of wealthy banker Curtis Randall for the wounding of Randall's companion, Byron Peters. But Peters is beneficiary of Randall's half million dollar insurance policy. So naturally the old bug of suspicion began to gnaw away at the back of my brain. Until, that is, I saw Peters, his wounds, the X rays and finally talked with Captain McManus at the local police headquarters. Sure, we Talked to Peters, Mr. Dollar.
Captain McManus
But only to find out exactly what happened. Curley went off his rocker and started spraying lead with his hunting rifle, then shot himself.
Johnny Dollar
Then my suspicion that Peters might have done the shooting.
Captain McManus
Didn't you see how Mr. Peters was hit by that 30.
Johnny Dollar
30.
Captain McManus
Now look, he saw Curly pull the rifle on Mr. Randall and shoot him down.
Johnny Dollar
Yeah, yeah.
Captain McManus
So he lunged at Curly like this.
Terry
Curly whirled around, pulled the trigger.
Johnny Dollar
Yeah, well, the X rays I saw, sure.
Captain McManus
Well, then you know when Peters lunged at him, the bullet creased his head from the top, went right through the muscles in the back of his left shoulder and landed in the floor.
Johnny Dollar
So it's pretty obvious that Peters couldn't have shot himself.
Captain McManus
It's impossible. He would have had to have arms five or six feet long to shoot himself on the top of the head at that angle.
Johnny Dollar
Hey, when did you first learn about this whole thing, Captain?
Captain McManus
When Mr. Peters came to, he phoned me from up at Curley's cabin where it happened.
Johnny Dollar
I went up there right away and.
Captain McManus
Curley and Randall were dead. Peters was still lying next to the fireplace where he'd fallen.
Johnny Dollar
But if he was able to phone you, he pulled the phone over to.
Captain McManus
Him by the cord. Still had a good right hand, you know.
Johnny Dollar
Oh, I see. Where were Randall and Curley?
Captain McManus
Randall? By the front door with a bullet in the back of his head. Curly lay between them.
Advertiser
Health insurance doesn't have to break the bank@oregonhealthcare.gov we're here to get you covered. Visit oregonhealthcare.gov to get started.
Johnny Dollar
Just how much do you know about this Curly character?
Captain McManus
Well, that's the part I don't understand.
Johnny Dollar
Why he did it. I heard he was an alcoholic.
Captain McManus
Sure, he was the town drunk in a harmless sort of a way. Except when he'd go off on a rampage and get into a fight or two. But never during hunting season.
Johnny Dollar
Uh huh. Well, what did he do?
Captain McManus
Odd jobs of any kind? Most anything. People had always refused to pay him until the job was done.
Johnny Dollar
To make sure he'd stay sober, huh?
Captain McManus
Well, at least reasonably sober. And just as soon as he got paid, he'd buy a lot of cheap whiskey and hole up in his cabin.
Johnny Dollar
That's where the murder occurred. Except.
Captain McManus
Yeah, except during hunting season. Then he'd never touch it. He was a good guide, Mr. Dollar. He made a lot of money from the people who came up from New York City and Hartford and such.
Dr. Matthews
That's the part I don't understand.
Captain McManus
His hitting the bottle during the season.
Johnny Dollar
Well, did he ever have any trouble with his clients before?
Captain McManus
Oh, he'd bellyache about them being so rich when he was so poor, that sort of thing. But he'd have to get awfully drunk. I swear I don't understand it.
Johnny Dollar
Well, look, Captain, I'd like to see the bodies of Mr. Randall and Curly. Are they still hereabouts?
Captain McManus
Still over at the coroner's office.
Johnny Dollar
Then let's go, huh? I wasn't quite sure what I was looking for. Maybe that's the reason I found it. At least found something that started that old suspicion bug gnawing away again. Peter's back at the hospital and it had a bad powder burn on his forehead next to where the bullet had creased him. Okay. He had said that Curly the guide pulled the trigger when he lunged at him. Randall there at the coroner's office had no powder burns. Okay. It was apparent that he had been shot from across the room. But Curly, who was supposed to have shot himself upward through the jaw, also showed no sign of powder burn. Sure, the bullet hole indicated he could have shot himself by holding the gun at arm's length. A 30. 30 is fairly short. But no powder burn. I said nothing of this to Chief McManus.
Captain McManus
Well, it pretty much bears out what Peters told me and I told you, doesn't it? Curley shot Randall, then Peters and himself.
Johnny Dollar
Then suppose just for the sake of argument that Randall did the shooting first, that is.
Captain McManus
Well, now, Mr. Dollar. Say, wait. Speaking of argument, Peter said that Randall and Curly had a pretty big one, you know, because Curly didn't find them any deer. That's when he started to get drunk and abusive. But as for Mr. Randall, on the.
Johnny Dollar
Other hand, suppose that Peters started the whole thing.
Captain McManus
Oh, now look, you know that doesn't make any sense. Then try to kill himself.
Johnny Dollar
Well, isn't that what you're saying Curly did?
Captain McManus
Sure, but that's different. No good old bum realized he'd gone too far. There was no other way out for him. But a man like Peters with money, everything he wants.
Johnny Dollar
Where's this cabin of curlies, huh?
Captain McManus
Quite a way. 10, 12 miles.
Johnny Dollar
How do I get there?
Captain McManus
Straight down Pear street to the Mobile gas station. You know where that is?
Johnny Dollar
Yeah, I saw it on my way in.
Captain McManus
Okay, you turn left there. You go six miles, then take the first right hand road right up the side of Deer Mountain until you get there. Okay.
Narrator
Oh, here.
Captain McManus
Here's the key to it.
Johnny Dollar
Oh, good. Thanks, Chief. I'll see you later.
Captain McManus
You want me to go along with you?
Johnny Dollar
No. According to you, this hunch of mine is all wrong.
Captain McManus
I'm sure of it.
Johnny Dollar
Okay, then I'd better wing it alone. From the outside, Curly's cabin was a shack, nothing more. And there were enough cheap whiskey bottles scattered around the yard to sink a battleship. Inside, however, it was pretty comfortably fixed up and back into the kitchen sink, I found a case of Prince Francis scotch, nearly full. Had Curly suddenly changed his taste for the better? Or had somebody decided to bait him with it? By the dark stains on the floor, I could see where both Randall and Curly had fallen. Where Peters had gone down. There was also the rifle slug embedded in the floor. Then I noticed the angle at which that slug had ended, as though it had been fired from the ceiling, certainly from higher than any normal man could reach. And Curly was only 5 foot 2 or 3. Then I saw something else. A heavy cord hanging down from one of the rafters above where Peters had Lain. It was frayed at the end as though forcibly broken. Now, suppose someone had hung a loaded rifle there by the trigger so the slightest pull would set it off. Had stood under it, holding the muzzle carefully next to his head to one side, just close enough to.
Narrator
Yeah.
Jerry Holland
Hello, Mr. Dolly.
Johnny Dollar
Captain.
Jerry Holland
Yeah. Listen now, you.
Narrator
You may be right.
Jerry Holland
Oh, I still don't see how you can be.
Johnny Dollar
What do you mean?
Jerry Holland
Look, I. I've got Dr. Matthews at the hospital here on this party line. You still there, Doc? Right here, Chief. Well, then you better tell Mr. Duller. Well, it's about Mr. Peters.
Johnny Dollar
Yeah?
Jerry Holland
He's left.
Captain McManus
Left?
Johnny Dollar
I thought you had him under sedation.
Jerry Holland
I guess it didn't take hold the.
Dr. Matthews
Way I thought it would.
Johnny Dollar
Well, what happened?
Dr. Matthews
Well, he woke up and asked me who it was.
Jerry Holland
Had been here to see him while he was drowsy.
Johnny Dollar
Did you tell him who I was?
Jerry Holland
Yes.
Dr. Matthews
And he seemed to drop off again.
Jerry Holland
So I left him. A few minutes later, I heard his.
Dr. Matthews
Big fancy car pulling away.
Johnny Dollar
Doctor.
Dr. Matthews
I went back to his room and he was gone.
Johnny Dollar
Doctor.
Jerry Holland
Listen, Dollar.
Johnny Dollar
Yeah, Chief.
Jerry Holland
I don't know what it means any more than you do, but if I was you, I would get away from that isolated cabin. You see what I mean, Dollar?
Johnny Dollar
Sure, Chief. I'll leave right away.
Byron Peters
That was very smart, Dollar.
Johnny Dollar
Byron Peters. Patch Rice, Byron Peters.
Narrator
Act three of yours truly, Johnny Dollar, in a moment. And now, act three of yours truly, Johnny Dollar and the hapless. Huh?
Johnny Dollar
So you weren't as badly hurt by that bullet as you pretended.
Byron Peters
That's right, darling. Does that help bear out your absurd suspicions about me?
Johnny Dollar
Not nearly so much as your coming up here to this cabin, Peters.
Byron Peters
What's that supposed to mean?
Johnny Dollar
You rigged the whole thing pretty well, but not well enough. Why you wanted to get rid of Curtis Randall, I don't know.
Byron Peters
You're out of your mind. Randall was a friend of mine.
Johnny Dollar
He must have had some reason for killing him.
Byron Peters
Curly Summers murdered Kurt. We had a big argument because he hadn't found us any game. The only reason it got out of hand was because Curly was drunk.
Johnny Dollar
On what? On some of that expensive scotch I found in the kitchen.
Byron Peters
How should I know? Yes.
Johnny Dollar
Where did he get that?
Byron Peters
How should I know?
Johnny Dollar
Well, I do. You brought it here to help bolster your phony alibi. To indicate that Curly had it up here, had been hitting it. But you pulled a boo. Boo.
Byron Peters
Why don't you talk sense, Detective?
Johnny Dollar
Are you trying to tell me Curly would ever have stuff like that?
Byron Peters
Look.
Johnny Dollar
Look at the old bottle scattered around outside. Cheap rot got, that's all. What's more, he never touched a drop during hunting season.
Byron Peters
That's about as thin evidence as you could possibly dig up. Dollar and you know it.
Johnny Dollar
Peters. Why did you come up here just now? Okay, I'll tell you that too. Lying there in the hospital nursing your sore shoulder, you didn't plan on that injury, did you?
Byron Peters
I told the police.
Johnny Dollar
Oh, yeah, sure, you told the police. Lying there, you suddenly remember the one thing that could show how you cleverly wounded yourself after you killed Randall and Curly. That piece of cord up in the rafter where you hung Curly's gun up by the trigger. You aimed it carefully along the side of your head, then yanked on it to set it off. Dangerous, but a great alibi.
Byron Peters
I told the police, the doctor. Curly pulled that trigger when I lunged at him, struggled with him.
Johnny Dollar
Little Curly held that gun high enough so the bullet would crease your head from above.
Byron Peters
I was bent over, lunging at him.
Johnny Dollar
Then enter the floor from up here where this cord is hanging.
Captain McManus
You're.
Byron Peters
You're pretty smart, aren't you, Dara?
Johnny Dollar
Curly was supposed to have committed suicide, huh?
Byron Peters
Yes, he must have, because I heard him shoot himself as I passed out.
Johnny Dollar
Oh, sure. The bullet entered his lower jaw, went up into his brain.
Byron Peters
That's right.
Johnny Dollar
That meant he had to hold that 30. 30 at arm's length. So the muzzle right next to his jaw. That's right where it would have left powder burn. But Peters, there were none. Because you shot him from across the room. The same as you did Randall.
Byron Peters
Yes, yes, the same as.
Johnny Dollar
I'll shoot you if you can.
Byron Peters
My right hand is still good, $. And so is the.38. You and your fool insurance company should have left things as they were. Chin up, dollar.
Johnny Dollar
Tell me one thing.
Byron Peters
Sorry, I haven't got time. When I left the hospital, I made sure I was seen heading for New York. And a carefully set up alibi.
Johnny Dollar
You still won't get away with it, you know. Any more than you got away with killing Randall.
Byron Peters
I had until you came along. And I will when I've killed you. So if you have nothing more to say.
Johnny Dollar
One thing. Why did you kill Randall?
Byron Peters
You're trying to stall me.
Johnny Dollar
Why? All right, all right.
Byron Peters
Because I forced him to name me. And his insurance. I was the only one who knew about some shady operations in his early business career.
Johnny Dollar
The old story, huh? That's right.
Byron Peters
Blackmail. That's why he's been paying me off, supporting me until recently.
Johnny Dollar
So you threatened to expose him? No.
Byron Peters
What would that get me financially.
Johnny Dollar
Then tell me. No.
Byron Peters
I've got to get out of here. To New York.
Johnny Dollar
Just one thing more.
Byron Peters
I don't know why you're trying to stall me, but it's no use. So if you have any prayers, darling.
Johnny Dollar
Sure, sure. That Chief McManus standing there in the doorway will slug you before you pull that trigger.
Byron Peters
Oh, no, not that old chestnut.
Johnny Dollar
Why not?
Terry
Peter.
Johnny Dollar
What? You.
Captain McManus
Doggone. A dollar. I thought I told you on the phone to get out of here.
Johnny Dollar
Expense account total, including gas, to get me Back to Hartford. $13.13. Remarks. Why? Why don't they ever learn? Yours truly, Johnny Doll.
Narrator
This is the United States Armed Forces Radio and Television Service.
Choice Classic Radio Detectives | Old Time Radio
Episode: Yours Truly, Johnny Dollar: The Hapless Hunter Matter
Release Date: December 2, 2024
In this riveting episode of Yours Truly, Johnny Dollar, listeners are taken on a classic detective journey set in the mid-20th century. Johnny Dollar, a freelance insurance investigator with an action-packed expense account, delves into the mysterious case of the "Hapless Hunter Matter." This episode masterfully combines suspense, intricate investigation, and sharp dialogue, capturing the essence of old-time radio detective storytelling.
The story centers around Curtis Randall, a banker from Hartford and a significant policyholder of TRI Mutual Insurance Limited, and his companion, Byron Peters. On a hunting trip near Kingman, New York, they hire a local guide named Curly Summers. Unbeknownst to Randall and Peters, Curly struggles with alcoholism.
Key Incident:
Johnny Dollar is summoned by Jerry Holland from TRI Mutual Insurance to investigate the incident, given the substantial insurance policy at stake.
Notable Interaction:
As Johnny begins his inquiry, he learns from Captain McManus that Byron Peters was hospitalized after being shot. However, discrepancies in the testimonies and physical evidence raise red flags about the validity of the initial reports.
Johnny visits Angel of Mercy Hospital to interview Dr. Matthews, the chief resident physician overseeing Byron Peters.
Key Discoveries:
Dr. Matthews reveals that the bullet wounds on Peters are inconsistent with a self-inflicted shot, indicating foul play:
Dr. Matthews: "You will realize how impossible it would have been for him to shoot himself in that fashion." [05:34]
Examination of the crime scene at Curly's cabin uncovers suspicious elements:
Johnny's Analysis: Johnny deduces that the setup at the cabin was designed to frame Curly, pointing towards Byron Peters as the true perpetrator.
Armed with evidence, Johnny confronts Byron Peters at the hospital. The interrogation intensifies as Johnny exposes the flawed alibi and mechanical setup intended to mislead investigators.
Critical Exchange:
Johnny Dollar: "You rigged the whole thing pretty well, but not well enough." [14:14]
Byron Peters: "You are trying to stall me." [16:36]
As pressure mounts, Peters attempts to maintain his innocence but ultimately succumbs to Johnny's relentless questioning, revealing his motives tied to blackmail and financial gain.
The episode culminates in Peters' admission of guilt, unravelling the complex web of deceit he wove to secure his insurance benefits. Johnny Dollar's keen observation and deductive reasoning not only uncover the truth but also restore justice for Curtis Randall.
Final Remarks:
Johnny Dollar: "I do not get away with it, you know. Any more than you got away with killing Randall." [17:02]
Byron Peters: "So if you have nothing more to say." [17:09]
Yours Truly, Johnny Dollar: The Hapless Hunter Matter is a quintessential example of mid-century radio detective storytelling. Through meticulous investigation, shrewd dialogue, and engaging suspense, Johnny Dollar unravels a complex case of betrayal and murder. This episode not only entertains but also showcases the timeless appeal of detective narratives, making it a standout installment in the Choice Classic Radio Detectives series.